Geraldine Lee v. Northern Nevada Adult Mental Health Services. et al

Filing 141

ORDER GRANTING D Sparks Police Department's 119 Motion for Summary Judgment. Clerk shall enter judgment accordingly. Signed by Judge Larry R. Hicks on 9/21/2009. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

Download PDF
h . . ) ' ) 1 ( j 2 3 4 5 ' ' ' ' L ; . l . L . , r : . ' 6 7 U N I ED STA T ES DISTRI T CO U R T T C D I T R I T O F N EV A D A S C 8 ***** 9 GERALDW E L LEE, 1 0 11 vs . Plitf, an if ) ) ) ) ) ) 03:6- V- 433- RH- AM 0C 0 L R ORDER 1 N NA M H S,ALEXANDER,CI Y A UTO 2 T TO W ,CI Y OF SPARKS POLI E DEPT. ) T C , 1 COOK ,FLOW ER S,J CK SO N,M OO RE, ) 3 A REY N OLD S a d DOES 1X , n ) ) 1 4 l 5 1 6 D e e da t . fn n s ) ) ) Be or t e cou ti D e e da tSpa ksPolc D e a t e t s M oton f r Sum m a y f eh r s fn n r i e p rm n ' io r l J dgme t( 11 :.Plitf Geaii eLe ha tlda o posto ( 1 2)t whih Defnda t 7u n # 9) anif r dn e s ie n p iin # 3 o c en 1 rple ( 135 .Dee da tCiyAut Towi g' ha j iedt emoin frs mm ayj dgm e ta d 8 e id # ) fn n t o n s s on h to o u r u nn 1 t er pl ( 1 4,1 6) 9 h ey* 2 3 . 20 1. Facts and ProceduralH i t ry so 21 Thi i a c vi r g t diput a i i g o tofa i c de twhe Pl i tf ' a t m obie w as s s i l ih s s e rsn u n ni n n a n ifs u o l 22 twe fom Norhe. Ne a aAdul Me tlHe lhSe rce (G NAM HS' .OnJ ne21, 6, o d' r t l vd n t n a at n i s GN ' ) u 200 23 a t rt eve i l had be n pa ke i t e s m e s ota N N A M H S f ra pr xi a el o e w e k,a fe h h c e e r dnh a pt o p o m ty n e 24 t e t - ourho rt w no i e w a pl c d on Pl i tf s ve i l bec us t e ve i l wasa l ge l w n yf uo tc s ae a n if h c e a e h h c e le d y 25 t ki g up t o ha dia paki g s a e ,ha expiedlce s spl t s ha a e piedha di a an w n cp r n p cs d r i n e ae . d n x r n cp 26 per i,and appear d t havebeen abandoned. On June 26,2006,D ef ndantCiy A ut Tow mt eo k t o 27 t w e t e ve i l . D e e da tM oor , he f c lt s pe vi o a N N A M H S,a t o i ed t e o d h h ce fn n e t a iiy u r s r t u h rz h 28 ltefrst t ecourtsdocketenty num be . l e oh ' r r 1 t w i g. on 2 On Jul 20 or21,2006,D ef ndantA l xanderr cei ed s veralvoi e m ai m es ageson y e e ev e c l s 3 hi tlphonec m plii ga o ttet vealma a lm e tot t eopeaina e doft ehos ia s ee o ann b u h s rl n g e n l h o rto l n h ptl 4 fclt . ( ef.M ot Summ.J ( l1 ) Ex. a 9:0- l) Dee da tAlxa de beivedt a a iiy' D s' . ' .# 9 , B t 1 1 . fn n e n r le h t 5 tec ntntoftel e s ge wa tveyha a sng. (#.Ex. a 1 :2- 3. De e da t Re nol s h oe h n sa s s t r r s i ' f , B t 22 2 ) fn n s y d ' 6 a d J c s n ls e e t t e m e s ge a d r c g i ed t e voi e asPl i tf s A f e t e m e s ge n a k o it n d o h sa s n eo nz h c a n if . tr h sa s 7 w e e l f on D e e da tA l xa de ' t l pho e D e e da tRe nol s i sr c ed D ef nda tLe , r et f n n e n rs ee n , f n n y d n tu t ene 8 t e die t roft e N N A M H S Dr p- n Ce t r t i f r Pl i tf t ats e c ul notus t e D r ph rco h o l n e , o n o m a n if h h o d eh o 9 I Cent r f r aperod oftm e. n eb i i 1 0 The Dr p- n Ce t ri a f c lt r n by i di i ua s w ih m e t lil es e t s ppor ot e o l n e s a iiy u n vd l t n a ln s s o u t hr l1 i di i ual w ih m ent lil essesi t ei recovery and t ser e as a pl ce w here s ch i di i ual n vd s t a ln nhr ov a u n vd s 1 c n f e s f . The C e t rhasa lbr r ,m i r w a e, nd r f i e a ora d s n ' scof e , e ,a d 2 a e l ae ne i a y c o v a e rg r t n e e fe ta n l s a ks The Ce t r a s pr vi esc m pu e sa d t l phone . The Ce t r doe notpr vi e 3 nc . n e lo o d o tr n ee s ne s od 1 m e i a i n, nd t e e a e no doct r orot e c i i a pr f s i na s a a l bl att e Ce t r 4 d c to a h r r os h r ln c l o e s o l v ia e h n e. 1 5 O n J l 25,2006.Pl i tf c m e t t e D r p- n Ce t rt r t i vehe pos e s ons uy a n if a oh o l n e o ere r ssi . 1 D e e da tJ c s n as e he a s s a tt r t i ve t e pos es i ns butPl i tf r f s d t e . 6 f n n a k o k d r s it n o ere h s so , a n if e u e h m 17 D ef ndantJackson t en asked Pl i tf- o l ave-and Pl i tf r f sed. Defe dantJaekson e h a n i tt e a n if e u n 18 i di a e s e w oul ha et ca lt e polc , hi h s e di . n c td h d v o lh ie w c h d 1 9 Spa ks Polc O f i e Ja e H a m e s one r s onde a d es or e Pl i tf f om t e r i e fc r m s m r t ep d n c td a n if ' rh 20 buidi g. Pl i tf t e s a e t a s e w a t d t e t rt e N N A M H S f c lt ,a d Ofi e ln a n if h n tt d h t h ne o ne h a iiy n tc r 2 1 H a m e s one t l he nott . Pl i tf pr c ede t e t rt e buidi g s r a i g. Pl i tf w a m rt od r o an if o e d o n e h l n ce m n a n if s 2 t l s ve a tm est s o s r a i g a d e i t ebuid ng. Pl i t f r f s d. O f i e 2 od e rl i o tp c e m n n x th li an if e u e fc r 23 H a m e sonet e ha dc f e Pl i tf a d pl c d he u de a r s f r o s r c i g a polc m rt h n n u f d a n i f n a e r n r r e t o b t u tn ie 2 ofi e i vi l ton ofSpa ksM uni i a C o e s c i n 9. 30. 20. 4 tc r n o a i r c p l d e to 0 0 25 1l. LegalSt ndard a 26 Summayj dgme ti a pr praeonl whe hepla igs de ostons a s e st ru n s p o it y n % e dn . p ii , n w r o t 27 i t r og t res a d a m i sonson fl ,t get e w ih t e a fda is i a y,s ow t a t e e i no ner ao i . n d si ie o h r t h f i v t , f n h h th r s 2 g nun is ea t a ymaeil a ta dt a t emo i gpa t i e tte t j dg e ta amatr 8 e ie su s o n tra f c n h th v n ry s n ild o u m n s te 2 1 oflu,'Fe . Ci .P.56() l as s igamotonf rs mm a zudgme tt ee ie ce a . d R. v ' c. n se sn i o u oj n ,h v d n , 2 t ge he wih al i f r nce t a c n r as na l be d a n t e ef o , us be r a i t e lg t o t r t 1 n ee s h t a e o b y r w h r r m m t e d n h ih 3 m os f vor bl t t e pa t oppos ng t e m o i n. M at us ia El c. ndu .Co.v Ze ih Radi t a a e o h ry ih to s ht e I s . nt o 4 Col .475U. . 587( 986) Count q Tuolmnev. nor Cm(.Hos .236F.d 11 8, p, S 574, l* , yf u So a p p , 34 5 1l 4 ( t Ci.2001 . 5 9h r ) 6 7 The m ovi g pa t bea st e bur e ofi f r i g t e c ur oft e bass f rism oton, n ry r h d n n om n h o t h iot i al ng w ih evi ence s ow i g t e a s nce ofany genui e i s e ofm at r alf ct Cel t x Cor .v. o t d h n h be n su ei a . oe p 8 Catet477U. . ,3 3( 98 ) Ontos is e f rwhihi be r t ebur e ofpr of t e r t, S 317 2 1 6 . h e su s o c t a s h d n o .b 9 m ovi g pa-y m ustm ake a s ow i g t ati tsufi i ntf rt e courtt hol t atno reasonabl n lt h n h s b tc e o h o dh e 1 t i roff c c ul fnd ot e t a f rt e m ovi g pa t . Cal e one v.Unie St t s,7 9 F. d 0 re at o d i h rh n o h n ry ' ' dr td a e 9 2 11 254, ( t Ci.1 ; ca/, I c a n Dr am wor s I c ,l F.Supp.2c 11 9,1 41( . . 259 6 h r 986) se 5? d m ( e k , n 62 1 2 1 CD 1 Ca. 2 l2001) . 1 3 14 To s c e sul rbutamoton frs mm ayj dgme t teno - ovi gpa t mus poi t u c sf ly e i ou ru n ,h n m n ry t n t f c s s pport d by t e recor whi h dem ons r t a genui e i sue ofm at ri lf ct Reese r. o at u e h d c ta e ns ea a . 1 Jefr onSc .DitNo.1 J,208F.d736( t Ci. 5 fe s h s. 4 3 9h r 2000) A t aeilf c'i afcttha miht . t tra a t's a t g m t 1 a f c t e o t om e oft e s i unde t e gove ni g l w . Ander on v Li ery Lobby, nc ,477 6 fe t h u c h ut rh rn a ' ' s .bt l. 1 U. . 248 ( 986 .W he er a o abl m i dsc ul dif ron t ema e i lf c sa is e 7 S 242, 1) r e s n e n o d fe h t ra a t t s u , 18 s mm a'j dpne ti nota pr prae.Seev Dtr n .71lF.d l 1 1 (t Ci.1 83) A u lu y n s p o it . ta g 2 4 , 43 9h r 9 . 1 di put r ga di g a m a ei lf c i c nsde e ge ui e ft e e i e ce i s ch t a a r a ona l 9 s ee rn t la a t s o i r d n n t h v d n s u h t e s b e i 20 j l c ul rtl aveditf rteno m ovigpa t. Li e t Lobby, U. . t248.Theme e u' o d eu' r c o h n n ry' b r. y n ' y 477 S a r 21 e it nce ofa s i tla ofev de c i s ppor oft e pl i tf sposton w ilbe i s fi i ntt x se c n il i nen u t h a n if ii l n u tc e o 2 e tbls ag n ied s ue t eemu t e i e c o wh c t ej r c udr a o a l f df r 2 sa ih e u n ip t;h r s be v d n e n ih h u y o l e s n b y i o n 23 t e pl i t f . See i .a 252. h a n if dt 24 11 . 1 D i cuss on s i 25 Plitf alge tef lowigcam sf rrle:( )duepr c s viltons ( )e ua anif le s h ol n li o eif 1 o e s oai '2 q l , 26 pr t c i n vi l to s a d ( )fe s e c vi l tons l a dii n,i he opposto Pli tf o e to o ai n ; n 3 r e p e h o ai . n d to n r ii n an if 27 a pe r t a l g vi l tons ofs a e l w a d t e Am e i a sw ih D i a iii s A c . D e e da t p a s o le e o a i tt a n h r c n t s b lte t fn n s 28 s e s mm ayj dgm e tone c oft eecams Tot eexe tne esa ,tec ur wiladdrs ek u r u n a h h s li . h tn c so ,h o t l e s 3 l each cl i bel w . am o 2 A. Due Process 3 5 Pl i tf a lgesDe e da tvi l t dhe duepr c s rght by ( )r tf i gt et w i gof an if le fn n oae r o e s i s 1 aiy n h o n 1. Tow i g n 4 herve il a d( )pr ve tnghe fom ac e sngt eNNAM HS fclt . h ce n 2 e ni r' r c si h a iiy 6 A s t t e t w i g ofPl i tf sve i l , he c ur ha a r a y f und a a m a t rof1 w t a oh o n an if h ce t o t s le d o s te a ht 7 v ow i g Pl i tf sve il wihoutnotc di notde y he duepr c s .'( r e (/ 3)a 6.. t n an if h ce t t ie d nr o e s' O d r /6 t ) 8 Li e i e, ai tf sw asnotde i d a opporuniy t a pe lt e t w i g i vi l ton oft e due k w s Pl n i f ne n t t o p a h o n n oai h 9 pr c s caus .Ne a aRe ie Stttss cin487.39 1 prvi e ,tfave il i twe o e s l e v d v sd au e e to 0 () o ds t l h ce s o d 1 pur ua tt N R S 487. 37 o 487. 38 a d t e owne oft e ve i l be i vest a t e ve i l i 0 sno 0r 0 nh r h h c e le h th h ce s ll unl w f ly t w ed.t e ow neroft e vehi l m ay fl a ci i acton ...t det nni e whet ert e a ul o h h ce ie v l i oen hh 1 t w i g oft eve i l wa lw f l' Se ton487. 3 ( )f rhe sa e , - on t etlng ofac vi 2 on h h c e s a u . ci ' 0 9 3 ' t r tt s l h ii u tp il 1 ac i n pur ua tt s bs c i n 1 t e c ur s a ls he ul a dat t ra he rng. The hea i g m us 3 to s n o u e to , h o t h l c d e eb ai rn t 1 be he d no l t rt a 4 wor i g da sa t rt e a ton i tl d.' 4 l t ae h n kn y fe h c i s ie ' 1 5 A lhough Pl i t fbsc rw ast w e f ra va i t ofr a ons m a y ofwhi h Pl i tf t a n it a o do re y e s , n c a n if l c a l nge ,i i undi put d t a Pl i tf ' ha di a pl ca d w a e pi e . Thus t e t w i g of 6 h le s t s s e h t a n if s n c p a r s x rd ,h o n 1 Pl i tf ' ve i l c m ple wih Ne a aRe ie Stt t s ci n 48 .38.Se N e .Re .St t ( 7 an ifs h ce o id t v d v s d au e e to 7 0 e v v a .i 1 487.38( emitngve ilst bet we i pake i aha dia s a ewihoutbengpr pel 8 0 p r ti h ce o o d f r d n n c p p c t i o ry 1 make ) 9 r d. 20 Pl i tf doesnota l ge a d t e e i no e i e c i di a i g,t atD e e da tde i d a n if le , n h r s v d n e n c tn h fn n n e 21 Pl i tf t e oppor u iy t a pea t e t w i g pur ua tt s c i n 487. 39. Be a s Pl i t f ha a n if h tn t o p l h o n s n o e to 0 c u e a n if d 22 a oppor uniy t c a l nge t e va i iy oft et w i g ofhe ve i l ,D e e da tdi no de y n t t o h le h ld t hon r h ce fn n d t n 23 Plitf duepr c s .SeeGoihmanv Rhe anM otr,l c,682F.d 1 20( t Ci.1 82) an if o es c .u os n . 2 3 9h r 9 24 ( oli gt a whe eteplitf- a ano po tniyt a pe lhi ve il ' t wig,tedue h dn h t r h an ith d p ru t o p a s h ces o n h 25 pr c s ca s wa notviltdlz o e s lu e s o ae . 26 27 z l i tf doesnotchalenge t epr vii n ofs cton 487.039 pr vi i g f rahearng wihi f ur p a n if i h o so ei o dn o i tno daysoft e flng ofa ci i acton. Acc r i gl .t e c urtneed notaddr s whet e duepr cessr quies h ii vl i o dn y h o es hr o er 28 a hearng wihi aperod bref rt a f urdays. i tn i i e hn o 4 1 2. A rres t 2 Pl i tf a s c nt ndsD e e da tdeni d he due pr c s w he s e w asa r s e f r a n if lo o e fn n er o es nh re t d o 3 obsr c i g apo i e of i e i vi l ton of Spa ks M uni i a Code s c i n 9. 30. 20. To t u tn lc fc r n o a i r cp l e to 0 0 4 de onsrt aco siutona vilton,Plitf mus de onsr t ( )ade rvain oflf , m tae n tt i l oai anif t m tae 1 p i to ie 5 lbe t , pr pe t a d ( )t o s i nc s oc i gbe a i rby t egove n e t' Brtai :. i ry and o ry n 2 t n c e e h k n h v o c h r m n . it n ' ' 6 Hans n,451F.d982,991(t Ci. e 3 9h r 2006) . 7 The coul hasrevi w ed t e evi ence and t e arl m ent oft e partesand tnds,asa ' t e h d h p sh i i 8 m a t rofl w , ha D e e da t s c nduc doe no ts oc t e c ns i nc . Conta y t Pl i tf s te a t t fn n ' o t s t th k h o c e e ' ' r r o a n if 9 ass rtons,herarr s w asnotE bira' . Def ndantar es ed Pl i tfff rr f sng t com pl w ih ei et t tl r y e rt an i o e u i o yt 1 Ofi e Ha m esone' i sr cins( )nott e trt eNT AM HSbuidiga d( )onc s e 0 tc r m rt s n tu to 1 o ne h N ln n 2 eh 11 ent red t ebuidi g,t exi t e buidi g. e h l n o th ln 1 2 O fi e H a m e s one a r s e Pl i tf f rvi l tng Spa ksM u i i a Code s c i n tc r m r t r e t d a n if o o a i r n cp l e to 13 9. 30, 20,whi h pr vi es 00 c od, 1 4 l i unl w f lf r a y pe s n t o s r c apu lc ofi e w ho i ac i g l w f ly i t s a u o n r o o b tu t b i tc r s tn a u l n a gover m ent functon, wih know l dge t at t e pers n obs r ct d i a publc n -i t e hh o tu e s i 1 5 1 6 ofie. A pes n o sr csapublcofie i heors e:...( )gjntntonal fc r ro b tu t i fc r f h 6 ii e i ly vi l t so r f s st obe t e l w f lor e ofapublc of i e i al w e f r e e t o ae r e u e o y h a u d r i fc r n a n o c m n a ton ... nvol i g a ac ua orpot nta t r a t publc s f t .... ci i vn n t l e ilh e t o i aey 17 l i undi put d t ataft rOficerH am m er t ne i s r ct d Pl i tf nott ent rt e buidi g, ts s eh et s o n t u e a n if o eh in 1 Pl i t f e t r d t e buidi g s r a i g. O nce i s de t ebuidi g, ai tf r f s d t l a e 8 a n if n e e h l n ce m n ni h l n Pl n i f e u e o e v . 1 Thus i ar sigPlitf-Defnda tsc nd c wa notabiro, Summayj dgm e ti 9 ,n re tn an it e n ' o u t s r ta . , ru ns 20 a pr pl a e w ih r ga d t Pl i tf s due pr ce sc a m . p o i t t e r o a n if o s li S 21 22 23 3 n t eopposton, Pl i tf alo appe r t a gue Def ndantvi l t d herFourh Amendme t Ih ii a n if s as o r e oae t n 24 rg t by( )a r sighe f rf ii gt f lo t eo fc rsi sr c insa d ( )a r sighe wihou i h s 1 retn r o aln o o lw h fie ' n tu to n 2 re tn r t t pr babl caus . Ast herf iur t f low t e of i e ' or er ,Pl i tf ' r lanceon Car y' Nev. oe e o a l e o o l h fc r s d s a n ifs e i e v. Gami g ContolBd., 27 F.d 9 3( t Ci. 2) i mip a e .The e t eNi t Cic i hedt a n r 9 3 7 9h r 200 ,s s lc d r ,h n h ru t l h t N e adas aut saut orzng t epl i tf ' ar es f rr f sngt i entf hi s l a euncons iutonali v tt e h ii h a n ifs r t o e u i o d iy m e f r tt i n vi l ton oft eFourh Am endm ent Thi cas doesnoti vol ePl i tf ' r f s lt i entf he s l,and o ai h t .se n v an if s e u a o d iy r e f 27 Pl i tf doesnotchalenget ef ci lvaldiy ofs cton 9. 30. 30. a n if l h aa t ei 0 0 A st Pl i tf ' pr ba l cl us cl i ,asdi c ss d above,Of i e Har m er t nepos es ed o a n if s o b e a e am su e fc r n so ss 25 26 28 s fi intfc st j siyPli tf ' a r s purua tt S a k M u ii a Cod s c in 90 0.20. u tc e a t o u tf an ifs re t s n o p r s n cp l e e to .3 0 5 1 B. A m eri answ ih D i abii i s Act c t s lt e 4 2 Pli tf ale e t a Dee da tviltdt eAmeia swihDia iiisAc (: DA') 42 anif lg s h t fn n o ae h rc n t s b lte t : A ', 3 U. . .jj l 1 -l 21 byare tng he be a s ofhe diabiiy. Thec ur ha r v e e t e SC 2 01 2 3, r si r c u e r s lt o t s e iw d h 4 e i e c a d a gum e t s b itd by t epa te a d tndst a Pli tf hasf ie t de o sr t vd n e n r n s u m te h ri s n i h t an if ald o m n ta e 5 is esoff c c nc r igwhehe Dee da tar sedPlitf t yr as nofgeqdsbiiy.s su a t o en n t r fn n re t an if t e o b h r ia lt ' ' 6 McGar v Cijt ''r tJ,38 F.d 1 59,1 ( t Ci.2004)( iainomitd) To te y . t ?f( #w J 6 3 2 265 9h r v/ p ctte te . h 7 c n r r .t e e i e ce i di a est a Pl i tf w asa r s e be aus s e r f s d t c m pl w ih o t a y h v d n n c t h t a n if re t d c e h e u e o o y t 8 Ofi e Ha m e sone' or e si vi l ton ofSpa ksM unii a Co es c i n 9. 30.20.Bec us tc r m rt s d r n o ai r cp l d e to 0 0 ae 9 no e i e c bef r t e c u ts gge t t a Pl i tf w a a r s e be aus ofhe di a iiy, v d n e o e h o r u ss b t an if s re td c e r s b lt l s mm ayj dgm e twihr gadt t eADA cam i a pr prae 0 u lu n t e r oh li s p o it. 11 C. R em ai i g Cl i s nn am 1 2 Pl i tf s c m pl i tf rhe a l gest a D e e da ttd d c ns i e t pr ve ta c s t a n i f o a n u t r le h t f n n ti o p r o e n c e s o 13 pr pe t a dprve tac e st prpe t a d fclt ...' ( is Am . o ry n e n c s o o ry n a iiy .' F rt Compl ( l ,a 4. As .# 6) t ) 1 d s us e a ove Pli tf ha f ie t m a et es owi gne de t de onsr t t e de rva i n 4 i e s d b - an if s a ld o k h h n e d o m ta e h p i to 1 ofhe c ns iu i nalrght . A c or i gl ohe e ns iac c a m f is Se Woodr m v W oodw ar 5 r o tt t o is c d n y r o p r y li al . e u. d 1 Cou t,Okahom a,866 F.d l1 1,11 6 ( t Ci.1 8 )( iai n om it d)( otng t a t e 6 ny l 22 2 9 h r 9 9 ct to te n i h t h 17 al ge c ns ia ym us r s l i a acua de rvai n ofa c nsiutona rg t. le d o p r c t e u t n n t l p i to o tt i l i h ) 1 8 Fi a l ,Pl i tf doe no oppos D e e da t s a gu e t and e i e c c nc r i g he n ly a n if s t e fn n ' r m n s v d n e o enn r 1 Frt n m e ta dsaelw cam s Ac o dn l, umm ayj d ne to t eecam si 9 is Ame d n n tt a li . c r igy s r u p n n h s li s 20 a pr prae.Se Loca Rul 7- ( ) Ree e 208F.d736(ic si gpli tf sbude i p o it c l e 2d; s, 3 d su sn anif r n n 2 1 // / 22 // / 23 // / 24 # 25 :6 27 4 l i tf a pe r t c m bi ehe e ua p ot c i n a d ADA a gu e t . p a n if p a s o o n r q l r e to n r m ns 5n heropposii n, Pl i tf a pea st alege Def ndantdicrm i at d agai s he be aus ofhe 1 to a n if p r o l e sine nt r c e r r ce.I i nota pr pra ef rPl i tf t as er new alega i nsout i e t e s ope oft e compl i ti an a ts p o it o a n if o s t l to sd h c h an n 6 28 o p stont amoi n f rs rm ayj dg e t p o ii o to o u n r u m n . 1 rbutigmotonfrs nm ayj dgme t. e tn i o un r u n) I I THEREFORE ORDERED t a De e dantsM o i n f rSumm a yJ dgm e t( 119) TS h t f n ' to o ru n# 3 i GRA N T ED . s TheClr oft ec ur s ale trj d m e tac or igl . ek h o t h l n e u g n c dn y I I SO ORDERE TS / D A TED t i hs da ofSe t m be , 9. y p e r 200 ' % LA N'R .Hl l. c cs IT I ED STATES D I T R I T J JD G E -N T SCI 21 7

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?