Dunn v. Palmer

Filing 14

ORDERED that the 5 petition for WHC is DENIED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the clerk shall ENTER JUDGMENT ACCORDINGLY. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that P is DENIED A CERTIFICATE OF APPEALABILITY. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 10/29/2009. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

Download PDF
OCT 2 S UN I ED STATES DI T R I T CO U R T T S C D IST R ICT O F N EV A D A W I LI M LYLE DUNN, LA Pe iine , tto r vs . J CK PALM ER,e aI, A t. Re ponde t. s ns ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) 3: 8- v- 574- C J V PC 0c0 RO RDER Thi a toni apeiim frawrtofh be scopuspu s a tt 28U.. .j 25 , s ci s ttt t l i aa r ru n o SC 2 4 by W ilar Dunn,a Nevada prs ner. The acton com esbef r t e Cour wih r s cctt ism ert . The li n io i oe h t t ep ot is C our wildeny t e petton. tl h ii 1 Fact and ProceduralBackground . s Peii ne wa co vitdahe aj r tili t eEi h hJ diilDititCour f rClr tto r s n c e r u . ra n h g t u ca src y t o ak C ount ofone countofr bber . Exhi i 2. The ti lcour f und pcttone t be ahabiualcrm i al y o y bt l ra to ii r o t in, and sent nce pettonert one hundr d f r y- i m ont si prson,w ih par l elgi iiy i sxt e d ii o e o t sx hn i t o e i b lt n i y m ont s. I . On appeal pettonerar ued t edit i tcour er ed by denyi g hi moton t dim is hd , ii g h s rc tr n s i oss bas d on t c s at ' f iure t colecta s rveilnce vi eot pe. 1 . The Ncvada Supr m e Cour f und e h t e s al o l u la da d e to tec ntntont bewiho tmei, darme peiine 'jdgme tofc nvcin.1 . h oei o t u rtan fl d tto rs u r n o ito d 26 The exhi iscied i t i or erilt e f r ' xhi i b t t n h s d r h o m T b t ,' ar t os fl d by r s ondent i ' e h e ie ep sn s ppor oft ei ans erand ar l cat d i t e r cor atdocket/10. u t hr w eo e nh e d / 1 Pettonerfl d a sat habeas cor uspetton en M ar h 23,2007. Exhi i 3. ii ie te p ii c bt 2 P ttone alge ( )tilc u s laldt pr c r te7- 1s r el nc vieoa d()tepr s c tr eii r l d 1 ra o n e fi o o u e h 1 u v ia e d n 2 h o eu o c e l 3 comm it d a Br d vi l ton wh n i f i d t pr s r e e i e c oft e s rv i a c v de . 1 . The te a y o ai e t al o e e v v d n e b u el n e i o d e l 4 s a e d s rc c ur de i d t e pe i n,a d o a pe l t e N c ad S pr m e Co r a lr e t e l w e t t it i t o t n e h tto n n p a , h v au e u t f- m d h o r l 5 cour ' de i l Exhi i 5. ts n a . bt 6 Pe ii nc m a l d a f de a ha e sco puspe ii n t t i Cour o Dc e be 29, tto r ie e r l b a r tto o h s t n c m r 2008 7 ( oc e /5) Rcpon e t ha ea s ee tepeiin(oc e #1) a dpeiin rha fldata es d k t/( s d ns v n w rd h tto d k t 0 , n tto e s i . e rv re 8 ( oc e /1 . d k t / 2) 9 l . Fe er lH abeasC or usStandards 1 da p 1 0 1 2 TheAntt rors a d Efbc ieDe t Pe at Ac (i EDPA' ,p ovi e t elga ie r im n l tv a h n ly t 4 A ' r d sh e l ) An a pl a i n f r a wrt of ha e s c r us o be al of a pe s n i p i to o c i b a op n h f ro n l1 s a d r f r t eCour ' c nsde a i n oft i ha e spe ii n: tn a d o h ts o i r to h s b a tto 1 3 14 l 5 l6 c sodypurua tt tl j dg e tofaStt c ur s al bega td ut s n o le u m n ae o t h lnot rn e wihr s e tt a ycam ta wasaj diae ontemeisi Stt c ur t ep c o n li h t du c td h rt n ae o t pr ce dn sunls t ea j diain oft ecan o e ig e s h du c to h liw () rs le i a d cso ta wa c ntay t , or iv le a 1 eutd n e iin h t s o rr o n ov d n un e s na l a pl a i nofce rye tbls e Fe e a lw , s t r i e r a o be p i to c la l sa ih d d r la a de e m n d by t c Supr m e Cour oft e Unied St t s or h c th t ae; 1 7 1 8 de e m i a i n oft e f c si l htoft e e i e c pr s n e i t e St t t r n to h at n i g h vd n e e e td n h ae cour pr eeedi g. to n () r s le i a de iin ta was basd on a unraona l 2 eutd n cso h t e n e s be 1 28U. . .j 254( ) 9 SC 2 d . 20 Th AEDPA t od fe a f de a ha e sc ur ' r l i r v c i g sa eprs ne e i iid e r l b a o ts o e n e i w r t t io r m l 2 1 a pl a i nsi or e t pr ve tf dc a h b a 'e ral'a d t e s r t a s at - eu tc n i tt s a c p i to n d r o c n e r l a e s r t i s n o n u e h t t e c r o v c im r c 22 gie ef c t t ee tnt sbl und rlw .'Belv Cone 53 U. .685 693 ( 002) A sat v n fe t o h x c posz c c a ' l . ,5S , 2 . te 23 c ur de i i n i c nta y t cea l e t b ihe Su r m e Cou tp e e e t wihi t e m c nig of28 o t c se s o r r o l ry s a ls d p e r rcdn, t n h an 24 U. . .j2 5 ,t tesat c u ta plc arl tatc nya it tegov r ig1w stfrhi gh S C 2 4 ti h t e o r p is ue h o rdcs h f enn a e o t n te 25 SuprmcCour')c ss'or'd tesaec ur c nfonsastoffcstataemaeily . e ts ae '' ii h tt o t o r t e a t h r tral f 26 iditn uiha l fo adc iinofgheSuprmeCourja dne eteesarve a ars ldilrnt n sig s be rm cso t c t n v rh ls ri s t eut f c k 2 1 fom (heSu r m cCo r'lpr c de t''Loc ye 1 An r d ,5 8 U. .63,7 ( 0 3)( uotng r t pe u ts e e n .' k r . d a e 3 S , . 320 q i 2 Wila sv Ta lr 529U. . 40 - 6( 000,a dctn Bel53 U.-a 6 4) lim ' yo , . S 362, 5 0 2 ) n iig l, 5 S t 9 . 3 A s a e c ur de ii n i a un e s n bl a plc ton ofcla l e t bl h d Supr m e t t o t c so s n r a o a e p i a i e ry sa i e s e 4 Cour pr c de tiift esaec ur ic tte t ec rec gov r ig lga prn il fom (heSupr me t e c n h t t o t d n i s h o r t e nn e l icp e r t i i e 5 Co r'ld cson butun e s na l a pi st a prncpet t ef cso t eprs ne ' ca c.' u ts e ii s r a o b y p i h t i il o h a t f h io rs s ' e ' 6 Lo k e , 8U. . t75( uoig Wilams 5 9U..a 41 ) Theu raon bl a plc tonca s cy r 53 S a q tn li , 2 S t 3 . n e s a e p iai lu e 7 'r quiest e s at cour deci i n t bem or t an i cor ector er oneous' t e sat cour ' ie r h t e t so o eh n r r '' h t e , ts 8 ap l ainofce ryesa the 1w mus beo jcieyune s na l.l .( u tn Wilams 5 9 pi to c lal tbi d a s t be tv l ra o be d q oig li , 2 9 U..a 409) Se aloRa ie v Ca to,365F.d75 (t Ci.2004 . S t . e s m rz . sr 3 5 9h r ) l0 l det r i i g whet era s at cour deci i n i cont ar t ,oran unr as nabl n em nn h te t so s ryo eo e 11 a plcaton of f der llw ,t i Cour I okst a st t e ur ' l s r as ned decii n. See ll fv. pii , e a a hs to o a e o ts a t e o so ' 1 Nunne a e ,5 lU..7 7,8 3-4( 9 1; umlev Maso,51 F.d 1 04,1 09 1 (t Ci. 2 m k r 0 S 9 0 0 1 9 ) Pl e . t 2 3 2 2 - 0 9h r 1 20 8 ( n b nc . 3 0 )e a ) 1 4 M or ove ,: d t r i a i n ofa f c ua i s e mad by a St t c ur s a l pr s m e e r e e m n to a a t ls u e a e o t h l be e u d 15 t be cor ect' and t epettonerts al have t e burden ofrc uti g t e pr s m pton ofcor ect es o r ,' h ii th l h b tn h e u i r ns 1 b ce ra dco vicnge ie c .'28U. . .j2254()1. 6 y la n n n i vd n e' SC e( ) 1 1 1 Di cusson 7 1. s i l8 1 9 A . G round O ne l h s f s g ound f rr l fpe ii ne a l ge t a hi Si t Am e dm e trghtt t e n i tt r r o e i tto r lc s h t s x h e n n i oh 20 e l c i e as it n eofc un e w a v ol t d w h n c un e f i d t pr s r e e i e ce Spe ik a l f- tv ss a c e o s l s i ae e o s l al o e e v vd n . cf l e y 21 pettonercont ndst a counself ied t obt i t e s r eil nce vi eot pef om t e 7-11 conveni nce ii e ht a l o an h u v la darh e 22 s or . te 23 l or e t pr v i er cieasitnc ofc uns l peii ne mus s ow ( )c u s l n d r o o e n fe tv ssa e o e, tto r t h 1 o n e 24 a t d dci inty i t a hi a t nl y m a e e r r s s rous t a h sa tonswer outi e t c s ope of c e tc e l , n h t s to c d ro s o e h t i c i e sd h c 25 pr fsinal c mpee ta ssa c a d()tedeiintpcfr a ccprj dic teoutomeote oe so ly o tn sitn e n 2 h fcc ro m n eu c d h c h 26 pr c e ig.Stikan r Wa higtn,466U. . 6 7-0(l ) Re adigtelrtp o go e dn rc l d . s n o S 668, 8 9 984 . g r n h is r n 3 l com m onl known ast eiefectvencs pr ng' - t e St i kl nd Cour expr ssy declned t ar iul t y h 6r i s o ' h rc a t el i o tc a e 2 s e ik gu de i e f ra t r e pe f r a c be on ge e a i e d te , ncudi g t e du y ofl yat , p c f i l s o to n y r o m n e y d n r lz d u i s i l n h t n o ly 3 t e d t t a oi c nfit ofi t r s , h dut t a v c t t e de e da t sc us ,a d t e d t t h u y o v d o le s n e e t t e y o d o a e h f n n ' a e n h u y o 4 c n m nia ew ih t e c i n ove t e c ur e oft epr s c ton. I . D e e s c uns lsd tc a e not o m c t t h le t r h o s h o e ui d fn e o e ' u is r 5 t b deic s c h u tv l ast giers t aS h c ls frj diile au to . re a s jgly o e ln d o x a siey o v ie o ' e kito u ca v lain . b c u e an c . 6 s ch s tofr l swoul i t r er wih t e constt tonaly pr t ct d i de e dence ofcouns land ue ue d nef c t h iu i l o e e n p n e 7 r s rctt e w i e l tt de couns lmus ha e i maki g t ctcaldecii ns.' I . e t i h d a iu e tvn n ai so ' d 8 TheSti kl nd Cour i sruct d t a r viw ofan ator ey' pe f nnance mustbe rc a tn t e h t e e t n s ro 9 ihi hl def re tal' and m us adoptcouns lsper pectvc att etm e oft e chale ged conduct i g y c n i r' t e' s i hi h ln ,n 10 or ert avoi t e 'dit r i g efect ofhi dsght' f .at689. A r vi w i g cour m us li dul e a do d h i so tn r s n i .' # ee n t t tn g 11 stong pr s m pton t atcounselsconductf lsw ihi t eF i e r nge ofr as nabl pr f s i nal r cu i h ' al t n h d a e o e o e so 1 assa cc..(n jtc( eiincjmus ov rometep eumpt ntat..tech l ng da ton 2 sitn . a d h p tto r t cc h r s i h . h al e ci o e 1 mihtb c nsde e s und til ta c y.'1 .( iai nomit d) 3 g e o i rd o ra sr t g ' d ct to te . 1 4 Consr i g t e Si t Am e dm e tt gu r nt enote e tve c u s l rs , utr t c tun h x h n n o aa e s c i o n e pe e b a h r 15 a f i pr ceedi g wih a r la l out om e,t eSti kl nd Cour concl de t atdem ons r tng t at ar o n t ei b e c h rc a t u dh ta i h l c uns lel lw a o jciesan adofra o a ln s aon iis fkintt warn af digof 6 o e flbeo n be tv t d r e s n be c s l e s n u t e o ra t m n 17 i efectve asss ance. l or ert s tsy Sti kl nd' second pr ng,t e def ndantmus s ow t att e nr i it n d o a if r c a s o h e th hh 1 atr e ' s b- a pcf nna c p eudie t ed fn e 1 .a 69192.Thets i whch rteei a 8 to n ys u p r ro n e rj c d h ee s . d t e ts te h r s 1 r a ona l pr ba ii t a , f r t e a t r e ' c a l n e c nd c ,t e r s l o t epr c e i g i 9 e s b e o b l y h t but o h to n y s h le g d o u t h e u t f h o c d n n t 2 qu si n woul ha e b c dif r nt / .a 691 9 . The Cou 'def e r a ona l pr ba iiy as( 0 e to d v e n fc e . # t - 4 l m d e s b e o b lt t ; a 21 pr b biiy s fi i ntt u de z i e c nfde c i t e out om e. J .a 6 4. o a l u lc e o n rn n o t n en h e ' J t9 ' 22 l e f c i e as it n eofc uns l n fe tv ss a c o e unde Sti kl nd r quiesa s ow i g ofde c e t r rc a e r hn f in 23 pefnna cco c unslrsligi prj die i ihpef r a c bengme s rda ans an ro n f o e eut t eu c , t ro m n e i nl w au e g i t 24 tbe tvcsa dadofr aona lnes' inde prval gpr fsina noms'' o jci tn r e s be s, u r e ii o e so l r .'Rompil v n la . 25 Be r .5 5U. . 74,380( 00 )(uoainsomitd .l tesaec ur ha a va yrjctda ad 4 S 3 2 5 q tto te ) f h tt o t s h d ee e n 26 i efeetve asssance cl i ,a f der lhabeascour m ay onl gr ntrelefi t atdecii n wascontar nr i it am ea t ya i fh so ry 4 1 t ,oran unr as na l applcaton oft eSti kl nd s andar . See Yar or ugh v.Genty,540 U. .1, o e o be ii h rc a t d bo r S 2 5 ( 003 .The ei asr ngpr s m p i nt a c un elsco d c f l wihi t ewier ng of 2) r s to c u to h t o s ' n u t al t n h d a e s 3 r a ona l pr f s i na as it nc . l . e s b e o e so l ss a e d 4 Pettcnerr ied gr und one i hi st t habeascol uspetton. The st t dit i t ii as o n s ae p ii a e s rc 5 c ur rjcedtecai ,a dona pe lteNe a aSup e eCour satdt eflo igi tndigta o t ee t h l m n p a h vd rm t t e h olw n n i n h t 6 t t t ilc ur di note ri de yi g t e ca m : h ra o t d r n n n h li 7 Appel nt c a m e t a hi c u ue was i e l c i e f r f ii g t l a l i d h t s o rs l n fk tv o a ln o ob an vi eo e i e c fom t e s e e oft e r bb r a d pr s n i t t e ti d vd n e r h c n h o ey n ee t t o h 8 9 1 0 1l 12 j r .Spe iial, ppclntcli c ta hsc uns laldt o ti vie uy cfc l a l am d h t i o e fi o b an d o y a e fom a c m e a t a poi t d a t ed o of heesa ls m e tt a w o l ha e r a r h t n e t h o r t t b ih n h t u d v de onsr t d a pe l n ' i noc nc by s ow i g t a he di notus f r e m t a e p la ts n e e h n ht d e oc durn t e c i e. He a s re t a t e vi e e i e c s oul ha e be n i g h rm s e td h t h d o vd n e h d v e pr s nt dat h pr l i al h a i g m /tont dim is ti l a d on a pe l c e c t e e i n y e rn , i o s s , ra , n m p a. H e f rhe cl i e t a hi c uns l f ie t pr s nt a e pe t wine s u t r am d h t s o e a l d o e e n x r t s concer i g t evi co evi encet r butt eSt t ' expcr w ines t s i ony. nn h d d o e h ae s t t s e tm Appelantf ied t de onsr t t athi couns lsperonnance was l a l o m ta c h s e' f descint Couns l asnotappoi t d t r pr s ntappelantuntl ar h 18, e. ew ne o e ee l iM c 2005,e htdaysalerhew asar es ed att e s ene ort e aleged r bbel . g t rt hc hl o' y The owneroft ebusnes t si cd t att e vi eot pe f om t es r eil nce h i s e tf h h d a r h u v la 13 l 4 l5 s se i r c r e ove e e ytr et f urda s Th s t evde e i e c q tm s e o d d r v r h e o o y . u ,h i o v d n e l 6 1 7 18 ott er bber no I ngerexit d att etm e t atcounselbegan r pr s ntng ho yo se hi h e ce i a pe lnt W e f rhe n t t a on diec a pe l t i c ur he d t a t e pl . a ut r o e h t r t p a,hs o t l h t h dit i t c l r di n t e r i de y n h1 moton t dir is b s d o t e s r c cu t d o r n n i g s i o sn s a e n h St t ' f i r t ga he t evi e e i e c be a s a pe l n f ie t s ow a e s a l e o t r h d o v d n c c u e p la t a l d o h u t att e vi eot pe cont i ed mat ral excul at r i f r aton ort att e hhda an ei , p o y n om i hh ofi c s a t d i b d f ih by notc l c i g i. Furhe ,t e St t di n t fc r c e n a a t o l tn t e t r h ae d o pr s ntany exper t s i ony durng ti land appclantf iedt i entf t e ee t e tm i ra l a l o d iy h e pe t a pel n s oul ha e c l d t s pp r hi t e r of d f ns . x r p l t h d v al o u o t s h o y a e ce e The e or , he diti tc u tdi notc ri de yng t i c a m . r f e t src o r d r n n i h s li 1 9 2 Exhbi5(ootot omitd) TheNe a aSuprmcCour' deemiaini n ta obe tvey 0 i t f n e te . vd e ts tr n to s o n jci l 21 un ea on bl a pl a i n ofSti kl nd. Pe ii n rha nots ow n t a t i lc u s l t d dei i n l i r s a e p i to c rc a tto e s h h t ra o n e ac e tc e ty n 22 a y w a , s a p ar t a t evi e t pe wa a r a y d sr y d prort co ns lsi v l e e ti t c n y a t p e s h t h d oa s le d c to c i o u c ' n o v m n n h 2 c s . Ev n i co n e h d t ke s e st r c v rt e vi e t pe t e s or ownc s a e t a t e t pe i 3 a e e f u s l a a n tp o e o e h d o a ,h t e r t td h t h a s 24 r c r e ove e e y s ve a da s Ast e c i no i dia i n t a ti lc un e wa i e l c i e t e e o d d r v r e rl y . h r s n c to h t ra o s l s n fk tv , h 25 Cour w i de y g oun o e. t l n r dn l 26 B .G round Two 5 1 l h s s c nd gr un f rr l fpe ii n rc nt n st a hi Fi h Am e dm e trgh t n i eo o d o e i tto e o e d h t s t e t n n i to 2 duc pr ces wasvi l t d when t e pr s cut rf ied t dicl s excul at l ormat lalevi ence. os o ae h o e o al o s o e p o' y ei d 3 Pettonerar ues t att c s at com m it d aBr dy vi l ton when i f ied t dicl seorpr se z t e ii g h h te te a oai t al o s o e ne h 4 s r eil nce vi eot pe. u v la da 5 7 Peiine rie t cisa tcam i hi a pe lofhijdg e ta d sne ce The tto r asd h n tn li n s p a s u m n n e tn . Dunn cont ndst att edit itcour er ed by denyi g hi m otont e h h s rc tr ns io dim is b s d on t e St t ' f i r t c l c a s r ei a c vi eo a e s s ae h a e s al e o o l t u v l n e d t p . u e l Du n a k g d t a t evi e t pcw oul ha e s ow n t a hedi n tus f r e n l e h th d oa dvh ht d o e oc on t e vi tm i an ate ptt es a e,butr t ert a he wasa t c ed by a h ci n tm o c p ah h t ta k gr up of m e w hi h iw l ded t e vi tm . W e concl de t at Dunn' o n c lu h ci uh s cont nton l cksm ert ei a i. re edy f rt eSt t ' f iur t gat e evi ence whet ert e evi ence was m o h a es al e o h r d hh d m a e i la d t e f i r t ga ht t e e i e c wast e r s l ofa ba f ih t ra n h al e o t r h v d n e u h e ut d at 6 Nc ad Su rmeCo r rjce teisa tcli ,saig: v a pe u t ee td h n tn am ttn 8 9 10 1 1 1 2 13 l4 I Danil v St t,En1 l 4Ne . , - 8, P. d 111 1l n es . a e f : 1 v 261 267 6 956 2 ,5 ( 998))we h l t a dim is lofe i i a c a g s ma be a a ai be 1. ed h t s sa rm n l h r e y n vll a atmptt prjdietedce da tsc s . tc o eu c h fn n ' ae l t e i s a tc s ,t e diti tc u tde i d t e moto t dir i s n h n t n a e h s rc o r n e h i n o sn s , f di g t at Dunn f ied t s ow t att e vi eot pe cont i ed m at ral mnh al o h hh da an ei , e c l a or i f r a i n or t a t e ofi e s a t d i b d f ih b n t x u p t y n o m to h t h fc r c e n a a t y o colectng i. W e concl de t att e dit i tcour di notel i s f di g. li t u h h s rc td 'n o m n r 15 l Exhi2.TheNev daSu rmeCour' detrniato wa notobecieyu raona l a pl ain 6 bt a pc ts er n in s j tv l n e s be p i to c 17 ofUnied St t s Supre e Cour prccedent t ae m t . . ya S ,7 1 h td a e e to n 18 J Brad.v v M ar lnd,373U. .83 8 ( 963)t eUnie St t sSupr m eCour f u d n 1 t ata sat ' s ppr sson ofevi ence,whet eri t ntonalori adver ent,wilvi lt due pr ces 9h t es u c i d h ne i n t l oa e os 2 whe t a e i e ce i f vor b e ormat ra t t e de e s . M o eo e , he s ppr s i n ofe i e ce 0 n h t vd n s a a l e il o h fn e r v r t u e so vd n 21 mus ha cprj diedt epr c e ig.Stiklrv Gr e e 527U. . 2818 ( 999 .To t v eu c h o e dn rc e . e n , S 263, -2 1 ) 22 de c ui e w he hc e i c cei m a cra a c ur m us d c de whe he i he e i a r as nab epr b b t tn n t r v d n s t il o t t e i t r r s e o l o a ly t i 23 t a ,ha t e e i e ce b e dicos d t t e de e s ,t e r s l oft c p oce di g wcul ha e be n h t d h vd n e n s l e o h fn e l e u t h r c n l dv e 24 difrn. Unie Sttsr Ba ly 47 U..66 ,68 ( 985.Se aloJ c s nv Br wn,51 F.d fee t' td ae . ge 3 S 7 2 1 ) e s a k o . o ' 33 25 1 57,1 71( t Ci.2 0 ) Pe ii n rha nots own t a t es r eia c vi e tpec n an d 0 0 9 h r 0 8 . tto e s h h t h u v l n e d o a o t ie l 26 evi ence t atw asf vor bl orm at ralt t edef nse. Pettonerhasnotdem onsr t d t att er i a d h a ae ei o h e ii tae h h e s 6 l r a o a l pr ba i t t a ha t evi eo a e b e dic os d, ha t er s l oft epr ce d ng w o l e s n be o bl y h t d h d t p e n s l e t t h e u t h o e i i ud 2 ha e be n dif r nt v e fe c . 3 Furt e m or ,t e f iur t pr serv evi ence t ati pot ntaly exc l at r can vi l t h r e h al e o e e d h s e il up o y oae 4 a def ndantsdue pr ces rght i t e f iur w asm otvat d by bad f ih. Ari ona v.Youngbl od, e ' o s i s f h al e ie at z o 5 488 U. .51 58 ( 988 ( ol igG nes ac i ia d fn a tca s ow ba fih ont epa toft e S , l ) h dn t l s rm n l e e d n n h d at hrh 6 polcc,f iur t pr se vepot ntaly us f levi e ce doesnotconstt t a deni lofdue proccs of i al e o e r e i l eu d n iu e a s 7 1w' . Furhe mor ,aba f i f i r t c lec potntal e c l a o y e i e c as c namo ntt a' ) tr e d at al e o o l t e ily x up t r vd n e lo a hu uo 8 ad epr c s vi lton.M ilrv V s u z 868F.d 11 6,11 ( t Ci.l ) Se alo Unie u o e s oai le . a q e , 2 l 20 9 h r 989 . e s td 9 St tsv M ari e - ari e ,3 9 F.d 1 1 6- 7 ( t Ci.2 0 ) The ei no idia in t a t e a e . tn z M tn z 6 3 076, 08 8 9 h r 0 4 . r s n c to h t h 10 s at ,i f ii g t eolectorpr se ve evi ence oft e vi eot pe prort i bei g r cor ed over act d t e n a ln o l er d hda i ot n e d ,e 11 i bad f ih. The N evada Supr m eCour ' det rm i aton t att e i s antcl i w aswihoutm erti n at c ts e n i h h n t am t is 1 notoj cieyune s n bl. 2 be tv l ra o a c l 3 The Cour wildeny gr und t o. tl o w 1 I . Certfcat ofA ppeal biiy 4V ii e a lt 15 l or ert pr cee w ih an appealf om t i cour ,pettonerm us r cei e a cerii at nd oodt r hs t ii te v ttc e 1 ofa pe lblt.28U. . .j225 ()1.Ge eal, peiin rmus ma e: s bsanils owigof 6 p aa iiy SC 3 c() n r l a tto e y t k u t ta h n a l7 t c deni lofa cons iutonalrght't war anta cer ii at ofappcalbiiy. / . The Supr m e Cour h a tt i i 'o r tfc e a lt # e t 1 h sh l ta apeiine d us de on taeta ra on blj rsswoul 5ndt edsrc c ur' 8 a ed h t tto rs t m srt h t e s a e u it m d h itit o ts 1 as e s e toft e c ns iutona cli sde a a l orwr ng. Sl c v M c ani l 529 U . . 9 ssm n h o tt i l a m b t b e o ' a k ' D e, ' . S 473, 4 48 20 ( 00 ) 2 0. 21 The Supr m e Cour f rheril m i at d t e st ndar f ris ance ofa certfcat of e t u t lu n e h a d o s u ii e 2 a pe lbit i M llrElv Coc r l,537U. . 2 ( 00 ) TheCou tsae i ta c s : 2 p aa l y n 'e - . k e l i l S 32 2 3 . r t td n h t a e 2 3 W edo not e uiepe ii ne t p ovc be or t eis a c ofaCOA , h t r q r tto r o r , f e h s u n e ta 2 4 25 26 s mej rsswoul grnttepeiinfrha e sc r us l de d,acli o u it d a h tto o b a o p . n e am ca bede aa l c e to g c eyjrs ofe s nmih a re, le te n b tbe v n h u h v r u it ra o g t ge at rh C O A hasbeen gr nt d and t e cas hasr cei ed f l consder ton,t at ae h e e v ul i ai h pefne wi n t e ai Aswesatdi Sl c ,'w j er adsrc cou t tto r l o pr v l l : t e n a k ' h e itit r g ha rjce tec nsiutona carsontemeis tes owigr q ic s ee td h o tt l l lin h rt,h h n c urd t s tsyj2 53()i sr ihto vad:Th peiin rmus de onsrt o aif 2 c s tag fn r e tto e t m tae ta raona l jrsswoul f d tedititc utsas sme tofte h t e s be uit d m h src o r' ses n h 7 l cons iutonalcl i sdebat bl orwr ng.' tt i am ae o' 2 l .a 1 40 ( uotngSl c ,5 9 U. .a 48 ) d t 0 q i ak 2 S t 4. 3 The Cour hasconsder d t ei s esr i e by pettoncr,wih r s ec t whet ert ey t i e h s u as d ii t ep t o hh 4 s ts y t e s a da d f ris a c oface tfc t o a pe l a d t e Cou tdc e mi e t a n ne m e t a if h t n r o s u n e rii a e f p a , n h r tr n s h t o e 5 t a s a da d. A c or i gl , he Cour w i de y pet i n r ac riia e ofa pe l b lt . h t tn r c dn y t tl n l i o e e tfc t t p a a iiy 6 8 I I THEREFORE ORDERED ta tepeiinfrwrtofha e sc r us( oc e TS h th tto o i b a op d k t I I FU R TH E R O R D ER ED t att e c e k s alENTER JU D G M EN T TS h h lr h l 7 #5)i DENI D . s E 9 A C C O R D I G LY . N 10 I IS FURTH E R O R D ER E D t atpettone i DENI D A CERTI ICA TE O F T h ii r s E F 11 APPEALABI I Y . LT 1 2 1 3 l4 Dt tsl dyfcbr20. adh .j aoOte,09 ei o U N I ED STAT T D I TR I T JUDG E SC 1 5 l6 l7 18 l9 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 8

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?