Skylights LLC v. Byron et al

Filing 12

ORDER granting 11 Stipulation permitting Federal Housing Finance Agency to Intervene. This order is effective immediately. The Federal Housing Finance Agency must file its answer on or before January 30, 2015. Signed by Magistrate Judge Cam Ferenbach on 1/23/2015. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DKJ)

Download PDF
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 300 East Second Street, Suite 1510 Reno, NV 89501 Tel: (775) 788-2200 Fax: (775) 786-1177 FENNEMORE CRAIG JONES VARGAS 11 Leslie Bryan Hart, Esq. (SBN 4932) John D. Tennert, Esq. (SBN 11728) FENNEMORE CRAIG, P.C. 300 E. Second St., Suite 1510 Reno, Nevada 89501 Tel: 775-788-2228 Fax: 775-788-2229 lhart@fclaw.com; jtennert@fclaw.com (Pro Hac Vice to be Submitted) Asim Varma, Esq. Asim.Varma@aporter.com Howard N. Cayne, Esq. Howard.Cayne@aporter.com Michael A.F. Johnson, Esq. Michael.Johnson@aporter.com ARNOLD & PORTER LLP 555 12th Street NW Washington, DC 20004 Tel: (202) 942-5000 Fax: (202) 942-5999 Attorneys for Proposed Intervenor Federal Housing Finance Agency 12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF NEVADA 13 14 SKYLIGHTS LLC, CASE NO. 2:15-cv-00043-GMN-VCF Plaintiff, 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 vs. DAVID BYRON; JENNIFER BYRON; CCSF LLC; FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATION; CITIMORTGAGE, INC.; CLEAR RECON CORP.; DOES I through 10; and ROE BUSINESS ENTITIES I through 10, STIPULATION TO ENTRY OF ORDER AND [PROPOSED] ORDER PERMITTING FEDERAL HOUSING FINANCE AGENCY TO INTERVENE AS CONSERVATOR OF THE FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATION Defendants. FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATION, Counterclaimant, vs. SKYLIGHTS LLC; THE FALLS AT RHODES RANCH CONDOMINIUM OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC., Counter-defendants. 26 27 28 1 1 2 3 1. The Federal Housing Finance Agency (“FHFA” or “Conservator”), as Conservator for Defendant Federal National Mortgage Association (“Fannie Mae”), seeks to intervene in the above-captioned action pursuant to 12 U.S.C. § 4617(b)(2)(A)(i) and Fed. R. Civ. P. 24. 4 2. On September 6, 2008, FHFA’s Director appointed the FHFA Conservator of Fannie 5 6 Mae and the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Association in accordance with the Housing and 7 Economic Recovery Act of 2008, Pub. L. 110-289, 122 Stat. 2654 (codified at 12 U.S.C.§ 4617) 8 (“HERA”). 9 10 3. The FHFA, as Conservator, has succeeded to “all rights, titles, powers, and privileges” of Fannie Mae, including its right to sue and be sued in the federal courts. 12 U.S.C. § 4617(b)(2)(A)(i). 300 East Second Street, Suite 1510 Reno, NV 89501 Tel: (775) 788-2200 Fax: (775) 786-1177 FENNEMORE CRAIG JONES VARGAS 11 12 4. 13 Accordingly, FHFA has an unconditional federal statutory right to intervene in this 14 matter, see Fed. R. Civ. P. 24(a)(1), and to assert its interests in a manner consistent with the 15 Conservator’s powers and duties. 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 5. Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 24(c), FHFA attaches as Exhibit A its intended Answer. /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// /// 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 STIPULATION FHFA and Plaintiff Skylights LLC, through their attorneys of record, hereby stipulate and request that the Court make this stipulation an order of the Court: The FHFA shall be permitted to intervene in the above-referenced action pursuant to 12 U.S.C. § 4617(b)(2)(A)(i) and Fed. R. Civ. P. 24. DATED this 22nd day of January, 2015. 7 8 FENNEMORE CRAIG, P.C. PITE DUNCAN, LLP By: /s/ Leslie Bryan Hart Leslie Bryan Hart, Esq. (SBN 4932) John D. Tennert, Esq. (SBN 11728) 300 E. Second St., Suite 1510 Reno, Nevada 89501 Tel: 775-788-2228 Fax: 775-788-2229 lhart@fclaw.com; jtennert@fclaw.com and By: /s/ with the consent of Laurel I. Handley Laurel I. Handley, Esq. (SBN 9576) lhandley@piteduncan.com Krista J. Nielson, Esq. (SBN 10698) knielson@piteduncan.com 520 South 4th Street, Suite 360 Las Vegas, Nevada 89101 Tel: (858) 750-7600 Fax: (702) 685-6342 9 10 300 East Second Street, Suite 1510 Reno, NV 89501 Tel: (775) 788-2200 Fax: (775) 786-1177 FENNEMORE CRAIG JONES VARGAS 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 ARNOLD & PORTER LLP (Pro Hac Vice to be Submitted) Asim Varma, Esq. Asim.Varma@aporter.com Howard N. Cayne, Esq. Howard.Cayne@aporter.com Michael A.F. Johnson, Esq. Michael.Johnson@aporter.com 555 12th Street NW Washington, DC 20004 Tel: (202) 942-5000 Fax: (202) 942-5999 Attorneys for Proposed Intervenor Federal Housing Finance Agency Attorneys for Defendants/Counterclaimants David Byron; Jennifer Byron; CCSF LLC; Federal National Mortgage Association; CitiMortgage, Inc.; Clear Recon Corp.; Does 1-10; and Roe Business Entities 1-10 LAW OFFICE OF MIKE BEEDE By: /s/ with the consent of Michael N. Beede Michael N. Beede 2300 W. Sahara Ave., Ste. 420 Las Vegas, NV 89102 Tel: 702-473-8406 Attorney for Plaintiff Skylights LLC 22 23 24 ORDER PERMITTING FEDERAL HOUSING FINANCE AGENCY TO INTERVENE Having considered the Stipulation to Entry of Order Permitting Federal Housing Finance 25 Agency to Intervene as Conservator of the Federal National Mortgage Association, it is hereby: 26 27 28 ORDERED that the Federal Housing Finance Agency is allowed to intervene in this action pursuant to 12 U.S.C. § 4617(b)(2)(A)(i) and Fed. R. Civ. P. 24; and it is further ORDERED that 3 1 2 3 this Order shall be effective immediately. January 23, 2015 DATED:_____________________ ______________________________________ HON. CAM FERENBACH UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE 4 5 The Federal Housing Finance Agency must file its answer on or before January 30, 2015. 6 7 8 9 10 300 East Second Street, Suite 1510 Reno, NV 89501 Tel: (775) 788-2200 Fax: (775) 786-1177 FENNEMORE CRAIG JONES VARGAS 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 4 Exhibit A Exhibit A  !#   (*   "$% &'))   + #& / " .*) ,- 0 14*.6782345 .6)4 2345 .7 94* :)4  4   4  0 0    0  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 0 0 0=?0 BDECF =I 43K ;<D<@ACDAGGHH @ 0980 M0 0 D0F =I0 I17 20 L>NI < J I 2K O< A0 00 0 I<LR00SJ05  0I? @ 00 G 11 3 DGTR09G1 F1 00 QD0F 0<P 0 <U7V8V820 W07V8V29 L <CC250CU 578220 O<AXY>ZIL 8FD<F QC Q[0 0 >CF 5782[\ <DAXY>ZIL M>7 QC Q 00 7 0 `bca d00]h FR0 J ?a A G Lh0S[?< ^_ Cef0 H0 < =[0 d[CgFL0AL F K =IFI [0 = A IXC<0<H0 ? C 0 BiA Q0 A C I EL[I0[C<DGLFAL ZCRCDXC =<I [0 ELMA> 0LDLG QI ZC 0 I A = 0 ?M<ILB=D ii0<IL QCRIDM=DAA0[0 ? C> j0LXCL;;P Q <I MP  O 0 H0  ;N0<F F Q 551D0D002 4 5=?lAN0 0 0 FF G k0 kC02MKF25 0 W0 K 4V99 M L4< 0CU220 2590 O<U220 V 0 J 9 >J 9 0FA<=YA Ai=RFA<L0 F<D> 0=PL?CQD<TD0 RA0 S?l L<00 <QA <LCB L0 0 DD<lDB 0 0 EL D m,n on0+n   q0 0o0p0r8 qrm+0  on0+n  q0 ,-popa  EO;;G PCD?Y st; 0  I 1VT 3 V 0 2 0I 0 0 0 >?F G Y0 0 0 0U5QV 4V  T0 = 0 0 p, o,0+-,r+ xyz v+ n qrm,0+qwpn {+r{r p,on 8n 0|  N N ;0  0 O 08o+pw ,} ,p,q   ;0  0 ;;\N0  \0 O @t \ I p},qz|rm +-p0r+ 0| 0 @t \ O O 0 O G0 pqr, xr+0}p}      0 IN FA00 08o+pw  r,pw 8r+ \ ; 0@u  0 \O 00ASl0 0 p rqn ,p0n 0 r, CR 0  P 0 0F LSM1G  p0n D0  O MLlM1\ 0M 0 0 0 0 N<<RD=0 YDCFI 0  O O N ;0 G  ;0 O 00   00 LD<QC[CF 00 SFA>? DG 0 TI 0 = 0 EO ;;\ OE 0 0 O0  0 0 0  N u0 st;  E0 ;; EN 0  O 0 G  k    G I  0 0 0 LD<V<0RD=00 0 SFARYDCFI < 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0  !#   (*   "$% &'))   + #& / " .*) ,- 0 14*.6782345 .6)4 2345 .7 94* :)4  4   4  0 0    0  0 0 1 0 [SFDL=BZ?0M=DZ<GF< RA>EL=D0?CQ0 <Q0~E K?0F0 ? > <S>0 F F?0 = A M0<<C0 S?l DD<lDBJ GD? C M 0 0 = 2 QiQF0=L=ACL0L0 < RA> FD> All0 =QC?DJ D?0 <K?0?D00 CC? C0 D<TFAYAF 0<<C0 ? C0 FC<=L?F 0~CD<CG=Y>lC B M CL L L 0 ? 3 ]?FFSC?D=l<0BF<iA?=CA<D0 C0E M=CYRA>FFFA0?M0 0 FA<< LD0? >F 0?DRh0 0CF 0l<?lF F 0C00<<C0CSLBAlFL?<TD0 =i L M < M = FD 4 ?0?0 FA S=CFL RA> >0Y T> AQRA04CJK0 0QLRD<Z?0 >04Q€0 DF=[CF0 ASD00<<C0 <L0 ?PL<S<2JK1I CQACQ0 FS<2JK= M <i F S ? 0 0D M 5 <SA[<FFC00 F 0L?FA<<~<CQ[iD<0BCi<RD0MF=F0S0M0>? L0 L 6 AH?< D0MFC[L?DF0D<TD0h0QL C?Rh00>C?lFC0<=LFF<QC[0A <<=0L0 ?M?FA<F 0==SMG E =h FF?0 = AF0<iD0=Y> 0LF< L 0 = L 7 RYD<YAZMQ0D<TD?D?0LlF 0S[?0M=DZ<0LA=LRC0L>Z=F0M0 [iCD0> 0BPCD?0 B? F0 0 Y< Y l 8 L >?F?Rh0>?FY >M=;;U 9 1‚ 0R F0 C0>?FYQC[=C0 FA=0 0 <h<F AiAB0S0F<Z?< I E C[? F F CD?0>? 0D?<<FDF 0S]Q0 L<FG F MA =0 =M P Y D ?M P hL 1 RD<0<C>lFD0 F?0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI0 <?=F 0> C? =Z? DPAlCM1L0<L >?F0 M < L M F 0 1 1 2‚ 0R F0C00 SF<=N<RuiD>0 =AQA<0Di< <060 40 I E C[? F F OA=<€0 <0 L0C<ZC0 LRRL0<F[hA G 1G =M C < 22 1 2 M < C D L2 0 S 1 ?0<AQA=L0 CLDB0 TRG==A[<F I 496 950 CD<C0 AMA 3 DF 0<LR0Y>A0 SFG CC0 0 FS D0 0 1 2V 11I D?0 <Y F<0 = ;;0 0 1 C[?0MFF<OA=<€0 <0 L0C<=C<0MF>=?j0 <?G JsG=C<FYA 4 R FFC0M0 SF<=N<RuiD>0FF=FC0 <=0 sLDl0 ~ KC0lD0L0 = L J = 0 1 OM0C>0FMR=CQ0 DL DS ZDA0 =QC?D0DI~ < >0 K~ADƒ„ 5 < > C0 L<0 DMLR[??[0 <==L?F G Q0 OM0C>EGlCF=0 1 CRQD<ƒ„hF FLF ACF0WA=<0A? >RFU >M=;;0AD<KC>F0?MG 6 D0LTB=GS0 MS0 ADB<i<=RL0 ? 0 0 B? F0 J CF<0>? AlF 0 Z? ZC [i< L  l 0= 0 1 F>0D0D<<F?0M0AiAB>l>0<Q?<0FP   0 7 ?<CR?FA=0DF<iL<F0<C> R=AhRC0 E 0P  N0 u  F B N0 O0 1 290 2…0E LMA =0<?=F<C>lFD0 F?0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI0 8 6@;N01 0 0F<Z?<RD<0 0> C? =Z? DPAlCM2L0<L >?F0 M < L M F 0 1 9 3‚ 00 FLF DZ>R<L0 YA FD=Y??D0 0L[00<?YC0 0 <FSM I E ?Z? S0 L <l0A? L[C? 0SYQ<FLYA Ch> 0=F F 0 F0 = M  D L F < LM A 2 F < L M F 0 2 L0<C>lFDZ??0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI0 1 YM0> C? 0 FDPAlCM3L0<L >?F0 4‚ 00 FLF DZ>R<L0 YA FD=Y??D0 0L[00<?YC0 0 <FSM I E ?Z? S0 L <l0A? L[C? 0SYQ<FLYA Ch> 0=F F 0 F0 = M  D L F < LM A 2 2 2 L0<C>lFDZ??0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI0 3 YM0> C? 0 FDPAlCM4L0<L >?F0 F < L M F 0 2 4 5‚ 0R F0 C0 ?0 SF C0 A=?FDL<0<?=<0C=R?0?0Q?DCR I E C[? F FM=LA0 =] ?RQ? 0TAF 0 S=A?<0 F=CF 0D0 =M F M S L M= DM L 2 FC0<S0AiAB>=?0?0 SF 5 MF D<iL<>0<0 F=LAI T ? DM 0 2 6 6‚ 0<?=F<C>lFD0 F?0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI0 I E RD<0 0> C? =Z? DPAlCM6L0<L >?F0 M < L M F 0 2 7 2 8 2 0 0 0 0  !#   (*   "$% &'))   + #& / " .*) ,- 0 14*.6782345 .6)4 2345 .7 94* :)4  4   4  0 0    0  0 0 1 0 7‚ 00 FLF DZ>R<L0 YA FD=Y??D0 0L[00<?YC0 0 <FSM I E ?Z? S0 L <l0A? L[C? 0SYQ<FLYA Ch> 0=F F 0 F0 = M  D L F < LM A 2 L0M0>lFDQD<DD0 BPCD?YD[<0 <A<L0 AI=CRYDCF?0M=CFD0 YF<C> C? 0LQA?lZM0>?F 0C R>C0 QDLi0 00<<RD0DF?0Q? G < L Y C L 3 hF E C[?0C000LD[<I0 S0 0R FF FF==0C R0 =M ?? 0 4 8‚ 0R F0 C0 0 ZC0F D0LD0 <hDYQCBL00<RL0SF D I E C[? F F G =C0 <i?FM0<<??A0YCR<0YF =0 0 =M  ;;0 L F AL 5 M0S]Q0AiABAQA<0D2 I0E ?0 F S0DZ>R<L0DL[C? 0SYQ<FF0 M L 6 F<h<FPL<F0<LRR?0 30 0=Z?LFL <l0A?YA FD=Y??D0L L[00<?0 0 F 0 F0YM0 ??lC> C? =Z? DPAlCM8L0<L >?F <C LM A F < < L M F 0 7 YA Ch>Y=F0<FSML0<A[CDD0>lFD0 F?0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI 9‚ 0R F0MF D?0 <M=C0D<<F?0M0S]Q0AiAB0E ?0 I E C[? FC0CD<C0C0D?FA=0DF<h<FPL<FI 0= = 8 9 Z?LFL <l0A?YA FD=Y??D0LYA Ch>YC0LF<FSML0M0< ??l F S0DZ>R<L0DL[C? 0SYQ<FF0L[00<?0=F0M0AF0YF<A[CDD0 M L < 1 C>lFD0 F?0CCAi00YM0 [iCDI > C? =Z? DPAlCM9L0<L >?F < L M F 0 1 1 1I PAlCM 10 YF<L >?F=C<0<C0LQS?D0MFR0 L0<SA00 ‚ CCAi0 L0M0 [iCD0FF=>l>QD>=L=FC0 L DFAH?<C 1 2 0 M C< =< R 0 1 A=L=IOLF<<FD00=L=00H?<G<?R0 3 <iD<0 0 0W<F A iD<?A SAR0 D<I0 8n 0 x +wn + qwpn 0 8r+ 8 1 4 1I 0iC=?0=L==F0CCAi=110=?0 >0FFRMA?I 1‚ E A <F0=A iD<0 PAlCM0V C0 Y >=C<0<<D0 < F< L YSB 1 5 1I PAlCM10YF<L >?FQD?F0YPCD?Y=QC[=FC0LDFAH?<C 2‚ CCAi02L0M0 [iCD0L===L0>?F €0>? 0MFR0L0<SA00 Y 1 6 1 A=L=IOLF<<FD00=L=00H?<G<?R0 7 <iD<0 0 0W<F A iD<?A SAR0 D<I0 0 M C< =< R 0 1 8 1I PAlCM10YF<L >?FQD?F0YPCD?Y=QC[=FC0LDFAH?<C 3‚ CCAi03L0M0 [iCD0L===L0>?F €0>? 0MFR0L0<SA00 Y 1 A=L=IOLF<<FD00=L=00H?<G<?R0 9 <iD<0 0 0W<F A iD<?A SAR0 D<I0 0 M C< =< R 0 2  qr,o x +wn qwpn 8r+ 8 2 1 1I 0iC=?0=L==F0CCAi=110=?0 >0FFRMA?I 4‚ E A <F0=A iD<0 PAlCM0V3C0 Y >=C<0<<D0 < F< L 0 YSB 2 2 1I PAlCM10YF<L >?FQD?F0YPCD?Y=QC[=FC0LDFAH?<C 5‚ CCAi05L0M0 [iCD0L===L0>?F €0>? 0MFR0L0<SA00 Y 2 3 0 M C< =< R 0 2 A=L=IOLF<<FD00=L=00H?<G<?R0 4 <iD<0 0 0W<F A iD<?A SAR0 D<I0 2 5 1I PAlCM10YF<L >?FQD?F0YPCD?Y=QC[=FC0LDFAH?<C 6‚ CCAi06L0M0 [iCD0L===L0>?F €0>? 0MFR0L0<SA00 Y 2 A=L=IOLF<<FD00=L=00H?<G<?R0 6 <iD<0 0 0W<F A iD<?A SAR0 D<I0 0 M C< =< R 0 2 7 2 8 3 0 0 0 0  !#   (*   "$% &'))   + #& / " .*) ,- 0 14*.6782345 .6)4 2345 .7 94* :)4  4   4  0 0    0  0 0 10 p88n - +xp0n o8,   2 €0D<FC?DL0M=0>? 0=QD?SDI0 0M=DZ<G 0 ?<0L E =?T=? F 0YF<<QC[=?0LF ?l0@BF?0 = A E ZCT=D0 lL D 0 3 CYA F<RYD<0D0<<T=?0?M0L C D0M0 = AF0D<FCB =h<SD>0 Y?[C? 0 <<==CR A=A<0F AlFF0[<R F<DZ<0L ?=A0D0S=H<F T = B 4 R=L<<0Y?[C?<RYD<I ?QTARCYA F 0<<==0 T 5 8n 0 +xp0n o8, + p88n -  6 OM0 [iCD0C>0L=C<CQC[0L0 ?MA>YQDh0AD<0<C=G[LlLMA <L >?FY? F0FF00>? YAZMQ0<?0C0<lCFRhQS<0 D0F<0 = < C 7 <=DG CD?€0>? L0A<CRQ<AF>F F 0AiAB?hA<0B10 I 41JK3G P Y ?<L M = † 0 8 ACL=0>?FY=QC[0YY<0D0>C0F0 0 <PL<F00CARh02uII 0067]JK ?Mi<>R=C0 =>0A[0W? S=?l D?0 <=?FA=0DF<PL<F0D0 D 9 ZMQ0AQS<0DE0C<YL <Fl?MD0 CD<C€0D<<F?0M0 AiABCR 1 i<[i=CB=C<>Z00<QDAAI A< F0D0FF0 FF 0LFCB0 C LM 1 1  qr,o +xp0n o8, p88n -  1 2 PCD?Y=QC[=C<hA<0BF<RQAD=L0Q<G=Li>ZCTAS]=0D?M DG >?F €0>? 0A0CARh0 0LF?<0Y> M=0 Fi<G ?<GDSF AQ[<F Y M C < 0 0 < 0 1 3 S 1 CRL0D>C0CRI 4 D‡A Q<DMD=0 0|n p88n - +o +xp0n o8,  1 5 OM0C l=0YCB0MFZ<<C>lRB==CDRh0>?FYC00<SFL0M0Q= <R[C<G?0DGFC0 A0> <>0SF?<0BPCD?0=CA=> YF<CF0 < Y 0 1 6 1 R=AhR?0M0 [iCD0 A0C=R?0 L<L0 A0LF?S<0L?0CFh0<=DL0M0 7 <Q?<0DF<L >?FZ<<QS<0DZM>0AZ<<QDAhFRF0DiA0BACL0YF< 1 CFGL =?DGDl?<QGCRL0D<FD>[?QDSFL0>?FYCRQSFARYDCFOM0 8 Q=0[?=L=0<> D<0D‡A?FD? C0 =LRQ0YPCD?0D0LD<V<<RD0 < l L Y 1 >0 0 9 C>EI = 2 8rm+0| +xp0n o8, p88n -  2 1 OM0C l=0YCB0MFZ<<C>lRB==CDRh0>?FYC00<SFL0M0Q= <R[C<G?0DGFC0 A0> <>0SF?<0BPCD?0=CA=> YF<CF0 < Y 0 2 2 2 R=AhR?0M0 [iCD0 A0C=R?0 L<L0 A0LF?S<0L?0CFh0<=DL0M0 3 <Q?<0DF<L >?FZ<<QS<0DZM>0AZ<<QDAhFRF0DiA0BACL0YF< L D l C D L [? L M < 2 CFG [?=L=0<><QGD‡A?FD?D> =LRQ0YL<L0 A0 ?RiA?=L<0 L 4 Q=0 =?DG l? D<0 RL0 <F C0 QDSF 0D0A[L<FA0CF 0TAZM[0 2 D?<0E DA CD<C0C0LFLI 5 <F A 0L0 D?0 <MRQDA> M 0 2 6 8n p88n - 80| +xp0n o8,  2 7 PCD?YM=C0RHC<A[<BC0C CRM=0MLl0F0ZDCF0D‡AL =?DG >?F 0C0DC<SF0< R0F>Z0D0CGFASM? L 0Q=CRL0[?=L=0 Y = 2 Y?RF0 FC<?0C l=0<<?FD<L0 4MC<RD<I 8 C> 0 [?lF0=R[C<GM0W=<Q0Y ? 0A0<?R0 0 F ZMQ 0< L ? F 0 0  !#   (*   "$% &'))   + #& / " .*) ,- 0 14*.6782345 .6)4 2345 .7 94* :)4  4   4  0 0    0  0 0 10 ˆ0| +xp0n o8, n p88n -  2 PCD?YM=Y?RF0>C0D0>lRCF0AL =?D0Y D?0 <=Y??D0L >?F 0C0C> 0Li<RCBC> <0Q=L0[?=L=L0CD<C0SYQ<FF0 Y < < 3 ZCAD0<QD?<C?DL0<<CGW<FFD0L=H<F>L0L <=FA0C l=0 ACFM0L=RAF 0Y DA><iQC? G D<SD?GA [iDCLBR[C<I0 F L l 0 LQ C0 Q 0 4  -,0| +xp0n o8, p88n -  5 PCD?Y=DFD?<00H?h<A>Y >?F 00L0 F>RF<SF >0 ?I Y? < F L C <<0 6 n p88n - }|0| +xp0n o8,  7 PCD?YC>RF0?0D0A A0R=<=h<iA?=0 >?F 0? 0 ]DL<L0 <? ?iDC>0CF I YY < LL [L D < 8 ,n p88n - ,0| +xp0n o8,  9 1 D?0 <h<Q<0LRF0 F0lA00>?FY CD<C0ACMRD0SBZ? A CRFPCD?I M < L Y0 1 1 0,0| +xp0n o8, p88n -  1 2 0QALC<0BAYAD<FL<RYD<0D[<C<00 >=8CR10YM0 TR0 E ? LiAF=h0 <<Q0 =0<<==<S AFR?S<00D02L0< <CC D < M D F 1 S<0Y??PL<S<C0YY>0<0LF0<<D00M0TD0SF<0D<FC?DATC=F< 3 >=L0 T> AQRA0=?0S> =FYAMMA?I DF<<<FYAMA?T=? F 0<<>0M0 0 B 0 lL 1 4 Q ? 1 Ci?C?F0YCB=Q0<<==0E A=A<0M0?M0L=<0<T0YQSFF0[<RF?0 5 i> h>BL0D0SMRYD<G 0<<T=F<AlFF0<>C<L0LA0LC D0M= F F 0 1 DZ<00=<FM0C I0 6 = ALC=A0<=[<0 qrm,0+qwpn  x 1 7 8n 0 + qrm,0+qwpn x 1 8 J QCCLBR[<F<==PCD?YD0 < >0 0 N<>AFA0Sl D0 AS0>?F 0 ROM0C>EK T YC = 1 9 1‚ 0 QALC<0BAYAD<F<A=L==L0>i<?S0CCAi=0=?0S>0 I E ? LiAF=h0<<<Q0 0<iD<0YC> ATL=iAlCMG 0 Y> D M 0 CY B 2 Y 2 =FLF0<<D0 1 <0 AMMA?I 2‚ PASD0L20 I†2 0D0 00 0M=LA0C0M0L ACR I S=CFF08uII 0021CR †4I1GF?0 SFM=F<iZ<0D0 2 2 BL ? D DM 0 2 CFL?00<>A0E CR D?0 <=AlF0D0FA==?0<PL<FI 3 SMAFFRQC< 0D0CD<C€0 M=CR?<<F0 F 0AiAB0 3‚ D?0 <=N<RL0 SF=CYAF<S<0FA=0DF<PL<FI I CD<C€0 <0Y =000 =0 QAR?<<F 0 0AiAB0 OA ? ? = D L M 0 2 4 4‚ OM0<<C0 S?l DD<lDBJ L0M0L=ACL0=C0lDB I < RA>EL=D0?CQ0 <Q0~E 0AF<~ D<TFAK?0DC<Q0 2 5 < 2 L0M0<<C0L<D D0YF<uDFRC<0Y[<?CCR?0>LF<L=ACL0L0CD< 6 YF<YRA>lTA[<FL0M0 ? 0FF=L0 AQ0D0=C=0M0 D<TFAYA D?0 2 CI 7 <0 0 2 8 5 0 0 0 0  !#   (*   "$% &'))   + #& / " .*) ,- 0 14*.6782345 .6)4 2345 .7 94* :)4  4   4  0 0    0  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 0 0 0 5‚ OM0 D<TFAM==Q<RRh0Z0 0>L0CD<C€0AlFG?<GL AG I <L=ACL0C0SQ<<0B> F C> Y D?0 <=~?M=0F=0 Z<=0 CL0 F> i CRi??l=02uII 0067hJKK?I D0AT> <I0 0 I 41JK2J JK < 1 † 0 6‚ NS?lF<L=ACL=?G~DLiL<F0YƒE 0M>h0S]Q0L>TG I AD0M0 D<TFAMi0ƒ„0AiABL0 „=C> <=h<FF0<B0 0 CFQ[<FlA?M DGYAQLS<0A=>0 FLFF<QD<FL0M0 „DA=C>CB F M DG CD=[<F L<>=AGL0C<Z? S0M0L=D0YF<ƒE G L0M> D0 C 0 0 M 0 0 ?T>DCB>DCFQ00<iL<F0Y „02uII 0067]JK0 DLSFA0<0F MFF 0AiABL0 E I0 0 I 41JK3I0 ? C LM ƒ 1 † 0 7‚ D?0 <==QAR?FA=0F?=<?0AiABL0M0 D<TFA0 <<L<0 I CD<C€0<S<0D<<FC0=S0=iL<F0YF<L=ACLIOMAYAG 0 CiBD0 0 CFA16L0F<0FF0C ?00 D<0MF<Fl?M= D?0 <=YAF i>?l Mi<010ALMA=C<>Z0DC[CDAFC0W? S=<0CD<C€0?=V D i=FDN<RL0 SF SRTLC<10 I067]JK L?L0 <0Y =0 >0?>F02uII 041JK3I ? OA ZL † 0 8‚ 10 I 067]JKi<[i=CB=C<>Z0MFZL>0<[?CYAQLS<L00 I 2uII 0 41JK30A< F0D0FF0C FC0 SRiA F0L<>=A0DC † 0 =iAAL?0?DF0W?l?MCYAF=QAR?FA=0Y D?0 <ZM>0F?0D<0E = S<i?AF > 0L<F S=00?=0<S<0D<<FL0CD<C0 ? ? =SRA €0 B< D <0 QD<TFAMi0 L=ACL=?I 9‚ PASD002uII 0067]JKOM0C>0 >0L>0L0W?l?M D?0 I S=CFL10 I 41JK3G < > E0C<QSRDF F S=0CD< F † 0 = <D C€0AF<S<0FA=I <=Y=0 QAR?<<F ?= D 0 1I 0D0CD<C0A0D?<0LCRQCC?DYL F?0 SFiASD0L20 ‚ E CR D?0 <C<<F>RF00<>AF 0A[0M=LAG S=CFF08 F L 0 uII 0021CR †4I1GFC0CD<C0=F<hDYQCBL00?=0L?L0 <0Y I†2 0D0 00 0MF D?0 <?0M0<<??A0YCYAFi=FDN<RL0 ? OA=0 ?M=?0DS <=F<PL<F0Y<0<E0C<0 SF Q0F> Q[hA0 0AiABCFAM0 >I ZM >< M F 1I 0D0CD<C0A0D?<000<<[?C?DYL F?0 SFiASD008 1‚ E CR D?0 <C<<F>RFCRFA DF 0 [0 =LAGS=CFL20 F L LA M 0 F uII 0021CR †4I1GMF 2uII 0067]JKi<>R=OM0C>0 >0A[0 I 2 0D0 00 0 C0 0 I 41JK30AQS<0 < > E0C<YL † F 1 † = <Fl?MD0CD<C€0AF<S<0FA=I W? S=?l D?0 <=Y=0 QAR?<<F D ?= D 0  qr,o qrm,0+qwpn x J ?F F0<==PCD?Y0 ‰S<0 >TAS0>?F K O?< Y 1‚ 0 QALC<0BAYAD<F<A=L==L0>i<?S0CCAi=0=?0S>0 I E ? LiAF=h0<<<Q0 0<iD<0YC> ATL=iAlCMG 0 Y> D M 0 CY B =FLF0<<D0 <0 AMMA?I Y 2‚ PASD0L20 I†2 0D0 00 0M=LA0C0M0L ACR I S=CFF08uII 0021CR †4I1GF?0 SFM=F<iZ<0D0 CFL?00=><F<PCD?Y=CTA<QC[=?0<PL<FI SMAFFA LT0 0>?F €0R<=0>? 0 F 0AiAB0 BL < M Y DM 0 3‚ D?0 <=N<RL0 SF=CYAF<S<0FA=0DF<PL<FI I CD<C€0 <0Y =000 =0 QAR?<<F 0 0AiAB0 OA ? ? = D L M 0 4‚ PCD?YQC[=C0 FA=0 0 <PL<F0 ASMCYAQLS<R<0 C00R<=0 I >?F 0>? 0D?<<FDF 0AiABF Ll00L<>=A0<RF F=CTA< Y D ?M M M? F0CD<C€0FA=I L D?0 <=?<<F D 0 6 0 0 0 0  !#   (*   "$% &'))   + #& / " .*) ,- 0 14*.6782345 .6)4 2345 .7 94* :)4  4   4  0 0    0  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 0 0 0 5‚ D?0 <=?FA=0 0 <N<RL0 SFDS <?lF<PL<F0L=?F=C0 I CD<C€0 <<FDF 0 <0YOA=0 Q[hAD0 0AiABQDFS<0D D ?M < M F ?FA=00C0AiAB0 D<<FDA > L<FI ?<i 6‚ D?0 <==QAR?FA=0F?=<?0AiABL0M0 D<TFA0 <<L<0 I CD<C€0<S<0D<<FC0=S0=iL<F0YF<L=ACLIOMAYAG 0 CiBD0 0 CFA16L0F<0FF0C ?00 D<0MF<Fl?M= D?0 <=YAF i>?l Mi<010ALMA=C<>Z0DC[CDAFC0W? S=<0CD<C€0?=V D i=FDN<RL0 SF SRTLC<10 I067]JK L?L0 <0Y =0 >0?>F02uII 041JK3I ? OA ZL † 0 7‚ @C<0DF<CTA<QC[=h?lC=A<0BF<iA?=0E CR D?0 <C< I =RL0 0R<=0>? 0<D0=<FRh0 0CF G 0D0CD<C0A0 M M < <F>RF00 RQC0<<[?C?DAlA?lF<AlF0D0 FA==L0 <A=<F<iA?=F0 < D?<0 C] ??> FA DF 0<CRD0 0?M=CR?<<F0YF 0<iQ? 0CF 0 F 0 F L S R L M D M T < LM Q=I0 C<0 0 8‚ 0D0CD<C0A0D?<000<<[?C?DYL F?0 SFiASD008 I E CR D?0 <C<<F>RFCRFA DF 0 [0 =LAGS=CFL20 F L LA M 0 F uII 0021CR †4I1GFC0CD<C0=F<hDYQCBL00?=0L?L0 <0Y I†2 0D0 00 0MF D?0 <?0M0<<??A0YCYAFi=FDN<RL0 ? OA=0 ?M<Q[hA0<PL<F0Y<0<E0C<0 SF Q0DS <=F 0AiABCFAM0 >I ZM M F 9‚ 0D0CD<C0A0D?<000<<[?C?DYL F?0 SFiASD008 I E CR D?0 <C<<F>RFCRFA DF 0 [0 =LAGS=CFL20 F L LA M 0 F uII 0021CR †4I1GMF CD<C€0<S<0 FA=0BTAS0Y?0 <0YOA=0 I 2 0D0 00 0 C0 D?0 <==QAR?<<F 0?F<L0=N<RL0 SF † F D h F ?0S<?ALF<?FA=GYDGQSARh0>?FYMLl0<YAQLS<R<I ==iAL00 0 <<F?0 B0 H?<0BPCD?0ASMF 0 <>=A0<R0 F M D 0C C YF M L {+pz+ +wn 8r+ 8 kE  0E iC=YAM0 >Z?lA>Y0  G 0AB0 0<Y > D0 ?U L F L L << 1‚ OMF >?FY=AH<FL0]DF<A>Y <RD<\ I C0 CD?€0 S=0 ADSQ? 0 ?0 0<?R0 P Y < Y ? T << h 2‚ OMF >?FYC<0LMD0BZC0YF0 [iCD\ I C0 CD?0=DF?lh0 BL0=L >?F P YF ? 0 3‚ OMFF<LA0<>A0MF10 I†41JK30A< F0D0 TR0C FC0 I C0M0 SFRQC<FC02uII 0067]JKi<[i=CB <CC>Z0MF ZL>0<[?CYAQLS<L00S<i?AF0?DF0W?l?MCYAF=QAR?FA=0Y D?0 SRiA F 0L<>=A0DC=iAAL? > 0L<F S=00?=0<S<0D<<FL0CD< 0 B< D C0 ?000D<0E =QD<TFAMi0 <ZM>??SRA €0L=ACL=?\ <F= 4‚ OMFM0 SF<>A0C0 < >0 >0 >0?0L0W?l?M D?0 I C0<LA0 QC<F F 0C>E0C<E0C<RRDF F S=0CD< F R M OM = <D C€0AF<S<0FA=0D0S0?0L0LTBF<PL<F0<0D0>C00>?FY0 <=Y=0 QAR?<<F RF =RRDF D<0 0AiABY <CRQ<ALPCD?\ ?= D C M Q M A F Y 5‚ OMFM0 SF<>A0C0CD<C€0FA=00<S<0l?=0<PL<F0D0 I C0<LA0 QC<F F D?0 <=?<<F==QARCCDFM0AiABCR F R M D ? F FC0CD<C€0FA=00S<?ALF<?FA=0Y >?FY0 MF D?0 <=?<<F==iAL00 0 <<F 0 CD?\ D ? F M D LP Y 6‚ OMF E h0ZCRRACLC>0FA<=0<0D0LF\D0 I C0 0<C A<0 =Dh<CF DB€<=CRQ==0 R < L Y C ‡0 ‡ ‡ ‡0 ‡ ‡ 7 0 0 0 0  !#   (*   "$% &'))   + #& / " .*) ,- 0 14*.6782345 .6)4 2345 .7 94* :)4  4   4  0 0    0  0 0 1 0 7‚ OMF E AQ?<=Q0F<0>Y=F<LA0<[=]=0D0AiA0 I C0 0 <T0SMLMA<?0 0 0 SF < 0 F RiL<I < A <C M R S C 0 2 NO N0?0ŠŠ0C0YCSAG 50 F=ŠŠŠRBL0 DCB0 1I M  2 3 0 4  8,,xr+ }& q‹ q+pn   {‹  5 @B0‡‡ =?0 BDECF 0 0 0 U0 0 > @AC0 A0 0=;< < 0;<>0 BDECF =I 43K 0 =?@AC0 AG H0 @ 0920 0 < 0 J 6 0M0 0 D<F =I 1780 0LDNI DAG H0 @ 012K 0 O< 0 J 7 03 I<LRI?05 0 0 0 QD0F0SF110 0  G < 0<L0 TR09 0 0 DG CC851 0 < 8 0O<U7V8V280CU7V8V29 0 >7578220 W0 578220 0 0 0 7 0>CF QC Q[\FD<F QC Q[a 0MAXY>ZIL 0<DAXY>ZIL 0 ] 9 CR D0 1 p+,rwo {r+0+ Œ ww{ 1 1 J ?a d[CgF0<h FR ^_ Ca GaH00S F =`bcA d =`_d[?<K [0 _ef0Lh“ ` Ž c ’Ig a f ec ‘c _ 1 2 EL A0 0˜B<0_g` ZCR I gDG`H0 0 b` _ C‘c =Ida ”c•–c ’ “_ — 1 3 ?š<0`˜`‘c`“Hda QC› I M D_ I I  = 0 ™fMg š0LDLG g` dc> Ž˜ =’0 _0 œ 1 4 551D0D<F 2 4 5=2MAN0 0 0?lLG 0 FFF0 k0 1 5 kC0 K 4<5 0 W0 K 4V99 O<U220 2 0CU220 2590 >M 9 V 0 J 9 J 1 6 F=DB0YA Ai=R D<TDA <<C0 F ? = L L<0 L ELA<0?C0PL<Q FA<L0 RA> SDl DD<lDB 0 Q0 1 0 7 0 1 8 1 9 2 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 8 0 0 0 0

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?