Egberto v. Nevada Department Of Corrections

Filing 215

ORDER DENYING # 193 Request for Review of Magistrate Judge's Order. FURTHER ORD DENYING # 199 Motion for Reconsideration. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 9/14/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

Download PDF
. L 6 ' 1 2 !..> .l2L1g2 11 . $ ' ---- 'L I ) . . .- - - l ?. . ,, 2' j f- - f-- - - . -- - - . r. . , ' , j- y ;. ss . ...):..'.y. j... , $ m..,t.',q:- .. . : .,..).af.k'.. . , k.' q7 .g ,, :;'s ; ..a..t,..,'syk k ,..r.,..,ar . . , . . ' '; 3 4 5 . . t ; r . . (// . jgj j -(J , j 1 4'. ) . .. . / . . ! . .- . Y' ' $ ' ': ' . .. . . - /' , '' dr > . . .. . )t j w , 6 2 6 UNI ED STATESDI TRI T COURT '' -= =L='-Y ' . T S0 - - = -' XW Y S W T O V W V A D A '' '' W RI KW EGRVRTO, O 9 1 0 11 1 2 l 3 1 4 ) ) Pl i tf, an if ) ) vs . ) ) NEVADA DEPARTM ENT OF CORRECTI NS ) O e a. t 1, ) ) Dee da t. fn ns ) ) 3: 6- v- 071S R CJ RA M 0c0 -- ORDER 1 5 Thi c s a i e o t of Det ndan s alege delbe a e i dif r nce t Pl i tf ' m e i al s a e rs s u e t ' l d i r t n fe e o a n if s d c 1 ne ds i pr s n,i vi l ton of t e Ei ht a d Four e nt Am e dm e t . Pl i tf a s a l ges 6 e n io n o a i h gh n te h n ns a n if l o le 1 neglgenc unde saelw.Hedema dsmoneayda age andij nctverle.Pe di gbefr 7 i e r tt a n tr m s nu i eif n n o e Egberto v. Nevada Department Of Corrections Doc. 215 l t e Cour a e t o m o i nsf rr viw ofa or e oft e M agita eJ dg . Fort er a o sgi e 8h tr w to b e e n dr h sr t u e h e sn v n 1 he ei ,t e Co r de ist em otons 9 rn h u t ne h i. 20 1 . 21 FAC T S A N D PR O C E D U R A L H I T O R Y S Pl i tf Ri k y Egbe t i i c r e a e w ihi t e N eva a De arm ent of Cor ec i ns a n if c e ro s n a c r t d t n h d pt r to 22 (t DOC' .Fis Am. N ' ( rt Compl!1 ECFNo. .Plitf, ale e hehast ohenitddics ) , 7, 33) an ifwho lg s w r ae s 23 i hi s i e hasbe n gi e mediain f rt epan,butha bee de id s r e'.(d) Plitf n s pn , e vn c to o h i s n n e u g l 1 .. an if y 24 ale est a t ei fr ay a E1 Stt Prs n ( SP' ,wheehei c renty ic r eae ,hasa lg h t h n im r t y ae io i ' E)r s u r l n ac rtd 25 c som andpr c ieoff ii g t pr perydi gnos , r a , d m e ia ei m a e ,a dhea gu st a ut a tc aln o o l a e te t an dc t n ts n r e ht Dockets.Justia.com 1 ti c nsiutsd lbeaeidifrnce (#..Plitf aloalge ta t one - a i ngmembes h s o tt e ei rt n fee .f ) an if s le s h tw o N z ga r, 2 a a ns whom het s ii d, r i c r e a e a ESP, ount rt Pl i t f s S nde s a di g' t a t e gi t e tfe a e n a c r t d t c e o a n ip t r t n n ' h t h y u 3 woul beic r eae ele hee.(d.. Healgest a heha r c ie de t t rat fom t e e d n ac rtd s w r 1 ) le h t s e ev d ah h e s r h s 4 i m a e ,a d hear ue t a t ef iur t hous t e e s w he e c nsiut sdelber t i dif r nc n ts n g s h t h al e o e h m le r o tt e i ae n fe e e 5 byNDOC.(d) I. 6 OnDe embe 22, c r 2006, aitf s edNDOC i t i Cou t trec us so a ton: 1-( ) Pl nif u n h s r on h e a e f ci () 2 7 s bsa tve due pr c s and eq a pr tc i n vi ltons unde t e FouMe nt Am e dm e tand u tn i o es u l o e to o a i rh eh nn 8 d lbeat idifr nc vi ltonsunde t eEiht a dFouree t Ame dm e t,vi 42U. . . ei r e n fe e e o ai rh g h n t nh n ns a SC 9 1 834a d( )saelw ne lg nc .Plitf a ende t ecomplito J l 1 20 7t addt e 9 n 3 tt a gie e anif m dh an n uy 7, 0 o h 1 f low i g D ef nda t :G l n W horon,H o ar Skol i ,Te D ' m i o,M . . Robe tBa ni t r 0 ol n e ns e t wd nk d A c D, r n se , 1 M . . E. .M c a i l,Ada Ende ,FrtsSc l tm a ,a d W ila Dona . TheFis Am e de 1 D, K D nes m l it h o t n n lim t rt nd 1 Com pl i t a ds no ne ca s s of a ton but c ns lda es t e tr t t o ca s s of a ton of t e 2 an d w ue ci o o i t h is w ue ci h 1 Com pl i ti t a sngl c us ofa ton. 3 an no i e a e ci 1 4 On Nove be 3,2009,t e Cour a optd te M a itae J dge' ( J' Re or a d mr h td e h g srt u s : ' p t n M) 15 Re ommendain( & R, No. )g a tngPlitf sM otonf rPr lm iar Ij ncin( CF c to R ECF 55 r ni anip i o ei n y n u to E 1 No. )i pa t Defnda t weeodee t f lo Dr Long' rc mmende c ureofte t ent 6 35 n re n s r r rd o olw . s eo d o s ram l or t s nd Pl i tf f r a ot e e a ua i n by a e ui a en doc or a d f low t a doc or s 7 oe a n i f o n h r v l to n q vl t t n ol h t t ' 1 r c m m e de c ur e oft e t e t butDef nda t w e enotr q ie t ta s e Pl i t f t a ot er 8 eo n do s r am n , e ns r e u r d o r n f r a n if o n h 1 fciiy.( r e 2 3,No .2,2009,ECF No.1 4) OnM ach3,201 ,teM Jhel atlphoni 9 a lt O d r v 2. r 0h d ee c 20 he rng a d de id te f lowig motons M otont Enf r eOr e ( CF No.1 8) M oin t ai n n e h ol n i : i o oc d r E 2 ; to o 21 Pr cudeDe ut AG fo Blc ig, ndei g, Itre ig( CFNo.l ) M otonfrOr e t el py r m o kn Hi rn or n efrn E 33 . i o d r o , 22 Show Ca s ( CFNo.1 5 ; Motonf rSa cins( CFNo.1 6) Afe rviwigame ial ue E 4 ) and i o n to E 4 . tr e e n dc 23 r po tta c nclde not igwaswr ngwihPlitf ss iebas dona M RIs a ,( rgM a . e r h t o u d hn o t anip pn e n cn H ' r 24 3, 0, t9:3a. .,e or sidiaigt a Plitf ha rf sdmediaina varoustmes (d. 201 a 0 m ) rc d n c tn h t anif d eu e c to t i i ,i 25 Pag 2 of 5 e 1 a 9:4a. ., rporbyDrKol ( honei)idiaigt a Dr. t 0 m )a e t . m p tc n c tn h t s Kohna dLongweei agee en n rn rm t 2 t a Pl i tf wasm a i ge i g i or e t ac uie a ce st na c tcsa d an unne d d c ne pos i l h t a n if ln r n n d r o q r c s o r o i n e e a , sb y 3 f rus asawe pon,(d.a 9: 5a. .,a d e ie c t a ma y pe pl h d s e Plitf wak oe a i t 0 m ) n vd n e h t n o e a e n an if l 4 w ihou a y lm p o ot e difculy a d t a heonl w a ke w ih alm p whe be ng s e b m e i a t tn i r h r fi t n h t y ld t i n i en y dcl 5 pes nne,i a 9:6-07a. .,heM Jf undt a Dee danswer i c m pla c wiht i Cour' ro l(d t 0 m )t o h t fn t e n o in e t h s ts 6 Nove be 2, m r 2009 or e ,a d het er f r de i d Pl i tf smotonsn s 1 8,1 5,a d 1 6, s e dr n h e o e n e an ip i o . 2 4 n 4 (e 7 i.a 9:9-1 a. .M iut Or e,Ma .3,201 ,ECF No.16 ) Healo de idmotonno.1 3. d t 0 0 m ; n e dr r 0 6. s ne i 3 8 Plitf fld aNotc ofAppe l( CF No.1 0)a d aM oi n f rRec nsdeain of an if ie ie aE 7n to o o i rto 9 M a itaeJ dge' Or e ( CFNo.1 2)whihti Cour de id.Se Or e,Aug. 201 , g sr t u s d r E 7 , c h s t ne ( e d r 24, 0 ECF 1 No.21 .Plitf alotldaMotonf rCo r Or ee Trns orain t l de ende tM edial 0 0) an if s ie i o u t d rd a p tto o n p n c 11 Exam ( CFNO.1 a daM oinf rCourOr ee M e ia Expe tECFNo. 79 , hofwhih E 76) n to o t drd dcl r( 1 )bot c 1 t eMJteaedasmoinst rc nsde a dde id.seeM a . Or e,Ma 6, 0, No.1 1 . 2h rt to o e o i r n n e (' g J. d r y 201 ECF 9) 1 Pl i tf ha now tl d t o m or m o i nsas i g t i Cou t o r vi w t e M a 6, 1 o dero t e 3 a n if s ie w e to kn h s rt e e h y 20 0 r fh 1 4 M J denyi g t os m otons. nhe i LEG A L STAN D A R D S 15 II . 1 6 Ru e7 ()pemisad src c u tud et mo iy o s ta ieama itaej d e sn n l 2 a r t itit o r j g o df r e sd gsrt u g ' o - 1 di pos tve r lng t a i c ea l e r ne usorc nt m' t l w : 7 s ii u i h t s l ry r o o o ryoa 1 8 1 9 20 21 W he apr t i l a t rnotdipos tveofapa t ' cl i ordef ns i r f r ed n e ra m te s ii ry s a m e e s ee r t ama itae u g t h a a dd cd ,hema itae ud emu t r m pl c n u t o gsrt j d e o e r n e ie t gsrt j g s p o ty o d c t e r qui e pr ce di gs an ,w hen a pr pra e,i s e a w rte or e s a i g t e h e rd o e n d p o it s u it n d r t tn h decson. A pa t mays r ea d tl obe tonst teor erwihi 1 da safe ii ry e v n 'e j ci o h d t n 4 y tr i be ng s r e w ih a c py. A pa t m a n tas i n a e r ra de e ti t e or e not i evd t o ry y o s g s r o fc n h d r tmeyo j ce t ,Th dititu g i tec s mu t o sd ri eyo j cin a d i l b e td o e src j d e n h a e s c n ie tm l b e to s n m odi yors ta i e a y pa'oft e o de t a i cl a l e r ne usori c ntar t l w . f e s d n l h r r h t s e ry r o o t so r yoa 22 Fe .R.Ci . 72() Loca Rul I 3- ()i t eeq iae tl c lr l. nde Rul 72() ta) d v P. a . l e B 1a s h u v ln o a ue s r e a, g u 23 tndi gi Gcea l erone us' n, lhought e ei e i enc t s ppo tt t er viw i gc ur on l n s l ry r o 'whe at h r s v d e o u r i,h e e n o t 2 t ee tr e i e c i l f wiht ede i iea dtnn c nvi tont a amit kehasbe n c m m it d.' 4 h n ie v d n e s el t h fn t n i o ci h t sa eo te '' 25 Page 3 of 5 1 Ra a ov Pac o u - ef r s h Dit, . 6 CV- 3 7IFBIARLI20 9W L 7 9 4 , t* 2 f n . th g eM d o d c . s.No 0 - 5 6 J I ,0 840a 1 2 ( . . . .M a.20, E D N Y r 2009)( uotngBur i v Eu oBr kes I c,No.05 Ci.0968( PS)KAM ) qi g e . r o r, n . v C( , 3 2 08U. . s. 0 S DitLEXI 71 8 , t*1 ( . . . . e t 5 2 08 ( u tn Co c eePiet Pr d .f S 3 6 a 8 E D N Y S p . , 0 ) q oig n r t p o o s o 4 CJ/, nc v Consr Labor r Pe son Tr sforS.Cal, U. .602,622( 993)) t o d ri .I . . t. es n i u t .508 S 1 ). t . r e s zn 5 conta y t 1 w whe i f ist a pl t m i a ple r l va t t t t s ca e 1 w trr l sof o e ur . rr o a n t a l o p y ) s p i s e e n s a u e , s a ) u e pr c d e ' r ' 6 l. d 7 11 1. 8 A N A L Y SI S Att e M ay 6,201 he r ng,a whi h Pl i tf a pe r d t l pho i a l , he M J s a e t a h 0 a i t c a n if p a e e e n c ly t ttd h t 9 ' hos t o m otons a e ba i a l ,l t i k,s oul be cons de e a m o i ns f r r c ns de a i n T ew t i r s c ly h n h d i r d s t o o e o i r to 1 be a s lvear a yr ldontos is e . ( e M otHrg 1 :5-06a. .Ma 6, 0, No. 0 c u e ' le d u e h e su s' S e . ' 00 ' m , y 201 ECF 11 1 1 . Couns lf rDefnda t a g ed t a t e e pe s sa d s c rt conc r si ta s ori g 9) eo e n s r u h t h x n e n e u iy e n n rn p tn 1 Pl i tf f ra i de e d nte a out i e oft e pr s n pa tc l ry f rt i Pl i tf ,who i one 2 a n if o n n p n e x m sd h i o - r i u a l o h s a n if s l of t e hi her s c rt t r a s a t e prs n, a d w he e a n w a not ne es ar f r hi w e l 3 hg e u y h e t t h i o n n xl s c s y o s l- 1 b ig -c u dn tb j si e .Se i.1 :8 0 am ..Th M Jd ne temoinsb c u eheh d 4 en - o l o e u tt d ( e d 00 - 9 . ) e i e id h to e a s a l pr vi usy r ld t a Pl i tf coul be s en by hi own doc o att eprs n bu t a hewoul no 5 e o l u e h t an if d e s t r h io t h t dt 1 or erta s ora i n outi e oft e prs n a d woul notor e a me iale pe ta t e c ur' 6 d r n p tto sd h io n d dr d c x r t h o ts 1 e pe s .Se i.1 11a. .. 7 x n e ( e d 0: m ) 1 8 Pl i tf a guest a hehasnotbe n a l t f n adoc o w ho w ile am i ehi a t epr s n, a n if r ht e be o id tr l x n m th io l s her que t t att eCo r or e hebeta s ore outi eoft eprs n f re a i aton.But he 9 o e ss h h ut dr r n p td sd h io o x m n i t 20 M J ga e Pl i tf s c a opporuniy w h n he or e ed hi ta s ored f r hi M R I Pl i tf v a n if u h n tt e dr m rn p t o s . a n if 21 a pa e tydi nott kea va t geoft i opporuniyandnow r que t t la et eprs na s c nd p rn l d a d na hs tt e s s o e v h io e o 22 tm e f ra e a i a i n t a i notm e i a l ne e s ' . On Fe r a r 201 ,t e M J o de e : i o n x m n to h t s d c ly c s m y b u n 8, 0 h r rd 23 t a t e M oton f rOuti e M e ialExa i GRANTED t t e e t ntt a,whe h th io sd de ms o h xe h t n Pl i tf i tans er e f r hi M R I he s al be alow e t r m a n i t e ar a f r a a n if s r f r d o s , hl l doe nh e o 24 25 pei d oft it ( 0 days i or e t o ti a i d pe den e amiain a ro h ry 3 ) n d r o b an n n e n t x n to t Pa e 4 of 5 g L 1 Pl i tf ' e pe s .Thedoc orwho pe f nn ss i e a i a i n s al s bm i ar por a n if s x n e t ro a d x m n to h l u t e t 2 3 ofhi fndi gst Mr Pedomowihi t n(0)dayso t ee a .M rPedomos al si n o . r tne 1 fh x m .r hl t e ha eape idoft e t (0)dayst de os t edocor a whihPlitf ma hn v ro w ny 2 o p eh t , t c an if y atndtlphonial.Thi s albet ee tnto an furhe dic v r i ti c s . te ee c ly s h l h xe f y t r s o ey n hs a e ( a . . de 2,Fe .8 201 ,ECFNo.1 (i ale pha i ad edl.Therquie Mllo c re . M g J Or r b , 0 62 tn m ss d ) e rd t c u rd 4 (eeHrg9:3 a. .M a.3,201 ,ECFNo.1 ( ic sigt er s lsoft eM RI) Nof rhe S ' 0 m, r 0 66 d su sn h e u t h ). ut r 5 di cover was per it dsand t er i no i di aton t e M J ever grant d per i si n t l ave t e s y m te h es n ci h e mso o e h 6 p i on a a n f ran i de e de te a i addii n t t e t i t - ay w i dow pr vi ed t e fr ttm e. rs g i o n pn n xm n to o h h ry d n o d h is i 7 The M Jt e e or pr pe l c a ac e i e t epr s n m otonsa m o i nsf rr c ns der ton a d di h r f e o ry h r t r z d h e e t i s to o e o i a i n d 8 notm a e cl a e r r i de yi g t em . k e r ro s n n n h 9 C O N C L U SIO N 1 0 I I HEREBY OR D E R ED t a t e M oto f r Revi w ofM a i t a e J dge sO r e TS h th in o e g sr t u ' d r 11 ( CFNo.1 3)i DENI D, E 9s E 1 2 I I FURTHER OR D ER E D t att e M oton f rReconsi er ton ofM oton f rCourt TS hh io d ai io 13 Or ee M edialExper byDititJ dge( CFNo.1 9)i DENI D. d rd c t src u E 9s E 1 4 15 D A TED :'hi ; rs ' wza ospe br2010. f dy t etm e , 1 6 17 18 . 1 9 20 2l R O B ER T C.J S U nie St t s i rc J dge td ae it u 22 23 24 25 Page 5 of 5

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?