Sonntag v. Balaam et al

Filing 124

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that the Report and Recommendation 123 is REJECTED. FURTHER ORDERED that the 112 Motion for Summary Judgment is GRANTED. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 3/3/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

4. ;

z *

iy g.

1

4

;
I

è : l
1 o

%

--- o lq Eo . ;.o ( j o - j( j uor . f r y -cuzt cHt/ .
k.

Ftif n

!. lo s EEl) c po ( --- b.v C: q
u u
l DE?l.( . )x

2
'

! '

! C1 klR - : 21

a
4

. r c z rtsc.SFtt c kc t q' ! (Lr i- z âf k )( sqïlcl :)
(î )s7Rl
gy -.w : . - ..- - 'e

1

!

5

6
7
!

INI J TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT
DI STRI O F NEVAD A CT

:

8

J ASON EI SONNTAG, UC pji tg anj '

9 1 0

vs .
11 : l 2
DENNI BALAAM e al, S t . .

Dee da t, fn ns l 3
i 1 4

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

.

w 3: - 0031 - 07* IRCJRAM ORDER

l 5
l i
;
Sonntag v. Balaam et al

Pl i ifJ s Erc Sonn ag ha s d s ve a Def da s f c tt i vi a i s a ntf a on i t s ue e r l en nt or ons iutonal olton . I ars n ou o hi p e ra d e i a t e W a hoe Cou y J i. The Cour pr vi s y gr t a 6 i i g t f s r t i l et nton t h s nt a l t e ou l an ed

I mo i t dimist Se d Ame d Compli t wih la e t a ndCouni11 Pl ntf 7 ton o s s he con nde a n , t e v o me 1. ai if
Doc. 124

'

l f l d t Thid A m e ded Co pl nt a l gig t aton one oc a i ,a t e ve m a e r c i t a 8 ie he r n m ai , le n h c s on w l - n xta ton : m 1 e e e hi c ldu i g a r d on hi uni p om pt d by di c plna y pr bl t ou 9 nt r d s el r n ai s tr e s i i r o ems hr ghou t e uni. th t 20 He ale st thew a f c d t s twih hi ha s c e behi d hi bac f t eehour , ha l ge ha s or e o i t s nds ha kl d n s k or hr st t 2 l of i e sen or e c pla e by p n i g a t s ra hi ,a d t a afert r d he w a s rpfc r f c d om i nc oi tn a e t m n h t t he ai s ti 2 s a c d a f c d t r m ai na ed i hi c lf one da D e e da t m ov f s m a y 2 e r he nd or e o e n k n s el or y. f n n s ed or um r '

23 j me , ndt Ma srt J geha rc udg nta he gitae ud s e ommen dden ngt moi L eRe ta de yi he ton.se por nd
2 Re omme dai J n.1 20ll ECFNo.1 3) Alh 4 c n ton, a 9: , 2 . toughteMa srt J ' elciatonof h gitae udges u d i
25 t g e alsan r appl bl t t c s a e c r ct t e Cour r s ctuly dia e s wib t he en r t da ds i e o he a e r ore , b ca t e pe f l s gr e t he

Dockets.Justia.com

I I

.

A

I

u *

1

I co l i i t R&R a t rfr rj csia grnt temotonf s ncusons n he nd heeoe ee t t nd a s h i or ummayj dgme ta a r u n s
1 ! 2 mat orlw . ter a
.

3
1 '

Th tmp rr sa kigo a imaefralgimaeraonsc a ofcrsft e e oa' b c l f n n t o e t t es u h s fie ae' y n i y

4 durn tan p torexta tondoe no vi aet con tttonwh ean ij r ordic or i ig r s or rci s t olt he siui er y nuy s omf ts
5 i er ti temeh ofrsr n. e v Hal,8 F.d l 3,1 ( hCi.1 96) Nor nh en n h tod e taitKe nan . l 3 3 08 092 9t r 9 .
6 d st e t ea ofat s --ore nt a t lu cofat erwh e isus i nota bir r or oe h hr t a er ve he c ua s as er t e s r ta y

:

7 grt t - t e orec in ewihlgii t or r vi aeteConsiuton. c ef le auious o nr c ompla c t e tmae des olt h tt i Mih ned r
8 v Su e 860F.d328, -36(t Ci.1 8) Nordoe tet orr a modet . mn r, 2 335 9h r 98 , s h emp ay nd s

'

9 de i ton ofcl t ng vi a e t Cons iuton w ih a c ai ofda r s y I w t m pe a ur s prva i o hi ol t he tt i t out l m nge ou l o e r t e
1 ors el uns t y condii . And s nv Counyo r 45F, 1 0,l 4-1 (t Ci 0 ever y aniar tons ero . t fKe n, 3d 31 31 5 9h r .

1
:

I 1 5)( lcigc e ) Fi ly,agadenvait srpsac atrama sr dit ac lbl k 1 99 cole tn ass. nal r - rey ti e rh fe s ai no el oc
i

!

- l e b tn dici i r p obl ,i l di g t po s s i ofc r ba c otb s i t be 2 xhi ii g s plna y r ems nc u n he s e s on onta nd, ann e a d o

l c ttton l u e ona e Se Mihefeder 8 F. a 33 Defn nt aee tte t 3 onsiui aly nras bl. e c n l , 60 2d t 2. e da s r nild o
1 s 4 umma'j dgme a amatroflw, l u y nt s te a
1 1 5 coNclusl u oN

I 6

I I HEREBY ORUERED t tteRe ta Re omme ton( No.1 i TS ha h por nd c ndai ECF 23) s

l7 REJECTED.

l 8
20
21

I I FURTHER ORDERED t tt ' i frSu r J T S ha heMoton o mmay udgme t( No,1 2 i n ECF 1) s
I I SO ORD ERED . T S

.

1 GRANTED. 9

1

'

22 Da e t s 3 da ofM a c 2011 t d hi d y r h, . 23
24 25

' '
R l ie Jn t RT C.JON ES t es D i rctJudge at sti '

Page 2 of 2