Geraldine Lee v. Northern Nevada Adult Mental Health Services. et al

Filing 141

ORDER GRANTING D Sparks Police Department's 119 Motion for Summary Judgment. Clerk shall enter judgment accordingly. Signed by Judge Larry R. Hicks on 9/21/2009. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

h

.

.

)
' )
1

( j 2 3 4 5 ' '
'

'
L

;
.
l

. L
. ,

r

:

.

'

6
7

U N I ED STA T ES DISTRI T CO U R T T C
D I T R I T O F N EV A D A S C

8

*****

9 GERALDW E L LEE, 1 0
11 vs .

Plitf, an if

) ) ) ) )
)

03:6- V- 433- RH- AM 0C 0 L R
ORDER

1 N NA M H S,ALEXANDER,CI Y A UTO 2 T

TO W ,CI Y OF SPARKS POLI E DEPT. ) T C , 1 COOK ,FLOW ER S,J CK SO N,M OO RE, ) 3 A REY N OLD S a d DOES 1X , n )

)

1 4
l 5
1 6

D e e da t . fn n s

) ) )

Be or t e cou ti D e e da tSpa ksPolc D e a t e t s M oton f r Sum m a y f eh r s fn n r i e p rm n ' io r

l J dgme t( 11 :.Plitf Geaii eLe ha tlda o posto ( 1 2)t whih Defnda t 7u n # 9) anif r dn e s ie n p iin # 3 o c en

1 rple ( 135 .Dee da tCiyAut Towi g' ha j iedt emoin frs mm ayj dgm e ta d 8 e id # ) fn n t o n s s on h to o u r u nn 1 t er pl ( 1 4,1 6) 9 h ey* 2 3 .
20 1. Facts and ProceduralH i t ry so

21

Thi i a c vi r g t diput a i i g o tofa i c de twhe Pl i tf ' a t m obie w as s s i l ih s s e rsn u n ni n n a n ifs u o l

22 twe fom Norhe. Ne a aAdul Me tlHe lhSe rce (G NAM HS' .OnJ ne21, 6, o d' r t l vd n t n a at n i s GN ' ) u 200
23 a t rt eve i l had be n pa ke i t e s m e s ota N N A M H S f ra pr xi a el o e w e k,a fe h h c e e r dnh a pt o p o m ty n e 24 t e t - ourho rt w no i e w a pl c d on Pl i tf s ve i l bec us t e ve i l wasa l ge l w n yf uo tc s ae a n if h c e a e h h c e le d y

25 t ki g up t o ha dia paki g s a e ,ha expiedlce s spl t s ha a e piedha di a an w n cp r n p cs d r i n e ae . d n x r n cp
26 per i,and appear d t havebeen abandoned. On June 26,2006,D ef ndantCiy A ut Tow mt eo k t o

27 t w e t e ve i l . D e e da tM oor , he f c lt s pe vi o a N N A M H S,a t o i ed t e o d h h ce fn n e t a iiy u r s r t u h rz h
28
ltefrst t ecourtsdocketenty num be . l e oh ' r r

1 t w i g. on
2 On Jul 20 or21,2006,D ef ndantA l xanderr cei ed s veralvoi e m ai m es ageson y e e ev e c l s

3 hi tlphonec m plii ga o ttet vealma a lm e tot t eopeaina e doft ehos ia s ee o ann b u h s rl n g e n l h o rto l n h ptl 4 fclt . ( ef.M ot Summ.J ( l1 ) Ex. a 9:0- l) Dee da tAlxa de beivedt a a iiy' D s' . ' .# 9 , B t 1 1 . fn n e n r le h t
5 tec ntntoftel e s ge wa tveyha a sng. (#.Ex. a 1 :2- 3. De e da t Re nol s h oe h n sa s s t r r s i ' f , B t 22 2 ) fn n s y d '
6 a d J c s n ls e e t t e m e s ge a d r c g i ed t e voi e asPl i tf s A f e t e m e s ge n a k o it n d o h sa s n eo nz h c a n if . tr h sa s 7 w e e l f on D e e da tA l xa de ' t l pho e D e e da tRe nol s i sr c ed D ef nda tLe , r et f n n e n rs ee n , f n n y d n tu t ene 8 t e die t roft e N N A M H S Dr p- n Ce t r t i f r Pl i tf t ats e c ul notus t e D r ph rco h o l n e , o n o m a n if h h o d eh o
9 I Cent r f r aperod oftm e. n eb i i

1 0

The Dr p- n Ce t ri a f c lt r n by i di i ua s w ih m e t lil es e t s ppor ot e o l n e s a iiy u n vd l t n a ln s s o u t hr

l1 i di i ual w ih m ent lil essesi t ei recovery and t ser e as a pl ce w here s ch i di i ual n vd s t a ln nhr ov a u n vd s

1 c n f e s f . The C e t rhasa lbr r ,m i r w a e, nd r f i e a ora d s n ' scof e , e ,a d 2 a e l ae ne i a y c o v a e rg r t n e e fe ta n l s a ks The Ce t r a s pr vi esc m pu e sa d t l phone . The Ce t r doe notpr vi e 3 nc . n e lo o d o tr n ee s ne s od 1 m e i a i n, nd t e e a e no doct r orot e c i i a pr f s i na s a a l bl att e Ce t r 4 d c to a h r r os h r ln c l o e s o l v ia e h n e. 1 5 O n J l 25,2006.Pl i tf c m e t t e D r p- n Ce t rt r t i vehe pos e s ons uy a n if a oh o l n e o ere r ssi .

1 D e e da tJ c s n as e he a s s a tt r t i ve t e pos es i ns butPl i tf r f s d t e . 6 f n n a k o k d r s it n o ere h s so , a n if e u e h m
17 D ef ndantJackson t en asked Pl i tf- o l ave-and Pl i tf r f sed. Defe dantJaekson e h a n i tt e a n if e u n

18 i di a e s e w oul ha et ca lt e polc , hi h s e di . n c td h d v o lh ie w c h d 1 9 Spa ks Polc O f i e Ja e H a m e s one r s onde a d es or e Pl i tf f om t e r i e fc r m s m r t ep d n c td a n if ' rh

20 buidi g. Pl i tf t e s a e t a s e w a t d t e t rt e N N A M H S f c lt ,a d Ofi e ln a n if h n tt d h t h ne o ne h a iiy n tc r 2 1 H a m e s one t l he nott . Pl i tf pr c ede t e t rt e buidi g s r a i g. Pl i tf w a m rt od r o an if o e d o n e h l n ce m n a n if s 2 t l s ve a tm est s o s r a i g a d e i t ebuid ng. Pl i t f r f s d. O f i e 2 od e rl i o tp c e m n n x th li an if e u e fc r 23 H a m e sonet e ha dc f e Pl i tf a d pl c d he u de a r s f r o s r c i g a polc m rt h n n u f d a n i f n a e r n r r e t o b t u tn ie 2 ofi e i vi l ton ofSpa ksM uni i a C o e s c i n 9. 30. 20. 4 tc r n o a i r c p l d e to 0 0
25 1l. LegalSt ndard a

26

Summayj dgme ti a pr praeonl whe ûhepla igs de ostons a s e st ru n s p o it y n % e dn . p ii , n w r o t

27 i t r og t res a d a m i sonson fl ,t get e w ih t e a fda is i a y,s ow t a t e e i no ner ao i . n d si ie o h r t h f i v t , f n h h th r s

2 g nun is ea t a ymaeil a ta dt a t emo i gpa t i e tte t j dg e ta amatr 8 e ie su s o n tra f c n h th v n ry s n ild o u m n s te
2

1 oflu,'Fe . Ci .P.56() l as s igamotonf rs mm a zudgme tt ee ie ce a . d R. v ' c. n se sn i o u oj n ,h v d n ,
2 t ge he wih al i f r nce t a c n r as na l be d a n t e ef o , us be r a i t e lg t o t r t 1 n ee s h t a e o b y r w h r r m m t e d n h ih 3 m os f vor bl t t e pa t oppos ng t e m o i n. M at us ia El c. ndu .Co.v Ze ih Radi t a a e o h ry ih to s ht e I s . nt o

4 Col .475U. . 587( 986) Count q Tuolmnev. nor Cm(.Hos .236F.d 11 8, p, S 574, l* , yf u So a p p , 34
5 1l 4 ( t Ci.2001 . 5 9h r )
6
7

The m ovi g pa t bea st e bur e ofi f r i g t e c ur oft e bass f rism oton, n ry r h d n n om n h o t h iot i
al ng w ih evi ence s ow i g t e a s nce ofany genui e i s e ofm at r alf ct Cel t x Cor .v. o t d h n h be n su ei a . oe p

8 Catet477U. . ,3 3( 98 ) Ontos is e f rwhihi be r t ebur e ofpr of t e r t, S 317 2 1 6 . h e su s o c t a s h d n o .b
9 m ovi g pa-y m ustm ake a s ow i g t ati tsufi i ntf rt e courtt hol t atno reasonabl n lt h n h s b tc e o h o dh e

1 t i roff c c ul fnd ot e t a f rt e m ovi g pa t . Cal e one v.Unie St t s,7 9 F. d 0 re at o d i h rh n o h n ry ' ' dr td a e 9 2

11 254, ( t Ci.1 ; ca/, I c a n Dr am wor s I c ,l F.Supp.2c 11 9,1 41( . . 259 6 h r 986) se 5? d m ( e k , n 62 1 2 1 CD

1 Ca. 2 l2001) .

1 3
14

To s c e sul rbutamoton frs mm ayj dgme t teno - ovi gpa t mus poi t u c sf ly e i ou ru n ,h n m n ry t n
t f c s s pport d by t e recor whi h dem ons r t a genui e i sue ofm at ri lf ct Reese r. o at u e h d c ta e ns ea a .

1 Jefr onSc .DitNo.1 J,208F.d736( t Ci. 5 fe s h s. 4 3 9h r 2000) A t aeilf c'i afcttha miht . t tra a t's a û t g m t
1 a f c t e o t om e oft e s i unde t e gove ni g l w . Ander on v Li ery Lobby, nc ,477 6 fe t h u c h ut rh rn a ' ' s .bt l.

1 U. . 248 ( 986 .W he er a o abl m i dsc ul dif ron t ema e i lf c sa is e 7 S 242, 1) r e s n e n o d fe h t ra a t t s u ,

18 s mm a'j dpne ti nota pr prae.Seev Dtr n .71lF.d l 1 1 (t Ci.1 83) A u lu y n s p o it . ta g 2 4 , 43 9h r 9 .
1 di put r ga di g a m a ei lf c i c nsde e ge ui e ç ft e e i e ce i s ch t a a r a ona l 9 s ee rn t la a t s o i r d n n t h v d n s u h t e s b e i

20 j l c ul rtl aveditf rteno m ovigpa t. Li e t Lobby, U. . t248.Theme e u' o d eu' r c o h n n ry' b r. y n ' y 477 S a r
21 e it nce ofa s i tla ofev de c i s ppor oft e pl i tf sposton w ilbe i s fi i ntt x se c n il i nen u t h a n if ii l n u tc e o

2 e tbls ag n ied s ue t eemu t e i e c o wh c t ej r c udr a o a l f df r 2 sa ih e u n ip t;h r s be v d n e n ih h u y o l e s n b y i o n
23 t e pl i t f . See i .a 252. h a n if dt
24 11 . 1 D i cuss on s i

25 Plitf alge tef lowigcam sf rrle:( )duepr c s viltons ( )e ua anif le s h ol n li o eif 1 o e s oai '2 q l , 26 pr t c i n vi l to s a d ( )fe s e c vi l tons l a dii n,i he opposto Pli tf o e to o ai n ; n 3 r e p e h o ai . n d to n r ii n an if
27 a pe r t a l g vi l tons ofs a e l w a d t e Am e i a sw ih D i a iii s A c . D e e da t p a s o le e o a i tt a n h r c n t s b lte t fn n s

28 s e s mm ayj dgm e tone c oft eecams Tot eexe tne esa ,tec ur wiladdrs ek u r u n a h h s li . h tn c so ,h o t l e s
3

l each cl i bel w . am o 2 A. Due Process

3
5

Pl i tf a lgesDe e da tvi l t dhe duepr c s rght by ( )r tf i gt et w i gof an if le fn n oae r o e s i s 1 aiy n h o n
1. Tow i g n

4 herve il a d( )pr ve tnghe fom ac e sngt eNNAM HS fclt . h ce n 2 e ni r' r c si h a iiy
6 A s t t e t w i g ofPl i tf sve i l , he c ur ha a r a y f und a a m a t rof1 w t a oh o n an if h ce t o t s le d o s te a ht

7 v ow i g Pl i tf sve il wihoutnotc di notde y he duepr c s .'( r e (/ 3)a 6.. t n an if h ce t t ie d nr o e s' O d r /6 t )
8 Li e i e, ai tf sw asnotde i d a opporuniy t a pe lt e t w i g i vi l ton oft e due k w s Pl n i f ne n t t o p a h o n n oai h

9 pr c s caus .Ne a aRe ie Stttss cin487.39 1 prvi e ,tfave il i twe o e s l e v d v sd au e e to 0 () o ds t l h ce s o d
1 pur ua tt N R S 487. 37 o 487. 38 a d t e owne oft e ve i l be i vest a t e ve i l i 0 sno 0r 0 nh r h h c e le h th h ce s
ll unl w f ly t w ed.t e ow neroft e vehi l m ay fl a ci i acton ...t det nni e whet ert e a ul o h h ce ie v l i oen hh

1 t w i g oft eve i l wa lw f l' Se ton487. 3 ( )f rhe sa e ,ç - on t etlng ofac vi 2 on h h c e s a u . ci ' 0 9 3 ' t r tt s çl h ii u tp il
1 ac i n pur ua tt s bs c i n 1 t e c ur s a ls he ul a dat t ra he rng. The hea i g m us 3 to s n o u e to , h o t h l c d e eb ai rn t 1 be he d no l t rt a 4 wor i g da sa t rt e a ton i tl d.' 4 l t ae h n kn y fe h c i s ie ' 1 5 A lhough Pl i t fbsc rw ast w e f ra va i t ofr a ons m a y ofwhi h Pl i tf t a n it a o do re y e s , n c a n if

l c a l nge ,i i undi put d t a Pl i tf ' ha di a pl ca d w a e pi e . Thus t e t w i g of 6 h le s t s s e h t a n if s n c p a r s x rd ,h o n

1 Pl i tf ' ve i l c m ple wih Ne a aRe ie Stt t s ci n 48 .38.Se N e .Re .St t ( 7 an ifs h ce o id t v d v s d au e e to 7 0 e v v a .i

1 487.38( emitngve ilst bet we i pake i aha dia s a ewihoutbengpr pel 8 0 p r ti h ce o o d f r d n n c p p c t i o ry 1 make ) 9 r d.
20 Pl i tf doesnota l ge a d t e e i no e i e c i di a i g,t atD e e da tde i d a n if le , n h r s v d n e n c tn h fn n n e 21 Pl i tf t e oppor u iy t a pea t e t w i g pur ua tt s c i n 487. 39. Be a s Pl i t f ha a n if h tn t o p l h o n s n o e to 0 c u e a n if d 22 a oppor uniy t c a l nge t e va i iy oft et w i g ofhe ve i l ,D e e da tdi no de y n t t o h le h ld t hon r h ce fn n d t n

23 Plitf duepr c s .SeeGoihmanv Rhe anM otr,l c,682F.d 1 20( t Ci.1 82) an if o es c .u os n . 2 3 9h r 9
24 ( oli gt a whe eteplitf- a ano po tniyt a pe lhi ve il ' t wig,tedue h dn h t r h an ith d p ru t o p a s h ces o n h 25 pr c s ca s wa notviltdlz o e s lu e s o ae .
26 27
z l i tf doesnotchalenge t epr vii n ofs cton 487.039 pr vi i g f rahearng wihi f ur p a n if i h o so ei o dn o i tno daysoft e flng ofa ci i acton. Acc r i gl .t e c urtneed notaddr s whet e duepr cessr quies h ii vl i o dn y h o es hr o er 28 a hearng wihi aperod bref rt a f urdays. i tn i i e hn o 4

1

2.

A rres t

2

Pl i tf a s c nt ndsD e e da tdeni d he due pr c s w he s e w asa r s e f r a n if lo o e fn n er o es nh re t d o

3 obsr c i g apo i e of i e i vi l ton of Spa ks M uni i a Code s c i n 9. 30. 20. To t u tn lc fc r n o a i r cp l e to 0 0

4 de onsrt aco siutona vilton,Plitf mus de onsr t ( )ade rvain oflf , m tae n tt i l oai anif t m tae 1 p i to ie
5 lbe t , pr pe t a d ( )t o s i nc s oc i gbe a i rby t egove n e t' Brtai :. i ry and o ry n 2 t n c e e h k n h v o c h r m n . it n ' '

6 Hans n,451F.d982,991(t Ci. e 3 9h r 2006) .
7 The coul hasrevi w ed t e evi ence and t e arl m ent oft e partesand tnds,asa ' t e h d h p sh i i

8 m a t rofl w , ha D e e da t s c nduc doe no ts oc t e c ns i nc . Conta y t Pl i tf s te a t t fn n ' o t s t th k h o c e e ' ' r r o a n if
9 ass rtons,herarr s w asnotE bira' . Def ndantar es ed Pl i tfff rr f sng t com pl w ih ei et t tl r y e rt an i o e u i o yt

1 Ofi e Ha m esone' i sr cins( )nott e trt eNT AM HSbuidiga d( )onc s e 0 tc r m rt s n tu to 1 o ne h N ln n 2 eh
11 ent red t ebuidi g,t exi t e buidi g. e h l n o th ln

1 2

O fi e H a m e s one a r s e Pl i tf f rvi l tng Spa ksM u i i a Code s c i n tc r m r t r e t d a n if o o a i r n cp l e to

13 9. 30, 20,whi h pr vi es 00 c od,

1 4

l i unl w f lf r a y pe s n t o s r c apu lc ofi e w ho i ac i g l w f ly i t s a u o n r o o b tu t b i tc r s tn a u l n a gover m ent functon, wih know l dge t at t e pers n obs r ct d i a publc n -i t e hh o tu e s i

1 5
1 6

ofie. A pes n o sr csapublcofie i heors e:...( )gjntntonal fc r ro b tu t i fc r f h 6 ii e i ly

vi l t so r f s st obe t e l w f lor e ofapublc of i e i al w e f r e e t o ae r e u e o y h a u d r i fc r n a n o c m n a ton ... nvol i g a ac ua orpot nta t r a t publc s f t .... ci i vn n t l e ilh e t o i aey

17 l i undi put d t ataft rOficerH am m er t ne i s r ct d Pl i tf nott ent rt e buidi g, ts s eh et s o n t u e a n if o eh in

1 Pl i t f e t r d t e buidi g s r a i g. O nce i s de t ebuidi g, ai tf r f s d t l a e 8 a n if n e e h l n ce m n ni h l n Pl n i f e u e o e v .

1 Thus i ar sigPlitf-Defnda tsc nd c wa notabiro, Summayj dgm e ti 9 ,n re tn an it e n ' o u t s r ta . , ru ns
20 a pr pl a e w ih r ga d t Pl i tf s due pr ce sc a m . p o i t t e r o a n if o s li S
21

22 23
3 n t eopposton, Pl i tf alo appe r t a gue Def ndantvi l t d herFourh Amendme t Ih ii a n if s as o r e oae t n

24 rg t by( )a r sighe f rf ii gt f lo t eo fc rsi sr c insa d ( )a r sighe wihou i h s 1 retn r o aln o o lw h fie ' n tu to n 2 re tn r t t
pr babl caus . Ast herf iur t f low t e of i e ' or er ,Pl i tf ' r lanceon Car y' Nev. oe e o a l e o o l h fc r s d s a n ifs e i e v. Gami g ContolBd., 27 F.d 9 3( t Ci. 2) i mip a e .The e t eNi t Cic i hedt a n r 9 3 7 9h r 200 ,s s lc d r ,h n h ru t l h t N e adas aut saut orzng t epl i tf ' ar es f rr f sngt i entf hi s l a euncons iutonali v tt e h ii h a n ifs r t o e u i o d iy m e f r tt i n vi l ton oft eFourh Am endm ent Thi cas doesnoti vol ePl i tf ' r f s lt i entf he s l,and o ai h t .se n v an if s e u a o d iy r e f 27 Pl i tf doesnotchalenget ef ci lvaldiy ofs cton 9. 30. 30. a n if l h aa ît ei 0 0 A st Pl i tf ' pr ba l cl us cl i ,asdi c ss d above,Of i e Har m er t nepos es ed o a n if s o b e a e am su e fc r n so ss

25 26

28 s fi intfc st j siyPli tf ' a r s purua tt S a k M u ii a Cod s c in 90 0.20. u tc e a t o u tf an ifs re t s n o p r s n cp l e e to .3 0
5

1

B.

A m eri answ ih D i abii i s Act c t s lt e 4

2

Pli tf ale e t a Dee da tviltdt eAmeia swihDia iiisAc (: DA') 42 anif lg s h t fn n o ae h rc n t s b lte t : A ',

3 U. . .jj l 1 -l 21 byare tng he be a s ofhe diabiiy. Thec ur ha r v e e t e SC 2 01 2 3, r si r c u e r s lt o t s e iw d h
4 e i e c a d a gum e t s b itd by t epa te a d tndst a Pli tf hasf ie t de o sr t vd n e n r n s u m te h ri s n i h t an if ald o m n ta e

5 is esoff c c nc r igwhehe Dee da tar sedPlitf t yr as nofgeqdsbiiy.s su a t o en n t r fn n re t an if t e o b h r ia lt ' '
6 McGar v Cijt ''r tJ,38 F.d 1 59,1 ( t Ci.2004)( iainomitd) To te y . t ?f( #w J 6 3 2 265 9h r v/ p ctte te . h
7 c n r r .t e e i e ce i di a est a Pl i tf w asa r s e be aus s e r f s d t c m pl w ih o t a y h v d n n c t h t a n if re t d c e h e u e o o y t

8 Ofi e Ha m e sone' or e si vi l ton ofSpa ksM unii a Co es c i n 9. 30.20.Bec us tc r m rt s d r n o ai r cp l d e to 0 0 ae
9 no e i e c bef r t e c u ts gge t t a Pl i tf w a a r s e be aus ofhe di a iiy, v d n e o e h o r u ss b t an if s re td c e r s b lt

l s mm ayj dgm e twihr gadt t eADA cam i a pr prae 0 u lu n t e r oh li s p o it.
11 C. R em ai i g Cl i s nn am

1 2

Pl i tf s c m pl i tf rhe a l gest a D e e da ttd d c ns i e t pr ve ta c s t a n i f o a n u t r le h t f n n ti o p r o e n c e s o

13 pr pe t a dprve tac e st prpe t a d fclt ...' ( is Am . o ry n e n c s o o ry n a iiy .' F rt Compl ( l ,a 4. As .# 6) t )
1 d s us e a ove Pli tf ha f ie t m a et es owi gne de t de onsr t t e de rva i n 4 i e s d b - an if s a ld o k h h n e d o m ta e h p i to
1 ofhe c ns iu i nalrght . A c or i gl ohe e ns iac c a m f is Se Woodr m v W oodw ar 5 r o tt t o is c d n y r o p r y li al . e u. d

1 Cou t,Okahom a,866 F.d l1 1,11 6 ( t Ci.1 8 )( iai n om it d)( otng t a t e 6 ny l 22 2 9 h r 9 9 ct to te n i h t h 17 al ge c ns ia ym us r s l i a acua de rvai n ofa c nsiutona rg t. le d o p r c t e u t n n t l p i to o tt i l i h )
1 8 Fi a l ,Pl i tf doe no oppos D e e da t s a gu e t and e i e c c nc r i g he n ly a n if s t e fn n ' r m n s v d n e o enn r

1 Frt n m e ta dsaelw cam s Ac o dn l, umm ayj d ne to t eecam si 9 is Ame d n n tt a li . c r igy s r u p n n h s li s 20 a pr prae.Se Loca Rul 7- ( ) Ree e 208F.d736(ic si gpli tf sbude i p o it c l e 2d; s, 3 d su sn anif r n n
2 1 // / 22 // /

23 // /
24 #

25 :6
27

4 l i tf a pe r t c m bi ehe e ua p ot c i n a d ADA a gu e t . p a n if p a s o o n r q l r e to n r m ns
5n heropposii n, Pl i tf a pea st alege Def ndantdicrm i at d agai s he be aus ofhe 1 to a n if p r o l e sine nt r c e r r ce.I i nota pr pra ef rPl i tf t as er new alega i nsout i e t e s ope oft e compl i ti an a ts p o it o a n if o s t l to sd h c h an n 6

28 o p stont amoi n f rs rm ayj dg e t p o ii o to o u n r u m n .

1 rbutigmotonfrs nm ayj dgme t. e tn i o un r u n) I I THEREFORE ORDERED t a De e dantsM o i n f rSumm a yJ dgm e t( 119) TS h t f n ' to o ru n#
3 i GRA N T ED . s

TheClr oft ec ur s ale trj d m e tac or igl . ek h o t h l n e u g n c dn y

I I SO ORDERE TS /
D A TED t i hs da ofSe t m be , 9. y p e r 200
'

%

LA N'R .Hl l. c cs IT I ED STATES D I T R I T J JD G E -N T SCI

21

7