Weber v. State of Nevada, ex rel Its Department of Transportation
Filing
61
ORDER Granting 46 Verified Petition for Permission to Practice Pro Hac Vice for Chris Harper and approving Designation of Local Counsel L. Joe Coppedge for Keith Weber re 54 Notice of Designation of Resident Attorney. Signed by Judge Kent J. Dawson on 11/2/11. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MMM)
t
y.
lt
h
:
UNI
TED STATES DISTRI CO URT
CT
DISTRICT O F NEVA DA
K IHWE E
ET B R
Ca e# 21 - 01 9 -KD-RJ
s
;0 W- 9 0 J )
Il ntl,
3ai i
VER I ED PETI O N FO R
FI
TI
PERM ISSI N TO PM CTICE
O
I TH IS CASE O NLY BY
N
A TTOR NEY N O T ADM I
TTED
TO TH E BAR OTION ISF URT
F TH O CO
A ND DESI NA
G
LO CAL CO UNSEL
CLARKCOUNTY, NE
VADA, ta.
e I
Deen n t)
f da ts .
EFFECTI JJ 1 20 4
VE INE , 0
FI NG FEE I $175.
LI
S
00
chrsHar
i per
5
- -
Pettoner r pe f l r pr nt t t Cour :
ii , es ctuly e ese s o he
t
ThatPettonerr i at
ii
esdes
E
dmond
ti l
csr
Okahom a Count
l
y
Okl oma
ah
-
(o n')
cut
y
(tt)
sae
ThatPettoneri a ator atl and am em be oft l lr of
ii
s n t ney aw
r he aw i m
ch i Ha p rIc
r r e ,n .
s
W ih ofi e a
t fc s t
2300W . nf t Rd.Suie 1 0
Da orh , t 2
E n ,OK
dmo d
(te t dde s
sre a rs)
(t
ci
y)
730124341
-
( i c de
zp o )
c per hrs pera c
har pc ihar lw.om
( lad e s
Emai dr s)
PiA 1 klu g ae,0/0-,t
a m $ sl zo t 1 /
d
-
.
n c it & 1 Jh Iias .
e ep # . 7f nt l
i
( s)35 0600
40 9-
(r ac + t lpho n
a e ode ee ne umbe)
r
*
I
I
3.
2
4
5
6
Tha Pettonerhasbeen r ai per onaly orasam em beroft l 11 by
t ii
et ned s l
he aw 1%1
K
eihWeber
t
t pr ij j r pr
o ov te egal e esent ton i connecton w ih
ai n
i
t
t above- ntted c e now pendi bef e t sCourt
he
e il as
ng or hi
.
1 6 19
0/ / 83
4.
Tha snce
ti
,pettonerhasbee and pr enty i am em ber
ij
n
es l s
( ae
d t)
i good sandi oft baroft hi tCourtoft St eof
n
t ng he
he ghes
he at
(tt)
sée
wher Pettonerr ary pr tcesI .
e ii
egul l ac i aw
7
5.
j
l
oka oma
lh
,
Tha Pettonerw asadm iled t pr i bef e t f l ng Unisd St esDi ti
t ii
t o actce or he olowi
t
at
srct
!
Co t ,Unie St t Cbcui Cou t ofAp al t Su e e Co t t Unie St t sa Co t
urs
t d a es
t rs
pe , he pr m
ur of he t d a e nd urs
9
ofot St eson t dat i ca ed f ea and t tPettone i pr nty a mem be i good
her at
he es ndi t or ch
ha ii r s ese l
rn
I
0
s andi oft bar ofs d Cours.
t ng he s ai
t
1I
Cour
t
Da eAdmit
t
ted
BarNumber
l
2
Tent Cic t
h r ui
52 1
/ 6/ 989
1
0325
13
U.S. C. eser Dititof a
D. W t n src Oklhoma
12 15 19
/ / 83
1
0325
I
4
U.SD. .
. C No/her DititofOkahom a
n s rc
l
1 11
2/ / 989
1
0325
15
U.S D. . as er Dit itofO ka
. C E t n sr
c
lhoma
4 8 1993
//
1
0325
1
6
17
18
l
9
20
6.
Tha t e ar orha been no dici i y pr
t her e
ve
s plnar oceedi i tt ed agai Pettoner
ngs nsim
nst ii ,
2I
no a s s e i ofa y lc ns c rii aeo prvie t a a bef ea j dii rgultr
r ny u p nson n ie e, e ttc t r i lge o ppe r or ny u cal e ao y
22
oradm i sr i body,ora r gnaton ort mi i i ordert avoi dici i ' or
nitatve
ny esi i
er naton n
o
d s plnal
y
23
dibanuentpr di exceptasdes i i deai bel :
s
ocee ngs,
crbed n t l ow
24
25
2
6
27
28
je atc e
s e ta h d.
1
,
I
I
1
I
2
i
I
!
1
I
I
1
7.
Ha Peii e e rbe nde ida misont t Stt Ba ofNe da? (fye ,
s tton r ve e ne d si o he ae r
vj ' l s
.
2
gi pa tc a so e l de id a mison :
ve riulr f ve' ne d si )
y
3
.
'
No
4
!
5
I
'
6
7
8.
ThatPettoneri am em be ofgood sandi i t f l ng Ba A s oci i
ii
s
r
t ng n he olowi
r s atons:
l lh maB As o ito
oka o ar s ca in
8
I
I
t
;
)
.
l
l
0
I
1
9.
Peii e ora y me e ofPe iine ' fn' ( o fc i 111ha bfiesi mor
tton r n mb r
tto rs i n or fie f 1-: s fc n e
1
t nonect wihwhih Peii ri asocae hasha tld a ia int)t > a a c uns
ha
iy) t c ttone s s itd / ve ie pplc to s o I r s o el
ppe
1
I.
J
un rLo l eI 1 2 d i t pa tt e ( )ye r i t f l ng matr q
de ca Rul A 0- urng he s hre 3 as n he ol
owi
te s
I
3
l
4
15
DaeofApplcaton
t
i i
Til ofCour
te
t
Adm i sr tve Body
nita i
orAr taor
bir t
Ca
use
None
lW asApplc i
iaton
Gr nt or
a ed
i o e ot
n j
l
E
1
6
.
17
18
;
19
E
20
(fn c s a y pla eatch asae ntofa dii la i to )
l e e s r , e s ta
ttme
d tona pplcainj
2l
1
0. Peii erc e t t t j iditonoft c ursa dsi i r boadsoft
tton onsns o he urs ci
he o t nd icplna/ r
he
I
22
St e of Ne
at
vadaw ihr pe t t 1 oft ssat gover ng t c
t es ct o he aw
hi t e
ni he onductofato eys t t s e
t
o he am
23
ext asa l beroft St e BarofN evada.
ent
nem
he at
24
25
26
27
28
l1
.
l
Peii ne a e st c mpl wih t sa a dsofpr esi l ond tr quie of
tto r gr e o o y t he tnd r
of sona c uc e r d
t m em ber oft baroft scourt
he
s he
hi
.
l.
2.
Pettonerhasdicl
ii
s osed i wrtng t t clentt t a i i notadm it t
n ii o he i hat he pplcant
ted o
p a tc i t sj idci a t a t cin h c ns ntdt s h rpr s ntto .
r c ie n hi urs iton nd h t he le t as o e e o uc e e e ai
3
.
Th tPe ii ne r s c f l pr yst tPe ii rbe a m itd t p a tc.7b f et sCo t
a tto r e pe tuly a ha ttone
d te o r c i ç e or hi ur
,
FO R THE PURPO SES 0F THI CA SE ON LY.
S
S
TATEol
r
couNTv oF
Okaoma
lh
Oka oma
lh
Chri Harper
s
)
)
)
ttone , i Ir td y w
r be ng i s ul
, Pe ii
Tha t f e i sae nt a ett
t he or gong ttme s r rl
e.
/
.
2
. ) e hd a :
?
,
' pos sa s ys
/
,.
'
/
e'
w#
,
.
Pet o e s gna u e
i r
tr
Subs i and s n t bef em e t s
crbed
wor o or
hi
eu.,
u,,
,
:
s%b
%b
%%
m '
#4y g; l%%%
& %@t %
f'
d yo
a f
N
*A*
# ol
.%
,
.r
A-, . , t cj
M! . z
w
o
)g
(5.o R
oayp bl or eko Co r
r u i
c
r f ut
. k
. AVe
Bps. .
Oxk s
.
,
.
.
.
DESI NA TI N OF RESI ENT ATTO RNEY
G
O
D
ADM I
TTED TO TH E BAR O F TH I C OU RT
S
AND CO NSENT TH ER ETO.
Purs
uantt t r r ent oft LocalRul ofPr i f t s Cour ,t Pettoner
o he equiem s he
es
actce or hi
t he ii
b le sit bei t be ti e e t o t cl nts t d sg t
eive t o n he s ntr ss f he i t) o e inae
e
P ii P Owe s1
hlp , n 1
l
,
Ator atLaw,m em beroft St eofNevada and pre ousy adm it t pr i bef et
t ney
he at
vi l
ted o actce or he
7*
J
-
above- il Cour asass at r i nce couns i t sacton. Theaddr sofs d desgnat
entted
t
oci e esde
el n hi i
es
ai
i ed
24
Neva counscli ,
da
s'
25
26
! W. orh R ,S t 1
2300 Danf t d. uie 20
jdmon , 701-3 4 5390 0
E dOK 3 2441 0-5 -60
27
( re,Ciy, ae, p Codea Tee neNo.
Ste t t Stt Zi
nd lpho
)
28
4
B tsegaot Ptieadneieprtsar tt!dsntn
yh dsntnh etnrnudrg dati)geh tseiao
i i i e io
sn ye e ah g i
constt es agr e and aut zaton f t desgnat r de adm it cou s t si
iut
eem nt
hori i or he i ed esi nt
ted
e1 o gn
s i atonsbi ng on al ofus.
tpul i
ndi
l
A P IT N O D SG A E RE I E TN V DACol S L
P ON ME T F E I N T D SD N E A
jE
N
I
Theu rine pat is a poit
ndesg d ryte) p ns
P lpPowe s1
hii . n 1
l
hi/ /hei Desi ed Resi Nevada Couns i t s cas
shert r
gnat
dent
el n hi e.
.
a
s
1
:
t rysgn tr )
pat i au e
t lysgn tr)
pa- i aue
t
'
CO NSEN T O F DESIG NEE
Th u ri dhe e co e
e nde sgne rby ns n
s
e
f
'
s caer sd n Ne d c tns li t sc s .
it e i e t va a o! e n hi a e
u
f :
.
?
.
t
91
42
Dein dRei ntNe daCo s l Sipnat ej Barnum ber
sg
sde va
un e,s g ur '
:
APPROV ED :
2nd
Dat t s
ed: hi
day of November, 2011
,20
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI JUDG E
CT
i
.
2:10-cv-01990-KJD -RJJ to:asï r. s 46
'
OS fop toca,nCasex r l. kilon' BalAs ' v Ea n r Documento n ta Filed 10/05/11 rPage:.s ? iei-48 (
l
'
'
r
icai u/ s xde i
c l 6 of 10
ex îu d ' l,e tsaue . e . a' a . s.n - r q ht ,v'vv o n.e' pp i tol o c lve uo - e ta c t u g3 )
l
.Tt
o
w w x aaw
T H E O KLAH OM A STATE C O U RTS N ETW O RK
.
1 '
I
1
l1 '
. .
* . .
z
..
1
I
l
.
.
Oloaur eorae
khmSpmCuCss
a
e t
1
i
St e ex.r .O kl
at
el
ahom a BarAss' v.Har
n
per
2000 O K 6
995 P. 1
2d 143
71O EJ 400
'
Cas Number:SCBDe
4444
Dccded:92/ /
i
01 2000
Supre eCourtofO kl
m
ahom a
STATE OF O KL
AHO MA exr .Okah
el l oma BarAssocat Com pl ian
ii
onl
an t
v.
Ch is C.Har iResp
ar
e
per
onden .
t
( R2d 11
995
441
O RI I PROCEEDI FO R ATTO RNEY DI PLI
G NAL
NG
SCI NE.
! Co iia tOka o B rAs o it n fldfr c mpan a antatre algi voit no Rue42o
! mpan nl lh ma a s cai , i omal o lit g is t n y l n iai f l 1 f
0
o e
o
e g
o
Oka o Rue o Poe so a Co d c.Af r h ar g,Prfs in lRe p n iiy Tiu a rc mme d d
th ma ls f rfs in l n ut t e i
e
n oe so a s o sbl r n l e o t e
i b
t
dimio ofcompi n .
s s al
ait
'
RESPO NDENT EXORERATED;
APPLI O N FO R ASSESSM ENT OF CO STS DENI
CATI
ED.
Al J W elb,Okaà ma 5arAsspcatp Okl oma Ci ,Okahoma.Atsr f Compl n t
l . c
en
lr
i iq
ah
t l
y
l ney or
aîan .
t ney or pocd t
en .
J S.Dawssn.James A.Sci e MierDsp rl Okah
ack
m ca, l
l
l tde, l oma Ci fOkaà
a i
t
y l oma,qtor r Res
HODGES.J.
!
l
1 OVERVI
.
EW
:
i
: pondentittteChareoC.Har Asoitn a)gdoecuto mit nutwadenthadiolleaéis
1C mparn,h Oklsm B f ( caldenteThe compl n alf sodc r nigdsltn rg 4 2
o lator . l a a s o, l e n on l c tResponr t vi ped ul nt
k ney a
a
h
a n cai j
r
es
per Respon .
ait eged ha
o t Okahoma Ruls o Prf sonalCon c (
f he l
e f oes i
du t ORPC) Okl.Stt tt 5 ch 1,app.3- ( 991 ( oh iin
, a a . i.
.
A 1 ) pr i t
o
agaistc
n ommunia in wih a peron kn t be r es ed b ar atorey) Respon t h n een
c to s t
s
own c
epr ent y i t n .
den as ot
Jicil ed orh r pr l sy been àe slj !ofa grev a.The Pr f sjnalRespon j ly Trbu ( RT)
s pi
n
as rt evou l
h tbec
i anc
oes o
sbit j nai
j
f nd t a Res den ha n volt r e 4. an r omm en dsmisal t e complit
ou h t pon t d ot i a ed ui 2 d ec
ded s s of h
an .
I
1. AGTS
4F
I
I
T2 At@E lma ofte al ged mjcpntu .Res den r pr ent GovenmentEr oyee lsuanc Com an
N. l
i l
l e
s jct pon t e es ed
r
npj s n r e
y
( CO) Th r es t i ar e ou o an auomobl accden iv vig Bob e Ten er( equer,GEI O'
GEI . e epr enaton os t f
t i
e i t nol n
bi equ Ten
)
s
isu ed Th al i s ar t Resp den vitt r l 4. of t ORPC b comm u c i g wih T
n r
e l on e hat
egat
on t oa ed ue 2
he
y
niatn t ene u
er
co er lg te a den wih tfstnetig t c sen o Tenequ ' at n ev l ou h k w t sh was
nc nn h cci t tou i
r
tn he on t f
ers torey en h gh e ne hat e
r pr s t l t e m ater
a e ened n h
t.
:3 Th u lig f t ar asf l OnDec
e nder n acs e ol
y
ows
ember27 1997 T qu J n Mclt h (en er boyr n
ene er oh
nos T equ ' fi d)
s
4 l . J (: PM
/ / 1 340
20
I
Case 2:10-cv-01990-KJD -RJJ Document 46
CSCN F p ' cl c tStl c a l.oklh n Ba As ' v Ha n r
I
oudDu t n: ae x rz v a ota r sn
m
i
re
Filed 10/05/11 Page 7 of 10
it :,ï s $o c . L D i a inso u d ic do t ta D7;t i=48 (
1 D.&x' , s nne' DIc to / s n/elv r u mwn ' kild 93)
t ' ' 5.
'
a
f
I
i
an tei ( P. 1 45 baby wer tav lg on a rr r n Pon Ci Th vehce I whc t eyI e
d h r 995 2d 1 1
e r el
n
ual oad ear ca t e lt n lh h wer
y.
ta l g was o
r vei
n
wned b Ten ers f heran Is ed t r gh hi bv GEI .Th pikup s r ck s e c te k hph
y equ ' at
d n ur h ou m
CO e c
tu om atk v c
wer i t r
e n he oadway I i u cl whet er att e t oft e accden Tenequ or h boy ren was drvr t
. t s n ear
h
h p
me h
i t
er er f i d
tig he
j
pik p. tt e pol e r or sh
c u bu h
i ep t ows l atT equ was drvn
c
h en er
iig.
'
1
74 Mcltsh an t babywer t en t te ho t I Pery
no
d he
e ak o h spi n r.
al
Oka o .Th b b wasuijr b ts p o'dl
lh ma e a y
nnued u u p ie y
!
h prbl slepig f s tme afert e accden.Mclt su
ad o ems e n or ome i t h
i t nosh bsequ ty h k suger He algedt
en l ad nee r y
l
e hat
t kn e i r f whih h iad s ger was cau d by t e ac dent Tenequ al gedl su f ed b or ne
he e qu y or c e l ur y
se
h ci .
er l
e
y fer ack I ck
pan asa r p oft a dentan was teat by a chr ac or
i
esut he cci
d
r ed
iopr t .
'
$5On J ar 13.1 ator ey Ken J (ean wr e t lter t GEI l t frtI t .h ielies
anu y
998. t n
ny ean J ) ot wo e t s o CO. n he ls eter e d if
ti
J h McnohadTnq e a hscins J a a vsdGECO ta h h b e rt ndt rpr etMcjos
on lts n ee u r s i l t e n d le I ht e as e n eaie o e esn lt h
e
a d T e e i tei cam s f rb n f s u de te me ia p y n p o iin o te p l y a d p s il iars
n en qu r n h r li o e e i n r h dc l a me t r vso f h oi n o sby li
t
c
n
u dert ucns ed mot ltpr i on oft e pol y.I t e sec d Iter Jean ien ii s ony M cl os as hi ll
n he i ur
ors ovsi
h
i nh
c
on e t .
d tf
e
h
nt h
s ci
ent
I
on a peron ijr cal f n len agais Ten
s al nuy l m or egl ce
g
n t equer I te s d l t J st es:'n est ato has
. n h econ eter ean at lv i i
g
det mied tatt ese ij i wer pr i el c s by te n i acs orf l es t act ofy i ued
er n h h nures e oxmat y au ed h egl
gent t
ai
ur o
our n r
(en er.
T equ l'
'
i
16 OnMar 4,1998,J s GEI a deman lteron beh fofte b .Mar s,J cl m ed $ 1. on
1
ch
ean ent GO
d et
al h aby xu ean ai
41 30
beh fofMar s f medialbis an $3, 00 f pai an suf ig an of ed t s te f $2. 0, I te
al
xu or
c l d 000. or n d fern d fer o etl or 50 00. i h
l
n
Iter Je made i ceart the was r r ent g it es s adv se t Tene ' wh h s at
et
an
t l ha
ep es i n er t
n
er o
quers en e t ed:
:
( ou is r Ien q e)i fl rs o sbefrtea cd n i q e t n a tedr e src c sl i
Y) rn ued ' e u r s ul e p n il o h c ie tn u si , s h i r tu k at n
F
y
o
v
e
t r way Sh wasobvitsl drvn t f tf c diinsl ihwer darn s,r nan f 'an
he oad . e
o l y iig oo as or on t wbc
o
e k es ai d oj d
was,tef or un e t st h v i e p irt t i pac.1 i alo cl t er i n evden e at
b ef e: abl o op er ehcl ro o he m t 1 s s ear h e s o i '
k
aI ofan con rbu or orcompar ie n ienc de ense av l e t your is ed,
I
y ti t y
atv egl e f
g
ai
abl o
n ur
a mycin wa
s
li s
e
a fut s p s e g ra d p r me n i rp ra t n I e s n e Ih v n rs rain# t
a le s a s n e n ef d c mpc e ci . n se c l a e o e ev t ' o
l
or
o
o s
tyig tl ca b or aj y o my cint peer f t flamoun ofdamages pt ab e. .
r n hs se ef e ur f l '
e s s or he ul
t
i ed ov
s
1 3i t rWrt On b fofM cIt ht G EI O on Mar 1 ,199 ..ean made t i s e sat
n ete ien
t
ehal
nos c
C
ch 8
8 1
hs am t ementr l n
egar g
di
Ten t ' 0 k I en .
eq l s 6g i ce
er
g
:7 I Mar o 1
n ch f 998,GEI pai Ten
CO d equers cli u derte medialpaymens pr sin of te p iy.Ie
' am n h
c
t ovio
h op l an
c
a erd ta te s tlme to T n qu r cam frme ia p y ns If T n q e wi a p s il u ii rd
v re ht h et n f e e e' li o dc l a me t et e e u r t o sbe nn ue
e
s
h
mool c i a ant IO adalbl ca a a s teo e o tecte C mpa ata sr ta l a
trt lm g is GEC n i iy li g i th wn r fh at . o li n set ht e n
s a
ai m n
t
l
n
s
s i r e t Tenequ on t ese cai s
tl epr sen ed
l
er h
lm .
!8 GEI S r esenatv Car W i l it viwed Mclt h i J s ofie i Au s.Atte tme W i l
1
CO' epr t ie l mbery n er e
nos n ean' fc n gu t h i
mbery
as d J l he k
ke ean f
new h t r
ow o eachTenequ .J s a ed t atT equerh mov d an t ath di n ha h
er ean t t h en
ad
e d h e d ot v er
n a es ort eph e n
ew ddr s
el on umber J st ed tat when T
. ean at h
eneq c ac ed hm t at h w oul i t r co t t
uer ont t i h e
d n un
ac
W i ber .Att tme of Mct t h' it viw Jean di o(tmak an m en i t at h stlr pr l Ten uer
m l
y
he i
n os s n er e
d )
e y
ton h e i e esen ed e
l
n i e dd h lf an t ig t t ec n r r '
et r i e ner y hn o h o ta y
h
j .
.
I
39 GEI S ca
CO' l
I
l I n es s
m og ot how taton Au t12I19981Ten ercal GEI t obai te sats o her
h
gus
equ
l
ed
CO o t n h t u f
sons cli .Att e tm e.sh If me G EI t atsh was di ssng J as oft atday. Sh was t d t h
' am
b i
e n or d
CO h
e
smi i ean
h
e
el o ave
Jean n tf GEI i
oi
y
CO mmedit y
a el
i
:
$1duct n o tAu se1nt 1l8,btlTenequer T n q e Iwa n In' rrpe e td b a at n y Wi b r
0 Th n ephon 9er9 w wihe lg ta e e u r s o o g e rs ne y n tore , mIel
e
gut i. v9 eivn h t
e '
y
con ed a ei
e
'
'
.
ask T equ I J s i r r ent her
en er f ean tl ep es ed .
l
T n q er c mme t d r gte ieriw po td Wi b r t
e e u s o ns ui h n ve rmpe m eI o
n
t
l
y
tOQalo.e tt w spo etdeeureldalencoththddntae hadeg',
hct ilw rh I a uthr Tnqert ctJaolhr ase i thatJean cs a(I
e ot g n a t
t
e
o ioehw i tt gtu fhfc an ohvaabas'k t
s vrop he otd eee e d
c
h a t tn
e
d/
's
:.
a
I
n
dO R hI
,
i
V1actht nloteiece,eeurnhe ecWmeitr.otCO' hronvu s995e2d M Ioh
1At edi) h nre Tnqeiomddenbr htcnayoi p lste n,1cjs
tal f e tvw he i fr i, y a n r t e r o a m t r
e g h ehr
l
r l e gus t s q
was u ydrvr t v l att tme oft ac i t Anen y i GEl sfes Au t( P. 1 46 21
t
1
998 idi es W i b i t ough T
n cat
m er h
y
t enequ was n t r esen ed b an ato n . Becau ofTen ers chan e i
er
o epr t y
t r ey
se
' equ '
n
t i on p whlh sh st ed t at M clt was drvn . GEI cn act d Resp den an ask hi t t e
est y n c
m
e at h
n osh
lig
CO nt e
on t d
ed m o ak
T n q e' sae n ud o t
e e u r ttme t n er ah
s
i
!
!2rpprtnoti Tnqe'stmn.EC snRsodnacpoMcts'stmnle
I nr aai tran eeur te etG IO etepnet oyf loh teetin
1 e o kg
sa
n sa v
4/ / l 3:0 PM
l 20 1 4
I
1
Case 2:10-cv-01990-KJD -RJJ Document 46 Filed 10/05/11 Page 8 of 10
OSCN FlzjDo t niuk-x C-. klh x Ia Asïa'Hkpz htaïyv .s n.e'p iai so c d lved = e t s ? ïed 93
t l ct ts t e - elo, aoc t3. s . t lr : : sln' i n ba plq ton's s/e i r ot n. cti=48 O
t
me
e
r
c
.
'
o
a
i
t Wi eû a copy of Tereguer'sttme tgvnt Wi el.a( l rp rfo Wibr t GEI .acte
o mb r
y
e
y ld e ctrm r e/ o CO nih
e
n y
l
s ae n f c mb r
.
cli 1 not Th r ds r l ttatT equ was n ln r eseced as ofAug t21 199 aft e
am og es. ese ecor ef h en er
ec
o o ger epr t
us
8, h
lt t The r on
a es
esp dentaran t t e Ten ers s at
r ged o ak
equ ' t ementon Oc ober20 1998 i La on O kah
t
n wt
l oma.
! 3 A te b gn ig o te sa e n ,Re p n e ta k c T n q e i s e wo l I e t h v a lwy rp eI n
I t h e lnn f h t t me t s o d n s e l e e u r f h ud i o a e a e r b t
1
k
e
T querr id tatsh sa n n t ha a Iwyerpr t Sh di no ment n t s was r es t by
ene
epl h e w o eed o ve a
e
esen. e d t
i hat he
o
epr enej
JaTenequerh sae n,R eanntl t sesentn qexusJ a watheirpcalni and sat Marxswtru h
e n D rgt w ermehat ep se ra kdT eMar i e n onssl e rs bin hrto . ru,binot
. ui anstt t Jso d nepre e urf onl
n e ed t
tl ee tg e h n Maxus asj T
h .
er
p
ed
y
medi
l
l
s
l
malgacam a ant erT n qe ak Re pnen Isehdacar aais teo e o tec tet 'hc
kn li g ish .e e ur sed sod tf h a li g nth wnr fh at oj ih
n
l
h rs o d dta h ddn k o b th th GEI wa io i it teq e t nfrp s il ri us me to
e e p n e h t e i ot n w u ta te CO s o kn no h u si o o s e emb re j f
g
o
b
wà i h p d outon pr t damage.
at t ad ai
cpary
11 pRocEDuRAu HI RY
1,
STO
:
'
I
! d J a fe a giv r e wilC/ lia t Co lia tte fe a c mpaital gn ta Re p n e th c
/ e n id r al t mpan n. mpan n h n id o ln l ig b t s o d npal
l
l
e c /
l
e
voi ed r e 4. oft e O RPC b commu catn wihTen erev t ou h k w t t s w as r esen et by
i at ul 2 h
y
ni ig t
equ
en h gh e ne ha he
epr t Il
a atre .atePRTJeanathaigonteTente.Attanhniigede ntitidm.twhposied oat n jo
n t ns Th
o y
h d s leepr enth matr onh uasur Jmotestcl ta' e R s tnee I k
el l rr es ed equer e er , a orsieaihJean n t phd htwas
n
n
f
e
o
T quer s ement
ene ' t
n
is siaigtep s ift ta tec teweeolh ra b c u eo ac n e t wi av hce gin T n h er
nf t t h c sbly h th at r fte o d e a s f o n czn t e ill / g e e u
eg n
i
l
:
I
a possbe cl m un t unisu ed mot itpr si n cft e pol y
il ai der he n r
ors ovi o s h
i.
c
:
I
%15 A tan crp ofT equer sat tun oat wa su te it e den e.I r l t t te su j tof
r s it en
' t emen der h s bmi d n o vi c t efecs hat h be
s
t
Resp den ' comm u cat n w i T'
on ts
nf i
o t enequ was GEI ' r pon bit f ? ly cl i made agaistT e u
h
er
CO S es sf l y or i i a ms
i
abit
n en er
b Mcnosh W i l t tfed atte hearn t t h h 'o k owldge tatI l s
y lt . mber esii
y
h
ig ha e ad ' n e
n
h lean upposedl r esened
y epr jt
( quer. Liewi Resp
Tene l' k se.
'
onden' u conr ced t tmon wa tat atte tme h t h st emenlh di
ts n tadit esi y s h . h i e ook er at t 4 d
,
ntko ta xa rpe e tdTnq e. h rsod n tsie ta h b lvdta iwo l b av lino
o nw h tl n e rs n e eu rT e ep re te tl h t e ei e h tt u e ia j f
e
e
fd
e
d
ot
rl17o teOR C frJa t rpeet ohMcnoh tep se gradT n qesh die o te
u . fh P 1 o en o e rsn b t lts,h asne,n e eurte r z th
e
v
v hil a te tne oft a cd n ,Th t si y wa ta i wo d be ig l u us a f rte s rl
e ce t h ù
he c ie l e e t
mon s h t t ul t hy n u l o h hr
i
e
ator y t r pr e b0t t i ur drve Ofa vehi e u t pas engermaki a cl m agai tt
t ne o e es nt h he ns ed i r '
cl nd he s
ng ai
ns' he
!
drv r Complï n p e e t dnoe ie et .Re g nd n ha a ta l wldg tatJ a rp ee t d
ie.
ana t r s n e
vd nc ha s o e t d cu lc e e h e n e r s q e
t
no
Te
nequera t tz oft hearng.
t he ine he
i
!
'
k, L S
V Am YSI
;
I
N1 Ths Cout r i o te rcor i de nov ( P. 1 47)St e ex r .Okah BarAs ' v W i i ,
6 i r' evew f h e d s
s
o. 995 2d 1
at
el l oma
sn . I ns
1 9 OK 5 . 2 8 8 P2 1 .,1 0 E e to ght i Co r i n t ou d b t ePRT Sr c mmen a in , h a e
95
9 $1 , 9 .d 4 5 . v n h u hs ut s o b n y h
7
' eo
d t s te r
o
n ed.Be or ti Cour w i i p dici ie t compl nan mu t pr e te c ges by claran con icig
ot
f e hs
t l m ose s pl he
n
ai t s œv h har
e
d v n
evden e.I .
i c J.
!
117Rue 4. ofte Okahoma RulsofPr essin Con t Okl St .t.51c 1,app.3- ( 991 pr ie I
1
l 2 h l
e
of o al duc , a. at i h.
t
A 1 ) ovd :
! rp e e t gacin,alwy rs al o c mmu iaea ou tes be to terpe e tt nUi a
n e r s ni l t a e h ln t c nc t b th ujc f h e rs nai t
n
e
o h
p ro teIwyrko t b rpeetdb aohriwy rntematruls tel e h s
es n h a e nws o e ers ne y nte a e i h t . n s h a / a
e e
wy j
te c en oft oherIwy ori auh ied b lw t do s
h ons t he t a er s torz y a o o.
I
I
Th c men s s a e'
e om
t tt
The pr i ton o communca i wi a r r en ed per ony appl ho ef i cic m s an es
ohbii f
i ton t
h ep es t
son l
i
es wev n r u t c
wher t e S er k ows t at t e per on i ilf t r esen ed i t e matert be dicu sed.Thi
e h awy n
h h
s s r ac epr t n h
t o
s s
s
p Iwver ha ac ual k w ldqe of t e f of t e r es t ton' bu s h a t
a
d t
no e
h act
h epr en a i
t uc
ual
mean t t .
s ha
kr wt
t edge r ay be if r fom t cicu t ces ..- a (w y can tev t r ie ent
o
t
n
n ered r he r ms an
'hus a er no ade he equr
I
o obt nig t cons tofcoun by clsig ey t t e obvi u
f ai n he
en
sel o n es o h
os
( ass ad ) Rul 4. has t ee r rmens ( ) a c
Emph i ded. e 2
hr equie t: 1
ommu c i ( wi a per on kn t be
nlaton 2) t
h
s
own
r es t b anator ey.( ontemat cft r es tton.
epr ened y
t n 3) h ter be epr enai
:1 Compl n l a oc es tatRe derth actllkrwl
18
aiar dv at h
t
spon l ad t r edge t Jean r es t T equ wbl I t
a
hat
epr ened en er i
e be
sa tme st tn tn t Respon
me i
a ig ta
dentc
ame t t e c cuson tatT
o h on l i h enequ was un epr t bas on a s is of
er
r esen ed ed
erb
4/ . l 3: P
l / 1 40 M
20
I
Case 2:10-cv-01990-KJD -RJJ Document 46 Filed 10/05/11 Page 9 of 10
öscbr xcro tne thaeex r-a a n B;rAsk-.HtDe ic :/vè l'os n. e lplcatol . ctdelveruoctnlnta. ciei =48930
Fo llcx nzl t- - eloklho ut . slv u r l / v vl. i n fi i i o F
l
t
r
p
os
i
l e . p? t d
-
!
mlc luain Compan n as s e s ac n tut no rë 42 whc wo l n g t terq i men o j ta
s ac lt s
o
iia t lo e k o srci f ue . ih ud e ae h e ur t f cu l
o
e
k edge ofte r es tton and ad at tatt sCoutr af r e 4. t r ie onytata Iwy sh d
nowl
h epr enal
voc es h hi
r edr t ul 2 o equr l h
a er oul
h v k o o te rpe ena in ç1 We r c Co lia t rq e tt rwre rl 42 t a rg t te
ae nwn f h e rs tt . 9
o
qe t mpan n' e u s o e i ue . o bo ai i
s
t
n
r ie en t a lwy ' kn edge ofr esenat n r stbe ac u .The e i t I n
equr m t hat a ers owl
epr t i nu
o
t al
xpl a guag cft e r e r qlles
ci
e l h ul e u r
atako eg oterpeettno tematrfh sbetfh cm n asnOR C, l Sa.i5
cuInwi e fh ersnaL nh t ote ujcote o mui t . P Ok . tti. ,
d
o
e
co
a
t
ch 1 app.3A,r e 4. ( 9 ) Fut ,1e c
.,
- ul 2 1 91 . rher h ommens iav n qu ton tat wi tact knowldge otte
t e e o esi h . t
hou ual
e
h
:
r e t i t ei n vol i ofr l 4, i.atrl 4. c . crbn ac u kn edget a lwyerbas on
eprsenat her s o i at
on
on ue 2,# ue 2 mtAs iig t al owt
o a
:d
tefcsd n th s mea a pligterl u d r l u t c swh r teIwy rs ou h v k o . rfs
h a t s o te a s p yn h ue n e cr msane ee h a e h l a e n wn We ju e
c
d
t adoptCompl n ts pr ed con r tonofr l 4. oft e O RPC.
o
aian i opos
stuc i
ue 2 h
I
520 Th e i n qu t n tat Respon
er s o esi h
o
dent commu cat wi Ten
ni ed t
h equer Th iquiy ten i () œh her
. e n r h s 1 èt
Rsoernscm etal wt Tnhadrw saott sbJeanftesente Tenequerona rperlThe
epnet 2) multn pontent qe ualknowl h tujc orh m tro w c Jtnmat sn d
d ' o nero i eeuact bu e hat t epr aed n hh ehe er jt
c
h
a edge e e t
e. e
T equ ,an ( wh h Res
en
d
t
s j ofte comru cat s bet
ubect h
n ni l
on
ween Resp den an T equ was h I ly f Mclt ' ij isi
on t d en er
er i i or noshs nur and
abit
e
GEI s r ponsbit f paymen ofMcItshs cli I herswor sat
CO' es i ly or
i
t
no ' am. n
n t ement Ten r sai tath 'on
l eque d h erI .
s
Maxs ddnthv angi neca a anthro l a c i frmei l a me t wh hd nth g o
ru, I o a e e le c li g i e. n lm o dc p y n i o o i h n
g
m
s
y a
a
s c
n
Ten ers ne i ce.T
equ ' gl
gen
enequ ' cli f medialpay en s h been se ted i Mar o 1998.J al ged
ers a m or
c
m t ad
tl n
ch f
ean l
è
t h r es t d Ten
hat e epr en e
egueron a cai agaistt ca t own an on an u n r mot itcl m.T equ '
lm
n he tl
e
er d
nisu ed
ors ai en ers
u i urd mot itcli wasn t subec oft ecommunc i Th s Res
nns e
or am
s
ot he j t h
iaton. u
ponden di n communc e ab ta
t d ot
iat èu
su j ti amat f whchJ r es td h .1 .atr l 4.
bec n
ter or i ean epr ene er . ue 2.
:
i
I
$ 1Co li n age ta tes b c o tematr nwi hJ a rpeetdT n qe wa teacd?.t
2 mpa at rus hth uj t fh t o l e n e rs ne e e u r s h ci tI
n
e
e
i
c
e
wo l b f r in t mo tIwy r r rs nig a is r n e c mp n ta v a c ud h v r r s ne T n qu
ud e o eg o s a e s ep e e t n n ua c o a y h t l n o l a e ep e e t d e e er
n
e
g n al rgadn tea cd n a wela tep s n e fig acam a anth r lJ a r r e tdMcro h
e er l e rig h c ie t s l s h ase g f i
y
l
n li g is e.f e n epes ne lts
j
o hscam a an ttec teo eronhsn gie c cai a ais T n q e, dc hsu i ue mooitjam
n I lt g is h at wn . i e l n e l m g n t e e u ran l i nn rd tr ll
l
g
n
s
s
agaistGEI he woud n ess i atem p t sh n ony t tt c t ownerwas n gl en bu aloiha
n
CO
l ec ary t t o ow ot l ha he atl
l
e
e i t t s t t
g
Ten uerwasnegl en.O nt ot han i a cai br gh byTen lra ns t e catl ow n J ëoul
eq
i t
g
he har d n l m ou t
eqke gai t h
t
e
er ean
d
at t(9 P2d148 t s o ta T n q e wa n tn gle tap st nic n itn wi J ansrprs càin
t
emp 9 5 . 1 )o hw h t e e u r s o e i nl o io n o sse t t e ' e e e tt
g
i
h
o
ofMcl t .Ths i ius r ed by t f tt atJ t c w r e t G EI .on on Mcl t ' behal,s atn lha
nosh i s l tat
l
he ac h ean wie ot o
CO ce
n osks
f t ig' t
t
T
enequ ' n len was te sol caus ofte ac d .See i atrl 1. and 1. Under r e 17 o t
ers egl ce
g
h e
e h cient
;. ues 6
7,
ul . f he
O RPC.J ' r es t i n ofMclt on a n l ce cli agaistTen erwoud appe t be icoc st t
eans epr en at
o
n osh
egi
gen
am
n
equ
l
ar o
n si en
wi J ' r es t i o Ten erev at dicos e o te c fitan c sen by te paris.Th t
t eans epr enaton f equ
h
en fer s l ur f h onl d on t h
c
te
usl he
c
ommunc i at t t o Ten
iat
on he i f equers sat tcoud n h e be t su j t on te mater of z '
me
' t emen l ot av en he bec
h
t
qans
r es t i n ofTen
epr en at
o
equer
.
ç22 Ev i te communcai i te sat
en f h
i tons n h t ementwer ab ta s bjcti a materi whc Jean r es et
e ou u e n
l n ih
epr ent
T n q e,Re p n en h dn k o e g o terpe e tt n 80hRe p n e ta d Wi b r t tidta ie
e e u r s o d t a o n wld e f h e rs nai . t s o d n n m el esi h th y
o
y f
e
l
di no k w t atTen erwas r es e by an ator .Th r cor t t Res den r ceied fom G I
d t no h
equ
epr ent d
t ney e e ds ha
pon t e v r
CO
r fe ed t at Ten er was u epr en ed at t t e Res den t h s at
e lct h
equ
nr es t
he i
m
pon t ook er t ement W h Resp en
.
en
on t
if med Tenequ t atsh c l h e an ator ey pr sent sh ment ne n hig ab t J
n or
er h
e oud av
t n
e
e
i d ot n
o
ou ean r es tn h .
epr eni g er
W hen Res
ponden as ed T
t k enequ i Jean r e t h s t ou h .Resp den m a cerai t t J
er f
epr sen ed er on hr gh er
on t de t n ha ean
di no r esen T equ ' s on an n i c cli agai s h ,
d t epr t en ers on
y egl e a m
gen
n t er
pl A t teogi t samn Ten qu rwas n tev nolota mdtlamnurong njlh
oc th i fin h tt et e e o e a ye ttMclapyetrii oai
y e m vg e e
n nhe eioshwas ppui a tm
h n
c
vo te
s
war
s
,
gen
us t s btu ha an ep es t ene er
ag isth f n i ce Th , ii dou flt tJe r r ened T qu on Mclt ' cai agais hqron
an er or egl
noshs l r
n nt
t ne ien is
he gt ce s ue.
g
!
i
13C mpannesstio rre etTsei iienRalodneerhleaoumi ta Repwld taf
Gnl e titJanöh Copt l oedspTho sepnetaleog iadt htSsodnro
1 codta taki stuto mpenqerle micsuain vntouht d GECO' ko e thd
o d
2 u ha
dn e rs n
cn
s
ne
J
u.
c lt s l v v r n I
o
n g
ean' r esen aton o Ten
s epr t i f equer r h t an Res den i.W e fn n evd ce t at Res dentac ual k ew
at er h
pon ts
id o sen h
pon
t l '
y n
'
t a Jeanr es ed Ten eratt e tm e Respon tt h s at
ht
epr ent
equ
h l
den ook er t emen .
t
I
12 Compk n r i on an e hc cpl on isu b te Amerc BarAss aton whc st es ' h t
14
alant el
es
tis ni s ed y h
ian
oci i
lh at : ' en he
W
r esened pary decar tatc sel beendic ged,(h sen bi c s woul be c fr wh h te)
epr t
t l es h oun has
s har
te) si e oure
d on im eter h
lwye ha b efec iel dichar .'ABA For Opii 95- 6.W e agr t att i i te sensbl c s .I
a r d een f tv y s qed '
mal non 39
ee h hs s h
i e our n
f t GEI pr
ac , CO obabl s l h e con i ed t tT
y houd av
fr
m
ha enequ h di h ged J . Ths if maton I n i pu d t
er ad sc ar
ean i n or i s ot m t o
Re
spon
dentf pu pos ofa r e 4 2 volton. Th r or G EI su id t Respond r l ta T e uer
or r es
ul
iai
e ec ds
CO ppl o
e
ent efect h t en
was un epr t att e tme Respon tt h s a em en .
r esen ed h i
dan ook er t t
t
I
, 1 2 1 3;0 PM
1
72 0l 4
J
2:10-cv-01990-KJD Haprr ko.ws v, ct uaFiled o osvd l er c e 10 ? 10 95)
OS Fcp Do meCaseckL OVlj B; AsY-.-RJJ Documents46e 'p iai10/05/11v Pagen.s of ti-48 (
CN l d cu n:l w) d. aà
u
tSut i
ooa k s y r
r
u .,/ vv o z. nlu t %/ c e i do . ta c,ed
'
n
I CO NCLUSI N
V
O
725Complkan ha fi !1sh by cearar con ncn evden et atRes
an t s al c ow
ed
i
t vl ig i c h
d
ponden voi ed r l 4. ofte Rul
t i at ue 2 h es
ofPr f i n Con ct Tl Compl n ts appl i f cos s i denid.
o esso al du . l
e
alan '
l on 0r t s
cat
e
RESPONDZNT EXO NERATEDI
APPLI O N FOR ASSESSM ENT OF COSTS DENI
CATI
ED.
$26ALLJUSTi CONCUR.
CES
Foo-Nor rEs
JRul J7o t eoRpc.okf.st .tt 5.ch ï app 3- r e J7( 991)pr
- e . fh
a at i. . ,
A, ul . 1
o/des'
Rue 1. con l to fI t es zGen ai l
l 7. fi
c
n er t
er Rue
()A Iwy rs a n trpe en a cin iterpe e tt no ta cen wi b drcs a v ret
a a e h l o e rs t l tf h e rs nai f ht i t l e l t d ej o
e
o
e y
an h cl unes
oter i
ent l s:
1
()h Swyrrasn byb lv sterpeettnwinta vreyafc ter ainhpwilh
1 te a e e o ai ei e h e rsnai l o des l f th elt si t te
e
o
e
o
l
g hercl t an
t
i ; d
en
( eac cl tcons t afercons t in.
2) h i
en
ens t
ul o
at
( A I ersh ln r es tacl tite r e t inoflatcj tmay be mat i l I ied by
b) awy al ot epr en i f h eprsenato
en
h i
en
eral i t
ym
t e iwyers r
h a
' esponsbit s t anot er ci tort a t id per on.or by t I
i li o
ie
h l
en
o hr
s
he awyers own it es s
'
n er t
uness'
l .
()t I
q he awyerr
easoc l bel veste r esenat wi n b adv s yafect an
aby i
e h epr t i l ot e erel f ed' d
on l
( t e cl tc ent aferconsut i W h r esenatonofmulpl cl n s i a sn e materi
2) h i ons s t
en
l on. en epr t i
at
t e i t n igl t s
i e
u deraken, h con la inshaliclde ex an inofte i pl aton ofte comm onr es tton
n t
t e sutto
ln u
pl at
o
h m i is h
c
epr ena i
ar t e a
l h dvan ages an rsk ivole
d
t
d i s n v d,
Tb c men s st a:
a om
t at
An i per isbl c l to it estm a exs beor r esenai i un t en,i whihev t
m m s i e onfi f n er
c
y it f e epr ttcn s derak n c ent he
r esen at shoud be decl ed. . . . s h a c fit ars afer r esenaton has b
epr t i
on
l
i
n
1 uc
f
on l
c ies t epr
tl
een
u t en,t I
ndarak he awyers d wih aw fom te rprsenaton
hout tdr r h e e t i .
Clatoni r )Sumrl j ofOocum ent Ciî ' s Doc
t î zv T
rar r
s tng l
bl
ument
Cl Na r
t re
v
Level
20 1 R 1 72. F. 1 f Week v Idep ent
QO OCI 2 230 3d 201
s .n end Schoo Dit No 18 ofOkah Cou ? OK.Bd Cie
! s
.9
l oma nt. .
td
ofEd
uc
Oka
lhox supr rr cour Cases
sr
t
Ci
l
e
Name
L el
ev
Z.19VD. 0P3I 2 ,
9..- . .cô 1
(
1
7
S A Ee rlOKL OM B RAS
T T x e. AH A A SOCA ONvSCROGGS
TI .
Drc s e
sus d
2 OK 3. 2 R3 21
007
15 d 2.
STATE e ( OKLAFO MA BAR ASSOCITI v. AGNER
x et
I
A ON W
Dlcus ed
s s
Ciatoni r T e ofA ut iy
t l ze . abl
hort
Cl: Narm
t
f
Okl œ su ere Cour Ca
ahor pr r
t ses
Cl
t
e
Na
me
-t
k
1 9 O1b .$éP2 1 7 q- f j Saee rIOka o a3a M B . Wlis
9 6 ( 9 ( 1 d 4 .j l. tt x e ih m r n v lp
9
L e
ev l
Dlc s e
sbs d
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?