Bynoe v. Helling et al

Filing 41

ORDER denying 30 Motion to Stay; denying 38 Motion to file supplemental authority; petition dismissed w/o prej; clerk to entr jdgmt. Case terminated. Signed by Judge Larry R. Hicks on 09/22/09. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - LG)

.

r-----

1
2

1 :
.
.

. ---- $

. -ri -. y) ' y -'- 11Ll0 ' ' )ftl -i
.,

.

-.

r?'E!), 'g( a !;1 . ''Cr-.(I ' F'# f ,q . r- J t:) tF 2) .
2 - Y-' - ' ' - - ' 5'l -l

. ''

''

-. - .;:. . i. . ql è.''L, '. )t ' ,'$'j, !
.

: #
z è 5
6
7

? l t sg2..: j t .i ' ( :2. , . j - .):.2 : .. . .., y r. . ' .. ':''-. . .l j. )
. ,
..

.

.

''

1 i l. u l !

t . zic-zv u ' - --'i z l - u:

g 7-b.., ..,?.: f ;:- -. ; .-...t ,,t . . .k . Ca h '' ' . .z .w . u-z;.5C. .i...'' = 2 - u i = ''' .
.

.

..

.

.

.

. .

.. -

.

' U N I E D STA T E S D IST R I T C O U R T T C

8
9 10

DI TR I T O F N EV AD A S C

1 M I HAELBRUCE BYNOE, 1 C 1 2 Peiine, tto r 1 v. 3s
1 HELLI G , 4 N

15
16

Reponde t s n.

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
/

3:07-v- 009- RH- PC c0 L V ORDER

1 7

Peii ne i pr c ed ng wih co ns li t i peii n f rwrtofha ea c r us tto r s o e i t u e n h s tto o i b s op

1 purua tt 28U. . .j225 .Thi c s pr ce dsontefrta ende peiintldApzl28,20 8. 8 sno SC 4 s ae o e h is m d tto ie i 0 19 ( oc e /17. OnM a 1 ,2009,hee ur e trda or e tndi gt a i wasundiputdt a t e D k t/ ) y3 t o t n ee n d r i n h t t s e h th
20 cam si t efrta e de peii nweeune ha se .( oc e #29. l t a or e,hi c ur as li n h is m n d tto r x u td D k t ) n h t d r t s o t lo
21 he d i pa ta f lo s: l n r s olw 22 A s a ge e a m a t r a e a m i t c ni a l e haus e i t e c ur t w hi h t e n r l t e , l i s e h c ly x td f h o to ch

23

pe ii ne wo l ber quie t pr s n t eca m woul tnd t eyli pr c dur ly tto r u d e r d o e e t h l i d i h am o e a l ba r d.Se ,eg: Ca setv.St war, F.d 61 , & n. ( oeCi. re e ., s t e t 406 3 4 621 5 9 ' r 2005) Thi .s
doe notm e np s a howe e ,ha a lc ofe ha si n i K xc s d'by a s ow i g ofc us v rt t ak x u to s t u e ' e hn ae
i s e d a ebe ng a pled - tr t a r l t a a pr ce ur ly ba r d c a m s i t c ni a l n ta r i p i i s , u e h t o d a l r e l i s e h c ly e ha se ,a d s c nd, r l t a apr c dur lde au tm a beove co eby a x u td n e o a ue h t o e a f l y rm

2 4
25

a dp eudc t a i o fr dt o e c m eap o e u a d f ut Twodsi c r l s n rj ie h t s fe e o v r o r c d rl e a l. itn t ue
s owigofc us a dprj dîe.g oot oeone. hn a e n eu c F n t j

26

Thi f nda e t lditnci n i sr ii a tbe a s t eNe a asa eco rs s u m n a si to s i tc p c u e h v d tt u t

a pl s bs a ta l t e s m e s a da dsf r a oi l g a pr ce tr ldef ul a do t e p y u t n i ly h a tn r o v d n o d la a ts h

1 2 3

f de a e ur s Thi Cou tac o di gl ,i num e ousprorc s s hasdec i e t hol e r l o t. s r cr n y n r i a e, ln d o d c a m sex a s e on t e pr m i e t a t e s a e c urs w o l note ns de t e c a m s li h u td h e s h t h tt o t u d o i r h li a s nta u e ui oca s i ul to by pe ii ne t att e c a m s i f c w oul be de i d b e n n q v l tp a i n tto r h h l i n a t d ne o pr c dur lgr unds i he r t r e t s a e c ur t pr s ntt e c a m s Suc a n oe a o f eun d o tt o to e e h li , h n une ui o a s i u a i n, o i t ut be une ui oc li lghtoft t a plc ton oft e q v c l tp l to t n r h q v a ni h p iai h pr cedur ldef ul rul sunde cur entN evada s at postconvi ton procedur ,m ust o a at e rr te ci e

4

5
6

i cudesiulto sta:( )peiine c nnota oi dim is loft ecam si sae n l tp ain h t 1 tto r a v d s s a h li n tt c ursbe a s heca notde o sr t c us a dprj diei t esaec urst o t cu e n m n tae a e n eu c n h tt o t o ove c m etepr c durlbas goonot t ol( )peii ne c nno a oi dimis lof r o h o e a r; f t e w 2 tto r a t v d s sa

t e cl i si t e st t court because he cannotdem ons r t i t e s at court t att e h am n h a e s ta e n h t e sh h aleg d c ns iutonalvi l ton pr ba l r s led i t e c nvi ton ofo e wbo i l e o tt i o ai o b y e u t n h o ci n s

7
8 9

ac-al inoc nta dca notte e yo eromet epr ce urlbas (ootot tr eq t ly n e n n h rb v c u h o d a r;f n e h e a d( )t epr c du a basote wiear now c nsse tya ple byteNe a a n 3 h o e rl r h r s e o itn l p id h v d
sa ec urs s c t a i i notpos i l t a t esae c urs asa dic e i na y ma tr t t o t, u h h t t s sb e h t h t t o t, s r to r te , woul c ns de t e c a m s de pie t e pr ce ur ldef u ta d de pie a f iur t d o i r h li sth o d a al n s t al e o

de onsrt ete ca s a dprj dieoracua inoc nce l t ea snc ofs c a m tae ih r u e n eu c t ln e . n h b e e u h n
une ui oc lsi u a i n, heC ou lw ilnothol t a t e e i no pos i iiy t a t e q v a tp l to t ll d h th r s sb lt h t h

1 0
11
l2

une ha se c am swo l beco sde e by t e sa ec ursi Ne a a.( oot ot x u td li ud n i rd h tt o t n v d F n e

furjAnyholi gofe ha sinont i ba i frhe wilbes b e tt aposï l o. dn x u to hs ss u t r l u j c o sb e

ds isTo tecamso EhebaiRED oadheldia n,aso tndediw j be im sa I h li R tO RD E o prhetr peei l.Faon t fv 11 lf n ss f tctua tfutE m eoe ,el I S THEREFO to
dim is dwi o t rj dc u ls, ti t it ( 0 d yso e tyofhi o d r s s e t u p eu ie ne s wihn h ry 3 ) a f n r t s r e , h
da soft e tlng by co ns l y h ii u e.
pettonerfl s an unequi ocalstpul ton as des ri ed on pages2 t 3 oft i orderor ii ie v i ai cb o hs s e sot e a pr p i t r le c ns s e tw ih t e hol i g t e e n. Pe ii ne s a ltl e k h r p o ra e ei f o it n t h dn h ri tto r h l i e

1 3
14

adecaaint a heauho ie t esiultonma eorrle s ughtwihi tn( 0 lrto h t t rz s h tp ai d eif o t n e 1) ( oc e #29,p.- . D kt 2 3)
Foot ot o e: t e e t ntt a pe ii ne r le o non- i di g c s a t ort t a n e n To h x e h t tto r e i s n b n n a e u h iy h t woul s gg s t a t e e ha s i n r qu r m e ti is l e c s d by c r um s a c st a d u e t h t h x u to e i e n s t e f x u e ic tn e h t

15

16

1 7
18

woul s ow ca s a dp eudie,nde ende tofapr ce ur ldea la ayss te dh u e n rj c i p n o d a fu t n l i,h
notaddr s exhauston and proceduraldef ul asr l t d by di tnctconcept . es i a t eae si s

Cour i no pe s a e .TheCour i pa i ulri notpe s ade by a t o iy fo ts t ru d d tn d c a s ru d u h rt r m a ot e cr ui t a i m er t a f urde a e (l t t eextntt a t e a t ort, s n h r ic t h t s e h n b c d s )d o h e h t h u h i) doe

1 9

pe ii ne c n ove co e t e ba t a untm e y ors c e s ve pe ii n by s ow i g tto r a r m h ro n i l u c si tto hn

Foonot t o: Se ,e..M ichelv.Stt,l 9P.3.33,36( e .2006)(t t ew e g, t l a e 4 2 Nv t A

20

21
22
23 24
25

g odc us a dprj die.';s ealoRobis nv I naco,36 F.d 1 44,1 52n. o a e n eu c 'l e s n o .g i O 3 0 0 3 ( tCi.2004)(e ognzngt a Ne a asc us a dprj diea ayssa dt ef de a 9l r ' r c ii h t v d ' a e n eu c n l i n h e r l c us a dp eu iea ay i aen al ie tc l. a e n rj d c n lss r e ry d n ia)
Foonot t re:Se ,c.:M ichel 1 9P.da 36(t ve whe apeiine c nno t e h e e g, t l, 4 3 t t n n tto r a t E
s ow g od c us s fi l ntt ove c m e t e ba st a untm e y ors c es i e h o a e u tc e o r o h ron i l u c sv pe ii n,ha e sr le m a s ilbe p a t d i t e pe ii ne c n de onsr t t a t tto b a e i f y tl n e f h tto r a m t a e h t a c nsiutona vi lton ha pr ba l r s led i t e c nvi ton ofonewho i acua l o tt i l o a i s o b y e u t n h o ci s t ly i noc nt' c tng Aff rz v Car i r 477 U , . n e , ii r r f . r e , ' ty S 478, 496,1 6 S. t 2639,91 L. d. d 0 C. E2

26

397( 986). 1) Foot oei ur Ac or Jone v. c anil2009W L 890 1 ( tCi. . 2009)(n nt b : c d s M D e, 9 5 9h r Apr 2, i
a unpu ls e diposton, di g t a t epe ii ne had no esa ls e f tlt of n b ih d s ii hol n h t h tto r t tb ih d u iiy e ha s i n, vc t e s bs a ta s m ia iy ofN e a a s a e a d f de a s a da ds t x u to gi n h u t n i l i l r t v d t t n e r l tn r o
2

l

ove c m eapr ce ur lba ) ro o d a r.

2
3
4

Fo t ot fve: Cour rj cspeiine' paallagu e ta t t ea s nc of o n e i The t ee t tto rs r le r m n s o h b e e

a a l bl s a e r m e i sf rt e r a onsi t e t x . Pe ii ne ' r que tf ran v ia e t t e d e o b e s n h e t tt o r s e s o evi e ta ybe rngt de onsr t abassf re c sngt e e ha si n r quie e ti d n i r a i o m ta e i o x u i h x u to e r m n s de i d.Ther q e tf ra e i e ta yhea i g t te c s ' al c ofe ha si n ne e u s o n v d n ir rn o tx u e' a k x u to s m ia l ove l o st e di tnc i n be w e n e ha s i n a d pr c d r ldef ul. i l r y r o k h si to t e x u to n o e u a at

Peiine ca ma ehi c us a dprj dieagu e t t t esaec u t i a ef r tto r n k s a e n eu c r m n s o h tt o rs n n fol
5
6

t ove c m et epot nta pr c d r lba s o ro h e il o e u a r .

7

Peii ne d d no tl t e si ulton de c i e i t ec ur' or e q ot d a ove. tto r i t ie h tp a i s rb d n h o ts d r u e b

8 Rat e ,on J ne l 200 ,pe ii ne fl d a m o i n f rs a a d a e a c o t i c s unde Rhi e v hr u 5, 9 tto r ie to o t y n b y n e f h s a e r ns .

9 We e , U.. 1 5S. t 1 28,15 5(005) Res o de t oppos t emoin. b r 544 S 269, 2 C . 5 3 2 . p n ns e h to
1 0 U nde Rhi e v W e e di ti tc ur shave t e di c e i n t hol a m i e pe ii n i r n s . b r src o t h s r to o d x d tto n

11 a e a c pe di g exha si n oft eune ha se ca m s û Rhî c sa i onl a a lbl f ra byn e n n u to h x u t d li . 1 A n s t y s y v ia e o
1 m i e ha ea pe ii n w he e a l as s m e c a m sha e be n e ha s ed. Jone v M c ani l 320 2 x d b s tto r te t o li v e x ut ' ' s . D e,

1 Fe .t px.78 ,786( 'Ci.2009) Addiinal,u de Kel v Smal,31 F.d 1 ( tCi. 3 dyp 4 9b r . to ly n r lv . l 5 3 063 9b r
1 2003)d src c ursha et edi c ei n t sa af lyex a se peii n. SeeKi g v.Ryan,56 4 itit o t v h s r to o t y u l h u td tto n 4

1 F.d 1l 9t Ci. 5 3 33( h r 2009)(oligt a t et re-tpsa -nd-be anc pr c du eesa ls e i h dn h t h h e se ty a a y e o e r tb ih d n 1 Kel rm ansvibl afe Rhi c ) Howev r i i wele tbls ed1w i t i cruit a apeiin 6 l e i a e tr n s . y e, ts l sa ih a n h s ic t b t tto 1 c ntii go l une ha se camsmus bedim is d. Ji i c v Rie 276F.d478, ( t 7 o an n n y x u td li t s se m nz . c, 3 481 9h 1 Ci.00l,cc fde id,538U. . ( 003) Rasb ryv.Gari ,448F.d 11 ( tCi. 8 r2 ) r. n e S 949 2 * e r ' ca , 3 50 9h r 2006) .
1 Thus t a l w ape ii ne t m a nt i a a to c nt i i g onl une ha s e c a m sw oul be 9 , o lo tto r o i a n n c i n o a n n y x u td li d

20 die tyc ntayt c ntoliga t o iy.Se alo,28U. . .j225 ()1 * ev. l4v,4551. . r cl o rr o o r ln u h rt e s SC ï 4 1 ( ) Ros Ltn 7, 75
21 509,522,l 2 S. t 1l 8( 982)(doptngar l o ittle ha sin'. 0 C. 9 1 ai ue f to a x u to ' ) 2 2 Ase plie i ti c ur' or e ofM a 1 , x an d n h s o ts d r y 3 2009( oc e /29) t i c ur wilnot D k t / ,h s o t l
23 ge e a l c nsde une ha sed ca m st be e ha s e on t e pound t a t esa e c urswilnot n r ly o i r x u t li o x u td h h t h tt o t l 24 c nsde t ecli s ie. t esat c u twou d tnd t a t e cli swe epr c dur ly def ule . Thi o i r h am ,. ,h t e o r l i h t h am r o e al a td s
25 i be a s N ev da c ur sm a e c s pr c du a ba s o untm e y ors e e s ve flngsi a pe ii ne s c ue a o t y x u e o e rl r f i l u c s i ii f tto r

2 s o sg odc u ea dp eu ie Ne . e .tt â 3 .2 ( ) 3 .1 ( ) Thee c p int t i 6 h w o a s n rj dc . vR vs a. j 47 6 1, 4 8 0 3 . x e to o h s
3

1 c ur' ge e a pr ci e, pr viusysa e byt eco r,i oc a i ne by t e e t' ofpe tne t o ts n r l a tc as e o l tt d h u t s c so d h n l y ri n 2 si ul to sby t epeii ne . l t i c s ,pettene hasc os n n tt fl s c s i ul tons 1 tp ai n h tto r n h s a e ii r h e o o ie u h tp a i . 3 Acc r i g y,heco r tndst a aNe a asa er m e yi silavalbl t peii ne a d r t r i g od n l t u ti h t v d t t e d s tl ia e o tto r n eu n n
4 t s a e c u ti notf tl . o tt o r s u ie

5

l lghtoft ef r go ng, hec ur wilde ypeii ne ' moton f ra sa pur ua tt ni h o e i t o t l n tto r s i o t y s n o

6 Rhie v We e a dwildimisti a tonwihoutprj diet alw peiine t r tr t sae n s . b r n l s s h s ci t eu c o lo tto r o eu n o tt
7 co r t e ha s hi c ai s u to x u t s l m .
8

9

I I TH E R EF O R E O R D E R E D t a pettone ' m oton f ri s a c of s a a d TS h t ii r s i o s u n e t y n

l a e a c purua tt Rhie v.Web ri DENI D ( oc e #30) 0 b yn e s n o n s es E D kt .
11 I I FUR T H E R O R D E R E D t a pe ii ne ' m otc t f l s ppl m e t la t or t TS h t tto r s im o ie u e n a u h iy

1 i s ppor ofhi rpl t r s o de t'o postoni DENI D ( oc e #38 . 2 n u t s e y o ep n ns p ii s E D kt )
1 3 I I FU R T H E R O R D E R E D t a t i pe ii n f rw rtofha ea c m us i TS h t h s tt o o i b so s

1 DI M I SED wihou prj die TheClr i diece t e trj dgme ta c r igl andt cos 4 SS t t eu c . ek s r td o n e u n c o dn y ole
15 t i cas . hs e
16

1 7
18

DATED t i F* - da of hs * y

92

e

.

, 2009.

19 20
21

UN1

STA T ES DI TR I T JUD G E S C

22
23

24

l' ec ur hasc nsde e peii ne ' m oton t fl s ppl m e t la t ort i s ppo'ofhi 'h o t l o i r d tto r s i o ie u e n a u h iy n u l t s
25 26

r pl t r s ondent'opposto .The c ur fndst e non- i di g ca e a t ort fo a ot e cic i e y o ep s ii n o ti h b n n s u h iy r m n h r r u t
c t d t e e n t be unpe s asve ie h r i o ru i .
4