Collins et al v. Laborers International Union of North America Local No 872 et al

Filing 41

ORDERED that Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction 21 & 25 is DENIED without prejudice. FURTHER ORDERED that Plaintiffs' Motion for Order Shortening Time to Hear Motion for Preliminary Injunction 25 is DENIED as moot. Signed by Judge Lloyd D. George on 6/29/11. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MMM)

1
2
3
4
5
6

UN I ED STAT ES D I
T
STR I C O U RT
CT
D ISTR ICT O F N EV A DA

8
9
10
11

GENE COLLI S, n i v du doi bu i s
N a ndi i al ng snes
as SO UTHERN N EV A DA FLAG GERS &
BA RRI
CAD ES,e a .
t 1,

2: 1 c 05 LDG1 - v- 24LRL
O R DE R

12

Pl ntfs
ai if ,

13
14

LABORERS I
NTERNATI
ONAL LI ON OF
NI
N O RTH AM ER I LO CA L N O .872, a .
CA
et l,

15
De e nt .
f nda s

16
17
Pl ntf s t v A fi a A m e i an ow ne co t u ton com pa e ,fl t s s tf
ai i f , i e rc n
rc
d ns r c i
ni s ied hi ui or

18
da a sa lge ya ii outofLo l8 sm ir pr e a i a r cilydicrmi t y
m ge le dl rsng
ca 72' se es nt tons nd a a l s i naor
19
pr c i s Pl i if t or z t tLoca 872' di c i i t y ac i , nc udi p e ntng
a tce . a ntf s he i e ha
l
: s rm na or tons i l ng r ve i

20
21
22
23
24

25
26

Plitfsfo c l ci go ttn igde t o c mp ei gftr j bs c us dP an if t d fu t
anif r m ol tn usa d n bs r o ltn uu e o , a e litfs o ea l
e
o tertu t o tiu in .Plitfsh v n w 5ldamoinf rap ei n r ij nci n
n h i r s c nrb to s an if a e o e
to o r l ay n u to
mi
prveni Loca 87 fom i 1 plci ormai ai nga Pli ifon ( l87 : dei nt
e tng
l 2 r ' ) a ng
(
nt ni ny antf Loca 2'1 lnque
ls;an o ( fom de ngan Pl ntf asauslte ofg sandi fom ( l87 . Pl.
it d/r 2) r
nyi y ai if tt etr ood t ng r Loca 21' s'
'
M o.f Prlm .n . Or rShore ngTi 2,ECFNos 21& 24.
t or ei Ij on de
tni me
.
Anij ncini ' ne ror nar rme yt tma onl bea r dup acea s ng
n u to s i xta di y e d ha y y wade on l r howi
a
t tt pli ifi e il t s c rle , Earhll dI tv Cart 626F. 462, 9( h
ha he antf s ntted o u h eif' t san ns. . lon,
'
3d
46 9t

Ci. l (iai a i ena quottonma ksomitd) pat s e ngapr lmi r
r 20 0) cttons nd ntr l ai
r
te .A ry e ki
ei nay

2

ij n to mu t e nsrt ( ) h tii lk l t s c e do t me i , 2 ta i i l eyt
n u cin s d mo tae 1 t a t s iey o u c e n he rt ( ) h t t s i l o
s
k

3

s f irpa a eh l i t a e ofprlmi yr if ( t tt baa eo eq te tpsi
ufer re r bl a' n he bsnce
m
ei nm' ele , 3) ha he lnc f uiis i n

4

i fv r a d( )ta a ij n to i i tep bl itrs.1 . ctn Witrv Nau al s De
t a o , n 4 h t n n u cin s n h u i ne et d (iig n e . tr Re . f
s
c

5

Counci 555U. 7,1 S. .3 37 l 2L. 2d249(
l
,
S. 29 Ct 65, 4, 7 Ed.
2008:.

6

Plitfsag et a t e e j yate s n bep o blt o s c e so temeiso t i
anif r u h t h y no i a o a l r ba ii f u c s n h rt f her
r
f'

7

dici nai cli t er42U. C.j1 1.Se ton 1 1t otcst e rghtof*a I
s rmi ton ams md
S. 98
ci 98 E e t he qual i
pr
(1l

8

pes wihi t jliditonoft UniedStt 't C keande orec rcs wihout
rons t n he krs ci
he t aes o ma
nf c onta t' t

9

rs c t rce'Domi 'Piz I v Mc
e pe t o a ,' nos za, nc. . Donal 5 U. 470, 4- ( 06)( i 42
d, 46 S. 47 75 20 quotng

U. C.j1 1a) a p oe t s c rg t a ans imp i e t yno g v r me tl
S. / 98 ( ), nd rtcs u h ihs g i tï ann n b n o e n n a
i
11 dici nai an i r tunde c oro Stt lw, 42U. C.5 1 () Cou t a ya
s rmi ton d mpaimen
r ol f ae a '
'
S.
981c. rs ppl

b r e -hfiga ay i t e au t d srmiaincamsu d rj1 81 S eLid e v S TL. ,
u d n s itn n lss o v lae ici n to li n e 9 . e n sy . L A.
LLC, F. 11 11 45(t Ci.2006 .Toe tbls aprmafci c eofdicrmi ton,a
447 3d 38, 44- 9h r
)
sa ih i a e as
s i nai
pli ifmus s ow t t ( )i i ame
antf t h ha: 1 t s mberofapr e e cl s ( iatmptdt c r tf
otctd as, 2) t te e o ontac or
c ran sr ie ,( iwasde e t rgh t conrc f t esr ie ,a i s
e ti e vc s 3) t
nid he i t o ta t or hos e vc s nd,n ome
crumsa s ()s h sr c rmane a ia et smia l st td i vdu swh ween
ic tnce , 4 uc e vies e i d valbl o i lry-iuae ndii al o r ot

me r oft pli ipspr e tdcls .1 a 11 tlj t plitf s tsi st i ta
mbes he antf otce a s d. t 45. çlf he anif aite he niil
bu de ofe t ihi aprma f ce c s ofr cildicrmi ton,t bur n s fst t
r n sabls ng
i a i a e a a s i nai he de hit o he
de e ntt pr i had a l ii a e non- i crm i t r r as f rt a r e a t o ' l a
f nda o ove t
eg tm t
d s i na o y e on o he dve s c i n. d t
'
11 t ft def nda m e t t tbu de t pl i ifm us pr t ts h a r a on wasm e e y
44. t he e nt e s ha r n, he a ntf
l
t ove ha uc
es
rl

21

a pr t x f i t ntona dic i i ton. I
e e t or n e i l s rm na i ' d
'
Pl i if ca m t tt ey ha de onsr td aprm af ci c e ofdic i i ton be aus
antfs li ha h
ve m tae
i a e as
s rm na i
c e
Pl ntfsa em i iyai if r nort owne busnes e un et e e i o e oym e c r c sç t t r
d i s s abl o nt r nt mpl
nt onta t i o hei
due

r calymotvae pr e ont dei ue ls,' s'M o .orPr i Ij 8 ECF Nos 21& 24,
a i l i td esnce he lnq ntit'Pl t f elm. n. ,
.
and be aus t e e nt ha tea ed s m ia l s t t d c pa e di f r nty i r ga ds t t r
c e t f nda s ve r t i l ry iua e om ni s f e e l n e r o hei
D

1

tus f nd pa
r tu
yment a pl c m e on t de i ntls j i a 9. Eve as umi Pl i if ha
s nd a e nt he lnque it' i t
'
n s ng antf s ve

2

saed aprm af ci ca e Pli tfsha f ied t de o ta et tt y a e lkel t s e d on t
tt
i a e s , a n if ve al o m nsr t ha he r i y o ucc e
he

3

m e isoft rdic i i ton cli s Pl i if h f ld t i c t a s cii ors tntal
rt hei s rm na i am . antfs ave aie o ndi ae ny pe fc ubsa i

4

evi enc s tci ntt ove co e t l ii a e r s p f t by Loc 872. Se ,e g. Ar
d e ufi e o r m he eg tm t ea ons ut orh
al
e . , agon v
,

5

Re lcSive St eDipos ,I . 29 F. 654,659( h Ci.2003)(kl ve ,Ar on'
pubi l r at s al nc, 2 3d
9t r
E-owe r ag s
l

6

e d e mus be b h s ii a s t nta t ove c et l gii er s putf t by
vi enc
t ot pecfc nd ubsa i l o r om he e tmat ea ons
orh

7

Re u i,)(iainso te ) Ciigtr eousa digj d me t a do ep n n a to
p bl ' ctto mi d . tn h e ttn n u g ns n n e dig cin
c'
t

8

a i tPli tfsf f iur t pa conti i and pe t pa nt t t tus,Loc l87
ga ns a n if or a l e o y
rbutons
naly yme s o he r t
a 2

9

mai ai t tPli if a e o t t lnque Em pl r Lit'be a e t y ha f ld t
nt ns ha antfs r n he s i nt
De
oye s s' c us he ve aie o

10

c rbut t t uni tu tasr uie unde t La - mz eme Ag ee nt Pl i if '
onti e o he on r s
eq r d
r he borM ag nt r me . antfs

11 dfiul c lci go ttn i d bsa dc mp tn frf t r j b rs lsfo Plitfs
itc t ol tn u sa dng e t n o ei g o uu e o s e ut r m an if'
y e
12

de i nts a us wih t tus. Pl i if 'cli st tr p e e ai ofLoc l87 r ere t
lnque tt es t he r t antfs am ha e r s nttves
a 2 ef r d o

13

c ran Pl i ifc por tonsa t hive 'a saed a i e tt Gba u ' Si St rCl a ng a e
e ti antf or a i
s t e s' nd t t n nt n o i nkr pt' x a e ni r
t

14

i ufi e t de onsr t t tunlwf dic i nai m or lkey m o i e Loc 8 sa tons
ns fcint o m tae ha a ul s rmi ton
e i l tvatd al 72' ci

15

a ns Pl i t f sort tLoc s snon- s i i t r r as i ot nvi e unw o t ofc ede e.
gai t a n i f
ha
al 72'
dicrm na o y e on s he s
r hy r nc

16

M or f m e aly,howe r Pl ntf sha f ie t de onsr t t tt y a e lkel t s e
e unda nt l
ve , ai if ve al d o m ta e ha he r i y o ucc ed

17

on t m e is oft i di c i i ton cl i a i s Loca 8 Loc l87 appa e l ne he
he rt
he r s r m na i
a m ga n t
l 72.
a 2
r nty t r

18

m ai ai t delnq
nt ns he i uentls,noris l te sofgo sandi Pa tc a l i lg Pli if
it
s ues e- r
t
od t ng. riul ry n i ht antfs'

19 r q e tdij ci erle a an t c l 7 , anif h v no d mo tae Lo a 8 29 rca
e u se nun tv eif g is Lo a 8 2 Pli tfs a e t e nsrtd c l 7 s a il
20

a m us f de i ue s t e m ai ai d by t t us o f a i nst ke pur ua t t Lab ni
or lnq nt à us s nt ne
he r t r or cto a n s nt o he or

21

M a t rA gr e e . The e or Pl ntf shav f ie t d m ons r t t tt a e Ike y t s c ed
se
e m nt
r f e, ai i f
e a ld o e
ta e ha hey r i l o uc e

22

on t me is
he rt .

23
24

Pl i t f sha a s f l d t d ons r t t tt ar lke y t s f rir pa a e ha m i
a n if ve l o aie o em t a e ha hey e i l o uf e r e r bl r n
t abs nc o pr lm i r r i f t t ba anc ofe te tps i t i f vo , t tt
he e e f e i na y ele , hat he l e quii s i n he r a r or ha he

25 r q e tdij ci ni i tepu lcitr s.Al o g Pli tfsh v s gg se ta te wi
e u se nun to s n h bi ne et t u h anif a e u e td h t h y l
h
l
26
3

!

i urme a a e i ldama i t a e eofij i r le,Pli if'prncpa
nc
ntl nd motona
ges n he bsnc nunctve eif antfs i i l
an i pa e l s sa e e onom i i n t e.Ast t baa e ofe tes t e ofPl n if
tci t d os e r c
c n a ur
o he lnc
quii , hr e
aitf
cor a i ,Bl Chi Ent prs , oppy M op,a Si St Cla ng,ha outt ndi
por tons ue p er ies Fl
nd x ar e ni
ve sa ng

j d me t a ans t e frdei u ntr s fn c nrb to s Th r q se ij n tv rle i
u g n s g i t h m o l e tu t u d o tiu in . e e uetd nu cie eif s
nq
s fuous a t St p- st p bec us t tPl ntf c m or ton i a r nty i good s a ng
uper l
s o e by- e
a e ha ai if o a i s ppa e l n
t ndi

6

wihtetu t ThefnalPlitf coporton,Sout nNe daFlgge s& Barc des( ne
t h r s.
i
anif r ai
her va a r
ria Ge

7

Coli )(1 1ns',f who ij nci rle i a rnty s
lns ç i ' or m n u tve eif s ppae l oughtona expe tdba i,a s t
Col )
n
die ss sers

8

r cildicrm i ton a a a fr tvedef et t tus ' c rbu i coleci n e f t i a
a a s i na i s n f ima i
ens o he r ts onti ton l to fors n

9

c ec rntypendi bef ea t j .Eve asumi a Pli if alge t tColi was
as ure l
ng or noher udge
n s ng, s antfs le ,ha lns
pl c d on t t s ' de i nc ls prort o i g any t us c rbu i ,s h f c s a e r l va
ae
he nlt s lnque y it i o w n
r t ont i tons uc a t r e e nt

11

t t a i bewe n Coli ar t tus, Pl i if 's tbe or t sc t Furh r e, h
o he cton t e
lns l he r t not antfs ui f e hi our, te mor t e
d

c ti notc nc dt tt rquese ij nci i i t publci ees.ls ngt r quetd
our s onvi e ha he e td n u ton s n he i ntr t sui he e se
r i f pa tcul ry i lg oft is pe ng i Coli ' ot rltga i i c e s rs of
ele , ri a l n i ht he s ues ndi n
lns s he ii ton, n r a es i ks
i ons s e r s t ,es ci ly whe e Coli ' r ci ldi c i i ton c a m sa e c r nty pe ng
nc it nt e uls pe a l
r
lns s a a s rm na i l i r ur e l ndi

b fr a ohe j d ea a ans t etu tt ee tt wh m Plitfs rq e tdrle woud
eo e n t r u g nd g i t h r s,h n iy o anif' e u se eif l
af e t A cc r ngl
fc.
o di y,

THE COURT HEREBY ORDERS t tPlitfs motonf prlmi r i unci (
ha anif' i or ei nay nj ton #21

& /2 )i DENI wi u p eu c .
/5 s
ED t t rj die
ho
THE COU RT FU RTH ER O RD ERS t tPl i if 'm oto f or rs t ni tm e t
ha a ntf s
i n or de hor e ng i o

he rmo inf rp ei n c ij n to ( 25 i DENI a mo t
a to o r l a n u cin # ) s
mi
ED s o .

2
1

Dt tiX dy fue21.
adhs / aoJn,01
e

1

Llyd D.Ge ge
o
o

Unt Stt DititJ
led ae src udge

4