GEORGE CHACHAS v. CITY OF ELY et al

Filing 54

ORDER denying 44 Motion for Attorney Fees. Signed by Judge Larry R. Hicks on 09/21/09. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - LG)

'1 .: ; . ') l.-.'.E f1trSF7-771.F-àg j -.ftFLE g I ' !'.;. 4 - u..t t. ) 7y- , t' .' z. y t-.ki) ) 1 ), ic,t. 7 )y.: i .t j1y t. u J
,
.

r . - -.. .

.

1
2
3 4
5

' i 1 r -'' ?' I i

'-

-

! i

l .
j
1-/ 1

) .. 1.-r.-.. . q
.

(F;.; .i'.),;iq 2i'-ï!tsIt.#à' :, .ù.:..t. r. . 2.. )j;. :q r . : ;s. :. . , 2

1 ' . ..L s .u y 1

r -. . u . c z .' 'su . - z z z-zzz zz -''- qA J - .- . z z k z z gue!T. ' ,z -

6 7
8

U N I ED STA TES DI TR I T CO U R T T SC DI T R I T OF NEV A D A SC
Y**

9 GEORGE CHACHAS,
1 0 Pl i tf, an if

l1 v.
1 CI Y OF ELY,NEVADA,eta . 2 T l,

) ) ) ) ) ) )
)

3: 7- V - 1 - RH - PC 0 C 0 S8 L V

ORDER

1 3 1 4
15 16 17

Defnda t. e ns

) ) ) ) )

Pr s nty be or t ec ur i degnda t 'moton f ra t r ey' f esfld Aprl1 , ee i f e h o ts ns i o to n s e ie i 4 2009.

c a l c a s ie n p sto n i29, c ) Doc. *48. D oc /441 Plitf Ge r eCha h s(: ha h s'ild a op o iin o Aprl 2009. . / . anif o g
The e fe ,de e da t t l d a r pl on M ay 18, r a tr f n n s i e ey 2009. oc. / 3. D /5

18 1 . 1 9 20
2l 22

Fac s and Proc dur lH i t r t e a so y

On M a c 30,2007, c a tl d acvi rg t c m pl i ta ans t eciy ofEl a d rh Cha h s ie i l i h s o an g i t h t yn

m e b r o t eE1 CiyCo n i. ./. fn a t mo e frs mma yj d me tDo ./0. m es f h y t u clDoc /1 De e d n s v d o u r u g n . c / 3
Th c ur g a t d de e da t'moton a d t e c s wasdim is d.Doc. e o t rn e fn ns i n h ae s se #42. r a tr de e da t The e fe , f n n s

movedfratr e - tespurua tt 42U. . .j1 88. /44. o to n y s b sno SC 9 Doc./
23 It. 24 D i cus i n s so

Thec ur,i isd s r ton, a a a d r as na l at r e - f est apr vaii g pa t i a o t n t i c e i m y w r e o b e to n y s e o e ln ry n

25
26

lRe e st t e e u- sd c e e t y num be . f r o h o l' o k t n r t r

1 ciirghsacin. U. . .j1 88.Ho e e , a a dofat r e - f e t adefnda ti v l i t to 42 SC 9 w v r an w r to n y s e s o e ns
2 lmie . i td Maagr We se ,993F.d718 71 ( t Ci.1 93)(ii gJen e ). ange,762F.d . s lr 2 , 9 9h r 9 ctn s n 'St l 2 3 8l 81 (t Ci.1 5) - c ur ma ga tat r e ' f e t adefnda tu de s cin 1 88onl? 5- 7 9h r 98 .% o t y rn to n y s e s o A e n n r e to 9 )
4 undert e lm ie c r um sanc s w h r t e ac i n i fi ol u .u r as na l porw ihou h i td ic t e e e h to s r v o s n e o b e tt

5 f undai ns'1 . e p a i adde ) o to .- d ( m h ss d.
6 An aci ni fi o ouswhe t epl i tf sa gu e t a ewho l' t outm e i orwhe t e to s rv l n h an if r m n s r lqwih rt nh

7 pl i tf b ur u st e lt g ton w ih an i pr pe pur os ,s c ast a noy o e baras t e a n if - s e h ii a i p t m o r p e uh o n r m r sh

8 dee da t'Dou lsv Pfn son.284F.d99 ,1 06(t Ci.2002) Hee tec ur fndst a fn n .' g a . lg t 3 9 0 9h r . r,h o ti h t
9 Cha has c m pl i tw a bas d on a i cor e t butr a ona l i t r r t t o oft e l w she w a c ' o an s e n n rc, e s b e n e p e ai n h a s 1 c ale gi g,a d t e e or ,hi c m pl i tha a s fi i ntl galf unda i n.Acc r i gl , s 0 h l n n n h r f e s o a n d u te e e o to o d n y hi
11 com pl i tw as notf i ol usand def ndant ar notentted t atorne ' f es. an rv o e se il o t y s e
l2

13

I I THEREFORE ORDERED t a dee da t'motonf ral r e ' fe ( oc. i TS h t fn ns i o to n y s e s D #44) s

14 D EN I D . E

1 5

I I SO O R D E R ED . TS

1 6
17 18

DA-E ti # / d yo-etmbr2 0 . I D hs ' a fspe e. 09

%

1 9
20 21 22 23 24
25

LA R R Y R . I K S HC L N I ED STA TE S D I T R I T J D G E TT SCU

26

2