Stevens v. Skolnik et al

Filing 121

ORDER. Defendants shall have until 11/15/2011 to file a supplement to their 104 Motion to Dismiss which includes properly authenticated evidence re: grievances. Defendants are cautioned that a failure to comply with this order will resul t in a report and recommendation that the Motion to Dismiss be denied. IT IS SO ORDERED. (See Order for specifics). (Notice of Compliance is due by 11/15/2011.) Signed by Magistrate Judge William G. Cobb on 11/8/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

:.-. 4:
.
.

.

- - - -

qu n

RCI D
E EW
. . s q nc
- -. E w :

---- E R D CCUNS t gg s F c D
- KE E
E g i C cc R

l

2

:cM -ë 221
1

3
4

XT
C E KUSDIT I IX I
kDI CTS R C XDA
R
STRI Y SQV

DEN W

B
Y:

5

6

I I
JN TED STA TES D I
STR I CO I
G
JRT
DI
STR IW O F N EVAD A

7

COUNTRY S
TEVENS,
8

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

Pl ntf,
ai if

9

v.
s
1
0
11

HOW ARD SKOLNI etal,
K, .

De e n s
f nda t .

3: c O9- v OO227 RCJ ( GC)
W
M I UTE ORDER
N

12

1
3

On M ar h 21 201 , De e
c
, 1 f ndant fl a M oton t D im is f Faiur t Exlaus
s ied
i o s s or l e o n t

1 Adm i sr tveRe dis ( . 1 ) Pl i tf ha oppo e ( c #1 0) a De e nt
4
nita i
me e . Doc # 04.. a n if s
s d Do . 1 , nd f nda s
l ha er ple ( .# 1 :
5 v e i d Doc 14.
1
6

Def
endant ar t tPl ntf aied t ex z thi adm i s r i re e e and a a
s gue ha ai iff l o hals s
ni t atve m di s,
s

1 r s thi Co pli ts ul bedimis dwihou prj die ( . 1 ) Thr ug
7 e ul s m a n ho d
s s e t t e u c . Doc # 04. o hout her
t i
1 m oton,Def
8
i
endant r ert num er grevanc fl by Pl ntf , f l t fl any oft
s ef o
ous i
es ed
ai if but aied o ie
he
1 ac ualgr e
9
t
i vancesand prs r pons exc :111r pec t grevance num ber 2006ion es
es ept $t es t o i
s
27-

2 1 7 3 a 2008- 7- 30.( c Do .# l Fx F,Ex. G. W hie De e a . d d fl t
0 1 5 nd
2 865 S e c o4 a.
)
l f nd nt i e he
s
21 Ne daOfe r a knga dl or a Sy t m (
va
nde Tr c
n nf m hon s e NOTI r por whihc n a n as mar
S) e t c o t i s um
y
22 ofa1 grevanc fl by Pl ntf ort r l vantt m eper od, hi doesnotalow t c tt
l i
es ied
ai iff he e e
i
i t s
l he our o

2 r viF a1 f hei or a inc nt ne i t a t l le nc s ( eDo . l Ex D, .E.
3 e e 1 o t nf m to o ai d n he c ua g i va e .Sc c # o4 . Ex )
24 M or ove Def
e r, endant f l t aut
s aied o hentca e tl doc ent fl w i. r pec t gre
i t ie um s iéd t es t o ivanc
h
e
l

2 nu r 2 - - 1 3an 2006 2 5 mbe s 006 27 175 d
- 7 8653 ( cDoc # 1 Fx F, G. Sc eg.Fe
0. Se
. O4 - . Ex. ) c . , d.
,
2 R.Ci P.5 c ( , e ; d. R.Evd.901 e .s q. s ealo Bi t.M o han,5 F.
6
v. 6( )4) ( ) Fe
i
, t e ; e s as 7 yni
O8 3d
27

28

'

1Ree st c ur'do ke numbe
fr o o t c t
s
r
.

'

k--. JQ

.

1 1 2 1 24( t Ci.2007 ( o r o
21 , 2 9 h r
) pr pe f unda inm t t adf mr nc s ppo tn mo i f r
to l bel i or i e u ri g ton o
s
de

2 s ma yj g e ,a do um e t m us bea be ia e a a t c d t ade l r ton of
um r ud m nt nd c n s t ut ntc t d nd ta he o ca a i

3 s one who hm pe s na kno e e ;Cfic f felrFors r v. U. De . o
ome
s ro l wldg ) rz ns or rc
e ty
S. pt f
4 Agrc t e 341 F.d 961 97 n. 7 ( t Ci. 2003) (al e t s tsy a he tc don
iulur ,
3
, 2
9. r
h
f iur o a if ut n ia
5 rquie nt jltfe dir g r o doc nt byc ur whe r e ngt molo .
e r me s t iis se a d f ume s o t n md wi be i nlz
s .
6
ThePLM pr vi st t<n) a to s lbebr g wih r s c t pls n c dii s
o de ha < o ci n hal ou ht t e pe t o i o on ton
(
7 u e s c i n 1 o t stte, a o he F de a l w, a prs rc i d i a j i,
nd r e to 983 f hi il or ny t r e r l a by ione onfne n ny al
8 prs orot c r tonalf iiy untls h adm i s r i r edi s as ar a l bl ar
ion,
her or ec i
ac lt
i uc
ni t atve em e
e vaia e e

9 e
xhaus e '42 U. C.û1 e( ). f l et e
t d.
'
S. 997 a The aiur o xhaus a nitatver
t dmi sr i emedisi teat as
e s r ed

1 ama tri a t me an i p ope l r ie i a une
0
te n ba e nt d s r ry as d n n nume a e Rul 1 m o i n.W yat
r t d e 209 to
t
1 t. r
1 'Tc hune 31 F.d 1 08, 19 ( t Oi.O03 ,C r. nfd) 4OU. 81 ( 3) Fal et
, 5 3 1 1 1 9 h r2 ) e t de c 5
S. O 200 . iur o
1 ex us
2
ha tadm i s r dver edi 1 1e r atvedef e,
nit a
em es sa1
m i
ens anddef
endnntsbeart
heburden
1 ofrai ng and provi fai ure t exhaust.Id.A c t i dec di a m oti t di m is
3
si
ng l
o
our , n i ng
on o s s

1 bms on ex
4
ed
haus i m a ookbe
ton, yl
yondt pl adi
he e ngsand dec dedi put s uesoff twihout
i
s edis
ac t

1 c nv r i t m o i i t o f s ma y j men . I (ii g Riz 1. I '
5 o e tng he ton n o ne or um r udg t d. ctn
ta J ntl
l Lo hor me s& W ar h e n' Uni 83 F. 365 368 ( h Ci. 988)( rc im l.
6 ngs e n'
e ous me s on, 7 2d ,
9t r 1
pe ura )
1
7
Thef iur t a d byt Fe r lRul so Evi e ei ac le eonlm ie udiil
al e o bi e he de a e f d nc s hal ng
i t dj ca
1 r sour es.Def
8 e
c
endant ' c
s ounse i ca i d t obs e t r es by pr di pr
l s utone o
enr he ul
ovi ng opery
l
1 aut i at e dence upon whi h t y r y i al fz tr flngsw ih t cour .De endant
9
hentc ed vi
c he el n l ttz e i
t he
t f
s
20 s lha up t and i l ng Tuesday,N ovem ber 1 2o11 t fl a s
hal ve
o
ncudi
5,
y o e uppl entt t i
em
o he r

21 motonwhihi l
i
c ncudes:()pr l aut iat document yevi er l edt grevanc
1 opery hentc ed
ar denc eat o i
e

2 numbe s 2
2
r 006- - 1 5 a 2006- - 30;an @ ) pr pe l a he ia e g iv e
27 1 7 3 nd
27 865
d
o ry ut ntc t d re anc
23 doc e s f eac l velofr
um nt , or h e
miew,a ong wih a1 prs r ponse f e y ot rgre
l
t 1 i on es
s, or ver he ivance
24
2 W hie a moton t dim i f f l e t exhaus adm i st a i r edis L pr l r se i an
l
i o s ss or aiur o
t
ni r tve em e s opery ai d n

25 u nume ae 1 ' ( )mo i a no amo i f s
ne
r td 2( 6 ton nd t
b)
ton or ummayj gme ,Wl l 3 5 F.d a 11 (ia ins
r ud nt mr, 1 3 t 19 ct to
26 o te ,hec t ysillokbe ondt pe di san t e i nta yr qur me ss l s i a pl.Se
mi d) t our ma tl o
l
y
be la ng d he vde ir e ie nt houd tl p y e
l
W'at,31 F. a 120,n. 1 (i n dee a sdi no me tt erbur e t e tbls fiur t ex us
l t 5 3d t 1
/
5 fndig fnd nt d t e h i d n o sa ih al e o ha t
be edoc
caus
ument subm ile di notper i appelat courtt de enni whe heri wasacom pl er or of
s
td d
m t
l e
o t ne t t
et ec d
27
f
f
t epant sg iv c hit r )
h li i re an e so y .
28
2

w.. .
.
-

.= *

l r f renced i Def
ee
n
endant 'M oton t Di m is. Def
s
i o s s
endant ar c i
s e autoned t a f l e t
hat aiur o
2 c pl ih t sor rurl r ul i ar
om yw t hi de il es t n epor and r om m endaton t tt M oton t Di m is
t
ec
i ha he
i o s s

3 be deni f f l et m ee tl bur ofpr ngt e
ed or aiur o
t le den
ovi he xhaus i av r at e de ens
ton
m hr f e.
4
'

I I SO O RD ER ED .
T S

5 DATED :Novem ber8,201 .
1
6

, r' (
z
j

-

7

I NI
J TED STATES M AGI
STM TE JU DGE

8
9

1
0
11
12
13
14
15

1
6
17

1
8
1
9
20
21
22
23
24

25
26
27
28

3