Kenner v. Benedetti et al

Filing 44

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that P's 40 , 42 , and 43 motions are DENIED. Signed by Judge Edward C. Reed, Jr on 12/13/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - PM)

'

Fk D
lc
ENN RE
D

RECEW D
I
SERVIDON
COUNS UF E OFRE
E MUIS
CORD

1

.

.

2

l

3
4

DE2 1h 2 1
21
CL USDI CTCOURT
ERK
STRI
DITRI OFNE
S CT
VXDX

BY:

5

U M TED STA TES D

6

xp
uyy

T COURT

DI
STRI OF NEVADA
CT

7
8

9

J
AMESJ
EFFERSON KENNER,
Peii r
ttone,

1
0
.

vs
.
11
J
AMESBENEDETTI e al,
,t .
1
2
'
Res
ponde s
nt.
13

1
4

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

3: cv08- 00489ECR-l
lAM

0 RDER

/'

Thi i apeiinf rwrt fh b m c ruspzs a t o2 U. C. 2 4i wh c p tto e ,
s s t o o io a e s op t u n t 8 S. j 25 n ih ei n r a
t
r
i

1 s a e prs r i pr e ng pr s . Pe ii r hms fl t e docum en s s eki hi r ea e or
5 t t i one , s oc edi
o e
ttone
ied hr e
t e ng s el s ,

1 ale n i y,a a l ( Nos 40, 43.
6 tr atvel n ppea. ECF . 42, )
1
7

Thecou t s spe ii rt thi pe ii f wrtofhab scor i f l bre e n us t
r advie ttone ha s tton or i
ea pus s uly i f d.
,he

1 c t il r st m e isoft petton i due c zs . Shoul t cour deny t pe ii pe ii
8 our w l add es he r t he ii n
olr e
d he
t
he tton, ttoner

1 may s k r e fom t N i h Cic tCou tofAppe sa t t sc r is s isde son. To t
9
ee eviw r he nt r ui
r
al fer hi ou t s ue t cii
he

)

20 e e pe ii rs ekst s m e r i i t i t nt o i a he s eksi hi pe ii t co t ni s
xt nt ttone e
he a elef n he nsa m tons s e
n s tton, he ur de e
21 t e m otons
h
i .
22

A ddii l t c t eni pettone ' r ue tf r l s pe ng r s uton ofhi pe ii
tonaly, he our d es ii r s eq s or e em e ndi e ol i
s tton.

!

23 TheN i h C ic tCour ofAppea sha not tde de whe he adi ti t
nt r ui
t
l s ye ci d
t r s r c cour hast a hor t t gr nt
t he ut iy o a

24 bal di adecsonona ha ascor peii I r Roe 257F. 1077,1 80(t Ci. )
ipen ng
ii
be
pus tton. n e ,
3d
079- 9h r2001.
25 Ever c r tc r ofa al t atha acualydecdedt si s howe r ha hed t tdititc t
y icui ou t ppe s h
s t l
i hi s ue,
ve , s l ha src ours

26 do,i f c , s ss h dic e i r au hort Hal v SanFr s Su ri Cou t 201 U. Dit '
n a t pos es uc s r tona y t iy. l .
ancico pe or r , 0 S. s.

!

$

1 LEXI 3 0, 0W L 89004 at*2( D. , ach8 201 ( tngc s sfom t Fis,Se ond,
S 303 201
4,
N. CalM r , 0) cii a e r he rt c
2 Thid,Fit Si h,Sev t Te h a DititofColmbi Cicui CoursofAppe ) n e bai
r fh, xt
enh, nt nd src
u a r t
t
al.
l
3 san r f an i r er e pe s s ki c lt r lr vi w i mar dl dif r ntfom t sanda d
t da d or nca c atd ron ee ng ola e a e e s ke y f e e r he t r
4 a i t apr ti l t i eebe aus i a ce a edha sc puspe ii rr ques i pos ppled o e r a de a n
c ean nc r r t
bea or
ttone e
tng tconvi ton
ci
5 r i hasalea be n c ct d, nd t ,he i no l rpr s e i noc nt Ar on v M a 85 S.
elef
r dy e onvi e a hus
s onge e um d n e . ons . y,

6 Ct3,1 L.Ed. 6( 964) Gl v.
. 3
2d 1 ; ynn Donnel 470F. 95a ( s Ci.1 , ec tsdicei
ly,
2d 98 1 t r 972) n our' s rton
7 i gr ntng bai pen ng a de s on on a ha ms c us pe ii i t be ç r s ve y s r ngl '
n a i
l di
ci i
be om
tton s o
ç cied r pa i y.
exe
'

8 Che e v Unie St e 767F. 335,337( hCi.1 .
r k . td ats,
2d
7t r 985)

9

To obt n s h r if apeii rmus de tae:( )t tt cli riesa s t i
ai uc ele , ttone
t monsrt 1 ha he am as
ubsantal

1 que ton a t r i ahih pr abiiy ofs ce son t mert;an ()t ca e i e r r nay
0
si nd hee s g ob lt
uc s
he is d 2 he s s xtaodi r
11 i vi s i cic s a es I eRoe 257 F. a 1 0.Exc tonal icum s a sm a xi t
nvol ng pec al r um t nc . nr
,
3d t 08
ep i c r
t nce ye s and,

1 i t c tsdicrton, ra apeiine ' rl s onbaiwher ( )pettone ' he t i s i l
2 n he our' s ei warnt tto rs eea e
l e: 1 ii rs alh s erousy

1 dee i ai whie he i i arert Woo kv Donnel 470 F. 93,94 ( j Ci.1 ( r
3 trortng l s nc c aed, dcoc .
l
y,
2d
lt r 972) pe
1 czim)Jo t v M arh,227F. 5 532( dCi.1 ( te, , cu ng) ( t r i an
4 lra ; hnson . s
2d 28, 3r r 955) Hmsi J.con ni ;2) hee s
1 e ror nay dely i t pr esi ofapeii Gl 470 F. at98;a ( t peii ers
5 xta di r a n he oc sng
tton, ynn,
2d
nd 3) he tton '
1 s nt 'c w o d be com pl t d b or m e ni u cola e alr vi w c d be unde t n, Bo r v Ci
6 e e e ul
n
e e ef e a ngf l l t r e e oul
rake
ye . t
y

1 o l d 40 F.d96 ( t Ci.1 6 )
7 foran o, 2 2 6 5h r 9 8 .
l
8

I t s ca e a r r vi ng t pe ii a t m ovi pa r zt e c tconc ude t at ;
n hi s , ie e ewi he tton nd he
ng pe s h our
l s h

1 pe ii rf ist s
9
ttone a l o how t t m e isofhi c ai sar s s r ast i c t a hi h pr biiy ofhi
hat he r t
s l m e o t ong o ndi a e g oba lt
s
20 s ces . Addii ly,pettone f l t s
uc s
tona l
ii r ais o how t ate e i
h xc ptonalcic z s a es exi tt atr quie hi
r lm t nc
s h e r s

'

:

2 1 i m edi t r l m e pe ng dipos ton ofhi habe s pe ii
m
a e e e s ndi
s ii
s
m tton.

22

I I THEREFORE Ol El Dt a p t in rs i s o r la eo a p a (
TS
o c h t ei o e ' mot f r ee s r p e lECFNO . 0
t
on
S4 ,

23 42,43)aeDENI
r
ED.

2
4

DATED ti /3 d yo
hs
a f

, 01 .
2 1

25

2
6

? C,

/..-.
. .
.

.

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI JUDGE
CT
2