Van Nort v. Fair et al

Filing 64

ORDER - P's 36 Motion for Leave to Amend is DENIED;P's 41 Motion for Revision of Orders is DENIED; P's 42 Motion for Leave to Amend iS DENIED; P's 43 Motion for Leave to Amend is DENIED; P's 57 Motion to Extend Dis covery is DENIED except for the possible issuance of subpoenas (as specified herein); P's 46 Motion for Issuance of Subpoenas is DENIED without prejudice. P may renew his motion provided he does so by 9/7/2011, and submits: (1) a list of individuals to be subpoenaed; and (2) a showing that any discovery sought thereby is not obtainable from some other source. Signed by Magistrate Judge Robert A. McQuaid, Jr on 8/23/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

'

ë

s

.

q

.

'

FL
IED
ENTE D
RE

' RECEI D
W
C VEDON
ER
COUNS UP TISOFRE
E M E
CORD

1

z

.

x

AI: 2 2 2 1
J
21

3
-

4

B:
Y

CL US tl r clcotRr
ERK is.ql
l'
ss
yzcyCFvzv y
m
DP UV

5

6

UNI
TED STATES D I
STRIW CO UA T
D I R I O F N E VA D A
ST W

7

8

SCOU I RAYVAN NORT,
E
.
pl i if
antf,
l
0
vs.
.
et l,
1l GLEN FM R, .a .
9

'

1
2

Dee n s
fnda t .

1 SCOW I M YVAN NORT
3
E
1
4
'

1
5

Pl ntf,
ai if
'VS.

'

1 RK K M HER,et a .
6
. l,
1 SCOU I M Y VAN NORT,
7
E

1
8
1
9

Pl i if
antf,
v.
s

2 GLEN F R, t a .
0
M e. 1
21
23

'

De e n s
f nda t .

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

3: - vO9 c OOo42LRH I
RAM I
i
..
!
:r
' '
, '...
?
I
:
'
I
A
l
l
3: cv- O909- OO1 LRH I
RAM I
l
.
'
.

.

!

.
.
'
i
.
. 3: c OO11 LRH I
O9-W
ORAM I
.
ORDER
,
)

-

J

2
4

Pan if cti Ra Va No t pan T , nimaea NotenNea aCorcin l
litfS ote y n r t lih a n t t rh r v d reto a

2 Ce t r(
5 n e NNCC) i pr e dngpr s a i r
,s oc e i o c nd nf? mapau rs i t scvlrg sa ton
pe i,n hi ii iht ci
2 pur ua t 42U. C. 1
6
s nt o
S. j 983.0n Aprl22 201 , s Nos: O9-Bi , 1 Ca e . 3: ('OOO42LRH (
RAM )
,
27 a: c ool tl l(
og-v- og- -u. RAM ) anda: cv- , ll l(
,
og- ool o--u. RAM )wer consolda ed.( eooc.
e
i t se
28

.

e

j

jj : :
.; :

..-..

1 # 30. Thes c eshaveac
)
e as
ombi hvevec swhih s dvedsc eeni Pendi
ned l ount
c ur
r ng.
ng
2 be or t c
f e be ourtar t f lowi m otonsfl by Pl ntf :
e he o l ng
i
ied
ai if

3

( )M o i f rLe v t Am e i 3: - vmbO 1 ton o a e o
nd n O9 c - 42 LRH I
ö
RAM I( c. 36 :
Do # );

4
5

( )M oi f rRe ii ofOr r S j c t FRCP 5409 ( c # 41 ;
2 ton o vson
de s ub e t o
Do . )
( )M o i f Le vet Ame i a: c ool lll I
3 ton or a o
nd n og-v- og-a ' RAM I( c. 42 ;
ll
Do # )

6

( )M o i f rLe vet Am e i 3: c - l LRH (
4 ton o a o
nd n og- v oOl oRAM )( . 43)
Doc # 9
i

7

()Moint Exe dDic v r ( c #5 )a d
5 to o tn so ey Do .l 7; n

8

( M o i f rl s nc o S
6) ton o s ua e f ubpoe s( . 46)
na Doc # .

9 A.M oHon f Leave t Am end i 3: evor
o
n o9- ooo42- RH IR.. I(
L'
AM Doc.# 36)
1
0

On M ay 5,201 ,Pl ntf ed a M oton f Leavet Am e t com pl nti mt e
1 ai iffl
i or
o
nd he
ai n 's

1 3: c ooo421 o9-w
LRH (1 M1 ( . 36.
1. . Doc # )
A.
1
2

.

Feder Rul ofCi lPr edur 1 pr dest l vet am end a pl ng ' ..s l
al e
vi oc
e 5 ovi hat ea o
eadi ' hal
.

1 bef e l gi nwhe jztc s r ql r s'Fe R. v. 1 a .Howe e ,hed cso t
3
r ey ve
n lsie o e z e . d. Ci P. 5( )
i
v r t e ii n o
1 gr l vele sol y wihi t di e i oft t'a courtand f t st be c i ed
4
ant ea i s el t n he scr ton he 'i I
I
ac or o
ons der

1 i l , ar no lmie t prj c t t op i p t ) uedea ba f ih,
5 ncude but e t i t d o: eudie o he posng ary und
ly, d at
1 diat motveand f iiy.DCD Progr s Lt t. i on,833 F. 1 1 ( bCi.
6 l onr i
utlt
am , d.?Leght
2d 83, 86 9t r
1 1 ) Unie St e t.W' ,6 F.d 9 , 9- ( bCi. 981 . '
7 987 ; td ats 7 c 55 2 77 97 80 9t r 1 )
èè
1
8

Pl ntf ied hi c pl nti tlsac i and t r
ai iffl
s om ai n li ton,
he ealerw asgi l vet fl an
ven ea o ie

1 a nde c m p a n .( c Do . 7 # 1 ,# 1 a P1' Am .Co p .( c. 1 . Pl i tf
9 me d o l i t S e c # , 3 5, nd .
s
' m l Do # 6)) a ni f
20 s varousdef
ued i
endant ale ng cons i t
s l gi
tm ionalvi atons oc ur i dlr ng hi f t day
ol i
c rng z i
s our een-

21 i c r e a i i t Ca s Ciyj i fom J 3,
n a c r ton n he r on t al r une 2008t June1 2008.( c # 1 )
o
7,
Do . 6.
22
TheAme d Co anti l sCo s14.( c. 1 ) On s r e ng t c t
nde mpl i ncude unt - Do # 6.
c e ni , he our

23 dimisdCo 3wihprj c , nd Coun 4wiho prj c ( c #1 a 8. Bywa
s s e unt t eudie a
t t ut eudie. Do . 5 t )
y
24 oft i t m oton f l
he ns ant
i or eavet am end,Pl ntf s
o
ai if eekst cur t de i i i Count4.
o e he sc enc es n
25
26
l

Ref st courtsdoc tnum ber Unl ssot nds not r er sar t doc number i
er o
' ke
.
e he e ed, ef ence e o ket
sn

27 c s a: c a e og-' ooo4z LlH ( )
v
- t RAM .
28

a

'

*

.

1

Count4 a l gesavi a i ofPl i ifsFi s Am e
le
ol ton
a ntf' r t
ndm entrgbtofac s t t
i
ce s o he

2 c urs S clc l Pl ntf alg st tt çaro Ciyj ipr i knoa c s t r'e rb
o t. pe i al ai if le e ha he s n t al ovde
y,
ces o e ac
s
t

3 m at i l and hasno l lbr y.Asa r ul,Pl ntf l st thi ac es t c t w ms
er a s
aw i al
es t ai ifalege ha s c s o our.
s
!

4 i peded f t pe i be ween June 3- 2098,pr ventng hi f om slng wha woul
m
or he r od t
17,
e
i
m r
i
t
d

5 e e ual beF' No tt.CcronCfpShe W sO c , o8 c v nt ly a r ) s r
n
r m e 3: -v oo689 ECR ( .
7PCI
6

Pl ntf e sentaly ar
ai if s i l guest tt coul s
ha he
' houl 1 thi c ai pr eed beca t
t
d e s l m oc
use he

7 c ti r r t c t t a l ga i ofhi com pl nti hi f
our s equied o ons rue he le tons
s
ai n s avor.Tha doesnot
t

8 c
hanget f tt tPl ntf silf l t s a eacai under42U. C. 1
he ac ha ai if tl ais o t t l m
S. j 983.Todos
o,
9 Pl ntf s r r t alege a rghts lred by t Cons itton orl oft Unied St t s
ai i fi equied o l
i ecz
he
ttzi
aws he t
ae

1 wa vil t d.Se W ' lu.At i s 487U. 42, ( 988) Mor o e , s ntt t Prs n
0
s oa e
c e
s
kn ,
S. 48 1 . e v r pur ua o he io
1 Liia i Re or Ac I
1 tg ton f m t PLRAI af de a c uf m us dimisaprs rscam it aci n
, e rl o t t s s
ione ' li f be to
1 dsfi ousorm alci l f l t s a ea cl m on whi h r le m a be gr e ors ks
2 ' lvol
i
i ots, ais o t t
ai
c eif y
ant d, ee
'

1 m one ar r le agai tade endantwbo i i munefom s b r lef' 28 U. C.j
3
t y eif ns
f
sm
r uc ei '
S.

1 1 5( ( .Dimis ofac pl ntf f l et s a eacai uponwhi r i c be
4 91 e)2) s s al
om ai or aiur o t t l m
ch elef '
an
1 gr edi pr dedf i FeLR. V. 1
5 ant s ovi or n I Ci P. 209( andt courtapple t s sandar
6),
he
is he ame t
d
1 underj1 5when r viwi t ade
6
91
e e ng he quac ofacom pl nt A pl ntf canbegi l vet
y
ai . ai if
ven ea o
1 am end t c et de ii i s,unl si i c e f om t f e oft com pl ntt tt
7
o ur he fc enc e
es t s l ar r
he ac
he
ai ha he

1 defci i ca
8
enc es nnotbecur by am endm ent.Se Cat t. Unie St e 70 F. 1 03,1 06
ed
c o7
t d at s,
3d 1
1

1 ( t Ci.1 )
9 9. r 995 .
h
20

On s ee ng, be c
cr ni t ourts i aly poi ed outt Pl i ' ft ti or t s at a
pecfc l
nt
o a ntf ha n der o t e
i

21 cai f vi aton ofhi Fi s Am endm entr ghtofac es t t c ts he wasr quied t
l m or ol i
s rt
i
c s o he our ,
e r o

2 algefcss wi t thes frda tzlnur Le st.Cas y, 1 U. 3 3 5
2 le a t bo ng ha
ufe e caa ij y. wi ? e 5 8 S. 43, 49- 0
23 (996) Therghtt ac s t c . i lmie t diec crm i lappe s habemsc pus
1 .
i o ce s he ourt s i t d o r t i na
s
al,
or
24 pr eedi and cvi r ght ac i c l ng condii ofconfnem ent 1 at354oc ngs,
i l i s tons halengi
tons
. d.
55.

2 f Ii t c nno etbls rlva ta t lnur smpl bye tbls ngt thi prs s
5 f nmae a t sa ih ee n cua ij y i y sa ihi ha s ion'
AJ
26 l lbr y orl as s anc pr am i s pari som et
aw i ar
egal sit e ogr s ub- n
heor tc s e.'I a 351
e ial ens ' d. t .
27 Rat r t i at S us go one s e f herand dem ons r t t tt lbr y orl l
he , he nm e s t
m
t p urt
t a e ha he i ar
ega
28

3

.

*

1 m ssa epr gr m hi de e hi e f r.t pur ueal g lcam . 1 Thea m a -n unr
s it nc o a n r d s fo t o s
s
e a li ' d.
'
c li j
2 r r m entm anda est tan i at ' ons r e t a nonf i ousl c ai had
equi e
t ha
nm e '
dem t at hat
rvol
egal l m

3 be nV tta e orwm bengi de 'I a 35
e srtd
s i mpe d. d. t 3.
'
4
Th i ta doc nti F'nNor l.Caro CipSh rfsO c , O8-v Oo689e niil ume n a
t ? s n r e i N c 3: c 5 ECR (
VPCIwm fld on De e r3 2008.Thec s wm dimis dwiho pr j c o
s e
c mbe o,
m e s s s e t ut eudie n
6 Januar 8,2oo9,duet pl ntf f l et eiherpayt $350 flngf orfl apr ry
y
o ai ifs aiur o t
be
ii ee ie ope l
%

7 c
omplt da ia i t pr e di m apau rs.On s r e ng t c tf
e e pplc ton o oc e nfo
pe i
c e ni , he our ound
8 t whie Pl ntf c ai si hehad ac es t a1 lbr y hewoul havebeen abl t sa if
hat l ai if l m f
c s o aw i ar
d
e o ts y
9 t flng r r e sand t r r ent f i uanc ofat por y r t ai ng or ,
he ii equiem nt
he equiem s or ss
e
em ar es r ni
der
1 hef l t dem ons r t t a nonf i ous cai wasf t at ori peded.
0
aied o
t a e hat
rvol
lm
rus r ed m

1l

I hi pr
n s opos s ond a ended com pl nt Pl ntf l
ed ec
m
ai , ai ifalegest he had c ai s
hat
l m

1 s e m i fom hi i ar aton i t Chur hilCount Jai i June2006.( .# 36- at
2 t m ng r
s nc cer i n he
c l
y ln
Doc
1
1 1 ) Heas er. t t ecai i l vi a i ofhi Fourt Am e entrght
3 0.
s t hat hes l ms ncude oltons
s
s
h
ndm
i s
1 r atngt s c and s z e.(d. Thef h Am e entcai i notadiec appealofa
4 el i o ear h
eiur I j
ourt
ndm
lm s
r t
l5 crm i lc e, habe c puspetton, aj1 cl m conc ni c tonsof
i na ms a
ms or
ii or
983 ai
er ng ondii
1 conlnem ent Thls Pl ntf
6
. z , ai ifhasnots at a j 1
t ed
983 c a m undert
li
hesef t .
ac s

l
7

Pli if lo m s r st tt â1 cai si c s 3: c - 41BXS I
a ntf a s s e t ha he 983 l m n a e o9-v ooO RAM Im wel
s l

1 mst sac
8
hi don wer rpe f flng and wer i peded. He doesnote ai how t wer
e i or i
em
xpl n
hey
e
1 i pe
9 m ded,and c ede t eac i wer fl d.The ar t s eale i Pl ntf
onc s hes tons e e
se e he am
l gatons ai i f
20 m ade i hi am ended c pl ntt wer dim i e on s re ng.W hie Pl i ifc ai she
n s
om ai hat e s ss d
c eni
l a ntf l m

21 wo dha ebe na et stsyt i mapau rsGlngr q rme sandt
ul v e bl o aif he nfor
pe i i e uie nt
he
22 r quiem ent f i s
e r
s or s uanc ofat m por r t ai ng or ,he si lhas nots
e
e
anr es r ni
der
tl
hown t ta
ba
23 nonf vol c ai wasf us r e ori peded.
ri ous l m
r t at d m
2
4

Pl ntf m ot on t am end hi com pl ntand pr
ai ifs
i o
s
ai
opos sec am ended com pl nt
ed ond
ai
.

25 f lt as rtany alegat t tw oul r ur ec t sc ai . He hmss m pl notse f h an
ai o se
l ion ha
d es r t hi l m
i y
t ort

2 algai o a a t lij y a ars tofa alg dviltono hsFis Ame
6 le ton f ny cua nul s e ul n le e oai f i rt ndme
nt
27 rghtt ac sst c t .M or over Pl ntf
i o ce he our s
e
, ai ifwaie f om t tm e t cout di m i s t s
td r
he i he
t s s ed hi
28

4

.

*

l c ai ,Oc obe 29,201 untlM a 5,201 t s k l avet am end hi c pl nt
lm
t r
0, i y
1 o ee e
o
s om ai .
2 De e
f ndant ar cor ed t Pl ntf undul del yed s ng am endm ent Ther or
s e r hat ai if
y a
eeki
.
ef e,

3 Pl i ifsM oi f Le vet Am e i 3: - antf
ton or a o
nd n 09 > 00042-,G ( . )( . 36 i de e
11 RAM Doc # ) s ni d.

4 B.M oHon f Re son ofOrde Subj tt FRCP 54* )(
or vii
rs
ec o
Doc. 41
# )
5
On M a 2 201 , l ntf sld aM o i nf rRe so ofOr r Su j c t Rul
y 3, 1 P ai if e
to o vii n
de s b e t o e
6 5409.(
Doc.# 41) Def
.
endant ar c r tt t si ye anot ratem ptbyPl ntf o
s e or ec hat hi s t he l
ai ift
7 c le t c tss r ngor r I 3: cv Oo042halnge he our' c eeni de s. n o9- LRH (
RAM ) t cour dim is
,he
t s s ed

8 Co 3 wih pr j c , nd Coun 4wihou prj c .( . 1 ) I 3: - v ool
unt t eudie a
.
t t t eudie Doc # 5. n og c - og9 LRH ( M 1 t c 'd s is d Co s1 6, d 9- 1V :Iprj c .( c # 5i 3:
RA. , he ouz im s e unt - an 1 . eudie Do . n 09t
I
1 c oo1 LRH(
0 v- o9RAM )) I 3: cv- 1 LRH I
. n O9- OO1 ORAM I t c tdim ised Count 1 3,4,
, he our s s
s,
1 6, 9 1 , 3 a 1 wihpr j c , nd dimis d d f nda sFurong V a s Le , la o,
1 8, , 1 1 nd 4 t eudie a
s s e e e nt l , y , e Co l z
1 J Do Poiy M a e a t Ca s CiyBo r o Comm iso r wih prj c .( c
2 ohn e lc - k r nd he r on t a d f
s i ne s t eudie Do .
.
1 # 1 i 3: c OO1 O3
4 n O9-v- 1 LRH (: )) Thi m o i lket t e o he sfl dby P a ntf,
1AM . s ton,i he hr e t r ie
l i if
1 s e st a e d hi c a nt Fort s ca msd s s e wih prj c , antf
4 e k o m n s ompli .
ho e li imis d t eudie Pli ifs
.
1 ar
5
gum ent ar una lng.The cl m s ar no l
. e vaii
s
se ai
e
onge partofany ac i and c
r
ton,
annotbe
1 br
6
oughta n.Ast Count4 i 3: cvgai
o
n o9- ooo42, he c thasaddr s Pl ntf' r ques
t our
es ed ai ifs e
t

17 t am e t c pl nti t tr d a
o
nd he om ai n ha egar bove. Pl i iff l t cur t defci eswi.
a ntf aied o e he i enci
t
h

1 r s c t Co 4.The e o e Pl i tf m o in ( c # 41 i de e
8 e pe t o unt
r f r , a n ifs to Do . ) s nid.
1 C. M ot on f Lea t Am end i 3: cv oo1 LQH (
9
i or ve o
n o9- - o9RAM )( .# 42)
Doc
20

On M a 23,201 , ai iffl t M oton f Lea t Am end t c pl ntsl i
y
1 Pl ntf ied he
i or ve o
he om ai ed n

21 3: c - O9O9- v OO1 LRH (
RAM ) ( . 42. Thec ur s r ç d P a ntf' orgi l ompli
. DOc # )
o t c e ne l i if i na c
s
ant
22 i t s c e and ent e an or dim i s ng Count 1 2,3,4, and 6,9,1 and 1 w ih
n hi as
er d
der s s i
s,
5,
O,
1 t

2 prj die.( c # 5i a: c - og- Ud ( )) I a ton, c ur dim is dCo t
3 e u c Do . n og-v ool Ll RAM . n ddii he o t s s e un

2 7wiho prj
4
t ut eudkea t d fnda sRa e Furo a W al (d. Plitf sgie
s o ee nt msy, lng, nd l. J ) an ifwa v n
25 t ry( dayslavet a end Count7.( 4 On Fe ar 8,2o1 Pl ntf edan
hit 30)
e o m
1d.
bnl y
0, ai ifsl

2 Ame d Compl i .( c # 2 ) l s r e ngt Am e d Compl nt t c ur f und
6
nde
ant Do . 3. n c e ni he
nde
ai , he o t o
27 t Pl ndf had vi at t c ' or gr i l
hat ai f
ol ed he ourts der antng eavet am end by gr l alerng hi
o
eaty t i
s
28

.

5

'

,

*

1 a de c
men d ompli .( . 26 i 3: c - O9- H (
a nt Doc # n O9- v OO1 LR. RAM )) Th c ur pr e e t t
. e o t d r d ha
2 t c s wo zd o ypr e dont f l wi cam si t org na c mpl i t ()Pli if
he m e tl nl oc e
he olo ng l i n he ii l o a n : 1 antf s
3 ca m a a n tde e ntHi e a g i Co 7 ( Pl i if cam ag i tt Do
l i g i s f nda
nd l n n unt ; 2) antf s li ans be e
4 de e da si Co 8;( Co 1 ( Coun 1 a ( )Co 1
f n nt n unt 3) unt 2; 4)
t 3; nd 5 unt 4.
5

Thecourtcokl notha been m or cear Thec r m oton f l vet am end
td
ve
e l .
ur ent
i or ea o

6 andpr e amendedcom pl ntdiecl vi at atl tt c tor s (
opos d
ai r ty ol es ems wo our der . Doc.# 5and

7 Doc # 26. I s e t a nd c t t twe ep e o l dimis dbytl c ur G :A
.
) t e ks o me oun s ha r r vi usy s s e
le o t .
I

8 pr j c .Pli ifhm s tf rh novai bm i t a e t c l i .Ac o d ngy,
eudie antf s e o t
ld ss o m nd he omp a nt c r i l
9 Pl ntf M oton f Le t Am endt c
ai ifs i or ave o
he ompl nti 3: c OO1 Lm 1(
ai n o9-v- O9RAM )(
'DOc.#

1 4 i de i d.
0 2) s n e
.
1 D.M odon f Leave t Am e i 3: cv oo1 O1
or
o
nd n o9- - 1 LQH (
RAM )(
Doc.i 43)
1
2

Pl ntf ied a t r M oton f Leavet Am end t com pl ntfl i 3: c
ai iffl
hid
i or
o
he
ai ied n o9- v-

1 ool o-u l ( AM ) ( .# 4 ) l t sa ton, hec ur dim is d Co s1 3, 6, 9,
3
l ll ' R. . Doc 3. n hi c i t o t s s e unt , 4, 8,
tl

1 l ,1 a 1 wih pr j c .( .# 1 i 3: c - 1 LRH ( )) Thec ul as
4 1 3 nd 4, t eudie Doc 4 n O9-V OO1 ORAM .
o ' lo
t
1 dim i e de endant Boar ofCom m i s oner ofCar on Ciy,Furong,M ays Lee,Colazo,
5 s ss d f
.
s
d
si s
s
t
l
,
l

1 a Jo DoePo iy M a r wih p eudie @d. Thec ts cfc l or r dt tt
6 nd hn
lc - ke t r j c . )
our pe iialy de e ha he
1 Am e
7
nded Com pl ntw oul pr ed on Count 2,5, 1 and 1 agai tDef ndant Fai,
ai
d oce
s
' O,
7,
2
ns
e
s r

l W al Ra s y, gt Doe # 1 # 2 # 3 a # 4, nd De yDoe # 1 # 2 # 3, nd # 4.(d.
8
l, m e S . s , ,
nd
a
put
s , , a
f )
1
9

De e
f ndant ar cor ec t tPl i ifsm oton t am end s lst r vi c ai st t
s e r t ha a ntf'
i o
eet o e ve l m ha

2 we edimis dV :Zpr j c o s r e ng The ei novai ba i f P a n ift
0
r s s e . eudie n c e ni . r s
I
ld ss or l j tf o
21 am end hi c pl nti t sr d.Ther f e,Pl ntf ' M oton f Lea t Am end i
s om ai n hi egar
e or ai ifs
i or ve o
n

22 a: c ool o-al'I
og-v- l ll.l RAM Ii denid.
l
s
e

2 E.M ot on t Eu end Di cover (
3
l o
s
y Doc.# 57)& M oton f I s
i or s unnc ofSubpoenas
e
2 (
4 Doc.# 46)
25
On J y1 201 ,P a n ifam o i t e e t dic ve yde d i .( . 5 )
ul 3, 1 l i tf
ton o xt nd he s o r a lne Doc # 7.
26 On Augts 1 2011 Pl ntf ed a notc ofhi i lt t pr d bec e hehasnot
lt 2,
, ai iffl
ie
s nabiiy o ocee
aus

27 be ngie pe .( c # 61) l g a tngt l s e t nson o d s o e yd a i st
e v n ns Do . . n r n i he m t x e i f ic v r e dlne he
28

6

.

*

1 c ul ce rya
o ' l a l dmonihe t pa te ,rt he s lbe no f her e ens ons oft e
t
s d he r is ' l re hal
l
urt
xt i
hes
2 de i a entex aor nar c r um s anc . ( .# 30. Pli f sha
adlnes bs
lr al y l c
t es' Doc
'
) andf hm d
3 m or t enough tm et c
e han
i o onduc di co y i eac oft secms . M or
t s ver n h he
es
eover,Pl ntf
ai ifs
4 a er ed r on f r ques i t ext i t thehasbeen una e t pr
ss t ems or e
thg he ens on, ha
bl o ocur pensf om
e
r
5 NDOC, sbe i by t f tt Pl ntf
i led
he ac hat ai ifhasfl and c
ied
ondnuest fl docum ent i t e
o ie
s n hes

6 c ns lda e a to .P ai if sno s tf ' a e ta r na ycr um sa e msiyi
o o i t d c ins l ntf hm t e ol. ny x r o di r ic t nc sj tf ng
f
h
7 an ext nsi oft c r di over deadlne.Fi l any m otonst e end t deadlnes
e on he ur ent sc y
i
naly,
i
o xt
he
i

8 w e et be r ce ved by t c tno l t t t
r o
e i
he our
a er han went one da be or t dicove y c of
p
ys f e he s
r ut f
9 dat ofJul 22,201 LR 26- Pl ntf a t i est undm e i soft m oton t hi
e
y
1.
4. ai if t rbut he
lnes
he
i o s
l t ans erbe
0 r f
tween i ttz i yhowe headm i. t swmscom pl t d on June 22,201 l .
ns i tons
a
ver
t hi
s
ee
1. n

1 viw o t f c t tPli if no pr s nt d e t a r na ycr ums a e ts i ng
1 e f he a t ha a ntf hms t e e e x r o di r ic t nc sjutf
yi
1 an ext nsi oft di coyer de i t e wilbe no f t de aysi t s m at er The
2
e on he s
y adlne, her l
ur her l n hi
t .
1 m oton t ext di over i deni d) i. t exc i oft pos i e is
3
i o end sc y s
e w t be ept on he sbl s uanceof
h

1 s
4 ubpoen% aspr de be ow .
ovi d l
1
5

On June2,201 ,prort t di over deadlne,Pl ntf e a m oton f is
1 i o he sc y
i
ai iffl d
i or s uanc
e

1 o s e s ( c # 46. Deen nt o j c e ( cDoc # 5 ) Pli ifr q s sfv
6 f ubpo na . Do .
) f da s b e t d. Sc
. 5. a ntf e ue t ie
l bl s
7 ank ubpoenmssgned unders oft coul t i uei t ec es.(
i
eal he ' o ss n hes as Doc.# 46.
t
)
l De endant ar t Pl ntf
8
f
s gue hat ai ifhmsa r
l eady propot ded an unr ona e am ountof
m
ems bl

1 d s ov r i t sma t r ( .# 5 ) De e n sur et c t lmi dic e yby
9 ic e y n hi te . Doc 5. f nda t g he oud o i t s ov r
20 r quii t tPl i tf ()s bmi als o t s i di i ua shepl nst s
e rng ha a n if 1 u t it f ho e n v d l
a o ubpoe p i rt
na ro o
21 t is eofanys
he s uanc
ubpoenas;and ( makeas ngt tanydicover soughtt r n i
2)
howi ha
s
y
he ei s

22 no ob ana efom s eo he s ur e. @d.
t t i bl r om t r o c
)
23

The c ti awar oft vol eofdicover pr
our s
e he um
s
y opounded by Pl ntf i t eca es.
ai i f n hes s

2 T eeoe tec u tid Dee d nss g eto rm o a l a dd ne Pan i'moin
4 h rfr,h o r'n s fn a t'u j sin es n be n e is litfs to
l
f
25 f rt is nc o s e s( .#46 , t utpr j c .Pl i tf ma r ne hi
o he s ua e f ubpo nm Doc
) wiho eudi e a n' f y e w s
i
26 moton f t isuanc ofs
i or he s
e ubpoenaspr de hedoess wihi lAeen (1 daysoft s
ovi d
o t n
5)
hi
27

28

7

1 or ra c ur e tys is ( ) als o t ei vi l hepl nst s bpoe ; d (
de nd onc r n l ubm t : 1 it f hos ndi duas
a ou
na an 2)
2 a s i t any di ove y s
how ng hat
sc r oughtvi s
a ubpoe i notobt nabl f om s e ot s c
na s
ai e r
om
her our e.
3

CO N CLU SIO N

4

I I H EREBY O RD ER ED :
T S

5

()Pl i fsM o in f Le v o Ame i 3: c OOO42- k RAM )( c #36 i
1 andf' to or a et
nd n O9-vL1H(
Do . ) s

6 D EN I D ;
E

7

( Pl i if Mo in f r Re ii o Or r Sub e t t FRCP 5
2) antf s to o vson f de s j c o
409 ( .# 41 i
Doc
)s

8 D EN IED ;

9

( Pl i if M otonf rLe v t Am e i 3: c - o9 LRH(
3) antf s i o a e o
nd n o9-v oo1 RAM )( . 42)i
Doc #
s

10 D EN IED ;

1
1

.

( Pl i if M o i f rLe vet Ame i 3: c OO1 O4) antf s ton o a o
nd n O9-v- 1 LRH(
RAM )( . 43)i
Doc #
s

1 D EN IED ;
2

1
3

( Pl i ifsM o int Er e Dic ve y( c #57 i N ED e c p f t os il
5) antf
to o
nd s o r Do . )sDr
x e t or hep sb e

1 is
4 s uanc ofs
e ubpoenasmsouti above;
lned

1
5

( )Pli if M o i nf rt I s nc o Su e s( c # 46 i DENI w ihout
6 a ntf' to o he s ua e f bpo na Do . ) s
s
ED t

l pr l ce.Pli if yr e smoinf rt is nc o s e spr ie hedo ss
6 e udi
antfma en whi to o he sua e f ubpo nm ovd d
e o
1 wihi Gleen ( 5)daysof hi or rands bmis ( ) als of ho ei ci d l hepl st
7 tn
1
t s de
u t : 1 it t s n l ua s
vi
an o
1 s
8 ubpoena;and ( as ngt anydi ove ysoughtvi s
2) howi hat
sc r
a ubpoenai notobt na efom
s
ai bl r
1 s e otl rs c
9 om
le our e.
20 DATED: Augus

,2011
.

2l

X

22

UN I
TED STATES M AGI
STM TE JUDGE
23
24

25
26
27

28

g