Sonntag v. Balaam et al

Filing 83

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED, the court ACCEPTS and ADOPTS in whole the 71 Report and Recommendation of the U.S. Magistrate Judge. FURTHER ORDERED, Plaintiff's 72 Opposition to the Report and Recommendation of Magistrate Judge Motio n to Strike and Vacate Biased, Conflicted Report is DENIED. FURTHER ORDERED, Defendants' 64 Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED as follows: (1) Counts I and II of the 42 Second Amended Complaint are DISMISSED with prejudice and Count III with leave to amend. FURTHER ORDERED, Plaintiff shall file a Third Amended Complaint stating only Count III in a manner identical to the previously filed 14 Complaint within thirty (30) days from entry of this Order. The Clerk of the Court shall enter judgment accordingly. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 10/23/09. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - KO)

1
2

3
4

5

6
7
8

UNI ED STATES DI TR I T CO U RT T SC
DI TR I T O F NEVADA S C

9 J SO N ERI SONNTAG, A C
1 0 1l 13
14

Plitf, a n if v. Def ndant . e s

1 DENNI BALM M ,etaI, 2 S .

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

3:7- V- 11 RCJ RAM ) 0C 3 - (
ORDER

1 5

Bef r t e Cour i Pl i tf' Opposii nt Repor and Recom m endaton ofM agitat oe h ts a n ifs to o t i sr e

1 Ju g Mot nt Stiean Va a eBis d, fit d Repod ( 72) i donAu u t2 , 6 d e i o rk d c t a e Con l e o c # fl e g s 4 2009. 1 Thsac inwasr f redt U. .Magitat RobedA. ouai , r, su n t 28 U. . . 7 it o ee r o S sr e Mc d J . pur a t o SC j 1 63 ( )1( ) LR I 14. eMagitaeJu g s bm iedhi Repodan Rec m men a in 8 6 b ( )B and B - Th srt d e u t ts do dt o 1 ( 71 onAu u t3, 9#) g s 2009, ec m men igt a t i Cour en eran o dergr n ig De enda t ' ro dn h t hs tt r a tn f n s 2 Mo in t Dim ist e Se ondAmen ed Co pait( 6 ) 0 t ossh c o d m ln # 4,
21
2 A. 2

1 ANALYSI . S
Revi w ofM agi t at Judge' O r er e sr e sd

2 3 Pur u n t 28 U. . .j 63 ( )1 ( )an LR I 3- ,a pady mayfl s e ic wr t n s a to SC 6 b ( )B d B2 i p cf ie e it 2 obec in t t e fn igsand r co m end t nsc a magita ej dg ma e pur u nt o LR 4 j t s o h id n o em ai f o srt u e d sa t
25 ( 1- . The dititcour m ustm ake a de nov det r î aton oft os pori ns oft e B4 s rc t o em n i h e to h
26 // /

27 // /
28

l magitae j dg ' r pod t whih obec in i ma e and ma ac ep ,rj c , mo i ,i srt u es e o c jt s d o y c t e e t or df n y 2 whoeornpar,h f digscrec m m en at nsm a eb t emags rt j dge.LR I 3- ( ) l i tt e i n n ro di o d yh ita e u B 2b,
3 De novo r vi w m eans t e cour m ustconsi ert e m ateranew , he s m e as i i had not ee h t dh t ta ft

4 been hear bef r and as i no deci i n pr vi usl had been r nder d. Ness v. d oe f so eo y e e

5 Commisoner 954 F.d 1 95, 497 ( t Ci. 92 .Thu ,al ought e dititc ur n e si , 24 1 9 h r 19 ) st h h sr o t e d c
6 nothol a de novo hearng,he coud' obl aton i t arie atisown i dependentconcl si n d it s i i so r g v t n uo

7 abou t os p din o t emagsr t j dgesfn igsor ec m m en at nt whiho j cins th e o o s fh ita e u ' id n ro d i o c be t o o
8 ar m ade. Unied St t sv.Remsia,874 F.d 61 ,617 ( t Ci.1989) e t ae n 24 9h r .
9 Aferconduc i g a de nov r vi w oft e r cor ,t e Coud acc pt and adopt t e t tn oee h e dh es sh

1 Magitat Judge' Miut soft e Cour ( 71) 0 sr e s ne h t# .
11 11 CONCLUSI N 1. O

1 2

I I HEREBY O RD ERED t att e COUdACCEPTS and ADOPTS i w hol t e Repod TS hh n eh

1 andRec m m en a inof S. itat J d e( 71 , dPl it f Opp st nt Repodan 3 o d to U. Mags r e u g # ) an a n i' f s o ii o o d
1 Recom m endaton ofM agitat Judge M oton t Sti e and Vacat Bi s d, 4 i sr e i o rk e a e Confit d Repod le c

1 ( 72)i DENI D. 5# s E 1 6 I I FURTHER ORDERED t atDef ndant ' int Dim is( 64)i GRANTED as TS h e s Moto o s s # s
1 f l w s: 7 ol o

1 8
20

1 .

Cou t I 1 o t e Sec n Amend d Complit( 42)ar DI M I SED wi n s and 1 f h od e an # eSS t h

1 p e u îe an Coun lI t lav t amend. 9 rjdc d t Iwi e e o h
I I FURTHER O RD ER ED t atPl i tf shalfl a Thid Am ended Com pl itst tng TS h a n if l i e r an a i

21 onl CountIli a mann rient alo t e pr vou l fed Compl it( 1 )wihi t iy ( 0 y ln e d i t h e i sy i c l an # 4 t n hd 3 )
2 day fo en r o t i Or er Th Cl r of he Coud sh lener u g e tac or igl. 2 s r m ty f hs d . e e k t al t jd m n c dn y
23 I I SO ORDERED. TS

2 4
25

DATED: s C * dayofOcob r2009 Thi 7 ' p ' P t e, .
-.

/ ,

'' '
'

2 6
2 7
28

/ V

.

/

.

Robedc. nes / Jo
W , .

UNIED ST TE PITRITJ DGE T A SCU