Denson v. Gillispie et al

Filing 4

ORDER that the Clerk of Court shall file the Complaint. The Complaint is dismissed for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. Amended Complaint to be filed within 30 days of this Order. Plaintiff's 2 Motion to Appoint Counsel is DENIED. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 8/3/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ECS, forms to plaintiff)

A l - : 21 t s ' 00 3
1 2 3
4

5

6 7
8 9 RI H A R D DEN SO N , C

UNITED STA TE S D IST R IC T CO U R T D IST R IC T O F N E V A D A

1 0
11 vs.

Plitl ani

CaeNo.2:0CV- 05 5- CJ( RL) s 1 - 0 2 R -L
O R DER

1 CLA RK COUN TY , ta . 2 e 1,
13
14

D ef nda t . e ns

1 5

Be or t ec u tiplitf' cvl iht c mpli t s a tt 42U. . . 1 3.Th c ur ha f e h o r s an ifs iirg s o an puru n o S C j 98 eo t s
a government lentt or om ce or empl yee of a gover m ent lentt ,'t e courtm us ïi entf a iy r o n a iy ' h t td iy

1 r v e e i, nd pl i tf w i nee t fl a a e d d c m pli t W he a ' rs ne s e sr dr s 9om 6 e iw d t a a n if l d o ie n m n e o a n . l n t io r e k e e s p

1 c gn z be cam sordim ist e c mplit or a y polin oft e c mpllt i t ecomplit( )i 8 o i a l li s s h o an , n -o t h o a ,f h an 1 s
Denson v. Gillispie et al

l fiolus maiius orfi t saeacam uponwhc rl fma bega td' ()s e smon tr 9 rv o , lco , al o tt li s ih ei y rn e , 2 e k c or eay 20 rl ffom adee da twhoi i mu e9om s c rle ' 28U. . .j1 1 A( ) Rul 1 ()6 ofte ei r e fn n sm n u h eif' SC 9 5 b . e 2 b( ) h
Doc. 4

21 Fe e a Rul sofCi i Pr ce ur pr vi e f rdim i s l a c m pl i tf rf i r t s a ea cl i upon drl e v l o d e o d s o s s a of o a n o a l e o t t u am

22 whc rlc ca begrne .Re iw u de Rul 1 ()6)i e snil ar l go aq esinoflw . ih eif n a td ve n r e 2b ( s se tal ui n u to a y n 23 Norh Sa l tr .v.Arz naCom.Corm',7 0 F.d 578,58 ( t Ci.1 8 ) l c nsdeig t tr nen io nn2 2 0 9h r 9 3 . n o i rn
24 whe he t e pl i tf h ss a e a cli upon whi h r l fc n be g a t d,a l a e i l le a i nsi t e t r h an if a t t d a m c ei a e r n e l m t ra a l g to n h
25 compl i tar accept d astueand ar t be cons r ed i t cEghtm os f vor bl t t epl i tf .Rus el an e e r eo tu n h t a a e o h an ir sl

26 v.La dre , 21F.d1 37,1 39( t Ci.1 ) Al g to sofapr s c mplian aehedt ls n iu 6 2 0 0 9h r 980 . l ain e o e o an t r l o e s
2 srng ntsa da dst a f r al e di gsd a ed b lwye s Hane v.Ke ne ,404 U. .51 ,52 7 ti e t n r h n o m pla n r û y a r . i s rr S90

28 (972 (e c ra ) 1 ) p r u im .

Dockets.Justia.com

1

Pli tf alegest ati t eeary morni g ofJanuar 7,201 ,polceoK cer wer wat hi g hi a n if l h nh l n y 0 i s e cn m

2 a d w atng f rhi t c i b down 9om a r ot Pl i tf f rhe a l ge t a a t rhe c i b d down,a n ii o m o l m o l an if u t r le s h t te le m 3 t u k a pr a he hi w ih ish ad i ht on.Pl i tf r n t a oi t etuc , nd de e da t as who r c p o c d m t t e lg s an if a o v d h r k a f n n Duc ,

4 wa drvngt etuc , t e e t wa d plitfla c lr td, ndsr c plitfl Plitf- a a r se . s ii h r k se r d o r an il c ee ae a tu k an il an il s re td w

5

Plitf ne talgest a t eme ia c r f rhi ij reswa ia e ua e Healge t a pol e an ir x l e h t h dc l a e o s nu i s n d q t . le s h t i c

6 ofi er l f hi sti g handc fed f ra hourbef rean ambul ncear i ed t t ke hi t t e hos ial lc s e t m itn u on o a rv o a m oh pt .

7 Onc a teho ptlhewa dig os dwih a lat3br ke rbs Attej i plitf alge ta e t h s ia, s a n e t t c s o n i . h al an if le s h t , 8 dee da tNa c r,nc, ihha dlsme ia c r a teji ga ehi 60 mgofiupofne ey1 fn n p ae l .whc n e dc l ae th al v m 0 , b r e vr 2
9 h ur ,whih d d nota lvi t t e pai . Pl i tf a s al gest a s v r lda s a t rbeng s r c , os ci l ae h e n a n if lo l e h t e e a y f e i tu k he

1 satdfeigpanfom ote ijre , ta dee d ntNa c r,Ic.ga ehi onl iupr fn. 0 tre e l i r h rnuis but h t fn a n p ae n , v m y b oe
11 Att e end ofhi compl i t pl i tf alegest athei kepti hi cel f r23 hoursaday,and t at h s an , an if l h s n s lo h

1 hi onl a c s t teji' lw l rr ibyimnerqu s fr s 2 s y c e s o h als a i ay s n t e e t o m . b
1 3 The l s t o iem si pl i tf ' com pl i tdo nots at acl i upon w hi h r lefcan begra t d. atw t n an ifs an t e am c ei ne

1 A pr -ralde a ne m a be ke ti a celf r23 hour a da . And r on v.Co nt ofKe ',45 F. d 4 e ti t i e y pn lo s y es uy l n 3

1 1 1 ,1 1 ( t Ci.1 95 .Plitf i aci ia dee da ti svea acin i teEiht J diil 5 3 0 3 6 9h r 9 ) anir s rm n l fn n n e rl to s n h g h u ca
16 D iti tCour oft e St t ofN evada. Couns lr pres nt pli tf-n t os actons and pr vi i n of src t h ae e e e s a n ili h e i , o so

1 c unslstsisterg tofa cest tec urs Se Stlehv. l a , F.d 1 49,1 53(t 7 o e aife h ih c s o h o t, e o- t Spcl n 654 2 3 3 9h s m 1 Ci.1 81.l plitf ca algea dtona fcsfrtes t oie st a co l saecams te h 8 r 9 ) f anif n le d ii la t o h e w tm h t ud tt li ,h n e
19 s oul putt em i t s par t count . hd h n o e ae s

20

Pl i tf ' ot e a lga i ns do s a e c a m s u o w h c r l fca be gr n e ,b tt e r q ie a n ifs h r le to t t li p n ih ei n e a td u h y e ur

21 s m e am endm ent because pl i tf hasus d i cor ectconstt tonalpr vii ns l count l,pl i tf o an if en r iu i o so . n a n ir

22 a l ge t a de e da t as sa tonsv ol t d t eEi ht Am e dm e t Pl i tf w a not prs ni m a e le s h t f n n Duc ' c i i a e h g h n n . an i s a io n t

2 und rajdgme tofc n itona t etme a dtusteEiht Ame dme tiia pl a l.TheFo lh 3 e u n o vci th i , n h h g h n n sn p i be c ut
24 Am e dm e ti t e c r e tc nsiuton lpr v son r g r i g t e f r e us d t s i epl i tE l eo n n n s h o r c o tt i a o ii e a d n h o c e o e z a n i n u t 25 2, ai tf a l ge t a hi m e i a ca tvi lt dt eEi h hAm e dm e t Agan, antf w a not prs n pl n ir le s h t s d c l r o a e h g t n n . i pl i ir s a io

26 imaeund raj dg e tofc n itona tetme a dtusteEiht Ame dme ti ia pl a l.Bel n t e u m n o vci th i , n h h g h n n sn p i be l c 2 v.W olih,441 U. .5 0,53537 & n.6 ( 97 ) The Foure nt Ame dme ti t e c re t 7 fs S2 1 1 9. te h n n s h o rc 28 c ntt tona poviinrgadigme ia c r ta ap etildeaic rc iesa aj i.Se Ciyof o siui l r so e r n dc l ae h t r -ra t n e e ev t al e t
-

2-

1 Re e ev.M as , n.Hos . 4 3 U. .239,2 4 ( 98 ) Ala e - a han v.Unie Stt s 1 7F.d vr s Ge n, 6 S 4 1 3 , v rz M c i td ae , 0 3 2 696, ( t Ci.1 9 ) I cou t3, antf alg st a hi beng sr c byt etuc a d hsme ia 701 9 h r 9 6 . n n pli ir l e h t s i tu k h r k n i dc l e

3 te t e ti ji viltd teFourh Ame dme t TheFourh Ame dme ti tec re tp ovson ram n n al oae h t n n. t n n s h orc r ii
4 r ga di g t e us o f r e butt e Fo r e nt Am e d e ti t e c r e tpr vii n r ga di g m e i a e r n h e f oc, h u te h n m n s h o r c o so e r n dc l
5 ca e.Addii naly,t e f ct alalegatons i count3 r peatt ealegatonsi count 1 a d 2. Pl i tf ' r to l h a u l i n e hlin sn a n ifs

6 am ended compl i ts oul have a counti voki g t e fourh Am endm entr gar i g t euseoff r e at an h d n nh t e dn h oc 7 hi ares, and t e amended compl it s oul have a count i voki g t e Foul eent Am endm ent s rt h an h d n nh -h t

8 rgadigtemedc lc r a tej i. e rn h ia ae t h al
9 Pl i tf ha na ed s ve a d f n a t , c i e be ow f rw h c he doe nots a ea c am . l an ir s m e r l e e d n s des rb d l o i h s tt li n 1 hi a e de c m pli t pl i tf w i n edt a lgef c st a c ul s ow ho t e ede e da t a ela l , 0 s m n d o a n , an ir l e o l a t h t o d h l e w h s fn n s r ibe
11 orpl i tf w ilneed t or i t es def ndant . an if l o nt h e e s

1 2 1 3

Onedef n a t t e Cl r Co n y De e ton Ce t r i abui i g.Pl i tf c nn ts eabui i g. e d n , h a k u t tn i n e ,s ln d a n ir a o u ln d Pl i tf- ass e t eLa Ve a M e r pol a Polc De a t e ta d Doug Gil s i ,S e if f an ilh u d h s g s to i n i e p r m n n t le p e h rf o

14 Clr Count ,n hi om cilca aciy.W hiei di i ualcapaciy actonss ek t i poseper onallabiiy ak yi s apt l n vd ti e om s i lt l5 upon a gover nentoë ci lf r actonsperor ed under col r of s at lw ,om ci lcapaciy ac i ns m ao i fm o t ea at to 1 generaly r pr s nt anot er way ofs i g tan entt ofw hi h an ofi er i an agcnt' Kent cky v. 6 l e ee h un ' iy c lc s .' u

1 Grha , 3U..1 9 1 (984 (uotngMonel De at e tofSocilSevc sofCiyofNe 7 a m 47 S 5 , 65 1 ) q i lv. p rm n a r ie t w 1 Yor , 6U..658 690n.5(978) l tec s ofd fn a tGils i,ta e tt i teLasVe a 8 k 43 S , 5 1 ). n h ae ee d n lepe h t niy s h gs
1 M et opolt n polceD eparm e t To s cceedw ih cl insagai s t edepart entand def ndantG il s i 9 r ia i t n. u t ar n th m e le p e

20 i hi om c a c pa iy, a n irm us pr ve t a a y c nsiuto a v ol ton t a h s fe e oc ur e ns i l a ct pl i tf t o h t n o tt i n l i a i s h t e u f r d c r d 2 1 asar s l of n ofi i l ol yorc s om , one l436 U. , t6 0, t r ugh af i r t t a nm u i i a e u t a fc a p i c ut M l, S a 9 or h o al e o r i n c p l u

22 e plye sa e ua ey,CivofCa t nv. ri,48 U. .378,388 91( 98 ) Plitf' al g to s m o e d q tl t n o Hars 9 S - 1 9 . an ils l a in e
23 do n ts ppo tt e c n l son t a w h tha pe e r s le f om s c ofk ila ton oft eLa Veg s o u r h o cu i h t a p n d e ut d r u h l a c i hsa
24 M etopolt n Polce Deparm ent r ia i t . 25 Fzaly,plizi hass ed Cl r Count ,butbecaus ott e sruct r ofgoverunentagenci si l a ltl u ak y e -h t u e r en

26 Cl r Coun yheha n ta l ge a y f c st a s ow h w t e c unt is l w a i vol e i h s a r s or ak t s o le d n a t h t h o h o y tef s n v d n i r e t
27 hi medi alcar . The LasV egas M et opolt n Polce D eparm ent i a di tnc entt ,w ih is ow n s c e r ia i t s si t iy t t

28 c pa iy t s e a d t bes e . Ne .Re .St t j 28 .8 . I ope a e t e Clr Co nt Dee ton a ct o u n o u d v v a . 0 2 0 t r t s h a k u y tn i
-

3-

1 Ce tr Se Ne . v.St t j280.84. Ac or ig t plitf' al ga ins a dee tv oft ep l e n e . e v Re a . 2 c d n o an ifs l to , tc ie h o i e c
2 deparm ent sruck hi w ih a ttck,and a contact roft e polce deparm enthaspr vi ed hi wih t t m t rl ro h i t od mt

3 i a e ua em e ia c r .N o p l yorcusom ofClr Cou t i a pa e tfom t e al ga i ns Unl s n d q t dc l a e oi c t ak n y s p r n r h l to . e s e 4 pl i tf c n al ge how t e c un y is l wasi vol e i t e ee e t , s oul omi Cl r Coun y i an ir a l e h o t tef n v d n h s v n s he h d t a k tn
5 hi am ended com pl i t s an .

6 Plitf ha s b itd a moto i sppor ofa poit e tofc unsl(2) t hee i no anir s u m te in n u t p nm n o c # .' r s T 7 c nsiutona rgh t a poit dc uns li aj 1 8 a ton.Howe er itçx e ton lcr um sa c s' o tt i l i t o p n e o e r t 9 3 ci v ,r e c p i a ic t n e ,

8 adititc urma a poitc uns lo idie t vilia tpurua tt 28U. . . l 1 ( )1) To src o t y p n o e frn g n ci lig ns s n o t SC j 9 5ge( ).
9 deci e whet ert es exce tonalcr um sancesexit aditi tcour m us eval a ebot t elkelhood d h he pi ic t s, s rc t t ut hh i i l ofs ccess on t e m ert and t e abiiy oft e pettone t ar iul t hi cl i spr s i lghtoft e 0 u h is h lt h ii r o tc a e s a m o eni h

l c mplxiy oft e lga is e ivole .' Ra d v.Ro ln ,11 F.d 1 20,1 25 ( t Ci.1 9 ) 1 o et h e l su s n v d ' n w ad 3 3 5 5 9h r 9 7

1 (ntr a quottonsa dcttonsomitd , tdrwnonohe gounds 1 4F.d9 2, 4n. ( t Ci. 2 i en l ai n iai te )wih a t rr , 5 3 5 95 1 9h r 1 1 98 ( nba c .Th c ur f dst at xc ptona cr u sa c sd note iti t i c s , ndt ec u t 3 9 ) e n ) e o t m h e e i l ic m t n e o xs n h s a e a h o r
1 de ist emoton (/ ) 4 ne h i /2 .
15 16 I I THEREFORE O RD ERE D t att e clr oft e courts al fl t e compl i t TS h h ek h h l ie h an . I I FURTHER O R D ER ED t att ecom pl i ti D I M I SED f rf iur t sat acl i upon TS hh an s S S o al e o t e am

1 whi hrelefcan begr nt d,w ih l a et am e d.Thecl r s alsend t pl i tf a ci i rght compl i t 7 ci ae t ev o n ek h l o an if v l i s an

1 f r wih i sr ci ns Pl itf wi ha et it ( 0)d ysfom t e d t t a t i or e i e tr d t 8 o m t n tu to . an ir l v h ry 3 a r h a e h t h s d r s n e e o l
l9 s bm i hi am ended com pl i t i he beleves t athe ca cor ectt e not d detci nci s. Faiur t u ts an , f i h nrh e ie e leo

20 c m pl w i t i o de w i r s l i t e d s is l t i a ton. o y t h s r r l e u t n h im s a of h s c i h l
2l I I FURTHER ORDERED t atpl i tf s al cl ary tte t e am ended compl itas s ch by TS h an ir h l e l il h an u

22 pl c n t e wor ' M EN D ED ' inm e i t l a ove v i i Ri ht Compli t Pur ua tt 4 U . . . a ig h dG A 'r d aey b c vl g s an s n o 2 SC

23 j1 , pa e1i tec pton, ndplitfsal ac t ec s n mbe,2:0- V- 05 5- CJ( RL) 983'on g n h a i a anifh lpl e h ae u r 1 C 0 2 R -L ,
24 a ove t e wor EA M EN D ED .' b h dI '

25
27
28

I I FURTHER ORDERED t a plitT smoini s ppor ofa poit e tofc unsl(2) TS h t ani to n u t p nm n o e #
Da e : i 3r da ofAugus , 1 t d Th s d y t 20 0.
,

26 i DEN I D . s E

U nied St t
-

D iti tJudge src

4-