Mariscal v. Skolnik et al

Filing 45

ORDER denying 38 Motion to Appoint Counsel. ; granting in part and denying in part 42 , 43 Motion to Stay and Motion for Leave to File. P shall have to 10/26/09 to file traverse. Signed by Judge Larry R. Hicks on 09/24/09. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - LG)

FL D IF ('r gE) 2''$ ( tu

REcEl/r . ,) F gE-, F ; N .w g ar 1. . , t:/lE,x qE (Fn giq lt īLp' 's ) g f dh h; ;

1

SEF 2 / 7'7 1f .J
. .

2
3
4 5 6 7 8

CEi(rTF8 pt'c.t ' LlhU.;l) luT u.ar fEraJ.) rSn tl F) T'7 .j l k (F k q k
C: Y DF qr rlv -

U N ITE D STA T E S D I T R I T C O U R T S C

D I T R I T O F N EV A D A S C

DA VI MARI CAL, D S

9 1 0 1 1
1 2 1 3
14 15

) ) Pe ii ne , tto r ) ) vs . ) ) D I ECTOR HOW A RD SKOLNI , e aI, ) R K ,t . ) ) Re ponde t . s ns )
/

3:7- v- 296- R H - PC 0 c0 L V ORDER

Thi aci n i apeii n f rawrtofha e se r uspur ua tt 28U . . .j 254,by s to s tto o i b a op sno SC 2
D a i M a ica,a Ne a aprs ne . On M ay20,2009,t i Cour gr nt d r s onde t 'm oton t v d rs l v d io r hs t a e ep ns io

1 6
17

dim isi pat a df undgrundst o( )t o( ) tr e f ur fv ,sx,a d sve une ha se s s n r, n o o w 1,w 4 ,h e , o , ie i n e n x u td
( oc e #37) Peii ne ee tdt a a do t os cai s( oc e /39) Reponde t ha ea s e e d k t . tto r lce o b n n h e l m d k t/ . s ns v n w r d t erm ani geai se ntie i tepeiinf rwrtofha e sc p us( oc e #41. h e i n l m o an d n h tto o i ba o d kt )
Be or t eCour i peii ne ' m o i n t sa t epr c e i gsa d r ques t fl a f eh t s tto r s to o t y h o e d n n e t o ie

1 8
19
20

21 22 23

ta e s t t esaesans e ( oc e # 2a d#43) Peii ne as st i Co r t sa t e rv re o h tt' w r d k t A n . tto r k h s u to ty h
pr c e i gs ashe f l d a s c nd pe ii n f rw rtofha e sc m usi t e s a e dit i tco r ,a d w il o e dn , ie eo tto o i ba o n h t t s rc u t n l

w a tt fl t i ne ca m i t ei sa ta ton.I . Re po de t oppos t emoton f rsa a d f r n o ie h s w li n h n t n ci d s n ns eh i o ty n o

24 l a e t fl a t a e s . The Co r w ilde y t e m oto si pa t Pe ii ne ha no s o n t a he i e v o ie r v r e ut l n h i n n r . tto r s t h w h t s 25 26

e tte t a say oft epr c e i gsm e ey be a s heha now fl d anew aci n i t e sa edit c n il d o t h o e dn rl c ue s ie to n h tt sH t
co r . M or ove , fpettone w i hest tl a ne c a m ,a d a e d hi pe ii np w oul ha e t ut e r i ii r s o ie w l i n m n s tto he dvo

1 se k l ave oft e c ur a r s o de t ha e tl d a r s ons ve pl ad ng i t i a to . Fed.R.Ci . ee h o t s e p n n s v ie ep i e i n h s ci n v P.

2 1 ()1-2) Tot ee tntt a peii ne s e sla eoftec ur t tl ata es t r s onde t' 5 a( )( . h x e h t tto r e k e v h o t o ie rv r e o e p n s
3 a s e , he c u twilgr ntt e m otons a d alow pe ii ne t i t da s t tl a t a e s . n w rt o r l a h i ,n l tto r h ry y o i e r v r e 4 A l o bef r t e Cour i pe ii ne ' s c nd m oton f ra poi t e tofc uns l s oe h t s tto r s e o i b p nm n oe

5 ( oc e /38) Thi Co l pr vi u l de i d am o i n f ra poi t e tofco ns l( oc e /7) The e d k t / . s u - e o sy n e t to o p n m n u e d k t/ . r
6 i no co siutona r g tt a poi t d c u s lf ra f de al be s c r uspr c e i g. Pe ns l ani s n tt i l i h o p n e o n e o e r ha a o p o e dn n yv a

7 v Fikv, U..551 555( 987) Boni v Vas ue ,999F.d425, (t Ci.1 93) The . n 481 S , 1 . n. q z , 2 428 9h r 9 .
8 decson t a po ntc u s li ge e al dic ei na ? Chane v Le i,801F.d 1l 1 96 ( t ii o p i o n e s n r ly s r to o . y . ws 2 91, 1 9 h

9 Ci.1 ) c r.denid,481U. .1 ( 987) Ba ho v Rily,730F.d 12 8,1 3 (t Ci., r 986 , e t e S 023 1 , s r . sq ' 2 2 2 4 9h r)
1 ce t de i d, U . .838 ( 984) Howe e , ns lmus be a poi t d i t eco pl xii soft e 0 r. n e 469 S 1. v r cou e t p n e f h m e te b
l1 c s a e s c t a de i lofe uns lw o l a ountt a de i lofdue pr c s , nd whe e t e ae r u h h t na o e ud m o na o esa rh 1 pe ii ne i a pe s n ofs c Im ie e ue ton a t bt i c pa l off il pr s ntng hi cl i s See 2 tto r s ro u h i td d ai s o n a b e a ry e e i s am .

1 Chanēv 801F.da 119 . eealoHawkisv Ben et423F.d948(t Ci.1 . 3 , 2 t 6, ss n . n t, 2 8h r 970)
14 The petton on fl i t i acton i or ani ed and rai est e i s esi a cl ar and ii ie n h s i s g z s h su n e

1 unde s a da l m a ne . The i s esdo nota pe rt be ove l co pl x. l doesnota pe rt a 5 rt n b e n r su pao ry m e t p a ht

l co nslij sii di ti isa c .Themotons albede id. 6 u e s u tte n h s n tn e i hl ne
1 7 I I TH E R E F O R E O R D E R E D t a pe ii ne ' m otonst s a ' hepr c e i gs TS h t tto r s i o ty t o edn

1 a drquetf rla et tl ata e s (oc e #42 a d/43 aeGIANTED I PART AND 8 n e s o e v o 'e rv re d k t i n f )r L . N
1 D E N I D I PAR T . The Co r wilnotjr nta s a oft e pr ce di gs How e e , he Cour w il 9 EN ut l oa r ty h o e n . v rt tl

20 gr ntpeii ne a dii naltm et fl ata e s . Pe iļ ne s a lha eup t , i c udi g,O c obe a tto r d to i o ie r v r e tto r h l v o and n l n tr
21 26, 9,t fl a ta e s t r s onde t 'ans e . 200 o ie r v r e o e p ns wr
22 // /

23 // / 2/ 4/
25 // /

26 I/

2

I I FUR T H E R O R D E R E D t a pe ii ne ' m ctc f rap oi t e tofc u s l TS h t tto r s lim o p n m n one

( oc e #38)i DENI D. d kt s E
3

oA-so ti J . d yo- e tmbe, 0 9 r hs e a ts pe r2 0 .
%

i

I E D STA T ES D I T R I T JU D G E T S C

3