Stevens v. Skolnik et al

Filing 71

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that defendants' 26 Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED. FURTHER ORDERED that plaintiff's claims arising prior to 04/29/2007 are DISMISSED with prejudice. FURTHER ORDERED that plaintiff's claims brought pursuant to 28:994 are DISMISSED with prejudice. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 08/03/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

;.. j. ! ) . i )t 8 t. . :3 7
.

r .

7''c- 7 l.- :F).. ? ' -'7 f 7 i .. .'sli i -à. l''' 2L p L -2
..- . . -

...J)f i.. -; - .) ' ï ' . .. ,, . .. .' . -'
., . . ..

.

1
2
( 5 9
4
5

1
l
l j

( ?'; - : 21 t. . .2 , ): t ?
.

,

t' '
1., . .
. . ..

'' - ''

.

' ' '7 t '' ''
,

' ''

jI . .

l
.

','' .. h >:;. 1

6

U N I E D STATES D I T R I T C O U R T T S C

7
8

DI TRI T OF NEVADA SC

9 COUNTRY ' I GI G HORSE'STEVENS,) SN N ' )

3:9- V- 27- CJ( AM) OC 2 R R

1 0 Pii lnf at, f 1 1 1 HWADSONKea, 2 O R K LI,tl . l 3
1 4
1 5

Def ndant . e s

k j j )
) )

O DR RE

Bef r t e Cour i t e Repor and Recommendaton oft e Unied St t s Magitat oe h ts h t i h t ae sr e

1 Judge(/ 0)CRec mmendaton' ent r donMay19, 6 /6 o i ' ee ) 2010.Thi acinwasr f redt U. , s to ee r o S

1 Ma itae Rob r A. o u i, r, ur u n t 2 U. . . 6 6( )1 ( ) dL I 1 4,Af r 7 gs r t e t Mc ad J .p s a t o 8 S C j 3 b ( )B an R B - t e
1 a t or ugh r vi w , he M agitat Judge r com m ends t att i Coul ent ran or ergr n i g 8 ho ee t sr e e h hs 'e t d a tn

1 De e d ns Mo int Dimis( 2 ) OnJ l 8, 0, an i h sfld a Non op ost n t 9 f n a t' t o s s / 6 . o / uy 201 Plit f a i f e - p io o i
20 Magitat Judge' Repor and Recommendaton(/4) sr e s t i /6 ,
21 1Dlcussl N .s o

22

Thi Cour ' ay acc pt r jct or modi ,i whol or i par,te fndigs or s tm e , ee , fn y e n th i n

2 3 2 4 25 26
27 28

r c mmen ai n ma eb t e ma ita e. 2 U. . . 6 6( )1 .Fu ter u der U. . . eo d t s d y h gs rt ' 8 S C j 3 b ( ) rh , n 28 S C o ' j 6 6( )1 ,fa p dy ma e a t el o j cin t t e ma ita ej d esr c mmen a in, 3 b() i a k s i y be t o h m o gsr t u g ' e o dt o t ent i Coud i r quiedt d akea denovodet r iaton oft ose podinsoft e (epod h hs s e r o' m em n i h o hr and r com mendat n)t whih obecton i made.l Neverhels ,t e sat t does not e i o c ji s o ' ' t e s h t ue

F r no jcdnt b t e? a p rymu t erea d feiwl l 1 d y at r en s re wi 1 ema itaeld es Ip r a d o a be t o e i I, a t s s v n i t t n Q a s f b ig e v d t h gsrt u g ' ' o t n o m l h e h e

rcmmedtn28U. . . 63 ( )1( ) eo naj . S C j 6 b()C . o
1

1 'eq i l s me ls err ve b E i Cout wh n n o j cin a e fe .Tho a v. n, ' u r ) o e s e iw y t s r! e o be t s r i d ' m s Ar re h o l' 2 47 U. . 40, 49 50( 9 5 ,Isea , n e tesa ue,hsCou tsn tr q i dt c n u t 4 S 1 1 - 1 8 ) n t d u d rh ttt ti ri o e ur o o d c e 3 ' n rviw at I. . f yis et atsn t h s be t fa obe t n.1.a 1 9.Si i r , ' y e e aI . o an s u h i o t e u jc o n jci '# t 4 a o' ml l ay
4 t e Nit Cicui has r cogni ed t ata di titc ur i notr quied t r viw a m agitat h nh r t e zh s rc o t s e r oee sr e

5 jdge' r por andr commendatonwher noobecinshave beenfld. UniedStt s u se t e i e j to i See t a e e 6 v. Revna-r pi, F.d 1114( t Ci. -a a 328 3 9h r2003)( ir gar igt est ndar ofrviw emplyed ds e dn h a d e e o 7 byt editit t henr viwigar porandr com mendatont whihn obecinswer h src courw ee n e t e i o c o j to e 8 made) .ee alo Schmitv, ;s s d Johnst ne,263 F. upp, 1219,1226 ( . i. o s 2d D Arz 2003)(eadig rn
9 t e Ni t Cicui' deci i n i Revna-r pi as adoptng t e vi w t atdi titcours ar not h n h r ts so n -a a ih eh s rc te

1 0 l l 1 2 1 3
1 4

r quied t r viw ' ny isue t ati nott e subec ofan obeci n,) Thus,i t er i no e r oee a s hs h jt j to '. ' fh e s obe t n t a ma itae jdg ' r c mmen a in, t en t i Cou t ma a c p te jci o o g sr t u es e o d to h hs r y ce t h r commendatonwihoutr viw .Seee, ,Johnst ne,263 F. upp.2d at1226 ( cceptng, e it ee q, o s a i wi ou r ve , ma itat j d e' r c m me da int whc noobe t nwa fld) t t e iw a gs r e u g s e o n t o ih h o jci o si . e
I t i cas , ai tg hasfl d a non- pposton t t e Magi tat Judge' Repor and n h s e pl n i ie o ii o h sr e s t

l Recommendain.Alhough no obectonwasfld,ti Cour hasrviwed t e Repor and 5 to t ji i hs e t ee h t 1 Recommendaton( 60) andacc pt i.Ac or igl, 6 i#, e s t c dn y 1 7 I I HEREBY ORDERED t atDef ndant'Motont Dimis((263)i GRANTED. TS h e s i o s s #9 s #
1 8 I I FURTHER O RDERED t atPl i tf s cl i s arsi g prort Aprl29,2007 ar TS h an i f am in i o i e
)

1 DI M I SED wi p eu ie. 9 SS t r jd c h 2 0 I I FURTHER ORDERED tat ait r camsb o g tp ru n t 28 U. . . 9 4 TS h Pl ni s li r u h u s a to f SC â 9 21 ar DI M I SED wi prj dc . eSS t e u ie h
22 I I SO O RDERED. TS

2 3
24 25 26

D T D T i. dyoA gs,00 A E : hs. a f uut2 1. 9

27
28

ober C.Jon t UNI ED STA S DI TRI T JUDGE T SC