Juliano v. Clark County Detention Center et al

Filing 15

ORDER that the Clerk shall file the complaint. FURTHER ORDERED that plaintiff's complaint is DISMISSED with LEAVE TO AMEND. Plaintiff shall have 30 days from the date this order is entered to file his amended complaint. FURTHER ORDERED that [10 ] Motion to Appoint Counsel is DENIED without prejudice. FURTHER ORDERED that 6 Motion to Dismiss is DENIED without prejudice. FURTHER ORDERED that 9 Motion for Extension of Time is DENIED as moot. Signed by Chief Judge Robert C. Jones on 1/29/13. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF; copy of forms w/instructions and copy of original complaint to plaintiff - MMM)

Download PDF
x, ! ' i ' ! . . .. . . .- . .- . . .. I vk vs L Ek O m z . R cEp . --. F lo C u sk è' - E QDz o uzl 'a S R u ;. p ogRz coyo 1 2 8i C ' Q ERK ' v o jyc a s sp c cj Dl rcrc/t v sTn r gu y 3 opr ypy ; I ! 4 5 6 ' . UNI ED STA TES DISTRICT C O U RT T 7 DI RI O F N EVA DA ST CT 8 9 ' 1 0 J OSEPH J ANO, ULI #94I 00 ' Pli if . antf, 1 vs 1 . 1 CLARK COUNTY DETENTI 2 ON CENTER,e a. t I, 1 3 Decn nt. f da s 1 4 ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) . 2:2- v 02I O- 1 c - 6 RCJ VCF ORDER / . 15 Pl i if who i aprs e i t cu t y oft Ne daDep r m e tofCo r c i , as a ntf, s ion r n he s od he va at n r e tons h 1 6 ' fl acom pl nti st ecour,whi def ied ai n at t ch endant haver oved.I appear fom t docum ent and t s em t s r he s he j 7 r ovalsat entt r ovalt f alcour waspr . em t em hat em o eder t oper I8 1 Pl ntf sM oton f Appoi m entofCounsel . ai if' i or nt l 9 Pl n ifha Gld amoto s eki tea nt ntofc s li t sc s ( /1 . aitf s e in e ng h ppoi me oun e n hi a e ECF / 0) . 20 A ltganti aci lri sacton doesnothavea Si h A m endm entrghtt appoi ed counsel St set ii n vi ght i xt i o nt . or h 21 ' v S lman,65 F.d 1 l 53( hCi.l l.I v ylmie crumsan s fdeal rsae . pel 4 2 349, 3 9t r 98 ) n er i td ic t ce, e r cou t r 22 empower t r ed o eques an ator t r es an i gentci lltgant Thecicum st t t ney o epr cnt ndi vi ii . r ancesi w hi a n ch 23 cour wilm akes ar t l uch eques , t however ar exceedi yr e,and t cour wilm aket r , c ngl ar he t l he equestunder ' 24 onl e ror naycrumsan es Unie ttsv306 Ac e o v d, 95F.d796, 8 ( hCi. y xta di r ic t c . tdsae . .4 rs flan 7 2 799-00 9t r 25 ' l 6) Wibo nv Es al r n,789F.d l 8,l 3l( hCi.1 86) 98 ; l r . c de o 2 32 3 9t r 9 . 26 A tndi ofsuch exceptonalcicum st i ng i r ances r r t t cour eval e bot t equies hat he t uat h he ; : I . ; I . ' ai ' IIehoos onthem eritsandthepl ntiftsabilitytoarticulatehisclaim sinpro seinligbtof l ilodfu ki ccess 2 tecmpci o teIglsusivle N eiherfact i diposii and bot m ustbe vi ed h o lxt fh eai e novd t y s or s s tve, h ew I 3 t t ri ma ngafndi rcr / v Sr wc 935F. 1 1 1 1 (t Ci.1 1tii Wlbor ogche n ki i ng. rc/ . c r, 2d 0 5, 0 7 9b r 99 lctng l n, I : 4 I . . . su a,78 F.d a 1 31 .Thedititc r ha con i r bl dic e i i ma ngt s fn ngs The pr 9 2 t 3 ) src ou t s sde a e s r ton n ki be e i di . 5 cour wilnotent anor diectng t appoi m ent counscl W hie, dicus bel pl ntf s t l er der r i he nt of . l as s sed ow, ai if' 6 com pl ntw ilbc dim i cdw ih l ai l s ss t eavet am cnd t l is do notappearcom pl and i appear o hc egal s ucs ex, t s 7 t t cour att s tm e t pl ntf w ilbcabl t ari at hi cl m si pr s i he el s t t e an o he t hi i hat ai i f l e o tcul e s ai n o e f ect o il 8 a nde compli . Pli ipsmotonf t a i men ofco e i de e wih prj c . me d ant antf i or he ppont t uns l s nid tout eudie 9 l 191 . 0 5A Th c r no t r t t c ant whih i ha s r e d p s ntt 2 U. C.j e ou t w u ns o he ompli , c t s c e ne urua o 8 S. . : 1 I.S re igP ru n t 2 U.. b1 1A l I cenn u sa to 8 SC. 95 j 1 2 F deac u tmu t o d cap ei n r ce nn i a yc s i whc a rs n re k e rlo rs sc n u t rl ays re ig n n ae n ih p io e s e s mi i l rde sfo ag v r me tl n i o o fc ro e ly eo ag v r me tl ni .S e2 U.. j 3 e rs r m o en na e t y r fie r mpo e f o en na e ty e 8 SC. t t ; ' 1 1 1 a .I isr viw, h c r mus ie iy a yc iabl camsa d dim isa cl mst ta e 4 9 5A() n t e e t e ou t t d ntf n or z e li n s s ny ai ha r 1 I l f i ous, m alci f lt st ea cl m upon whi r i m ay be gr ed ors m onet yr i ffom 5 rvol i ous, ai o at ai ch elef ant eek ar ele r i I l adee da who i i 6 fn nt s mmunefom s hr i . Se 2 U. C.j 1 1 b( )() Pr s pla ngs r uc el cf e 8 S. 9 5A()l,2 . o e e di , i r 1 bo ve, t lbeal c t d.Erc nvPa du , U. 89 94( 7)Heb v P//r 62 . we rmusbe i rly onsme iho . r s 551 S. , 200 . be . fc, 7 7 , l F. 33 3 ( bCi.2 1 . lste lv Pa aPolc De ' 901F. 696, ( hCi.1 ) 8 3d 8, 42 9t r 0 0)Bai r r' . csc ie p t , , 2d. 699 9t r 988 . I Tosaeacl m unde 42U. C.j1 3,apl ntf mus ale t ese ilelmens ()t targht 9 tt ai r S. 98 ai if t lge wo s nta e t: 1 ha i 20 s ue b teConsiutonorlwsoft Unie Sttswa vi ae a ( t tt ale dvi ai ec rd y h tt i a he td ae s oltd, nd 2)ha he lge olton 2l wasc ommitdbyaperonp tngun rc o ofsat lw.Se We tv At n , 7 U. 42, ( 988 . te s ci de olr t e a e s . kis 48 S. 48 1 ) 22 ' I ad tont t s re ngrquieme sund rjl I pu sa t tePls Lii ton n dii o he ce ni e r nt e 9 5A, ru nto h ion tgai 23 Ref Ac of1 ( l ,afdea cou tmus dimisaprs ne ' cli $ftealeg tonof onn t 995 PLlA) e rl r t s s io rs am,ç h l ai i 24 povery i untue,'ori t acton ti f vol orm alci f l t sat acl m on whi r i m ay t s r ' f he i ts ri ous i ous, ais o t e ai ch elef 25 be gr ed,orseeksm onet y r i agai a def ant ar elef nst endantw ho i i m une f om such r i ' 28 U . C . sm r elef ' S. ' 2 9l1() ) Dimisalofacompli f f l et stt acli uponwhihr ifcanbegr e i 6 9 5e( s s 2 ant or aiur o ae am c ele antd s . j 1 2 ! I : q 1 I I . ! 1 . . 1 pr de fri Fe rlRul of viPr e e1 ( ()an t c ta ist s mesa r unde ovi d o n dea e Ci l oc dur 2b)6, d he our pple he a tndad r 2 j1 5whe rviwigt ade c ofac ant a a nde c ant W he aco 'dimis s '91 n e e n he qua y ompli or n me d ompli . n ul s se t 3 ac ai unde j1 5()t pli ifs ul b gie la t a dt c ant t die to ompl nt r 91 e,he antf ho d e v n e ve o men he ompli wih rcins 4 ast curng isdefci es unl si i cl f om t f oft com pl ntt t defci escoul o i t i enci , es t s ear r he ace he ai hat he i enci d 5 notbec e b ame dmen .Se Cat v Unie St e ,7 F. l1 11 ( h Ci.1 . ur d y n t e o . td ats 0 3d. 03, 06 9t r 995) 6 Re e un rRul 1 b)6)i e sntalyar i onaqu tonoflw.S Ch ppe v viw de e 2( ( s se i l ulng esi a ee a l . 7 Lab at y Cor o or ot p.fAmeia, 2F.d71 ,72 ( hCi. 000) Dimis lfrfiur t sat acl m rc 23 3 9 3 9t r2 . s sa o al e o t e ai 8 i pr s operonl i i i cl t t pl ntf cannotpr any setoff s i s y f t s car hat he ai if ove act n uppor oft cl m t t he ai hat 9 woul e il hi orhe t r if Se M ore v Wale ,l F. 75 7 ( hCi.1 ) l makng d ntte m r o elc . e ly . k r 75 3d 6, 59 9t r 999 . n i 1 t sdet m i i t cour t 0 hi er naton, he t akesastueaI alegatonsofm at i f sat i t com pl nt and t r l l i eral act t ed n he ai , he 11 cour consr t t tues hem i t Ightm os f abl t t pl ntf .See War n he i t avor e o he ai if shaw v. Xoma Cor ,74 F. p. 3d 1 955,9 ( hCi.l ) Ale tonsofapr s c ana a ehed t Is srnge tsa r st n 2 57 9t r 996 . lga i o e ompli nt r l o e s ti n tnda d ha 1 f lpla n dr te bylwye s Se Hu sv Rowe 449U. 5 9 ( 98 , ne v Ke n r 404 3 onma e digs at d a r. e ghe . , S. , 1 0) Hai s . r e , . 1 U. 51 5 ( 97 ( erc iml He ,627 F.d a 3 W hiet sa da d unde Rul 1 b ( 4 S. 9, 20 1 2) p ura ; bbe 3 t 42. l he t n r r e 2( )6) 15 does not r r det l f al alegatons,a pl ntf m ust pr de m or t m er l s and equie aied acm l i ai if ovi e han e abel 1 co l i .Bel lntcCor v Two l 1 S. .1 5,1 65(007) A fr acrci i 6 ncusons lAta i p. . mby, 27 Ct 95 964- 2 . omuli e t on at l oft el ntofaca s ofa toni is tcint/ ,e pa anvAlai 478U. 265, (98 . 7 he eme s u e ci s n ufi e . #.s epa s . l n, S. 286 1 6) l 8 Addii ly arviwigc tho d' gi byie iyi e i ( l ato )t t tonal, e e n ours ul l n d ntf ngpladngs al ins ha, be eg 1 be a ete aen moet nmer c cl i , r note ildt tea s i oftut ' As rh 9 c us h y r o r ha e on usons ae ntte o h sumpton r h. hco ' 2 v I ,l S. .l 1 ( 09) S hie lga c l insc n pr det fa wor ofa 0 . qbal 29 Ct 937, 950 20 . ' l e l oncuso a ovi he rme k W 21 compl nt t m ustbesuppored w ih f ualalegatons.'/ 'W hcn t e ar wel- eaded f ual ai , hey t t act l i ' #. ç her e lpl act 22 alegatons,acour shoul ass et rver t and t det ne whet t pl bl gi rie t l i t d um hei aciy hen enni her hey ausi y ve s o 2 ane ilme t rle l d tr nigwhehe ac ai saesaplusbl cli f r i (s a 3 ntte nto eif d. t emi n De t r ompl nt tt a i e am or cl ij ef 2 co e -p ii t kt trquie t rviwigc tt drw onisj di a e re ea c 4 ntxts ecfc as ha e rs he e e n our o a t u cil xpeinc nd ommon 25 sens ' 1 e.' d. 26 . 3 2 1 1 i ! ' l Fi l, al or par ofa com pl ntfl by a prs m ay t ef e be dim is sua naly l t ai ied ioner her or s s ed 2 sotite ro e'camsaka aga lbss i ei lwo i fc p nefh pi nrs li lc n rube aiet rna rn at s h . l i 1 I Tiilecisae I h nu slmbsd s cd a 3 onIga c l inst taeune bl ( g,camsa i tdefnda swh aei nefom s tor e l oncuso ha r tna e e.. li gans e nt o r mmu r ui 4 cl m sofi fi me o a lga i e e twhih cla l doe note s) aswe la cai ba e on ai n rnge nt f e l ntr s c e ry s xit, l s l ms s d 5 fnciul a mala lga i s( g. f ntsi ordelson s en ros .Se Netk v Wilams, U. a f fc le ton e. , a a tc u i al c a i ) e iz e . li 490 S. 6 3l 3 28(1 9)s ealoM c evrv Bl k 9 F. 7 ,7 ( bCi.1 91. 9, 27- 98 . e s Ke e . oc , 32 2d 95 98 9t r 9 ) , 7 11 . I t C om pl nt 1 ns ant ai 8 ' Pli if who i i a c r td a Hi De e tSt e Prs (Q antf, s nc r e ae t gh s r at ion ' HDSP' h s s d Clr ' a ue a k ) 9 Count Detnton Ce e ($ y ei ntr ' CCDC' ,t LasVe sM e r oltn Polce De a t t Clr Cou y ' he ) ga top ia i p rmen , a k nt ' 1 Shert0 ilDougl Gil pi Naphcar Naphcar smedi diect Dr. as les e, e, e' cal r or New m an, Does1 20.Pl ntf and ai if ll cl m s t when he wasa pr raldet nee atCCD C def ai hat eti ai endant w er delber el i fer t hi s e i at y ndif ent o s 1 s i m edi needsi vi aton ofhi Ei . A m e entrght 2 erous cal n ol i s ght h ndm i s. ) 3 Pl ntf alegest CCDC m edi per ai if l hat cal sonnelwer delber el i f er t hi serous e i at y ndif ent o s i ' 1 m edi needs when t f l t pr l teat hi s i pai and i ectons and ot isues 4 cal hey aied o opery r s erous n nf i her s : 1 sem m i f om a serousgunshotwound t he s ai pi t hi ar est H e al alegcshe w as 5 t ng r i hat ust ned ior o s r . so l l deni neces y physcalt apy. 6 ed sar i hcr 1 7 Suc c ai s by pr ti de ai e a e a l e un rt e Due Pr e s Cl us of t h lm e ral t ne s r na yz d de h oc s a e he 1 Fourc nt Ame 8 te h ndme . Fr s v Agno ,1 2 F.d 11 11 ( hCi.998. Thcsmesa r nt o t . s 5 3 24, 28 9t r1 ) a tndad 1 applest a pr raldet nee' cl m ofdelbcr e i f cr 9 i o eti ai s ai i at ndif enceundert Foureent Am endm entast he t h o 20 aprsonerscl m undert Ei h Am endm ent / The Ei h Am endm entpr bist i poston i ' ai he ght . #. ght ohi t he m ii 2 1 ofcr and unus punihm cnt and Sem bodi br and i i tc concept of di t ci lzed uel ual s s t es oad deals i s gniy, vii ' 22 sa adshuma t andde e y. Esel vGambl 429U. 97, 02( 976.A deane or io rs tnd r , niy c nc ' tle . ' e, S. 1 1 ) ti e prs ne ' ' 23 cl m of i ai nadequat m edi car does not constt e cr and unusual punihm ent unl s t e cal e iut uel s es he 24 m i r m entrs t t l ofddelber e i fer steat ies o hc evel t i at ndif ence t serousm edi needs.'1 at106. The o i cal ' d. 25 S lb aei fer c 'sa dad i v an o jci a as beci pr t icrt ndif en e' tn r nvoles be tvc nd u j tve ong. Fis,t ale d de rt he lge 26 de i ton mu tbe i ob e tv tr ,' ufiinty s rous'Far rv Br nn 5llU. 8 83 prvai s , n j ci e e ms t fce l e i .' me . e an, s S. 25, 4 4 . ! ! . I 1 . 1 1 ( 994 ( iig Wis v Setr 5 lU. 29 298( 9 l) Se nd,t p ionofii mus ac wih a 1 ) c tn lon . ie , 0 S. 4, 1 9 ). co he rs fcal t t t ' 2 's fci l cul e st e ofm i ' w hi ent l m or t m cr neglgcnce,butl t conduct çuf i enty pabl at nd ' ch ais e han e i ess han 3 unde t ke f t e ve y p os ofc us ng h ra n or h r um e a i ann.Far e , 1U . a 837. A prs of i i ldo n m r 51 S. t i on fc a es ot ( $ 4 ac i a de i r t l i dif r ntm a runl st e of i i k tn lbe a e y n f e e nne es h fc al nows ofa di r g r a e e sve rs nd s e a ds n xc s i i k i ! . 1 5 t i at healh orsaf y.' d. o nm e t et 'I 6 ' l a y ng t i san r t N i h Cic tha he d t tbe o c i c n be s d t ta n ppl i h s t da d, he nt r ui s l ha f r t a ai ha ' 7 prs ioner' ci lrght have been abrdged,tt i f er s vi i s i the ndif ence t hi m edi needsm us be s antal o s cal t ubst i . 8 M er çndif ence, l i e i f er ' neglgencej or t edi m al actce'w ilnot s ' m cal pr i l uppor t s cause of acton.' t hi i ' 9 B r gh o v Cute ou t n . trLabo at is 62 F. 458 46 ( hCi.l ) cii çc /, U. a 1 0 r ore , 2 2d , 0 9t r 980 , tngf- /c 429 S. t 05- 6. / ' ! I . 1 'E c ai t a aphy i anha be n ne ie i dignosng orte tngame c c ton do s 0 'A! ompl nt h t sci s e glg nt n a i rai dial ondii e ll nots at avald cl m ofm edi m i r m entundert Ei hA m endm cnt M edi m al actcedoes te i ai cal steat ' he ght . cal pr i l2 notbecom e a constt i vi aton m cr y becaus t vi i i a prs iutonal ol i el c he ctm s ioner.'Est l v.Gam bl 429 ' ele e, 1 U. a 1 . e aloAnd ron y Cou y o r 45F. 1 1 ,1 l ( h Ci.1 ) McGuc i v 3 S. t 06,s e s e s ' nt fKen, 3d 3 0 3 6 9t r 995, . . kn . 1 Smih, 4 F. l l ( hCi.l 2)( er / #onot rgr s ,WMX Te h .I .v M iln 4 t 97 2d 050, 050 9t r 99 ov m c he ound j c s, nc . le , l 1 4 F. 11 , 1 36 ( h Ci.l 97)e ba ) Eve gr s n glg nc i i ufiintt e tbls 5 0 3d 33 l 9t r 9 ( n nc . n os e ie e s ns fce o sa ih l de i r t i dif e et s rousme c lne ds Se Woo v Hou ewrght90 F. 1 2,1 34 ( h 6 lbe ae n fernc o c i dia e . e d . s i , 0 2d 33 3 9t 1 Ci.l ) A prs ersmeediage me wihdign i orte t ntd sno s ppol acli of 7 r 990 . ion ' r s re nt t a oss rame oe t u ' am t 1 d i rt i fecnc .Sanc e v Vid,8 F. 240,2 (t Ci.1 9) 8 elbeae ndifr e h z . l 91 2d 42 9h r 98 . I 9 Del y of or i e f r nc wih, m e c te t e c n alo a o t de i at a , nt r e e e t di al r a m nt a s m unt o lber e J 20 idifrnc Se tv Pe r439F. 1 ,1 (*Ci. 006) Clme v Go z 298F.d8 , n fee e. elet . nne , 3d 091 096 9 r2 , e nt . me , . 3 98 2l 9 (uCi. 00 . ltvMor 2 F. 73 74 ( b r2002 . pe v Smih, 03F. 11 05 9, r2 2)Halet . gan, 96 3d 2, 4 9tCi. )Lo z . t 2 3d 22, , , . 2 11 1( :Ci.l . c onv M c nts 9 F.d33 332( 'Ci.1 96)M cGu ki v Smih, F.d 2 3 9b r 996)Ja ks . l o h, 0 3 0, 9b r 9 . , , c n . t 974 2 2 I ,l 9 ( t Ci.1 ov r uld onot rgr nd b F.f T c .I .v M ilr 1 F. 1 33, 3 050 05 9b r 992) e r e he ou s y #A' e hs, nc . le , 04 3d 1 . 24 (:Ci.) )(nba l Hulhi on v Unie St e ,838F.d39 394('Ci.J 88) W hee! 9b r 997 e nc; c ns . td ats 2 0, 9â r 9 . r he I ; 25 prs ioneri alegi t del s l ng hat ayofm edi teat ent ncesdelbcr ei fer cal r m evi i at ndif ence, however t prs ,he ioner I ' 2 mus s t tedea Idt frhe ij y.Se Halet296F.dat7 46. 6 t how hath ly e o ut r nur e lt, 3 45- , McGuc i 974F.da kn, 2 t 2 5 , l l F ' l 1 6 . h ply v xe . . fsaeprs nco ' , 6 F2 4 4 4 7( uci. 9 s (c c ra . 0 0 s a e . v ad o tt io mm r 7 6 .d 0 , 0 9z r l 8 ) p r u im) , s 2 l , Pa tf cmpa tufsf m svrl eetadmut eds se.H wi, I lni s o ln sfr r eea dfc n sb i sd e l if i e o s mi l 3 however be gi l , ven eave t t e an am ended com pl nt asdi sed bel o il ai , scus ow. 4 : Fist whie pl ntf hasnamed t physcaldet i cent CC DC asadef r , l ai if he i enton er endant t , he 5 dee ince e is linot S cron'ctngund tec orof tt lw f pupos of l 83a tons tnto ntrtefs a ' s 'a i p erh ol sae a or r es û 9 ci . 6 42U. C.j 1 ,s ealoHowltv Ros , U. 356, ( 990 . S. 983. e s et . e 496 S. 365 1 ) y N ext pl ntf alegesonl t uni ii CcDcm aphcar m edi per onnelhave , ai if l y hat dentfed e cal s 8 f l t teathi pai i ectons and ot com plcatons fom a gunshotwound i vi aton ofhi aied o r s n, nf i her i i r n ol i s . 6 Ei h Am endm entrght Thi cour fi t t cl m s ar s vague t i i unabl t det m i ) ght i s. s t nds hat he ai eo hat t s e o er ne k 1 ) whet t curentacton i fi ousorf l t sat a cl m f r i . Pl ntf m us descrbe who ( her he r i s rvol ais o t e ai or elef ai if t i lI s t l wasdelber el i fer t whatspecii s i m edi needsand whatpr s y t peciicaly i at y ndif ent o tc erous cal eci el he 1 l) def : endantdi orf i t do. The Ci lRi s Actpr des: d aied o vi ght ovi 1 3 Eveypes wbo,u rc orof(tt lw) .. s j cs orc us st r ron nde ol sae a . ube t, a e o bes jctd, n ctz nort Unie Stts . t t d rvaino an ube e a y iie he td ae . .o he epi to f y 14 rght ,pri l ,ori m unii s ed by t Constt i ..s lbe i s vieges m tes ecur hc iuton. hal la et t pat ij e i a a ton a Iw,s ti e t,orot r ibl o he ry nurd n n ci t a ui n quiy he pr e pr c e ng f r drs .42U. C.j l op r o c di or e e s S. 983. l 5 I The sat e pl i y r quie t t t e be a a t a c ne ton or lnk be we t a tons of t 6 t ut a nl e r s ha her n c u l on c i i t en he c i he 1 7 def endant and t de vaton aleged t have been s f ed by pl ntf. SeeM onel v. De ment s he pri i l o uf er ai if l part l 8 . . ' o l Se le , 6U. 658(1 ) Riz v Goode 423U. 362(976 .ThcNi hCic tb fsocal rvc s 43 S. 978 . zo . , , S. 1 ) nt rui as 1 h 9 ( ( $ , edt t ( pes s j cs a h t t de rv tonofac tt i lrghtwihi t me nig l ha aq ron ube t notero he p iai onsiutona i , t n he a n 2 ofs cton 1 b e i 983,i he doe a a Gnna i a t pa tci t s i a t r s afim atv a t or o is t f s n f tve c , ri pa e n no he ' fr i e c s m t o 2l per or an actwhi he i l l r r t do t caus t deprvaton ofw hi com pl nti f m ch s egaly equied o hat es he i i cb ai s 22 , , ma . Joh onv Duh ,5 F. 7 7 ( hCi.l . de ns . j 88 2d 40, 43 9t r 978) 23 Furher pl ntf appear t nam edef t , ai if so endant G il eand Newm an i t rcapa t as s lespi n hei ciy ' : 25 def endant A super sor i onl labl f t constt i . vi s y i e or he iutonal vi atons of . ..s di es i t ol i ubor nat f he 26 s viorpani pat i ordiect t vi atons, knew oft vi alonsand f l t actt pr uper s ci ed n r ed he ol i or he ol i aied o o event ' 24 s l s s t abiiy u de g ) 1 a ie o y up a s wi ofp s lpari i ton by t upewior . ' lt n r j 983 rs s nl on ho ng erona tcpai Li he 6 ! l i 1 1 1 t m.Theei nors he r s epondc ts ro la lt u rg)1 83.'Ta orv Lit88 F. 1 40,1 a upe ir ibiiy nde j 9 , yl . s, 0 2d 0 045 I ' 2 (:Ci.I 9) 9b r 98 . , . 3 ' I St rv Bac 633 F.d II I( h Ci.2011,t Ni hCic tr e s d t editit n ar . a, 3 9 9t r ) he nt rui ev re h src 4 c tsdimis lofas r s ylablt cli as re a i ttes rf ofaj ï.l ta c e t our' s sa upevior i iiy am setd gans h heif al n h t as,he ' 5 pl ntf cl m ed t he was atacked and s abbe t ai if ai hat t t d went t ee tm esby ot i at becaus prson y-hr i her nm es e i 6 ofi i l , i l n t s erf, f ie t pr t c hi i vi a i of t Ei h a Foure t tc a s nc udi g he h if a l d o o e t m n ol ton he ght nd t en h 7 A m endm ent / atll 94.A ferr ew i pl ntf salegatons,t courtf s. #. 93t evi ng ai if' l i he ound t t pl ntf hat he ai if 8 ale dwihs fi e deait tt s rf kne ors dha knowna t da gesi t j l lge t ufcint t lha he heif w houl ve bouthe n r n he ai, ' 9 and t he was delber el i f er t t hat i at y ndif ent o hose danger / at 1205. l r s. J. n eachi is concl on,t ng t usi he 1 co the d t a S r t a lc bl c s iu i al t nda d i de i r t i f e e e a pl i tf m a 0 ur l h t ' e he pp i a e on tt ton s a r s lbe a e ndif r nc , a n if y whe l sa e a c a m f r s r i or la lt ba e u t s er i or sknowl dge ofa a qui s en e i 1 t t l i o upe v s y i biiy s d pon he up v s ' e nd c e c c n l un on tt ina c duc byoh s./ a 1 9 Th co t ttdt t$a dee ant ybehel la e 2 c siuto l on t ter ' #. t 1 6. e ursae ha $() fnd ma ' d ibl l a a s per ior u r j 1 çf t r e ss eihe ( ) hi or h r peron i ol men i t 3 s u vs ndc 983 i he e xit t r 1 s e s al nv ve t n he l con ttton de i ton,o ( a s tcintc us lc ci bewe n t s r s ' wr gf 4 siui al prvai r 2) ufi e a a onne ton t e he upeviors on ' ui l con t dtec siui a vi aton.'l at11 ( otngHa e v Bl k 8 F. 6 6 ( h 5 duc an h on ttton l ol i ''d. 97 qu i ns n . ac , 85 2d 42, 46 9t 1 1 Ci.l ) . pl ntf ca e tbls t ne e s r c us l n c i f s pe vior labiiybyale ng 6 r 989 ) A ai if n sa ih he c s a y a a co ne ton or u r s y i lt lgi l t t defnda tst)i moto asre ofa t byot r'orS owigl rf td)t tr nat a 7 hathe e nttel n in eis cs hes' t kn n y euse o emi e . j s i of t b ot cr , c t s r s k w orr a on ys ul ha k g eres ac s y h s whi h he upe vior ne e s abl ho d ve nown woul ca eot r d us he s 1 t i lc ac tt i lij y. / (ntr l t insat ai s a ctton omitd) Thus1() 9 o nfit onsiutona nur ' #.i ena quoato , lerton , nd iai s te . ,ta ' zl s l upcrviorcan be labl i hi i vi capaciy f hi ow ncul eacton ori i i t tai ng, s i e n s ndi dual t or s pabl i nacton n he r ni 2j s upervi on,orcontolofhi subor nat f hi acqui cencei t cons iutonaldeprvaton;orf si r s di es; or s es n he tt i i i or 2 c nduc t ts we arc e sorc lusidifrnc t terg sofot r.'1 ( i Wat n v k o tha ho d e kls alo n fee e o h iht hes' d. quotng kis . zr Ci o lnd,l F.d 1 7,1 ( hCi.1 ) $ t foaka 45 3 08 093 9t r 998). y 24 Becausepl ntf alegatonsm ayi plcat hi cons iutonalrght,hehasl ai ifs l i m i e s tt i i s eavet t e o il j zj an amended com pl nt l pl ntf el s t pr ai . f ai if ect o oceed i t s acton by t i an am ended com pl nt he n hi i ilng ai , ' 26 i a s d t ath s oul s ci ca l i c iy e c de e ntt t e be tofhi a lt c a iy wha s dvi e h e h d pe t ly d ntf a h f nda o h s i s biiy. l r f t ' k i 7 1 1 ) : i ! 1 cons i tonal rght he beleves each def tm i i i endant has vi at and suppor each cl m wih f ual ol ed t ai t act 2 . 2 ale atonsa ute c defnda ' a i . Agan,t r ca be no la lt un r42 U. C.j 1 lg i bo a h e nts ctons i he e n ibiiy de S. 983 3 unl t e i s e afi i lnk or connecton bet een a def ndants actons and t cl m ed ess her s om fnnatve i i w e ' i he ai 4 de i ton.Riz 423U. 3 . a v Eno o, F. l 4,1 ( 'Ci. 98 . ns n, F.d prvai z o, S. 62, y . mot 633 2d 6 67 9b r 1 0)Joh o 588 2 M , ' 5 at743. Pl ntf cl m sm us besetf t i shor and pl n t m s sm pl , conci y and diecty. ai i rs ai t orh n t ai er , i y sel r l See 6 Swir iwizv Sor maN. ,53 U. 5 5l ( ) Fe R. v.P.8. e kee c . e A. 4 S. 06, 4 2002 . d. Ci , 7 Pl ntf i i onned t t cour cannot r er t a prorpl ng i or t m ake ai if s nf hat he t ef o i eadi n der o 8 pl ntf s am ended com pl nt com pl c.Local Rul l 1 r r t an am ended com pl nt be ai if' ai et c 5- equies hat ai ' 9 com pl ei is fw ihoutr er et n tcl t ef ence t anyprorpl ng. si bccaus asagener r e, amended o i eadi Thi s e, al ul an l co ai s ere steorgial ompl n. eJol,v Rha 37 F. 55 57( hCi.1 67. c 0 mpl nt up sde h ï n c aitSe a .r . y, 5 2d , 9t r 9 )On e / . 1l pl ntf fl s a a e d c pl i ,t or g n pl a ng no I ge s r esa f c i i t c s . ai if ie n m nde om a nt he i i al e di on r e v ny un ton n he a e 12 Ther or i anam endedcompl ntasi an orgi com pl nt each cl m and t i vementofeach ef e, n ai , n i nal ai , ai he nvol ' : . 1 defnda mus bes fcintyalg d. 3 e nt t ufi e l le e I j l 4 I ! Fi ly,a t sc tha s r e d te c nal s hi our s c e ne h ompli a dimis d i wih lav t a n ant nd s s e t t e e o me d l purua t 28U. C. 1 l a, fnd nt motont dimis( #6)i prmaur.Ass h,h 5 s nto S. j 9 5A()dee a s' i o s s ECF s e t e uc te 1 motoni de e wih prj c Pli ifsmotonf e en i oftmet o et motont 6 i s nid tout eudie. antf' i or xt son i o ppos he i o 1 dim is( #9)i de e a m' . 7 s s ECF s nid s oot I IV. C oncl i n 8 us o l 9 I I TH ER EFO R E O R DERED t t Cl k s l D ETACH and FI t T S hat he er hal LE he 20 co a nt( /1 1 . mpli ECF / - ) 2l I I FURTH ER O RD ERED t t pl i ifs c pl i i D I I T S ha a ntf ' om a nt s SM SSED W I TH 22 LEAV E TO AM END . 23 II T SFURTHER ORDERED t t ai if lha t ryt lda fo t t t t ha pl nlf wil ve hi t 3o ys r m hedac ba 2 t sor ri cnt ed t tl hi a e e c m pl nt i he be i ve hec c r t h no e de i i nc e . 4 hi de s er o ie s m nd d o ai , f le s an orec t e t d fc e i s 25 The am ended com pl ntm ustbe a com pl e docum enti and ofisel,and wils s t orgi ai et n t f l uper ede he i nal 26 com pl nti isentr y. Any alegatons pari orr ai n t iet l i , tes, equess f r i fom prorpaper t ar not t or elef r i s hat e 8 . 1 1 1 ' j ; I l 1 car i f w ar i t am ended com pl ntw ilno I red of d n he ai l ongerbe bef e t cour. or he t j I I FURTHER ORDERED ta pan if h lce rytt tea n e c mpli TS h t litf s al la l il h me d d o ant e 3 as s uch by pl ng t wor 'FI ST AM EN DED' i m edi el above çci l Ri s Com pl nt aci he ds C R 'm at y s vi ght ai 4 Purua t 42U. C. 1 3:onpa 1i t c pto an pl nifs lplc t c s numbe, 1 s nto S. 9 98 ' ge n he a in, d aitf hal a c be a e r2:25 CVOZI6ORCJ- CF,above t wor SFI ST AM EN DED'i t s V he ds t R 'n he pacef Sc As No. or ç e ' ' 6 I I FURTH ER O R DERED t pl ntf i expr sl cautoned t i he doesnot T S hat ai if s es y i hat f 7 tm el fl an amended com pl nt i complance wih t s or , t s case m ay be i m edi el i y ie ai n i t hi der hi m at y 8 di ised. sm s 9 I I FURTH ER O R DER ED t t Cl k s ls t pl ntf abl s i 1 T S hat he er hal cnd o ai if ank ecton 983 1) ci lrght com pl ntf m w ih i r i al wih onecopy oft orgi com pl nt ( vi i s ai or t nstuctons ong t he i nal ai . 11 I I FURTHER ORDERED t t a n ifsmotonf a oi men o co el ECF T S ha pli tf' i or pp nt t f uns ( ' ) #1 )i DENI wiho prj c . 2 0 s ED t ut eudie l J I I FURTHER ORDERED t t fn nt motont dimist /)iDENI TS ha dee da s' i o s s EcF/6 S ED 1 wih u peu ie 4 to t rjdc . ! I 5 ' I I FURTHER ORDERED t tpli ifsmotonf e e inoftme( #9) T S ha antf' i or xtnso i ECF I i D EN I asm oot 6 s ED . l 7 D ATED t s 29+ dayofJ hi anuaf 2013. y, 1 8 19 ' l ED ' STA DI TRI S C E 20 2' l . 22 23 24 25 2 $ 9 I I

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?