McCreary v. Sandoval et al

Filing 3

ORDER that the Clerk shall file the Complaint. The Complaint is DISMISSED for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted, with leave to amend. Plaintiff to file Amended Complaint within 30 days. Signed by Chief Judge Robert C. Jones on 5/11/12. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ECS, cc: forms to plaintiff)

:1
7

5

FL
IED
E
NTERED

RECEI D
W
SE
RVED 0N
COUN UP TISOFR OR
SE AR E
EC D

MAt 1 1 2 1
22
1
2

CL US DITRI COURT
ERK
S CT
DITRI 0FNEV
S CT
ADA
BY:

'

DEFU
TY

3
4
5

6
7

UNITED STA TES DISTR ICT C O UR T
DISTRICT OF NEVAD A

8
9 PA UL M CCREA RY,

1
0

Pl n if
aitf,

11 vs.

Ca eNo. 1 CV- 03l RCJ ( H)
s
2:2- 0 7- -CW
O R DER

1 BRI SAN DO VAL,etaI,
2
AN
.
l
3

Def
endant
s.

1
4

1
5
Pl ntf, i aprs ra E1 Stt Prs hass te a a i tont pr e dj
ai ifwho s ione t y ae ion, ubmitd n pplcai o oc e n
1 f mapa rs( )an acvirght compl nt s ntt 42U. C.5 1 Thec th s
6 or
upei #1 d i l i s
ai purua o
S. 983.
our a

,

l r ewed t com pl nt and pl ntf wilneed t s i an am ended com pl nt
7 evi
he
ai ,
ai if l
o ubm t
ai .
1
8

W hen a dprsonerseeks r essf om agovem m ent entt oroficerorem pl
si
edr r
al iy
t
oyee ofa

1 govem m ent entt ' t cour mustdi iy cogni e cl m sordim i s t com pl nt orany
9
al iy,' he
t
çdentf
zabl ai
s s he
ai ,
'

20 pori oft c anti t c ant( )i fiol , ii ,orf l t saeacli up
ton he ompli ,f he ompli 1 s rv ous malcous ais o tt am on
21 whihrle maybegrntd;or( sek mo ar r iffom adee n whoi i
c eif
ae
2) e s net y elc r
fnda t
s mmuncfom
r
2 s rlef' 28U. C. 1 5A() Rul l ( ()ofteF r RulsofCi lPr e r prvi s
2 uch ei .
'
S. j 91 b . e 2b)6 h edeal e
vi oc due o de

,

23 f di i alofa com pl ntf f l e t s at a cl m upon whi r i can be gr ed.
or sm ss
ai or aiur o t e ai
ch elef
ant
24 Alegatonsofa pr secompl na ar bel t l sti
l i
o
ai nt e d o ess rngentst
andar t f m alpl ngs
ds han or
eadi

25 drhe bylwyes Haie v.Kene , 4U. 51 5 (972)( rc im)
a d a r. n s
r r 40 S. 9, 20 1
pe ura .
26
Unde Fe rlRul o Ci lPr e e8()2)!pla ngmus c li al h ta pli
r dea e f vi oc dur a( , e di
t opan f or nd an
s

2
7

sae n o tecam so n ta teped rl ett dt rl f'. .T)epedn
ttme t fh li h wig h th la e s nie o ei . . ( h la lg
l
c'

28

ofer Sl s and concl i ' or$a f m ul c r t l oft el ent ofa causeofacton
f s tabcl
usons' < or al eciaton he em s
l

sa da d Rul 8a nc do sn r qule' tie f cma al ai nj'b ide nds
tn r
e nnou es e ot e r % a ld a l leg to , ut t ma
de
'
mo e ta a u d ne ie de e tunlF/ ly ha e m eac us ton. A pla ngt l
r h n n na or d, - f nd= - a l- r dc al
e dl h t

'

.

1

wilno do. Nordoc aco aits fc i itn r ç k da srinll' e dof
l t '
'
s mpl n ufie f te des ' e se to s'd voi
na

ff t f ualenhancem ent' ...
lurher act
.'

2

3
4
5

6

( c mpqn mu t o ti s fiin fqu l te, c e tdq tu ,o' tt açam t
A) o lit s c nan u f e t a ta matr a c pe . r e t t ae li o
ç
s
s

r l t tl pl usbl on is f e ' A c a m h s f c a pl usbily whe t pl i lfpl a
el ha s a i e t ac .' l l a a l l a i lt
ef
n he a ntf e ds

f t l tnttatal t c ur t (rw l raona ei ee et tt d e nti
acua cone h lows he o to la hc e s bl nfrnc ha he efnda s

la gf t p ic uc ale d.Theplusbiiysa r i not nt ai oba lt
ibl or he s pnd t lge
a l lt tnda d s aki o s
pr biiy
r qule nt'butl a ksf l e ta as erpos i lt t tadqfnda h sa td
e r me ,' t s ofpor h n he
sbiiy ha
e nt a ce
lnIlf l ëW h r ac mpan pe d fcsta qgç r l c n ltn wih' ade e nts
! x ul t ee o llt la s a t h t r t ey o sse t t ' f nda '
y
me

I blk l So ssot fteIn b t e p sill a dplusblyo re tlme to
lill
t
i
t
raeft,t tp h r o h ie ewe n o sbly n a ll t f nie n t
cl

7 Ashcr tv.I ,556 U. 662,l29 S.Ct 1937, 1 49( )( tt omitd)
of qbal
S.
.
9 2009 ciai
ons te .
8

I a1 t ee count pl ntf alegest prson ofici satH i Des tar notf l i t
n l hr
s, ai if l
bat i
t al
gh
er e
olow ng he

9 adm i statve r aton t gover t greva pr
ni r i egul i hat
ns he i nce ocedur . Pl ntf hasno rghtt an ef ectve
e ai if
i o
f i
l0 grevance pr
i
ocedur M ann v.Adam s,855 F.2d6 6 ( hCi. 988 ( de) Pl ntf alo
e.
39, 40 9t r l ) or r. ai if s
l1 alegest he was tansf r fom H i Des tSt e Prson t El St e Prson. :A prsoners ng
l
hat
r er ed r
gh
er at i o y at i
d i
ui

1 prs ofi a sunde s c i n l 3 f rr t i ton m us ale t thew a r t la e a i tf
2
ion fci l
r e to 98 o e ala i
t l ge ha
s e a i t d ga ns or
13 exer si hi constm tonalr ght and t t r alat y acton doesnotadvance l tm at
ci ng s
i i
i s
hat he et i or
i
egii e

1 pe ogi lg l , u h a p e e i g i tt tona or a dici i e.' Bar tv.Ce oni 31F.
4
nol ca oa s s c s r s w n ns iu i l der nd s pln ' net
nt ,
3d

1 81 81 -1 ( hCi.1 4)( rc im) Pl n ifso h ra l atonss ow t hewa ta fre
5
3, 5 6 9t r 99 pe ura . aitf' t e leg i h hat
s r nse r d
1 becaus bew ast eat ng bi celm at notbecausepl
6
e
hr eni
s l es,
ison of al wer r alatng agai tbi .
fci s e et i i
ns m

l Pl i ifha n s a e a pl usbl c a m ofr a i to
7
a ntf s ot t t d a i e l i
et la i n.
l
8

Pl ntf alo aleges t hç washogs w ih a prsonerwho had t cul s and t he
ai if s l
hat
ed t
i
uber osi,
hat

1 ha not e ex m i ed b m e i lpe s nnelf e pos r t t r ul i. Delber e i fcr
9
s be n a n y d ca r o
or x u e o ube c os s
i at ndif ence
20 t a s rousm e c c dii c be a vi a i oft Ei h Am e e , butpl ntf m us alege
o ei
di al on ton an
ol ton he ght
ndm nt
ai if
t l
21 f s t can show t partcul prs of i al knew about a c ci s y dir ga d d,t rs
act hat
hat i ar ion fci s
s e r e he ik
, nd ons ou l
22 t pl ntf shealh. See Far erv.Br
o ai if'
t
m
ennan,511U .S.8 ,8 (1 ) I a ame d c
25 37 994 . n n nde ompli ,
ant
23 pl ntf w ilnced t alege who t
ai if l
o l
hese ofi al ar , how t ar aw ar ofpl ntf expos e t
tci s e
hey e
e
ai ifs
ur o
24 t cul s and how t have di r ded t rs as oci ed wih t exposur . Pl ntf ef r
uber osi,
hey
s egar
he iks s at
t hat
e ai ifr e s

25 t gre nc num b s b t c tdo no p s s c e oft e gre nc sa pl i ifwoul
o i va e
er , ut he our es t os e s opi s hos i va e nd a ntf
d
26 s iln d t ale a l e e ntf c s i t b oft co pli te en i t c tdi pos e st e
tl ee o l ge I r l va a t n he ody he m a n v f he our d s s hos
27 copi
es.
28
2-

-

.;,
'
,8
:
;

'
*

k

1

M any oft def
he endant t pl ntf nam esar supervi s. $A s viorm ay be labl i
s hat ai if
e
sor ç uper s
i ef

'

2 t r e sseihe ()hi orhe pes li ve nti t c siutona d prvato or()a
hee xit t r 1 s
r rona nvol me n he on tt i l e i in, 2
3 s tci caus connecton bet
ufi ent
al
i
ween t superviorsw r ulconductand t constt i
he
s ' ongf
he
iutonal

4 vi a in. Ha s n v. a k,885F. 6 6 ( t Ci.1 9) l pli ifc n a l et tprs n
olto ' n e Blc
'
2d 42, 46 9 h r 98 . f antf a leg ha io
5 ofici swer delber el i f er t hi rs ofexpos e t m ber os s t he cannots t
t al
e i at y ndif ent o s ik
ur o
cul i , hen
ue he

6 s
upervi s oft
sor
hose of i al m er y beca t ar s vior l pl ntf nam esany
fci s el
use hey e uper s s. f ai if
7 s vi s asdef
uper sor
endant i hi am ended compl nt t hi alegatonsw ilneed t satsf t
sn s
ai , hen s l i
l
o i y he
8 Hansen sandar
t
d.
9
1
0

I I THEREFO RE ORDERED t t clr oft cour shal f l t compl nt
T S
hat he e k he
t l ie he
ai .
I I FURTH ER ORDERED t t com pl nti D I ISSED f f l e t s at a cl m
T S
hat he
ai s SM
or aiur o t e ai

11 upon whi r i can bc gr ed,wih l
ch elef
ant
t eave t am end. Tbe cl k s ls t pl ntf a ci lrght
o
er hal end o ai if vi i s

l c antf m wih i tu i s Pli ifwil vct ry( da fom t d et tt sor ri
2 ompli or t nsr cton . antf l ha hit 30) ys r he at ha hi de s
1 ent ed t s i hi am ended com pl nt i he bclevest he can cor ectt not defci es.
3
er o ubm t s
ai , f
i
hat
r he ed
enci

'
.

14 Faiur t com pl wih t s or w ilr ul i t di isaloft sacton.
l eo
y t hi der l es t n he sm s
hi i

.

1
5

'

I I FURTHER ORDERED t pl ntf s lcl l tte t am ended com pl ntass
T S
hat ai if hal eary il he
ai
uch

16 by pl ng t wor CAM EN DED' i m edi el above dci lli sCom pl ntPur uantt 42
aci he
dS
'm
at y
ç vi t ght
ai
s
o

1 U. C. 1 3'onpa 1i teca in,a pli ifs lpl etecaenumbe, 1 CV- 7
7 S. j 98 ' ge n h pto nd antf hal ac h s
r2:2- 0031 1 RCJI H)ab t wor C
8
-CW , ove he d Q
AMENDED.
'
'
1
9

Da e M ay 11, 2
t d:
201

.

20
21

22

Chi U ni
ef t

23

t es Di rctJudge
at
sti
.

24
25
26
27

28
-

3-