Skylights LLC v. Byron et al
Filing
12
ORDER granting 11 Stipulation permitting Federal Housing Finance Agency to Intervene. This order is effective immediately. The Federal Housing Finance Agency must file its answer on or before January 30, 2015. Signed by Magistrate Judge Cam Ferenbach on 1/23/2015. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DKJ)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
300 East Second Street, Suite 1510
Reno, NV 89501
Tel: (775) 788-2200 Fax: (775) 786-1177
FENNEMORE CRAIG JONES VARGAS
11
Leslie Bryan Hart, Esq. (SBN 4932)
John D. Tennert, Esq. (SBN 11728)
FENNEMORE CRAIG, P.C.
300 E. Second St., Suite 1510
Reno, Nevada 89501
Tel: 775-788-2228 Fax: 775-788-2229
lhart@fclaw.com; jtennert@fclaw.com
(Pro Hac Vice to be Submitted)
Asim Varma, Esq.
Asim.Varma@aporter.com
Howard N. Cayne, Esq.
Howard.Cayne@aporter.com
Michael A.F. Johnson, Esq.
Michael.Johnson@aporter.com
ARNOLD & PORTER LLP
555 12th Street NW
Washington, DC 20004
Tel: (202) 942-5000 Fax: (202) 942-5999
Attorneys for Proposed Intervenor
Federal Housing Finance Agency
12
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEVADA
13
14
SKYLIGHTS LLC,
CASE NO. 2:15-cv-00043-GMN-VCF
Plaintiff,
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
vs.
DAVID BYRON; JENNIFER BYRON; CCSF
LLC; FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE
ASSOCIATION; CITIMORTGAGE, INC.;
CLEAR RECON CORP.; DOES I through 10;
and ROE BUSINESS ENTITIES I through 10,
STIPULATION TO ENTRY OF ORDER
AND [PROPOSED] ORDER
PERMITTING FEDERAL HOUSING
FINANCE AGENCY TO INTERVENE AS
CONSERVATOR OF THE FEDERAL
NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATION
Defendants.
FEDERAL
NATIONAL
MORTGAGE
ASSOCIATION,
Counterclaimant,
vs.
SKYLIGHTS LLC; THE FALLS AT
RHODES
RANCH
CONDOMINIUM
OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC.,
Counter-defendants.
26
27
28
1
1
2
3
1.
The Federal Housing Finance Agency (“FHFA” or “Conservator”), as Conservator
for Defendant Federal National Mortgage Association (“Fannie Mae”), seeks to intervene in the
above-captioned action pursuant to 12 U.S.C. § 4617(b)(2)(A)(i) and Fed. R. Civ. P. 24.
4
2.
On September 6, 2008, FHFA’s Director appointed the FHFA Conservator of Fannie
5
6
Mae and the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Association in accordance with the Housing and
7
Economic Recovery Act of 2008, Pub. L. 110-289, 122 Stat. 2654 (codified at 12 U.S.C.§ 4617)
8
(“HERA”).
9
10
3.
The FHFA, as Conservator, has succeeded to “all rights, titles, powers, and
privileges” of Fannie Mae, including its right to sue and be sued in the federal courts. 12 U.S.C. §
4617(b)(2)(A)(i).
300 East Second Street, Suite 1510
Reno, NV 89501
Tel: (775) 788-2200 Fax: (775) 786-1177
FENNEMORE CRAIG JONES VARGAS
11
12
4.
13
Accordingly, FHFA has an unconditional federal statutory right to intervene in this
14
matter, see Fed. R. Civ. P. 24(a)(1), and to assert its interests in a manner consistent with the
15
Conservator’s powers and duties.
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
5.
Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 24(c), FHFA attaches as Exhibit A its intended Answer.
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
///
2
1
2
3
4
5
6
STIPULATION
FHFA and Plaintiff Skylights LLC, through their attorneys of record, hereby stipulate and
request that the Court make this stipulation an order of the Court:
The FHFA shall be permitted to intervene in the above-referenced
action pursuant to 12 U.S.C. § 4617(b)(2)(A)(i) and Fed. R. Civ. P.
24.
DATED this 22nd day of January, 2015.
7
8
FENNEMORE CRAIG, P.C.
PITE DUNCAN, LLP
By: /s/ Leslie Bryan Hart
Leslie Bryan Hart, Esq. (SBN 4932)
John D. Tennert, Esq. (SBN 11728)
300 E. Second St., Suite 1510
Reno, Nevada 89501
Tel: 775-788-2228 Fax: 775-788-2229
lhart@fclaw.com; jtennert@fclaw.com
and
By: /s/ with the consent of Laurel I. Handley
Laurel I. Handley, Esq. (SBN 9576)
lhandley@piteduncan.com
Krista J. Nielson, Esq. (SBN 10698)
knielson@piteduncan.com
520 South 4th Street, Suite 360
Las Vegas, Nevada 89101
Tel: (858) 750-7600 Fax: (702) 685-6342
9
10
300 East Second Street, Suite 1510
Reno, NV 89501
Tel: (775) 788-2200 Fax: (775) 786-1177
FENNEMORE CRAIG JONES VARGAS
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
ARNOLD & PORTER LLP
(Pro Hac Vice to be Submitted)
Asim Varma, Esq.
Asim.Varma@aporter.com
Howard N. Cayne, Esq.
Howard.Cayne@aporter.com
Michael A.F. Johnson, Esq.
Michael.Johnson@aporter.com
555 12th Street NW
Washington, DC 20004
Tel: (202) 942-5000 Fax: (202) 942-5999
Attorneys for Proposed Intervenor Federal
Housing Finance Agency
Attorneys for Defendants/Counterclaimants
David Byron; Jennifer Byron; CCSF LLC;
Federal National Mortgage Association;
CitiMortgage, Inc.; Clear Recon Corp.; Does
1-10; and Roe Business Entities 1-10
LAW OFFICE OF MIKE BEEDE
By: /s/ with the consent of Michael N. Beede
Michael N. Beede
2300 W. Sahara Ave., Ste. 420
Las Vegas, NV 89102
Tel: 702-473-8406
Attorney for Plaintiff Skylights LLC
22
23
24
ORDER PERMITTING FEDERAL HOUSING
FINANCE AGENCY TO INTERVENE
Having considered the Stipulation to Entry of Order Permitting Federal Housing Finance
25
Agency to Intervene as Conservator of the Federal National Mortgage Association, it is hereby:
26
27
28
ORDERED that the Federal Housing Finance Agency is allowed to intervene in this action
pursuant to 12 U.S.C. § 4617(b)(2)(A)(i) and Fed. R. Civ. P. 24; and it is further ORDERED that
3
1
2
3
this Order shall be effective immediately.
January 23, 2015
DATED:_____________________
______________________________________
HON. CAM FERENBACH
UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE
4
5
The Federal Housing Finance Agency must file its answer on or before January 30, 2015.
6
7
8
9
10
300 East Second Street, Suite 1510
Reno, NV 89501
Tel: (775) 788-2200 Fax: (775) 786-1177
FENNEMORE CRAIG JONES VARGAS
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
4
Exhibit A
Exhibit A
!# (*
"$% &'))
+ #& /
" .*)
,-
0 14*.6782345 .6)4
2345 .7 94* :)4
4
4
0 0
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
1
1
1
2
1
3
1
4
1
5
1
6
1
7
1
8
1
9
2
2
1
2
2
2
3
2
4
2
5
2
6
2
7
2
8
0
0
0=?0 BDECF=I 43K
;NI < J I 2K
O< A0 00 0
IZIL 8FDCF 5782[\ ZIL
M>7 QC Q 00 7
0 `bca d00]h FR0
J ?a A G Lh0S[?<
^_ Cef0 H0
<
=[0 d[CgFL0AL F K
=IFI [0
= A
IXC<0 0LDLG QI
ZC 0 I A= 0
?M j0LXCL;;P
Q J 9
0FA<=YA Ai=RFA 0=PL?CQD?F G
Y0
0 0 0U5QV
4V
T0
=
0
0
p, o,0+-,r+ xyz
v+ n qrm,0+qwpn
{+r{r p,on 8n 0|
N N;0
0 O08o+pw ,} ,p,q
;0 0
;;\N0
\0 O @t
\
I p},qz|rm +-p0r+ 0|
0 @t
\
O
O 0 OG0
pqr, xr+0}p}
0 INFA00
08o+pw r,pw 8r+
\
;0@u
0 \O 00ASl0
0 p rqn ,p0n
0
r,
CR0 P 0 0F LSM1G p0n
D0
O MLlM1\
0M
0
0 0 0 N<? DG
0
TI 0
=
0 EO ;;\ OE0 0 O0
0 0 0
N u0
st;
E0
;;
EN0 O 0 G
k
G
I
0 0 0 LDEL=D0?CQ0 0 F F?0 = A M0< FD> All0 =QC?DJD?0 lC
B
M
CL L
L
0 ?
3 ]?FFSC?D=l<0BFFFFA0?M0 0 FA<<
LD0? >F 0?DRh0 0CF 0l >0Y T> AQRA04CJK0 0QLRD04Q0
DF=[CF0 ASD00<? L0
L
6 AH?< D0MFC[L?DF0DC?lFC0<=LFF 0LF<
L
0
=
L
7 RYDZ=F0M0
[iCD0> 0BPCD?0 B? F0 0
Y<
Y l
8 L >?F?Rh0>?FY >M=;;U
9
1 0R F0 C0>?FYQC[=C0 FA=0 0 <h? 0D?<lFD0 F?0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI0
=F 0> C? =Z? DPAlCM1L0<L >?F0
M < L M
F
0
1
1
2 0R F0C00 SF<=N0 =AQA<0Di< <060
40
I E C[? F F OA=<0 <0 L0CA0 SFG CC0 0 FS D0 0 1
2V
11ID?0 =?j0 0FF=FC0 <=0 sLDl0 ~ KC0lD0L0
=
L J
= 0
1 OM0C>0FMR=CQ0 DL DS ZDA0 =QC?D0DI~ <>0 K~AD
5 <> C0 L<0 DMLR[??[0 <==L?F G Q0 OM0C>EGlCF=0
1 CRQD<hF FLF ACF0WA=<0A? >RFU >M=;;0ADF0?MG
6 D0LTB=GS0 MS0 ADB? AlF
0 Z? ZC
[i< L l
0= 0
1 F>0D0D<l>0 R=AhRC0 E0P
N0 u
F
B
N0 O0
1 290 2
0E LMA =0=FlFD0 F?0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI0
8
6@;N01 0 0F C? =Z? DPAlCM2L0<L >?F0
M < L M
F
0
1
9
3 00 FLF DZ>R 0=F F 0 F0
= M
D L
F
< LM A
2
F < L M
F
0
2 L0lFDZ??0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI0
1 YM0> C? 0 FDPAlCM3L0<L >?F0
4 00 FLF DZ>R 0=F F 0 F0
= M
D L
F
< LM A
2
2
2 L0lFDZ??0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI0
3 YM0> C? 0 FDPAlCM4L0<L >?F0
F < L M
F
0
2
4
5 0R F0 C0 ?0 SF C0 A=?FDL<0=<0C=R?0?0Q?DCR
I E C[? F FM=LA0 =] ?RQ? 0TAF 0 S=A?<0 F=CF 0D0
=M F
M S L M=
DM L
2 FC0=?0?0 SF
5 MF D0<0 F=LAI
T
? DM 0
2
6
6 0=FlFD0 F?0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI0
I E RD<0 0> C? =Z? DPAlCM6L0<L >?F0
M < L M
F
0
2
7
2
8
2
0
0
0
0
!# (*
"$% &'))
+ #& /
" .*)
,-
0 14*.6782345 .6)4
2345 .7 94* :)4
4
4
0 0
0
0
0
1 0 7 00 FLF DZ>R 0=F F 0 F0
= M
D L
F
< LM A
2 L0M0>lFDQD C? 0LQA?lZM0>?F 0C R>C0 QDLi0 00<R C? =Z? DPAlCM8L0<L >?F
Y=F0lFD0 F?0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI
9 0R F0MFD?0 YC0LFRlFD0 F?0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI
> C? =Z? DPAlCM9L0<L >?F
< L M
F
0
1
1
1I PAlCM 10 YF<L >?F=C<0l>QD>=L=FC0 L DFAH?0FFRMA?I
1 E A =C<0<?FQD?F0YPCD?Y=QC[=FC0LDFAH??F 0>? 0MFR0L0?FQD?F0YPCD?Y=QC[=FC0LDFAH??F 0>? 0MFR0L00FFRMA?I
4 E A =C<0<?FQD?F0YPCD?Y=QC[=FC0LDFAH??F 0>? 0MFR0L0?FQD?F0YPCD?Y=QC[=FC0LDFAH??F 0>? 0MFR0L0? 0=QD?SDI0 0M=DZ0
Y?[C? 0 <<==CR A=A<0F AlFF0[0L=CYQDh0AD<0?FY? F0FF00>? YAZMQ00C0? L0AF F 0AiAB?hA<0B10 I 41JK3G
P Y
??FY=QC[0YY<0D0>C0F0 0 R=C0 =>0A[0W? S=?lD?0 <=?FA=0DFZ00ZCTAS]=0D?M DG
>?F 0>? 0A0CARh0 0LF?<0Y> M=0 FiC0CRI
4 DA QlRB==CDRh0>?FYC00 <>0SF?<0BPCD?0=CA=> YF?FZ<0AZ<[?QDSFL0>?FYCRQSFARYDCFOM0
8 Q=0[?=L=0<> D<0DA?FD? C0 =LRQ0YPCD?0D0LD0 0
9 C>EI
=
2
8rm+0| +xp0n o8,
p88n -
2
1
OM0C l=0YCB0MFZ<lRB==CDRh0>?FYC00 <>0SF?<0BPCD?0=CA=> YF?FZ<0AZ< =LRQ0YL
M
0
2
6
8n p88n -
80| +xp0n o8,
2
7
PCD?YM=C0RHC?F 0C0DCZ0D0CGFASM? L 0Q=CRL0[?=L=0
Y
=
2 Y?RF0 FC0C l=0< 0 [?lF0=R[CC0D0>lRCF0AL =?D0YD?0 <=Y??D0L
>?F 0C0C> 0Li <0Q=L0[?=L=L0CD<C0SYQL0L <=FA0C l=0
ACFM0L=RAF 0Y DA>Y
>?F 00L0 F>RF0 ?I
Y? < F L C <<0
6
n p88n -
}|0| +xp0n o8,
7
PCD?YC>RF0?0D0A A0R=<=h?F 0? 0 ]DL0CF I
YY < LL
[L D
<
8
,n p88n -
,0| +xp0n o8,
9
1
D?0 ?FY
CD<C0ACMRD0SBZ? A CRFPCD?I
M < L Y0
1
1
0,0| +xp0n o8,
p88n -
1
2
0QALC<0BAYAD=8CR10YM0 TR0
E ? LiAF=h0 <0<0LF0<=L0 T> AQRA0=?0S> =FYAMMA?I DF<<0M0
0
B
0
lL
1
4
Q ?
1 Ci?C?F0YCB=Q0<<==0E A=A<0M0?M0L=<0 h>BL0D0SMRYDC0 0
N<>AFA0Sl D0 AS0>?F 0 ROM0C>EK
T
YC
=
1
9
1 0 QALC<0BAYADi0
I E ? LiAF=h0<< ATL=iAlCMG 0 Y>
D
M
0
CY B
2
Y
2 =FLF0<A0E CRD?0 <=AlF0D0FA==?0EL=D0?CQ0 LF<L=ACL0L0CD<
6 YFlTA[L0CD<C0AlFG? F C> YD?0 <=~?M=0F=0 Z<=0
CL0
F> i
CRi??l=02uII 0067hJKK?I
D0AT> h0S]Q0L>TG
I AD0M0 D <=h0 FLFFCB
F M DG CD=[=AGL0C D0
C 0
0
M
0
0
?T>DCB>DCFQ00?l
Mi<010ALMA=C<>Z0DC[CDAFC0W? S=<0CD<C0?=V
D
i=FDN0?>F02uII 041JK3I
?
OA ZL
0
8 10 I 067]JKi<[i=CB=C<>Z0MFZL>0<[?CYAQLS=A0DC
0
=iAAL?0?DF0W?l?MCYAF=QAR?FA=0YD?0 0F?0D<0E =
S 0L0 >0L>0L0W?l?MD?0
I S=CFL10 I 41JK3G <> E0CRF00<>AF 0A[0M=LAG S=CFF08
F
L
0
uII 0021CR
4I1GFC0CD<C0=F Q[hA0 0AiABCFAM0 >I
ZM ><
M
F
1I 0D0CD<C0A0D?<000<<[?C?DYL F?0 SFiASD008
1 E CRD?0 RFCRFA DF 0 [0 =LAGS=CFL20
F L
LA M 0 F
uII 0021CR
4I1GMF 2uII 0067]JKi<>R=OM0C>0 >0A[0
I 2
0D0 00
0 C0 0 I 41JK30AQS<0 <> E0CTAS0>?F K
O?<
Y
1 0 QALC<0BAYADi0
I E ? LiAF=h0<< ATL=iAlCMG 0 Y>
D
M
0
CY B
=FLF0<?F 0R<=0>? 0 F 0AiAB0
BL < M Y
DM
0
3 D?0 <=N?F 0>? 0D?<=A0 L?l
Mi<010ALMA=C<>Z0DC[CDAFC0W? S=<0CD<C0?=V
D
i=FDN0?>F02uII 041JK3I
?
OA ZL
0
7 @C<0DF? 0RF00 RQC0<<[?C?DAlA?lF FA DF 0RFCRFA DF 0 [0 =LAGS=CFL20
F L
LA M 0 F
uII 0021CR
4I1GFC0CD<C0=FI
ZM
M
F
9 0D0CD<C0A0D?<000<<[?C?DYL F?0 SFiASD008
I E CRD?0 RFCRFA DF 0 [0 =LAGS=CFL20
F L
LA M 0 F
uII 0021CR
4I1GMF CD<C0?FYMLl0=A0Z?lA>Y0
G 0AB0 0 D0 ?U
L F L L <<
1 OMF >?FY=AHY ?FYC<0LMD0BZC0YF0 [iCD\
I C0 CD?0=DF?lh0 BL0=L >?F
P YF
?
0
3 OMFF<LA0<>A0MF10 I41JK30A< F0D0 TR0C FC0
I C0M0 SFRQCZ0MF
ZL>0<[?CYAQLS=A0DC=iAAL? > 0L??SRA 0L=ACL=?\
A0C0 <>0 >0 >0?0L0W?l?MD?0
I C0<LA0 QCE0CC00>?FY0
<=Y=0 QAR?<A0C0CD<C0FA=00?FY0
MF D?0 <=?<0FA<=0<0D0LF\D0
I C0 0Y=F<LA0<[=]=0D0AiA0
I C0 0 @AC0 A0
0=;< <
0;<>0 BDECF=I 43K
0 =?@AC0 AG H0 @
0920
0 <
0 J
6
0M0 0 D7578220W0 578220
0 0
0 7
0>CF QC Q[\FDZIL 0ZIL
0
]
9
CR
D0
1
p+,rwo {r+0+
ww{
1
1
J ?a d[CgF0<h FR
^_ Ca GaH00S F
=`bcA d=`_d[? =0 _0
1
4
551D0DM 9 V 0 J 9
J
1
6
F=DB0YA Ai=R D
SDlDD<lDB 0
Q0
1 0
7
0
1
8
1
9
2
2
1
2
2
2
3
2
4
2
5
2
6
2
7
2
8
8
0
0
0
0
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?