-GWF United States of America et al v. APS Healthcare, Inc. et al

Filing 10

ORDER Granting 9 Motion of Notice of Election to Decline Intervention. Signed by Magistrate Judge George Foley, Jr on 5/17/2012. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - SLR)

!

Z

!. ,

@

@

DANI G.
EL BOGDEN
Unie St t Ato ney
t d aes tr

i
-i -'' '
l î '. r
'

: ROGER W ENTHE
L
.

'k
.., j, '.' , I ê
,
, J
' .:

2 Ba N o.89
r
20
As i t ntUnied St t A tor y
ssa
t
a es t ne
3 333 La V e s Bl So. #5000
s ga vd. ,
La V e s N ev 8 01
s ga , ada 91

4 Tee h n : 7 2 3 8 6 3
lp o e ( 0 ) 8 - 3 6
s Fa ( 388678
x:702) - 7
r g rwe te u do.o
o e . nh @ s jg v
6

7

Ato
t nwysf Unied St t sofAme ia
or t
ae
rc

8 CATH ERI CO RTEZ M A STO
NE
N eva A tor y Gene al
da t ne
r
9 o ox xA R . R OH w ER
lo Deput A tor y G e r l
y t ne
ne a
Ba N o.l1
r
866
11 5 Ea tW as ng on Ave.St 39
55 s
hi t
, e. 00
LasV e ,N V 891
gas
01

12 TCe ho :( 0 )48 - 0 7
lp ne 7 2 6 0 0
la Fa ( 486x: 702) 3768
do wer a .v.o
rh rf zn z v
/
14

15

Ato e f St t ofNe
tm ys or ae
vada

16

U NI
TED STA TES DI
STRI T C O U RT
C
DI RI T O F N EV A DA
ST C

18 U NI
TED STATES O F A M ERI , al, :
CA et .
e r l CH ERY LE I R,
x e.
QER
:
l9

:

Pl i if ,
a ntf s
20
21

V.

:
:

x o. 2: 1 cv- 45 J - F
1 - 0l 4-CM GW

:

:
22 A PS H EA LTHCA RE, N C. I N OV A TI :
l ,N
VE

FI
LED I CAM EM AN D U NDE R
N
SEA L PU R SU A NT TO

23 RESOURCE GROUP,LLC DJ A APS
B/

:

31U. C.j3730
S.

HEALTHCARE M I EST a APS
DW
nd
,4 HEA LTH CA RE BETHESD A ,I C .
N

:
:
:

25

Def nda s
e nt .

:

26
27

UNI
TED STATESyAND STATE O F NEVADA N
s
N O TI O F ELEC TI N T O D EC LI E I TER VEN TI N
CE
O
N N
O

28

-2 -

'

!

'

:
I
I

i

1

Pu s mH t t eFas Cli Ad ( , 1U. C. 3 0b ()B) t eUntdS ae
ru o h le ams FCA) 3 S. j 73 ( )4 ( sh i tts
e

2 notfest Co tofisde i on no t i ewen i t sac i Ptrua tt t N e da Fale
ii he ur t csi
t o nt l e n hi ton, ls n o he va
s

3 Cli Ac (
ams t NFCA) NRS 3 7 1 0 2 ,h S aeof v d as n tte t Co r ofi d cso
,
5 . 1 4 )t e tt Ne a a lo o i s he u t t e iin
i
s
4

nott i ew e i t sa i
o nt ne n hi cton.

5

Alhoug t Unie St t sa t Stt o Ne a de i t i e e t y
t h he t d a e nd he ae f vad clne o nt nrne, he
6

7 r pe tulyr e t Co tt 31U. C.j3730( (1,whihal t rlt t manant
es cf l efr he ur o
S.
b) ) c lows he eaor o iti he
8 a i i t nam e oft U nied St t s pr di how e , ha t ' cton m a be di m i s
cton n he
he t
a e ; ovi ng,
ver t t he ' i
a
y
s s ed

9 onl i t c ta t Ator y Ge r gi wrte cons tt t dim is la t i r s ns
y f be our nd he t ne
ne al ve itn
en o he s s a nd her ea o
l0

f c e i ' I The a s r e t Cou t o NRS 357. 30,whi h a l t r aort
or ons ntng. d.
'
y lo ef r he
rt
1
c lows he elt o

l1

12 manti t a ton i t nameoft Stt ofNeva ar NRS35 080 1 , c pr des
i an he ci n he
he ae
da, l
d
7. 4 ) whih ovi
la t tt a ton %ma bedim is o ywih l a oft e c tt ki i o ac ountt publc
ha he c i ' y
s s ed nl t e ve h our, a ng nt c
he
i
14 pur e oft sc pt a l t be ti e e t oft pa tes'
pos s hi ha er rd he s nt r s s he ri .
'

l5

TheUnied St t sCou tofAppea sf t Ni t Cic thashed t t not t t ndi
t
ae
r
l or he n h r ui
l ha
wihsa ng
,

l6

t slngua fo t FCA quot d a
hi a
ge r m he
e bove t Unie St t hmst rghtonl t ahea i whe
, he t d aes
he i
yo
rng
n
17

18 io jcst as t e n o d s sa o tea to .U. e rlGre v No tr o Co n, 9
t be t o et me t r imis l f h cin S. x e. e n . rh o r .5
l
19 F, 953,959( hCi.1 ;U. e rlKilnzs t v. t onCor , F. 71 7233d
9t r 995) S. x e. li worh Norhr
n.25 3d 5, 25
20 ( h Ci. 1 .Therf e t Uni d St esa t Saeof va rque t ha, houl eih
9t r 994)
eorshe t at nd he tt Ne da e s t t s d ter
e
21

t rltro ted fn a t rp s ta ti a to b à s se stld o oh r s
he eao rh ee d n po o e h t h s cin e imisd, e t , r te wie
e

22

23

di c i d,t s Cour pr de t Unit St t a t St t ofN e
s ontnue hi
t ovi he t d a es nd he a e
vada w ih notc a a
t
i e nd n

2 4 oppor u t t be he r bef r r i or g a i isa o l
t niy o
a d o e ulng
r ntng t ppr va .

25
26

Fu temo e p ru n t 31U. C. 3 0 c( )t UntdS ae rq e t ta a1
rh r r, u s a t o
S. j 73 ()3 ,he i tts e u ss h t 1
e
pl a ngsfld i t sa ton be s r ed upont Unie Stt s t e Unied St t a s f quess
e di ie n hi c i
ev
he t d a e ; h
t
aes l o e t

27

28

.3 -

t tor r is d by t Co tbe s ntt t Gove nme ' c el n eUnie Stt sr s r es
ha de s s ue
he ur
e o he
r nts ouns .
td ae e e v
1

isrghtt or ra de ii tans rpt, t i e e i t sa ton,f good c e,a a lt
t i o de ny poston r c i s o ntN ne n hi c i or
aus t aer

2

d ts n t s e t d s sa o t erltrsa to o cam t e 31U. C. 3 3 ()4 .
ae a d o e k he imisl f h eao ' cin r li md r
S. j 7 0 e( )
3
4

TheUnied Sut salo r quesst ti bes r e wih alnotc ofa al
t
e s e t ha t e v d t l ies ppe .

s
6
7

TheStt ofNe afrhe rquess purua t NRS 357.30() t ta1pl di fld
ae
vad u t r e t, s nt o
1 1,ha 1 ea ngs ie
i t saci bes r e upon t St t ofNe da a t tor r is byt Cour bes n t
n hi ton
evd
he a e
va nd ha de s s ued he
t eto
,

t Stt ofNe da scouns .The St t ofNe dar ewesisrghtt or ra de ii
he a e
va
el
ae
va es l t i o de ny poston

8

ta c i t ,t i t r e i t sa ton,f goo c us ,a al trdaes t s e t dim is of
r ns rp s o n e v ne n hi c i or d a e t ae t and o e k he s s al
9

lo t r aorsaci orcai underNRS 357. 0. The St t ofNeva as r
he elt ' ton l m
08
ae
da lo equesst ti be
t ha t
11 s n'd wih alnotc ofa a .
e e t l ies ppe l
12

vadar ues t tt r a orsCom pl nt
eq t ha he elt '
ai ,
Fi l t U nie St t s a t St t ofNe
naly, he t d a e nd he a e

13

t sNotc an t a t c d pr e Or rbet s ald.Th Unied St t and t Stt o
hi
i e, d he ta he opos d de
m e e
e t
aes
he ae f
14

15

Ne dar
va eques t ta1 otwrpa r on tl i t sa ton r m an u rs a be a ei dic sng
t ha l l
pe s ie n hi c l e i nde e l c us n s us i

I

l6 t c e a e t ntoft i si a i n by t Unie St t a t Stt ofNe da s h
he ontnt nd x e
he nve tg to
he t d aes nd he a e
va , uc

I
!

l7 pa sar pr dedby 1w t t Cou ta on f t s epu pos ofe uai whehe t s a
per e ovi
a o he
r l e or he ol r e val tng
t r he e l

!
I
j

z8

a tm ef maki alelc i t it r enes d beextnd
nd i or
ng r e ton o n e v
houl
e ed.

l9

//
/
20

2l //
/
22 //
/
23 //
/
24

//
/
25

26 //
/
27 //
/
28

-4 .

@

@

A pr s d or ra c p ni st sn ie.
opo e de c om a e hi otc
Dat M a 1 20 l
ed: y 6, 2
Res f l s it
pectuly ubm ted,
DAN I G,BOGDEN
EL
: St esAt e
1
at
t
ROG R ENT E
As s nt nied St esAtor
si
t
at
t ney
CATHERI CORTEZ M A STO
NE
Nevada Ator y Gcner
t ne
al

B:
y

'

-. .
-

L I' XY'SA.

t.
?

DONN A ROHW ER
Deput Ator Gener
y t ney
al

t
>w

l
2

4

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
DI
STRI OF NEVADA
CT
UNI
TED STATES OF AM ERI e a . :
CA, t l,

e r .CHERYLE KERK
x el

5

:

Pl i if ,
antfs
6
7

:
:
:

V,

N o. 2: 1 CV- 45 J - F
1 - 01 4- CM GW

:

:
8 A PS H EA LTHCA RE, N C. I OV ATI :
l , NN
VE

RESOURCE GROUP, D/ A APS
LLC B/

9 HEALTHCARE M I EST a APS
DW
nd
10 H EA LTH CA RE BETHESD A ,m C .

:

:
:

FI ED I ( M FRA AN D UN DER
L
N M
SEA L PU R SU AN T TO

3 U. . 937 0
1 SC. 3

:

11

Def nda s
e nt .

:

12

13

O R D ER

14
l5

The Unied Sl es a t Stt ofNe da havi de i d t i e v ne i t sa i
t
at nd he a e
va
ng clne o ntr e n hi cton

p ru n t t eF leCli Ac,3 U. C. 3 3 ( )4 ( ,a d teNe a F le Cli Ac,
u s a t o h as ams t 1 S. j 7 0 b ()B) n h v da as ams t

16
l7

NRS35 l 0( ,t Cour r esa f lows
7.1 2) he
t ul s ol :

l8

I I ORD ERED t t
T S
ha ,

:9
f

1 ''e c
. Ih ompli beuns ald a s l upon t de en rtby t r l t ;
ant
e e nd ewed
he f dal he e aor

20

2. Al ot rc e soft Cour' fl i t sa ton r mai und s ala d notbe m a
1 he ont nt
he
t ie n hi c i e n er e n
s
de

21

publc ors v d upon t de e a ,e e f t sOr a The Unied St t 'and St t of
i
er e
he f nd nt xc pt or hi der nd
t
aes
ae

22
23

24

N e da' N o i eofEl c i t D e i l e v nton, hi h t r l t rw ils r e u t def nda
va s t c
e ton o clne nt r e i w c he e a o l e v pon he e nt

onl a s r ie oft compl nt
y qer e vc
he
ai ;

25

3. The s a be lfe ast a1 o he m a t soc ur i i t saci af e t da e oft s
e l itd o l t r ter c rng n hi ton notr he t
hi

26 O r r
de ;
27

28

I

-6 -

4.Thepa te s l s v alpla ngsa motonstl di t saci n, n udi s
ri s hal er e l e di nd i ie n hi to i cl ng uppori
tng
1 me rnda up nt Unie St t , a p o ie f ri 3lU. C. 3 3 c () a u o t S ae
mo a , o he t d aes s r vd d o n
S. j 7 0()3 , nd p n he tt
2

o Ne a a a p o i df ri NRS 3 7.3 ( ) Th Untd S ae a dt eS aeo Ne d ma
f v d , s r vde o n
5 1 0 1 . e ie tts n h tt f va a y
3
4

or ra de ii ta c i sa a e e il d t i e ve i t sadi n,f good ca e a a
de ny poston r ns rpt nd r ntte o ntr ne n hi
o or
us , s ny

s tm e;
i
6

5. The pa te s l s r e al notc ofa alupo t Unied St t a t St t of
ris hal e v l ies
ppe
n he t
aes nd he ae

7 N

e
vada
;

8

6.Al or er oft sCo t ha l s ntt t Unie Stt sal t Stt of
1 d s hi ur s l be e o he t d a e rd he ae Neva a t t
da; nd ha
9

10

7. Shoul t r lt ort de e n pr e t a l s a ton be dimi s s tl or
d he e aor he f nda t opos h t hi c i
s s ed, e ted,

11

o he wiedicon i d,heCou wil ovi t Unie Stt sa t Stt of
t r s s tnue t
rt l pr de he t d a e nd he ae Neva wihnotce
da t
i

12

a d or ln
a i t p oval
a a oppor uniy t behe r bef enzi g orgr ntng isa pr .
nd n
t t o

l3

14

I I SO OR DER ED ,
T S

15

Daed: May 17, 2012
t

16

17
l8

U nied St es s r cJR.
t
a FOLEY, udge
GEORGEt D i t i tJ
United States Magistrate Judge

l9

2O
2l
22
23
24

25
26
27

28

.7 .