Goodall aka James Goodall, Jr. v. State Of Nevada et al

Filing 34

ORDERED that the Motion to Dismiss (# 25 ) is GRANTED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the motion for stay and abyance (# 32 ) is DENIED. Signed by Judge Edward C. Reed, Jr on 8/10/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

FJ; t E:I)E rE D jt 'F
.-

1 2 r / )

()N(- 7R:a ?g;a )f s.1 7 ;Fy(y (J J. ,7 i ; jtt J( j jl ) .
t . ,,

, j: -'-Tâ)g'.t - )L: 'jy . ? j ;j rl
.

a

yg ,y y
.j

3
y

l )
1$ .

:s:kp -ro u u rjr L7' r ' j
yy yj jg yy yy y yy ) y y yy
.. . - .. . .

5
6

- .- - -

.

''- -yyy --- g j

7
8
9

UNI ED STATES DI TR I T COURT T S C
D I T R I T O F NEV A D A S C

10 J M ESGOODALL, R. A J, l1 1 vs 2. Peii ne , tto r

1 STATE OF NEVADA,e aI, 3 t.
1 4
15

Res onde t. p ns

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

3:7- V- 6 9- CR- AM 0 C 02 E R ORDER

1 6

l7

Thi i apr s peiin frwHtofha ea c r uspu s a tt 28U. . .j2254. s s o e tto o b s o p ru n o SC

18 Res o de t ha em ove t dim ist epe ii n on t eba e ofe ha si n a d pr c dur lde a l p n ns v d o s s h tto h s s x u to n o e a f u t

1 ( o k # 5 .Afe mut l e tnso so tmet o frh sr s o s o o p sto t t emo i nt 9 d c d 2 ) tr lp e x e in f i o fe i e p n e r p o iin o h to o i
20 dimis peiine tldamoton frsa a da e a e ( oc e /32)oft epeiin.Res o de t s s, tto r ie i o ty n b y n e d k t/ h tto p n ns

21 haveoppos dta moton( oc e #33)a dpeiine ha nottldarpl ,at o g t etmef r e ht i d kt n tto r s ie e y lh u h h i o
22 doi g s hase pie . no x rd 23 24 de i d. ne
25 26

Them o i n t dim iss albe g a t d mz t em oto f rsa a d a eya c s al be to o s s h l r ne d h in o ty n b n e h l

1

Res onde t'moto t dimisrle ont ote res ( )t a Gr undOneloft e p n s in o s s eis w h o i : 1 h t o h

2 peiini t e ha se ,a d( )ta Gr u dsTwoa dThr ear pr c dtr lydefule .Peiine tto s m x u td n 2 h t o n n e e o e lal a td tto r
3 hasnota gue t a G r un One i e ha s e ,a d by hi m o i n f rs a a d a e a c , ppe r t r dht o d s x u td n s to o t y n b y n e a a s o

4 c nc ded t a i i not N et e ha hea dr s e t eis eofpr c dur ldef ul,f ii g t m a ea y oe h t t s . ih r s d e s d h s u oe a a t aln o k n

5 a tmptt agueag is tedea l oft pr vi eas owigofc us andprj diet ovec m es c te o r an th fut o o d h n ae eu c o ro u h 6 adea l,i i e it.Colmanv.Thomps n 501U. . 750( 991 . fu t f t xss e o, S 722, 1)
7 Unde t e Lo a Rul s ofCi i Pr ce ur ,Rul 7- ,f iur o a pa t t pr s n rh cl e vl o d e e 2 al e f ry o e e t 8 poi t a d a t ortesi op oston t a m oton t hal c ns iut a c ns ntt t e gr ntng oft e n s n u h ii n p ii o i b l o tt e o e o h a i s h

9 m o i n. Thus t em otont dim iss albegr nt d f rpeii ne ' f iur t o pos dim is l to ' ' ,h i o s s hl a e o tto rs a l e o p e s s a .
1 0 A s f rpe ii ne ' m oton f rs a a d a e mz e, be eo r tndsi i s f i i ntt o tto r s i o t y n b y c t u ti t n u fc e o

1l wa r n t er quese r le . Fis,at oug pe ii ne r c gni est er l ofRhi e v.Webe ,54 ra t h e t d e if rt lh h tto r e o z h o e ns r4

1 U..269( 005) i tec ntxtofe ha sinar sa a da e a ce heha c mpltl fie t 2S 2 ,n h o e x u to l ty n b y n , d s o eey ald e
1 a dr s t epoi t Rhi e i e ttesaspe quiiet ob a ni g s ch asa .Rhi e ca to ed t a a 3 d esh n s n s d n ii r st o t i n u ty n s uin h t 1 sa - nd- be anc ts oul bea aia l onl i lm ied cr um sa ce s' nd i a pr pra eonl when 4 t y a a y e th d v lb e y n i t ic tn s'a s p o it y 15 t edititc ur dee ni est a t er wa ç ood c us ' f rt ef iur t e ha s a dwhe et e h src o t tn n h t h e s t g a e' o h a l e o x u t n rh
16 cou t ' dst a t e c a m sa e no c e ry m e il s . d.a 278. Thus i i i c m be tupon t e r tn h t h li r t l a l i rt e s 1 t st s n u n h 1 pe ii ne t de o s r t t t e c ur t a he ha good c us f rhi f iur t e ha s a d t a be 7 tto r o m n t a e o h o t h t s a e o s al e o x u t n h t

l cli sm e i r vi w .l t i i sa ce de pieha i gt i oblgai n hi hlght d b r s o de t , 8 am rt e e n h s n tn , s t v n h s i to g i e y e p n n s 1 pe ii ne di nott ket eopporuniy t pr vi es c a gum enti ar pl bre .M or ove , r vi w 9 tto r d ah t t o o d uh r n e y if e ra e e 20 oft eune ha se cli ,Gr und One s pporsa fndi g t a t ecli i m e il s . The e i no h x u td am o ,u t i n h t h am s rte s rs
21 c ns iutona r q i e e tt a a sat cour a poi tc uns lt as i ta pe ii ne i a y pos o tt i l e u r m n h t t e t p n o e o ss tto r n n t

22 co vitonrviw.Colman,501U. . t752,John onv.lcr,393U. . 488( 969) Thus n ci e e e S a , s zv y S 483, 1. ,
23 t e e i no c ns iutona vi l ton pr s nt d i t i c a m wa r ntng t i cour ' r vi w . hr s o tt i l o a i e e e n h s li ra i h s ts e e
24

1I i ofnot t a r s onde t 'ar u e ta a ns Gr und One i m o erghty f e s d o i l ck ts eh tep ns g m n g i t o s r i l o u e n ta 25 ofvibiiy a af de al nsiu i nal l i .Thecai a gue t a pe ii ne , rgh st d epr c s a d a lt s e r co tt to c am l m r s h t tto r s i t o u o e s n

eq al ot c i nwe evi l td be aus t esaedititc ur f iedt a poi thi c u s l oas ithi u pr e to r o ae c e h t t src o l a l o p n m o n e t ss m 26 wih hi saepos- onviton ha e speii n a d f ie t c nduc a e i e tay hea i g i or e t t s tt tc c i b a tto n a l d o o t n v d n i! rn n d r o

alw hi t de eo t ef cst s ppor hi cams Se Peiin( oc et/9)pp.4- . lo m o v lp h a t o u t s li . e tto d k / , 6
2

Thi lav t eceul wih bu oneco cl sc -t atpe ii ne hasno bas st o pos se e h .tt ' t n u im b tto r e op e dim is lofeihe t e u e hause c am ort os t ata epr c dur ly de auled. Thec ur, s sa t rh nx td l i h e h r o e al f t ot
t e ef r ,s a lg a tt em oton. h r oe h l rn h i

I I THEREFORE ORDERED t a temotont dimis( oc e /25)i TS h th i o s s d k t/ s
G I N TE D . G

6
7 DEN IE D .

I IsFURTHER ORDERED t a t emotonf rsa a da e a ce( oc e #32)i T h th i o ty n b y n d k t s TheClr s ale trj dgme ta cor igl. ek h l ne u n c dn y

8
9

10 11

Dae ti l d yo Au ut2 1 . td hs O a f g s, 0 0

Z. W .
U N I ED STA TE S D I TR I T J D G E T SC U

23
24 25

26

3