Black v. United States Department of Homeland Security

Filing 21

ORDER Granting 18 Motion to Redact Prohibited and Private Identifiable Information from the Court Record. Signed by Magistrate Judge Lawrence R. Leavitt on 10/3/11. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MMM)

l

'
.
.

v

P. ef r y Bl k
J f e ac

'

1

7 8 La Vea BldS# 5
52 s g s v 4 0

2

La Veg , V 891 1
s
as N
23- 009

t...; . ?y 7è ? ..
. ) . : .
:
.

.

. .

( )98 21
800 0- 85
3

Plit pr Se
an # o
4

5

U N ITE D STA TES D I
STR IC T C O U R T

6

D ISTR I T O F N EV A DA
C

7

+

8

P. J
EFFREY BLA CK ,

9

Pl ntf ,
ai i f

*
# Cas N o. 2: 0- 02040- CM e
1 cvJ
LRL
#
#

10

V s.

#

11
12
13

U NI
TED STA TES D EPA RTM ENT
OF HO M ELAN D SECURI ,
TY
D ef nda .
e nt

14

*
#
#
*
*

PLA I TIFF' M O TI N TO REDA CT
N
S
O
PR O H I TED AN D PRW A TE
BI
I EN TI ABLE I FO R M A TI N
D
FI
N
O
FR O M TH E C O URT RECO RD

+

l5

l6

COM ES N OW t pl i i f appea i p s i t sm a t r r pectuly m ovest s
he a ntf ,
rng gp e n hi te , es f l
hi
.

17 Co tPurua tt Ru e5.( )oft eFe e a RulsofCi l oc du e a Rul 9 37 b)o
ur, s n o l 2 a h d r l e
vi Pr e r , nd e 0 ( f
18

t sCour' LocalRul ,f an or t r
hi
ts
es or
der o edactdocum e si t Cour' r cor t cont n
nt n he
ts e d, hat
ai

19 pr bied a prvat pe s
ohi t nd i e r onali nttabl i onna i aboutt Pl ntf
de ii e nf
ton
he ai i f
2O
21

I s
n uppor oft sm oton,Pl ntf r i upon t M em or
t hi
i
ai if eles
he
andum ofPoi sand
nt
Aut ii s s tf t her i
horte e orh e n.

22

23

D a ed: Sept ber23,201l
t
em

24

Res t uly Subm it
pec f l
ted,

25
26

'

P.l fe B l k
efr y ac

27

28

Pl nt o Se
ai ffpr
l

q

1
2

M EM O M NPV M-O- POI
F
NTS AND AUTHO RI ES
TI
Feder Rul ofCi lPr edur Rul 5. a a d Loc lRul 90 ( ) o lneprv c
al es
vi oc e, e 2( ) n
a e 37 b , uti i a y
.

3

pr ec i f docum enttlngsm a t t Cour.U nl sot nvi e or r by t Cour,
ot tons or
ii
de o he
t
es he s de ed
he
t

4

pa tesw ho fl el t oni orpape docum e s a e pr bied fom flng docum e st
ri
ie ec r c
r
nt , r ohi t r
ii
nt hat

r c a n s fcprva e i ii e i or a i t i ude a i vi ' com pl e s al
, ont i pecii i t denttabl nf m ton, o ncl
n ndi duals
et oci
6
7

s curt num be and f 1dat ofbit
e iy
r
u1 e
rh.
On N o be 22,201 t Pl i iftl t c pl nti t s cas a atac a
vem r
0, he a ntf ied he om ai n hi e, nd t hed

8 t t l ee n ( 1 e hi t .Exhi t #1 #5 /6a /9 c n ane s cfcp i t i n i a e
o a of lve 1 ) x bis
bis , ,/ nd / o t i d pe ii rvae de tt bl
i
9

i or aton c i tng oft Pl ntf s Soc alSecurt N um ber dat ofbit a pl e of
nf m i ons s i
he ai if
i
iy
, e
rh, nd ac

10 bit A ss h,t Pl ntf pr ry r ct t si or aton prort tlng t com pl i
rh.
uc he ai if ope l eda ed hi nf m i
i o i i he
a nt

11 wiht Clr o t Cou ti a c da ewih Fe e a RulsofCi l oc du e Rul 5. a
t he e k f he r, n c or nc t d r l e
vi Pr e r , e 2( )
1 a t sCo r' Loc lRul 903 b)
2 nd hi u t
s a e 7( .
13

On J 21,20l1 t Def
une
, he endanttl a A dm i sr tve Recor D ecl a i n,a
i ed n
nit a i
ds
ar to nd

14 Va g l de , ncu ng a51pa s po tngdo u e ( 5 3 . sd ume to nl
u hn n x i l di
ge up ri c m nt 1 - ) Thi oc n pe y
15 publci s cii prva e i ntfabl i or aton c s i oft Pl ntf Soci Se iy
i zes pe tc i t de i i e nf m i onsitng he ai i fs
al curt
16 N um be ,da e ofbit and pl e ofbit on pages2,17,27,and 39.
r t
rh,
ac
rh
17
l8

I t sM oton i notgr nt a t Pl ntf sper onali ii e i or a i as
f hi
i s
a ed, nd he ai if
s
denttabl nf m ton,
des i above,i notr ct d f om t publc tlngs s rous a ir r bl har c d be
crbed
s
eda e r ht
i ii , e i
nd r epa a e m oul

l9 c us d t t ePli if t i l t Pl i ifsi e tf beng soln.ThePl n it ar tr d
a e o h antf, o ncude he antf d n iy i t e
aitf e ie
20

f all e or m e ofk e who wor d ext i y unde coveri hi poston,
eder aw nf ce nt t r
ke
ensvel
r
n s ii has

21

ale been t vi i ofi ntt t tt tocc r d i 2005,wher hi Soci Sec iy
r ady
he ctm
de iy hef ha
ur e n
e s
al urt

22

num berw ast l uly us t open bank account a lne ofcr t The t : was
m awf l ed o
s nd i s
edi.
hel
t

23

s e
ubs quenty r t t t LasVegasM etopolt PolceD e t entFi
l epored o he
r ian i
parm
nanci lCri es
a m

24

Di son f i tga i
vi i or nves i ton.

25

The ef e, he Pl ntf r pec f l r que t t sCotr t gr t M oton r tng
r or t
ai if es t uly e s s hi
lt o ant he
i edac i

26

Pl i ifsprva e i ii e i onnaton f om t cour tl and t e e an or die i
a ntf
i t denttabl nf
i r he
t ies
o nt r
der r ctng

27 t Clr o t Cou t o s bsiut t at c df u ( r d ce pa st tc re pon wih
he e k f he r t u tt e he ta he o r 4) e a td ge ha o r s d t
28 t f urpa e de c i d a vei t eDe e a t d c m e ( 5 3 .
he o
g s s rbe bo n h f nd n ' o u nt 1 - )
s
2

1
2

3

DATED t s231 da ofSe e ber 20ll
hi . y
d
pt m ,
.

4

5

Res t uly Subm it
pec f l
ted,

8

J

P.Jef r
f ey l
ack

9

l0

Pl n i o Se
ait fpr
f

l1
12
l3
14
15

l6

I IS SO O RDER ED
T
17
18

19
20
21

LT TED STA TES D I
NI
STRI J DGE
CT U
IN I
J TED STA TES M AGISTRATE J DGE
U

22

23

D A TED :

24
25

I 26
I
1 27
i
i

28
3

10-3-11

1

U N ITE D STA T ES D IST R ICT C O U R T
DI
STR IC T O F N EV A D A

2
3
4

5
6

#

P. JEFFR EY BLA CK
7582 LasV egasBl S /450
vd /
LasVegas N e
, vada 891
23

*
*
*
*

7
8

Pl ntf ,
ai if

+

V.

9

10

#
*

Cas N o. 2: O-CV-0ZO4O-J -LlL
e
I
.
CM
t

#

UN I
TED STA TES DEPAR TM EN T
o F H O M ELAND SEC UR I
TY

*
*
*

11

D ef ndant
e
.

12

*
*
#

13

l4

CERTI CA TE O F SERV I
FI
CE

l5

IHEREBY CERTI t s rv cet t D ef ndant oft pr edi M oton To
FY hat e i o he
e
, he ec ng
i

l6

RedactPr bied a Prva e l
ohi t nd i t ndenttabl l or aton fom t Cour Recor wasm adeon
ii e nf m i r he
t
ds

l7

Sept m be 23,2011,by per ona l ha delve i copi t eoft t O fi oft Unied
e r
s ly nd i rng
es her o he fce he t

l8

St e A tor
at s t ney,Ll Geor Fede alBuidi 333 Sout LasVegasBoul var Suie 8 6,
oyd
ge
r
l np
h
e d, t 01

l9

LasVe ,N V 89l01.
gas

20

21

DATED t s23r da ofSept be ,2011.
hi
d y
em r

22

Res f l Subm i ed,
pect uly
t
l

23
24

.

25

P. efe Blc Pl ntfpr S
J fry a k, ai f o e

26

7582 LasVegasBl S /450
vd /
LasV egas N V 89123,
1009

27

( 00 98 21 5
8 ) 0- 8

28
l

C as 2: c 02040e 10- vJCM LRL Docum ent15- Fi 06 21 11 Page 2 of51
3
l
ed / /
t

*

v

*

.

i

C ON FID B N T IA L - FO R O FFIC IA L U :: O N LY
l

.

2

PPR

M oF -

=

oN r

M Qx qm D x I w
x
xx

* p

m

AW

vj Axh aw a
bx
m

3
#

6
5

>
w =.
AX
Am x v- - s e x

#
*

' - * ' 0*% *
%
'
> !
x I

*
*

sux c. = . - .
!s

6

, v H R M

7
@

w:
=
I
M

M

M : %
-

*

G

*

* - 5
4655 1
- 4

*>

'w -

*

*

@

,

-

' %
'

i

I

A. 0 1
f *4

> 5
7*

Jux c. jJ . . .
a

#

'

10
.

.
'
*
'

*

11

1
2

*

x

u w v cE.
gkl -

Y I A-

-

14
15

w o

.. .

.

.>
v--

e
% N.
W.
- 5
%
X >

.
*
*

'

'

''
''

..
.

'

w,
-a=- ,
o

'

Nl w

@
#

e-

m- l oG
>

l 4*

r

lx

.

-

* O - ' d ' -' Al M* $@ %
=
f
*
*e* % e * * Add. ,
l
A4
m .
)*
* a * * N e 1e 1
M

>

24
> m G ' *A - w>
=
* *
25 # Y = A -V Y UM - 26 < e O W *
F* *
**
e
2 Y- Y
7
Y N- M O ' P*

2 >
8

.

.

R'' ''G USM M Y
'

*

18
QK I I
O SY
YG
19 I - % e
hM
m >
20 1* 5#* Y - % e
1

2 -.
3

- - y 1
.4:

*

'

16
1.
1,
k.
1

*

.

ov u -

I *
*W*

.. >
q.w

.

*

'

13

'

- *:
.

.

o .. w

h* V*
e >
- G
'I * <
'*
e e
œ *
A-' -- X '* ' ' *
1 '
= ' M '' e - > R e
2 9*

-e

#

.

.,- -

me 000Q0

Case 2: O- v1 c 02040JCM LRL Docum en 1 3 Fi 06/ / Page 17 o 51
t 5l
ed 21 11
f

C O N F ID E N T IA L - F O R O F F IC IA L U S E O N LY
1

FREEDOM OF I
NFORM ATI ACT & PRI
ON
VACY ACT

2

QEQW ST FOR I
NFORM ATI ANp uxcokns
ON

3

#
#

4
5

N n ap J lEv BLACK
Ea t
7 8 t ve a Bl s #4
5 2 as g s vd
50
xev a 891 u
23

6

I V=
Pb n (00 9 0- 8
n e:8 ) 8 21 5

7

#
.

.
#

1
009

X B: / 2/ * 3
07 1 1
POB: n Di g CA
Sa e q,
S. No. 4 55 461
S. 5 6- - 4

10

sU. c.j5 e s .
s. 22 t <

#
*
#
*

Appeln
la k

n eFrv t Ac e 1 4
i a' t f 97
y
po lc La 93 57
i w - 9

*

8

9

n eF- - o o I f r to t
- œ m f n n mx i nAc
Pu i La 1 - 31
blc w - 2

5U. C.û52 e s .
S.
2a t %

+

*

.

13
14

#
#

Ho e a d Se u iy Ac
m l n c rt t

Cn n M . vlk I FOI Om c r
-'> Pa i CE- A
e

11

UNI
TED STATES I M I R ATI N ANp
M G
O
CUA ' S ENAOR CEM KNT
OM

#

Fubi La 1 - %
lc w 07 2

FOI PA Se ton
A/
ci
l f r fo Dic e u Un t
n e mnl n s l s a i
8 No Ca ia StN. .
* % ptl . W
5* Fl r Su t 5
x . ie 85
W ahngow D. 205 6
i t
C. 3

#
#
+
*
#

6 C. R. r 5 e < .
F. Pa t t

l5

16

Cas No. 08 FOI 1
e
* A- 40

#

Re m n e
s d ht

#

NO TI O F A PPEAL
CE

+

17

18

- . .
- -

.

#

J SDI ON
URI CTI

ADMI STM TI APPM L I HEREBY MADF b Phl JFmyBlc ( rat
NI
VE
S
O y ii e
p
a k,hee fœ
20 rfr lo> t S pelnt be gactano t Unie K A a efte Stt ofNe a a d
eenv t he ' la s,
Ap
ii fhe td - s nd i ae
vA n
2l wl L af d r le o e o t T- n po tto Sx udt Adm i s r to Uni d St ks
o s e e a mpl ye f he
x ra i n
y
nita i n, t a
e

no
tf

22 Ha lM A u i p
a
rt uaua t t Fr d efI o z o Ac Til 5o tx Uni Stt Col ,
y,
nt o be œ om nf re n t te f l
e ao

23 Sœto 5 ,h ra rrfre t a t G A',a dtw M v c Ad of1 4, l 5o heUntd
in 22 lee he eer o s l FOI ' n l
w
)
ay
97 Mte ft ie
24 S sCG Sœton52 ()I r. trrfre t a ' ePrv c Ac*,e Til 6o tx Unt
*
i 2a hee e eerd o s'
af
n iay t)
te f l id
25 R4 Ctl ofFM- lRe ulto ,Cepe 1 PM 5,Smto 5. a Sxto 525 (- A
*- xe
g ains
tr ,
in 9 nd in . ,I O
t
26 rfre t a teY HSRulsa Re lto ', n s xl asr iea pe li h
eer o s b
e nd guainsd a d œh umiitatv p a s e xre u n
l
vd m
27 te( 1Co'-lDe e o Ho A Se uryx eofte Oe ea Co ,
h *zn , o nt f melnd c i oëc l n rl nn-lWae w
t
24 X 2 5 .( C. R. û5,()a d5. () DHSMD No. 4* .( )
0 28 6 F. û 9a n 25a;
0 14X0).
00001
7

I

I

I

!

i

!
Case 2: O- v1 c 02040JCM LRL Documen 1 3 Fi 06/ / Page 27 of51
t 5l
ed 21 11
--

'

k

C O N FID E N T IA L - FO R O F F IC 1A L U S E O N LY
1

2

FQEKDOM OF DX ORSLKTI ACT & PW VACY ACT
ON

QEQUEST FOR I
NFORM ATI AND QECORDS
ON
3
#

4
5

Pm 1.P JEFFR EY BLACK
I
75 La Ve sBl S e 50
D s ga vd

#
@

n e F- - om ofldb m a i Ac
a
l r ton t
N blc La 1 2
i w * 31

.
#

5U- C.j5 e xq.
S. 22 t

6

L V% a, v da 8 2
m
sNe a 91 3
1 :( 0 9 21 5
6- W ) :0- 8

7
8
9

I B: 7 1 9
H 0 / M 63
Y B: nDigo CA
Sa e ,
S. No. 46 5 4 4
S. 5 - 5- 61

#
#
#
4
#

Re ese .
qu t r

'

-1 M va yAc o 1 4
1e
c t f 97
Pu lcL: 93 57
bi w - 9
5 u os. j5 l s .
c. 22: t <

!

yol Re
A qu-tNm ê25

:
j

@

10

11

12
l3
14
15

16

#

UNI
TED STATM I M I
M GRATI &
ON
CUSD M S EN FO RCEM ENT

#
*

Cadn M . a i I -F A Ofi r
f n P vlk CE OI tœ
FOI PA >- o
A/ -ln

*
#

I o ma in Di l ur Uni
nf r to x os e t
g No% Ca io St N . .
œ
pt l . W
5 Fl ksu e 5
1 t
xx i 85

'
wasunmow oc 2 6
l
053
.

*
*
*

I

.

.

I ee wausc:t , Mal
i rd
v
ri
g
i
xo 7œ 811 ( 37 1 7
40 . 469 6,

i
j
j

l
x

.

Re pon o t
s d .

!

.

#

I

#

i

#

)

p ..
-

i

j

,

18

REQUEST I IEREBY M ADE
SI

p- m #oteF-21 o Ifr t aAd, ie!ot
x nt b -'0n fnomai
o Tt fl
l e

,

19 UntdSe s , e t n5 2 Iet œ reerdt a Y OI ' R das tePr yAc o 1 7 ,
i t C* S ci 2 ,h la rfre o s A'. lo l i
e
o
)
l wc t f 9 4

20 Tie5o teUntdSae Co e S in52a
t fl i tts d, xt 2 4)
l
l e
o

rfr t a teNrv c Ac .mls
eeM o s h piay cla i

2 maeb PipJBl k te free t ate k qetr , n act o t Un# S 1 d y bl . a ,kmat rf=do sh u eus ' Nig ian fl ' -1
l c
e
el
i
w .
M
22 a do Qw Stt ofNe dw Ods c rq ihee sr u nteUSl o ton& Cut
n f ae
va
u h e e s r eœ m h
mml i
soms
23 F o me Ofimo Prfsin Re- i lt Ie fe mfr t a t R m n ns.
afme nk lc f oeso al s biiy h = tr emd o s h: M
de t
24
, w FOI e t blsz s apm s m pt t tm c dsi tx po sen ofa nc c a d
1
1
A sa ile
u i e
on
er n l x i
ge i n
t
q
25 o heF u veBr c oft Uo d St t sgo e n e . ar op l a c s i et t ev pl, ll q
ft x u
an : he
a e v r m nt e eny c e sbl o b
e ax a

26 S C ll D I M ule Fe rla n ist pmvd tef le tp sbl d s lwz ofi n on*
U K le A
rs dea ge ce o ie b uls os i e icz - nf ae
27 QM p bl W h o
u i
c. e

t M v c Ad s Hkal al w si vi a st a k n- qt a a - '
be a y
l l
y o ndi du l o
z
o n g
s

28 ' y m o r o
' ee f e oe p t i n t t mq l s a t e e t r c r a ha e c pism n t- E
s
era ni g o he e ve . nd o
w he e o d nd v o e de I
l

.
000027

!

j

l
i

l

I

j
I

1
I
i

C a 2: 0- 0204Ose 1 cvJCM LRL Docum ent153- '
.

1

C O N F 1D :N T1A L . F O R O F F IC 1A L U : B O N LY
l

2

> R

Rm uEsT O R I kM ATI AND ppr nknR
NO
ON

'

i

M OF I ORM ATI ACT a Pm VACY AW
Y
ON

A
-

@

;

@

pm y. z
x x
p
75 œ VQ

w pjAcx
a
BN4 S N S
O

*
*

w y- a oél --- o
m wa w
x b l w l zzl
llu x

I V- xu .x w j a
A
.
zsj
. . .j oj j j y
. j g oz g

.
.

gux c.js . . .
%

7

'

4
5

:

,

X B2 /1 1 3
Q7 1 96
O B: n1 CA
W
%
S. Ne. 5 1
$. * 5* 4

*
#
@
@

n :Pzv Ad of1 4
ie
W
hj lj :3. D
uj aw 5

*

5U. I5 d < .
KC. %

8

9

A> 1
l
<

.

: 1:

'm cn gr u T 4 x lAoy a
r
Al
MM c u

*
*

11
12

CUM AENM T MY
r- '.M. I I FOI OH
M K CF A

*
#

H' = *
=
e
Ad
M ku w 1 .
* 2%

Fox A s- a
w
I
ne A pDl do xl

*
*

gc F. p- 5et .
R
-

13

,

UA

: Ne C+ *1 tN.
K
S W.
14
ls

*

W*

*

5 Fl ,S* 5
% #5

*

X 256
03

#

16
17

*

>>

C No. 20 l9F O IA 1696
>

.

-

N@ W CE OF AFD G L

.

*

1B

X I O I ! nH
QI fW

19
2
0
21
22
23
2
4
25
26
27
2:

ADMI W RAW VâAP EALB RRRKRYMADK Y M I JD BG M
NI
P
Ye
* e *a % *
A,
> .o # e U* % e o % : o N- - e
%
f * f
:
e j &- * + 2 ' b o t T= e * > * A ml d n U! %
g < '' 1
fh
% *- oy M
w
ofj- -- an al pu! o uw F'' ' of# -'-anAd. 5o l U*
l let y
' ,- M- -'
'
rG ft
* % *' ' D ,
œ'n5 >
mu * e * % G % e * M N M # l 4 M* 5d
W .
t Une $t C* . * 5 2a ! * * ' a
e I *
Se
2 () >
* .Nw M v Ad5. Ti do
e * f%
U* dS C o F l l n .C> 1 M 5 S o 59* * ''-52 .
- * f - Dv eln
*
.e n.
'' .5 * ' t * Ru e *= . n *. ml e ''''' - e l
' *e & DH: e
l :)e dt . ''
-'
>
:e
-=% * -r e #>
1 wl 1
ofH- ln e
ez
.0* efe n''-1r m-kW -%n*z .
''' *1s X . *7 I . I 5Kq e 5. *) DHSM 2 6X K. j . )
25 ;
nl veNo. .( 1
œ l4X* .
Fa v l o 6
g
f

003
00