Dunn v. Palmer

Filing 14

ORDERED that the 5 petition for WHC is DENIED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the clerk shall ENTER JUDGMENT ACCORDINGLY. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that P is DENIED A CERTIFICATE OF APPEALABILITY. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 10/29/2009. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

OCT 2 S

UN I ED STATES DI T R I T CO U R T T S C
D IST R ICT O F N EV A D A

W I LI M LYLE DUNN, LA Pe iine , tto r
vs .

J CK PALM ER,e aI, A t. Re ponde t. s ns

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

3: 8- v- 574- C J V PC 0c0 RO RDER

Thi a toni apeiim frawrtofh be scopuspu s a tt 28U.. .j 25 , s ci s ttt t l i aa r ru n o SC 2 4 by
W ilar Dunn,a Nevada prs ner. The acton com esbef r t e Cour wih r s cctt ism ert . The li n io i oe h t t ep ot is
C our wildeny t e petton. tl h ii 1 Fact and ProceduralBackground . s

Peii ne wa co vitdahe aj r tili t eEi h hJ diilDititCour f rClr tto r s n c e r u . ra n h g t u ca src y t o ak
C ount ofone countofr bber . Exhi i 2. The ti lcour f und pcttone t be ahabiualcrm i al y o y bt l ra to ii r o t in, and sent nce pettonert one hundr d f r y- i m ont si prson,w ih par l elgi iiy i sxt e d ii o e o t sx hn i t o e i b lt n i y m ont s. I . On appeal pettonerar ued t edit i tcour er ed by denyi g hi moton t dim is hd , ii g h s rc tr n s i oss bas d on t c s at ' f iure t colecta s rveilnce vi eot pe. 1 . The Ncvada Supr m e Cour f und e h t e s al o l u la da d e to

tec ntntont bewiho tmei, darme peiine 'jdgme tofc nvcin.1 . h oei o t u rtan fl d tto rs u r n o ito d
26 The exhi iscied i t i or erilt e f r ' xhi i b t t n h s d r h o m T b t ,' ar t os fl d by r s ondent i ' e h e ie ep sn s ppor oft ei ans erand ar l cat d i t e r cor atdocket/10. u t hr w eo e nh e d /

1

Pettonerfl d a sat habeas cor uspetton en M ar h 23,2007. Exhi i 3. ii ie te p ii c bt

2 P ttone alge ( )tilc u s laldt pr c r te7- 1s r el nc vieoa d()tepr s c tr eii r l d 1 ra o n e fi o o u e h 1 u v ia e d n 2 h o eu o c e l
3 comm it d a Br d vi l ton wh n i f i d t pr s r e e i e c oft e s rv i a c v de . 1 . The te a y o ai e t al o e e v v d n e b u el n e i o d e l 4 s a e d s rc c ur de i d t e pe iî n,a d o a pe l t e N c ad S pr m e Co r a lr e t e l w e t t it i t o t n e h tto n n p a , h v au e u t f- m d h o r l
5 cour ' de i l Exhi i 5. ts n a . bt 6 Pe ii nc m a l d a f de a ha e sco puspe ii n t t i Cour o Dc e be 29, tto r ie e r l b a r tto o h s t n c m r 2008

7 ( oc e /5) Rcpon e t ha ea s ee tepeiin(oc e #1) a dpeiin rha fldata es d k t/( s d ns v n w rd h tto d k t 0 , n tto e s i . e rv re
8 ( oc e /1 . d k t / 2)
9 l . Fe er lH abeasC or usStandards 1 da p

1 0
1 2

TheAntt rors a d Efbc ieDe t Pe at Ac (i EDPA' ,p ovi e t elga ie r im n l tv a h n ly t 4 A ' r d sh e l )
An a pl a i n f r a wrt of ha e s c r us o be al of a pe s n i p i to o c i b a op n h f ro n

l1 s a d r f r t eCour ' c nsde a i n oft i ha e spe ii n: tn a d o h ts o i r to h s b a tto

1 3
14

l 5
l6

c sodypurua tt tl j dg e tofaStt c ur s al bega td ut s n o le u m n ae o t h lnot rn e wihr s e tt a ycam ta wasaj diae ontemeisi Stt c ur t ep c o n li h t du c td h rt n ae o t pr ce dn sunls t ea j diain oft ecan o e ig e s h du c to h liw () rs le i a d cso ta wa c ntay t , or iv le a 1 eutd n e iin h t s o rr o n ov d n
un e s na l a pl a i nofce rye tbls e Fe e a lw , s t r i e r a o be p i to c la l sa ih d d r la a de e m n d
by t c Supr m e Cour oft e Unied St t s or h c th t ae;

1 7
1 8

de e m i a i n oft e f c si l htoft e e i e c pr s n e i t e St t t r n to h at n i g h vd n e e e td n h ae cour pr eeedi g. to n

() r s le i a de iin ta was basd on a unraona l 2 eutd n cso h t e n e s be

1 28U. . .j 254( ) 9 SC 2 d .
20 Th AEDPA t od fe a f de a ha e sc ur ' r l i r v c i g sa eprs ne e i iid e r l b a o ts o e n e i w r t t io r m l 2 1 a pl a i nsi or e t pr ve tf dc a h b a 'e ral'a d t e s r t a s at - eu tc n i tt s a c p i to n d r o c n e r l a e s r t i s n o n u e h t t e c r o v c im r c

22 gie ef c t t ee tnt sbl und rlw .'Belv Cone 53 U. .685 693 ( 002) A sat v n fe t o h x c posz c c a ' l . ,5S , 2 . te
23 c ur de i i n i c nta y t cea l e t b ihe Su r m e Cou tp e e e t wihi t e m c nig of28 o t c se s o r r o l ry s a ls d p e r rcdn, t n h an

24 U. . .j2 5 ,tû tesat c u ta plc arl tatc nya it tegov r ig1w stfrhi gh S C 2 4 ti h t e o r p is ue h o rdcs h f enn a e o t n te 25 SuprmcCour')c ss'or'd tesaec ur c nfonsastoffcstataemaeily . e ts ae '' ii h tt o t o r t e a t h r tral f 26 iditn uiha l fo adc iinofgheSuprmeCourja dne eteesarve a ars ldilrnt n sig s be rm cso t c t n v rh ls ri s t eut f c k
2

1 fom (heSu r m cCo r'lpr c de t''Loc ye 1 An r d ,5 8 U. .63,7 ( 0 3)( uotng r t pe u ts e e n .' k r . d a e 3 S , . 320 q i

2 Wila sv Ta lr 529U. . 40 - 6( 000,a dctn Bel53 U.-a 6 4) lim ' yo , . S 362, 5 0 2 ) n iig l, 5 S t 9 .
3 A s a e c ur de ii n i a un e s n bl a plc ton ofcla l e t bl h d Supr m e t t o t c so s n r a o a e p i a i e ry sa i e s e

4 Cour pr c de tiift esaec ur ic tte t ec rec gov r ig lga prn il fom (heSupr me t e c n ç h t t o t d n i s h o r t e nn e l icp e r t i i e 5 Co r'ld cson butun e s na l a pi st a prncpet t ef cso t eprs ne ' ca c.' u ts e ii s r a o b y p i h t i il o h a t f h io rs s ' e '

6 Lo k e , 8U. . t75( uoig Wilams 5 9U..a 41 ) Theu raon bl a plc tonca s cy r 53 S a q tn li , 2 S t 3 . n e s a e p iai lu e
7 'r quiest e s at cour deci i n t bem or t an i cor ector er oneous' t e sat cour ' ie r h t e t so o eh n r r '' h t e , ts

8 ap l ainofce ryesa the 1w mus beo jcieyune s na l.l .( u tn Wilams 5 9 pi to c lal tbi d a s t be tv l ra o be d q oig li , 2 9 U..a 409) Se aloRa ie v Ca to,365F.d75 (t Ci.2004 . S t . e s m rz . sr 3 5 9h r )
l0 l det r i i g whet era s at cour deci i n i cont ar t ,oran unr as nabl n em nn h te t so s ryo eo e 11 a plcaton of f der llw ,t i Cour I okst a st t e ur ' l s r as ned decii n. See ll fv. pii , e a a hs to o a e o ts a t e o so 'î

1 Nunne a e ,5 lU..7 7,8 3-4( 9 1; umlev Maso,51 F.d 1 04,1 09 1 (t Ci. 2 m k r 0 S 9 0 0 1 9 ) Pl e . t 2 3 2 2 - 0 9h r
1 20 8 ( n b nc . 3 0 )e a )
1 4 M or ove ,: d t r i a i n ofa f c ua i s e mad by a St t c ur s a l pr s m e e r û e e m n to a a t ls u e a e o t h l be e u d
15 t be cor ect' and t epettonerts al have t e burden ofrc uti g t e pr s m pton ofcor ect es o r ,' h ii th l h b tn h e u i r ns

1 b ce ra dco vicnge ie c .'28U. . .j2254()1. 6 y la n n n i vd n e' SC e( )
1 1 1 Di cusson 7 1. s i

l8 1 9

A . G round O ne l h s f s g ound f rr l fpe ii ne a l ge t a hi Si t Am e dm e trghtt t e n i tt r r o e i tto r lc s h t s x h e n n i oh

20 e l c i e as it n eofc un e w a v ol t d w h n c un e f i d t pr s r e e i e ce Spe ik a l f- tv ss a c e o s l s i ae e o s l al o e e v vd n . cf l e y
21 pettonercont ndst a counself ied t obt i t e s r eil nce vi eot pef om t e 7-11 conveni nce ii e ht a l o an h u v la darh e
22 s or . te

23

l or e t pr v i er cieasitnc ofc uns l peii ne mus s ow ( )c u s l n d r o o e n fe tv ssa e o e, tto r t h 1 o n e

24 a t d dci inty i t a hi a t nl y m a e e r r s s rous t a h sa tonswer outi e t c s ope of c e tc e l , n h t s to c d ro s o e ï h t i c i e sd h c

25 pr fsinal c mpee ta ssa c a d()tedeiintpcfr a ccprj dic teoutomeoîte oe so ly o tn sitn e n 2 h fcc ro m n eu c d h c h 26 pr c e ig.Stikan r Wa higtn,466U. . 6 7-0(l ) Re adigtelrtp o go e dn rc l d . s n o S 668, 8 9 984 . g r n h is r n
3

l com m onl known ast eiefectvencs pr ng' - t e St i kl nd Cour expr ssy declned t ar iul t y h 6r i s o ' h rc a t el i o tc a e

2 s e ik gu de i e f ra t r e pe f r a c be on ge e a i e d te , ncudi g t e du y ofl yat , p c f i l s o to n y r o m n e y d n r lz d u i s i l n h t n o ly 3 t e d t t a oi c nfit ofi t r s , h dut t a v c t t e de e da t sc us ,a d t e d t t h u y o v d o le s n e e t t e y o d o a e h f n n ' a e n h u y o 4 c n m nia ew ih t e c i n ove t e c ur e oft epr s c ton. I . D e e s c uns lsd tc a e not o m c t t h le t r h o s h o e ui d fn e o e ' u is r

5 t b deic s c h u tv l ast giers t aS h c ls frj diile au to . re a s jgly o e ln d o x a siey o v ie o ' e kito u ca v lain . b c u e an c .
6 s ch s tofr l swoul i t r er wih t e constt tonaly pr t ct d i de e dence ofcouns land ue ue d nef c t h iu i l o e e n p n e 7 r s rctt e w i e l tt de couns lmus ha e i maki g t ctcaldecii ns.' I . e t i h d a iu e tvn n ai so ' d 8 TheSti kl nd Cour i sruct d t a r viw ofan ator ey' pe f nnance mustbe rc a tn t e h t e e t n s ro

9 ihi hl def re tal' and m us adoptcouns lsper pectvc att etm e oft e chale ged conduct i ç g y c n i r' t e' s i hi h ln ,n 10 or ert avoi t e 'dit r i g efect ofhi dsght' f .at689. A r vi w i g cour m us li dul e a do d h i so tn r s n i .' # ee n t t tn g 11 stong pr s m pton t atcounselsconductf lsw ihi t eF i e r nge ofr as nabl pr f s i nal r cu i h ' al t n h d a e o e o e so

1 assa cc..(n jtc( eiincjmus ov rometep eumpt ntat..tech l ng da ton 2 sitn . a d h p tto r t cc h r s i h . h al e ci o e
1 mihtb c nsde e s und til ta c y.'1 .( iai nomit d) 3 g e o i rd o ra sr t g ' d ct to te .
1 4 Consr i g t e Si t Am e dm e tt gu r nt enote e tve c u s l rs , utr t c tun h x h n n o aa e s c i o n e pe e b a h r
15 a f i pr ceedi g wih a r la l out om e,t eSti kl nd Cour concl de t atdem ons r tng t at ar o n t ei b e c h rc a t u dh ta i h

l c uns lel lw a o jciesan adofra o a ln s aon iis fkintt warn af digof 6 o e flbeo n be tv t d r e s n be c s l e s n u t e o ra t m n
17 i efectve asss ance. l or ert s tsy Sti kl nd' second pr ng,t e def ndantmus s ow t att e nr i it n d o a if r c a s o h e th hh

1 atr e ' s b- a pcf nna c p eudie t ed fn e 1 .a 69192.Thets i whch rteei a 8 to n ys u p r ro n e rj c d h ee s . d t e ts te h r s
1 r a ona l pr ba ii t a , f r t e a t r e ' c a l n e c nd c ,t e r s l o t epr c e i g i 9 e s b e o b l y h t but o h to n y s h le g d o u t h e u t f h o c d n n t 2 qu si n woul ha e b c dif r nt / .a 691 9 . The Cou 'def e r a ona l pr ba iiy as( 0 e to d v e n fc e . # t - 4 l m d e s b e o b lt t ; a 21 pr b biiy s fi i ntt u de z i e c nfde c i t e out om e. J .a 6 4. o a l u lc e o n rn n o t n en h e ' J t9 ' 22 l e f c i e as it n eofc uns l n fe tv ss a c o e unde Sti kl nd r quiesa s ow i g ofde c e t r rc a e r hn f in

23 pefnna cco c unslrsligi prj die i ihpef r a c bengme s rda ans an ro n f o e eut t eu c ,û t ro m n e i nl w au e g i t

24 tbe tvcsa dadofr aona lnes' inde prval gpr fsina noms'' o jci tn r e s be s, u r e ii o e so l r .'Rompil v n la . 25 Be r .5 5U. . 74,380( 00 )(uoainsomitd .l tesaec ur ha a va yrjctda ad 4 S 3 2 5 q tto te ) f h tt o t s h d ee e n
26 i efeetve asssance cl i ,a f der lhabeascour m ay onl gr ntrelefi t atdecii n wascontar nr i it am ea t ya i fh so ry

4

1 t ,oran unr as na l applcaton oft eSti kl nd s andar . See Yar or ugh v.Genty,540 U. .1, o e o be ii h rc a t d bo r S

2 5 ( 003 .The ei asr ngpr s m p i nt a c un elsco d c f l wihi t ewier ng of 2) r s to c u to h t o s ' n u t al t n h d a e s
3 r a ona l pr f s i na as it nc . l . e s b e o e so l ss a e d 4 Pettcnerr ied gr und one i hi st t habeascol uspetton. The st t dit i t ii as o n s ae p ii a e s rc

5 c ur rjcedtecai ,a dona pe lteNe a aSup e eCour satdt eflo igi tndigta o t ee t h l m n p a h vd rm t t e h olw n n i n h t
6 t t t ilc ur di note ri de yi g t e ca m : h ra o t d r n n n h li 7 Appel nt c a m e t a hi c u ue was i e l c i e f r f ii g t l a l i d h t s o rs l n fk tv o a ln o ob an vi eo e i e c fom t e s e e oft e r bb r a d pr s n i t t e ti d vd n e r h c n h o ey n ee t t o h

8
9 1 0
1l
12

j r .Spe iial, ppclntcli c ta hsc uns laldt o ti vie uy cfc l a l am d h t i o e fi o b an d o y a e

fom a c m e a t a poi t d a t ed o of heesa ls m e tt a w o l ha e r a r h t n e t h o r t t b ih n h t u d v de onsr t d a pe l n ' i noc nc by s ow i g t a he di notus f r e m t a e p la ts n e e h n ht d e oc durn t e c i e. He a s re t a t e vi e e i e c s oul ha e be n i g h rm s e td h t h d o vd n e h d v e pr s nt dat h pr l i al h a i g m /tont dim is ti l a d on a pe l c e c t e e i n y e rn , i o s s , ra , n m p a. H e f rhe cl i e t a hi c uns l f ie t pr s nt a e pe t wine s u t r am d h t s o e a l d o e e n x r t s concer i g t evi co evi encet r butt eSt t ' expcr w ines t s i ony. nn h d d o e h ae s t t s e tm
Appelantf ied t de onsr t t athi couns lsperonnance was l a l o m ta c h s e' f descint Couns l asnotappoi t d t r pr s ntappelantuntl ar h 18, e. ew ne o e ee l iM c 2005,eî htdaysalerhew asar es ed att e s ene ort e aleged r bbel . g t rt hc hl o' y The owneroft ebusnes t si cd t att e vi eot pe f om t es r eil nce h i s e tf h h d a r h u v la

13 l 4 l5

s se i r c r e ove e e ytr et f urda s Th s t evde e i e c q tm s e o d d r v r h e o o y . u ,h i o v d n e
l 6
1 7 18 ott er bber no I ngerexit d att etm e t atcounselbegan r pr s ntng ho yo se hi h e ce i a pe lnt W e f rhe n t t a on diec a pe l t i c ur he d t a t e pl . a ut r o e h t r t p a,hs o t l h t h dit i t c l r di n t e r i de y n h1 moton t dir is b s d o t e s r c cu t d o r n n i g s i o sn s a e n h St t ' f i r t ga he t evi e e i e c be a s a pe l n f ie t s ow a e s a l e o t r h d o v d n c c u e p la t a l d o h u t att e vi eot pe cont i ed mat ral excul at r i f r aton ort att e hhda an ei , p o y n om i hh ofi c s a t d i b d f ih by notc l c i g i. Furhe ,t e St t di n t fc r c e n a a t o l tn t e t r h ae d o pr s ntany exper t s i ony durng ti land appclantf iedt i entf t e ee t e tm i ra l a l o d iy h e pe t a pel n s oul ha e c l d t s pp r hi t e r of d f ns . x r p l t h d v al o u o t s h o y a e ce e The e or , he diti tc u tdi notc ri de yng t i c a m . r f e t src o r d r n n i h s li

1 9

2 Exhbi5(ootot omitd) TheNe a aSuprmcCour' deemiaini n ta obe tvey 0 i t f n e te . vd e ts tr n to s o n jci l
21 un ea on bl a pl a i n ofSti kl nd. Pe ii n rha nots ow n t a t i lc u s l t d dei i n l i r s a e p i to c rc a tto e s h h t ra o n e ac e tc e ty n 22 a y w a , s ï a p ar t a t evi e t pe wa a r a y d sr y d prort co ns lsi v l e e ti t c n y a t p e s h t h d oa s le d c to c i o u c ' n o v m n n h 2 c s . Ev n i co n e h d t ke s e st r c v rt e vi e t pe t e s or ownc s a e t a t e t pe i 3 a e e f u s l a a n tp o e o e h d o a ,h t e r t td h t h a s 24 r c r e ove e e y s ve a da s Ast e c i no i dia i n t a ti lc un e wa i e l c i e t e e o d d r v r e rl y . h r s n c to h t ra o s l s n fk tv , h 25 Cour w i de y g oun o e. t l n r dn l
26 B .G round Two

5

1

l h s s c nd gr un f rr l fpe ii n rc nt n st a hi Fi h Am e dm e trgh t n i eo o d o e i tto e o e d h t s t e t n n i to

2 duc pr ces wasvi l t d when t e pr s cut rf ied t dicl s excul at l ormat lalevi ence. os o ae h o e o al o s o e p o' y ei d 3 Pettonerar ues t att c s at com m it d aBr dy vi l ton when i f ied t dicl seorpr se z t e ii g h h te te a oai t al o s o e ne h 4 s r eil nce vi eot pe. u v la da

5
7

Peiine rie t cisa tcam i hi a pe lofhijdg e ta d sne ce The tto r asd h n tn li n s p a s u m n n e tn .
Dunn cont ndst att edit itcour er ed by denyi g hi m otont e h h s rc tr ns io dim is b s d on t e St t ' f i r t c l c a s r ei a c vi eo a e s s ae h a e s al e o o l t u v l n e d t p . u e l Du n a k g d t a t evi e t pcw oul ha e s ow n t a hedi n tus f r e n l e h th d oa dvh ht d o e oc on t e vi tm i an ate ptt es a e,butr t ert a he wasa t c ed by a h ci n tm o c p ah h t ta k gr up of m e w hi h iw l ded t e vi tm . W e concl de t at Dunn' o n c lu h ci uh s cont nton l cksm ert ei a i. re edy f rt eSt t ' f iur t gat e evi ence whet ert e evi ence was m o h a es al e o h r d hh d m a e i la d t e f i r t ga ht t e e i e c wast e r s l ofa ba f ih t ra n h al e o t r h v d n e u h e ut d at

6 Nc ad Su rmeCo r rjce teisa tcli ,saig: v a pe u t ee td h n tn am ttn
8
9
10

1 1
1 2
13 l4

I Danil v St t,En1 l 4Ne . , - 8, P. d 111 1l n es . a e f : 1 v 261 267 6 956 2 ,5 ( 998))we h l t a dim is lofe i i a c a g s ma be a a ai be 1. ed h t s sa rm n l h r e y n vll a

atmptt prjdietedce da tsc s . tc o eu c h fn n ' ae
l t e i s a tc s ,t e diti tc u tde i d t e moto t dir i s n h n t n a e h s rc o r n e h i n o sn s , f di g t at Dunn f ied t s ow t att e vi eot pe cont i ed m at ral mnh al o h hh da an ei , e c l a or i f r a i n or t a t e ofi e s a t d i b d f ih b n t x u p t y n o m to h t h fc r c e n a a t y o colectng i. W e concl de t att e dit i tcour di notel i s f di g. li t u h h s rc td 'n o m n r

15

l Exhïi2.TheNev daSu rmeCour' detrniato wa notobecieyu raona l a pl ain 6 bt a pc ts er n in s j tv l n e s be p i to c
17 ofUnied St t s Supre e Cour prccedent t ae m t .

. ya S ,7 1 h td a e e to n 18 J Brad.v v M ar lnd,373U. .83 8 ( 963)t eUnie St t sSupr m eCour f u d n 1 t ata sat ' s ppr sson ofevi ence,whet eri t ntonalori adver ent,wilvi lt due pr ces 9h t es u c i d h ne i n t l oa e os
2 whe t a e i e ce i f vor b e ormat ra t t e de e s . M o eo e , he s ppr s i n ofe i e ce 0 n h t vd n s a a l e il o h fn e r v r t u e so vd n

21 mus ha cprj diedt epr c e ig.Stiklrv Gr e e 527U. . 2818 ( 999 .To t v eu c h o e dn rc e . e n , S 263, -2 1 )
22 de c ui e w he hc e i c cei m a cra a c ur m us d c de whe he i he e i a r as nab epr b bï t tn n t r v d n s t il o t t e i t r ç r s e o l o a ly t i 23 t a ,ha t e e i e ce b e dicos d t t e de e s ,t e r s l oft c p oce di g wcul ha e be n h t d h vd n e n s l e o h fn e l e u t h r c n l dv e

24 difrn. Unie Sttsr Ba ly 47 U..66 ,68 ( 985.Se aloJ c s nv Br wn,51 F.d fee t' td ae . ge 3 S 7 2 1 ) e s a k o . o ' 33
25 1 57,1 71( t Ci.2 0 ) Pe ii n rha nots own t a t es r eia c vi e tpec n an d 0 0 9 h r 0 8 . tto e s h h t h u v l n e d o a o t ie l
26 evi ence t atw asf vor bl orm at ralt t edef nse. Pettonerhasnotdem onsr t d t att er i a d h a ae ei o h e ii tae h h e s

6

l r a o a l pr ba i t t a ha t evi eo a e b e dic os d, ha t er s l oft epr ce d ng w o l e s n be o bl y h t d h d t p e n s l e t t h e u t h o e i i ud 2 ha e be n dif r nt v e fe c .
3 Furt e m or ,t e f iur t pr serv evi ence t ati pot ntaly exc l at r can vi l t h r e h al e o e e d h s e il up o y oae

4 a def ndantsdue pr ces rght i t e f iur w asm otvat d by bad f ih. Ari ona v.Youngbl od, e ' o s i s f h al e ie at z o

5 488 U. .51 58 ( 988 ( ol igG nes ac i ia d fn a tca s ow ba fih ont epa toft e S , l ) h dn t l s rm n l e e d n n h d at hrh
6 polcc,f iur t pr se vepot ntaly us f levi e ce doesnotconstt t a deni lofdue proccs of i al e o e r e i l eu d n iu e a s

7 1w' . Furhe mor ,aba f i f i r t c lec potntal e c l a o y e i e c as c namo ntt a' ) tr e d at al e o o l t e ily x up t r vd n e lo a hu uo

8 ad epr c s vi lton.M ilrv V s u z 868F.d 11 6,11 ( t Ci.l ) Se alo Unie u o e s oai le . a q e , 2 l 20 9 h r 989 . e s td 9 St tsv M ari e - ari e ,3 9 F.d 1 1 6- 7 ( t Ci.2 0 ) The ei no idia in t a t e a e . tn z M tn z 6 3 076, 08 8 9 h r 0 4 . r s n c to h t h
10 s at ,i f ii g t eolectorpr se ve evi ence oft e vi eot pe prort i bei g r cor ed over act d t e n a ln o l er d hda i ot n e d ,e 11 i bad f ih. The N evada Supr m eCour ' det rm i aton t att e i s antcl i w aswihoutm erti n at c ts e n i h h n t am t is

1 notoj cieyune s n bl. 2 be tv l ra o a c
l 3 The Cour wildeny gr und t o. tl o w
1 I . Certfcat ofA ppeal biiy 4V ii e a lt

15

l or ert pr cee w ih an appealf om t i cour ,pettonerm us r cei e a cerii at nd oodt r hs t ii te v ttc e

1 ofa pe lblt.28U. . .j225 ()1.Ge eal, peiin rmus ma e: s bsanils owigof 6 p aa iiy SC 3 c() n r l a tto e y t k ç u t ta h n a
l7 t c deni lofa cons iutonalrght't war anta cer ii at ofappcalbiiy. / . The Supr m e Cour h a tt i i 'o r tfc e a lt # e t

1 h sh l ta apeiine d us de on taeta ra on blj rsswoul 5ndt edsrc c ur' 8 a ed h t tto rs t m srt h t e s a e u it m d h itit o ts
1 as e s e toft e c ns iutona cli sde a a l orwr ng. Sl c v M c ani l 529 U . . 9 ssm n h o tt i l a m b t b e o ' a k ' D e, ' . S 473, 4 48

20 ( 00 ) 2 0.
21 The Supr m e Cour f rheril m i at d t e st ndar f ris ance ofa certfcat of e t u t lu n e h a d o s u ii e

2 a pe lbit i M llrElv Coc r l,537U. . 2 ( 00 ) TheCou tsae i ta c s : 2 p aa l y n 'e - . k e l i l S 32 2 3 . r t td n h t a e
2 3 W edo not e uiepe ii ne t p ovc be or t eis a c ofaCOA , h t r q r tto r o r , f e h s u n e ta

2 4
25

26

s mej rsswoul grnttepeiinfrha e sc r us l de d,acli o u it d a h tto o b a o p . n e am ca bede aa l c e to g c eyjrs ofe s nmih a re, le te n b tbe v n h u h v r u it ra o g t ge at rh C O A hasbeen gr nt d and t e cas hasr cei ed f l consder ton,t at ae h e e v ul i ai h peïfne wi n t e ai Aswesatdi Sl c ,'w j er adsrc cou t tto r l o pr v l l : t e n a k ' h e itit r g ha rjce tec nsiutona carsontemeis tes owigr q ic s ee td h o tt l l lin h rt,h h n c urd t s tsyj2 53()i sr ihto vad:Th peiin rmus de onsrt o aif 2 c s tag fn r e tto e t m tae ta raona l jrsswoul f d tedititc utsas sme tofte h t e s be uit d m h src o r' ses n h
7

l

cons iutonalcl i sdebat bl orwr ng.' tt i am ae o'

2 l .a 1 40 ( uotngSl c ,5 9 U. .a 48 ) d t 0 q i ak 2 S t 4.
3 The Cour hasconsder d t ei s esr i e by pettoncr,wih r s ec t whet ert ey t i e h s u as d ii t ep t o hh

4 s ts y t e s a da d f ris a c oface tfc t o a pe l a d t e Cou tdc e mi e t a n ne m e t a if h t n r o s u n e rii a e f p a , n h r tr n s h t o e 5 t a s a da d. A c or i gl , he Cour w i de y pet i n r ac riia e ofa pe l b lt . h t tn r c dn y t tl n l i o e e tfc t t p a a iiy

6
8

I I THEREFORE ORDERED ta tepeiinfrwrtofha e sc r us( oc e TS h th tto o i b a op d k t
I I FU R TH E R O R D ER ED t att e c e k s alENTER JU D G M EN T TS h h lr h l

7 #5)i DENI D . s E
9 A C C O R D I G LY . N 10 I IS FURTH E R O R D ER E D t atpettone i DENI D A CERTI ICA TE O F T h ii r s E F 11 APPEALABI I Y . LT 1 2

1 3
l4

Dt tsl dyfcbr20. adh .j aoOte,09 ei o
U N I ED STAT T D I TR I T JUDG E SC

1 5
l6
l7 18

l9 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 8