Egberto v. Nevada Department Of Corrections

Filing 215

ORDER DENYING # 193 Request for Review of Magistrate Judge's Order. FURTHER ORD DENYING # 199 Motion for Reconsideration. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 9/14/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

.

L 6 '

1
2

!..> .l2L1g2 11 . $ ' ---- 'L I ) . . .- - - l ?. . ,, 2'
j

f- -

f-- - - . -- - - . r. . , ' , j- y ;. èss . ...):..'.y. j... , $ m..,t.',q:- .. . : .,..).af.k'.. . , k.' q7 .g ,, :;'s ; ..a..t,..,'syk k ,..r.,..,ar . . , .
.

' ';

3
4 5 .
. t

;
r .

.

(// . jgj j -(J , j 1 4'. )
. .. .

/

.
.

!
. .-

.

Y' ' $

' ': '
.
.. . .

-

/' , '' dr >
. .

.. .

)t j w

,

6
2 6

UNI ED STATESDI TRI T COURT '' -= =L='-Y ' . T S0 - - = -' XW Y S W T O V W V A D A '' '' W

RI KW EGRVRTO, O
9 1 0

11 1 2 l 3
1 4

) ) Pl i tf, an if ) ) vs . ) ) NEVADA DEPARTM ENT OF CORRECTI NS ) O e a. t 1, ) ) Dee da t. fn ns ) )

3: 6- v- 071S R CJ RA M 0c0 --

ORDER

1 5

Thi c s a i e o t of Det ndan s alege delbe a e i dif r nce t Pl i tf ' m e i al s a e rs s u e t ' l d i r t n fe e o a n if s d c

1 ne ds i pr s n,i vi l ton of t e Ei ht a d Four e nt Am e dm e t . Pl i tf a s a l ges 6 e n io n o a i h gh n te h n ns a n if l o le

1 neglgenc unde saelw.Hedema dsmoneayda age andij nctverle.Pe di gbefr 7 i e r tt a n tr m s nu i eif n n o e
Egberto v. Nevada Department Of Corrections Doc. 215

l t e Cour a e t o m o i nsf rr viw ofa or e oft e M agita eJ dg . Fort er a o sgi e 8h tr w to b e e n dr h sr t u e h e sn v n 1 he ei ,t e Co r de ist em otons 9 rn h u t ne h i.
20 1 . 21 FAC T S A N D PR O C E D U R A L H I T O R Y S Pl i tf Ri k y Egbe t i i c r e a e w ihi t e N eva a De arm ent of Cor ec i ns a n if c e ro s n a c r t d t n h d pt r to

22 (t DOC' .Fis Am. ç N ' ( rt Compl!1 ECFNo. .Plitf, ale e hehast ohenitddics ) , 7, 33) an ifwho lg s w r ae s

23 i hi s i e hasbe n gi e mediain f rt epan,butha bee de id s r e'.(d) Plitf n s pn , e vn c to o h i s n n e u g l 1 .. an if y 24 ale est a t ei fr ay a E1 Stt Prs n (ç SP' ,wheehei c renty ic r eae ,hasa lg h t h n im r t y ae io i ' E)r s u r l n ac rtd
25 c som andpr c ieoff ii g t pr perydi gnos , r a , d m e ia ei m a e ,a dhea gu st a ut a tc aln o o l a e te t an dc t n ts n r e ht

Dockets.Justia.com

1 ti c nsiutsd lbeaeidifrnce (#..Plitf aloalge ta t one - a i ngmembes h s o tt e ei rt n fee .f ) an if s le s h tw o N z ga r,
2 a a ns whom het s ii d, r i c r e a e a ESP, ount rt Pl i t f s S nde s a di g' t a t e gi t e tfe a e n a c r t d t c e o a n ip t r t n n ' h t h y u

3 woul beic r eae ele hee.(d.. Healgest a heha r c ie de t t rat fom t e e d n ac rtd s w r 1 ) le h t s e ev d ah h e s r h s
4 i m a e ,a d hear ue t a t ef iur t hous t e e s w he e c nsiut sdelber t i dif r nc n ts n g s h t h al e o e h m le r o tt e i ae n fe e e

5 byNDOC.(d) I.
6 OnDe embe 22, c r 2006, aitf s edNDOC i t i Cou t trec us so a ton: 1-( ) Pl nif u n h s r on h e a e f ci () 2
7 s bsa tve due pr c s and eq a pr tc i n vi ltons unde t e FouMe nt Am e dm e tand u tn i o es u l o e to o a i rh eh nn

8 d lbeat idifr nc vi ltonsunde t eEiht a dFouree t Ame dm e t,vi 42U. . .â ei r e n fe e e o ai rh g h n t nh n ns a SC 9 1 834a d( )saelw ne lg nc .Plitf a ende t ecomplito J l 1 20 7t addt e 9 n 3 tt a gie e anif m dh an n uy 7, 0 o h
1 f low i g D ef nda t :G l n W horon,H o ar Skol i ,Te D ' m i o,M . . Robe tBa ni t r 0 ol n e ns e t wd nk d A c D, r n se ,

1 M . . E. .M c a i l,Ada Ende ,FrtsSc l tm a ,a d W ila Dona . TheFis Am e de 1 D, K D nes m l it h o t n n lim t rt nd
1 Com pl i t a ds no ne ca s s of a ton but c ns lda es t e tr t t o ca s s of a ton of t e 2 an d w ue ci o o i t h is w ue ci h 1 Com pl i ti t a sngl c us ofa ton. 3 an no i e a e ci

1 4

On Nove be 3,2009,t e Cour a optd te M a itae J dge' (ç J' Re or a d mr h td e h g srt u s : ' p t n M)

15 Re ommendain( & R, No. )g a tngPlitf sM otonf rPr lm iar Ij ncin( CF c to R ECF 55 r ni anip i o ei n y n u to E
1 No. )i pa t Defnda t weeodee t f lo Dr Long' rc mmende c ureofte t ent 6 35 n re n s r r rd o olw . s eo d o s ram
l or t s nd Pl i tf f r a ot e e a ua i n by a e ui a en doc or a d f low t a doc or s 7 oe a n i f o n h r v l to n q vl t t n ol h t t ' 1 r c m m e de c ur e oft e t e t butDef nda t w e enotr q ie t ta s e Pl i t f t a ot er 8 eo n do s r am n , e ns r e u r d o r n f r a n if o n h

1 fciiy.( r e 2 3,No .2,2009,ECF No.1 4) OnM ach3,201 ,teM Jhel atlphoni 9 a lt O d r v 2. r 0h d ee c 20 he rng a d de id te f lowig motons M otont Enf r eOr e ( CF No.1 8) M oin t ai n n e h ol n i : i o oc d r E 2 ; to o 21 Pr cudeDe ut AG fo Blc ig, ndei g, Itre ig( CFNo.l ) M otonfrOr e t el py r m o kn Hi rn or n efrn E 33 . i o d r o ,
22 Show Ca s ( CFNo.1 5 ; Motonf rSa cins( CFNo.1 6) Afe rviwigame ial ue E 4 ) and i o n to E 4 . tr e e n dc

23 r po tta c nclde not igwaswr ngwihPlitf ss iebas dona M RIs a ,( rgM a . e r h t o u d hn o t anip pn e n cn H ' r
24 3, 0, t9:3a. .,e or sidiaigt a Plitf ha rf sdmediaina varoustmes (d. 201 a 0 m ) rc d n c tn h t anif d eu e c to t i i ,i
25 Pag 2 of 5 e

1 a 9:4a. ., rporbyDrKol ( honei)idiaigt a Dr. t 0 m )a e t . m p tc n c tn h t s Kohna dLongweei agee en n rn rm t
2 t a Pl i tf wasm a i ge i g i or e t ac uie a ce st na c tcsa d an unne d d c ne pos i l h t a n if ln r n n d r o q r c s o r o i n e e a , sb y

3 f rus asawe pon,(d.a 9: 5a. .,a d e ie c t a ma y pe pl h d s e Plitf wak oe a i t 0 m ) n vd n e h t n o e a e n an if l
4 w ihou a y lm p o ot e difculy a d t a heonl w a ke w ih alm p whe be ng s e b m e i a t tn i r h r fi t n h t y ld t i n i en y dcl

5 pes nne,i a 9:6-07a. .,heM Jf undt a Dee danswer i c m pla c wiht i Cour' ro l(d t 0 m )t o h t fn t e n o in e t h s ts
6 Nove be 2, m r 2009 or e ,a d het er f r de i d Pl i tf smotonsn s 1 8,1 5,a d 1 6, s e dr n h e o e n e an ip i o . 2 4 n 4 (e

7 i.a 9:9-1 a. .M iut Or e,Ma .3,201 ,ECF No.16 ) Healo de idmotonno.1 3. d t 0 0 m ; n e dr r 0 6. s ne i 3 8 Plitf fld aNotc ofAppe l( CF No.1 0)a d aM oi n f rRec nsdeain of an if ie ie aE 7n to o o i rto

9 M a itaeJ dge' Or e ( CFNo.1 2)whihti Cour de id.Se Or e,Aug. 201 , g sr t u s d r E 7 , c h s t ne ( e d r 24, 0 ECF
1 No.21 .Plitf alotldaMotonf rCo r Or ee Trns orain t l de ende tM edial 0 0) an if s ie i o u t d rd a p tto o n p n c

11 Exam ( CFNO.1 a daM oinf rCourOr ee M e ia Expe tECFNo. 79 , hofwhih E 76) n to o t drd dcl r( 1 )bot c
1 t eMJteaedasmoinst rc nsde a dde id.seeM a . Or e,Ma 6, 0, No.1 1 . 2h rt to o e o i r n n e (' g J. d r y 201 ECF 9)
1 Pl i tf ha now tl d t o m or m o i nsas i g t i Cou t o r vi w t e M a 6, 1 o dero t e 3 a n if s ie w e to kn h s rt e e h y 20 0 r fh
1 4 M J denyi g t os m otons. nhe i LEG A L STAN D A R D S

15 II .

1 6

Ru e7 ()pemisad src c u tud et mo iy o s ta ieama itaej d e sn n l 2 a r t itit o r j g o df r e sd gsrt u g ' o -

1 di pos tve r lng t a i c ea l e r ne usorc nt m' t l w : 7 s ii u i h t s l ry r o o o ryoa 1 8 1 9 20 21 W he apr t i l a t rnotdipos tveofapa t ' cl i ordef ns i r f r ed n e ra m te s ii ry s a m e e s ee r

t ama itae u g t h a a dd cd ,hema itae ud emu t r m pl c n u t o gsrt j d e o e r n e ie t gsrt j g s p o ty o d c
t e r qui e pr ce di gs an ,w hen a pr pra e,i s e a w rte or e s a i g t e h e rd o e n d p o it s u it n d r t tn h

decson. A pa t mays r ea d tl obe tonst teor erwihi 1 da safe ii ry e v n 'e j ci o h d t n 4 y tr i
be ng s r e w ih a c py. A pa t m a n tas i n a e r ra de e ti t e or e not i evd t o ry y o s g s r o fc n h d r

tmeyo j ce t ,Th dititu g i tec s mu t o sd ri eyo j cin a d i l b e td o e src j d e n h a e s c n ie tm l b e to s n
m odi yors ta i e a y pa'oft e o de t a i cl a l e r ne usori c ntar t l w . f e s d n l h r r h t s e ry r o o t so r yoa

22 Fe .R.Ci . 72() Loca Rul I 3- ()i t eeq iae tl c lr l. ç nde Rul 72() ta) d v P. a . l e B 1a s h u v ln o a ue s r e a, g u
23 tndi gi Gcea l erone us' n, lhought e ei e i enc t s ppo tt t er viw i gc ur on l n s çl ry r o 'whe at h r s v d e o u r i,h e e n o t 2 t ee tr e i e c i l f wiht ede i iea dtnn c nvi tont a amit kehasbe n c m m it d.' 4 h n ie v d n e s el t h fn t n i o ci h t sa eo te ''
25 Page 3 of 5

1 Ra a ov Pac o u - ef r s h Dit, . 6 CV- 3 7IFBIARLI20 9W L 7 9 4 , t* 2 f n . th g eM d o d c . s.No 0 - 5 6 J I ,0 840a 1
2 ( . . . .M a.20, E D N Y r 2009)( uotngBur i v Eu oBr kes I c,No.05 Ci.0968( PS)KAM ) qi g e . r o r, n . v C( ,

3 2 08U. . s. 0 S DitLEXI 71 8 , t*1 ( . . . . e t 5 2 08 ( u tn Co c eePiet Pr d .f S 3 6 a 8 E D N Y S p . , 0 ) q oig n r t p o o s o
4 CJ/, nc v Consr Labor r Pe son Tr sforS.Cal, U. .602,622( 993)) çt o d ri .I . . t. es n i u t .508 S 1 ). t . r e s zn
5 conta y t 1 w whe i f ist a pl t m i a ple r l va t t t t s ca e 1 w trr l sof o e ur . rr o a n t a l o p y ) s p i s e e n s a u e , s a ) u e pr c d e ' r '
6 l. d

7 11 1. 8

A N A L Y SI S Att e M ay 6,201 he r ng,a whi h Pl i tf a pe r d t l pho i a l , he M J s a e t a h 0 a i t c a n if p a e e e n c ly t ttd h t

9 ' hos t o m otons a e ba i a l ,l t i k,s oul be cons de e a m o i ns f r r c ns de a i n T ew t i r s c ly h n h d i r d s t o o e o i r to

1 be a s lvear a yr ldontos is e . ( e M otHrg 1 :5-06a. .Ma 6, 0, No. 0 c u e ' le d u e h e su s' S e . ' 00 ' m , y 201 ECF 11 1 1 . Couns lf rDefnda t a g ed t a t e e pe s sa d s c rt conc r si ta s ori g 9) eo e n s r u h t h x n e n e u iy e n n rn p tn
1 Pl i tf f ra i de e d nte a out i e oft e pr s n pa tc l ry f rt i Pl i tf ,who i one 2 a n if o n n p n e x m sd h i o - r i u a l o h s a n if s l of t e hi her s c rt t r a s a t e prs n, a d w he e a n w a not ne es ar f r hi w e l 3 hg e u ïy h e t t h i o n n xl s c s y o s l-

1 b ig -c u dn tb j si e .Se i.1 :8 0 am ..Th M Jd ne temoinsb c u eheh d 4 en - o l o e u tt d ( e d 00 - 9 . ) e i e id h to e a s a
l pr vi usy r ld t a Pl i tf coul be s en by hi own doc o att eprs n bu t a hewoul no 5 e o l u e h t an if d e s t r h io t h t dt 1 or erta s ora i n outi e oft e prs n a d woul notor e a me iale pe ta t e c ur' 6 d r n p tto sd h io n d dr d c x r t h o ts

1 e pe s .Se i.1 11a. .. 7 x n e ( e d 0: m )
1 8 Pl i tf a guest a hehasnotbe n a l t f n adoc o w ho w ile am i ehi a t epr s n, a n if r ht e be o id tr l x n m th io

l s her que t t att eCo r or e hebeta s ore outi eoft eprs n f re a i aton.But he 9 o e ss h h ut dr r n p td sd h io o x m n i t
20 M J ga e Pl i tf s c a opporuniy w h n he or e ed hi ta s ored f r hi M R I Pl i tf v a n if u h n tt e dr m rn p t o s . a n if

21 a pa e tydi nott kea va t geoft i opporuniyandnow r que t t la et eprs na s c nd p rn l d a d na hs tt e s s o e v h io e o
22 tm e f ra e a i a i n t a i notm e i a l ne e s ' . On Fe r a r 201 ,t e M J o de e : i o n x m n to h t s d c ly c s m y b u n 8, 0 h r rd

23

t a t e M oton f rOuti e M e ialExa i GRANTED t t e e t ntt a,whe h th io sd de ms o h xe h t n Pl i tf i tans er e f r hi M R I he s al be alow e t r m a n i t e ar a f r a a n if s r f r d o s , hl l doe ï nh e o

24
25

pei d oft it ( 0 days i or e t o ti a i d pe den e amiain a ro h ry 3 ) n d r o b an n n e n t x n to t
Pa e 4 of 5 g

L
1 Pl i tf ' e pe s .Thedoc orwho pe f nn ss i e a i a i n s al s bm i ar por a n if s x n e t ro a d x m n to h l u t e t

2
3

ofhi fndi gst Mr Pedomowihi t n(0)dayso t ee a .M rPedomos al si n o . r tne 1 fh x m .r hl t e ha eape idoft e t (0)dayst de os t edocor a whihPlitf ma hn v ro w ny 2 o p eh t , t c an if y atndtlphonial.Thi s albet ee tnto an furhe dic v r i ti c s . te ee c ly s h l h xe f y t r s o ey n hs a e

( a . . de 2,Fe .8 201 ,ECFNo.1 (i ale pha i ad edl.Therquie Mllo c re . M g J Or r b , 0 62 tn m ss d ) e rd t c u rd
4

(eeHrg9:3 a. .M a.3,201 ,ECFNo.1 ( ic sigt er s lsoft eM RI) Nof rhe S ' 0 m, r 0 66 d su sn h e u t h ). ut r
5 di cover was per it dsand t er i no i di aton t e M J ever grant d per i si n t l ave t e s y m te h es n ci h e mso o e h
6

p i on a a n f ran i de e de te a i addii n t t e t i t - ay w i dow pr vi ed t e fr ttm e. rs g i o n pn n xm n to o h h ry d n o d h is i
7

The M Jt e e or pr pe l c a ac e i e t epr s n m otonsa m o i nsf rr c ns der ton a d di h r f e o ry h r t r z d h e e t i s to o e o i a i n d
8

notm a e cl a e r r i de yi g t em . k e r ro s n n n h
9 C O N C L U SIO N 1 0

I I HEREBY OR D E R ED t a t e M oto f r Revi w ofM a i t a e J dge sO r e TS h th in o e g sr t u ' d r
11

( CFNo.1 3)i DENI D, E 9s E
1 2

I I FURTHER OR D ER E D t att e M oton f rReconsi er ton ofM oton f rCourt TS hh io d ai io 13

Or ee M edialExper byDititJ dge( CFNo.1 9)i DENI D. d rd c t src u E 9s E

1 4
15

D A TED :'hi ; rs

' wza ospe br2010. f dy t etm e ,

1 6
17 18
.

1 9
20 2l

R O B ER T C.J S U nie St t s i rc J dge td ae it u

22 23
24 25 Page 5 of 5