Pankow vs Michael J. Astrue

Filing 13

REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION that P's 8 MOTION for reversal be DENIED, and D's 12 Cross motIon for summary judgment be GRANTED. Objections to R&R due by 1/14/2010. Signed by Magistrate Judge Valerie P. Cooke on 12/28/2009. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

1 2
3
4

UNI E D STA T E S D I TR I T C O U R T T S C D I T R I T O F NEV A D A S C

5 6 7 8
9

SEAN M . PANKOW , Pli tf, anif vs .

M I HAEL J. C ASTRUE, Dee da t fn n .

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

3:8- V- 066 - CR- PC 0 C 0 6E V REPORT AND RECOM M ENDATI N O OF U. .M AGI TM TE JUDGE S S Dec mbe 1 2009 e r 4,

1 0

Tbi Re or a d Re om m e da i n i m a et t eHono a l Edwa d C.Re d,J . Unie s p tn c n to s d o h rbe r e r, t d

11 St t sD i ti tJ dge. The a ton w a r f n' d t t e unde s gne M a i ta e J dgepur ua tt 28 a e sr e u ci s ee e o h r i d g sr t u sno

12 U. . .j636()1 ( )a dLR I 14. SC b ()B n B13 Beor t e c ur i plitf smoton f rr ves loft e c m m isone' de iin (/) f e h o t s anif i o e ra h o si rs cso /8 . 14 Dee da to pos da dtldacos - oinf rs mma yj dg e t( 12)Fort er a onss tfrh fn n p e n ie r sm to o u r u m n # . h e s e o t

1 b l w,tec u-rc mme d ta pli t fsmo in f rrv ra (/)b d n e a d d fnd n ' 5 eo h o l e o n s h t an i ' to o e e s l /8 e e id n ee a ts t f 1 cos moi nf rs mma yj d e e t( 1 beg a td. 6 r s to o u r u g m n # 2) rn e
1 7 1 ADM I I TR ATI E PROCEEDI G S l . NS V N

1 8

OnAugus 27 2003, antf Se nM . nkow (ilitf 'pr t cieyslda a plc ton t, pli if a Pa û an if) o e tv l e n p iai p

1 frSupplme tlSe urt I c me ( R 28 . Plitf alg d dia iiy basd on Prde - il 9o e n a c iy n o A ) an if le e s b lt e a rW li

20 Sy dr m e(1W S',mor i obest po tga ti bypa ss r ey, pr sin, - olran ps c oss no t P '2 b d iy s- src s u g r de e so bip a, d y h i ) 21 ( R 74) Pli tf scai wa d nidiiilyonJ ne4, A . anif l m s e e ntal u 2004,AR 28)a do rc nsd r tonon ( n n e o ie ai 22 M a 27s2005 ( R 28) On J l 1 , y A . uy 0 2006,a he rngwashel beor AdmiitaieLa J dge ai d fe n srtv w u
23

24 25

Pu s a tt t e c ur, o de ( 7) boh p risha e si ult d t a t ede ii n oft e ru n o h o ts r r # , t a t e v tp ae h t h cso h A dm i it a i e Law Judge f il and accur t l s m m a ied t emat rilmedialevi enc oft er cor i n s r tv a ry aey u rz h ea c d e h e dn
t i cas . hs e

26 t W S i a genetc dier er t at i cl des s or st t r , m ent lr t r aton or l a ni g T s i sd h nu h t au e a ead i er n 27 dia iii s i c m pl t s xu ld ve o m e t c a a t rs i be a i r p ob e s 1 w mus l t n ,an a s b l e , n o e e e a e l p n , h r c e itc h v o r l m , o t ce o e d n

iv lntr ur et e tc nsa ty, ih, u ld wihar du e n edf rc l re ,la st o e iy' A R n o u ay g o a o tn l whc co p e t e c d e o ao is e d o b st-( 28 30 . )

1 (i LJ'Pee F. l, ndAto n yDe ni A. û ' tr Belia A) tr e n s Came o rprs ntdplitf ( R 28- 8(pi in) r n e e e e an if A 3 o no ; 2 AR 7 7- 61(rnsrpt)TheALJtldawrte opii nonJ nuay23, 2 7 ta ci l. 'e i itn n o a r 2007,i whihheuphed nc l
3 t ede ilofpli tf ' cli .Pl i tf r q e t dad i ita i er viw on Febr a r 2007( R h na an ifs am a n if e u se m n sr tv e e u o 23, A

4 22) a dt eAppe l Cou clde idrviw onOcobe 1 ,2008,ma igt eALJSde iinfna ,n h as n i n e e e t r4 kn h ' cso i l

5 ( R 7 9 . Ha i ge h u td ala m iitaie rm e is paniffld ac mp an frj dca A - ) v n x a se l d n sr tv e de , litf ie o lit o u iil
6 r viw onDec m be 19 2008(/) ee e r, /2 .
7 8 l . BA C K G R O U N D l Pl i tf w a bor on A pr l1 ,1 a n if s n i 3 982, nd w ast e t f u ye r o1 a t etm eofhi he rng a w n p o r a s d th i s ai

9 ( R 422) Plitf di notc mplt hihshoola dhasnoGED.Ho e e, hascompltd 1 3 A . an if d o ee g c n w v rhe ee 6 1 unisofc le eco reslr eyi c mputrnewor a m iitain( R 732 .Plitfhasno had 0 t o lg u s ,ag l n o e t k d n sr to A ) anif t

1 p s r lv n e po me t( R 3 ) Plitf alg sta h b c m eds b e o Oco e 1 , 0 3 1 at ee a t m ly n A 6 . anif le e h t e e a ia ld n t b r 7 2 0
1 ( R 28 . 2A ) 1 3 TheALJfundplitf a l t pef r ot e j bst a exiti sgniia tnumbe si t e o an if b e o ro m h r o h t s n i fc n r nh
1 nainal onomy( R 36)a dt usfundplitf t o dia ld.'Spe ii al ,heALJmadete 4 to ec A nh o anift t s b e ' ctc ly t n h
1 f low i g fndi gs 5 ol n i n : 1 6 The cl i a tha note ga e i s bs antalg i f la tviy am n s n g d n u t i an u ci t

1 7
1 8

snc Octbe 1 ,2003,t e alg d ons tdae ( 0 CFR ie o r7 h le e e t2 41 920(7 a d41 .71e s q.. 6. 1) n 6 9 t e )
Thecli a tha t e f low i g s ve ei pa r e t :Pr de am n s h o l n e r m im n s a r

1 9
20

W ils ndom e( W S)a dmor i obe iysauspos g src liy r P n b d st/tt t a ti by as s r ey,a dde r s in( 0CFR 41 920(). p s u g r n p e so 2 6. c)
Thec a m a tdoesno ha e a i pa nnen orc m bi a i n of li n t v nm i t o n to i pa nne t t a m ee s orm edi aly e ua s one oft e ls e m i ns h t t cl q l h it d

21
22

i p i ne t i 2 CF PM 4 4, ub a t Ap e dx 1( 0 m an n s n 0 R 0 S p r P, p n i 2 CFR 404.520( ) 41 .25a d41 .26) 1 d , 69 n 6 9 .
4. Afe ca e u c ns de a i n of t e e tr r co d t e tr r f l o i r to h n ie e r , h unde s gne tndst a t ec a m a t t er s dua f nc i na r i d i h t h l i n has h e i l u t o l c pact t pe f nn lght xe tona wor a i iy.Li ht k a iy o r o i e ri l k d v t g wor ' i vol e lfi g no m or t a 20 pounds a a tm e wih n v s itn e hn ti t

23

24

fe ue tlfig orca yig ofObecs weihig u t 1 ' q n itn r nn jt gn po 0
25
26
27

pounds Eve t ough t e wei htlfe ma beve' ltl ,a . nh h g itd y l ite y

j bi i ti caeg r whenir q ie agooddea ofwaki g o sn hs t oy t e u rs l ln

28

orsa di g:orwhe i i vol essti g mos oft etm ewih tn n n t n v itn t hi t s m e pus l g a puli g of a m or !g c ntol . To be o h n n ln r e o rs c ns de e ca a l ofpe f r i g a f l orw i er nge oflg t o i rd p b e ro m n u l da ih w or , n i di i ua m us ha e t e a iiy t do s bs a ta l k a n vd l t v h b lt o u t n i ly al o t es a tvii s l s m eo e c n do lgh wor ,we 1 f h e c i te . f o n a it k
2

1
2

detr i et a hec n a s do s de tl wor , e st e ea e e m n h t a lo e n a' y k unls h r r a dii na lm ii g f c or s c a l s of fne de t rt or d to l i tn a t s u h s o s i x e iy '
i abii' t stf rl ng perods n lt o i o o y i,

3
4

Duet hi m e t lc ndii n,hecli a ti si hty i par d o s n a o to t am n s lg l m ie i hi a iiyt unde sa d, e e be ,a d c ny o tdet ied n s b lt o rtn rm m r n a u al i s r d i ns and s i hty i paie i hi a iiy t m a e n tu o ; lg l m r d n s b lt o k

5
6 7
8

j d me t o d tie wo k rlt d d cso s He i u g ns n eald r -eae e iin . s
mode ae y i par d i hi a iiy t i t r c a pr p i t l r tl m ie n s b lt o n e a t p o ra ey w ih t epublc a d s i hty i pa r d i hi a iiy t i t r c th i n lg l m ie n s b lt o n e a t ' a pr prat l w ih s m n zs r an c w or e s l a di i n, p o i ey t u i o s d o k r . n d to he i si hty i paie i hi a iiyt r s o d a pr pra e yt s lg l m r d n s b lt o e p n p o it l o w o k pr s ur s i a us a w or s t i g,a d t c a ges i a r es e n u l k e tn n o h n n r utne wor s ti g oi k e ln

Thecam a tha nopa tr lv ntwor ( 0CFR 41 .65 . li n s s ee a k2 69 )
9

6. 1 0
11

The cl i a tw as bor on Aprl 1 , 1 82 and w as21 ye r am n n i3 9 as ol ,w hi h i detned as a younge i di i ua a e 1 - 4,on d cs i r n vd l g 84

t edaehi a plcainwastld( 0CFR 41 .63) h t s p i to ie 2 69 .
1 2
The c a m a t has a lm ie e uea i n a d i a l t li n i t d d to n s b e o c m m uni a ei Engls . o ct n ih

1 3
1 4
1 5 1 6
l7

8.
9.

Tr nserbiiy ofjo s il i not a is e be a s te a f a lt b k ls s n su c u e h cli a tdoes notha e a y pas r lva twor ( 0 CFR am n vn t ee n k2 404.64) 9.
Cons de i g t e c a m a t sa e e uc t o , or e pe i nc , i rn h l i n ' g , d a i n w k x re e

a dr sdua f ncinalca a iy,t eea ej bst a e iti n ei l u to p ct h r r o h t x s n
c npef r ( 0 CFR 41 .60() a d41 966) a ro m 2 6 9 c, n 6. .
1. 0 Thecl i anthasnotbe n undera4 iabiiy, a dei e i am e ç s lt ' s tn d n d ' t e Soc alSec r t A c ,f e A ugus 27 2003,t e da e t e h i u iy t ' m r t. h th

s g ii a tnum be si t ena i na ec nom y t a t ecl i a t i n tc n r n h to l o h th am n

1 8
19 20

a plc tonwasfld( 0CFR 4l .20( ). p iai ie 2 69 g )

( R 2 - 8. A 83 )
1 1 STAN D A R D O F R E V I W 1. E

21

Th c k-mus u h l te d cson o a a m i itaie lw j dg i te ALJp o e l e out t p o d h e ii f n d n sr tv a u e f h r p ry
22 23 24

a ple t e cor e tl ga sanda ds a d hi f ndi gsoff c a e s ppore by s bs a t a evi e c i p id h rc e l t r n s i n atr u td u tnil d n e n

t e rcor . Se Smoln hed e e

Chalr 80 F.d 1 73,1 79 ( t Ci.1 96) 42 U. . .j 405g) e, 32 2 9h r 9 ; SC (.

tsubsa tale i enc ' ha be n de i e a t ee a te i e c whih a r as na l pe s n m i ht t tn i v d e' s e fn d s t lv n v d n e c r e o be ro g

25
26 27 28

a ce ta a equaet s ppor ac ncuson. Mathe sv. al,1 F.d678 679( t Ci.1 93) c p s d t o u t o l i ' t w Shal a 0 3 ' , 9h r 9 * ,
s ealoRihar s nv Pe als 40 U. , 401( 971) Su sanile ie cei mor t a amer e s c d o . r e , 2 S 389, 1 . b t ta v d n s e h n e s i tlabutls talaprpondea c .Se Ja wr on t Chatr 11 F.d l cnil es hr e rn e e n s ' . e , 2 3 064,1 ( t Ci. 066 9h r

3

1 1 97)ciigsmoln, F.da 1 79.û'od tr iewhehe s bsanile ien ee it (hecoul 9 , tn e 80 3 t 2 l' eem n f t r u t ta vd c x ss t t
2 mus!loka terco da awhol,c nsde igbot e i e c t a s pporsandundem i e t e t o th e r s e o i rn h v d n e h t u t r n sh
3 ALJ' tndi gs Howe e si t ee i e cei s s e tbl ofm o et a oner tona i t p r tton.he Si n . v r fh v d n s u c p i e r hn ai l n e ea i t

4 de iinofteALJmus beu hel.'Oreav Shall , F.d7 8,749(t Ci.1 95)(iai ns cso h t p d' tz . aa 50 3 4 9h r 9 ctto 5 omitd) TheALJaonei r s onsbl f rdeemii gc e i iiy a df rrs li ga bi uiis te . l s e p i e o tr nn rd b lt, n o e ovn m g te . 6 Me ne v Ap è,1 2F.d 1111 111 ( t Ci.1 99) a l . jl 7 3 , 3 9h r 9 .
7 The Soci l Se ur t A dm i it a i n de i e di a iiy as t e %i a iij t enga e i a y a c iy n sr to tn s s b lt h tn b ltr o g nn 8 s bsan i lga nf lac i iy by r a on ofan m ed c ly de e m i abl phys c l m en a i paim e t u t ta i u tv t es y ial tr n e i a or tlm r n 9 whi h .. s l se orea be e pe t d t l s f ra c ntnuous pe i d ofnotl s t a 1 m ont s' c . ha a t d n x ce o a t o o i ro es h n 2 h. '

1 42 U.. .j 423( )1( ) A cli a ti c nsdeed dia ld û nl i hi physc lorme tl 0 SC d ( )A . am n s o i r sb e t y f s o ia na
l i par e tori pai nen sar ofs c s ve iyt a he i no onl una l t do hi pr vi uswor l m im n m n t e u h e rt h t s t y b e o s eo k 1 b tc nno ..e ga e i a y o he ki d ofs bsa talga nf lwor whi h e it i t e na i n l 2 u a t, n g n n t r n u tn i i u k c x ss n h to a

l e onomy..' 42U. . .j423()2)A) 3c ..' SC d( ( .
1 4 Pur ua tt t e Socil Sec rt Ac ,r gultons ha e be n a opt d whih esa ls a sn oh a u iy t e a i v ede c tb ih
1 f r a i e , i e- t p s que ta e a ua i n pr c s t de e m i ew he he a c ai a ti di a l d.Se 5 o m lz d fv s e e n i l v l to o e s o t r n t r l m n s s be e

1 20C. . . 404.520.TheAdmiitai eLaw J dgec nsde s ( )whehert epe s ni engagng 6 FR j 1 nsrtv u o i r : 1 t h ro s i

1 i s b tnilg if l ciiy ( )sveiyo tealg di p ime t ( ) te tei panne t 7 n u sa ta an u a tvt ; 2 e rt f h le e m ar n ; 3 wheh r h m i n '
1 me t orequasalsedi par e ta dme t tedurtonrquie e t ( )whehe t ei diiual 8 es l it m im n n es h ai e rm n ' 4 , t r h n vd

1 i ca a l ofdeigwor heors ehasdonei t epas;a d( )whehe tei par e tpr v nt t e 9 s p be n k h nh t n 5 t r h m im n e e s h
20 pe s n fom doi gan ot e wor .1l l a a y poi ti t efve se i quiy i i dee ni e t at ro r n y h r k ( f tn n n h i - tp n r t s tn n d h
21 a c a m a ti ori no di a l d,f rhe r vi w i unne es a y. li n s s t sb e ' t r e e s u c sr
22 1V . AN A LY SIS

23

Pl i tf a guest a t e ALJ c m m itd lga e r ra d t a s bsa tale i e ce di not an if r hth o te e l ro n h t u t n i v d n d

24 s ppo tteALJ' c ncusons( 8,p.5) Spe ii al ,plitf a s rst a t eALJ()f iedt u rh So li # . ctc ly an if se t h t h 1 al o
25 prpel c e i t e o iin ofplitf' te tng physca ;a d ( )di notpr pel s ppolhi o ry r dt h p no anifs rai iin n 2 d o ry u r s

26 tndig tat obsexiti sgniia tnumbe si t enaina e ono yt a plitf i ca a l of i nhj s n i fc n r n h to l c m h t an if s p b e
27 pe f nni g.I . 5.Thet o a gum e t a e r l t d bec us pl i tf m a nt i st a i t eA LJha r o n d p. wr n s r e ae a e a n if i a n h t f h d 28 c e ie t e opi i n of pl i tf s t e tng pbys c a ,t e t e A LJ c ul no have r a h t e r dtd h no a n if r a i i in h n h od t ec h
4

1 c nclsont a plitf wasca a l ofj b pe fr a c . o u i h t an if p b e o ro m n e
2 D e e da t s pos to i s m pl t a t e ALJ pr pe l di c e ie t e o i i n ofpl i tf s fn n ' ii n s i y h t h o ry s r d t d h p n o a n if

3 teai gphyscin,a dt uss bsa ta e i e c s pporsteALJ' de iinta j bse iti t e r tn i a n h u tnil v d n e u t h S cso h t o x s n h 4 naina ec nomy( 1 , 4- ) to l o # 2 pp. 5 .
5 A. O pi i n ofPl i t f ' Treatng Phys ci n no a n ifs i ia

6

tf e ALJi r s ons bl f rde e ni i g c e i iiy, es l i g c nf i t i m e i a t s i on l' -h s e p i e o t n n n r d b lt r o v n o lc s n d c l e tm y

7 a d r s l i g a biuiis'Edlnd v Mas anar,253 F.d 11 2,115 ( t Ci.2001,ciig n e ovn m g te . u . s i ' 35 6 9h r ) ln
8 Andr wsv Shal l ,5 F. d 1 35,1 39( t Ci.1 95) Cas swihi t eN i t Cic i ditng ih e . a a 3 3 0 0 9 h r 9 . e t n h n h r u t si u s

9 bewee teopi insof( )te tngphyscins ( )e a ii gphysca s a d( )non-xmnii g t n h no 1 rai i a ,2 x m nn iin , n 3 e nn 1 physca s fe trv.Ch tr 81F.d 8 1 830( t Ci.1 .Ge eal,heopi insofteai g 0 iin . se ae, 3 2 , 9h r 995) n rly t no r tn
11 phys c a s a e a f r ed g ea e wei ht t a t e opi i ns of o he physci ns be a s tea i g i in r fo d r tr g hn h no tr ia c u e r tn
12 phys ci ns tar em pl yed t ctr and t us have a great r opporuniy t know and obser e t e ia ûe o o le h e tto vh

13 painta a idi iua ... Smoln v Chatr 80 F.d 1 73,1 8 ( t Ci.1 96)(iains te s n n v d l ' ' e. e, 32 2 5 9 h r 9 ctto 1 omitd) : teai gphyscin' medialopiin a t t enau eands veiyofa i diiua' 4 te . : r tn A ia s c n o s o h tr e rt n n vd ls
15 i paim entm us be gi en cont oli g wei hti t atopi i n i w el- uppoded and noti consi t nt mr t v r ln g fh n o s ls n se

1 w ih t e ot e s bs a tale i e c i t e cas r co d. Edl n v. as anar ,253 F. d l1 2,11 7 6 t h h r u tn i v d n e n h ee r ' ' ud M s i 3 5 5

17 ( t Ci. )ctn SSR 96- p. 9h r2001 iig 2
18 The ALJ m a dir g r t e t ea i g phys ci n' opi i n w he he or not t a o i i n i y s e a d h r tn i a s no tr h t p no s

1 c nta itd,Magale e v Bowe ,881F.d747 751(t Ci.1989) howe er a ALJma not 9 o r dce ln s . n 2 , 9h r , v ,n y

2 rj c t ete t gph sca ' o ii ni i i c nr dce b ohe ph sca s o iinsu ls t e 0 ee th rai y iin s pn o f t s o ta itd y t r y iin ' p n o ne s h n
21 ALJ tm akes t ndi gs s t i g f l h s eci i , l gii at r as ns f r doi g s t at are based on t in e tn o ' p f c e tm e e o t o n oh

22 s bsa ta e i e c i ter c r .' I .( uoig Wiansv Bowen,853 F.d 6 3,6 7( t Ci. u tnil v d n e n h e o d' d q tn n . 2 4 4 9h r
23 1 87),s ealoLe tr 81F.da 830. 9 ) e s se, . 3t
24 l t i c s ,t eALJpr pe l dic e ie t e o i i n ofpl i tf ste tng physcin,Dr n hs ae h o ry s r d t d h p n o a n if r ai ia .

25 M il r Dr M il r pe f nne a m e t le al a i n of pl i tf ,ye he opi ed t a pl i tf w oul le . . le r o d n a v u to a n if t n h t a n if d

26 lkeybea sntfom wor du hi physc lc ndiin ( R 34) Theopiin ofas e ils about il be r k es ia o to A . no p cait
27 m e i a i s e r l t d t hi a ea of s ec aly i e tte t m or w e g t t a opi i ns of nond c l s u s e ae o s r p i t s n il d o e ih h n n o

28 s e ilss 20CFR j41 927( )5)Hol hanv Masanar,246F.d11 5,1 02- 3f . ( t Ci. p cait. 6. d ( ' o , .si 3 9 2 0 n 2 9h r
5

1 20 1.Be a s DrMilrsonl pe f nne ame tl l ainbut fe e a opi inonplitf' 0 ) c u e . le' y ro d n a evau to o fr d n no anifs
2 phys c lcondii n,t e A LJ s ec f c ly r f s d t a cor D r M il r s opi i n t e c ntoli g ia to h p ii a l e u e o c d . le ' n o h o r ln

3 weght TheALJnotd tatDr M ilrstndi gsweenots p ore by te obeci eme ia i. eh . le' i n r u p td h j tv dc l
4 fndigs( R 34)Fore a pl, no tope i exa iainofplitf de onsrtdplitf sfl in A . x m e a rh d c m n to an if m tae anif u l

5 srngt, te h nonnalelxe , ndsnston( R 32) Therf r,heALJsae s e ii, ge tr a o s rfe s a e ai A . eo e t ttd p cfc co n e s n
6 why he di c e ie t e opi i n of pl i tf s tea i g phys c a r g r i g pl i tf s phys ca s rdtd h no a n i f r tn i in e a d n a n if il
7 condii n. to

8 B.

A LJ' C onc us on t atSi nii antN um be s ofJobsExiti t e N at ona Ec nom y S li h g fc r snh ilo

9

Plit f r u sta d f n a t dn t e t eb r e a se tv o d m o srtn t aj b an i a g e h t ee d n di o me th u d n t tp i e f e n taig h to s f

1 e i ti t e na i na e o om y a d t a t e A LJ di nothave s bs an i le i e ce t m a e s ch a 0 x s n h to l c n n h th d u t ta v d n o k u

1 tn i g S e i c l , an if o e t a t ev c t na e p r p o o e tr ef o -eae j bs As 1 i dn . p cf al plitf n ts h t h o ai l x e t r p s d h e o d r ltd o . y o
1 o eafitdwihPW S, aitf aguesta hewo l beuna l t perom i a yoneoftes j bs 2 n flce t pl n if r ht ud b e o fr n n h eo 1 a d t a t evoc tona ex e ts ie ttc to ofo l f od-eltdj bsundes or ste AlJ* 3 n ht h ai l p r' d niiain n y o r ae o rc e h a s
14 m i unders andi g ofPW S. D ef ndantar uest atpl i tf f ist not how t i partcul rpl i tf s tn e g h a n if a l o e hs i a a n if

1 c udn t ef n a yo t e o sa dd fn a t lon ts h t- oo t e h e j bs d a dr cl 5 o l o p ro n n fh j b - n ee d n as oe t a t fh t r e o do e l ie t w y
1 w ih co s m abl s 6 t nu e.

1 7

l t i c s , voc tona e pe tst si on aswelaspl i tf sownt si onypr vi edt e n h s a e a ai l x r' e tm y l an if e tm od h

1 s bsan i l e i e ce upon w hi h t e A LJ ba e hi de i i n. The r c gni e expe ts of a 8 u t ta v d n ch s d s c so e o zd rie 1 voc tona e pe t o i e t enec s a y f und t o f rhi t s i ony.Ba ls v Bar har , F. d 9 a i l x r pr v d s h e s r o a i n o s e tm y is . n t 427 3

20 1 11 1 1 ( t Ci.2005) Asdee da tnots plitf di no que tont ee pe tstsi on 2 , 2 8 9h r . fn n e , anif d t si h x r' etm y 21 (/ 2,p.4'AR 754) l a diin,teei f rhe s ppor i t er c r f rt eALJ' c ncuson /1 , . n d to h r s u t r u t n h e o d o h So li
22 r ga di g pl i tf s a iiy t be a ound f od. Pl i tf t s ii d t a he w as a l t c nt olhi e r n a n i f b lt o r o a n if e tf e h t be o o r s

23 crvigsa d as noe t a he wa a l t s op unac ompa id by hi mohe ( R 74142) a n n lo td h t s be o h c ne s t rA -.
24 The e or ,t e t s i o y oft e voc tona e pe ta d pl i tf ' t si ony as t hi on' abiii s r f e h e tm n h a i l x r n a n i f s e tm o s n lte 25 pr vi e a eq a ee i e cef om w hi h t eA LJco l de e m i et at ai tf c ul per or c r a n o d d d u t vd n ' r ch u d t r n h pl n i f o d f m e t i

26 j b i ten to a e o o y. o s n h ain l c n m
27 // / 28 // / 6

1 2

V . C O N C L U SI N O Bas d on t e f r goi g t e e ur co cl de t a t e A LJ' de i i n w as s ppo t d by e h oe n , h o t n u s h t h S c so u re

3 s bsa tal vi e c a dt e eor rco me dst a plitf smotonf r e e sl( 8) eDENl D u tn i e d n e n h r f e e m n h t an if i o r v ra # b E
4
5

ddee d ntsmotont a-nn (/2)beGRANTED. fn a ' i o ti /1 f
l . RE C O M M E N D A T IO N v

6
7

I I 'u E lEFo lE RECOM M EN DED t a pl i tf ' m o i n f r r ve s l(/ )be T sr t t h t a n ifs to o e r a /8
oEx lr.p a dd fnd n ' co smoinf rs mm ayj d m e t( 1 )b GRANTED. n ee a ts r s t o u r u g n : 2 e o

8
9
10

I T E D :o e e be u cm r

,

2009.

-

1 1
12

N I E I STA T E S A G I T M T E JUD G E TI S

13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24

25 26

27
28

7