Kroshus et al v. United States of America et al

Filing 684

ORDER GRANTING Defendants Re/Max Realty Professionals and Judy Ashton's 606 Motion for Good Faith Determination, each party to bear their own attorneys' fees and costs. All claims, whether known or unknown, against Re/Max Realty and Judy Ashton for contribution and/or equitable indemnity are hereby extinguished. Signed by Magistrate Judge Robert A. McQuaid, Jr on 11/15/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

:

.
'

lk n
ll
sy o
s

.

.

R Q l!
2 Vp
syr
r y i,y
x t t syg n u o s
wx aj jj j

.

1

MI
CHXELE.
STOBERSKIESQ,
,
NevadaBarNo.004762

2 M CHARY J THOMP ON, Q.
.
S ES
4

(0 )3 4 2o e
7 2 8101 Ec

t 5
s

XûV 15 2 1
11

NevadaBa o.011001
rN
o LsoN ,CAN NON ,
GORM LEY & D ESRUI
SSEA UX
9950 W es CheyenneAvenue
t
1 sVegas Nevada 89129
.
x
'

a

.

.

,
8
Y:

cu a p T m c
sas a ox
pj j r
sm c'
y .
(Fvvvk .
) ju
'
..

.

-

.

- -.
-

( )38 0701fx
702 3a

!7' .
7 00'
.
M

- . -..

. ' -' ''

j

1 mso esi ocd.o
tb rk@r g cm
A tor
t neys f Def nt RF AX REALTY
or enda s JM

8

UN I
TED STATES DI
STRICT COURT

.

!

,

9

bsmc o NVO
l ' F EAA
T r

10

'

j

* W* *

E

1 x 1I Jovx ohvx PMoi ILIEx vA.E T )c s xo 3 8c-04
1: RBI xosd s A Rum Rstu cl B R ) A E .: -vo26
uNSMA. l . T I A .ls :
C '
0
L !
'
w ts
'
.,

;

-

5 m 7 1 l MoRE- , R. AIN.
:
2
.ILIw. w t ROLXI wwn ,
NE
1J 1 j Rcl oMEPTXMESG-S Ivs
IE
.
liu PSN U I DAER.
,
BJ
A 1 ,
14l 3, RAMONA DAVI. Dö CRUTC ' l
s 1'
.

liw I B A D C U C E wB' YMcalH .
il1
7
R N Y R TT K SE xk;T
H
L
c
'!1 4 s 'lx I II DoI 'pt I:
=#- 1I xBfA KTH:cVys- ixLN A
1
iö'
'ryMCAGC ?vD I A '
xp > RT A j E
ru N
;J2 11 T MQ c K1ltH Iyxlo xl,
k1 51 o bo 1on LHlotl kjo.E
n
fM
; ! wlif K. s DI R. I.
t Ak DAG . ANE DAv s
: t 1 ' JRus-omsJITIO EhM F ID
i # 1I MlGIlEAMF.'IAJESTIERLTRNE.
è 7 J E J KLE , .
c
! ' 6 I l T J h JURG T N s AEvB

'

,

,

-

.

'

1
8

1
9
--

.

Zu

2
1

-

)
)
)
) ORD cM x'l c
)
ER
r'
x
)O FN AnoFR/oNAt,
EE N S El .
) REAL DP T EsMA s
TV
s X

l
l.
1
!
j
'

crsr à P zx L ROS I. BOR
'm ERE H. ANE E IDE XH ) ANDJUDYAS
HTON' MOTI !
S
ON
suc RosE. I
M CHXEITEE7ER.BRICE E.
- J
NAGEL.
J/ANNET'E M.
I NAGéL.wI -A/
'
LII
AoAh d s ox AoAMsoA OARYL R.
l ox. uM
GRovER. k.BARBARA spEccél . osEpH
J .
oJ
spEccil W ESLEY s'xuoNs. I
lb,
r
M ITY
sTALl s. RUS I - AxcEP j tn- .
ox
SE- L
I
lcll r

J REMY Gbrra AMANDA BAI I . '
E
ll
EB,
1E '
z
uosf w . I-E.J .MELI
As BA. I R ,
I
SSANEFF,
,
J
osEpy NEFF.DAW D M. RJ . RGI A
l
T pp VI NI
22 1 '
TRrP. EVER/'TA. RJ J E. 0ik.
p
I cl a oH& D t
'
2 1 oox' L. M . tAk NORI A.Mzkv
31
l DoH Aoll
kA
EG
t
'

'

)
)
'
)

--

.

Oko MEA IMCA 'EVI
RG L
I
DM - L
2 j NyE AR BRE AD MHLé V
41 Mco ,O ETMCA A 9II ER
1 S J s, NDALLS ALBs RHONDA
TAIB G
T J ,
2 ' S l Is DAVI S E DST S
51 H % )
D HIL RAVI
1 P , Epjox J NN/ERV rr ox DAVI
Aj w
n
E
sRs
D
,

) FoR Goc FAI
m
TH
) OETERMI
NATI
ON
)
)
)

)
)

I

)
)

.

)

)
)

j
j

)
)
)

'

.

2I u s mRL otx x ilRx xc )
8j mo xvs ,l rl ssE ,x v .
l
oE
.

'

'
.
.

Page 1of5'

'

I
I

'j

,

.
.

.

)

21 cMASAI,'v BDfTERESAJN I R )
6 BCHAEL HLsEE RN U H' NF ' )
I . RH JI lE
O AG E :
I YR N U L MMI REEO A G ,
REED,
2l DE.oAE MwlEZENrNEAMAjw , à
7 A GtoDIKTH-YJ.MlsjAY '
R H vf
i olAEtILPlRUA sgRTR X )
N E ANUA R , L ' Y
L E o
S o ;
Ul
-

1
I

i
' .
l

h

'

1
I
1
1
1

.

j .

.

1

LI
NDENM E EK EDWARD J S
I
. TEVENS,

2

5l

coNw i J su va qs,
B .
ROSEM ARY HI
GGm S.
J NET CHA PM A N ,sco rr CHAPM AN , J
A
'
USO
n ox. cc kl KROX.DAN LAWSON.
E
Lomt h LAw soN,
àfœ
àRANDON KNAPP,
Tn cy KNAPP,
LEstl LEVERETr,
B
CHXRLES
TANG CHAL YANG PRESNELL,
LEROY M ARX,
J
AsoN E. ARI GARY R.M VI E,
M CH,
'KL

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

l
6k
1
1
7I
!
'

CARMEN MEI E Km sTopl' BRU> ,
KL
qm
l
ANNET'SBRowh.Oi CAUL .
I
'
iJ m
K.
'
M ARI QIECAUEK. . J k piBol l
N J
Kl AME ï t
M
Ap
st ROSE, ENNI
m
J
FERW UGHAN, AXREN
W

)
)
)
)

3
4

.

.

GRAY BARBARA GRAY J r rL ms vn âd
ns
UI A
8 I BARBkaw vc ox, on uh lo oeNEiedn
a JE ' eas
.

a 1 he pe s ssmia l st td,
1 ot r ron i lry i e
ua

9

pani
l ts
.i r

' v
I .

'

)
)
j

)
)

-

1
C

I
.

)

'

1

' .

.

.

h

.

)

'

l

''
)

( , 1 ' uxlEo S
1
' TATESoFAMBRI DEP
f
CA ARTMENT )
!
5 !
of'IEI
/r. XTERI tru hi Bbl oF
I
OR ho g y uwu
s
)
: l 1 RECL
14p 2
AMATJ Mj p fc REGI
ON ouAclq
ON
)

'

l
I

1 k 1 c s xcl ö yc DIKK vp-ôt' )
: 3 s o nz ylE R s n- l E
u
f x,
l
'toz, , oceoyft.eneiéiy-AeoHRBura of )
S P3 4 eetrv rhItnrfoscEfteIKEu . )
ira oiecasr r I B T h E e,
r t roo IZ
!
,
l
rc
t

I

-

,

lgL :

%Jœ
'
à .>
$
î
;1 1
5
k
w
S j 1
g
6
ï >
-

ö
o
-

1
?

Re lma n,
ca to IRUCKEECARSON I GATI
RRI
ON
DI
STRJ T, bAWD P OVE
C
. RVOLD,
GARY

)

sr E.
'ox Tkucu ERI F
VER EDERALwATER

)
)

LYo N . cHRl , D.GARY Ht TCHI GS,
1 LT .
J
N

) .
)

s Asrjsc1 oFF t EY, cot 'v oy
t 'ya TY
slxt
m r

ll hRo Hubcyr os C. L.NVESTVENT
tcH
r ll
k
A. I
PROPERTI s KI COMS
ES NG
TRUCTI CAL
ON,
' l kDI
I Elx cH. AAH El- H. ATERNEVAI
'
ll GRE
uc
V

)
)
)

11 s f s srE wT h RpoytM R AX- ' )
e ut fs'Eves F.ckpfA I m
K Y o a E L Y TM
1 I o ALoMal, AsuTox D.x Axby mox, )
9j R r ' byr
E HN
r I
s xLL )
A
xs

,

i
i
I

j

.

-

'

,.

.1

2 I N ALTY, DWE BXNKER,
o i
COL LL
DOESIX
)
n lsv , n BLACK a dWHI COMP ES1 )
cuie a d
n
TE
ANf -

.

2 j xa
1
j
j

2I
2

.

.

j
'
l

)
)

.

Deedns
fnat.

.

.
)
)

.

-

I

23

2j
4

.

2s

l(
'

Dfdn Rayreia,cdi bse mRJ A Rayreia )
ena elP fsnlI.oguns sF X etP fsnl
e i t oso sn n i s M l oso s
Rel Poes nl'adJd Astns' ho'(olciey' J Rat
at rfri as)n uy ho'(Astn)cl t l ' MAX el
y so '
e k RF
y

2 I Prfsin l Dee d ns)Moinfr o F ihDeemiainhvn c meo frb aigo
6
ocso as fn a t' to o Go d at tr n t a ig o n o er n
o
n

'

2 !
71
,

.

.

tt2 +d) o Jl, 0 1zcayJno sn Eqo telwfmOL ON, A eq
lh 9 aq fuy2 l. ahr ., mpo , s.fh a i S c l oN
a
.
r
,
l Gol fiEv & oEsRu lssEAlr appeari on behal oft RE/M A X Realy Professi ,
l o a
x
ng
f he
t
'onal
s
.

,

21
8
,
I

,

.
.

.

Page 2 of5

l

!
j

.

.

.

1

'

l

.

. 1
l

'

.

1

De e dan s a l Rob r M a dox o t lw fr o M A DD OX & ASSOCI
f n t , rd
et d
f he a im f
ATES, l n R. .
Ca vi X

2

Dunl oft fr ofDI NLAP & LAX ALT,EuaeneLevery,LEVERTY & A SSOCI
ap. he im
J
t
ATES,

3

I
Ro r Ha roft 'nn HAGER & HEARN E, nd Le Hot hk ns Es ap a i g on b hal of '
be t ge he I
i
a
e c i . q. pe r n
c f
i
1

.

4 . tePlitf ca s a dteCo r h vn c n iee tep pesa dpedn so Geh ri, n I
h anif ls, n h ut a ig o sd rd h a r n la ig n l een a d

.

s

havi hear or ar ent
ng
d al gum ,

s
j

'

IIH RB O D R DA JD E A DD C EDtt
TS EEY R E E ,DU G D N ERE h:
a

7 D avicison. Teorlondet ftsiueiVlo(c/i o.
I 1 hculsosedh ao dcs n eil-mcd rv
j
ta ir e cl ssd s à fCp .
c l
8'

.

.

9

2.

'

1 Ne 356 81 P.d 5 l( 991 .
07 v. , 1 2 6 1 )

..

n e Cour hasconsi ed t f or dicuss i The Doct s Co.v.Vi
f
der he act s s ed n
or
ncent 120
,

1

l
o

E

Ne 644: 9 P. 681 687( 04 .
v. 652, 8 3d , 20 )

l

$ 1
i l 1'
l
I
1
I
t R 2
C k 1I
s ;

.

'

l
'

3 ne orhsosediftsitj iMG Gad olis7 l
. cutacnir teao dcsdn M rnHtFr50 '
de l cr ske
e e

F Su p 9 3( Ne.9 3.
p 1 D. v 18)
'

*1ë F
&

?t
%

'

.

I

.

l

! -@ l . 4 'tCorhsos ee teste na ut.$200l wenPanis 1
bi k a
j!
. l utacni rdh etmetmono 1,0 xte litf 1
b
d
l
f
e
f
i iz . n u ssA el rfsi as eedn . h hso e aur nuac fns
ki' , au wR /t xR aypoes nlo rpaa w i itb pif misrneud.
,z
j
t
o
c
o
.

.

a. 1
kj
,

T Courtfndst the settementam ounti reasonabl and suf ci
. i hat
.s ' e
he
l
fi ent

.

f l32 1
$
5

.

.

.

(
j
r
(
'

; 1
. 6
e

j
Q

1
7
!
s
'
'

'

5:

.

. eCour h sc i e e t da ge came b Pl n if,a i ha c sde e
n
t a onsd r d he ma s li d y aitfs nd t s on i rd
'

. rs ofpoce ngonlohsdc . eCour fnl ta t r i asrngpptni t t
t iks r edi
he
lt i s n
tifs h t hee s to
e talha
.
.'
RE/
MAX Re lyPr e son sa dAs onwoul beabet pe ia ais tePlitfs cli
at ofs i al n q ht
d
l o rval g n th anif' ams

1I prato R cat 65
9 usntN s hpr4.
u
e
' ..
6. ne orhsosed htrhrwsoli orurelatingo the
.
cu acnir weet e aclsnrrd
t' de h e
uo a
zo l

1

.

.

z I'el n.r cutnshthrwscolsnofu rligou ste n
l ste t'x orsdtatee ani l i rr det th e met
tme l
c u o a an e u
'

'

.

22

bet e Pl ntfs a IF/ Ax Roaly Pr es onal n e s tl e am ountw asani at
w en ai if nd l -M
t of si s.
e tem nt
ved

' 7a

t ot b ar l h neaotatons.
hr m
ms cnqt
ii

2
4

.

.

.

j
'

.

'

.

j'
t
l

.

'

7. ' The Co u ha c ns de e t sn nc a c dii oft s tl d f nd na a d t e
t l s o i r d he a i l on ton he e ti e e a
ng
n h

j
. .
.
.
,
j
z j isurance cv rg o testl gd fn a t.RE/ Rel Prfsinl iad fn t
. n
s
o eae fi etn ee d ns MAX at oeso as s eu c
l i
y
j
j
I
'
'
2 j Nea ac r rt n.Th e tyi isrd ai teisrn eise cetoc vrt ste n.
6 j vd opoai
o e ni s nue ,z h nua c s t in t o e l ed me t
t
d
m
.

.

.

.

.

27 I n e Cqur '
tsndst s lem entam ountr
he etl
easonabl and s lci i Ightoft i ance '
e
ufi enl n i
he nsur
!
l

.

28 1 Coveq
age.

'
'

-.

.

'

;.

.

1
'

'

!

1

8.

n e Cour hasconsi ed t sr h and w eakness ofpot i cont i i
t
der he tengt
es
ental
rbuton

I

$

2

and i nniy cl m s. n e Cour hol t t I -M . x Re ! Pr b so sDeenda a
nder t ai
t ds hat he tF/ 4
al ofs inal f nt
y

3

woul beabl t s
d
e o how t t di notha actve f ul. The Cour fntst pot i cl m s
hat hey d
ve i a t
t i l hat ental ai

.

.

'

4 t f c nti to a d e t bl i e n t d n we gh i f vo ofde i g d f t
or o rbu i n n quia e nd m iy o ot i n a r
ny ng oo ai
h

j
'

s'
'
j
.

'

.

I

.

9 'eel etgee bwcPiisnt RJ A Say
. I stmnae n e e lnfadb F X et
- t rm t t n at e M l
h e
f

.

e1 Poei a Dfdn stfshftseftiVlclàmclo .. gio, '
. rfsnl enat aset aq s obn ei Cei Cr vD vsn
so s e s ii e cr i r so a p d
7 l l Nev
07
3681. 5l19)hDcrC..iel10 e.4,518. 61j .
5,1Pd6(91TeotsoyVcn,2Nv64629Pd8,
2
, o
n
3
j

.

.

.

'

.

.

'

'

.

7 200 . nd
an
e Fle 5 su 91 D. v. 98 .
8 I 68 ( 4)a MGM Gr dHotl r i 70F. pp. 3( Ne 1 3)
.
'

.

1'
0

.

,

5
s

1
2

Dee d ns MoinfrGo dF i Dee niain
fn a t' t o o at tn n to .
o
h

'

'
'

1
3
. l . Th iE/ . Re l P oeso asDee d ns MoinfrGo dF ih
2
e t MA. at rfsin l fn a t- t o o at
x
y
o
.
'
tn n t s eey rne n tetr y
n o
s e
1 Dee'iainib rb ga tdi i 'ni t
4
j
'
.
1 A1cazswhei k
3
I li - twr nowno un
n
l
s
. .
r known,a nns
gl t
Reat pr esi l j
ly of ionas 1
1
.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

'

1', Dee d nsfrcnrb to ado e uubeid mnt aeh rb e t k ihdp ru n t NRS 1
6j fn at o o tiuin n/r q i l n e iy r ee y xi use us a to
n
.
.

'
1
1

1

I I H R B O DE ED,ADJUDGED,AND DECREED t t
TS E E Y R R
ha:

1 1
8
19

*.
1

2
0

I
I

a

RE M AX Rea! Pr e so l a J dyAs t sM otonf Go d Fat
/
l ofs inas nd u
y
hon' i or o ih
'

'

Det m i i i her g ed,each pary t beart row n atom eys'f and cos s'
er naton s eby rant
t o
hei
t
ees
t.
.

'

.

.

1i l. 5
7l 7 4.
k

o

'
.

1
'

No opposii wril oror ,was r ved t RF AX Realy Pr es onal
ton, ten
al
ecei o JM
t of si s

.

.

;

'

1
1

'

l
1

1
1

.

!
j

j' ù
Z
j
y
:.'
1Ap
o
' à $i
2 ,2 !
z '
Z, '
=
6 1i
: !
h 3t
f4
! J#:
Q
!
:xp!
I 1
( '
: 7
$

.

j Professi1 sDdhslmnaeredeoegoodPii a tRJA Ra
( onat Tceeeent mintbweflbtsn h F X et
0 endants@ as me n ite aitnf de M l
. t t tn n a f
l
y

9

Z

'

.

.

2j
1I
'

.

(

'

l
.

1

2 Allmsw e eko n rnnw sgitEMAXRay rfsoa I
. lca ,htrnw ouko naan R / el Poesnl
i h '
s
t
i s

I .

.

2 : a d J dyAs on f c ti tona ore i ei emniya eh r b e tng ihe
2I n u
1
ht or. rbui .nd/ qumbl nd .t r e e y x i u s d
on
j

.

.
.

DATED t s- l5+ - day ofNove r 2O11.
hi
mbe,

23
24 I

j

.

25I

'

.

.

t so j sjvwolrav sp .
xw
rv
s
uoc

2
8

.
.

:. .

..
.

-

'
.

.

'
.

'

.
1

.
.

2
7

.

.

j
l
j

Paae 4 of5 .

.
,

.

'

I
.

l

,

I

1
l

j

,

i

1

SU BM I
TTED BY :

.

.

2

OLSON ,
CA 0N , ORM LEY &
G
DESRU I
SSE ,

3

'

4

/.?
.z
(

k
'

-.
.
'
.
.

'

.

; ..
q zz
'
By
f.
MI
C 'vE.
1 STOBERSKI ESQ.
,

5

N eva '

s

'

zAc

N o. 004762

.

'

.

j
I
d

.

Y J THOM PSON EsQ.
.

7

N ev aBA N o.01l
00l
9950 W estCheyel eA venue
m

l
aI
l

.

j

.

.

.

.

l'

.

..
..

.

.

1% Ve a, v d 8 1 9
. g s Ne a a 9 2
.
At re sfr fn a tlE
t n y o Deed nst
o
a J
nd UDY ASHYON

'

l
$

REAL
TY

l
j

9
.

g

11
oj

j
1

k X 1
: : 1I
j

.

.

5. 1
2

j s,. .
j
:, l
tl ' a
e ;
u q1
1?1 !
G
,
t

.

'

.

.

.

4
4
ï 111 1
gq j

.

'

'

- JV
' :
HI
d lr 1
7 2 5

'

' I' 1 l
i- s
j7
O

5

(
7

.

'

.

I
l

.

.
'

i

j
j

'

.

17

l

.

.

l

! .
I
.

j

'

l
I

.

(

.
.

1
8

!

I
;

.

.

1

,

1I
9
I

.

.

2I
0'
I

.

'

'

21
1
,
l

.

I

'

.

I

22

23

'

24
25

x

'

'.

25
-

'

.
.

27

2
,

.

.

'

.

'
.

'

'
.

Pa 5 of5 .
ge

j
I
I

j.
I

.

,

i
.
'