Morrison v. Benedetti et al

Filing 17

ORDER ADOPTING 16 Report and Recommendations re 12 Motion to Dismiss. IT IS ORDERED that Ds' 12 Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED. Clk shall enter judgment. Signed by Judge Brian E. Sandoval on 1/29/2009. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - PM)

'

.% ,

,

F Eqr 1 I! l

E'aa (7 1'T.('.9 LiEE :):EFFIt,2.g ': , tT A J..g: ''lll -5 N i?1ijt à7, 7
.

Fr 21 FD ' c E: . /

1

2
3

tlh 3 û 259 Jl (

4
p,: ,
.

C.R j:) T7)é (l l j CElQ. /.T F ; - 1' F s0k.:é f./-t . rc ; :--, ' à t: -. :
.

u- - -us u -. y u zm a

yr. -.v iî1 Fr . v .

5

6
7

UNI ED STATES DI TR I T CO URT T SC
DI TR I T OF NEVADA SC

8 EDW ARD ELRY MORRI O N, S

9 1 0 1 2
13

Pl it , ani l v De en ans. fd t

1 JI BENEDETTIeta. 1M , I,

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

3:7- V- 48- ES- PC 0C 2 B V

ORDER

1 4

Bef r t e Cour i t e Repor and Recom m endaton oft e Unied St t s M agitat oe h ts h t i h t ae sr e

1 Ju ge ( 1 )CRec m m en a i n'en er donAu u t 200 ,nwhc t e Ma ita eJ dge 5 d #6 o d to ' t e ) g s 27, 8 i ih h gs r t u 1 r c m m en st a t i Cou en er or er an igde enda t ' int Dim is( 1 ) d 6 eo d h t hs d t an d gr tn f n s Mot o s s # 2 an o 1 t e a to bedim is dwih u p e u ie.No obe tont t e Repod an Rec m men a in 7 h c in s s e t o t r j dc jci o h do d to
1 has been fl d. 8 i e
1 9 1 D I cusSI N .S O

2 0

Thi Coud ' a ac ep , rj c , or modi , i wh l or i p r,t e fn ig or s i y c t ee t m f n oe y n a t h id n s

21 r c m m en at n madebyt emagitae.28 U. . . 636( )1 ( 005 .Furh r un er2 eo dis o h srt ' ' SC j b( )2 ) te , d 8

2 U. . . j 63 ( )1 , i a p ry mak s a t el obec in t t e magitat j dge' 2 SC 6 b( ) f at e i y jt o h m o sr e u s
23 r com m endaton, t en t i C our i r q uied t ' ake a de novo det r i aton of t ose e i h hs ts e r o ' m em n i h

2 p ri n of h ( por an r c m m end t n t whihobec in i made.l1. Nev rhels , 4 o t s te r t d e o o e a i )o c j t s o o ' .. e t e s 4

2 t es a u edo sn td qui l s m eIs er e iw b (hi Coudl h nnoobe t nsar fld. 5 h t t t e o de r ) o e s r ve y t s re we jci o ei ' e' 26 Thomas v.Ar ,474 U, .1 0,149-50 ( 985) I sead,undert e sat t ,t i Coud i not n S4 1 . nt h t u e hs s
27 28

1Foranobj q int be tm el, pary mustser eandfl iwihi 10 daysaferbeig e to o i y a t v i t tn e t n s red wi t e ma ltat j dges r po an r c m m e da in. 8U.. . 6 6b()2 0 ) ev th h gsr e u ' e d d e o n t 2 SC j 3 ()1 (0 5. o
1

l r quied t conduct' ny r viw ata$ . . . o an is e t ati no t e s bec of o j c in '' ero ' ee a l f y s u h s t h u j t an be t o
.

2 L= at1 9. Si i ry,t e Nit Cicui has r cognied t ata dititcour i d 4 m l l h nh r t a e zh s rc t

s notr quied t ero

3 r vew amagitat j dg ' r podan r c m m e da inwh r noobeci n h ve been fl d. ei sr e u es e deo nt o ee j to s a i e
4 See Unied St t s v Revna-f Di , t ae -a a 328 F 3 1 1 ( t Ci. 03 ( ir gar ig t es an ar d 1 4 9 h r20 ) d s e d n h t d d
. .

5 ofr vi w em plyed byt e dititcour when r vi w i g a r pod and ee o h s rc t ee n e
.

r com m endaton t whi h e io c
,

6 n o j c inswer made ' ee alo Sc m itv Johnst ne,263 F supp.2d 1219 o be t o e ls , s hd o
.
-

1226 ( . D

7 Arz 2003 (e dig t e Nit Ci uis decson i Re n -ani as adoptng t e viw t at i. ) fa n h nh r t c' ii n v a r a iheh
8 dititcours ar notr quied t r vi w ' ny isue t ati nott s rc te e r oe e ' s a hs h

e s bec ofanobec in.) uj t j t o. o 9 Thu ,i t er i no obec in t a magitat j d e' r c m men a in, t en t i Cour m ay s fh e s jt o o sr e u g s e o d t h hs o t
1 acc ptt e r com m endaton wihoutr vi w . See e. . Johnst ne 0 ehe i t ee g. o , 263 F. upp.2d at 1226 s

1 ( c e t g, t ou r vew, magitat j d e' r c m m en a i nt whih 1 a c p i wi t e i a n h sr e u g s e o dt o c o 1 fld) 2i. e
1 3

n obecin wa o j to s

l t i case, Pl it fha no fe an obe t n t t e Ma ita e J dge' Rep r an n hs ani s t i d f l jci o h o gs r t u s o t d

1 Rec m men at n( 1 ) Al ou hnoobecinwasfld, t i Coud has r vi wed t e Repor 4 o d i # 6. t g o h j to i hs e ee h t
1 and Recom m endaton, and accept i. Accor i gl 5 i st dn y
,

1 6 I I ORDERED t at en an s Mot nt Dim is( 1 )i GRANTED Thi acton TS h def d t ' i o s s # 2 s o si 1 i dim is d wi o tprj die.Th Cl r o t e Couf sh len er u gmen 7 s s s e t u eu c h e e k fh t al t jd t
,

18 19
20

I I SO ORDERED TS

.

DATED:Thi 291 day ofJanuar , 2009. s8 y .

2l
22

23
24 25
26

UNI ED STATES DI TR I T JUDGE T SC

27
28

2