Walls v. Recontrust Company, N.A. et al

Filing 20

ORDER Denying 18 Motion for Temporary Restraining Order. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that 7 Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED and STAYED while the parties engage in mediation. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 5/24/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - EDS)

1 ,
-- -

8LF) f'

N
1

L fiq h Jla ll

y; Cb1 1--s u,,$J( .a 0'( 7 IRS F ïtry %îV r O asa g'
-

-..- r. f) -.t w;y . . (
r
.

-

--

2

J pjy z j s y . g g
? UNI ED STATES DI TR I COURYv T SG
DI T R I T O F NEVA D A S C
R O B ERT A LLEN W A LLS,

3
4
5
6
7

/ / tg....r ( -..?.. ( .w . ..
'1 '*i .' 1 ''
'' -

t-- '- c x-. uur -r . r u s ....u . .

ë. -

. .. . 0. .

rc a ,, , . rj =2

Plitfl an il
VS.

2: 0 c - 02 1 RCJ l J 1 - v 0 9 - -U
O R D ER

8
9

R ECO N TR U ST CO . N . .etal, ,A .
l 0

D ef ndant . e s
l1 12

l 3

Pl i tf hass ed Def ndant on muli l caus sofacton r l t d t t e f r cl s r ofhi a n if u e s tp e e i ea e o h o e o u e s

1 m orgage. Pe di g bef r t e Cour ar Pl i tt sM oton f rTempor r Resrai i g Or er, 4 t nn oe h t e a n ir io ay t nn d

l orgial tldil tt c ur,a dDee da t'Motont Dimis( 7,t whihPlitf ha no 5 i n ly ie rsae o t n fn ns i o s s # ) o c an if s t
1 r s on e . Fo t c r a onsgi e h r i ,t e Cour s oul de i s t e M oton f rTe por r 6 ep d d l r h e s v n e en h t h d ne h i o m ay

1 RetanngOr e a dg a t teMotont Dimis(/) 7 srii d r n rn s h i o s s /7 .
11 8. 1 9 FACTS A N D PR O C ED U M L H I T O R Y S On ora outM a c 1 2004, antf R o e tAl n W al pur ha e r a pr pe t l c t d b rh , Pl i if b r l e l c s d e l o ry o a e s

20 at5222Pine rCa i Ct,Norh La Ve a ,NV 8 0 1(thePr pe t ' f r$1 15 0.(/ ,Ex. o e bn , t s g s 93 d t o ry' o 7 ,0 /8 ) 21 C,a 1, . Thede d oftus lssno - a t M orga eHomeSpe ilss l c a ln e a d n nt 3)2 e r t it n p ry t g cait, n . s e d r n o

22 pat Chia oTil a tusee (#.Ex.C, t1.Wal ma ea a j sabert n t t Morg ge ry c g te s r t .f , a ) ls d n du t l-ae o e o ta
23

l- i c nsiut sc ns ntt g a tngt emoton. R. 2( ) 'hs o tt e o e o r n i h l i L. 7- d .
24

2 heCour tke j diilnoieoftepubl rc r sa d c dbyDee da t (/) T t a s u ca tc h i eod d u e c fn ns /8. 25 Se M a kv S. yBe rDitis, F.d 1 7 ,1 8 ( t Ci.1 ) e c . Ba e srb .798 2 2 9 2 2 9h r 986 .

1 .
#

1 Holl Spe ilss fxe at4.50 frt oy as a draj sige eysxro tstee fe t z e cait, l d 2 % o w e r, n e du tn v r i n nh h r atr o 2 3.50 plstei urntide ,'a deme i tenot,b tne e t e c e 1 .50% .(d.Ex. 2 % u h t re n x' s f d n h e u v r o x e d 02 c 1,
3 D,a 1, 5 . t 2, )
4 On Oc o e 1 ,20 6,W al r f a c d t e Pr pe t b ma i g a i t r s - n y tb r 6 0 ls e m n e h o ry y k n n n e e t o l

5 a j sa l-acn t t Countywi eHomeLoa s l c.f r$2 9000 (d. Ex.B,a 1,a d du tb er t o e o rd n,n o 2 , , i , t) n
6 securi g t e not wih a ne deed oft us t lnde Count yw i e,w ih Def ndantRecont us nh et w r to e r rd t e rt

7 Co.N. . tuse a dMorga eElcr ncRe itainSyse s lc.S ERS' a d o ie ' , A as r te n t g eto i gsrto tm ,n (6 M ' s ç m n e' )n

8 a dt e ekil '(d.Ex.A, t2, .Theie ondhomcrde't tede doftus,sgne by n i n t ay ' i , b a 4) çc s i r'o h e r t i d
9 Plitq ma e cla t a t ePr pe t wasPlitf' s c n home, hi prmay r sde ce an i k s c r h t h o ry an ifs e o d not s i l e i n .

1 (#. Ex. a 29 31 .Thede d oftu tis l n t st ee it n eoft es c n homerde .(#. 0 f , A, t - ) e r s tef o e h x se c h e o d irf, 1 Ex. a 2 .Theiiilntr s r t u de t en w n t wa 5.75/ , ie f rtle ye r , t 1 A, t ) nta i e e t a e n r h e o e s 8 00 fx d o l t a s wih r

l monhl p ymensof$1 211 (#, B,a 1 2) Th itrs rt wa adusa l e ey 2 ty a t 1 .5. f.Ex. t - . e neet ae s j tbe v r
13 t el e mont s t er afe by addi g 2. 50% per entt t e ' ur enti dex,'asdesned t er i ,not wv h h e tr n2 c oh Y r n ' h en

1 t e ce d 1 .75% .1 .Ex. a 2 .AsumigPlitf ha z r e uiyi tehomea tetme 4 o x e 18 (d, B, t ) s n anif d eo q t n h th i 1 ofrfna cng(a e ont eproritrs- nl l a ) terf a cngga ehi ac s pr ftof 5 e n i b sd h i n eeto y o n ,h em n i v m ah o
1 $5 , 0 , e r s ntng t eic e s i e uiybew e n pur h s i 200 a d r fna cng i 200 . 6 75 0 rp ee i h n ra e n q t t e cae n 4 n e ni n 6
l Pl itf' p ottf o t e 2006 r f a cng wa s fi intt mc tt e fr tt r eye r ofpa m e t 7 a n ifs r i r m h em n i s u l e o e h ts h e a s c y ns

18 att ei iil a eof5.75 ,wih$1 l 8. 0r m anig asofNo e be 2 09whe t er t frt h nta r t 8 % t 7, 3 6 e i n vm r 0 n h a e ts
1 r s t W ha e e Pli tf di w i t e epr ft , di notus t e t pa h smor ga e O n J ne 9 ee. t v r a n if d t h s o is he d h e hm o y i l g. u

20 25, 2009, c nr s rc r e tenotc ofdea l.f .Ex. a 2) Re o tu t e o d d h ie fut(#, E, t . 21 OnFe r ay2 201 , antf s e Rec nrlt(rone usyna edastk c nsr c' a d b u r , 0 Pli if u d o tts er o l m ç e o tu t' n l )

22 BAC HomeLo nSe z ig LP (ç AC' i saec ur o trecus sofa ton:()ijncie a ni n , 1 c B ' n tt o t n h e a e ci 1 nu tv ) 23 rl t ()bra hoftducaydut;a d( )fa d.Plitf alofldt epr sntMotonfr ei l 2 e c i ir y n 3 ru an if s ie h e e e io
24 25 Tempor r Resr i i g Or eri s at cour . 0n Fe r ar 4,201 ,BAC e t nded an oferof ay ta n n d nte t bu y 0 xe r Page 2 of 8

l

1 modi aint Plitf (t eOfe' .1 .Ex. ) TheOfe idiae ta asofFe r a' 4, f to o anif ih fr' (d , J. k t ) rrn c ts h t bu l y
2 201 ,t ea o ntowe ont enot wa $245420.3.BAC ofe e t mo iyt eitr s- nl 0h mu dh es ,5 fr d o d f h n e e to y

3 aj sa l-aela t afxe ,se -aela .Unde teOFe,tert woul be3.75 frte du tbert o n o l d tp rt o n rh r h ae d 8%oh
4 fr tlveye r ,wih amo t l pa r e tof$1 3138 4. 7 % f rt esxt y a ,wih amont l ts i a s t n hy yn n 2 . , 8 5 o h i h er t * hy
5 pa m e tof$1 49. 9*a d 5. 75 t e e te un i t e m a urt da e ofNove be 1 2 3 , ih a yn 3 4 , n 3 % h r at r tl h t iy t m r ,06wt

6 mon hl pa me tof$1 08.4.(#. Ex.J a 3 5) Th Ofe wa s tt t r i aeon Fe nlr ty y n 4 4 f , , t , . e rr s e o e m n t b ay 7 1 ,201 (#. Ex.J a 1 .Appa e ty, antf di nota c ptt emodfcai nofe . 9 0. f , , t ) r n l Pli ir d ce h i to rr
8 De e da t r m ov d o M a c 3,2 1 a d ha e now m o e t d s is fn ns e e n rh 0 0 n v v d o im s .
9 ll . LEG A L STAN D A R D S

1 0

A.

Rul 1 ( )6) e 2b(

1 1

Fedea Rul ofCiiPr c du e8a( )r q ie onl i s or a dpli sae e tofte rl e vl o e r ()2 e urs y û h t n an ttm n h a

1 cl i s ow i g t att e pl ader i e tted t r lef'i or ert Sgi et e def ndantf i notce of 2 am h n h h e s n il o e i n d o t v h e ar i 13 whatt e ...cli i and t e gr undsupon whi h f res s' Conly v.Gi son,355 U. .41,47 h am s ho c t t .' e b S

1 ( 957 .Fede a Rue ofCii Pr c du e 1 ( )6)ma da e t a ac ur dim isac us o a ton 41) rl l vl o e r 2 b ( n ts h t o t s s a e f ci
15 t atf ist s at a cli upon w hi h r lefcan be gr nt d. A moton t dim i sunderRul h al o t e am c ei ae i o ss e

1 1 ( )6 tsstec mplitss mcinc . eNorhStr1 tlv Arz naCor .Comm '.720 6 2b () et h o an ' u e y Se t a n ' . io . p r, l
1 F.d5 8,581( t Ci.1 8 ) W h nc nsdeigamotont dimisunde Rul 1 ()6)fr 7 27 9h r 9 3 . e o i rn i oss r e 2b ( o
18 f sur t st t a cl i ,dim js li appr prit onl whe t e compl i tdoes notgi e t e al e o a e am s sa s o ae y nh an vh

l de e da tf i notc ofa lgal c gnia l c a m a d t egr un son whi h i r s s Se Bel 9 fn n ar ie e l o z b e li n h o d y c t et. e l

20 At.Cor . .Twombl,550U..5 4,55 ( 0 7) I c nsdeigwhehe tec mpliti l pv y S 4 5 2 0 . n o i rn t r h o an s
21 s m cintt s at acl i ,t e cour w ilt ke al mat ralalegatonsast ue and cons r e t em i u e o t e am h t la l ei l i r tu h n

2 t e l h mos f v r bl t t epli tf. eNL l du .I c v Ka l n,792F.d 896,89 ( t 2 h i t t a o a e o h an if Se g n s, n . . p a 2 8 9h 23 Ci.1 86 .Th c ur, r 9 ) e o t howe e ,i no r quie t a c pta tuealg tonst a a eme ey v r s t e r d o c e s r le a i h t r r l
24 c n l s r ,u w a r nt d de uc i nsoff c ,o unr a ona l i f r nc s Se S r w e lv Gol e o c u o y n r a e d to a t r e s be n e e e . e p e l . d n
25 Page 3 ef 8

l St t War ï r ,2 6 F.d 97 ,988 ( t Ci. ) A f r uli r ctto ofaca s ofa ton a e ro s 6 3 9 9 h r 2001 . o m ac e ia in u e ci
2 w ih c ncus l a l ga i nsi nots fk i n ;a p antf m us pl a f c ss ow i g t a a vi l ton t o l o ' le to s y u l e t l i if t e d a t h n h t o a i

3 i plusbl,notus posil. hcotv I bal 1 9S.Ct 1 37,1 49( 0 9)(iigTwombl v s a i e j t sbe As rj . q , 2 . 9 9 2 0 ctn y.
4 BelAt.Cop. 55 U..5 4,555( 00 ). l l r, 0 S 5 2 7)
5 l e e a l ,a diti tc u tm a notc nsde a y ma e i lbe o d t e pl a i gsi r l g r n rl y s rc o r y o irn t ra y n h e d n n u i n

6 o aRul 1 ()6 moton... n e 2 b () i Howe c,maeil lc ipr pel s bmitda patofte v r tra wl h s o ry u te s r h i
7 compl i tm aybe consder d on a m oton t dim i s.HalRoach St di s,I c.v.Ri har Fei er an ie i oss uo n cdn

8 & Co.89 F.d 1 42,1 55n.9( t Ci.1 90)(iainso itd .Si ial,i oc me t , 6 2 5 5 1 9h r 9 ctto m te ) m lry ç u ns d
9 w h s c n e t ar al g d i aco pl i ta d w h s a t e tct no pa t que tons butw h c o e o tns e l e n e m an n o e u h n i iy ry s i , ih

1 aenotphysc lyata he t tepla ig,ma b c nsdce i r l gonaRul 1 ()6 0r ial tc d o h e dn y e o i rd n ui n e 2 b ()
11 m oton t dir is'wihoutconver i g t e m oton t dim i si t a moton f rs r m ar i o sn s ' t tn h i o s s no i o un y

1 jdg e tBr nc v Tunnel 1 F.d449, 4(t Ci.1 94) Morov runde Fe ea Rul 2 u m n. a h . l, 4 3 45 9h r 9 . e e , r d rl e 1 ofEvic c 201 ac ur ma tkejdkil ieofû atesof bl rc r .' kv S.Ba 3 d n e , o t y a u a notc k tr pu i e o d'Mac . y m c
1 Be rDiti . 798F.d 1 79 1 8 ( t Ci.1 86 .Ot e w ie i t edititc ur c nsde s 4 e srb , 2 2 , 2 2 9 h r 9 ) h r s , f h src o t o i r
1 m a e il o t i e oft e pl a i gs t em oton t dim isi c nve t d i t a moto f r s m m a y 5 t ra s u sd h e dn ,h i o s s s o re r o l in o u r

1 jdgme tSeeAr i v Sant Clr V le Tr ns . nc ,261F.d91 9 5( t Ci. ) 6 u n. p n . a a a aly a p Age y 3 2, 2 9h r 2001 .
17 B. Tem por r Rest ai i g O rders ay r nn

1 8

Un erFed. Ci. 65b) aplitf mus ma easawigtmtir adit a d d R. v P. ( , anif t k lo n l rm e ae n

1 irpaa l ij r ,os,orda a ewi rs lt panifwihou atmporr r sriigore . 9 re rbe nu y l s m g l eut o litf t t e ay e tann d r l
2 Te por r r s r i i g o d r a e go e ne by t e s m e sa da d a plc bl t pr l i a y 0 m a y e t a n n r e s r v r d h a t n r p i a e o ei n r m

21 ij ncins S eCalI de .v- OpeatrCor .v Relan En r pSem .I c,1 1F.S pp. 1 nu to . e . n p u ç r o p . i t cg t , n . 8 y. u 2( 22 11 1 11 6( . . l20 1 (çh sa dadf ris igaprl iayijncini t esmea te 1 , 2 E D Ca. 0 ) l e tn r o sun T ei n r nu to s h a s h m 23 sa d r f ris igatmporr rsriigo d n' ,TheNit Cic ii tepatstf rht o tn ad o sun e ay e tann r e ' ) nh rutn h s e o t w

24 spaaes sofciei frdtemiigwhehe t grn p ei iayij ncierle: e rt d rtra o tr nn t r o a t r l n r nu tv eif m
25 Page 4 of 8

1
2
3
4

Unde t eta iina ts, plitf- us s ow: 1 asr ngl eioodofuc es on r h rdto leta anil t h ( ) to i lh m k scs temeis ()t eposiiiyofre aa lij l t plitfiprl iayrle inot h rt,2 h sbl irp rbe nu' o aniff ei n r eifs t y m gr ntd,( )abaa c ofh r s i sfvorngt eplitfla d( )a va c me toft e ae 3 ln e a d hp a i h an i n 4 d n e n h l p bl itr s (n cet i c s s .The ale n tv t s r q ie t a a p an ir u i n e e t i ran a e ) c t r ai e e t e u r s h t litf
de ons r t e t e ac m b na i n of r ba l s c e so t em e isa d t epos i i t m t a e ih r o i to p o b e u c s n h rt n h sb l y i

ofkrpaa l ijr orta srousqu sinsaerie a dt ebalnc ofh rs is e rbe nu y h t ei e to r as d n h a e ad hp
tpss ar l i hi f vor i h py n s a .

5 Ta lrv We t ,488F.d 11 1 00( t Ci. ) ' he et of r ulto srprsntt o yo . sl y 3 97, 2 9h r2007 , T s w o m ain e e e w
6 poi t on a si i g s al i whi h t e r quied degr e ofir par bl hann i c eas s ast e ns ld n c e n c h c r e re a e nr e h 7 pr ba iiy ofs ccessdecr as s.'f . The Supreme Cour r centy r ier t d,however t ata o b lt u e e'# t e l et a e ,h

8 plitfs e iga ijncinmus de onsrt ta irpaa l ham i iiel,' otus posil. anif e kn n nu to t m tae h tre rbe r snk y 'n j t sbe l
9 Witrv. ne NRDC,1 9S. . 3 4-7 ( 008 (ee tngteNit Cicutsatratv ll ig 2 Ct365, 7 6 2 ) rjci h nh r i' len ie t i n sd
1 s al't s) TheNit Cic i ha e pl il r c gnz d t a isç osi it 't s wa over ld b 0 c e' e t. n h ru t s x i ty e o ie h t t i sb ly ' e t s rue y c p i

11 Witr a dta ttheprpe lga sa dadfrprl iayij ncierle rquie apat t ne , n h t tl o r e l tn r o ei n r nu tv eif e r s ry o g m
1 de onsr t tha he i Ikey t s c e d on t e me is t a he i lkey t s f r ir pa a l ha m 2 m ta e t t s i l o u c e h rt , h t s i l o u l r e r b e r k

1 i t ea s nc ofpr lmi a yr lelt a t ebaln eofe uiistpsi hi fvor a d t a a 3 n h be c ei n r eif h t h a c q te i n s a , n h t n

1 ij nci ni i t epu lcitr s.'St r a s I c v Se e k ,58 F.d 11 9,11 7 ( t Ci. 4 nu to s n h b i n e e t'' o m n , n . . l c y 6 3 0 2 9 h r

1 20 9)(uotng Witr 1 9S. . t37 ) 5 0 q i ne , 2 Cta 4 .
16 1 1 1. 1 7
18

A N A LY SIS A. M oton t Di m i s i o ss
1. Breach ofFi uci r. Dut d ay y

1 9

A lnde i nota fduc a y ofabor ow e ,bu a t l t e i a Gd ca y ofb t a e rs i ir r r t n se s u ir oh

20 t us ora d a be eGcir undcra deed oftus . l mus actf il w ih res ectt bot e ttes. rt n n ay rt t t ary t p o h n ii

2l Pl i tf- l ge t a t u t e Re ontus br a he istduc a y dut by iii tng f r c os r an ila l s h t r s e c r t e c d t i i r e y n ta i o e l u e
22 pr ceedi gsagai s t e Proper y wihoutbei g i s r ct d t do so by t e benefcil w ihout o n nth tt n n tu e o h ay t 23
24 25 page 5 of 8

obt i i g t e orgi alpror i s r not fom t ebe efcil ,a d wihoutivesi atng w het ert e an n h i n ns o y e r h n i a' n y t n tg i hh

1 n t ha b e ç ai of by i s r nc .' I Nc a a t e powc ofs l c n otb e e c s d u tl h o e d e n ' d r n u a e' n v d , h p 3 r a e a n e x r ie n i t e

2 be eiir ortetuseerc r stcn tc . v. v.Stt j1 7.80()c .Re onr s wa te n tcay h r t e o d h o ie Ne Re a. 0 0 2 () c tu t s h 3 tutewhe i rc r e t enotceo dea la dnotc oftuseesl,/8, A,a 2'i.Ex. r se n t e od d h i f fut n ie r t ae (/ Ex. t ,d , 4 E,a 2) a diteeoeddnotne ddie tonfom tebe e cay.I a yc s , antf alge t , n t h rfr i e rci r h n f ir n n ae Pli ir le s
5 ltri t eCo plitt a BAC isr c e Re ontu tt f r cos .( 1!21 .No i t e ea y ae n h m an h t n tu t d c r s o o e l e # ( ) r s h r n
6 r quiem entt att e t us eeobt i t e orgi alpr m isor not fom t ebenefci r . Thi cause er h h rt an h i n o s y er h ay s

7 ofac i n i notpl usbl . to s a ie 8 9
10

2.

Fr ud a

Th ee e t ofc nunon lw fa d i Ne ada a e e lm n s o a ru n v r:
1.A f le r pr s nt ton m adeby t e def ndant as e e e a i h e ;

11
1 2

2. fnda tsknowldgeo beift a t erpr s ntton i f le( ri s m ce t Dee n ' e r le h t h e e e a i s a s o n u in b ssf rma ig t er p e e tto l a i o k n h e r s n a in ;
3.Def ndantsi t nton t i duce t e pl i tf t actort regai fom actng i e ' ne i o n h an if o o nr in r la ce upon t em ir pr se t ten' e in h se e n ai ,

13

1 4
15

4. antf'j siiberla c upont emirprsntton' nd Pli ifs u tfa l ein e h se ee ai , a
5.D am aget t e pl i tf r s li g f om s ch r la ce. o h an if e u tn r u e in

l Bulma ,I c v Ne . l,8 5P.d588 59 ( ev 1 2) Unde Rul 9() crumsa c s 6 b n n . . v Bel 2 2 , 2 N . 99 . r e b , ic tn e
1 c nsiutng fa d o r it k mus b sa e wïhpa tc lrt .Fe .R. v.P. b) 7 o tt i ru r n sa e t e tt d t riu a ïy d Ci 9( .
18 Pli tf alegest a Recont us def a ded Pli tf by w r ngl cl i i g t have a t ort a n ir l ht r t ru a n ir o y am n o u h iy

19 t f r cl s a d t atBAC defauded Pl i tf by i sruetng Recont us t f re l s . Fist o oe oe n h r an if n t i r t o o co e r ,

20 Re ontus pl i l h d a t ort t f r c os ,s t e e wassm pl no f le s a e e tm a e. c r t a n y a u h iy o o c l e o h r i y as tt m n d 21 Se ond, antf ha notal ge a y r i nc on t e al ge l f le sa e e t b ton y t ath wa c Pl i ir s l d n ei e h l dy as tt m n , u l h e s e a e

22 hame ( rwil hame )b tealge l wr n flfrcosr .Theeinoplusbl fa d r d o lbe r d y h le dy o g u o e l u e rs a i e ru
23

24
25

3 h sl s al ga i n i uni t li i l a sa e . ' i a t l to s n elg b e s t t d r e
page 6 of 8

1 cl i he e. am r

2

B.

Tem porar Res rai i g O r er y t nn d

3

Be a s no plusbl c am sr m an, antf c n ots c e d on t e me is Eve i t e cue a i e l i e i Pli if a n u c e h rt . n fh

4 C ourti plcsa cause ofacton f r wr ngf lf recl sure,a t m por r r s r itng or eri not mi i o o uo o e a y e t a ri ds

5 w a r nt d be a s t e f r c os r he e i c e ry pr pe . r a e c u e h o e l u e r s la l o r

6

Re e ty,heCour ha grne nney-a prl iar ijncinsi smi rc ssi or e c nl t t s a td i t d y ei n y nu to n i l a e n d r m a

7 t per i pl i tfstm e t utlzeN evada' delnquentmort age m edi ton pr gr m .SeeN ev. o m t a n ir i o ii si g ai oa

8 Re .St t j l 08 ( 009) l t i c s ,BAC ha ar a ye tnde a ofe t c n e tt e v a . 07. 6 2 . n h s a e s le d x e d n fr o o v r h

9 a j sa l-aen t it aveyr aona l se -aela , giniga afrbeo - ake rt of du tbert o e no r e s be tp rt o n be n n t a- lw m r t ae
10 3. 75% and i cr asng t no m or t an 5. 75% . Thi m odii aton w oul have r duced 8 nei o ch 8 4s tc i d e ll paym ent a d gi en Pl i tf t e oppoluniy t ear equiy i t e hom e. Pl i tf di nott ke sn v a n if h - to n t t nh an ir d a 1; advant ge oft i ofbr ! a hs l . 13 Thi i nota cas ofpr dat r lndi g. Pl i tf t ok advant ge ofa 1 w i toduct r r t ss e e oy e n a n if o a o nr o y ae

1 t b y as co d h m e t e so pe ma ig pa mc t e e be o et er t a j se upwa d. 4 o u e n o , h n t p d k n y n s v n f r h ae d u t d r

1 Plitfha rjce age eousofb t c nvettea j sabela it afxe ,se -aela a 5 an ir s ee td n r lr o o r h du t l o n no d tp rt o n t
1 r t sl w e t an t os h co l o t i i he we e t s e a sm i rl a i t e m a ke . 6 a e o r h h e e u d b an f r o ek i l o n n h a rt
17 N everhel s ,t e Cour w ilgi e Pl i tf ni et dayst engage i m editon undersat 1 w and t es h t l v an if n y o n ai tea 18 pr ve he i s rousaboutlvi g up t hi oblgatonsundert e m orgage. o s ci in os ii h t

1 9
20

C O N C L U SI N O
I IS HEREBY O R D ER ED t att e M oton f rTempor r Restai i g O r eri T hh io ay r nn ds

2 l D EN I D . E 22
23

I I FURTHER ORDERED t att e s cond M oton f rTem por r Resr i i g Or er TS hhe io a y ta n n d

4 ur entm or gage r t s a ealeady above 5% and ar lkel t r s overt enextfw cr t ae r r e i y o ie h e
24 25 year . s page 7 of 8

1 ( 1 ) fldont eda oftehe rn ,i DENI D. # 8, e h y h aig s E 2 I I FURTHER ORDERED ta teM oint Dimis(/)i GRANTED a d TS h th to o s s /7 s n

3 STA Y ED whie t e pa te en a e i m e i ton. Couns lf rt e d f ns s a ls b i a pr pos d l h ri s g g n d a i e o h ee e h l u m t o e
4 or e f rm edi ton and i t rm paym ent consit ntw ih t e Cour ' i sructons att e hearng. dro ai nei s se th ts n t i h i 5
6
7 .

D A T ED : Thi 24t day ofM ay,2010. sh

8
9

U nied St t

s Di ti tJudge s rc

10
11 12
13

1 4 15 16 17 18 19

20
21

22 23

24 25 page 8 of 8