Matthews v. LeGrand et al

Filing 159

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that the Court ADOPTS AND ACCEPTS the 147 Report and Recommendation of the United States Magistrate Judge. Defendant Joseph Ferro's 62 Motion to Dismiss, or in the alternative, motion for summary judgment is GRANTED and plaintiff's 60 Motion for Injunctive Relief is DENIED . Signed by Judge Larry R. Hicks on 09/22/09. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

- - -'

FLIRED hD g ENIZ

Ft;/D1 lll7) q)T! ,j E'( 2t$LF iS;'r?I :ïE'k kEI'LOA J Fh iEFtC ) qA I J Ji
.

CEF 2 2 2 0 09
1 1

2 3
4 5

GLD:.0l7'jjy2'2yy .1 1k tlOFyy'(y r El ' '.,iE'yjt 7 6 ,) ' ' lf . t S J
7%: /

-.

'' ' ''

'-. - s ' . - .. u r . su .
-

0FPU''j '' . .... .

6
7

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF NEVADA

8

9 FELTON L . MATTHEWS , JR .,
1 0 11 vs . Plaintiff,

1 ROBERT LEGRAND, et a1., 2 1 3
14

Defendants.

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

3 :O8-Cv-OO322-LRH-IAM R
ORDER

Th e court has considered the report and recommendation of the

15

United States Magistrate Judge ( 147) filed on August 7, 2009, in #
16
wh ich the Magistrate Judge recommends that this court grant the 17 de fendan t Joseph Ferro 's motion to dismiss , or in the alternative ,

18

motion for summary judgment ( 62) . Plaintiff has opposed ( 70), and # #
19

defendant has replied
20 21

( 71). #

Additionally, the Magistrate Judge

recommends that this court deny plaintiff's motion for injunctive
relief ( 60). Defendants have opposed ( 66) and plaintiff has replied # #
22

( 73). #
23
Th e court has considered the pleadings and memoranda of the 24

p art ie s and other relevant matters of record and has made a review and 25
d ete rm ina tion in accordance with the requirements of 28 U .S .C . 5 636

26
1

applicable case law , and good cause appearing , the court hereby
A DO PT S ANr ACCEPTS the report and recommendation of the United

Magistrate Judge ( 147). Therefore, defendant Joseph Ferro's #

te dismiss, or in the alternative, motion for summary judgment ( 62) is GRANTED and plaintiff's motion for injunctive relief ( 60) # #
D EN IED .

Tt is so ORDERED .
DA TED : This 22nd day of S tember , 2009 .
*

UN ITED STATES DTSTRICT JUDGE

18

19 20 21

23

2