Tracy Petrocelli v. Timothy Filson, et al.

Filing 218

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that P's 216 Motion for Leave to File Reply Brief Over Twenty Pages in Length is GRANTED. The Reply has already been filed, so no furth action is required by the Clerk. FURTH ORD that P's 203 Motion to Stay Proceedings and Hold Litigation in Abeyance is DENIED. FURTH ORD that P shall have 30 days from the date of entry of this order to file a notice of abandonment of unexhausted claims, abandoning claims in his 4th Amend Pet that have been held t o be unexhausted in state court. If P does not file the Notice w/in the time allowed, the 162 Fourth Amended Petition will be DISMISSED, in its entirety. FURTH ORD that if P files the Notice w/in the time allowed, Rs shall thereafter have 90 day s to file an answer, responding to the exhausted claims. FURTH ORD that, in all other respects, the schedule for further proceedings set forth in the 147 order shall remain in force. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 3/10/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - PM)

' '
:

'
. 1

4

F l PE Ig 'Et E D NC
-

c tsli- sc uox o si'i r a hh f
VAF 1 û 2 1 I û1
1

--- 26 IC OEV D s q g (N gvn )

2
3

tt Fk(S p s j g jr l f ' / l u çr gla j;gjNwA; s g : A 'E?IT JY

k
5 UM TED STA TES DISTRICT C OU RT

6
7

DI STRI OF N EV ADA CT

8 TRACY PETROCELLI , 9 Peii r ttone,

1 vs 0 .
l E. M C 1 K. DANI et . EL, al,

1 2
l 3
14

Reponde s s nt.

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
/

3:4-v-45 RCJVPC 9 c , 9- 0

ORDER

l5 l r ntoducton and Backzr i ound 1 6 Th sa ton i ape ii f wr t ba a co tsby Tr c Pe r eli a Ne da prs rund i c i ' tton or i of be s m u s a y toc l, va ione er

l s ntnc of ah.l i beor t c ur o Per el' M oto i S1yPr ce di sa HodLii ton 7 e e e de t t s f e he o t n toc lis in o o e ng nd l tgai

l i Abe nc ( ke#203 ,ie Ap i2i20l l t t i Perc li r st thi a tons ul 8 n ya e doc t )fld rl , 0.n ha moton, to elague ha t s ci ho d
TRACY PETROCELLI V. RON ANGELONE, ET AL. Doc. 218

i be sa d s t at m a r t m onc a a n t s a e c ur t e us hi une us e c a m s The c t 9 t ye o h be y e u e g i o t t o t o xha t s xha t d l i . our 20 w il e t e m oton wil e i ePe - c lit a ndo hi u xha t d c ai so f cedim is l bi l d ny h i , l r qu r n o e l o ba n s ne us e l m r a s s a of s 21 e ie p ii a wilmove t i c s t ' a d r s uton ofPe r e l' r m a ni c a m s on t i ntr etton, nd l h s a e ow r e ol i toc li s e i ng l i , be r
22 m- t . eris 23 l is J nua y 4, 1 n t a r 985 dt son o Pe r e l' diec a a ,t N e ada Sup e e Cou t ci i n toc lis r t ppe l he v rm r

24 de c i d, sf l , h fc soft eca easr ve ldbytl e de ea til s rbe a olows t e a t h s e ae fe vi nc t ra : 25
26

Tr c Pe r cei' j ur yt Re b ani ' a hi on wbe ebekild hi a y to lis o ne o no eg n W s ngt r le s fa e He fe W a hngt a a r nty d ovet Col udo i aCor te,o inc e. ld s i on nd ppa e l r o or n vqt t
Okl ho a i ava a t Re i a D a s whi h he s ol whieAt tdrv n ' he a m n n nd o no n tun c t e l tes l i g' t

Dockets.Justia.com

ve c e U po a rvi i Re Pe r ce l de i d henee e a f r whe d i t c hi l . n r i ng n no, to li c de d d ou - el rve ru k t ge a ot d i t s w . ne tda hi s a c f ra v hi l uli a e y 1 d t a o t r m n he no Tbe x y, s e r b o e c e tm t l e o I al e c rde e . de l r J m e W is a e d t Pe r ce l' r qu tf ra oc us d a alr The a e , a s lon, cc de o to li s e es o t dri ofa Vol w agen est ve ks pi ckup,and t t dr of wib t deal att he wo ove f t he er he Appr xi a e y f t tve m i t sl t r a Re pa r m a s w o pe s n d i n a o m t l ory-i nu e a e , no tol n a ne r o r vi g tu m atbi t de c i î n oft V W s e ng t d Pyr m i La r ck c ng he s rpto he pe di owar a d ke.

whe . a t130 p, ,aDodg de lrs w i m d ii g no t c Ki z eLa elAt bou ; m. e ae a he rv n rh m etk ne.
T'ateveni Petoceliw aspi h ng, r l cked up on t Pyr i H i ay and gi a he am d ghw ven rde t Sut if . e t d t drve t thi m ot c cl ha br n down. n Sut lf e i o clf e H ol he i r ha s or y e d oke l c if , Pe r ce l gota rde t Spa lswih a l al m e wa de Pe r elit n t k a c b t to li i o rt t oc ga r n. toc l he oo a o R e and appar l pai hi f e fom atwo-nc rol ofbil no enty d s ar r i h l ls. The ne day,t gam e war and hi parmerl xt he den s ooked f Petocelis or r l> m ot c e I t a t e f d t e V W tu wib bl odsai a bule hol son or ycl . ns e d, b y oun h r ck t o t ns nd l t e t pas he sengersde.Thecardeal ' body wasf i er s ound l ert da i a cr ce, at hat y n evi c ve e wih r ks s ge u h a s r bbe y. i ba k poc t we e t r d si bty o r d t oc , a br s nd h u r H s c ke s r u ne lg l i s de o an e pt bi wale wa m i sng. vi tm , n i ut d m y; s l t s s i The c i who us ly c r id l r ua l a re a ge a o sofc h w ih hi ,h d be n s tt r e tm e w ih a . c lbe w e pon. m unt as t m a e bo h e i s t 22 a i r a One s wa t t e ne a he s wa t t he . e t r s twa t t b c of hot s o h ck; not r hot s o he m n hid ho s o àe a k t he d f o a di t nc o t t t e i be . he a r m s a e f wo o hr e nc s

l t a ndon d t u k,22 c lbe b l tc s ngswe e f nd.W he be wa n he ba e r c . a i r ule a i r ou n s ar es ed,Petoceliw ascar yi a . calbers i ut atcpit w hi he t tt r t r l r ng 22 i em -a om i sol ch es iied heal ayscar i l w r ed oaded and r eady t fr Balitcst s on t casi f o ie. lsi est be ngs'ound i t n he

a nd d VW r ve ld t tt y h d be n frd fom Pe r et' pitl Te t o t ba one e ae ha he a e ie r toc lis so . ss n he
'

buletf m d i W is schestand a t tbuletfr &om Petoccl's pi olalo l ot n lon' es l ed r h ' st s r ve l s m ia m a ki s. e a ed i l r r ng ' Att i l Pe r e l p ovi d hi own a c mtoft kilng. fe drvi of r a , toc li r de s c ot he li A tr i ng f t e ca l ,t c rd al rsoppe atagassaton a fle t t u k.Fr t h r ot he a c r t d t i nd ild he r c om he s a i Pe r e l d ove t t uc H e a W is n pr c de t a gue a tt prc t ton, toc li r he r k. nd l o o ee d o r bou be i e oft e tu k.Peto elil d $ 50 00 on t da hb d a of e e a t m lo h rc r c l ai 3, 0. he s oar nd f r d o f $ 0 00 ca h. c rde l rwasi ule a c le hi a t t ' La e ,o t 5, 00. s The a a e ns t d nd a l d m ç k. t r n he pur ' wa b ck W is t c gr bbe f t e s e rng whe l Pe r e l t n pule outhi y a , lon wi e a d or b t e i e . toc li he ld s pit a s d: Y o who i t pu 'Thevi tm l ug d a s d h had a gu sol nd ai t w s he nk. ' c i a be nd ai e n al albougb Petocelineversaw one.The cardtal t ed t t t pit fom so, t r l er ri o ake he s ol r Pe r c l a h co i d t d i A st y sr l d, he gun w e of wo O t e t o eli s e ntnue o rve. he tugg e t nt ft r hr e

tme . toc lietfe ; 1 kne iwa s otng,a lwa j ttyn t puli i s Per eltsiid t w t s ho i nd s us r ig o l t 1 a y.r hi . l wa a a cde .twa a a i n. di tdoa hn I us wa fom m.. t s n c i ntl s n ccde tl dn' nytig. j t . ( ct !teewa s onehur,s i ti c r'Thee he Per liwe tt a do or h r s ome t hotn ie a. ra r tocel n o '

ti t keep hi f om geti t gun.'Petocelidr t a nea by doct ' ofi red o m r tng he ' r l ove o r or s l ce, we up t t e door butdi notgo i be a ehe tdi n' kno ho t t l hi nt o h , d n c us e d t w w o el m bowlng aley and caled t hos t ,buttdil ' know w hatt s ' He t n r ur i l l he pial ' cn t o ay.' he et ned t t t u k, r e t Pyr m i La e a d hi t c rde e ' bo un s m e r c . o he r c d ov o a d k n d he a al r s dy der o o ks Pe r elib a wal n a t rhi t u k bog d do n, t n r ur ed t t e ve cl toc l eg n ki g fe s r c ge w but he et n o h hi e t r ti vc hi g ove a t gu H e a s pi ke up t c dea e ' w a l t t k hi o c re s l s nd be n. l o c d he ar l r s le , oo s m o y,t e t busne sa c e tc r s i o ( w i d,a di c r d t wale . ne hr w he i s nd r di a d nt he n nd s a de he l t Petoc l t n wa ke t t hi hw a w he c h obt i d rde ba k t Re r eli he l d o he g y r e a ne i s c o no.

1
2

us ofa dç dl we po n e s n e e f t m ur rc vi ton w a s ta de t e a y a n. e t nc or he de on c i s e t a h.

Pe elwa co ce b aj yoffrtd gremude a r r wibt loc ls s nvitd y ur is e e r r nd obbey t he

3 Per celv. at . Ne 46, 49, P. 5 5 0 (985) to li St e,1 01 v. 48- 692 2d 03, 05-6 1 .
4 O n Se e be 8, 982, he ti lc ti pos d t e s n e ceofd a h on t e m ur rc c i pt m r 1 t ra our m e h e t n et h de onvi ton, 5 a a s nt nceofi ion e f 1 ye r on t e r be y c vi ton, usa a tona 1 ye r i nd e e mpr s m nt or 5 a s h ob r on c i pl n ddii l 5 a s n 6 p i on f t us ofa de dl we pon. Exbi t5. r s or he e a y a bi '

7

Pe ela ald.Se Ex biZ ( nngbrel Ex biAA (ns ln bre) Exhi tBB koc li ppe e e hi t ope i it; hi t a wei g it; bi

8 (e ybre) n eNe daSuprmeCou tafr donJ nuay4,1 5.Per c lv St e,1 1Nev. rpl if. va e r fime a r 98 to eli . at 0 9 46, 2P. 50 ( 98 . e aloExli t9,ExhbtFF. 69 2d' 3 1 5)s e s lbi , ii
1 0 OnAu s l 1 5, toc lfldape ii or tc ctonr i i t tt src c ur. gu t 2, 98 Pe r eli ie ttonf pos-onvi i el n hesaediti t o t ef
1l Ex b l H . On M a c 20, 1 85, t s a e di ti t co r he d a e de i y be rng. Exhi t Y ài i rb 9 he t t src u t l n vs ntar a i bi

1 (r ns rpt. On De e r31 1 6,t saedititc t nid t petton.Exbi t1 Pe r el 2 ta c i ) c mbe , 98 he tt src our de e he ii bi . toc li

1 a ae Exhi tJ (pe ngbre Exbi tKK (ns rngbre Exhi tLL (e ybre).The 3 ppe ld. bi J o ni ig; bi a wei ig; bi rpl it
1 N e da Supr m e Coun d s i s d t a ea o J 23,1 4 va e i m s e he pp l n une 988. Ex bi N N . bi t 2 1 5 O n A u t2 1 8, to elitl d ape ii f rwrtofha a c us i t sc t i ii tng gus 4, 98 Pe r c l i e tton o i be s om n hi our , n ta i

l t c s of Pe r e l v Whily,CV - - 6 he a e toc li . te N 88 0446 l D M . Exhi t 1 Couns l wa a nt d t -' I 3 bi 6. e s ppoi e o

l r pr s n Per cel.Se Ex bis2a 5t Re pond nt'Fe ua y7,1 97Fii ; OnM a :1 1 89, 7 e e e t to li e hi t nd o s e s br r 9 lng. y5, 9
l 8
1 9

1 U nl s ot r s n e t e i t i e ii d by nu be s i t sor rw e e Gl d b e s he wi e otd, be xh bis d ntfe m r n hi de r e y 20 Petoc l a a e l c e i t e r or a d ke /1 3 t o h #1 9. U nl s ot m i e no e t r eli nd r o at d n h ec d t oc t / 6 hr ug 6 e s he s t d, he e bis i ntte by I te s i t s or rw e e f l by r s xbi t de i d i e t r n hi de r ied e ponde s a a e I t d i t r o d a nt nd r oca e n he ec r t 2 I doc t 6,a doc t#70 t r gb /7 ke #3 nd ke h ou / 6. 2 2 23 2The c tr f r t t ss a e c tpr c e ng a Pe r e l' çfr ts a e ha a a ton. our e e s o hi t t - our o e di s toc lis lis t t be s c i ' ' 3 Thec t r us isol rs t m of enum b r t i ntf Pe r e l' Gr t ' r l be s our he e es t de ys e Gi e s o de iy toc lis s f de a ha a e a i U s ng t c r ' c r e fl n be s t m ,t tc s woul be i ntf e a Pe l e l v. cton. i he ou t s u r nt ie um r ys e ha a e d de ii d s toc li 24 W hlly, 3: cv 0446 H DM . .e t 88- 25 l t s acton on Febr y 7, 1997,r pondent fl a docum ententted:iResponse t n hi i uar es s ied il q o Pe ii e ' Ex a a i , W hy G r s 2 27, 6 a 9 Shoul N o Be Ba r d A sAn Abus oft e tton r s pl n ton ound 6, 28, nd d t re e h :t W rt ( ke / (, s è; , i, doc t / (Reponde s Fe r ay 7,1 Fiig,) Ata he t t tdoc ntée 1l 55) nt, b u r 997 ln ,. tc d o ha ume r e bis w hi h a eco e ofdoc xhi t , c r pi s umen sfl d i Pe r e l ! I hily,CV - - t ie n t oc li ) q te .s N 88 0446 H DM . -

î

1 upon a m o i by Pe r e l t c r or r d hi fr tf de a ha a a ton,c s numbe CV- ton toc li he ou t de e s is e r l be s c i a e r N 88-

2 0 11M , s se wihou prj c t alw hm t rttnt frhe e ha thi cli si sae 446-17 dimisd t t eudie,o lo i o et o ut r x us s ank n tt r
3 c r . Se Exhi t 6, 8, 1 a l1t Re pon nt Fe u r 7,1 Fii ou t e bis 7, 9, 0, nd o s de s' br a y 997 lng. 4 On M a c 1 1 9, t o elif l d ape ii n f wrtofba asc usi s a e dit i tc t r h 0, 98 Pe r c l ie tto or i be om n t t s rc our.

5 Exhi tPP.n est e diti coun di m i ed t petton onJanuar 22,l992.Exbi ttr Pet oceli bi at s rct s ss hat ii y bi u. r l

6 a pe ld.Se Exhii W W ( ni bi l Exli tXX (ns i breg;Exhi tYY (e yb it. p ae e bt ope ng ref; lbi a werng i bi rpl re)
7 The Nev da Su e e Cour dim i s d tl a e on D e e be 22,1 3. Ex bi ZZ. a pr m t s s e le pp al cm r 99 bi t 5 8 Pe e l t n i ta e t s hi s c koc li he nii t d hi, s e ond, e r l be c r ac i ,o J l l 1 f de a ha as o pus ton n u y 3, 994.He fl d it

9 t orgi ha a pe ii i t a ton o Ocobe 2 1 4 ( ck t#4) Couns lwasa poi e f r he i nal be s tton n be ci n t r 8, 99 do e . e p ntd o 1 Per el ( ke #7, #24 .OnFe u r 9,1 6, to lifl d afrtame de ha a peii 0 toc li doc t #8, ) br a y 99 Per cel ie is n d be s tton

11 ( ke #28 . doc t )
12 Res pondent t fl a m oton t di s ar ng t cert n cl m s i t Gr a ended s hen ied i o smi s, gui hat ai ai n he st m

1 peiinweeune ause pr e urlyb re a c tt e a a eofbewrt( c t#3 .n e 3 tto r xh td, oc d al ard, nd onsiutd n bus t i do ke 6)
1 co t a e t a m oto o a eoft w rt o 4 ur gr nt d h t i n n bus he i gr unds a di m i s d tvecl i sfom t fr t m e d , nd s s e i a m r he ts a nde

1 peiin( ck t/46, 6) 5 tto do e / #5 .
1 6 I a or r e e e Se em be 30 J 97,t s co r de e t e fr ta e d ha a pe ii n n de nt r d pt r , 9 hi u t ni d h is m nde be s ttonz l r i t tce t i c ai s i i we e a a us of t wrt a d t tc r a n c a m s we e pr c dur ly 7 ulng ha ra n l m n t r n b e he i n ha e t i l i r o e al

1 de a td,a de ngt r maide o t cli ont i me is( ket ) J 8 f ule nd nyi he e n r f he ams her rt doc #78 . udgme wa e t rd nt s n e e

1 ( ke #79 . 9 doc t ) 20 Per el a ld ( oc t/80 .l apu ibe o ni tl don M a ch 8, toc li ppiae d ke / ) n bls d pi on ie r 2001,hec r of t ou t
21 a asa fr d i pa tr vere i pa t a r ma e Per cel v Angeone, F.d 8 ( h ppe l fime n r, e s d n r, nd e nd d. to li . l 248 3 77 9t 22 Ci. 1 ( py i t c r a do ke #88) Thec r ofa pe sa tnne t diti c ur' d ni lon r200 ) co n e o d t c t . ou t p al fi d he srct o ts t a,
23 t m e is ofce t i ofPe r c l' c a m s t co t e r ed t dit i tc tsde e m i tonst t he rt , ra n toc lis l i ; he ur r ve s he sr c our ' t r na i ha 2 c rai cl i swe e a a us oft w rta t tc rai cl m swer pr e r l dcf td. I n e 4 e t n am r n b e he i nd ha e t n ai e oc du aly aul e d.
25 cour ofappeal r anded f f t pr t s em or urher oceedi ngs. l d.

26 5 The c r f r t t ss a e c r p oc edi g a Pe r e l' % e ond sa e ha a a ton. oun e e s o hi t t - ou t r e n s toc lis ' c s t t bc s c i ' '
4

1

Aferr vi t r and t dihictcourthear fom t pari r di tl st soft t ecei ng he em he s d r be tes egar ng ie am be

2 rma dcams wihrs ctot e a tono t ecli i sat c z (e doc t z,/3, , e nde li , t epe l be xh usi fhos ams n t e outs e ke#g /9 #94

3 #9 #98,/99,#1 ) l a or re ee Fe uay7,20 ( c t/1 0) t c trldt tt 7, / 01 . n n de ntrd br r 03 do ke /0 ,he our ue ha be
4 r a em nded cl m sw er çr xed,'m eani t s eoft m had been exhaus ed i sat court som e ai e çni ' ng hat om he t nte and 5 had not The court e ended t Petoceli t opport t t am end hi petton t r ove t . xt o r l he uniy o s ii o em he

6 une ha t d c a m s a t n, i a s a oft i c s t r t n t s a e c ur t e us t s c ai s x us e l i , nd he durng t y l s a e, o e ur o t t o t o xba t ho e l m . l

7 Per elt ntldas c da nde p ii ( c /l ,ndte t c rctypogrphia er s toc lihe ie e on me d etton do ket/o4)a h n,o ore t a c l ror, 8 at ida nde peii ( ke /1 , pore yi c udi i i o ycamse ha tdi saec t br me d tton doc t/ 08)pur tdl n l ng n t nl li x use n t t our.
9 On M ay28, 3, hec r or e e t sa to s a dpe ng Pe c l' e ba ton o c a m si s a e 200 t ou t d r d hi c i n t ye ndi ko elis x usi f l i n t t

1 c ur ( c #1 ) 0 o t do ket 09 .
ll On Augus 11 2003, îo e l fi d ape ii nf wrt ha a co pusi t sa editi t our . t , Pe c li ie tto or iof be s r n he t t sr c c t 1 Ex bi 26.Peto lil t rtl d a s e e t t t tton.Exh bi 32. n e sa edi ti tc ur he d 2 hi t r ce l a e ie uppl m nt o ha pe ii it t t s rc o t l

1 e de ir he rngs Exhi t 29 30, (r ns lpt) Th p ii nwa dimis byt saeditit 3 vi nta y a i . bis , 31 ta ci s . e etto s s s ed he t t src

1 c r o Aprl1 20 Exhi t36.Per ela pe ld.SeeEx bi38( ni bre Ex bi39 4 ou t n i 4, 06. bi toc li p ae hi t ope ng ig; bi t 1 ( s lngbre Exbbi 40 (e ybre TheNe daSu e Cou ta r donJ y 26 2007. 5 an wei ig; i t rpl ig. va prme r m me ul ,
1 Ex bi 4 l6 6 hi t .

1 7

OnNove r1 ,20 ujonamotonbyPeto lit sa oft sa tonwa lfe ( c t mbe 6 07, i rcel,he ty hi ci s itd do ke

1 #1 ) OnJ nu r l1 2 Percel fldhi f t a nde p ttonf wrtofha a c pus 8 47 . a ay , 009, to li ie s ourh me d eii or i be s or
1 ( ke #1 . The f urh a n d petton i l s31cli f ha asc 9 doc t 62) o t me de ii ncude ams or be omusr le ,i l ng e if ncudi
20 s ve al ih s a t . e r w t ubp r s 21 On M ay 26,2009,r pondent fl a m oton t di i ,as rtng t ceMan ofPetoceli s es s ied i o sm ss se i hat i r l'

2 camsha ara be naj c td'ha c rai ofPerc l' cai aeu ha tdi saec t 2 li ve te dy e dudiae , t e t n t to elis l ms r nex use n tt our' ,
23 a t tc r a n ofPe r e l' c a m sa epr qd a l ba r d. O n M a c 23 201 t c t a t d nd ha e t i toc lis l i r oc ur ly r e r h , 0, hc our gr n e

24 t moto t dimisi pat ndde e ii patdoc t 0) Thec 'de e t moi t dimis he in o s s n ra nid tn r( ke #20 . our nid be ton o j s t

25 wihrs c t Gr nds6()6( ,7b) 79,1 l a l oft f rha nde peii Thec t epe to ou c, d) ( , ( 0, 2, nd 3 he ou t me d tton. oul t
26 6 The coun r e s t t ss at cour pr ef r o hi t e- t oceedi as Petocelislt r sat habeas acton.ng r l' thid t e i '

' i
;

:
.

i
:

1 dimis dGrunds12, 4, , a, bs a , c, d, a, nd8() Theco tuldGr s7() s se o , 3, 5 6()6()7()7()7()8()a c . urr e ound e, 2 #b) 9,11 l 1 a,l ($,1 () 1 d) 1 e,l a ,1 1 c,1 d) 1 e,1 j,1 g,1 h) ( , , 4, 5() 51 5c, 5( , 5() 6() 608, 6() 6( , 6() 6() 6() 6( , 3 1 () 1 1 ,1 ,20 21 22 23 24,25 26,2 28 29 3 a d 3lt b une a td, nd, t r s c 6 i, 7, 8 9 , , , , , 7, , , 0, n o e xh use a wih e pe t
4 t t s une ha t d c a m s t c ul gr n e Pe r c l tm e t fl a n i e of a ndon e of o bo e x us e l i , he o - a t d t o eli i o ie otc t ba m nt
5 t exbaused cl m s,i catng bi el i t abandon t t m t ai ndi i s ecton o be mexbaus ed cl m sand pr t ai oceed wih t t be

)

:
!
!

6 ltga i n ofhi r m a ni e a t d ci i s o , n t ale na i ,t f l a m oton f sa r qu s i g ii to s e i ng xh us e a m , r i he t r tve o ie i or t y, e e tn
I

7 as a oft s pr ce di gst alow hi t r t r t sat c t o e us t une ba t d c ai s n e t y be e o e n o l m o e u n o t e our t xha t he x use l m .

4
1
E

8 c tor r d t t i Pe r el dd no ,wihi t tme al d,Gl a notce ofa nd our de e ha, f toc li i t t n he i lowe e i ba onme o nt f
9 une ause c ai s a ndo ng a 1 of hi une us e c ai s or a m oton f r a sa t a l xh t d l m , ba ni 1 s xha t d l m , i o t y o low 1 e a ton ofhi une use c a m si s a e c t bi f rh am e de pe ii n w o d be dim is d, 0 xh us i s xha t d l i n t t our, s ou t n d tto ul s se

;

1 i ise iey, s a t Ro evLu y,4 U. 50 ( 98 . 1 n t ntrt puru nto s . nd 55 S. 9 1 2) 1 2 Per elih tldhi motonf sa ( ke #203,r po nt tldt iopposto t tl toc lten ie s i or ty doc t ) es nde s ie ber iin o le 1 moto (oc t#21 , ndPer elrple ( k t/21 . 3 in d ke 2) a toc li e id doc e / 7)
j Rhi 4 nes
'

1 5

Un r28U. C. 225 ( )A) t sfdeal ou t a grnt wrt ha a c p u es de S. j 4@)1( ,bi e r c r c nnot a a iof be s orus nls
'

1 çle a i a has e ba s e t r m e e a ia e i t e co t o t St t ' Thi e us i 6 s l pplc nt t x u t d he e di s va l bl n b urs f he a e. ' s xha ton l r uie e i ( ou d i prnc pl sofc iy'asi gi ssat ç h tr to r u t t a r sa 7 eq r m nt s ' nde n i i e gr om t ' t ve t es ' e i s ppo t niy o dd es nd t 1 c r c ale d vi a i ofsat pr s ne ' f de a rght . Col m a v Th 8 ore t l ge ol tons t e i o r s e r l i s ' e n . omps 501U . 72 73l ' on, S. 2,
:

i
!

1 ( 9 l. 9 19 ) 20 l Rhi sv We r 5 U. 26 ( 005) t Su e Co t l t t dititc ur. ysa n ne . be , 44 S. 9 2 ,be prme ur hed ha a src o t ma ty
21 a mi e pcii - a peii c an ng boh e use a une ha se cli - i ti ie x d tton tton ontii t xha td nd x u t d ams n lm td l

l

2 cr umsa c , s t t ttone ma r e hi une use l i t t saec rswihoutosng 2 ic t n es' o ha ape ii r yp es nt s xha tdc ams o he t t ou t t l i ' 23 hi rghtt fde a ha a r viw t t one ye rsamt oflmia i s Rhi s,5 U. a 27 75 s i o e r l be s e e o he - a t e i tton . ne 44 S. t 3-

f

2 ( pl ni howt na t nt teAnttrors a Efe i ahPe lyAc o 1 ( 4 ex ai ng hee cme ofh ier im nd fctveDe t nat t f 996 ABDPA) ,
25 whi i posed a onech m yearst ut oflm iatonson t tlngoff alpettons,af ect t teat çnt at e i t i he i i eder ii f ed he r m

2 ofmi dpe ii ) I Rh le t Cou tr e t tadititc tma sa ami dpe ii onl i: 6 xe ttons . n iîs,he r uld ha src our y ty xe tton y f
6

1 ( )te peiine ha t 1 h tto r s t good c us' f hi fiue t e hau thi cai i sat c r;( t a c' or s alr o x s s l ms n t e /ut 2) he 2 une ause cams aepotntal meiorou ;a ( t r i no i c to t t peii r xh td li r e ily rt i s nd 3) hee s ndiain hat he ttone 3 i e inal e ge i dltr ltgai tci .I a 278.t( Rhi ssa mus bea sse çi ntnto ly nga d n iaoy ii ton a tcs d. t tA) ne ty t se sd dn
4 lgh o t Sup c e Cou ts i t u to t a t dit i tc ts d o y sa m i d pe ii ns i i t f he r m r ' nsr c i n h t he s rc our houl nl t y xe tto n

5 fi t dcr umsa c .' Wootn v Kik a 5 F. l 9 1 ( hCi. 08 , ii Rhi s 5 lmie ic t n es'' e . r l nd, 40 3d 01 , 024 9t r20 ) ctng ne , 44
6 U . a 273- 5. M or o r t c ur m us ke p i m i t a A ED PA ai st e ot a e t e f a iy of S. t 7 e ve , he o t t e n nd h t m o nc l g b m lt r
7 sent encesa t encolr pettoner t exhaustt rcl m si s a ecourt or seeki habeasr i nd o zage ii s o hei ai n t t bef e ng elef

8 i f d alc ur .Rhi s 54 U . a 27 7 , e alo W o e 5 F. d a 1 n e er o t ne , 4 S. t 6- 7* e s s ot n, 40 3 t 024. 9 Fort r a onss a e be o w ib r pe tt ea h ofPe r c list xha t d cl i s t c r he e s t t d l w t es c o c t o e l' me us e a m , he ou t

1 wildeny Petocelisr 0 l r l' equestf aRhi s s ay. or ne t

11

Gr d 7f ) oun e

1 2

I Gr und 7 e , r cel c amst thi tilc uns lwa i fe tve a t pe ly p s of . o n ( ) Peto li li ba s ra o e s nef c i , t he nat ha e

1 hi ti l t o f ii g t o j c t i tu tonsa fna a gu e tr g r ngt p sbiiy ofpa ol or 3 s ra,% r aln o b e t o nsr c i nd i l r m n e a di be os i lt f re
1 cl m e c ' Foulh A m e d Petton, 1 * e al i a pp.1 86 4 e n y. ' ' t nde ii p. 85, e so d. t s 85- . 1 5 Pe r ce l a gu s t a t r i go c us f bi f l e t e u t t i c a m ,be a e of to li r e h t he e s od a e or s aiur o xba s h s l i c us

I

'

l t upe ve ng a hort ' nd t ha i l w . M o i f St y, 4- Pe r elia gu st t hec r 6 t r ni ut iy'a t nge n a ' ton or a pp. 7. toc l r e ha t ou t s c '

l s dgr tasa t al hi t rtr t saecoutopr e t cli i Gr nd7e, c us t 7 boul an ty o low m o eu n o tt rt esnthe am n ou ()be a e he 1 Ni . Cic ti 2008, i dSe e tv l i 5 F. 789(t Ci. ) ac s i vi a 8 nf rui,n h decde chrs .gnaco, 49 3d 9h r2008 , a e nvol ng
1 cl i t tac pia de e ntsc ns iu i l i ht w e evi a e by t pr e ut ' a gu e t a he 9 a m ha a t l f nda ' o tt tona r g s r ol t d he os c or s r m nt h t
20 coul r vecl ency andpar ei sent d ecei em ol f enced t deat Pet oceliappear t cont t o h. r l so end hathecoul not d

21 ha e usedi saec th cli asctdi Gr md7e beor Se hrs wa d i d.Thec r ve xha t n tt ourte am s re n ot () f e c e t s ecde ou t
2 f n t i a gu e t bew ihoutm e i. 2 i ds h s r m nt o t rt

23

Thecam i Gr nd7( i acam o i fci assa ceofPer el' tilcou e.To li n ou e) s li f nefe tve sitn toc lis ra ns l

24 e t iba i sabls n neseci sitnc c e cl m,h ttone tbow:()t rpr e ai wa tveassa eof ounsl ai tepeii rmus s J he e esntton s 25 d fcintfli ' l a obe tvesa dadofraona e s';a d( t dei entpef nc e i e , alng t ow n jci tn r e s blne s' n 2) he fci be ronna e 26 prj c dt dee e.Stiklld; Wa hlî on, U. 668, (l 4) Unde t frtprngof eudie he fns rc al ) s bgt 466 S. 687 98 . . r he is o
7

1 t anal i , t pettoner m ust s bat ys s be ii bow t tcounselm ade er or so s i t couns w as not hat ' r s er ous hat el

2 f to ng a t Sot e ' a a e d t d f nda byt Si . Ame unc ini s he c ms l gu r nte he e e nt he xt h ndme t'Stikand, U . n . rc l 466 S. '
.

3 a 68 t c vit d de e da m a ng a c a m of i fe i a s s a e m us i ntf t a t or t 7. $ on c e f n nt ki A li ne f ctve s it nc t de i y be c s

4 o si sofc e t taealge no t ha be nt rs tofra o bl prfsi alud nt' mison ounslha r le d to ve e he eul e s na e oeson j gme . '
5 1 at690.çA f rass m entofatom e per or d. t ai ess t y f mance r r t every efortbe m ade'o elm i e equi es bat f t i nat

6 t dit tng e f t of nds g ,o r c ns r t bec r u sa e ofc uns lsc le d c duc , nd he sori fec s bi i ht t e o tuc t ic m t nc s o e ' ha l nge on t a 7 t e l t t c nd tofc o va ua e he o uc ouns ls pe f m a c a t e tm e. 1 a 68 l r ctve a s s a e of e ' r or n e t b i ' d. t 9. nefe i s it nc '

8 co e i vi ai oft Si hAme n i rprsnttont tflst l a obe tvesa r unsln olton he xt ndme t s e ee ai ha al ' ow n jci tndad be
9 ofr easonabl ness'i Ightof<pr lng pr es onalnorms' att tm e oft r es aton. I at e 'ni f evaii of si ' he i he epr ent i d.

1 688-9.eeas Bo yv VanHo --U. -- 1 S. l 1 1 ,1 L. 2d255( ) 0 8 , lo bb . s ok,- S. -, 30 CL 3, 6- 7 75 Ed. 2009 .
11 The e or bec u et rc an nz3 j l okst t pr e s o l m spr va lng a t tm e r f e, a s hest i kl da ys s o o be of s i na nor e ii tbe i
1 oft re esent i t deci on i Sechrest m or t 25 year aferPetocelisti ,hasno i 2 hc pr aton, he si n , e han s t r l' ral mpact 1 on t questonw he herPetocelir ved i f i as sance ofcouns asa r ul ofhi ator s 3 he i t r l ecei nefectve sit el es t s t ney'

1 fiur t o j c t j yisr tonsa ag ntrgadi t posi lt o paol orce nc 4 al e o b e to ur n tuci nd rume e r ng he sbiiy f r e lme y. 1 5 Furhemor i i pli fom t rc d ta t cai i Cr md 7e co d ha e be n t r e, t s an r he e or h t he l m n zot () ul v e
1 a tc ae a e ause i saec t bt o dse hr s wa d ci d.l f c , toc li deac os l 6 riul td, nd xh td n tt oul î ç c e t s e de n a tPe r e lma l ey
l r l t d a gum e t- t s t ntv c a m ,t thi c nsiu i al i ht w e e vi a e by t a gu e 7 eae r n he ubsa i e l i ha s o tt ton r g s r ol t d he r m nt l r ga d ng t a ia lt o c e e y a pa ol - i hi fr ta e de pe ii i t s f e a h be 8 e r i he va l biiy f l m nc nd r e n s is m n d tton n hi ed r l a as 1 a ton, e l f esc àr l w a de i d. r ppe r ,he e or , obeno r a on whyPe r e l c d 9 c i w l be or -c c r s c de The ea a s t r f e t es toc li oul 20 notha e haus e i s a e c t i o ofhi t r e sat - ou tha a pettons t cl i t thi ve x t d n t t our n ne s h e t e c r be s ii , he a m ha s

21 c el siefe i f fiigt obe t ur i tu tonsa agume rgadi t posi lt ouns wa n fctvc or aln o jctoj y nsrci nd r nte r ng be sbiiy
22 o paol orcl nc n e 20 Se hr s de ii do snotc fmt good c us f Per el' f re eme y. 08 c e l cson e onsi e a e or toc lis

23 f iu et e us t cl m i Gr nd 7 e . al r o xha t he ai n ou ( )
24 Gr ound 8 b) (

'

2 5

t Gru d8b , to elcamsh t i a pelt c u s l siefciet o f i r t ag e n o n ()Per c l li ta hs p lae o n e wa n fe t t r al e o r u i v f u

26 t tt r w a i ufi i n e de e t s pon t r bbe y c c i n a r ha he e s ns tc e t vi nc o up he o r onvi to nd obbe y a t unde l ng r s he ryi

8

l f l f t f o mur rr l a r bbe y a a a gr va i cic sa e. Fourh Am e d e ony or he el ny- de u e, nd o r s n g a tng r um t nc ' ' t nde 2 Pe ii n,p.1 . e al o / a p J - . tto 88, e s #. t p. 88 89 s 3 Re r ng h s f l r t e ba tt s c a m i s a e c m , toce l a gu t tt r i go ga di i aiu e o x us hi l i n t t ol Pe r li r es ha he e s od

4 c us f hi f iu e be a et a t r yswho ltga e hi t e s a e c th be spr e di sw e e a e or s a l r c us he to ne ii t d s hr e t t - our a a oc e ng r
5 i f i f f lng t r se i. See Repl i SupportofM oton f St p.25. nef ectve or aii o ai t yn i or ay,

6

Rhi sdoe no go i o de a la t wha c tt t t ood ca e ' o a f l e t e us ; nd, ne s t nt t i s o t onsiu es t g us ' f r aiur o xha t a

7 t N i h C ic tha p ovi d no c e rgui nc be ond hol ng t tt t s i l s s rnge t n a he nt r ui s r de la da e y di ba be e t s e s ti nt ba n

8 t xta di r crumsa e'sa r Se Jac s v Roe,425F. 654,66l62 ( hCi. ) s ror nay ic tnc s' tndad. e kon . e 3d - 9t r2005
9 (ii NLRB v Ze Iabl Co,61 F. 567, ( . Ci 979 ctng . no e . 0 2d 569 9t nl $. b
1 0 So edi ti t oursha c cl de t tt s a da d i m or ge r t n t s wi ne de m s rc c t ve on u d ha he t n r s e ne ous ha he ho ng t d l1 f tc us ' t e us a pr e r ldef ul. Se ,eg. Rhi s v W e er 408 F. or t a e' o xc e oc du a a t e . , ne . b , Supp. d 8 8 2 44, 49

1 ( S. 2005 (ppi ngteSuprmeCour' ma t o r ma d) Thi viw f s ppori Pa ev 2 D. D. ) a yi h e ts ndae n e n . s e mds u tn c . 1 Di glel 544 U. 408 ( ) whee t Su e Cou ta kn ed d t ta peii rs 3 Gu i mo, S. 2005 , r he prme r c owl ge ha ttone'
1 Sr as a e c uson' a utt tm e i es ofhi f de a pe ii w oul ge r ly c tt e goo 4 çe on bl onf i ' bo he i ln s s e r l tton d ne a l ons iut d 1 ca e f rhi f iu et e a tsa er m e esbef eGln hi f d r pe ii Pa ,5 U . a 41 5 us o s a l r o xh us t t e di or i g s e e al tton. ce 44 S. t 6
16 17. l 7

On t e o he ha d, r que t oraRhi ss a m us beas e s d t n lg oft Su e eCour ' h t r n a e sf ne ty t s s e t i ht he pr m i ts

1 i tu i t tt di ti tc t houi onl s a m i d pe ii nsi Ti ie c r um sa e .' W o e 8 nsr cton ha he s rc our s d y t y xe tto n lm t d ic t nc s '' ot n

1 v Kikand,5 F. 1 l l 4 ( hCi. 08)( tngRhi s, U. at27 75 .I Wootn,h 9 . rl 40 3d 0 9, 02 9t r20 cii ne 544 S. 3- ) n e te
20 pe ii ra t m pt d t s goo c s un rAàl c t sa i t t wa ' de t i pr s i t a ttone te e o how d au e de W . t t tng ha he s un r he m e son' h t ç by 21 hi co el nc ude a l t is sr s d be or t Calf r i Cou t Appe li hi pe ii n b or s uns i l d l of he s ue aie f e he io n a r of a n s tto ef e

22 t Calfr i Su e Cou t' Wooe 5 F. a 1 Fi ngt tusiiai iade uae,he be io na prme r. ' tn, 40 3d t 024. ndi ba j tfc ton n q t t
23 N i h Cic te ai e a f l ; nt r ui xpl n d s blows
24 ...To acceptt a pettoner' ti esson' t a cl m had been i uded i hat ii s tmpr i ' hat ai ncl n a a l t brefc tt e 'g c s ' woul r nd s a a o y or r r i n ppela e i ons iut s 4 ood au e ' d e er t y- nd- be de s outne. l e d,i t c r wa wilng t sa m i d pe ii ba e on a pe ii nt ' l c of nd e f he ou t s li o t y xe ttons s d tto r s a k k nowl dge t ta c a m w a note u t d,vit a l e r ha s pe ii ner a Ias e ha l i s xha s e r u ly ve y bea tto , t e t t bose r esent by couns coul ar t he l t hi couns had r sed an epr ed el d gue hat hotght s el ai

25
26

; r

)

:

!

1
2

une a t d cl i a d s c e as a Suc a s he ew o d r n a oul Rh n s a is xh us e a m n e ur t y. h c m ul u f of i e nd t i t ucton t ns r i hat dit i cours s d onl s ay m i s rct t houl y t xed pettons i llm ied ii n ti t
cicum st r ances.' '

:

3 1 (mpha i i orgi lctto omitd) d.e ss n i na, iain te . x 4 l Ri rv Cr for 415F.upp. 1 07( Nev20 ,t sc r o yrquie apettone n ne . aw d, s zd 2 D. . 06) hi ou t nl e rd ii r
5 t s t h thewa pr ve t dfom r sn t cl m, t e byhi owni a ceorc nf i a t o how % a t s e n e r aii g he ai eih r s gnor n o uson bou
6 t l w ort sa sofhi ca e, b c r um s a ce ov rwhi h hebad ltl orno co r , u h a t he a he t m s s or y ic t n s e c ite ntol s c s be 7 a tonsofc ms lc t ri c ci ot e ihe n onea e i n oft e p ii r sc e ry e r s de ie t r ie t ecl i v nto h cttone ' l a l xp es ed sr o a s h a m
. .

!
ë

!

8 or when pettone had no knowl ii r edge of t cl m ' e s e ' Ri 4l5 F. he ai s xit nce.' ner, supp.at l21l. The
'

9 deci on i Woot however t si n en, , mder i any r i m nes elanceonRi ner.Li t pettone scl m i Woot ke he ii r ai n en

;

1 t t wa und t i e sont tc ms l drie une a tdcli , r el' usiiain, 0 ha he s erhe mprsi ha ot e ha asd xb use ams Petoc lisj tfc to
1 t thi pos- nvitonc s lpe f me i fe i l i fii t r iet cl m,i on t a c ul l ha s tco c i oun e ror d ne fctvey n a lng o a s he ai s e h t o d
.

i
!
; '

1 b rie i vlu lye ey c s . Ac e tn eo s c ag o -a s te r wo l c n l twi te 2 e as d n i al v r ae c pa c f u h o dc u e h o y ud o fi t h l c h
, 13 Supr e Courts gui em dance, i Rhi n neh t m i bat xed pettons s d onl be st ii houl y ayed i lm ied n i t 14 cicum st r ances,and i w oul r contar t t goal ofAED PA . ' t d un r y o he s

:
i

1 5

The U nie St t s D it i tCo t f r t So he n D it i t of Ca ior a i a r c ntor r t d a e s rc ur o he ut r s rc lf ni , n e e de ,

. !
; i I

J rjce acai ofi fe tveassa eo pos-onvito c ns a goo c us 6 ee td l m nefci sitnc f tc cin ou el s d a eunde S/n s sai . r l c' ttng' ï ,
1 7
18

The e a pe r t b a m ea ur ofa e m e t ts m e f t e t re e na t r p as o e s e gr e nt ha o ac or ihe xt r l o orouti t contolofPettonerm ay be s fci t dem onstat good cause f sde he r ii uf i ent o r'e or f lle t exbaus cl m si sat court A st N i h Cicui has i cat t t aitr o t ai n t e . he nt r t ndi ed hat he good cause sandar does notr r a s i ashi asext di y t d equie how ng gh vaor nar

1 9
20

cr u tn e, n teS prmeCo r h sh l ta ra o a ec n u ino e ic msa c s a d h u e u t a ed h t e s n bl o f so v r

i

21

I

'
22 23 24

tm e i s m a alo p ovi a s fc e s ow i ofgo ca e, hi Co ' i i lne s y s r de uf i i nt h ng od us t s ul s t pe s de t ta s a da d ofç xc a e ne e t' sa a pr i t a r a o bl r ua d ha t n r ' us bl gl c ' i n p opra e nd e s na e e s a a d t a v t a a l i ofe c us und l hi s t nd r o ool o n na ys s ood a e er t ne . - Her , Pettonerass s t t f l e t r se t unexhaust cl m seari e ii ert hat he aiur o ai he ed ai ler c be atrbut t t f t tst e habeascouns conduct a w i r ng an t i ed o he act hat t at el ed de-angi i nvestgaton,r s an ext ve a ay ofcl m s,and m ay be f t onl i f lng i i aied ensi rr ai auled y n aii t f m ul e and or ze t cl m si a m annert comporsw ih t t o or at gani he ai n hat t t he echni cal

I : !

' r

r uie nt o s ci 2 e usi ' ( t Opp.a d M ot a ll) Pe ii rs eq r me s f e ton 254 xha ton. Pe . ' n . t . ttone '
pr f ed r on does notcons iut good cause f f lng t exhaus Cl m 1 i of er eas tt e or aii o t ai 4 n s a e c t Unde a a i a i oft S xc bl n e t- t nda d tc t t our . r n pple ton he t ua e egl c ' s a r t ouns ls e e'

25
26

ovesght..d ejnotc ttt go c us'f f lngt e au tcli i sae ri . ogs onsiue od a e'or aii o xh s ams n tt c tL lasow Ayes 2 WL 61 0( D. IMac 9, our.coj s . r, 006 838 E. Ca. rh 2006) at* ) 3.

'

1 0

TheCoras o c ur wa c r f lt ditnguih be we nt xcus bl ne e q' j s o t s a e u o si s t e t a e glc ' e whihc dco tmt goodc us , dsmpl ne i nc ,ra o ngt ttEl poi c oul nsi e a e an i e glge e e s ni ha 'the nt i whehe s outi u tola ee n prcude t brngi oft ()is ' s t r ome sde, nconr lbl ve t e l d be i ng he sue. '
I a *2. l t tc s , hedi ti tco twasno pe s a d t tc d. t n ha a e t src ur t r u de ha ouns l swor l a e' k od a ove s ghtoft une ba t d cl m f ie t c tt ego c us ,r a oni g t t nd r i be x us e ai a l d o ons iut od a e e s n ha

çll t c l fundte ecrumsa est j tf t dea t ngoodca ec d tifhe ou- o b s ic tnc o usiy he ly,he t us oul
be f nd i vit ly e r c e whi b t Supr me Cou t e ry di noti t n i ou n rua l ve y as , c he e r cl a l d ne d n Rhi ' 1 at*3 nes.' d.

6

f iur t r s t cli i sa ec ur wasno t r ul ofa e e na e ntouti al e o aie he am n tt o t t he es t ny xtr l ve sde hi c r , tw a du t de i e a ede s o m a e by c uns li tf m ul tng a s ontol bu s e o lb r t ci i ns d o e n tor a i nd

Thesma in pr s ntd he ei a l goust t ti Cofa o a Pe ii rs i to e e e r s na o o ba n n , s ttone '

7
8 9 l0

or nzngt cams'orpr e ttont t saes e c tAss h,tsi y ga ii he li 'f esnai o he tt uprme our. uc ç lmpl l
s yi t tt i s wa ove l ke by c a ng ha he s ue q roo d ouns i no out i t c ntolo el s t sde he o r f peii ttonersi be i hel bound by t act ofhi counsel' f#.at*2. nce s d he s s .'
l s ,Pettoneri unabl t dem onstat good cause f f lng t exhaust n um ii s eo e or aii o Cl m 14 i s at cour. Accor ngl t Cour de i t s ay t f ai n te t di y, he t clnes o t he edera l ii n mderRhi s v.W eber. ne pr oceedi and hol t m i f alpetton i abeyancet ngs d he xed eder
.

11
1 2

v Cule 20l1WL 1 4 ( D. l201 )a *9-0. . ln, 1 25 S. Ca. 1 t 1
W hiet scourtm i hest et pl an çexcus e negl ' l on t Rhi good cause l hi ght iat o ace t abl ect' abel he nes

) san r t sc ta r e wih teco ti Ho s a t c r i Cor s o,t tasmpl s e nt 3 t da d, bi our g e s t h ur n yo , nd be ou t n ja s ha i e mtme
t t t t pos - vi ton c ns l a i f c i e f rove l ngt i s i note ugh t s w go ha s a e tcon c i ou c w s nefe tv o rooki he s ue s no o ho od c us t de Rhi s a t ts ef c ore t re e nal o, ro sde t c r of t pe ii e a a e m r ne , nd ba om a t ihe xt r t o ut i he ontol he tton r nd
hi couns i r r s el s equied.

l t sc r ' vi w,un rt c r um sa e i t sc s ,t c l de t tPe r e l n hi ou ts e de he ic t nc s n hi a e o onc u ha toc li
cause f hi f l e t exhaus, bas s mpl upon bi concl y and unsuppored as i or s aiur o t ed i y s usor t serton

f

i fe i as it nc ofc ne f ctve ss a e ouns , t m or woul c lc wih t Su e e Cour ' i t u to i el wihout e, d onfi t t he pr m ts nsr c i n n Rhi s t at i e pettonss d besa d i onl lm ie c r ums a e , nd J w ou d d s e r a ne b m x d ii houl tyc n y i t d i c t nc s a t l i r ga d nd und nni et e g soft AEDPA, o e our get fna iy o s nt nc s a t e cou a e n h oal he t nc a he i lt f e e e , nd o n r gepe ii ne s tto r

t e ha ttei cai i sat c t f eflng i fde a'oun.S eA/j;. 544U. at - ' ee o x us h r l ms n t e our be or ii n e r lc e //tF ?, S. 273 77, s
al Ftc/vl 540F. atJ024.Thi courtfndst so l,t , 3d s ' i hatpetocelihasnot r l sbown good- e,underRhi s, caus ne

2 f hi f iu et pr ou l e ha s i s<e c r,t cli i / oun 8( ) 4 or s a lr o evi sy x u q n tt ou t he am n Gr d b .
25

26

:
E .

i

1 2
'

Gr ound 9 l G r ' 9,Pe r e l c a m st t r ce ve i e f c i a s s a ceo c uns i hi s a epos n ound toc li li ha he e i d n f e tve s it n f o el n s t t t

3 co c i n pr c d ngs Fou t Am e e Pe ii n, 1 5- Gr m d 9,f t m os pa t s t f nvs to o ee i . rb nd d tto pp. 9 96. ot or be t r, e s olb t

4 onl ge r l ndu pe fi camsofa t ne e r .Theo ys mewha s cii a s ri ofal e y ne a a ns ciid li tor y ror nl o t pe fc s e t on tonz y
E 5 e r i Gr nd 9 i t e c a m t tc ns lf ie t i s i t a di c e a ia e m ii tn r or n ou s h l i ha ou e a l d o nve tga e nd s ov r va l bl tga i g 6 e de ce I a 1 5. vi n . d t 9
,

'

7

o ne oft s he howi t m ustbe m a underRhi s,t esabls t a say i war ant i ngs bat de, ne o t ih hat t s r ed, s

i

;

8 t t upe àause c a m i t e i ly m e io i s. Rhi s,5 U. a 278. Tbe e i no f de al hat he x t d l i s t nta l rt rou ' pot ' ne 44 S. t r s e r
9 cons i tonalrghtt couns i sat postconvi i pr tm i i o el n t e cton oceedi ngs.Penns v a v.Fi e 481 U . yl ani nly, S.

; i
!

1 551(987)Murc .Girat 492U. l( 98 (ppl ngt uet c pia c s ) Consque l 0 1 ; ryv a r ano, S. 1 9) a yi herl o a tl aes. e nty,
11 t r i no vi bl c a m ofc tt i ly i fkc i a s s e ofc he e s a e li ons iutona l ne l tve s i mnc ouns li s a e pos pr e di . e n tt t oc e ngs

1 Se Wai i v Tor a, U. 5 (982 ( r t r i n c tmton lrg t c nslt r 2 e nwrght . n 455 S. 86 1 ) whee bce s o onsi i a iht o ou e hee
!

'
i

1 c n beno de i in ofe fc i as itnc ) l v i o t e cwe le tbls dprnci e ,Pe r el 3 a pzvato fe tve ssa e . n e w f b s l-sa ibe i pls toc li
1 bmsm ade no s i t t cl m i Gr 4 how ng hat he ai n ound 9 haspot i m ert ental i.

!
!

1 5 1 6

Gr und 1l o I Gr nd 11 Pe r e l c ai s t t hi c s i to rght w e e vi a e t c us t e n ou , toc li l m ha s on tm i nal i s r ol t d t a e b be

.

1 samt iyma tddei tonofS e diai a dei rto gve t hij r de rv dhm of 7 t orl- ndae fnii prme tton nd lbeain' i n o su y pie i due
1 pr e sa e al ot cton. Fou t A m e de Pe ii p. 0, eealo i at 200- 9 Pe r e l 8 oc s nd qu pr e i rb n d tton, 20 . s s d. pp. 1 . toc li
l9 ar guest t r i good caus f hi f l et exhaus t scl m ,because ofti er ng cbangesi hat he e s e or s aiur o t hi ai 'nt veni n

;

2 t e l w .N M oton f St y, 1 . eeal o l a pp. 1 s or s c jc j ,pe r e l a gue t a hi 0 h a , i or a p. 0, s s . t 9- 8. ( e pe j jajy toc li r s h t s d. 21 c ai i Gr nd 11i b e up t N i h Cicui Cou t Appe l ' cii i Pol .o a f v , 03 l m n ou s as d on he nt r t r of a s de son n kv u tt l/ 5 p

'

22 F.d903( hCi. 07)a 3 9t r200 , ndpol .not ci duntl fe hi a pe lnhi t r sa eha c a ton. kwzs de de i al r s p a i s hid tt b as c i
23 Perocelisar r l' gumenri notcom peli s lng.

I

24

Pet ocelicoul have r s t s cl m i st e cour bef e Pol w as deci r l d aied hi ai n at t or k ded. Petoceli r l

2 de o ta e t shi s l.l t s a editi t oul, n hi t r pe ii f wrt ha a c pu , ic 5 m ns r t d hi m e f n he t t s rc c - i s hid tton or i of be s or s tl d t
26 Augustl1,2003 - aboutf year bef e Pol was deci - Petocelim adet scl m . Exhi t26, our s or k ded r l hi ai bi

1 2

1 pp.21 25. H ad Petoceliass t t cl m on t appeali t acton,i woul now be exhaus ed. r l ered he ai he n hat i t d t

2 How e r Peto elidi n do t t The c a m wa a a ve , r c l d ot ha . li s b ndon a d no a s re o a a bef e t ed n t s e t d n ppe l or he

3 Ne daSupe Cou tSe Exhi t pp.l - (ttme ofis sprsnt ona e i t r sae va rme r. e bi38, 820 sae nt sue ee ed pp aln hid tt 4 ha a a ton) Per elha pr d dnoe plnai be s ci . toc li s ovie x a ton-muc Is t dc us '-f hia ndo nt b e ss goo a e' or s ba nme
5 oft sc a m on t a pea i h st r sa e ha a a ton. hi l i he p l n i hid t t be s c i 6 So, bie t d i i n i Pol m a ha a d s e wei t Pttoc li sc a m ,Pe r e l' w l he ec s o n k y ve dde om ght o r e l' l i toc li s

.

7 ab lt t e us t c a m w a n de e nto t Pol d ci i n, nd Pe e l ha nots w n good iiy o xba t be l i s ot p nde n he k e s o a toc li s ho
8 cause f hi f l e t exhaus t cl m . or s aiur o t he ai 9 10 Gr ound 1 4 l Gr n ound 14# Petocelicl m st hi consi tonalrght w er vi at tbecauset N evada r l ai hat s tm i i s e ol ed l he

1 c pial nihm e s t m ope a e i a a bir r a c prc ousm a r' Fo t Am e d Pe ii l a t pu s nt yse r t s n n r ta y nd a i i nne . urh ' nde tton,
1 p.252,see al i atpp.2522 . so d. 55.

l 3

W ihrs c t ttscam, toc li ppe r t aguet t sa s oul bega e be a etll t epe to ii li Per ela aso r ha a ty h d rntd c us ùto

1 Pe ii ne ' c 4 tto r s ouns lsknowl dge t si s ba no be n pr vi s y r l d on by t N e d Supr m e e' e , bi s ue s t e e ou l u e he va a e

1 Cour,de piet o ousde ii ciso t e sae' de t pe ly s tm . M oto f S a p.l 5 t s t he bvi fcen e f h t t s ah nat yse ' ' in or t y, 8.
1 Thi, w e r i no as owi g ofgo c us f Pe elisf l et e us t sci i .Se 6 s ho ve , s t h n od a e or loc l' aiur o xha t hi a m eRhi s ne , l 5 U . a 27 l f c i Pe r e l h d not ba ne t sc a m on t a al n h st r sat ha as 7 44 S. t 8. n a q f toc li a a ndo d hi l i he ppe i i hid t e be l a ton,i i po sbl t tt e N e ada Su e e Cou tm i ha r e o t scl i . Pe r elir i e 8 c i t s s i e ha h v pr m r ght ve ul d n bi a m toc l a s d 1 t sc ai i hi s a e h e s pe ii i t sa e diti c r , n hi t r s a e ha a a ton, the 9 hi l m n s t t ab a tton, n he t t s rct ou t i s hid t t be s c i bu

20 di not s l t cam i hi a a .Se Exhi t pp. 3 , bi38 pp.1 - Pe r eli f r d ase- he li n s ppe l e t bi26, 30- 3* Exhi t , 8 20. toc lofe s
2! no e a to f t a nd e oft cl i on t a a i hi t r s a e ha ea a i n, nd he xpl na i n or he ba onm nt be a m be ppe l n s hid t t b s cto a 22 ha ,t r f e, aie t s w good c us f rhi f iur t e ha tt c ai . s he e or f l d o ho a e o s a l e o x us he l m

i I

23 2 4

Gr nds l ( ) 1 b) 1 c .l d) 1 e ou 5 a . 5( . 5( ) 5( . 5( ) l Gr n ound1 Péto li l mst t sc tmto l i t evi a e td ot s tnta 5, r celcai ha hi onsi ina rgh swer olt d 'uet he ubsa i!

25 a ij i efc of c itnt teno prs c oral sond t ndov ra hi whihdit d nd nurous fe t a onsse patr f o e ut i mic uc a ere c ng c sone
26 t f c f n ng pr e s a d r nde e bo h t e ti l a d s nt nc ng be rng f da e aly unf r' he a t i di oc s n e r d t h ra n e e i a i un m nt l ai. '

I 3

I

.

w

ë

i

1 Fourh A m e de Pe ii p.256.s e al o i a p 25 6 G r t 1 i cl es fv s bpa t, t n d tton, , e s d. t p. 6- 2. o md 5 n ud i e u r s

2 de inaedGrunds1 a , 5( , 5() 1 d ,nd1 e.Se , a 25 6 l Gr d1 a, toc li sg t o 5() 1 b) l c , 5()a 5() e' t 6-2. n oun 5()Per el #.
i
:
'

3 cl m s t t pr ecuton com m it m i ai bat he os i ted sconductqby gi ng i z vi nadequat notce ofi entt s t e i nt o eek he

4 dc hpe ly. I at2 .s ealo i atpp.25860. . Gr nd l 08,Petoc l camst tte at nat ' d. 58, e s d. ' - l ou 5 n r eli li ha h
5 pr ec i Si opel dipaa d MrPer elb usngpeor i t nol '1 a p. s e os uton çmpr ry s rge . toc li y i j atve enni ogy. d. t 260.e ' 6 aloi a pp. - .l Gr md 1 c)Peto licamst ttepr e uto ti opel i tuce s d. t 26061 n ot 5( , rcel li ha h osc in d mpr ry nsr td 7 t uor t s damesa t tl c nu t ' 1 at 261 s eas i a pp.26162.l Gr nd hej r s o en s ge o le omz niy. d. p. ; e lo d. t ' - n ou
8 1 d) Peto licamst tt pr s c i c nmit mic uc qi f ii t t r ove t l te 5( , r cel li ha he o e uton or ted s ond t tn a lng o u n r he etr

:

:
1

: i !
I

9 fom Dr Geo t tepr e t .'I a p.26 l Gr r . r w o h oscuor' d. t 2. n ound 1 e,Per el cli t ttlli , 5() toc li ams ha ftral
1 a lat â d pos- onvi to c un l we e i f e tve f r f ii t c le 0 ppe l e n tc c i n o se r ne f c i o a lng o ha l nge t c e i he xt ns ve
ll pr ecut i m i os oral sconductwhi occur ed i M r.Petocelis ti .' 1 atp.262. ch r n r i' ral' d.

'

:
!

1 2

W ihr pe tt alofhsGr md 1 cams Pez el ag st tt r i g c us frhs t es c o l i ot 5 li , toc li rue ha hee s ood a e o i

:

l f iur t e us be us ofi fkc i a s sa eofhi c uns l i f ii t a j r t s c ai son bi 3 a l e o xha t ca e ne l tve s i t nc s o e , n a lng o s e t he e l m s 1 die a pea a d i hi t ees a e h be sac i . Se M oton f r S a p.1 4 r ct p l n n s hr t t a a tons e i o t y, 9.

;
!

1 5

Thi courtfndst Petocelihasnotmadea s i ofgood cause f hi f l e t exhaus s i hat r l how ng or s aiur o t

(

l t cli a sre i Gr s1 () 1 b) 1 () 1 d) a 1 e .Se dic sonofGr 6 he ams setd n ound 5a , 5( , 5c, 5( , nd 5() e s usi ound8 , *)
1 su a. 7 pr

1 8
;

Gr nd 1 a .1 1 1 c .1 dJ l e .1 ( 1 $ 1 h) 1 i ou s 6( ) 6( 6( ) 6( . 6( ) 6 9. 640. 6( . 6() 9.
l Gr nd l Pe r e l c a m s t thi c tt i lr g s w e e vi a e Kd t ti lc t n ou 6, toc li l i ha s ons iutona i ht r ol t d d ue o ra our

1 9

20 eror a voi diea dt fiur ofc elt obe tt t ur slctonpr es. Fout Ame d r s t r r n be al e ouns o jc o hej y ee i oc s' rh nde '
i 2 1 Pe ii p. , e alo i a pp.2 83. Gr nd 1 i u s ni e s m e tove l ppi s bpa t, tton, 263* e s d. t s 63ou 6 ncl de n o wha ra ng u r s

1 I
! 1
i
:

22 whi aede i ae Grundsl () 1 b) 1 () l ( ,l e,1 t,1 ( ,1 h)a 1 i.Se i ch r sgn td o 6a, 6( , 6c, 6d) 6() 6() 6g) 6( , nd 6() e d.

23 a 256-2.l Gr 1 a, toc lcl mst tdtheti c tmpr e l d t qu iidt uy, t 6 n ound 6()Per eli ai ha t l ral ouri op ry eab- alfe hej r l 2 fie t lf- alf t ur a dpe ntdt dee efom i vi lyquetoni potntaj r s 4 ald o iequ iy hej y, n rve e he fns r ndi dual si ng e iluor 2 c n enn terve o ted ahp n l . l . t2 6 s eas i . t2 6 6 . l Gr u d 1 ( ) 5 o c r ig h i iws n h e t e at ' d a 6 ' e lo d a 6 - 8 n o n 6b , y' , 26 Per elcli tat Eletilc tf ldt a q t yi uieast bis l a 268( eeas i toc li ams h th ra our aie o de uael nq r o a . d. t s lo d.
I 1 4

1

i

i
!
'

.
!

l a 268 70. l Gr nd l c , toc li ai t ttl til our fie t lf quaiypr pe t t n ou 6() Per el cl ms ha çl he ra c t ald o ie- lf os ci t ve

I
i

2 j os' 1 a 27 .s ealoi a 27 73.l Grt 1 d) Per el cai t t (l tilc r urr. d. t 0, e s d. t 0- n omd 6( , toc li l ms ba the ra ou t '
3 i pr pe l i s d ove l r s rc i voi d r s m o ry mpo e ry-e t i tve r ie lnda ds' 1 a 27 . e alo i a 273 77.l Gr nd r . d. t 3, e s d. t - n ou ' s

i

4 1 e , eoc li li t t<dlfns c ms lweei fe tv frfii t rha lt ede t rtc nt 6()Pe elcamsha tE ee e ot e r nefcie o alng o e biiat ah eie
'

r

5 j r s'I a 277.e aloi a 27 78.l Grund1 9, toc li l msta tlleti c r erd uor. d.t , e s d. t 7- n o ' s 6( Per elcai h ttth ral ou t re
6 by f ii g t pr i i di dua s q se e voi die. 1 a 278' ee alo i a 27 79. l Gr a ln o ov de n vi l e ue t r d r r ' d. t , ' s s d. t 8n ound

;

7 1 g , tocelcamst tsthetilc t. erone l fie t co eye mi t bei so t 6() Per li li ha tll ra our . r ousy ald o ls l xa ne he lef f be . 8 pr p tve ur sa e mi dt m i ahu e ,i mplt a nc itnt nne.'d. 27 80. os eci j or nd xa ne be n ni d nco ee ndi onsse ma r'I at 99 l Gr und 1 h ,Per el cam st ttllilcou elf ie t pr de co tmto ly e f ci n o 6( ) toc li li ha ttra ns a ld o ovi nsi ina l fe tve
.

i i :
l

1 rprs nai d i tee tr j ys lci pr es. I a 281 s aloi a 28l8 l Grund 0 e e e tton urng h nie ur ee ton oc s ' d. t ; ee s d. t -2. n o '
11 1 i:Per elcli t ttap laea dpos-on ctonc msl r i ciei fiigt rie 6()' toc li ams ha tllpelt n tc vi i ot e wee nese tv n aln o as
1 t scl m .'1d. at282,see al f at2822 hi ai ' . so #. 83.

@.

!

13

Petocelimxuest t e i Mood caus f hi f l e t exhausta1 oft r l hal ber s e or s aiur o 1 hese cl m s becaus ai e

' ' ' ' ' ' . 1 ofts e n l ga de l 4 'ubs que t e l ve opme st a we e noti e se e a t tm e ofM r Pe r elis a a . nt h t r n xit nc t he i . toc l' ppe l' '
'
;

l M oto f St y, 1 The o y l ubs q ntl ga de l e ' c t d by Pe r e l,ho e r i t 5 i n or a p. 9. nl ç e ue e l ve opm nt' ie s toc li w ve , s he

l Unie SttsSupe Co tsde iin i M oga v Iln s 5 4 U. 71 (992 ,is edJ l 6 td ae rme ur' cso n r n . lioi, 0 S. 9 1 ) su une 5,
I
!

1 1 7 992. See i n e M or d. gan deci on pr e by m or t a decade Petoce l s t r sat cqur si edat d e han r li hid t e- t

I

i ng he- s o n gan xpl n h I p ii srwrtofha a c pu n e tm i oft deciin i u or aoesnote as why t e g etten i - be s or s
.

l c a m s i Gr und l we e notr i e i Pe r e l st r sat ha asa to 9 li n o 6 r a s d n toc li hid t e be c i n.
:

20

Pe r e l a s a gu st at sa la e c uns l a i fkc i f rf ii g t r s t si s o toc li lo r e b hi ppe l t o e w s ne l tve o a ln o aie hi s ue n

21 hi a e , p r ntyr e ng t hi die t ppe lt t e d Supr m cCo l Se M oton f rSoy, s pp al a pa e l ef ni o s r c a a o heN va a e ur . e i o
.

k

'
E
'

r ga n, owe r be our oe c e uc l i f ne f c i s i t nc 22 pp.1 20. H e e a i h ve ,t c td s nota c pts h a c a m o i f e tve a ss a e of 923 cou clw ihout or , s if c i n of egood- a er quie e i po e b ns , t m e as ats a to l c us e r m nt m s d yRhi s.s cdi c s c ne xk s us im

24 o Gr nd8()sl - An morov r t si feci assa eofa laecou e doe not ppe r f ou b, t a. d, e e ,hi nef tve sitnc ppelt ns l s a a pl
:

25 t speak t Pet ocelis f l et r s t e cl m si hi t r st e habeas acton. o o r l' aiur o aie hes ai n s hid at i

2

2 6

Pe r e l ha n s toc li s ot hown good c us f rhi f l e t ex us t cl i ss t orh i G r und l a e o s aiur o ha t he a m e f t n o 6.

'

'

1 5

1
E

i ! 1 '

1 2

Gr nd l ou 7 I G r und l Pe r elic a m st t sc ns iu i l i ht w e evi a e t t i r cton n o 7, toc l l i ha bi o tt tona r g s r ol t d t he ntodu i by

!

3 ofi c urt prj iila fnd menal fa de d nc oftuueda r s s 'a t pe ly na c ae, eudca nd u a tly lwe vie e f tr ngeou ne s the nat
4 pha e' Fo t Ame d Petton, 28 , eealo i at 28 302. s . urh ' nde ii p. 4. s s d. pp. 45 Pe r c l a gu s t t i vi w o de l e si t 1 w t i ce t tm e ofM r Pe r e l ' t o elî r e ha , n e f ve opm nt n he a t n he i s . toc lis

!

6 a a a i ta ha a a plc tons't r i goo c us f rhi f iur t e ba thi c am.M oton ppe l nd niil be s p ia i , he e s d a e o s a l e o x us t s l i ' i

7 f St y, 20, e aloRe y i Su to M etc f Sty( ke /21 ) p.30.Petoc l ct t or a p. . e s pl n ppor f im or a doc t/ 7 , s r eli ies he

8 Sup e Co tsde ii i Da r v Me rlDow Ph mac utcas I c.509U. 5 ( 9 ,a r me ur' cson n ube t . rel ar e i l, n , S. 79 1 93) s
!
@

9 t ciia s bs qu ntlga de elpme .Se M oton f Sty,p.2 he ltc l u e e e l v o nt e i or a 0.
1 0 However t D aubertcas wasdeci i 1993, or t t year bef ePelocelifl li , be e ded n m e han en s or z l ied zs

:

'
:
l

l1 t r s a e c r pe ii n f rm i ofha a co pu Se Exhi t26. D au r wa o t booksw be hid t t - ou t tto o t be s r s. e bi be t s n he n
1 t trr 2 hat hid ound ofs at postconvi i ltgaton w asconduct and t e i no r on pr te cton ii i ed, her s eas esent by ed 1 Petocelit expl n why t cl m i G r md 17 wer notr s i t petton. Petocelihas not 3 r l o ai be ai n ot e ai ed n hat ii r l l s 4 hown good caus f hi f l e t exbaus t cl m i Gr e or s aiur o t he ai n ound 17.

i

I
i

1 5
1 6

Grun 1 o dà
11Gr nd 1 Peto li a m st at sc s iu i na rght we e vi a e td t t f iur of . ou 8, r ce l cl i h hi on tt to l i s r ol t d ' ue o he a l e r

l t tilc topr dehij r wihaUna miylsnlton. Fou t Ame dPeii p. , e 7 he ra ourt ovi s uy t ni t n t ci ' rh nde tton, 303. e ' s
I
!

1 alo i . atpp.3038 s d 06.

i

1 9

Ast c u tundesa Per e l' a gume ,h sonl t or t tt r wa good c us f be o r rtnds toc lis r nt i y be y ba he e s a e or

20 hi f l e t e s aiur o xhaus t s cl m i sat courti t t cl m ti based on f t hi ai n t e s hat he ai ts undam ent due pr al ocess

i
:

.

21 c enst ts ul ha be nrie byti a a lat c el ttlo hn fut Peii r onc r ha ho d ve e asd ral nd ppel e ouns bu,irug o a lof ttone,
2 w e enot' M oton f rSt y, 21 s e a s Re y i Su 2 r . ' i o a p. ; e l o pl n ppor ofM oton f rSt y, 30 31 Thi i no t i o a pp. - . s s t 2 a s ow i g ofg ca e. Se dic sono Gr 3 h n ood us e s us i f ound81) s pr , u a.

I

!

24

Gr ound 1 9

'
i

25

l Gr nd 1 Petocel camst thi co ttto lrghsweevi ae ' ca etej y n ou 9, r li li ha s nsiuina i t r oltd t us h ur be
.

26 i tu ton di not o ry i tu tt ir ont elmiedus ofp i rba a t de ei t pe ly nsr c i s d pr pe l nsr c he u y h i t e ro d c evi nc n he na t
! l 1 6

I I

i

.
. .

(

'

1 pha ean di n pr e ta i tt a birr a d c prcousi titonoft de t pe ly.'Fourh s d d ot otc gans he r ta y n a ii nlc i he ah nat ' t
i
'

2 A m ende Pe ii p.307.see al i atpp.307- 1. d tton, , so d. 1

3

Poi igt idltnvSt e 11 Ne J 9, 81. ntn oM d eo . at, 4 v. 08 96 32d296(998, lawa v. at,11 Ne 1 )Hol y St e 6 v.

4 73 6P. 987(000 ,ndfv .v St e,1 7Ne 6 28P.d498( )Per elagu st thi 2, 3d 2 )a lnç . at 1 v. 09, 3 2001, toc li r e ha t s
i
.

5 cl m i çl gel bas on 1 t thaschanged si t diecta alandm a w el a y r r i y ai s çar y ed aw ha nce he r ppe y l ppl etoactvel

6 t M r Pe r e l' c s . M o i n f rSt y, 22. M i e on Holawa a Ev s, o . toc lis a e' to o a p. ' ddl t , l y, nd an howe r we e a 1 ve , r l

7 dei dwelbeor Per elltgae hi t r saeba a acin.Thepeii i Per el' t r cde l f e toc liii td s hid tt be s to tton n toc lis hid
i :

8 sa eha a a to wa fl d A u s 11 200 Se Ex bi 26 Pe r e l m a sno s t t be s c î n s ie gu l , 3. e hi t . toc li ke howi ofgood ng
9 caus f hi f l e t r s t s cl m i t pr e or s aiur o aie bi ai n hat oceedi ng.

l
i

1 0 11

Gr und 20 o l Gr md 20,Petoceli ai st hi cons i tonalrght w er vi at tduet t adm i i n ot r l cl m hat s tm i i s e ol ed t o he sson

!
:

1 o c ltvea prj ca vitm i c tsi nyatt gul a pe at pha e ofhi til' 2 f umuai nd eudiil ci mpa t etmo he it nd n ly s s s ra. '
13 Fourt Az h nended Petton,p.31 .see alo / .atpp.312- 4. ii 2, s ' # 1

1 4 (
q
j
'

Per elague t ttll r i go c us t alw t scli t b e use a i i lr l toc li r s ha ttbee s od a e o lo hi am o e xba td s ts agey

1 bae o Pa v Te e s e 50lU. 8 11lS. . 5 sd n yne . nn s e , S. 08, Ct2597(991, c tesaec t di no ha 1 ) whih h tt ours d t ve
1 an opporuniy t r e on att tm e ofPettoner' appeal' M oton f St p.23. al Repl i 6 t t o ul he i ii s .' i or ay, , see so yn

1 Su 7 ppor of otonf rSt y, 3 Pa t M i o a p. 2. yne,houg wasde i d s m e 1 ye r be or t o eli n ta e t h, c de o 2 a s f epe r c l i ii t d
' '

1 bi t r s a eha asa i n.See Exbi t l a ton, yn wa de i e wbiePe rc li ss c 8 s bid t t bc cto bi 26. n ddii Pa e s c d d l b e l' e ond 1 sa e ba s a to wa s ilpe ng i t s a edi ti tc 9 t t bea c i n s tl ndi n he t t s rc oun. Se Exhi t PP a I U. T'e tm i e bis nd . J h i ng

E

C
r

20 oft Payne deci on does notest i good cause f Pet ocelis f l e t exhaustt cl m i he si ablsh or r l' aiur o he ai n

21 Gr nd 2 Pe r e l alo a gue t thi co e we e i f e tve f f lng t r i e t i c a m on ou 0. toc li s r s ha s uns l r ne f c i or aii b a s h s l i
;
:

) . 22 a ppealori hi sat habeasactons. How ever as i dicus a n ste ' i , s s sed bove,i t scourts vi s an n hi ew, uch

!

23 a sri ofator yic etnc i f ln t r s t cli i sat cour,wihoutmor, sn) se ton t ne n omp c e n alig o aie he am n t e t t e doe (t
24 s how good caus underRhi . Se dic so ofGr nd 8( , u a. e nes e s us in ou b) s pr
25 26

.

I

17

i !

i
I

l 2

Gr und 21 o l G r t 2l Pe r e l c a m s t thi c tm to rght w e e v o a e t c us ht was n o md , toc li l i ha s ons i i nal i s r i l t d ' a e be

3 de i e oft ade ua ea s sa eof n i tt i alz tone r.'Fo r h Am e dPe ii n, 31 , pr v d be q t s it nc a nsiuton i a i xpe t' u t nde tto p. 5' 4 s al o i a p 31 1 . Pe r licl i st thi ti lc ns lw e e i f e tve i vi a i n ofhi ee s d. t p, 5- 8 toce l a m ha s ra ou e r ne f c i , n ol to s 5 c tt tona rgh s f f ii t obt i t s r i e of a d pr s ntt t s i o of s b a e r . ons iu i l i t , or a lng o a n he e v c s , n e e be e tm ny , uc n xpe t 6 Se i a 31 1 e d. t 5- 8. 7 Pe r lia gu , n hi M o i n f St y, hat h r i g ca s f rhi f iu e t e us t s toce l r es i s to or a t t e e s ood u e o s a l r o xha t hi

8 cl m i sat c ur, ec us < theman b ofr s r up whihi i bas d i o r ai y r c nt ai n t e o t b a e i l g i ody e each on c t s e s f eltvel e e
9 o i n. M oton f r St y,p. Pe r e l lss t f l ng lt r t r asr pr s' i t tS y of rgi ' ' i o a 24. toc li i t he olowi ie a u e e e e ng ha t nt bod

l rs rh'u whiht cam i Grund21i basd:De s a Coni (d .,Vi e O fndes 0 eeac ' pon c he li n o s e Lii nd s e s) olnt je r: 1 The y,Ree c ,Pubi Polc an Pr tc ( tn,20 )a 23753'Gol t n,(d.,Fo e sc 1 or s ar h lc iy, d acie Boso 08 t - , dsei e ) r n i 1 Ps hoo ( .llofl ) W en r(d., ndbo o yc lgy@ e Yor 2 .Clnni ha 2 yc lgy vol 2 . ie e )Ha ok fps hoo , w k, 003) l ng m, ,
1 Re dy a Sor ns n, ' s ri oft ur Da r n s a Fe r Ca t lSe e ng:Ra e a 3 i nd e e çAs e t ons Fut e nge ous es ' t de al pia nt nci t s nd

1 Coreae o Su e e pùs ic duc = dVi e e, a 4 r lts f bs qu nt onM s on t olnc Law ndHumanScl f t pt2 . n /cvor se . 007) a d ,
15 Ct ngham and Sor en,Pr ctveFact sf Vi ent i mni ens edi i or or ol M sconducti Cl e Cusoôy, l n os t pràonlournal

1 8 2 - ( 07) f a 24.Pez el sae :l hieefe tvecoms l dha pr e e e pet 6 7> 4153 20 . #. t toc li tts tW l fci t e woul ve esntd x r '
17 t i ony 9om an i tt i i i expcr t r estm nsiutonalzaton t o ebutt St e' evi i y pr he at s dentar esent i offum r aton e

1 d nge ous s i t pe ly p s , he eha e be n m a a n si t lt r t esncet e ' 1 a 8 a r ne s n he na t ha e t r v e ny dva ce n he ie a ur i h n. d. t ' 1 24- . 9 25 2 0 The c a m i Gr nd 21 i a cl m ofi f e tve a s sa e oft i lcou el A s i di c s d, l i n ou s ai ne f c i s it nc ra ns . s s us e

21 a , t r adt Gr 7()t a l i ofacai ofiefb tveassa eofc ns ll ksat bove wih eg r o ound e,he nayss l m n fci sitnc ou e oo
22 whet rcot s spe or he m el' rf mancew asreas onabl com pet i lghtofpr lng pr es onalnormsat y cnt n i evaii of si

23 t e tme. Se sl l / t?l, U . a 688 89.s a s Bob y v V H oo - -U . -- ,1 0 S. .l h i e ' ' c pi 466 S. t - , ee l o rc f b . an k, - S. - - 3 Ct 3,

24 l 1 1 L. 2d255 ( 09 . Be a e un rStikatd,t a l i ofc s lspe f r nc i 6- 7, 75 Ed. 20 ) c us , de rc l t he nayss oun e ' ro ma e s
25 conduct f om t per pectve oft tme oft ti ,s ed r he s i he i he ral ubsequc advances i t lt at e have no nt n he ier ur

26

:

18

.
;

E

(
!

1 be rng on t is ofi îe ie as it n ofc ns l a c ra nl do no s ow go c us f ai be s ue ne fctv ssa ce ou e, nd e ti y th od a e or
2 Pet ocelisf l e t exbaus t s cl m . r l' aiur o t hi ai

q ! '

3

Pe r c li l o a gue , n t s m ege rcm a me f t d t ougho bi m oton f sa t t s t o e l a s r s i he a ne i r r o m hr ut s i or t y,ha hi

4 c ouns we e i f ctv f f lng t e u t t s cl i . n i ba d a s ri n,howe r doe no el r nefe i e or aii o xba s hi a m s l s elo ve , s t

5 esa ihgo c us , t nt emea ngofLt ne de ii Se d s us i of o 8( ) s pr tbls od a e wihi h ni tcRhi s cson. e ic son Gr und b , u a.
.

6

Gr ound 22

E I 1
1

7 l Gr u d 2 ,Perc l camsta hsc n t in lrg t we eviltd b c us Mr n o n 2 to el li h t i o si o a ihs r oae e a e . i mt 8 Pe el' ca tltils tn n a rviw ondie ta a weec ducedbeor saej ca koc lis pia ra, ene cig, nd e e rc ppe l r on t f e tt udiil
9 ofi e s whos t n e i ofi e w a notdu i go be vi bu w bo e t nur wa de nd nt o tc r e e ur n fc s rng od ha or t s e e s pe e n

1 populree ton. FourhAme e Peii p. 9, e aloi a pp. 9- 1 0 a lci ' ' t nd d tton, 31 ' e s d. t 31 2 . s
ll Petoceliar r l guest hi appelat and sat postconvi i couns wer i f i f f lng hat s le te cton el e nef ectve or aii 1 t exbaus t sisue i t s at court See M oton f St p. Tbe courtdoesnotacce such a 2 o t hi s n he t e s. i or ay, 25. pt 13 bal cl m of i f ectve as st d ai ne f i si ance of cot s # w ihout.m or as satsf i of t good- e m el t e, i acton he caus
'

;

1 r q r me i e byRhi s Se dic s in ofGr nd 8( , pr 4 e uie nt mpos d ne . e s u so ou b) su a.
;

:
:

1 5

Gr ound 23

1 6

l Gr nd 23, toc l c a m st thi c ns i tona rgh swer vi a e t c us e c i n ou Pe r eli l i ha s o tm i l i t e ol t d t a e xe uton be

i
i

1 b lta ij cin voae te c n tmt n lp o i t n a an tc u la d u u u lp ns me t. 7 y eh l ne t ilts h o si i a r hbio g is re n n s a u ih ns' o o i '
1 Fo t Am e d Pe ii p. 2. eealo i a pp. 8 urb nde tton, 32 , s s d. t 322- 0. 3
J 9 W ih r t espectt t s cl m , Petocelisentr ar ent i hi m oton f s ay,i as f l s: o hi ai r l ' ie gum , n s i or t s olow . The courthasrul t t sci m i t exhaust H ow ever good caus ed hat hi ai s m ed. , e

:
20 21

e sst alow Pettone t r tr t saec xit o l ii r o eu n ? t t ounst e us t sca m.M u h oft o xha t hi li c he
;
i or aton upon whi t scl m l based i quie new . See Exhi t 142-1 A t nf m i ch hi ai s s t bis 46. t tm e ofPe ii r sa c o s a e ha a a tons m uc oft ba kgr und o t he i ttone ' pp al r t t be s c i , h he c o n he

E
!

22
23

Ne dalt ij cinpr oc wa silnotpubi knowl ge s t r wo dha va eha)ne to ot o) s tl lc ed , o bee ul ve
be nno f a i ewa f i t ha ebe n s c s f l r ie pr vi l n i e c sbl y or t o v e uc e suly as d c ousy. s pr bl a c nt f rt ef c t tt ecli wasno pr s ntd t t Ne da oba y c ou s o h a t ha h am t e e e o be va Supr m e Co ti t I s r und o s a e ha a p oc e ngs Pe ii rs d be e ur n he a t o f t t be s r e di . ttone houl

i
i

24

alo dt e au tt scli i t sa ec rs lwe o xh s bi am n he tt ou t.

25 M o i f Sty, pp. - ( t i t or re trdMac 23 201 (oc t ton or a 2526 ci on o de nee rh , 0 d ke #200)omitd) at tc .
i E 26 19

1

.

'

;

:

.

.

:

1 i
!

Ex bi l i a c py of t N e da D e r m e t of Core ton tconfde i l Exe uto hi t 42 s o he va pa t n r c i s' t i nta c in
: '

2 M a l' asr vie i Fe u r 20 nua ' e s d n br a y 04. Ex bi 1 i a c ofa a i u bre fl d i t Unie hi t 43 s opy n m c s i f ie n he t d 3 St t Supr m e Cou t i a c s outof t El ve h Cic t Co t of A p l e il d Ne s v a es e r n ae he e nt r ui ur pea s ntte l on . 4 Ca mpbel Ex bi 1 i a c ofa La V e s Sun a tc e, r M a c 1 200 e il d tKil r l. hi t 44 s opy s ga ri l f om r h 8, 4, ntte ' le

:

5 M akes Fi Requessy'r di t t i m i nte nal t ' egar ng he ben-m ne xecuton ofLawr i enceCol l Exbi t145 i wel. bi s

6 ac py o a a tcefom ame c lj n ,TbeLa c ,e ild tna quaeAna she i i Leha o f n ril r dia oural n et ntte e de t l e t sa n t l i !
!
!

7 ljci f Exe utony' tdAprl1 2005 And,Exhbi l i ade lrtonofMakJ S. ah, ne ton or c i 'dae i 6, . i t 46 s caai r . He t
8 M . . a r nty p oduc d f us i t c s ofBe t v. c ani l 2: 4- v- 5- D - F,a d D , ppa e l r e or e n he a e es M D e , 0 c 008 KJ GW n
9 s gned by D r H eat on M ay l6,2006. i . h

1 0

Petoc lidoe notd s rbe w ha e f t he m a whie i sat c r ,t o ai t e N e da r el s e ci t f ors de, l n t e ou t o bt n h va

11 De r me ofCore i ' xe uton m a l i or rt s pa t nt r ctons e c i nua , n de o uppor hi s a e c r ltga i o t c a m t s t t ou t ii ton f he l i
12 i Gr n ound 23.nordoes Petoceliexpl n why t docum entcoul nothavc becn obt ned by mcans , r l ai hat d ai

!

1 ofa s po naorot e l ga pr e s i s a e c t Pe r lidoe note a n t s g fc nc oft 3 ub e h r e l oc s n t t our . toce l s xpl i he i ni i a e he
14 am i bref9om t Nel case, w ih r pectt hi cl m ed abiiy t exhaus t cl m heset f h cus i he son t es o s ai lt o t he ai s ort

;
!

1 i G r und 23. Si ia l wih r s c t t M ar 1 2004, s Ve s S a t e a t Aprl1 5 n o m l ry, t e pe t o he ch 8, La ga un ri nd he i 6, cl '
!

1 200 La eta tcl Pe r e l doe noti ntf w ha i or a i i t e a tcl s he c a m s wa 6 5, nc ri e, toc li s de iy t nf m ton n bos ri e li s 1 ne e s r t hi a lt t e us hi c ai .Fi ly, toc li snot s rbet cic s a e of 7 c s a y o s biiy o xha t s l m na l Pe r e l doe de c i he r um t nc s

:

1 t pr cton oft He t de l r ton he d snote a n wby t tde l r i n, o s m ia t i, 8 he odu i he a h c a a i , oe xpl i ha c a ato or nt i l r o t 1 co d notha be n obt i d e ri r a hedo s n pr vi e a e a ton w hy t i or a i n i 9 ul ve e a ne a le , nd e ot o d ny xpl na i he nf m to n

20 t tde lr tonwasne e s r t hi e usi ofh sca m. ha c a ai c s a y o s xha ton i li
!

21

Tbe r c d s owst tPetoc l wa a e t a i f ct d, r i ul e hi Gr nd 23 cl i i e or h ha z eli s bl o, nd n a di a tc at s ou am n

2 sat c ti 20 whe hei ta e hi t r s a e h be sac i Jc Ex bi 26, 3 38.Howe r 2 t e our n 03 n nii t d s hid t t a a ton. e hi t pp. 4ve ,

i
.

23 Per ela n dta cai ona aland,t r f r di notexhaus i.See Exhi t 38 a 40. toc li ba done h t l m ppe , he e o e, d tt bis nd
2 Pe r ce i ha m a no s 4 to li s de howi ofg d c us f h sa ndon e toft c a m on t a pc i hi ng oo a e or i ba m n he l i he p al n s
. .

l

t he ai n al 25 t r sa eh bea a to , orf hi f l e t exhaus t cl m i gener . hid tt a s c in or s aiur o
26

;

I

i
2 0

!

'

a

.

; :

E
; I

1 2
:
'
.

Gr ound 24 l Gr n ound 24, Pe r c l cl i st thi c nsi ton rgh swe evi a e t ue t t f iur o t o eli a m ha s o tm i al i t r ol t d t o he a l e f d
.

3 t N evadaSupr eCourtt conductf rand adequat appelat r ew .'Fourh Am ended Petton, he em o ai e l e evi ' t ii 4 p.33l;see al î .atpp.331so ' # 33. 5 l hi m oton f st Petoceliar n s i or ay, z l guest t e i good cause f hi f i e t exhaus t s hat her s or s aiur o t hi

:

!
i

6 cl i i s a e c l , hi die ta pea ,t s i c ul notha be n br hte r i ron a a , i i a m n t t ou ' on s r c p l ç t o d t a ve e oug a le ppe l as t s 7 ba e on t de i i ci o t die ta pc opi o ' M oto f St y,p.26. Thi ar m e ,of sd he fc en es f he r c p al ni n. ' i n or a s gu nt
8 cour e, s doesnotaddr st r ques i w hi i why w ast scl m notr sed i any ofPetocelis es he eal ton, ch s: hi ai ai n r l'
'

'

i : I

9 t eesat habeasactons? A ûerr pondent posedt tqueston i t rr ponset t m oton f say hr t e i es s ha i n hei es o he i or t

1 (e Opposten t Moton f Sty,p.60) Pez el ague i bi rpl < st why i wa not 0 se ii o i or a , toc li r d, n s e y; L o A t s
11 pr e e i sat pos - o c i n pr e di , ttone ha c ai e t ti i duet i f e tve poses nt d n t e t c nvi to oc e ngs Pe ii r s l m d ha t s o ne f c i t 1 c c i co s . Re y i S 2 onvi ton un el ' pl n uppor of M oton f St y,p.35. Pelo li p ovi s no f r he ' t i or a ce l r de ut r

'

!

! '

1 a gume a ut ora s bsa iton o s c a cli ofi fkci a ssa e o pos- nvi in 3 r nt bo , ny u tnta i t u h a m nel tve s itnc f tco cto
1 c m s l Suc aba d c a m ofi fe i a s s a eof ot s , ihout or doe not ats yt good 4 ot e . h l l i ne f ctve s i t nc c m elw t m e, s s i f he -

i i

1 c u epr ng oft Rhi s sa r s.Se d s us i ofGr nd 8( ,s pr 5 as o he ne tnda d e ic son ou b) u a.
1 6
1 7

Gr ound25
l Gr n ound 25 Pe r e l cl i s t thi c s iu i nalrght w e e vi a e tb t f l e t , toc li a m ha s on tt to i s r ol t d t y he aiur o

i 1 i

1 s ta1o t eeme sofc pia elgi lt t t grndj yort t c ur f aprba ec us 8 ubmi 1 f be l nt a tl i biiy o he a ur o he o tor o bl a e

1 d tr n to . Fo rhAme d dPeiin p. 3 , e as i. t p. 3 - 5 9 eemiain' u t ' n e t o , 3 4 s e lo d a p 3 4 3 . t *
2 0 l hi motonf sa Per cel a s rst a t scam ba me i ( l i wiho a cia i t n s i or ty, to li s e t h t hi li s rt abet t ut ny tton o

i
I

t 21 any contoli lg l uh r y , and t Petoceligoest s at w iboute anaton: ç''ef l t r lng e a a to i ) hen r l o t e, t xpl i s' aiure o lh
i or ay 22 r s t scl m eari asnotPettoner' f t' M oton f St ,p.27.l bi r y,Petocelias t aie bi ai lerw ii s aul. ' n s épl r l sers

p
! '

23 t ti f c i a s s a e ofhi pos - onvi i .ouns li go ca s f hi f l r t ex us t ha nefe tve s i t nc s t c cton c e s od u e or s aiu e o ba t he 2 cai Se Re y i Su 4 l m. e pl n ppor o M oto f rSty, ' 36. t f in o a pp. 3525

I

-

26
@

!

21

l

Asi dic s bo , hec t snot c e s h ac a m ofi f ctvea s s a ofc s s us eda ve t our doe a c pt uc l i nefe i s i tnce ouns l e,

2 w ihoutm or as s if ton oft good- e r r e i t e, ats ac i be caus equiem nt mposed by Rhi nes. See di si of scus on

3 Grund8b)spr o ( , u a.
4 5 G r d 26 oun l Cr n zound 26,Petocelicl m st hi constt i r l ai bat s iutonalrght w er vi at tbecaus t deat i s e ol ed t e he h

6 pe ly i c u lan u ua punibm e i a 1c r um sa e . Fou t Am e d Pe ii p. , ee na t s r e d nus l s nt n 1 ic t nc s ' ' rh nde tton, 336* s
7 al i atpp.336so d. 37. 8 Th s ge r lc l nge t t de t pe ly co lc s w ib t hol ng of t Unied St t s i ne a hale o he a h na t nfi t t he di he t ae

9 Su e Co ti B=ev Re s, U. 35(008) I t tc s ,t Cour r ldta e c inby prme ur n . e 553 S. 2 . n ha a e be t ue h t xe uto

1 lt lij ci a c ni douti Ke mc wa c tmtona.l a ast Ba eb di f e l e 0 eha ne ton s a e n n ky s onsi i l t ppe r he z ol ng orcoss
11 Petocelisar z e t t deat penaly, m a t how adm i st ed,i necess iy unconstm tonal z l' gtm nt hat he b t no ter ni er s arl i i .

1 Pe r e l doe no e pl i how h sc a m i Gr nd 26 c ul ba a pos i e me i i lghto Bu e. 2 toc li s t x a n i l i n ou o d ve ny sbl rt n i f z 1 3 Furhe r ,Pe r e l doe nots ow good c us f rhi f l e t e a tt scl i i sa e t nno e toc li s h a e o s aiur o xh us hi a m n t t

1 c r.Peeo eli ctalya s re t scli i t saeditit our i hi t r sat b e a to ( e 4 ou t c la u l s e td hi am n he tt src c l n s hid t e ab as ci n s e

1 Exbi t26, 2829)buthedi n r iet is ebeor t Ne daSu e Cou to t a a 5 bi pp. - , d ot as he su f e be va prme r n be ppe l
l i t ta to Se Ex bis38 a 40. 6 n ha c i n. e hi t nd
l7 1 8 1 9 Petoceliar r l gues: Pe ii ne r que t t the be a l tto r e s s ha lowed t e u tt sc a m i t s a ec r s The e o xha s hi l i n he t t ou t . r i t d c us 'f t sr que t c us M r Pe r c lia s r st tunde m o r s' goo a e' or hi e s be a e . t o e l s e t ba r de n, evol ng s ndar ofdecency,i i crue!and unus puni hm entf t gover ent vi m ds ts ual s or he nm t lilis own cii o (l t tzens. A st hese sandar have evol si Pettonerw asl i t ds ved nce ii ast n sat c ul , hos c rs s l be a l de a opponuniy t r l on t s c a m . t e o - t e ou t hou d t fbr d n t o u e hi l i

2 0

2 l M oton f ay, 27.Petoceliof er no explnaton how tsandar ofdecency'haveevol si i orst p. r l f s a i tt ds ' ved nce

2 he Itg e hi t r sa e ha a a to 2 ii at d s hid t t be s c i n. 2 3 Pe r elia s a s rs w ih r s c t t sc ai , sge rc a gu e t tt r i g ca e toc l l o s e t , t e pe t o hi l m hi ne i r m nt ha he e s ood us

2 f hi f iur t e la tt s c a m be a e ofi efkc i n s ofhi c 4 or s a l e o x l us bi l i c us n t tye es s ouns i f lng t r ie i on el n aii o a s t 25 die ta pe lo on t e a pc li a y ofhi t e s a e ha ea a to . Se M oton f St y, 27rc p a r h p a n n s hr e t t b s c i ns e i or a pp. 28.
26

'

: .

:

1
.
:

!
i

J Pe kocel ' bal cl i of ne f c i a s s a eof ns wih tm or , oe n e t bls goo c us lss d a m i f e tve s i t nc cou el t ou e d s ot sa ih d a e

2 frhi fiuet e us t scam.Se dsusi o Gr nd8( , u a. o s alr o xha thi li e ic son f ou b) spr
3 Gr nd 27 ou .

4
I

I Gr d 27 Pe r el ca mst thi 4 nvito an s n e e a ei ld pu s ntt t n oun toc li li ha s t co ci n d e t nc r nvai rua o he

5 r g s a p otctons a f de bi und r t l e na i lCov an on Ci la d Poltca l i s ' i ht nd r e i for d m e he nt r tona en t vi n ii l t ght . ' :
:

6 Fo t Am e e Pe ii n,p. , e alo i a pp.3 3 urb nd d tto 338. e s d. t s 38- 9.

7
:

He ea i Per c l ma t e cam i Gr d 27 be or t sa edititc ti hi t r r gan, to eli de h li n oun f e he tt src our n s hid
.

8 saeh be a to ( eEx biz6 p 40- )but di n r s t is beor t va aSuprme tt a as cin se hi t ' p. 41, he d otaie he sue f e heNe d e
9 Courton t appeali t acton. See Exhi t 38 and 40. he n hat i bis

:

1 0
i

Pe r el a gue t a t r i good c us f hi f l e t e ha ttls c am t ca e toc li r s h t he e s a e or s aiur o x us li l i t us be

11 i t m atona l w i i r a i y bei co i er by va i sc r si t i r i .'M oton f St y, n e i l a s nc e sngl ng ns d ed r ou ou t n he r ulngs' i or a 1
i

toc ls f r u t r x a i n r u r f r ha r m nt t s ot how ng 1 p.28.Pe e l ofe sno f rhe e pl nato o s ppo t o t ta gu e .I i n as i ofgood 2

1 cuefr sfi r t e h uth cam. 3 a s o hi al e o x a ste li u
1 4 . Furt m or Petoceliscl m ofi f i as sanceofcouns ,f notr sng t scl m on her e, r l' ai nef ectve sit el or aii ài ai

1 d r c a a oron t a a i a y ofhi s a eha a a tons w ihou m or doe no e t bls g 5 i e t ppe l he ppe l n n s t t be s c i , t t e, s t s a ih ood
!

1 c us f hi f iur t e ha tt sc a m . Se dic sonofGr md81)spr 6 a e or s a l e o x us hi l i e susi ot , u a. 1 7 Gr und 28 o

1 8
'

l Gr n ound28, to elicai t thi de t s ntnc i unc tt tona ' c us oft rs Pe r c l l ms ha s ah e e e s onsiu i l ç a e he ik be

1 t tt ir pa a e pu s e tofe c i wilbe a i d t i e tpe s . Fourh Am e d 9 ha he r e r bl nihm n xe uton l pple o nnoc n r ons' ' t nde
20 Petton,p.340*see alo i atpp.340ii , s d. 42.

.

'

E

2l

Pet oceliar r l guest t e i good causef hi f l e t exhaus t scl m ,asf l hat her s or s aiur o t hi ai olows:

E
.

2 2
23
24
25

Th ei X er s t c us 'frt srque t(ob al dt e us t scai i tesae good a e'o hi e s t e lowe o xha thi l m n h tt c qa t r hno f u tofPeiine t scam wasn rpr o l pr s ntd i ouns s h oug al tto r hi li eve eviusy e e e n

sat c r . A d tc l snc hi l s r nd ofsat b a pr ee i gs t f c al t e ou t diimaly, i e s a t ou t e abr s oc d n ' be a m t ba i oft e cl i ha s fe i Pe ii ne ,s f vordu t w i s e d pu l iy s s h a m s hit d n tto r a e o de pr a blc t r di t pos bl executon ofi egar ng he si e i nnocentper ons. An exam pl woul be t s e d he w i s e d c r e s r ga di g t To W ilngha c s i Ttxa . de pr a ontov r y e r n he dd li m a e n s
.

I

' '

'

'

26
23

. :

. .

I

;

;
! '
!

l M oton f rSt y, 28- The ei no f rhe e pl na i ors ppor f rt sa gu e .Thea l g ton i o a pp. 29. r s u t r x a ton u t o hi r m nt le a i
2 t t e was notas m uch upublciy r di t pos bl extcuton of i hat her i t egar ng he si e i nnocentper ons,wben s ,

3 Peto eliltgatd h sdie t ppe l hi t r e sat ha ea a tt s a t e e i n do sno! m ou r c l ii e i r c a a and s h e t e b s c im , s h r s ow, e a nt 4 t a s w i ofgo c s f Pe r e i, f l e t e us . o ho ng od au e or toc lis aiur o xha t
5 Furher or Petoceliscl m ofi f i as sanceofcouns , ornotr si t scl m on t m e, r l' ai nef ectve sit el f ai ng hi ai

I
.

6 die t pe loron t a a i a ofhi sa eha a a to ,w iho m or , esnote t bls go r c ap a he ppe l n ny s t t be s c i ns t ut e do s a ih od

i

7 c us f rhi f it et e a tt scli .Se dic sonofGr und 8 b) s pr a e o s all o xh us hi am e s us i r o ( , u a.
I

.

!
i

8 .

'

Gr nd 29 ou

9

l Gru d2 P to elcamsta hsc nttto arg th v b e voae b cue'th n o n 9, e cli li h t i o si in lihs a e en iltd ea s tle u l
.

10 e xecuton ofa deat sent i h ence aferkee ng t condem ned on deat r f an i di e am ountof t pi be h ow or nor nat

1l tm e c tm t sc ue a t u lpunihm e . Fourh Am e d Pe ii n, 3 , e al o i a pp. i onsi e r l nd mus a s nt' ' t nde tto p. 43' e s d. t s
E 12 34353.

1 3 E

W ihr pe t t q s i of t es ct o he ue ton goodca lef hi f iur t e u t hi c a m , toc li r ue : t or s a l e o xha s t s l i Pe r e l a g s ' s

1 4
' 15 16

Th r i l dc us 'ort srqu s (ob al dt e a tt scli i t sae ec s ç goo a e'f hi e e t t e l owe o xh us hi am n he tt c urs a t ou n fulofPeii ert saec rsha ne rh te o t) s hr gh o a t tton ,he tt ou t ve ve ad h
oppor uniy t nle on i.The cicum sancesoft cl m havecbanged s nceM r. t t o l t r t he ai i Pe r e l wasl s i s a e c t a s v r a dii alye r ha bee ad d t hi toc li a t n t t our, s e e al d ton a s ve n de o s confne ent t ough no choi ofhi own. A ddii l t t ext t appelat i m , hr ce s tonaly, o he ent hat le

i i i

1 7 l 8 1 9

c s la saepos-on ci co elaie t r s t sis o die ta pe l oun e nd tt tc viton uns f ld o aie hi sue n rc p a,

t i d e i a ss a e de r v d M r Pe r c l ofhi s a e a f de ald pr e s he r ef ctve s it nc p i e . t o eli s t t nd e r ue oc s a e alpr ec i rgh t efe tve as it nceofc s lon a al nd i pos nd qu ot ton i t o f c i s s a oun e ppe a n t c c i a gua a t d by t e Fit Si h,Ei ht a Foure nt Am e e t t onvi ton, s r nt e h fh, xt g h nd le h ndm n s o

t Consiuton. be tt i
20 M oto f St y, 29. i n or a p.
21 The f t Petocelihas been confned f sever addii act hat r l i or al tonalyear - aboutf l year s otr sz

2 a mal -sn eh lt ae hsls saeh b a a to , o s t sa l hg o c u efrhsfi r t 2 c ly ic e ii td i a t tt a e s cin d e no etbi o d a s o i al e o g s u
23 exhaustt s cl m i t st e habeasacton. hi ai n hat at i

2 4
E

M or ove , t o lisc a m o i f e tvea s sa eofc ns , orn r sngt scl m i a e r Pe r ce l' l i f ne f c i s it nc ou elf ot aii hi ai n ny

25 ofhi s at habeasactons, w ihoutm or does nolestblsh good cause f hi f l e t exhaustt s ste i t e, a i or s aiur o hi

26 c ai ' Se dicu sonof o 8( , t l l m. e s s i Grund b)st ' p a.

!

2 4

'
!
;

. '

' *

1

1

Gr und 30 o

2
!
.

l Gr 30,percel camst tbi c tt ina rg siav be nvi ae x et t n ound to li li ha s onsiuto l ibt l e e oltd g o he du

3 c ul tvee r si t a s i n ofe de ea i s r tons gr sm ic uc by St t of i i sa um a i r or n he dmi s o vi nc nd n tuc i , os s ond t a e fc al nd 4 wi es e , n i es t ma i prva i m s sa d ys e tcde i tonof . toc lisrgh t t f e tvea s sa W Pe r e l ' i t o hee f c i s it nceofc uns . o el ' '

(

5 Four h Am ended Pettc p.354,see al i atpp.354t iim, . so d. 56.

6

Pe r ce l' onl a gu e t tt r i g d c us f h sf iu e t e us t sc a m i hi to lis y r m nt ha he e s oo a e or i a l r o xba t hi l i s s

.

7 blnke i f e tve a s sa ofc ns l r e t As i di c s d a ve t c t snot c pt s a t ne f c i s it nce ou e a gum n . s s us e bo , he our doe ac e a

1 !

8 goo ca e unde Rhq s Per elis bad sae ntt thi c uns lwee i fe i f not d us, r ne , toc l' l ttme ha s o e r nefctve or

1
7
!

9 e ba sigtecam.S eds u so o Gr u d8b , u a. x u t i li e ic sin f o n ()s pr n l
l 0 ll Gr und 31 o Fi ly,i Gr nd 31 Pe r e l c ai st a hi c c i a s nt nc a e t ors i tona na l n ou toc li l m h t s onvi ton nd e e e r mc utm i l
.

12 tbecaus he m ay becom e i t e ncom pet t be e ent o xecut ' Fourh Am ended Petton,p.357. ed.' t ii
i !

13

l appear t Gr t j hat ound 31doesnot atl att s tm e:st e apot ntaly m eriorous cl m . , east hi i at e il t i ai

1 Se Mari z Vil e v Stwar,l1 F.d628, 32- ( hCi.99 ,s r ds bnom. e t 4 e tne- laral . e t 8 3 6 35 9t r1 7)a me u Stwar v. 1 M ari z Vil eal5 U. 6 11 S. .1 8( 998 . M oe r i Pa tiv Qu tr 551 5 tne - lar , 23 S. 37, 8 Ct 61 1 ) rove,n net . areman,
i !

1 U. 930( 6 S. 2007)t Su e Cou t dta ii un c s r t as a tui cam ofi o tnc ,he prme rhel h tts ne esay or ie n u pe li nc mpee y
.

l i a iiil a esp tt ni od rt peewet cam. 7 n n nta h b a eio n re o rsl he li i
i
I
,

1 8

Re r ng t e que ton of good c s f hi f iu e t e us t s c ai i s a e c t ga di h si au e or s a l r o xha t hi l m n t t our,

19 Petoceliar r l gues:

20
2l

The ei t r s ' c us 'f t sr qu t(o b alowe t e us t scai i t sa e good a e' or bi e es t e l d o xha t hi l m n he tt co )a ia ast acam a iiatngic uns s t ppe r hat li ntcp i n ompeen et bee c e s ul be t c o xe utd ho d
r i e i a i tal tton f rwrtofh e s c u . M ar i z- ar a v St war , a s d n n nii pe ii o i ab a om s tne Vdl e l . e t

'

: '

2 2
23

1 8F. 628(t Ci.997,J ?n ls bn)a. e tv Mari z vil e l 5 l 3d 9h rl ) xi- c u tr Stwar . tne- lar a, 23 ? U. 63 l1 S. .1 8(998) MrPerc lt r or rquet t ttesae S. 7, 8 Ct 61 1 . . to eliheef e e ss ha h tt c rsha a opro rniy t trtr l on t scli s t tim a bepr s l df ou t ve n ru t o is ue hi am o ha t y e ewe or
f dc al be s r vl w . e r ha a t e

i
(
!

.on o a p. 0- . 24 M o i f r St y,p 3 31 Butt M a - le - lar ala gum e doe notesa ih go c us f r t he l i3 z vil e r t nt s t bls od a e o
25 Per el' fiur t e a tt scai i sat c ur.Per elic dha e usé t scam j t toc lis al e o xh us hi l m n t e o t toc l oul ve xha td hi li us
26
25

qw
: t ' à

.

.

i

1 aswel i hi t r sat habeas acton ashe coul now . To tl ext such a cl m woul have been l n s hid t e i d le ent ai d
.

2 hel t be pr at e i Petocelist r sat ha do em ur n r l' hid t e beasacton)i w oul be now aswel. i t d l 3 Kelv l 4 Petocelireques s a K ely s ay, i t aler i i cas a Rhi say i notgr ed. See l t l t n he t natve, n e nes t s ant

i

5 M oton f St pp.33- n e courtw ildeny t r i or ay, 47. l hat equest .

!
I

6

j n v Ryan, 64F. 1 33( hci. )tec r of pe sh dt ti a to t t nKig 5 3d 1 9t r2009,b ou t ap al el ha,n ddiin o be
.

7 say pr t ocedur aut zed i Rhi ,dit i cours r ai di eton t per i pettoner t f l t e hori n nes s rct t et n scr i o m t ii s o olow he

8 t e -tpsé a a ya eprc ur a ov i Cad r nv U. DitCt( yl j 1 F. 981 hrese ty-nd-be nc o ed e ppr ed n le o . S. s. .Ta or, 34 3d , 9 98 ( h Ci.9 ,a Kel v Smal,31 F.d 1 63 ( h Ci. 03) Folowi t tpr e r 6 9t r1 98) nd l . l 5 3 0 9t r20 . l ng ha oc due y
:
.

E

1 (omei sr erdt a t L l3 oc d e' ai l s ':()apeii ra ndshspetton 0 s tme efre o s be G l pr e ur'or k l my' 1 ttone me i ii Ke ) Ke y ) 1 l d eea yune use cli ;()t dsrct ur sa a holsi a ya et a nde f ly 1 o elt n xba td ams 2 be iti co t tys nd d n be nc he me d, ul
1 e ba td peii n,a l ng t p ttone t op runiy t pr e d t s e c tt e us t 2 x use tto lowi be e ii r he po t t o oc e o mt our o xha t he

1 deee cli . nd( t peii e l e a ndshi peii a i i or ai t ne y- xha se 3 ltd ams a 3) he tton r atr me s tton gan nc por tng he wl e u td ,
:

r
;

l cl m s K e l 31 F. a 1 0- 1 The Ke l pr e r hm n r quie e ofa s 4 ai . l y, 5 3d t 07 7 . l oc du e s o e r m nt y bowi g ofgood n
15 cause f t pettoner' f l e t e or he ii s aiur o xbausl .

r

1 6

Ho e rc w ve , ompar t t Rhi spr e e t eA'/ypr c dtr ha a sgnii a dr wba k f r ed o he ne oc dur , h c / o e le s i tc nt a c o

1 pe ii er Unl t Rhi s pr e e t e K e l pr e e do s no h n t pr e tape ii ne s 7 tton s. i he ne oc dur , h ke l oc dur e t i g o ot c y tto r :
;
'

l u xha t d c a m s fom untm e i s i t e i t rm . Ki g,5 F. a 11 . 8 ne us e l i r i lne s n h n e i n 64 3d t 41
.

1 9

OnAprl 4,1 t i2 996,hcM rtrors a ie r im ndEfe i eDe t Pc lyAclAEDPA) fclv ah nat ( wentnt fe t i oe f c .

20 PU .L. b No.1 1 2,1 0 Stt 1 l 1 ( 9 . n eAEDPA ma vai amc dme st t 04- 3 1 a. 2 4-226 l 96) de rous n nt o he 21 s a ut sc ntoli f de a ha a c p pr ctc Oneoft am endm ent i pos aone- st ut t t e o r lng e r l be s or us a i e be s m ed year at e
.

E
:

22 oflmia i nso t fln o f de a ha asco puspe ii .W ih r s c t t s a t oflm iatons i t to n he ii g f e r l be r ttons t e pe t o he t m e i t i , 23 t ha a c puss a ut pr vi s he be s or t t e o de :

2 4
E
:

25 26

( ( )A 1ye rpei oflmiato s la yt a a i tonfra d)1 - a rod i t in hal ppl o n pplcai o wrtofha a c pusbyapes i c t pus ntt t j me i be s or ron n usody rua o he udg nt
ofa St e cour. The im iaton perod s lrun f om t l es ofat t i ti i hal r he at t

26

1 ! I I

.

. q

l 1

I
!
'

l
2

co u i ofdiec r v e ort e ex r i n oft e tm e f r ncl s on r t e iw b piato h i o s ng s revi eeki ucb ew;

( tedat o whibt udg tbe a fna byt A) h e n c hej men c me i l he

:
i

3
4
5

( t daeonwhiht i di n t tlnga a iai B)he t c he mpe me t o ii n pplc ton c e e b St ea in i vi aton o t Consi i o lws r ald y at cto n ol i f he tmton r a
f om flng by such St e acton; r ii at i

oft U m t d St t s i r m ove i t e a i ntw a pr ve e he e ae s e d, f h pplca s e nt d

:
!

6
7

( t d eonwhih t c tmtona rghta s re wa C) he at c he onsi i l i s e td s
i ta l r c z d by t Supr m e Cour,i t r g ha nii ly e ogni e he e t f he i ht s be n ne y r c ni ed by t Sup e e Cou - a d m a e wl e og z he r m l n t de r r i y applcabl t caseson colat alr ew 'or etoactvel i eo l er evi ,

8
9

(aitedes ntdcoultevebeenpecove edthoughmher D)h rt o whc dh fcu ldidct o teca to ae n ih ba ata r iae fhr li c m sp e e l s r
ci e igence. ex er s ofdue dii

i

1 28U. C.j22 ( () n eAEDPA Imiainsp idi t ldwhiea' o ryflda iaton' 0 S. 44d)1. i tto ero s ole l ' pel e pplc i ' pr l1 f os c itono he olaealeifi pe n beoeasaec r.28U. C. 2 d( .The orp t onvci rot rc ltr rle s ndig fr tt ou t S. â 244()2)
1 lm ia i nspe i i n t l d, 2 i t to rod s ot ole howe er du i g t epe nc ofaf de al ab spetton.Se un an v , r n h nde y e r b ea ii eD c

E

'
I

1 v.Wale ,5 U . 1 ( 01 . 3 k r 33 S. 67 20 )
1 4 n e e or ,i t Kel pr c du ei f l d,i o d rt a d asaut oflmiai ba ,t e r f e f be l o e r s olowe n r e o voi tt e i t tons r l y l
' 1 ne y- xh us e c a m s wbi b a e t b s tf t i an a e de pe ii al rt s a i lfe m us 5 wl e a t d l i , c r o e e orh n m n d tton fe he t y s i td, t

i
i i

1 rlt ba kt cli i tef ly e austd sayedpetton.SeeKig,564F.d at1142. 6 eac c o ams n h ul xh e t ii n 3
-

l 7

t a n metf pedn rlts akote aeo te r iapedn whn.te li % med no a laig eae bc t h dt fh oin lla ig e .h cam An g .

1 ..a s re i t a e de pl a n a os o oft c nduc ,t a s c i n,o oc ure e s tf t or 8 . s e t d n he m n d e di g r e ut he o t r n a to r c r nc e orh

1 atmptdt bes tf t i t orgi l e di Fe R. v. o.l ( )2) j a ev Fei 5 7. 9 te e o e orh n he i na pla ng. d. Ci Pr 5 c ( . nM yl . lx, 451 5.
'

20 644(005) t Su e Cour bedt tapciine ma a ndt a ane cam i oape ng 2 ,be prme t l ha tto r y me o dd w li nt ndi
21 f de a ha a pe ii a t r t e pia i of t lm ia i pe i onl i t e new c a m s r s a e r l be s tton fe he x r ton he i t tons rod y f h l i ha e . 22 .com m on cor ofoper i f s,w ih t cl m si t pe ng petton. M a e 545U . a 6 An : e atve act , t be ai n he ndi ii yl , S. t 59.

i
p

23 a nde ha e tton,' snoteit c me d b aspeii S doe r aeba kwhe ia s nsane g ou f t if u tdbyf c s n t se w r nd orr le s ppore at
'

!

2 t tdif ri bot tm e a t ' fom t s t orqi lpl a nz s tf t ' 1 a 6 4 ha f e n h i nd voe r bo e he i' na * e di '' e orh. d. t 49. ' '. ' ' i '' ' ' ' i ' '

I 1 1

25
:

A dititc execiesdicei i d tnni ngwh t rorno t grntaKel,ty.Kel; src oun r s s rton n ee ni ehe to a l)sa I, )

26 3I F.3d atl 5 070.The coun m ay pr l r use t st an exhaused habeaspetton when t s t e opery ef o ay t ii he m ut

l

27
'

i

i

.

& .

, z

i
'

E ;

1 oflm ia i nswoul pr ve t e pe ii ne f om e rs c s f ly a e di t r - s e thi c a m .Se i t to d e nt h tto r r ve u ce s u l m n ng o e a s r s l i e
2 Ki 564 F. at 1141 42. ng, 3d. -

3
:

l t sc s t o ye rA EDPA lm ia i p r o r n o l ng a Ther c d i ca e t at n hi a e, he ne- a i t tons e i d a ut o go. e or ndi t s h

4 t rebasbeenno postconvs i ltgaton,and,t ref ,no sam t y t lng oft lm iatonsperod, be cton ii i be ore t or oli be i t i i

5 snc 200 w h n t d s i s ofPe r e t' t r s a e ha ea a ton wa a fr e on a pe . Se i e 7 e he i m s al toc lis hid t t b s c i s f im d p ai e
.

6 Exhi t .Tbe e o e, K e l s a woul be ttPe r e l on y t t c e t t sn w l e ha t d bi 41 r f r a l ty y d ne i toc li l o he xt nt ha hi e y- x us e
7 cl m s- t ai boset addedback i ot f alpetton f l ngt r obe nt be eder ii olowi he eques edst t ay-w oul el eback dr at

i

!
'
4
!

8 t e us e cl i st be i l d i t s a d pe ii o xha t d a m o nc ude n he t ye tton

. 9

Per eli e ge r la gu n st t b ne y- xha td camswoul not tmeba r d, toc lmak s ne a r me t ha t e wl e use li d be i - re

.

1 bu hedoe no pr d a s c fca yss i t sr gar w ib r s ctt any pari ul rcl m .The 0 t s t ovie ny pe ii nal i, n bi e d, t e pe o tc a ai
1 c ur , oweve , ase a i t et xh us e cl i sî t f r h a e dpe ii n,wli h Pe r e l 1 o th r h x m ned - me a t d a m n he ou t m nde tto h lc toc li

i
I

l woul ex us d i asa ( ot 7e, ( , 11 1 l () 1 09,l c , 5d) l e , 6() l b) 2 d ha t urng ty Gr mds ()8b)9, , 4, 5a, 5 5() 1 ( , 5() 1 a , 6( ,
1 1 c,J d,1 e,1 4 1 g) 1 b) 1 () J 1 1 20 2) 22, 2 25, 27 28, 30,a 3 6() 6() 6() 69, 6( , 6( , 6i, 7, 8, 9, , , 23, 4, 26, , 29, nd 1 31,ndha c 4 )a s ompae hos camst tee use camsi t furba nde tton, c wo d rdt e li o h xha td li n he o t me dpeii wbih ul 1 bepldi asa dffhame dpeii f l ngt lyprce r ( ou 6c, d)7 , ( 5 e n tye it nde tton,olowi heKel o due Gr nds ()6( , 1)79,

:

l 1 1 a 1 ) S Klg,56 F.d a 11 (g ehol t tM a erquie ac rs n ofa 6 0, 2, nd 3 . ee n 4 3 t 42 N d ha yl e rs ompaio I
y
i

.

: :

-

1 peiine ' ne cli t t prpel e ha tdcamslfpe ngi fdea cou tn t a ye rir 7 tto rs w ams o he o ry x use li et ndi n e rl r, oto n ale 1 vesonoft c ant ont ni cli s equ ntydimisdfrfiu et ex us.'.l a as 8 ri he ompli c ai ng ams ubs e l s se o alr o ha t' t ppe r ) 1 t t c r t tofalPer elisune usedcli ,heema bec orbl agume t tatheeof 9 o he ou tha, l toc l' xha t ams t r y ol a e r ns h tr
20 t os c ai smi ht e a eba k, h elm g r l t c unde A y/ , o e u t dcl m si Per e l' f rb a e de tton. r o c t xha s e ai n toc lis ou t m n dpe ii

I

;
'

21 Gr nds1 d a 1 mihtagua yrlt ba kt Gr l a dGr d 1 l g agubl rlt ou 5() nd 7 g r bl eae c o ound 2, n oun 9 niht r a y eae

2 bctGon 7b.hcu asme,opmoeotiaayiolad iotialdc i 2 ako rud()Tcor su sfru ssf snls n ,n wt uf l ein l h s y h n y dg
23 t rltonba kis t t ound l ( ,1 a 1 wo drlt ba kt exh use cai , ndc l he eai - c sue,ha Gr s 5d) 7,nd 9 ul eae c o a td l msa oud 24 t r or s r veasatt oflmiai sc le f l ng aKel sa Theea ast beno heef e uvi t ue i tton halnge olowi ly ty. r ppe r o

f

i

25 c orbl agumc tt ta yofGr nds7t,8b) 9,l ,1 1 a ,1 b ,1 c,l () 1 a,1 ( , ol a e r n ha n ou () ( , l 4, 5() 5() 5() 5e, 6() 6b)
26

28

.

â t

1 >

!

I
i

1 1 () l d ,1 e , 69, 6( ,1 h ,l i,1 20, l, 23, 25, 27, 29, a d31wo d 6c , 6() 6() 1 4 1 g) 6() 6() 8, 2 22, 24, 26, 28, 30, n ul
2 r l eba k t e u t d c ai si t f urh a e de pe ii n. e at c o xha s e l m n he o t m n d tto 3 l pl m e a i oft Kel pr c r i am a trof hi c tsdic e i Se K i g, 4 F. d m e nt ton he l o edu e s y te t s our ' s r ton. e n 56 3

'
;

4 a 1 43. The c ur wile r i e is dic eton t de Pe r e l a Ke l s a Th kilng ofJ t 1 o t l xe c s t s r i o ny toc li ly t y. e li ames
5 W ison,undcryi tzs cas occured on M ar 29$ 19827 and Petoceliwas convi ed i Sept l l ng li e, r cb r l ct n ember
! :

6 ofha yea -n ryt e de a sa l t tmesnc hi c ci n, to e lhasltgae i sa e t t r ea l hr e c de go. n he i i e s onvito Per c li ii td,n tt
7 tour,adiectappealand t ee s at babeasactons.''e l toft e sat habeasactonsw asltgat t r hr t e i fh as hos t e i ii ed

i ;

8 du i a s a of t s f de a ha a c s ,be we n Augu t 2003 a J y 2007. l e r sng is rng t y hi e r l be s a e t e s nd ul n xe cii t 9 dic e i n, he c ti mi f oft i s r to t our s nd ul he mpor a prnc pl ofco iy a f de a i m . Tb Smt h a t nt i i es m t nd e r ls e e as

i

1 srngi eeti t tnaiyofisci na j 0 to ntrs n he i lt t rmi ludgme s a e e to ofisc pi sntn eswiho nt, nd x cuin t a ul e e c t ut
11 t due de a The c ti alo m i df loft c es i nali e be n AEDPA,t e m os r c nt m l y. our s s n u he ongr s o nt nt hi d h t ee
12 w i r ng f al l sl i i t habeas a de-angi eder egi aton n be rea,t tr o teduce del ys i t executon of s at and a n he i te

5
;
'

1 f de al zz na s nt nc s p r i ul ry i c pia c s s ' Se 3 e r c ini l e e e , a tc a l n a t l a e .' eRhi s 544U . a 27 Tbec t sa s ne , S. t 6. our i l o 1 c ni a how e r t t f c ng t u tm a e pun s e t ca ia ha a pe ii r m us bepr de 4 og z nt ve , ha , a i be li t i hm n p t l be s ttone s t ovi d
15 r easonabl opporuniy t exhaus pot i l m eriorous habeas cl m s i st e cour, t avoi e t t o t entaly t i ai n at t o d

i

1 t ne e s r f f iur ofs h c ai s. W ih t e co i e a i i m i a wel-nf r e oft 6 m c s a y or e t e uc l m t hes ns d r tons n nd, nd li o m d he
:

(
'

hi hi ena her t bi i o ovi i 1 p oc dur l s o yoft scase,t scourtcannotcount nce anot say oft sacton t pr detm e 7 r e a hit r . 1 f rye a he i w o d b Pe r c l' f urh- s a e h be a ton. The c ur w il ny Pe r elis 8 o t not r- t ui e t o elis o t t t a as c i ? o t l de toc l'

1 m oto f a s a w ilr q r Petoc l t a nd hi t c u t d cl i s orf c dim i s ofhi 9 i n or t y, l e uie r eli o ba on s m xba s e a m a e s s al s

20 en ief rha nde tto a wil fr ou t me dpeiin, nd lmoveti a tont r e ol i ofPe r c lisvibl cli , h s c i owa dr s uton to e l' a e ams
j

I

21 on t i m e is he r rt .
22

I

;

i

23
I 24
25 t ci , t t ha ohe iea tdi ba f t i a fma ne i t saec a tcsorha he s t nvs ce n d aih n n n rn he tt ounso i t sc r.And, r n hi ou t

7Rep neth v maen so n ta P t cl hsee eggdi dltr liain so dns ae d o b wig ht er el a vr nae n i oy igt o i a t o

2 c rany tec u t o sn t a t s g e th t n i rp rd lyh sb e tefut f to el' 6 e til,h o rd e o me n o u y s ta a y mpo e ea a e n h a lo Per c li s
cu r ntc el who be a Peto lis c ns lon Se e r27,2 ( oc e #l ,afe t re ouns , c me r cel ou e ptmbe 007 d k t 40) tr he
conc uson ofPet ocelisl tsat ha l i r l' as t e beasacton. i

29

: > i zl .
(

: I
;

1

I I 'u xl Eyo l E o l o Ek Eo t tpe i ne ' M oto f T sr t ' t t ha uto r s i n orLea t Fie Re y Bre o v r ve o l pl i f e

!
!

2 Twe yPa si Le h( ck t#21 i GRANTED.Therpl i s r o t moto f sa ha nt ge n ngt do e 6) s e y n uppo t f be in or ty s
3 a r dy be n t l d, nd ha be n c i r d i t i or e ; he e or no f t ra i n on t e p r o t lea e ie a s e ons de e n h s d r t r f e, urbe cto h a t f he
4 Cl k i neces y i t s r d. er s sar n hi egar

1 '

5

I IS FURTH ER OR DERED t T hatpettoner' M otont St ii s i o aypr oceedi ngsandl ol Lii i l d tgaton

'

6 i
7

nAbe n (oc t#203 i DENI ya ce d ke )s ED.
I I FI R TH ER OR DERED t pe ii T S J hat ttoners l have 30 daysf om t dat ofenty oft s ha l r he e r hi

i :
p

8 or t fl a notce ofabandonment of t exhaused cli s abandoni t cl m s i bi f t der o ie i m t am , ng be ai n s ourh

9 a nde peiint ha bee hedt b u xba tdi saec r ( o me d tto hat ve n l o e ne use n tt ou tGrunds7e,8( , 11 1 () b) 9, , 4,

: E
i
i

1 1 a ,I () 1 c,l d) 1 e,l a) 1 1 c,1 d,16e,1 9,l g,1 h) 1 i,1 l 1 0 5() 5b , 5() 5( , 5() 6( , 608, 6() 6() () 6( 6() 6( , 6() 7, 8, 9, 1 20, 1 22, 24, 26, ,28, 30,a 31 .I peiine doe no , t n tetmeal d,Gl 1 2 , 23, 25, 27 29, nd ) f tto r s t wibi h i lowe e 1 an tc o a a d n n o u e h u tdcamsabandoni al ofhi unexhaustd cl m s,pettoner s 2 o ie f b n o me t f n x a se li , ng l s e ai ii '
1 Fou t Ame dPeiin( ock /1 wil din is d,nise iet pms ntoRos v Lun y, 55 3 rh nde tto d et/ 62) lbe s zse i t ntr y, ua t e . d 4
.

1 I S. 09(982) 4 J 5 1 .
.

.

! i
'
:

1 5

I I FURTHER ORDERED t t i pettonert esanotceofabandonm entofunexhaus ed T S ha, f ii il i t
'

nig l s ne use li , t n he i l espondents lt eaaer hal her 1 cl m s>abando n alof:i u xha td cams wihi t tm e alow ed,r 6 ai
1 have 90 days t fl an answer r pondi t t exhaus e cl nï re ai ng i pettoner s f t 7 o ie , es ng o he t d ai s m ni n ii ' ourh

'
!

1 a nde petton( ot s6( , d) 7b) 79,1 1 a 1 . 8 me d ii Gr md c)6( , ( , ( 0, 2, nd 3)
l 9 I IS FU RTH ER O RD ER ED t ,i al ot r pect t s T hat n 1 her es s, he chedul f f herpr e or urt oceedi ngs

! !

20 s tf t i t or re e e No mbe 1 2 ( ke #1 s l r mai i f c . e orh n he de ntr d ve r 6, 007 doc t 47) hal e n n or e

21

!
;

22 23

o a e t s 10t da o - a cl t d hi h y fv r a 2 f , 01 . .
,

24
5
!

.
U NI TED ST ' S DI STRI J D GE CT U

'

25

26
: 30

.

!
I

I