Collins v. Mattice et al

Filing 28

ORDER accepting 26 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION : P's 3 Motion for a Temporary Restraining Order is DENIED. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/10/2009. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

Li1. E( . 6f ) $î

11J.1 ' '1 '

1'' #('7 't 'C :u j F .'.1 '1 Jï L.
Cr : 7 è p ; iS C rI; R h h Fa ' t F ) 'Z I J r l l I F t I)

1
2

h0 1 0 259 V (

t
h I

L
t --a .--- ---. . s-- --. -yk -- .. ,' r ,;
,
.

3

4
5 6

j t. ''I 1.'1./ .. .. ', .;b1 '. > ' !J L rr'IY r1r L - = = . ,-= = . ; = -- . ' ,= = = == '
UNI ED STATES D I T R I T CO U R T T S C

7

DI T R I T O F NEVA DA SC

8 MELVI J.COLLI S, N N
9 Piit#, an i

) ) ) )

3:9- V- 95- CJ( AM) OC 1 R R ORDER

q W ES MATTI E,etaI, a vC . . l l

y )
)

1 2 13
1 4

Df dn. enat es

9

Bef r t e Cour i t e Repod and Recom m endaton oft e Uni d St t s M agi t a e oe h ts h i h t e ae srt

1 J d e ( 2 )(Re ommen ain' e t r d o Ocobe 1 , 00 .Thi acinwa r f redt 5 ug # 6 d c ' d to ) n e e n t r 6 2 9 st o s ee r o 1 U. .Magitat RoberA, 6S sr e t Mcouai , .pur uantt 28U. . . 636( )1)B)andLR I 14. d Jr, s o SC j b( ( B1 Afera t or ugh r vi w ,t e M agi tat Judge r com m ends t att i C our ent r an or er 7 t ho ee h sr e e h hs te d

l denyigPlitfsMotonf raTempor r RestaiigOr er( 3) Noobecint t eRepor 8 n a nir io ay r nn d # . j to o h t
1 and Recommendaton has been fld, 9 i i e
20 1 Dl cussl N .s o

21

Thi Cour ' ay ac ept rj ct or modiy,i whol or i par,t e fndigs or s tm c , ee , fn e n th in

2 r c m men ai n mad byt ema itae.28 U. . . 63 ( )1 .Fu ter u d r 8 U. . . 2 eo d to s e h g srt ' ' S C b 6 b ( ) rh , n e 2 S C 2 j 636( )1) i a pary makes atmel objctont t e magitat jdge' r c mmendaton, 3 b ( ,f t i y e i oh sr e u s e o i 24 t ent i Cour i r quiedt ' ake adenovo det r i atonoft ose porinsoft e gepor h hs ts e r o ' m em n i h to hr t
25 and r c m mendaton)t whih objcton i made.l Neverhelss,t e satt does not eo ioc ei s ' t e h t ue 26 'equielqsome Iss rrviw by Ihi Cour when no obectonsar fld. Thomasv.Ar , 'r r e e ee ts j ji ei ' e' n
27

28

1 Fo a o jcinl b t ey a p r mus s rea dfeiwi i 1 d y a tr igs re wt t ema itaejd esrp r a d r n be t o e i l at o m y t e v n i ! t n 0 a s fe ben e v d t h gsrt u g , e ot n l h h

rcmmedtn28U. . . 6 6b)1( ) qo nai . S C j 3 ( ( )C . o
1

1 47 U. . 40, 49 5 ( 9 5) lsea , de t esau e t i Cou tsn t eq i dt c n u t 4 S 1 1 - 0 1 8 . n t d un r h t tt ,hs r i o r ur o o d c e 2 ' nyr viw atal.., anyisuetati nott esubec ofanobj cin.!.at1 9.Si i ry, ' ee a 1 of s h s h jt e to '# 4 ml l a
3 t e Ni t Cicui has r cogni ed t ata di t i tcour i not r quied t r vi w a m agi t at h nh r t e zh s rc ts e r oee sr e

4 jdge' r por andr commendatonwher no obectonshavebeenfld.See Unied Stt s u se t e i e ji ie t ae 5 v. Reyna-r pi , F.d1114( t Ci. -a a 328 3 9 h r 2003)( ir gar igt esandar ofr viw emplyed ds e dn h t d ee o
6 b tedititc urwhenr viwigar porandr com mendatont whihnoobecinswer y h s rc o l ee n e t e io c j to e 7 madel see alo Schmitv. ; s d Johnst ne,263 F, upp. 1219,1 26 ( .Arz. o s 2d 2 D i 2003)(eadig rn
8 t e N i t Cicui' deci i n i Revna- api as adoptng t e vi w t atdi ti tcours ar not h n h r ts so n Ta iheh s rc te

9 rquied t r viw ' ny isue t ati nott e subectofan obecin.) Thus.i ter i no e r oee ' s a hs h j j to r, fh e s 1 ob ecton t a magitat j dge' r com m endaton, t en t i Cour may accept t e 0 ji o sr e u s e i h hs t h 1 r commendaton wihou r viw, See e. .Johnst ne,263 F, upp.2d at1226 ( cceptng, 1e i t te e n, o s a i 1 wihoutr viw, magitat jdge' r commendaton t whih no obectonwasfld) 2t ee a sr e u s e io c ji i. e 1 3 l t i c se, endanthasnotiedanobjctont t e Magitat Judge' Reporand n hs a def fl e i oh sr e s t
1 Rec mmendaton.Al ough noobecin wasfld,hi Cour hasr viwedt e Repor and 4 o i t h j to i ts e t ee h t

1 Rec m mendaton ( 26) and accepsi.Acc r igi, 5 o i#, tt o dn y
1 6 1. CoNcuusl s I o

1 7

I I HEREBY O R D E R ED t at Pl i tf s M oton f r a Tem por r Restai i g O r er TS h a n ir io ay r nn d

1 ( 3)i DENI D, 8# s E
1 9 20
21 22

( I SO O R D E R ED . TS DATED:Thi s

1 da o Nov mb r2009. 0 yf e e
,

23

2 4
25

' R ober CuJ0 e t UNI ED ST T S DI TR I T JUD G E T SC

26 27 28