Powell v. Gibbons et al

Filing 18

ORDERED P's # 16 Motion to file excess pages is GRANTED. FURTHER ORD the # 17 Amended complaint is DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE. FURTHER ORD Clerk SHALL ENTER JUDGMENT accordingly. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 10/20/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM) (Main Document 18 replaced on 10/22/2010) (DRM). (Main Document 18 replaced on 10/22/2010) (DRM).

1 2

3
4

5 6 7 UNITED STATES DISTR I T CO UR T C DISTR I T O F NEVA D A C

8 KI RI H A. TC POW ELL, 9 Pli tf, an if 1 vs 0.

11 J M ES GI BON S, al, A B et . 1 2
13

Dee da t . fn n s

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
/

3: 9 c - 009 - CJ RAM 0 -v 0 3R ORDER

1 4

Thi i acvi rg t a to fld p -ua tt 42U. . .j 1 83.OnFe rzz 26, 0, s s i l ih s cin ie m s n o SC 9 b t y 201 a

1 te Ctuz d rctdpli tf t fl ana e de c mpli twihn ti' d y . ( oc e /1 ) Pli tf 5 h l t ie e an if o ie m n d o an ti hzy a s D k t/ 1 . a nif t l r q e t d a dt i Co z p-ntd t ' e t n insoftm et fl t ea e d dc m pli t ( oc e #1 6 e u se , n b s u t a e , wo x e so i o ie h m n e o an . D k t 3
1 a d#1 ) OnJ l 26, 0, l itf fld a a e de c m pli t ( oc e /1 ) Plitf a s fld 7 n 5. u y 201 p an if ie n m n d o an . D k t / 7 . an if lo ie

1 amoto t fl e c s pa e .( oc e /1 ) TheCo r ha r viwe t ea en e c m pli t ndg a t 8 i n o ie x e s g s D k t/ 6 . u t s e e d h m d d o an a r n s
19 pettoner' m oton t fl exces pages.H ow eve ,on r vi w oft eam endedcompl i t t eCour fnds ii s i o ie s r ee h an , h ti 20 t atpl i tf scli sar untm el ,fi ol us, ot e wi ef i t sat acogni abl f de alci i lght h a n if a m e i y rv o and h r s a l o t e z e e r v li s
21 cl i . am 22 1. Screeni g St ndard na

23

Purua tt tePls ne Lii aim Re o m ActI LRAI f de lc ursmu tdim isa s n o l io r tg tc f r z P ,e m o t s s s

24 pl s ner' cl i s,li t e alegaton ofpovery i untue,'ori tl acton ti fi ol us orm alci us' i o s a m if h l i t s r ' f le i ts rv o i o ,' 25 tf ist s t acl i on whi h r lefm aybegr nt d,'orçs e sm onet r r lefagai s adef ndant ho 6a l o t e a m c ei a e ' te k ay ei nt e w

26 i i m t efom s c r le . 28U. . . 1 l ()2) 28U. . . 1 1 A .Dim is lo ac m pli tf r s m m r u h eif' ' S C # 9 5 e( , ' SC j 9 5 s s a f o an o

1 f iur t sat a cl i upon whi h r lef m ay be gunt d i pr vi ed f r i Fede alRul of Ci i al e o t e am c ei e sod on r e vl

2 Pr c d r 1 ( )6) a dt eCour a pi st es m esa d r u de Se to 1 1 ( )2 whe r v e i g o e ue 2b ( , n h t p le h a tn a d n r cin 9 5 e ( ) n e iw n
3 t e a equacy ofa com pl i toram ended com pl i t hd an an .

4

Re iw und rRu e1 1 )6)i e s nta l ar lngonaq e tonoflw .Se Ch ppe v ve e l 2 ( s se ily ui u si a e a l.

5 Lab r t l Cop.fzme ia, 32F.d71 ,7 3( t Ci. 00) Dim is lf rfiur t saeac am o a oy r o q rc 2 3 9 2 9 h r 20 . s s a o al e o tt l i
6 i pr peronl i i i clart attl pl i tf c nrotpr ve any s toff ct ils ppel oft e cl i t at so y f t s e h le a n if a l o e a s r u ' h am h t

7 wo l e ttehi o he t r le .S eM ore v Wale ,l F. d75 , 9( t Ci.1 9 ) I ma i g u d n il m r r o e if e ly . k r 75 3 6 75 9 h r 9 9 . n k n
8 t i det r i aton,t eCourtt kesast uea1 alegatonsofmat ralf ctst t d i tl eompl i t and t e hs em n i h a r Il i e i a a e n le an, h
9 Cour c nsnz st em i t elghtmos f vor bl t t epli tf. See War haw v.Xoma Cow . 74 F. d to t e h n h i t a a e o h an if s , 3

1 955 9 7 ( t Ci.1 96 . Ale ainsi apr s c mpli ta eh l t ls srnge tsa da d t a 0 , 5 9 h r 9 ) lg to n o e o an r ed o e s ti n tn r s h n
11 f r a pla i g dr fe bylwy r .Se Ht he v At e 4 9U. . 9( 98 ) Hai e v. r e , 4 o m l e d n s a td a e s e t s . p , 4 S 5, 1 0 , n s Ke n r 40 g w '

1 U. .51 ,52 - 1( 9 2 +e c ramj s et&tBalsr r v Pac c Polc De h 901F.d69 ,69 2 S 9 0 2 1 7 ) r u i ; e z ) ite i . s a ie p 269
1 ( t Ci.1 9 ) 3 9h r 9 0 .
14 A 1orpart acom pl i tfl d byaprsonerm ay t er f r bedim i seds as ont i t e 1 of a n ie i h eo e s s u p e fh
l5 pr s nerscl i s l ck an ar uabl basi eiheri l w or i f ct Thi i cl descl i sbased on l gal io ' am a ge s t na n a . sn u am e

1 c n l so sta a et t n bl ( . . li sa ans de e da t who a elnr u efo s i o cam so 6 o c u i n h t r m e a e cg cam g i t fn n s r ' n n rm ut r li f r
1 ifige e tofalga i tr s whihce rydo sno e its swela cai sba e onfncf l a t a 7 n rn m n e ln e e t c la l e t xsl a l s l m s d a iu f ct l z

l a lgai ns( . .a tsi ord l so a s e a i s.S eNetk v Wila s 490U. . 9, 27 28( 98 ) 8 le to cg fn a tc eu in l c n ro ) e i e . li m , z S 31 3 - 1 9 ' ,
1 s ealoM c e v rv Bl c ,93 F.d 79 ,79 ( t Ci 1 91 . 9 e s K e e . o k 2 2 5 8 9h n 9 )

2 f. TleAme de Compl i t( oc e /1 ) 0Il nd an D k t/7
21 22 CountI Pl i tf aleges t e f low i g:O n Ja uar 1 ,2003,at Hi h D es r Stt Pr s n, a n if l h ol n n y6 g e t e io

23 d f nda tRihe lf h sa sgn dpos a pod2C- .( m . m pl,a p.1 ) Theo lc d o t pod ee n c y e t i si e t t D A Co . t 9 . fi e o r o
2 2 wa br ke a d f ie t s cze y s ut Pl i tf wa o t al - l ne' sa u , i p ot e i e 4D s o n n a ld o e l l h . a n if s n ç k a o ' t t s n r e tv r w
25 s gr gaton, e e i andwasa hi h rs of ei gatacked.Def ndantc am don alow edorf iedt sopl m at s t g ik b n t e l al o t ' ne

26 Des h m p,Va d m a l a d St cuna fom c m i g t r ug t e po 2 b oke do r a l w i g t e ca n e l, n e l n r o n h o h h d D r n o , lo n h m

2

1 a c s t po 2 , er pli tf wa h us d.(J.a p. 0) Theim ae at c e hi .(#..W hl c e s o d C wh e an if s o e . , t 2 . r n ts ta k d m f ) ie
2 hew asbei g atacked byt ei m at s,def ndantCam don s otpli tf i t er ghtsde ofhi back and nt hn e e h a n if n h i i s

3 hpwihlft t )hot nselwhihc ntie afrinla s bsa c a do ohe s bsa ces al i t iol 4 s gu h ls c o an d oeg ed u tn e n /r t r u tn ,m l r
4 ba tre t a a eus dt ta kplitf, olo i gpli tf byGPS s se . (#..Pli tf a lg st a te is h t r e o rc a niff lw n an if y tm ' f ) an if le e h t '
5 def ndantCam don f ied t sop t e i m at s f om a t cki g hl . Pl i tf aleges t athe s fer d e al o t h n e r ta n ' m a n if l h uf e

6 pe na e tbodiy ij r ,e oto a dite s a d ta t e ta kng de ie wee twe ke b GPS n nn l n u y m i n l srs , n l t h r c i l vc s r t e d y t
7 s se sta ca s di tns pai a altm e ofd y a ni h s l s ofse p,si gng s ns tos, a dj y tm h t u e n e e n t l i s a , t g t,o s le tn i e a irs ( n

8 ts ueda a e. tJ. a p .1 - 4) is m g ' f , t p 9 2 . '
9 Pl i tf ' cl i ofdelber t i dif r ncet saf t i ban-dbyt esat t oflm iatons. a n if s a m i a e n fee o ey s e h t ue i t i

1 Be a s j 1 8 c nt i snos e ii sa t oflm i tons f dea c u t s oud bo r w sa esa t s 0 c u e 9 3 o an p cic tm e i m i , e r l o rs h l ro tt tm e

11 oflm iai ns f rpe s na ij z a to si j 1 8 s is. Se ,eg. Walac v Kat ,5 9 U. .38 i tto o r o l nu y ci n l 9 3 u t e . , l e . o 4 S 4 l 1 ( 0 7) I Ne a a,a pe s n lij l a to mu tbe br ug twihi t o ye l . Ne .Re .Sft 2 20 . n vd ro a n u' cin s y o h t n w as v v a. 1 l .90( )e . Pl itf alg sa fiur t pr tc hi fo atc b ot e im aest a oc ure i 3 1 1 4 () an if le e al e o o e t m r m ta k y h r n t h t c r d n
1 2003,appr xi at l s xyeal bef r he fl d t e orgi alcom pl i ti t i acton.As s ch,pl i tf ' 4 o m ey i s o e ie h i n an n h s i u an if s 1 delbe at i dif r nce cl i i dim i s d asuntm el . 5 i r e n fee am s s s e iy

16

Rega di gpl i tf ' cl i t atdef nda tCam don s othl wih GPS ta ki g devi es, r n a n if s a m h en h't m rc n c

l7 t i alegaton i fi ol us A f i ol uscl i t atl cksa ar uabl basseiheri 1 w ori f ctmus h s l i s rv o . rv o am h a n g e i t na na t

1 be dim i s d.Pl i tf ' c a m i ba e on f nc f l a tt la l ga i nsofha i g GPS ta k ng de i e 8 s se a n if s l i s s d a iu f c t le to a vn rc i vc s
19 i pl nt d il i e hi body. Thes alegatons ar f nt stc and del sonal and t e cl i s al be m a e rsd s el i ea ai ui , h am h l

20 dim is dasfi oous Se Neiz e v Wilams 49 U. .31 ,327 28 ( 989 ,s ealoM c e v rv s se rv l . e tk . li , 0 S 9 - 1 ) e s K e e . . 21 Bl c , 32F.d79 , 98( t Ci. 9 1 .Cou t1sdim is dwihprj diea u t eya dfiolus o k 9 2 5 7 9 h r 1 9 ) n i s s e t eu c s n i l n rv o . m
22 Cotnt11 l

23

Pl i tf aleges t at on Apr l 1 , 2006 and J l 1 , 2006,uni entted m airoom a n if l h i0 uy 9 d ii l

2 pe s n e a E1 Stt Prs n o e e ic m i gmalo ti eo hi p e e ce ( m . 4 ro n l t y ae io p n d n o n i u sd f s r s n . A Compl, tp. 5) .a 2 ,
25 Pl i tf alegest ati Febnl r 2008,l galm ai addr s e t an ator ey wasr tlne t hi beca se a n if l hn ay e l esd o tn e tr , o m d u 26 t e atom ey was no l ngeratt ataddr s ,and tl r t nl d mai was cpened out i e ofpl l tf ' ht o h es le e u e l sd a if s

3

1 pr s nc a dte tdasr gulrmal (t ) OnAptl26, 06, antf s ntou g i gSe alp ron l e e e n r ae e a i. ff . ' 20 pli if e t o n l g e s a i l

2 mait afih-a e og niain,but lc e s fiintfndsfrp sa e.(J.a p. .Mah o lo at b s d ra z to ' he a k d ulce u o o tg f , t 26) io m '
3 s f r t rnedt el ter t pl i tf,i f rm i ghi t athehadaleadyus dbi lm i ofpos age f rA prl m feu h e t s o an if n o n m h r e si t to i

4 tr ug M a 2 06.(d..OnJ l 11 2 06 pli tf atmptdt malalte b twa de i dp sa e ho h y 0 I ) uy , 0 , an if te e o i e tr u s n e o tg

5 o c a an. (J.. Pli tf co tndst a t e ei cde t rpr s ntapoiy ofc ns rhi ,an min e g i f ) an if n e h t h s n i n s e e e lc e os p d s 6 r u ig hi lga a dpes na malfo 2 06- 01 .(d. a pp. - 7) o tn s e l n r o l i r m 0 2 0 1 , t 25 2 .
7 Pl i tf ' alegatons f i t s a e a cogni a l cl i f rr let Prs ner have a Fis a n if s l i a l o tt z b e a m o e i l io s rt

8 Ame dm e trgh t s nd a d r c i emal Wihe ow v Pa.i5 F.d 26 ,2 5 ( t Ci.1 95 ( e n n i t o e n e ev i. t r . j 2 3 4 6 9h r 9 ) p r ;
9 c ru ) Howe e , ifo pubf a e ce , ublcofii l, iï rghsgr ups al n wsme i ma u im . v rmal rm lc g n is p i lca s cv l i t o , rd e da y

1 beo e e ou sdet ep io e s pr s nc .Mannv Ad ms 8 6F.d58 ,5 0- 1( tCi.1 8 )( e 0 p n d ti h rs n r ' e e e . a , 4 2 9 9 9 9h r 9 8 p r
l1 c rum l Prs nsa eno r q ie t pr vi ei di e tprs neswih t l ie pad posa ef rter u i . io r t e u r d o o d n g n io r t m i td i tg o h i m

1 o toigmal (d) Plitf fist saeac g ia l cai , ndCou t1sds isdwihprj die. 2 ug n i.1 .. anifal o tt o nz be l m a n 1i im se t eu c
13 CountH 1

1 4

Pl i tf al ge a p lc wih n t eN e a aDe a t e t Co r c i nsofde yi gc r a n if le s o i y t i h v d p rm n of r e to n n ae

15 f rhi physi aland m e K lw el- ei g.Pli tf alegesatcons i-cybet een oneorm or def ndant os c na lb n a n if l t pl a w ee s

1 t eoverup t e il gal i tusve,hi h t ch devi esi sde pl i tf ' body'f om 1 96 t r ugh 201 . 6o - h le , n r i ge c ni a n if s 'r 9 ho 0

1 ( m .Compl, a p.28 . Pli tf ale e tat d f n a t ma e a t te pt t hav pli tf 7A .t ) an if lg s h e e d n s d n l tm o e an if a
l8 def cat / xpelahi h t ch de i ei pl i tf'ssom ach by havi gpl i tf s eagas oi t s i aldoct r e ee ge v c n a n it t n a n if e k n e tn o 19 i Las V egas,N evada. Pl i tf aleges t at tdef ndant knew t e hi h t ch devi e w as put i n ' a n if l ' h te s h ge c n

2 plitf ' f od ie s (nd medcai ns ?)Hih De e tStt Prs n a d by o e ormo e nu s so 0 an ifs o tm a l i to i g s r a e io n n r re r
21 c re to a ofie sfo 20 4 2005a ds i de iei sili pli tf' som a h.'( m .Compl, t o r c in l lc r rm 0 n ad v c s tl n an ifs t c ' A .a

2 p. l. 2 3)
23 Pl i tf s le a i nsa es f c al f l iul t m a et ec a m f i ol us A fi ol us a n if a l g to r o a m l m c f as o k h l i rv o . rv o y
24 cl i t atl cks an ar ua l bass eiheri 1 w ori f ctmus be dim i s d. Pl i tf ' a l ga i ns am h a g be i t n a na t s se a n if s le to 25 r gar i g a tcons iacy behvee one orm or def nda t t cover up t e il gal i m t i e,hi h t ch e dn t pr n e e ns o - h le , n sv ge 26 devi esi si epl i tf ' body' ar patnty f nt si and del sonal SeeNeizke v.M li m s,490 U. . c n d a n i fs ' e e l a tc ui . t la S

4

l 31 ,3 7- 8 ( 989 ,s e alo Mc e v rv Bl c ,9 2 F.d 795 79 ( t Ci.1 91 . Co mtIIi 9 2 2 1 ) e s K ee . o k 3 2 . , 8 9h r 9 ) t I s

2 dimisdwihprj dieasfiolus s se t eu c rv o .
3 CountI V

4

Pl i tf alegest aton Aprl26,2004,def ndantCol M or ow i f nnedpl i tf t at an if l h i e e r no a n if h

5 s m eofhi i m at greva ceshad been l s.D ef ndantM or ow as ed pl i tf t si n hvodoc m ent o sn e i n ot e r k a n if o g u s

6 pe ti ig t teg iva c s ( m . ran n o h re n e . A Compl, tp.3 ) .a 4 .
7 Pl i tf f ist sat a cogni abl cl i i CountI .Prioner haveno cons i tonal an i f a l o t e z e am n V ss tm i

8 rghtt a im at gre a c s se . Olm v.Wakne o a, U. . 2 9 ( 983 .Thus t en n i o n n e iv n e y tm i i k n 461 S 238, 4 1 ) ,h o 9 exi t nceof ort e f iur ofpr s n ofk il t pr pery i pl m entan adm i itatveappeal pr ces se , h al e io t a s o o l m e n sr i so s 10 wihi t eprs n s sem doesnotr i e cons iutonalconcer s Btckly v.Bar ow ,997 F. d 494,495 t n h io y t as tt i n. t e l 2

11 ( t Ci.1 93 ,Flc v Al a,93 F.d 7 8 ( t Ci.1 91 .'A prs njg iva c p oc dte i a 8 h r 9 ) ik . b ' 2 2 2 8h r 9 ) ' io re n e r e tr s E
1 pr cedt alrghtonl ,i doesnotconf rany s bsantve rghtupon t e i m at s.'Buckly,997 F. d at 2 omi yt e uti i h n e' e 2

l 495( ii gzz c v De o e ts 568F. pp. ,1 ( . . 1.1 8 ) s ealoMannv Adams 8 5F.d 3 ctn l e z . R b ri, Su 8 0 N D 11 9 2 * e s , . ,5 2 1 6 9,64 ( t Ci.1 8 ) l- n e i doe n tgi ers t a pr tce lbe t i tr s r q ii g t e 4 3 0 9h r 9 8 . tl c , t s o v ie o o e td i ry n e e t e u rn h le
1 pr cedur lpr t ctonsenvi i ned by t e Fomteent Am endm ent' zt cc v.DeRoberi ,568 F.Supp. 5 o a oe i so h h 'zz ts

1 a 1 *S e c rv M oor ,638 F.Su p.31 ,31 ( . .M o.1 8 ) Thus a prs n sa fme be ' 6 t 0, p n e . e p 5 6 ED 9 6. , io tf m rs
1 i vol e entand actorsr gar i g an i r at ' greva cecannots r e ast ebasi f rlabiiy undera 7 n vm i l e dn n n es i n ev h s o i lt

1 j1 8 a ton.Bu ke , F.da 495 Pli tf ma not i t i a a tona ans de e da t 8 9 3 ci c ly 997 2 t . an if y man an n ci g i t fn n Monow

1 b sdonhi a tos rgadil plitf'i naegiva ce.Co n I i dimis dwihpeudie a 9 ae s cirs e r lg anifs m t re n s u t V s s se t rj c , s
20 t er i no cogni abl cl i f rvi l ton ofpl i tf ' cons iutonallght . h es z e am o o ai a n if s tt i is 21 CountV

22

Pl i tf aleges t atM C lW ordc om ,Gl balTelLi k,I Sol tons,NDO C phone a n if l h l o nC ui

23 adm i i tat l and sever l nam ed def ndant pl ce t i h t ch audi / iualdevi es i / round/ n n s os a e s a d ûg e h ovs c na o

2 plitf, sro sa dorondo r,lg tfxtrs orohe obet,(ndli wae'fr el a Hih 4 anifhi o m n / o s ih i ue, t r j cs a n tr'om ry t g
25 De e t a ePrs n, n c re tya El Stt Prs n.( m . s r Stt io a d u r nl t y ae io A Compl, t 35 .Pl i tf alge t a t e .a p. ) an if le s h t h

26 çlg tc de ie, u i viua,so edgtli ag so artiva sse . (d, tp. 6) Ono a out çih e h vc sa do s l tr iia m e n ere l y tm ' 1 .a 3 . r b l '
5

I M ay 1 ,2005, e dant Pr t r, s cr f,Hart Dudl yandot erdef ndant ti f ct d pl i tf ' f od 2 def n s ae A h a t , e h e s fn e e a n ifs o

2 ta s fo ie s@ HihDesr Stt Prs n, d21 (n lc n e ldt xcsbsa c si co di e t ry ,o d tm g et ae io Po 7 a d o c ae o i u tn e n n m n 3 p c es orot e f odie st a c us dpli tf t pa sbood i soo f ra ou amont . (#.a p. a k t, h r o t m h t a e an if o s l n t l o b t h' f , t '
4 36 . antf wa a m itdt t ei tr a ya HihDesr Smt Prs nfo l ne2- , 005,orm e ial ) Pli if s d te o h n im r t g e t e io r m u 7 2 f dc

5 obs r ai n a d tsi g.(t ) Pli tf wa t e r tr e t Pod 2 - A.(d4 Pli tf alge t a e v to n e tn ff . an if s h n eu n d o D 1 1 . a n if le s h t
6 fr m June21- 9, o 2 2005, endant As cr f a d Har ti f ct d pl i tf ' f od and/ rtayswihat xi def s h atn t en e e a n ifs o or t oc
7 subsancecausi g pl i tt snos t swel up,bl e spont neousl ,cause ahi h f ver uncontolabl t n a n ir eo l ed a y d ge , rl e

8 s a i g, a a h s (ndjblrye e iht@ HihDesr Stt Pls n. (d.a p. .Pli tf frh r h kn he d c e , a u r y sg g e t ae i o ' 1 , t 37) an if u te '
9 alegest atdef ndant Pr t rand D udl y û ons ied wih a bl ck i m at portratHi h Des rtSt t l h e s ae e t pr c t ane e g e ae
10 Prs n ,Pod 29 - 3 hous d,t have t ati m at puton pl i tf s f od tay a t xi s bsance t at io 1 eo hne a n if o r o cu t h

11 s bs que ty causedpli tf ' eyestlbecomebl ry,rngi g i ear ,nosebl eds, u e nl a n i fs t ur i n n s e headachesandsl er iv

1 o jcsmaeil ig i plitf sii,whih ae usd asc meat viw plitf' wrtng a d 2 be t trai n n anip rs c r e z a r o e anifs ii s n
1 tansf r di iali agest comput z orot erel ctoni devi esorgl bal osii ni gdevi es pl i tf ' 3 r es gt m o es h er c s o p to n c ; a n ifs

1 e l,h a ,fc , c mt r a b r wih hih f ve fo t e e o j csa d/ rtos a tvai g t e by 4 as e d a e ne k h o t u n t g e r r m h s b e t n o h e c i t h m n 1 hih tc de i e see tialo s tlie' (d. a pp.37- 8 . On Se tm be 26,20 5 d f n a t 5 g e h vc s lcrc r ae lt.' 1 , t 3) pe r 0 , ee d n
16 Cr s m an and s pel i or per onnelatEl St t Prion cons ied t have Epl ced i / n pl i tf ' os u ws y s y ae s pr o ia n o a n ifs

1 b ownp pe ta hba i 38- 3,ali htc a di/ iua d vi e' (t,a p. ) Pli tf as e t ta 7r a r rs g n 3 lg e h u o v s l e c . 1L t 38 . an if s rs h t '
18 def ndant M CIW ordcom and ot el ihave pl ce audi / i ualdevi es ilpl i tf s r om s lght , e s l h 'i s a ov s c l a n if o , i s 19 door ,or ot er fxm r s boxes ta h bags ai vent,wals snk ar a,beds,orili e pl i tf 'a d s h i e, , rs ,r s l, i e rs d a n if n

2 c ns ie wih 1w e f re e ta d Ne a a De a t e tofCore tonsofi il. (J. a p.3 ) 0 o p r d t a n o c m n n v d p rm n r ci fc as f , t 9 .
21 Pl i tf f rhe a l g st at t oxi s bsan e' a c n e l d i hi b e k a tta , n t e p r c c fe a n if u t r le e h a t c u t c 'w s o c a e n s r a f s ry i t e ih o f e t d

22 pa kes'a dwe e1 txttelkefe z d idu lkefn powe ' (t) Pli tf a s rst a t et xi c t, n r 6 e t i re e re n i ie ' a r n ' fi . an if se t h th o c
23 s bsance i t e cof ee packet was an atem pt û o have pl i tf def cat t e hi h t c devi e i ut nh f s t t t a n if e e h g e b cn

2 p anifslf sdeo so a hora pe di a e s o t c ntol an ifsbo iyf nc ins' (J..He 4 l itf ' e t i f t m c p n x r a , r o o r pli tf d l u to . f ) '
25 al o alegest atçuseoft ephonecausespl i tf ' f ce,head,ear t tu' r d/ ot'duet wieà ppi g sl hf h a n if s a so tn e h ' or n

26 wih h g tc a di de ie .@J) Pli tf a s rst a de e da t't ius oft ehi htc de ie ' t i h e h u o v c s . an if s e t h t fn n s t s e h g e h v c s' m
6

1 e us sva iusph sc ls mpt m s a welase o inalta m a l s ofse p,fa , n a ge .(d,a a e ro y ia y o , s l m to ru ,o s le e r a d n r 1 . t

2 p. 0) 4.
3 Pl i tf ? alegatonsa es f ct alyf nciulast m aket ecl i f i ol us A f i ol us a n ifs l i r o a u l a f o h a m rv o . rv o 4 cl i t atl cks an ar uabl bas s eiheri l w ori f ctm us be di m ised. Pl i tf' alegatons am h a g e i t na na t ss a n its l i

5 r g r i gç ihtc a di / iua de i e 'bengplc di hi s rom digst i c l,h wa e , sf od, ' e a dn i g e h u o v s l vc s' i a e n s u r t n h s elt e t rhi o h

6 txur s bo e ,ta h b gs arv nt, l,snka e ,be s ec. a di hi bod a epae ty fntsi i t e , x s r s a , i e s wals i r a d , t ) n n s y r tn l a a tc 7 a dd l so a.Se Netk v Wilams 4 0U. . 9,3 7- 8( 98 ) s ealoM c ee e v Bl c , 2 n eu i n l e i e . li , 9 S 31 2 2 1 9 ; e s K v r . o k 93 z

8 F.d7 5,79 ( tlCi.1 91.Cou tV i dimisdwihprj diea fiolu . 2 9 8 9l r 9 ) n s s se t eu c s rv o s
9 CountVI

1 0

Pli tf a lg st a d fn a t ha ee ga e i aç usom ofg l cng a doa dviua an if le e h t e e d n s v n g d n t t c pa i ) u i n s l

l1 devi est ats or di ia i ageson com put r an. ot erel ctoni devi e w ili E1 Smt Prs n .. c h t e g tl m es d h er c c s ttn y e io

1 .i pli tf sr o ( el ... ndot e r o s r c y r ,s o e s' ( m . 2 n anif o m c ll a h r o m , e - a d h w r . A Compl, tp. .Pl itf ' .a 42) an if 1 a s rstat t t e ede ie , e e d nt wil r aet lee i a e o pli tf oro j c si hi r om ' 3 s e t h wih h s vc s d f n a s lc e t t tr d m g s f an if b e t n s o ' a 1 t a de ithi çi aflelg to hi tu i a e' (#.a p . 43 .Pli tf alge ta ta di a d 4 h t p c m tn a s ih f s r e m g . f , t p 42- ) an if le s h t çu o n '
15 viualdevi esar i s ow er ,onr om doors f od sot , wals, s c en h s o , o l s on l onpr pert,i pi es condui,mbl s o yn p , t e,

1 ee tia s r es onot e ob e t, itwihi tepi es foo s wa lv ds snks t ies i wae ,n 6 lcrc l u g , h r j cs bu l t n h p , l r , ls be , i . o lt,n tr i 1 ars se . (#.a p. ) Pli tf al g st a tei i,t c de i e 'c u elox cs el i pli tf ' 7 i y tm ' f , t 43 . an if le e h th t g e h vc s' a s * i m ls n an ifs ' hh t
18 r om ,bedst vi rat ,foort vi r t ,i ht t tiker orot e r om fxtlest r cei ehi h ener y fow o o b e l o b a e lg s o lc , h r o i tr o e v g gl

1 it te tatcussplitf pan. (J.. Plitf alge ta ted vie c us tesmestof 9 no h m h a e anif i ' . ) anif le s h t h e c s a e h a e 'J
20 s m pt m s as aleged i Coun. V ,and il addii n,cause vi ra i ns w ihi hi body,depr s i n,a yo l n t l to b to tn s e so

21 l e g tne s x drve'i hoc sta m a't hi b d ,a d at egh e e saeofawae e s' (d.. t i h e d e i y t k /ru ' o s o y n t i t n d tt h 's h rn s. 1 4 '
22 Pl i tf ? alegatonsar s f c ualyf nciul t m aket ecl i f i ol us.A f i ol us a n if s l i e o a t l a f as o h a m rv o rv o 23 cl i t atl ck. an ar uabl basi eihe i l w ori f ctmus bedim i s d.Pl i tf ' alegatonstl t am h a s ge s t rn a na t s se a n if s l i la 24 Eli h t ch devi es' ng pl ced i ts ow er ,onr om doors f od sl t ,on wals onpr pery,i pi es tlg e c 'bei a n th s o ,o os l, o tnp,

2 c nd i,tbls elcrc ls re,o ote obet,buitwihi tepie ,foos,wal,be s snk , 5 o ut a e , e tia u g s n h r j cs l t n h p s l z ls d , i s
2 ties i wae ,a d!i ars se , c usng ûoxi s el i pli tf sr om s dst vir t,l o t 6 o lt,n tr (n n i y tm ' a i t c m ls n an if o be o b ae to r o ' t
7

1 vi r t ,lght t fi ker orot err om fxt r st re ei ehi h e er y fow i t tl m t atcaus spl i tf b a e i s o lc , b o i u e o c v g n g l n o le h e a n if

2 pan' r p t nl fntsi a ddeuso a.Se Netk v Wilams 490U . . l , 27- 8( 98 ) s e i'a e a e ty a a tc n l i n l e iz e . li , S 3 9 3 2 1 9 ,e . 3 aloM c e v rv Bl c ,9 2F.d 795 7 8 ( t Ci.1 9l .Co n V1i dim is dwihprj diea s K ee . ok 3 2 , 9 9h r 9 ) u t s s se t eu c s
4 fi ol us rv o .

5 6

CountVlI Pl i tf aleges t aton Decem be 22,2005,he s bm it d a Fr edom ofl f r aton a n if l h r u te e n om i

7 r q e t o r c r st t eUnie S ae De a t e to J siea dt eFe erlBur a of io s ( m . e u s fr e od o h td t ts p rm n f u tc n h d a e u Prs n . A

8 Co pl, tp. .Pli tf alge t a h r c i e alte fo f dea ofiil, tnor c r swee m .a 45) an if le s h t e e e v d etr r m e r l fcas bu e o d r 9 pr duc d.(d.. o e 1) 1 0 TheFr e o o I f nnai n Ac (4 OI ' pr vi e i di i uaswih a iudiilye d m f n o to t ç A ' o d s n v d l t j cal F ) 1 e f r e bl rg t f cc s t go e n e t ge c doc m e t. Li nRaii s I e v U S. p 'c xp - . l n o c a e ih o a e s o v r m n a n y u n s' o sn , n . . De tfz f , ' lc 1 35 F.d 1 7 ,1 79( tCi. 00 )(iig 5U. . . 55 ) The ea en nesaut l e e pto s e c 2 4 3 0 2 0 9E r 2 4 ctn S C j 2 . r r i tt oy x m in , a h
1 pr t ci g a ans te d s l s r ofas e ik tpeofs nstveg vemne ti f nnain. 5U. . .9 3 o e tn g i t h ico u e p ct y e ii o r n n o to SC

1 5 2( ) I-9) Fol r q fe arco ds e ue toi e s na lfd s rb rque tdr c r sa dt c m pl 4 5 b ( )( . A e u r s e r r q s t : a o b y' e ci e e se e o d n o o y r 1 wiht u ls e nze sai gt etm e, a e f e (f ny , ndpr c dur st bef lowe . S e5U. . . 5 t t b ih d ls t tn h i plc ,e s ia ) a o e e o o l d' e p ' SC

1 j55 ()3( ) ( !l a dtm eye ha sin o a miitaierme isi apee uiiet jdiil 6 2a()A . F ul n i l x u to f d nsrtv e de s rrq st o u ca
1 r v e urd rFol . Ju ii lWath,nc r U S. al /wcat/py,1 0F. up .d111 11 ( . C. 7 e i w le A ' d ca c l . . Nav tl zz tr' 6 S p z ' z , 2 D D.

1 20 1. Prort s e il j diilrve ,are r srq etrmus e ha s hi orhe a miitai e 8 0 ) i o e klg u ca e iw e od e u se t x u t s r d nsrtv 1 r m e i s i cu i gtll apr pe FOI r q e t Se He lyv Unie st ts 59 F.d 1 43 1 44( t 9 e d e ,n ld n iig o r A e u s. e d e . td a e , 4 2 0 , 0 5h l
2 Ci.1 79 . l t e r c r s r q e t rf is t e ha s a m i itai e r m e is t e lw s i ma be 0 r 9 ) f h e o d e u se al o x u t d n srtv e d e , h a u t y

21 ds isdfrlcko s be t te j rs ito .He ma v. rt yse sPr tcinBoar , 99F.d im se o a f u j c matru idcin y n MeiS tm oe to d7 2 2 1 21 1 2 (tCi.1 8 )c r.d nid,481U..1 1 (987.Forrquetdmaeil t q aiya 2 4 , 4 3 9b r 9 6 , c f e e S 09 1 ) e se tras o u lf s
23 tagencyr cor s' t e d 'unde Fo l ,tan agencym us et ercr at orobm i t er quest d mat ri l' a d tt e r At t ih ee nh e e e a s' n ûh 24 agency m us be i contoloft e r quesed m at ral att e tm e t e FOI r questi m ade.' Unied tn z he t ei s h i h Ae s ' t

2 SttsDe 'c xi fc v TixAn lss 4 2U..l 6,1 4 1 5( 98 ) Gr n Ce tParnes i,nc 5 ae p t/ // fc . z ay t, 9 S 3 4 - 4 1 9, a d n. t rhp l . y 26 v Cuomo,1 6F.d473, 9 ( ndCi.1 99) . 63 47 2 r9 .
8

l

I t e il m ntcas ,pl i tf f ist sat a cogni a l cl i f ra FOI vi l tom ashe n h rs e a n if a l o t e z b e am o A o ai

2 f is t alege t e nat r oft e docum e t t athe see s. Pl i tf alo f is t alege t att e Unied al o l h ue h nsh k a n if s a l o l h h t

3 St t s De a t entofJus i e and t e Feder lBur au ofPr s ns hast e r cor s he s els and tz the a e p rm tc h a e io hed eç la

4 ma eaf la dpr pe FOI rqu s.Thi Co r lc s u iditonov rplitf ' cam i t ea s nc d ul n o r A e e t s u ta k j rs ci e an ifs li n h b e e
5 of exhauston ofFOI r quie ent . M or over t t e ext ntt atpl i tf ca adequat l alege a i A e rm s e ,o h eh a n if n ey l 6 cogni abl cl i unde Fo l i t e f t r ,t atcl i maybeas ered i an acton br ughtunderFOI , z e am r A n h u- e h am u st n i o A

7 l t e t a i tl i s ntcvirg t a to s Count Ii dim is dwihprj die. ' h r h n n le n m i l i h s ci n . a Vl s s s e t eu c
8
9

CountVlI I
Pl i tf alegest ati 1996,def ndant Thom ps n and H ebe tt ok fom hi cel hi a n if l hn e s o ro r s ls

1 pe s na j ur a .( m . 0 r o l o n l A Compl,a p. .Plitf ltgae t ec n ic tonofhi j ur a i a ohe . t 47) an if ii td h o fs ai so n ln n t r 11 c s fldi 1 98 i t i Unie Stt sDitit ur, tc s nu be 3: 8 c - 05 3 ECR- PC.(J.. a e ie n 9 ,n h s td a e src Co ta a e m r 9 - v 0 2 V f)
1 Co r r c r si d c t t a t ec s pr ce de t j r til ndi no cos d.( o ke il 9 -v- 05 3 2 u t e o d n i ae h th a e o e d o u y ra a s w l e D c tt3:8 c 0 2 ' 1 ECR- PC) Pli tf c m pliu t a defnd nt c n iue t i va epl i tf' prv c wih viua 3 V . an if o ars h t e a s o tn o n d an ifs ia y t s l
1 devi espl ced i hi cel,and tus t e s t lie t seewhatpl i tf wr t sand il galy obt i t es 4 c a nsl i e h a e lt o an i f ie le l an h e

l i ag sbyhih tc d vie . (J.. 5me g e h e c s' f ) ' 1 6 Thealgainrg r igdee da tTh mps na dle etonfsaigplitf sot a le to e adn fn ns o o n l b rc ic tn anif j t l m

l ha be nltg tdi a ote c s, ndc nnot ltg tdi ti a ton.A f alu g e to temeis 7 s e iiae n n h r ae a a be iiae n hs ci m jd m n n h rt
18 bar a s bsequentae i n bet ee t e s m epari sort ei prvi sovert e s m ecaus ofacton.Ftnd su to w nh a te h r ie ha e i t

1 f rAnmal,I c v Lt'n,96 F.d 1 91 ( t Ci.1 9 ) l a dii n,plitf' ale a ins t a 9 o i s n . . qa 2 2 3 9h r 9 2 . n d to an ifs lg to h t
20 def ndant contnue t iw ade pl i tf ' plvacy w il vi ualdevi espl ce i hi cel and ius t e e s i ot a n if s i tl s c a dn s l teh 2l sa eliet seewhatpli tf w dt sand il galyobt i t es i agesbyhi h t ch devi e 'ar pat nty t lt o an if e le l a n h e m ge c s' e e l

22 f ntsi a d deuso a .Se Netk v Wila s 49 U. . 9, 27- 8( 98 ) s ealoM c e v rv a a tc n l in l e i e . lim , 0 S 31 3 2 1 9 . e s K e e . z ,

2 Blc , F.d7 5, 8(t Ci.1 91.Comt i ds is dwihprj dceasfiolus 3 o k 932 2 9 79 9h r 9 ) l X s im se t eu i rv o .
24 fz tntI ol X

25

Pl i tf alegest att er i acons i c w ihi t eDepnrm entofCor e tons'cant en a n if l h h es pm y t n h t rc i e

26 s or keepe sand m anager t usedece tve tadepm ctces,bai and s ich,m aki g f l em i l adi g te r so pi r i t wt n a s se n

9

1 sae e t,r ii gprc swih u n tc ,( n )fit et h no wa rnte . ( m . m pl,a p. . ttm n s a sn ie t o t o i e a d alt o o r ra i s' A Co . t 49) r '
2 Prs n i m at sar notcompeled t pur haseanyiem sf om t eprs n cant e ,and i deed,t er i no io n e e lo c t r h io en n h es 3 corsi-tonalrghtt pur has iem s fom a pfs n ca t e .u'e Kee an v.Hal,83 F. d 1083,1 92 utt i u i o c et r io n e n b e n l 3 0

4 ( t Ci.l 96) As s c ,t e alg d pr cie oft e p io c n e n f is t sa e a cam f r a 9h r 9 . u h h le e a tc s h rs n a t e al o tt li o 5 c nsi tona volto .Co ntI i dim is d wi p eudie. o tm i l i ai n u X s s s e t rj c h
6 H1. Concl si n uo 7 IT IS TH ER E FO R E O R D E R ED t atpl i tf sm oton t fl an a e ded com pl i t h an ir i o ie m n an

8 c nani g e c s pa e ( oc e #1 )i GR ANTED. o ti n x e s g s D k t 6 s 9 I I FURTHER ORDERED tat t e a e de c mpli t ( o ket /1 ) i TS h h m n d o an D c /7 s
1 DISM ISSE D W I H PREJU D I E , as t e alegatons i t e am ended com pl i t ar untm el , 0 T C hli nh an e i y
11 f i ol us,and ot el ie f i t sat acogni abl cl i f ra f de alci i rght acton. rv o h w s al o t e z e am o e r v l i s i

1 2
1 accor i gl . 3 dn y 1 4
15 16

I I FUR TH E R O R DE R E D t att eCl r ofCourtSH A LL ENTER JU D G M EN T TS h h ek

DATED t i 20t day ofOct ber 2010. hs b o,

17 18
19

. CI ED STAT - DI TR I T J D G E T SCU

20 21

22
23
24 25

26

10