United States of America et al v. Healthsouth Corporation et al
Filing
261
ORDER granting in part 255 Objection/Appeal Magistrate Judge Order/Ruling LR IB 3-1; and otherwise affirming 253 Order on Motion for Attorney Fees. Signed by Judge Andrew P. Gordon on 5/20/2020. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRS)
Case 2:13-cv-01319-APG-VCF Document 261 Filed 05/20/20 Page 1 of 2
1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
2
DISTRICT OF NEVADA
3
***
4 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ex rel.
JOSHUA LUKE,
5
Plaintiff,
6
v.
7 HEALTHSOUTH CORPORATION, et al.,
Case No. 2:13-cv-01319-APG-VCF
ORDER GRANTING IN PART
OBJECTION TO MAGISTRATE
JUDGE’S ORDER
(ECF No. 255)
Defendants.
8
9
10
Magistrate Judge Ferenbach awarded the relator’s former counsel Troutman Sanders LLP
11 $200,688.73 in attorneys’ fees. ECF No. 253. Defendant HealthSouth objects to that decision,
12 arguing that Troutman should recover no fees because the law firm engaged in an impermissible
13 conflict of interest representing HealthSouth while at the same time suing it. ECF No. 255. In
14 the alternative, HealthSouth argues that Troutman’s fees should be reduced because Judge
15 Ferenbach included post-conflict fees he meant to exclude. Troutman responds that it is entitled
16 to recover its pre-conflict fees and acknowledges that Judge Ferenbach’s fee award is too high
17 because it includes some post-conflict fees. ECF No. 257.
18
I have conducted a de novo review of the fee motion and related papers as required by
19 Local Rule IB 3-2(b). I agree with and adopt Judge Ferenbach’s legal and factual analyses, as
20 modified below.
21
Judge Ferenbach found that:
22
Troutman’s representation of both the relator and HealthSouth on and after
February 22, 2017 is a conflict that requires disgorgement of fees once conflict
arose, and Troutman is not entitled to any fees or costs for work on or after February
22, 2017. Troutman earned fees while acting ethically from 2013 to 2017 prior to
23
Case 2:13-cv-01319-APG-VCF Document 261 Filed 05/20/20 Page 2 of 2
1
the conflict, and the Court finds that Troutman is entitled to reasonable fees for that
time period. The Court exercises its discretion and reduces the total lodestar an
additional eight percent, on top of Troutman’s voluntary ten percent, to deter future
improprieties.
2
3
4 ECF No. 253 at 6:13-15. I agree and adopt this finding. Judge Ferenbach then correctly
5 determined the hourly rates to use for the lodestar. Id. at 8-9. But as both parties acknowledge,
6 he inadvertently included some post-conflict hours that should have been excluded from his
7 calculation. I calculate the lodestar as follows:
Timekeeper
Paralegals and Librarians
Nick Harper
Paddy Browne
Natalie Sacha
Thomas Prouty
Jeremy Burnette
Daniel Streeter
Kevin Kieffer
Bryan Lavine
Merril Hirsh
Total
8
9
10
11
12
13
Rate
$1501
$175
$285
$350
$425
$375
$520
$595
$600
$710
Hours
1.52
9.0
27.8
109.5
33.2
15.9
1.4
136.8
38.2
21.1
394.4
Total
$225
$1,575
$7,923
$38,325
$14,110
$5,963
$728
$81,396
$22,920
$14,981
$188,146
14 Applying Judge Ferenbach’s total 18% reduction (which I find appropriate here) yields a fee award
15 of $154,279.72. Given the circumstances of this case, that is a reasonable amount.
I HEREBY ORDER that Magistrate Judge Ferenbach’s Order (ECF No. 253) is affirmed
16
17 as modified above, and HealthSouth’s objection (ECF No. 255) is granted part. Troutman is
18 awarded $154,279.72 in attorneys’ fees.
DATED this 19th day of May, 2020.
19
20
ANDREW P. GORDON
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
21
22
1
Troutman’s calculation in its response used its original rates, rather than the rates determined to
be appropriate by Magistrate Judge Ferenbach. Compare ECF No. 257 at 8 with ECF No. 253 at
23 8-9.
2
HealthSouth’s calculation excluded .7 hours of paralegal time. ECF No. 255 at 9.
2
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?