Kegel v. Brown & Williiamson Tobacco Corporation

Filing 173

ORDER denying 160 Motion to Dismiss. granting in part and denying in part 155 Motion to Reconsider. Signed by Judge Larry R. Hicks on 09/24/09. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - LG)

.- .- - -.

FLS ID

l
2 3

L't, zj k -z t
,

C)hs!fc ttsoj (7 ''7JL 'lta !$77 jtDf.' i èïF lj
.

-..yijL - . l Ltz . .

Sël 2 4 Lvr ' n f)
gj ,a, .

4
5

(uà-;(? r ) qy 4 . '
0: 7:
..

Lr;s; ''sjjjy(tj y : 'og(. k, )lj r . t -y .s y ; , ; ill y -

= = m - = = = -.- - z - - oFpp aJ -.. 7, f.

6 7
8

UNI ED STA T ES D I T R I T COU R T T SC D I TR I T O F N EV A D A SC
***

9 STEVEN A . KEGEL. 1 0 11 :. , 1 BROW N & W I LI M SON TOBACCO 2 LA C ORPORA TI N,e a . O t l, I 3 D e e da t . fn n s 1 4 1 5 Pl i tf, an if

) ) ) ) ) )

3: 6 CV - 0093- RH - PC 0- 0 LV

) ) ) ) ) )

ORDER

Be o et e c u ti Pli tf Stve Kege ' M o i n t Re onsde ( 1 ) De e da t f r h o r s an if e n ls to o c i r # 55'. f n n s

1 Br wn& W ila s nTobac oCor orton,e a.c le tvel t ee da t' ha eflda 6 o lim o c p ai t l(o lci y ç fn n s' v ie n D ) 1 o posto ( 1 )t whih Plitf-e le ( 16 ) Alobeor t ec u ti Dee da t'M otont 7 p iin # 61 o c an itrpid # 9 . s f e h o r s fn n s io 18 Dim isPlitf' Te t Cli frReif( l .Plitf hasfldano po iin ( 168 t whi h s s anifs nh am o le # 60) an if ie p sto # ) o c 1 Defnda t rple ( 1 . 9 e n s e id # 72)
20 1. M ot on t R econsi er io d

21

Plitf s e spa ta r c nsdeainoft ec ur' M ac I 2009,or e ( l .l an if e k ril e o i rto h o ts rh 0, d r # 50) n

2 p diua , an ifa k tec u tor c nsd rt ep rino iso d rm a tn s m ma yj dq e t 2 a c lr Plitf s s h o r t e o i e h o t f t r e n ig u r u >n n o
23 on Pl i tf s c a m f rbe e isunde t e W ela e a d Frnge Be ettPl n, be R e ie e tPl n, a n if li o n ft rh fr n i ni a t tr m n a

24 a dt eSpe ilSe ea c Be eisPlnpuruan t 29U. . .j 11 a) l iso d r tec ur nh ca v r n e n ft a s to SC 32( . n t r e ,h o t
25
26
l ef r t t e c ur' docketent ynumber R ' e s o h o ts r .

1 f u d t a Pl i tf ha f ie t e ha s hi a m i i t a i e r m e i sbec us he tf ie t pur ue o n h t a n i f d a l d o x u t s d n s r tv e d e a e ûa l d o s

2 hi lg tt rcevebe eisunde t eL lns.'( r e ( 1 a 1 . Thec ur frhe f undt a si h o e i n tt r h p a l' O d r # 50) t 9 ) o t ut r o h t
3 Pl i tf f ie t de ons r t t a e ha s i n ofhi a m i i t a i e r m e i sw oul ha e be n a n if a l d o m ta e h t x u to s d n s r tv e d e dv e 4 f tl ort a t e r m ed e a a l bl t hi w e e i a e uat . u ie h t h e i s v ia e o m r n d q e 5 Pl i tf hasf l d t e m oton t r co sde pu s a tt Fe e a Rul ofCi i Pr c dur a n if ie h i o e n i r ru n o d rl e vl o e e

6 59() û hieRul 59e)( ft eFe ea RulsofCii Pr c durqpem isadititc ur t e . ç l e ( o h d rl e W v l o e e r t src o to
7 r c nsde a d a e d a pr vi usor e , he r l of e sa i x r or i a y r m ed , o be us d eo i rn m n eo d r t u e fr n e ta d n r e y t e

8 s ai gyi teitr ssoftnaiyandc ns r ainofj diilr s ur e .' Car olv Nakatni p rn l n h n eet i lt o ev to u ca e o c s'' r . a,
9 342 F. d 93 ,9 5 ( t Ci. 3 4 4 9 h r 2003)( ia i n omit d) Re onsde a i n oft eco r' i ii lde ii n et to te . c i r to h u ts n ta c so

1 i i a pr p it i t ea s nceof(1 ne l dicovee evde c '()a itr e igc a gei O s n p o rae n h b e ) w y s r d i n e, 2 n n e v n n h n n 11 c ntoliglw'or( )cea e 'rorma ietii sie.Cal ol342F.da 945,Sch ol J'. o r ln a , 3 l r no n fs nu tc w, 3 t . o f) /No. b 1 1 j uln mah Count,( 'A AC andS,I c,5F.d 1 55,1 ( t Ci.l (iai ns 2 J M to y X. ' , n ' : 2 263 9h r 993) ctto .$
1 omitd) 3 te .
1 4 Pl i t f a j e t e c ur e r d be a s ç l i tf i de m e t ha e e ha s e t e a n i f rp s h o t r e c u e ç a n if s e d o v x u t d h p

1 a m i i ta i e r l e i s a a l bl und rt e pl n a a co s quenc ofD e e da t 'f iur t f low 5 d n s r tv en d e v ia e e h a s ne e fn n s al e o ol

1 cli spr c dursc nsse twiht er quie e t of29C.. .j2560.03. ( 1' M otRec ns 6 am o e e o itn t b e rm n s FR 5 9 P .s . o . ' 1 ( 1 5 a 2. Se to 2560.03- tst frhmii u rquie e t f re pl ye be eftpln 7 # 5 ) t ) cin 5 1 tes o t nm m e rm n s o m o e n i a 18 pr ce u e perani gt cam sfrbe eisbypa tcpa t a dbe etcais.... 29C. . ., o d r s ti n o li o n ft rii ns n n - ire i ' ' FR j 1 2560.03-( ) ' heeav lnfist etbls o tlow cam spr ce ursco sse twiht e 9 5 1a .W r i a al o sa ih r b l li o d e n itn t h p

20 r quie e t ofge to 2560.03- j adam a ts albede medt ha ee ha se hi e rm ns s cin 5 1, i n h l e o v x u td s
21 ad i itai er l e isa albl unde t epl n ....'29 C. . .j 2560.03- () m n sr tv en d e v ia e rh a ' FR 5 1 1.
22 As a pr lm i a y m a t r t e c ur no e t a wih r g r t t e W e f r a d Fr nge Be e i ei n r te , h o t t s h t t e a d o h la e n i n ft

23 Pl n a d t e Re i e e tPl n. a ntf ha y tt pr v de ev de c i di a i g t athe a ple f r anh tr m n a Pl i if s e o o i i n e n c tn h p id b 24 s c be e is A st e co r ' pr vi us or e r c g i e ,t one oft e c r es onde c i a y w a u h n ft . h u ts e o d r e o nz d û n h or p nen n y

25 a dr s e Pl i tf ' e i i iiy f rt e W e fr a d Frng Be e i Pln o t e Reie e tP1 n. d e s s an ifs lg b lt o h la e n i e n ft a r h tr m n a ' '
26 2

1 ( r e ( 15 )a 1 . Furhe,heei noevde cebeo etec ur s ggetngt a Dee da t O d r # 0 t 9) t r t r s in fr h o t u si h t fn n s
2 de i d Pl i tf be e isunde t e e pl ns To t e co ta y, he l te s c nve i g Pl i t f ' n e a n if n it rhs a . h n r r t e t r o y n a n i fs 3 t nni a i n s a e t a asa r s l oft e t r i a i n-Pl i tf w a no l nge e i i l f r s or t r e n to t t h t e u t h e m n to a n if s o r ig b e o h t e m 4 di a iiy be e isa d S e i lSe e a c Be ett . The l te s m a e no m e ton oft e W e l r a d s b lt n ft n p c a v r n e n i s e tr k ni h lù e n 5 Fr nge Be e i Pl n ort e Re i e e tPl n. A c or i g y, o t e e t ntt e m oton t r c ns de i n ft a h tr m n a c dn l t h xe h i o eo i r 6 c a l nge t e eo l f fndi gs a t t e W e f r a d Fr nge Be ettPl n a d t e R e i e e tPl nh le s h u - s i n s o h t la e n i ni a n h tr m n a
7 t e courtwildeny t em oton. h l h i

8

A st t e S e i lSe e a c Be ett ,on M a c 8, o h p ca v r n e n is r h 2005, . . ynol s s ntPl i tf R J Re de a n if

9 alte notfi ghi t a asar s l ofhi alge mirprs nttons hewasnol nge ei il t etr ikn m h t e ut s le d se e e ai p o r lgb e o
1 r c i e s o tt r di a iiy be eft ort e Spec a Se e a ce Be eft . On M a ch 1 2005, 0 e e v h r e m s b lt n is h il v r n n is r 5,

11 Plitf rs o de ,s ndigltest vai usR..Re nolse plyee teq esgngja a pe lof an if ep n d e n etr o lo J y d m o s b u ti n p a r

1 t ede ii nta g ehas be ntr iae fo ghor tr dia iiylbe eft.'( l' Opp.Mot 2 h cso h t h j e em n td rm s t em sb lt n is' P .s .
l Su m . .( l 8) Exs ll 1 11 ) 3 m J # 2 e . 5, 16, 7.
1 4 l is pr vi usor e ,t e c ur hel t a bec us Pl i tf f ie t a pe lt e de i lofhi nt eo d r h o t d h t a e a n if a l d o p a h n a s

1 Spe i lSe e a ce Be e is he f ie t e ha s hi ad î i t a i e r m e i s Pl i tf now a gues 5 ca v r n n ft s a l d o x u t s m n s r tv e d e . a n if r 1 t a de i i nc e i t e M a c l te sr qui et e c ul t fnd asa m a t rof1 w t a he ha 6 h t fc e i s n h r h e tr e r h o ' o i t te a ht s l e ha s e hi a m i i t a i er m e i s Thes dei i nc e i c ude f ii g t pr vi e i vi l ton 7 x u t d s d n sr t v e d e . e tc e i s n l a ln o o d , n o a i

1 of29C.. .(2560.03- ( ) ( )t es e ii plnpr viin onwhiht ea ve s be e' 8 FR i 5 1g , 1 h p ctc a o so c h d re n tt i
19 de e m i ai n wasbas d an ( )ade c i ton oft epl n' r v e pr c du e a d t etm elm is t r n to e d2 s rp i h a s e iw o e r s n h i i t

20 a plca l t s c pr ce ur s Sc 29C. . .j2560.03- () p i be o u h o d e . c FR ' 5 1g .
2l De e da t do notdiput t a t el te sf ie t pr vi et ea ove ct d i f r a i n. fn ns s e h t h et r a ld o o d h b - ie n o m to

22 I s e d, e e da t a gu t a t e we e notr quie t i c ude t e i f r a i n i t e l te s n ta D fn ns r e h t h y r e rd o n l h n o m to n h e tr 23 bee us t e i di i ua r s onsbl f r t e l te s M s Tr m bl y,w a nott e pl n adm i i ta or A s a e h n v d l e p i e o h et r , . e a s ha n sr t .

24 Defnda t not.29C. . .j2560.03- ()saes iheplna m iitaors alpr vi eacam a t e ns e FR , 5 1g tt ,t a d n sr t h l o d li n t 25 wih .. notfcain ofanya ves be eftdeem iain. 29C. . .j2560.03- ( ) t . ii to d re n i tr n to ' ' FR 5 1g .
26 3

1

Thec ur dia r e wih De e da t 'f r ul i r a i g oft er j lton.AsPl i tf o t s g e s t fn n s b m ac e dn h ep ai an if

2 not s c nt a y t Def nda t 'a s r i ns t e a plc bl r gu a i nsw e e e a t d prm arl f rt e e , o rr o e n s s e to , h p i a e e l to r n c e i iy o h 3 be ettofel i a t . The r gul tons s a e, t ' e ne s a da ds a e i t nde t e s r m o e tm e y ni am n s e ai t t tf -b w t n r r n e d o n u e r i l

4 be eitde e m i ai ns t i pr veac es t i f nna i n on whih abe ek de e m i a i n i m a e n i t r n to , o m o c s o n o to e n t t r n to s d .
5 and t assur t atpari i ant and benefci l es wilbe afor ed a f l and f i r vi w ofdeni d o eh tc p s i ai l fd ul ar e e e

6 cli s' 65Fe . g.702 6( ov.21 2000)sc aioEasmanKodakCo.: STWB,l c.452 am . ' d Re 4N , , *es t ' . n, 7 F.d21 .222( t Ci.2006)(i'e%ee e e ha se ' oviinwa pli l desgn dt gie 35 9h r tfh d m d x u td pr so s any i e o v 8 cam a t f c d wih i a e ua ec am spr ce u esa f s ta k i t co r .. .) Thus t ec ur li n s a e t n d q t l i o dr at rc no u t .' . ' ,h o t
9 fnds t a Def nda t 'de i e y oft e l te by s m e ne ot e t a t e pl n adm i i t a o i no i h t e n s lv r h et r o o h rh n h a n sr t r s t l de rm e t lt Pl i tf s e la s i n a gu e t 0 ti n a o a n i f x l u to r m n . 11 Thr ugh t eM a c 8,2005,l te , e e da t i f r e Pl i tf t a he w a notei i l o h rh et r D f n n s n o m d an if h t s lg b e

1 f rt e Spe i lSeve a ceB e e i s Th sw asa a ve s be e i de e m i a î n w ihi t e m e ni g 2 oh ca rn n tt . i n d r e n tt t r n to tnh an

1 0t29C.. . 2560.03- . Se 29C.. .j2560.(3-( )4)( ei iga a ves benei 3 ' FR j 51 e FR 5) lm ( d tnn n d re tt
1 de e m i a i n a ' de i l r d c i n, t r i a i n of...a be eft. . ha i bas d o a 4 t r n to s ' n a s e u to or e m n to a n i . t ts e n

1 de e m i ai n ofapa tcpa tsorbe e i ir ' ei i iiy t pa tc pa ei apl n ....) Be a s 5 t r n to rii n ' n fca y s lgb lt o rii t n a ' cu e '
1 t el terf ie t pm vi e t es ecfcpl n pr v so o whih t eadve s be e i de er i a i n 6 h et al d o d h p ii a o ii n n c h r e n ft trn n to
1 w asba e a d t)de c i e t e pl n' r vi w pr c du e and t e tm e lm isa plca l t s c 7 s d n ( s rb h a s e e o e rs h i i t p i be o u h

18 pr c dur s t elte voltdt erqur me t stfrh i 29C.. .j2560.03- ( ) Ass c , o e e ,h etr i ae h e ie n s e o t n FR 5 lg . u h 1 unde 29C. . .j2560.03- () Plitf i tde m e t ha ee ha sedhi a m iitatve 9 r FR 5 11, anif s t e d o v x u t s d n sr i 20 rm e isa albl unde tepln .. . 2 C.. .j2560.03- 4) e de v ia e r h a .' 9 F R ' 5 11.
21 Il . M oton t D i m i s i o ss

22

D e e da t s e di m i s lofPl i tt s t nt c a m f rr le ,whi h a l ge D e e da t fn ns e k s sa a n iT e h l i o e i f c le s f n n s

23 wr ngf ly t r i at d Pl i tf i r t la i n f r e e eii g hi rght u de t e Shor - 'r o u l e m n e a n i f n e a i to o x r s n s i s n r h tl e m 24 Di a iiy B e e i s Pl n i vi l ton oft e ç u da e t lpublc polc oft e St t ofN eva a. s b lt n tt a n o a i h t n m na f i iy h a e d' '

25 ( it Am.Compl ( 1 4)! 1 2. Dee da t agu t ec mplitfist saeacli upon F fh .# 5 - 2 ) fn n s r e b o an al o tt am
26

4

1 whihrle ca bep-ntd,war nigdimislu de Fe ea Rul ofCi iPr c du e1 b)6)' c eif n a e ra tn s sa n r d r l e vl o e r 2( ( .
2 To s r i e a m oton t dim i sf rf iur t s a e a c ai ,a c m pl i tm us s t s .yt e uvv i o s s o al e o tt l m o an t a if h

3 Fe e a Rul ofCi i Pr c dur 8 a ( )notc pla i g sa da d.Se M e di ndo v Ce tne a d rl e v l o e e ( )2 i e e d n tn r e no . ni l 4 Hos . c .Ct. 5 lF.d 1 p M d r, 2 3 097,11 3 ( t Ci.20 8) Tha i,a c m pl i tmus c nt i % s or 0 9 h r 0 . t s o an t o an E h t a
5 a d pl i s a e e toft e c a m s o i g t a t epi a e i e tte t r le ' Fe . . v.P. n an tt m n h l i h w n h t h e d r s n il d o e i f ' d R Ci

6 8 a() TheRul 8( )2)pla i gsa daddoesno r q iedealdf cua algains howe e , ( )2 . e a( e d n tn r t e u r tie a t l le to ' , vr
7 apl a i g t atotkr o l ilbesa d c ncuso s'o taf nnul i r ct ton oft eeem e t ofa e d n h l s n y ça l n o l i n ' r k o ac e ia i ' l ns h

8 c us ofa ton'wilnots fie.As opf v I bal 1 9S. .1 1 49( 009)( uotn Bel a e ci ' l u fc h t . q , 2 Ct 937. 9 2 q ig l
9 Atantc Cor .).Twombl ,550U. .54 ,555 ( 007). li p' y S4 2)

1 0

Furhem or,Rue8()2)r quie ac m plitt i onti s fiintfcua matr t r e l a( e rs o an o i an u fce a t l te, c

11 a c ptd astu ,t sa eac am t r le t a i pl usbl on isf ce' 1 .a 1 (nt r al ce e r e o tt l i o ei f h t s a i e t a .' d t 949 i e n
1 quotton m a kso itd) A cai hasf ca plusbiiy whe t epl a ed f c ua c nt ntal w s 2 ai r m te . l m a il a i lt n h e d a t l o e lo

1 tec u tt drw t er as na l ifrnc ,basdont ec ul' j diilex einc a dc mm on 3 h o r o a h e o b e n ee e e h o - s u ca p re e n o t
1 s ns ,t a t e def nda ti la l f rt e m i c nduc a l ge . Se i .a l 4 e e h th e n s ib e o h so t le d e d t 949- 0. çfhe pl us biiy 5 t ' a i lt 1 s a dar i nota i t a pr ba iiy r q ie e t buti a ksf rm o e t a a s e rpos i iiy t a a 5 tn d s kn o o b lt e u r m n , ts o r hn he s b lt h t

16 de e da tha a t d unl w f ly. ' he eac m pl i tpl a sf c st a a em e ey c ns se twih a fn n s ce a u l W r o an e d a t h t r r l o it n t 1 de e da tsla iiysi so ss o toft elnebew ee pos i iiy a d plusbiiy ofen ilm e tt 7 f n n ' ib lt t t p h r h i t n sb lt n a i lt tte n o

l r lef' 1 .a l 49(ntr a quottonmaksa dcttonomitd) 8 ei .' d t 9 i en l ai r n iai te .
l 9 l r vi w i g a m oton t di m i s t e co r a c pt t e f c s a l ge i t e co pl i ta ne e n i o s s , h u t c e s h a t le d n h m a n s

20 tue.ll (iai nomitd) Howe e,taea srins...a oungng t noti gmor t a a r c. ctto te . v r t r se to b m ti ) o h n eh n
21 f nnuli r ct ton oft ee e e t ofa... am ...a enote tte t an a s m pto oftuh.' o a c e iai h lm ns cli r n il d o s u in r t '

22 Mos v U.. c e Se ' 572F.d 9 2, (t Ci. 9)( l tngl b l 1 S.Cta 1 ) s . S Se r t n . , 3 6 969 9h r 200 q l i q a , 29 o . t 951
23

24

21 isM ar h 10, 20 9 o de ( 1 0) t ec ur grntdPlitf ia et tl a a e de c m p an 1: t c 0 , r r # 5 . h o t a e an if e v o ie n m n d o l it alegi g a wr ngf lt r i a i n cl i bas d upon t eexe ci eofhi rght unde t e Shor-fer Di a iiy ln o u e m n to a m e h rs si s rh l -' m s b lt i f ctsat a vi bl wr ngf lt r i a i n cl i orw het c Pl i tf has e i e ee t s ppor s ch a cl i .' n a t e a e o u e m n to a m h r a n if vd n o u tu am '

25 Pln.Non t ee s t ec u tc uton d,û-h c ur-qr lngi i nowa idiai eofwhehe Plitf c n a eh ls ,h o r a i e tg e o ts u i s n f y n c tv t r an if a a6 ( r e ( 1 0 a 1 n.0. O d r# 5 ) t 7 1 )
5

1 (leai ni orgi a)(ntr a quotto makso itd) Thec ur dic unstes algains atrto n i n l i en l ain r m te . o t s o t h e le to
2 be a s t e do û ot i g m or t a s a e a l ga co c us on - e e i t a c nc us o i c s i t e cu e h y t hn n e h n tt e l n l i v n f h t o i in s a tn h

3 fnn ofafcua algain. 1 .ciigl b l 1 S.Ct a 1 . il s m ,orac m plitt o a t l le to ' d ( tn q a , 29 ' . t 95l) in u f o an o
4 s r i e a m oto t dim i s t e non- one us r ia t alc nt nt 'a d r as na l i f r nc sf om u vv in o s s.h c l o y fcu o e , n e o b e n e e e r

5 t a c ntnt m us bepl usbl s ggesi eofac am e tti g t epl i tf t r le ' f .( totn ht o e s t a i y u tv l i n iln h an if o ei f ' # q t i g

6 I bal 1 9S. . t1 49) q , 2 Cta 9 .
7 D e e da t a gue t a Pl i tf s c a m t rwr ngf ldi c a geba e o t e e e c s ofhi fn n s r h t a n if l i b o u sh r s d n h x rie s 8 rght unde t e Shor-l n' Di a iiy B e e isPl n f isasa m a t rof1 w be a s N e a a 1 w is rh t-e n s b lt n ft a a l te a cu e v d a 9 doe no r c gni e s c a c a m . t-he es e ce ofa t r i us di c a ge i t e w r ngf l us a l s t e o z u h l i il sn o to sh r s h o u . u ly

1 r tla o y,nt r u to ofe pl ym e tbym e nswhih a ede m edt beco ta' t t epu lc 0 eai t r i e r p i n mo n a cr e o nr l o h b i y

1l polc ofgheStt ofNe ad j' D 'n eov.Gar ne ,81 P.d206,2l ( e .1 ) Ne a a iy t ae v a .' A g l dr 92 6 N v 991. v d
l c urs ha e r c gni e t a di c a gi g a e pl ye f rs e i g w o ke s'c m pe s ton be e is 2 o t v e o z d h t s h r n n m o e o e kn rr o n ai n ft ,

l pefr igj r dut,orrf sngt vi lt telw viltspublcpolc a d s pporsacli f r 3 rom n u y y eu i o oae h a o ae î iy n u t am o
1 t ri usdic a ge I .a 21 ( ia i nsomit d) Q om pa a l t ri usdi c a ge ma a iewhe 4 o to s h r . d t 2 c tto te . t c r b e o to s h r s y rs n
15 a e pl ye di m i s sa e pl ye i r t la i n f r t e e pl ye ' doi g of a t whi h a e n m o r s s e n m o e n e a i to o h m o e s n cs c r 1 c ns s e tw ih ors p ori e ofs u d publc poie a d t e c m m on good. 1 .a 21 6 o it n t u p tv on i iy n h o ' d t 6. '

1 7

TheNe adaSupr m eCour ha saed,i l a l ,hepu lcpolc oft i sa ef vor v e t s t t û e ry t c b i iy h s tt a s

1 *c no i s c rt fre plye sij rdwhiei t ec ureoft ere plym e t'' lar De ' 8 e o m c e u iy o m o e nu e l n h o s h i m o n.'Dil d p t 1 St rs I c v. c- 'h,989P.d88 ( e .1 99) Re ognii gti poiy,t eCo r ha uphel 9 o c , n . Be k i vt 2 2 N v 9 . c zn h s lc h u t s d
20 t rtousdi cha ge cl i sst m m i g f om em pl yeesflng w or m en' com pensaton cl i s.1d.at oi sr am e nr o ii k s i am

21 886, s nn Hal ah'.675P.d394-397( e .1 8 ) AsDeknda t noe ,i s hol ig, . Han e ws 2 N v 9 4. t n s td n o dn
22 t e ec s sr l i pa to Ne a a sl giltve s he ego e ni g wor m e ' e m pe s ton, nd h s a e ey n r n v d ' e sa i c m vrn k n s o n ai a
23 N e a a l w doe note nt i s m ia pr vi i nsa dr s i g e pl ye - r v de be eftpl ns vd a s o an i lr o so d e sn m o rp o i d n i a .

24 Nonehe e s :hef iur oft el g sa u et ena tasa ut e pr s l f r i di gr tia o y t l s - i a l e l e i lt r o c tt e x e sy o b d n eai t r t l

25 dic agef rt eflngof. . li sdoesnotprcldeghec urqfo pr vi igarm e yf r s h r o h ii . cam e u t o t rm o dn e d o
26
6

1 wha gheco r c ncu ejt betriusbe a ir' Hans n,675P.da 396. t t u t o ld s o o to h vo . ' e 2t
2 l i nots r rsng t atNe a al w f ist a d e st ea a lbiiy ofawr ngf ldi c a ge ts u p ii h v d a a l o d r s h v ia lt o u sh r
3 c ai bas d upon a l g tons t a t e e pl ye t r i a e t e pl i t f f re er i i g hi s or -e m lm e le a i h t h m o r e m n t d h a n i f o x c s n s h tt r

4 di a iiybe e t bec us t e Em pl ym e tRe ie e tl c m e Se urt Ac (t R1 A ') 29 U. . . s b lt' n f s a e h o n tr m n n o c iy t tE S ', SC

5 j l - 462,e tnsveyc vese ply rpr vie be eftplns sc 29U. . .j l1 0(ûts al j 001 1 xe i l o r m o e - o d d n i a . 'c SC 4 tl h l
6 beunlw f lf ra y pe s n t di c a g ..apa ùcpa torbe efc a r ore e c sng a yrgh t a u b n ro o sh r e rïn n i io f x r ii n i t o

7 whî h hei e tte unde t epr vii nsofa e pl y ebe ei pln ....) Nonehel s -he e, he c s n ild r h o so n m o e n tt a ' ' t es r t
8 courthas hel t att e Short-'r D i abiiy BeneftPl n i a vpa r l pr ctce exem ptf om dh h -fe m s lt i a s t yol a i r

9 ERI A . ( r e ( l 0)a 1 ) Thus Pl i tf doe no ha e asaut r r m e y a aia l t hi . S ' O d r # 5 t 7. ' , an if s t v t t o y e d v lb e o m
1 tl i pr c s l i s c c s s ie. w he e no c m pr he sve s a ut r r m e y e it st a c ur sha e 0 it s e i e y n u h a e , . , r o e n i t t o y e d x ss h t o t v

1 bee wilngt c e t pu lcpolc t r la iiy. D 'ngco &.Gar ne'81 P, d 206,21 ( e . 1 n li o r a e b i i y o t ib lt ' A l ' d l 9 2 ' , 8N v

l 1 91 (iainsomitd) 2 9 ) ctto te .
1 3 i lghtoft e l c of a s a ut o , ot e t 1 r m e y a a l bl t Pl i tf a d t e N e a a nï h ak t t o or h r o 4 e d v ia e o a n if n h vd

1 Suprm eCoud' rco niinoft ei po- nceofprtcigt eitrssofij r dwokes t e 4 e s e g to h m la t oe tn h n ee t nu e r r,h
15 courttndst atundert e ci cum s a ees pr sent d i t i case,t r i atng Pl i tf f rexer i i g i h hr tn e e n hs em n i a n if o c sn

1 hi r ght unde t e Sho t-e u Di a iiy B e e i Pl n i co t a y t t epu lc polc oft e St t 6 si s rh r -l n s b lt n tt a s n r r o h b i i y h ae 1 ofN e a a A c or i gl ,t e c ur w ilde y t e m oto t di m i s 7 v d . c dn y h o t l n h in o s s .

18

I I THEREFORE ORDERED t a Pli tf sM oton t Re onsde (/ 55 i GRANTED TS h t a n if i o c i r /1 ) s

1 i pa t DEN I D i pa t 9 n r and E n r.

20
21 22

I I FURTHER ORDERED ta Deknda t'M otont Dimis( 160 i DENI D. TS h t t ns i o s s # )s E
I I SO O R D ER ED . TS

n - pe r o A -s o t î A fr y ofse t m be ,2009. r hs
*

23 24 25
26

LA R R Y R.HI K S C U N I E D STATES DI TR I T J D G E T SCU
7