Sells v. McDaniel et al

Filing 86

ORDER. The Court has reviewed the 84 Report and Recommendations and ACCEPTS it. Accordingly, IT IS ORDERED that Defendants' 46 Motion for Summary Judgment is GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART. Counts I and III through XVI should be DISMIS SED; the federal claims against Defendants in their official capacities for money damages in Count II should be DISMISSED; and, the motion for summary judgment on Count II of the complaint should be DENIED. The Clerk of the Court shall enter judgment accordingly. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 10/23/09. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

.

*

l

2 3
4

5

6 7

UNI ED STATES DI TRI T CO URT T SC DI TR I T O F NEVADA S C

8 W I LI M CATO SELLS,JR. LA , 9 l 0 v. Plitf, an if

1l E. .MCDANI L,ela/, K E .

1 2
13

De en an s f d t.

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

3: 8- V- 70- ES- AM 0C 1 B R ORDER

1 4

Bef r t e Cour i t e Repor and Recom m endaton oft e Unied St t s M agitat oe h ts h t i h t ae sr e

1 Ju g ( 84) ' ec m m en at n'e t r donAu u t 2009.Thsaci nwasr f re t U. . 5 d e # (R o d d i ' ne e o) g s 6, i to ee rd o S 1 Magitat Ju ge Rob d A.Mc u i pur u ntt 2 U. . . 63 ( )1 ( )and LR I 1 4. 6 sr e d e o a d s a o 8 S C j 6 b ( )B B1 Afera t or ugh r vi w , he M agitat Judge r com m ends t att i Coud gr nti par and 7 t ho ee t sr e e h hs an t

1 den i padDe en an s Mo i nf r um mar Ju gm en ( 46) Noobec int t eReporan 8 yn f d t' t o s o yd t# . j t oh o td
1 Recom m endaton has been fl d. 9 i i e
20 1 Dl cussl N .s o

21 Thi Cour ' a ac ep , rj c , or modi ,i whoe or i pad,t e fndig or s t d y c t ee t m fn y l n h i ns 2 r c m m en a insma e b t e ma ita e. 28U. . . 63 ( )1) Furh r un er U. . , 2 eo d to d y h gs r t ' ' S C j 6 b ( . t e , d 28 S C 2 j 63 ( )1 ,i a p dy mak s a tm el obec in t t e magitat j dge' r c m m en at n, 3 6b() f a e i y jt oh o sr e u s e o di o 2 t en t i Cour i r qui d t ' ak a d n vo d t r ia i n o t os podi n oft e (e or 4 h hs ts e r o m e e o e e m n to f h e e o s h rp t 2 an r c m m enda in t whc o j c in i mad .l Ne erh lss,t e s a ut does no 5 d eo t ) o ih be t s o o e' ' v te e h t t e t 2 'equi i s m eIs errviw by(hi Cou twh nnoobeci n a efld.Th m asv. n, 4 6 ' r )o e s e e re t s r) e j to s r i ' o e' Ar 47
27 28
1For obe t nt bet ey ap rymu ts r' a dûe iw'hn1 da saf rb igs redw':temagsrt jd a'rp r ' an jci o i f a t s ev n f t l i 0 y t en ev i h o m e lt e t itae u g s e o t

adrcm edtn2 U....J ()1( ) n eo m nao.8 SC j6 6b() . i C
l

1 U. . 40, 49 50( 98 ) lsead, nd rh sat t ,hi Couri no r qui dt c nd c i n S 1 1 - 1 5 . n t u e te t ue t s ts t e r o o u t' y e a 2 r viw a aI. . fan is et a i no t e s bec ofan o j ci n... a 1 9. Si i r , h e e t l . o y s u h ts th u j t be t '1. t 4 o 'J m l l te ay 3 Nit Cic ihasr c gnz d t a adititc ur i n tr qur d t r ve a ma ita ej dges n h r ut e o ie h t s r o ts o e ie o e iw c gs r t u '
4 r porandr com m endatonwher noobj ctonshavebeenfld. UniedSt t sv. et e i e ei i See t a e Revnae 5 Tani,328 F.d 111 ( t Ci. 03)( ir gar igt e san ar o r viw emply d b t e a 3 4 9 h r 20 d se d n h t d d f e e oe y h

6 ditit ourw h nr viw igar p dan r c m men a i nt whihnoobec in wer madel sr c t e e e n e o d e o c d to o c jt s e o , ' 7 seealoSchm itv. s d Johnst ne, F. upp.2d 1219,1226 ( . i. o 263 s D Arz 2003)(eadi gt e Nit r n h nh
8 Cicui' decii n i Revna-r ni as adoptng t e vi w t atdititcouds ar notr quied t r ts so n -a a iheh s rc e ero

9 r vew t n is et a i no t e s bec o anob e ton.) Thu ,ft er i no obeci nt a e i d y s u h ts th u j t f a j ci n. s i h e s j to o 1 magita ej dgesr c m m en at n,h nt i Courmayac ep t e r co m enda inwi ou 0 srt u ' e o d i t e hs o t c th e m t ott h 1 r ve .See e. .Jo nson , 63F. upp. a 1 26( c e t g, t ou r viw , m a ita e 1 e iw n, h t e 2 s 2d t 2 a c p i wi t e e a gs r t n h 1 j dges r c m m end t n t whih no obeci nwasfld) 2 u ' eo ai o c o j to i. e l 3 I t i case,def ndant have notfld an obj ci nt t e Magitat Judge' Repod n hs e s i e e to o h sr e s 1 an Rec m m en a in.Al ou hno obeci nwasfld, hi Cnur h sr vewe t e Repor 4 d o d to tg h j to i ts e ta ei dh t 1 an Rec m m en ai n ( 84) an ac ep si.Ac or igl, 5d o d to # , d c t t c d n y 1 6 I I HEREBY ORDERED t atDe en ant'Mo i nf rSummar J dgm en ( 46)i TS h fd s t o o yu t# s
1 G RA NTED i par and DENI D i pad as f l w s: 7 nt En ol o

18
1 9

1.
2.

Count Iand IIt r ugh XVIshcul be DI M f SED ' s I ho d SS ,
The f der lcl i s agai st Def ndant i t ei ofi i scapacii s f r m oney e a am n e s n h r fca te o

20 dam ages i Count1 shoul be DI M I SED'and n 1 d SS ,

21

3.

The m o in f rs m m ar j dg en on Coun 1 o t e c m pl itsh ul be t ou o yu m t t 1 f h o an o d

22 DENI D . E

2 3
24

Th Cl r o t e Cour s alent rj d m en a c r igl. e ek fh t h l e u g t c o dn y
I I SO ORDERED. TS

2 5
26
27

DATED: i C'-.d yo Oco er2 0 . Ths s,cO a f tb , 0 9$ % cr .
. .

y

k '. .. .

Z

t)

'

/7 '

J'
.

2 8

Robed c J nes o

UIo TTS l7c JDE NI LAEo'trUG ' ' E s' r

?' '