Sells v. McDaniel et al

Filing 81

ORDER granting 39 Motion for Preliminary Injunction.; adopting Report and Recommendations re 64 Report and Recommendation. Signed by Judge Brian E. Sandoval on 07/15/09. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - LG)

1 2

3
4 5

6 7

UNI ED STATES DI TR I T CO U RT T SC DI TR I T O F NEVADA SC

8 W ILI M CATO SEL S, R. LA LJ, 9 F 3 litf ér i , llf l 0 v. lE l K.MCDANI L, a. E et I, I 2 D ef nd n s. e at 1 3
.

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

3: 8- V- 7O- ES- AM OC 1 B R ORDER

1 4

Bef r t e Cour i t e Repor and Recom m endaton oft e Unied St t s M agitat oe h ts h t i h t ae sr e

l J d e ( 6 )(Rec m m e d t n' e t r d o Ap i 9,20 9,i whih t e Ma ita e Ju ge 5 ug #4 ' o I n a i ' n e e n rl o) 0n ch g sr t d 1 r c m m e ds t att i Cour gr n plit f Mot n f ra Pr l iar Ij n t n ( 39) No 6 eo n h hs t a t a n i' fs i o o ei n y nu ci # m o I obec in t t e Rep r an Re om m en a in ha b enfld. 7 j t oh o ot d c dt o se i e
.

1 8

1 D l cussl N . s o

1 9

Thi Cour d ay accept rj c ,or modi , i whol or i par, t e f digs or s t' m , ee t fn y e n th in n

2 rc mmen at n madeb t ema itat .28U. . . 6 6( )1.Futeru d r28U. . . 0 eo dis o y h gsr e' S C j 3 b( ) rh , n e SC 2l ç63 ( )1)iap dymak satmel obe t nt t ema itat j dge' r c m men a in,t en 6 b ( ,f a e i y j c i o h g sr e u s e o o dt h o
22 t i Coud i r quied t ' ake a de novo det r iaton oft os podinsoft e repod and hs s e r ol m em n i he o hr

2 r c m men a in t whc obeci ni made.l Nev rhees ,he sat t d esn t' qui l 3 eo d t ) o ih j to s o ' ' e t l s t t u e o o 'e r ) re 2 so e Is er e iw b (hsCou twh nn ob e t nsar fld. Thoma v. n, 4 U. 140, 4 m e s r ve y t i r) e o j c i o ei ' e' s Ar 47 S 25 1 9 50 ( 9 5) I sea , dert e sat t , hi Coud i n tr qur d t c n uc d nyr viw 4 - 1 8 . n t d un h t ue t s s o e ie o o d t' e e a
.

2 a al . . any is e t a i n tt e su j c o anobec in. L= at149. Si iary,t e Ni t 6 t I . of s u h t s o h be t f j t 'd o' mll h nh
.

27 28
1F

adrcmmnai .8U... 6 6b() ) n eo edtn2 SC j b ()1( . o C

o ano jcint bet ey ap rymus s rea dfeiwk i 1 da saf rb igs we wl temagsrt Jdg ' rp r r be t o i l a t t ev n i t t n 0 y t en e d t h o m l h e h itae u es e o t

l

l Cic ih sr c g ie t at dititc ud i n tr qui dt r ve a magitat j dgesr p r r ut a e o nz d h a src o s o e r o e iw e sr e u ' e o t 2 an r c m menda inwh r n obe t nsh v b enfld. Unt dSt t sv. v a Ta i , deo t o e e o j c i a e e i See i o e e ae Re n - na 3 3 8 F. d 11 4 ( t Ci. 03)( ir ga dig t e sand r ofr ve emply d b t e ditit 2 3 1 9 h r 20 ds e r n h t a d e iw o e y h sr c 4 c ulwh n r viwig a r p d an r c m m en a i nt whc n obec inswer mad l s e o r e e e n e o d eo d to o ih o j t o e e; e

5 as Sc m itv.J hnson ,263 F. u p.2 1 1 ,1 26 ( .Ar .2003)(ea ig t e Nit lo h d o te sp d 29 2 D i z r dn h nh
6 Cicui' deci i n i Revna-r ni as adoptng t e vi w t atdititcours ar notr quied t r ts so n -a a iheh s rc te ero

7 r viw ' n is e t ati n tt e s bec o an obeci n.) Thu ,it er i no o j ci nt a e e a y su h s o h uj t f j to '. s f h e s ' be t o o 8 ma ita ej d e' r c m m en a in,he t i Cour ma ac ep t e r c m m en a inwi ou gs r t u g s e o d t t n hs o t y c th e o dt ott h 9 r ve .Seee. .J hn t n , F. u p 2 a 1 2 ( c ep ig, t ou r ve , ma ita e e iw n . o so e 263 s p . d t 2 6 a c tn wi t e iw a gs r t h 1 j d e' r c m m en a i nt whih n obe t nwa fld) 0 u g s eo d to o c o j c i o si . e 1I I t i case,def ndant have notfld an obecton t t e Magitat Judge' Repod n hs e s i e j i oh sr e s
1 an Rec m men a in. Al ou h n obeci nwasfe , hsCour h s r viwed t e Repod 2d o dt o t g o jt h o i d ti l ta e e h 1 an Rec m mend t n ( 64) an ac ep si Ac or igl, 3do a i # , d c t t c dn y o .

1 4
1 6

I I HEREBY ORDERED t atpaitf Mo i n f ra Pr l iar lj n t n ( 3 )i TS h l n i ' to o fs ei n y nu ci # 9 s m o
I I SO O R D E R E D . TS

1 G RA NTED . 5 .

I 7
l 8
1 9

DATED:Thi 15t day ofJul ,2009. sh y

20

' /
, . -

*y .' - X - f' '

.

21
22 23
24 25

UN TED STATES DI TRI T JUDG E SC

26 27 28

2