TAYLOR v. BRAND SCAFFOLD SERVICES, LLC et al

Filing 19

ORDER granting 2 Motion to Dismiss. Clerk shall enter jdgmt. Signed by Judge Larry R. Hicks on 09/24/09. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - LG)

1 $
EkfTD lJ TE
y
FLED I

SCvïjN BhSaD gTtE) I V
y y y ys yyy y yy z y ya yy jy y y y

2
3 4 5

sgg g j sg j
cL'Ktsjpy lycljy E7 ; à qg rg ? a
FY > ;

D1;il lOFlivj t ET2( l jktùj
.w . .x

pgpgy y

6 7
8

U N I ED STA TE S D I TR I T COU R T T SC D I T R I T OF NEV A D A SC
***

9

1 0
1 1

STEPHEN TAYLOR,

Plitf, anif
v.

1 2
BRAND SCAFFOLD SERVI ES,LLC; C 1 BRAND SERVI ES,LLC, 3 C 1 4
l5

Defnda t. e ns

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

3:9- V- 2 0- RH- P 0 C 04 L V C
ORDER

1 6

Bef r t e c ur i de e da t Br nd Sc fol Ser ies LLC a dBr nd Se v c s LLC' o e h o t s fn ns a af d vc , na r ie , S

1 (û rnd' moint dimisfldonM a 8,2009. 7 û a ' to o s s ie B ) y Doc. . antf StphenTa lr(t a 1 r' #21Pli if e yo 1 yo ' T )
l tld ar s o s on M a 26,2009.Doc #9.The ea tr Br nd tl d ar pl onJu e9, 8 ie e p n e y . r fe - a 'e e y i n 2009,
1 D o ./1 . 9 c /0

20 1 . 21

Fac sand Pr ce ur lH it r t o d a so y Thi i aTil Vl e pl ym e td s rm i a i n a ton. yl ri a Afi a - m e i a who s s te l m o n i c i n to c i Ta o s n rc n A rc n

22 wase pl ye by de e dan Br nd asas op se a d. yl ra lgest a Br nd a d isempl yee mod fn t a h tw r Ta o le h t a n t os

23 rcal ha a sdTa lr s be tdhi t difrnttr sa dc ndiinsofe plyme tt a whie a ily r se yo , u j ce m o fee em n o to m o n hn t
24 e n l ye s a d e e t aly l i hi of s ll on t eba i ofhi r c .Doc. , r p o e - n v n u l ad m f o ey h ss s ae /1 Exhi i 1 bt .
25 26 1
Ref r t t e cour' doc e numbe . es e h ts k t r

%

1

O n A prl2 , 08, y oril d a c m pl i tw ih t eN e a a Equa Ri ht C om m i s on i 2 20 Ta l i e o an t h vd l gs si

2 (û ERO'.Thee fe.onM a 27s 08,Ta lrfldac mplitwiht eEqualEmplyme t û N ' ) ra tr y 20 yo ie o an t h on 3 OpporuniyCommison(iEOC' . EEOC deciedt purueTa lrscam a dis e a tt si : E ' The ) ln o s y o ' li n su d
4 rghtt - ue l teron Oc obe 2,2008. i -o s e l tr 5 On A prl1 2009,Ta l rf i d t e unde l i g Til V1 a tc . oc. / ,Exhi i 1 i 7, y e ie h ry n te 1 c im D / 1 bt .

6 The e f e ,Br nd fl d t e pr s ntm oton t di m i s D oc. r a t r a ie h e e i o s s. #2. 7 I .Le alSt ndar Ig a d

8

l co sderng û m o i n t dim is a l lpl a e al gai nsofm a e i lf c a et ken n n i i i to o s s , l wel- e d d le to a t ra a t r a

9 a tuea d co sr e i alghtm os f vo a l t t enon- ovi g pa t .'WylrSummi P b/17v s r n n tu d n i t a r be o h m n ry ' e t .) . 7

1 Tur e Br ad.5 .,l c,1 5F.d658,661(t Ci.1 98)( iainomitd)Howe e ,ac ur 0 n r o -ç n . 3 3 y. 9h r 9 ctto te . vr o t
11 doe no ne e s rl a s m et etu h ofl ga co cl sonsme ey be aus t e a ec s i t ef r s t c s a iy s u h r t e l n ui rl c e h y r atn h om 1 off c ua ale a i nsi apl i tf ' c m pl i t Se Clgg v. u t 2 a t l lg to n an ifs o an . e e C'l Awar ne sNe bor ,1 F.d 75 , e s tv k 8 3 2

1 75 - 5( t Ci.1 94) 3 4 5 9h r 9 .
1 4 The e i a s r ng pr s m pton a a ns dim i s ng a a ton f rf iur t s a e a cl i . e r s to e u i g i t s s i n c i o al e o t t a m Se

1 Gilganv. 5 li Jamc De .Cor . 1 8F.d246, (t Ci.1 97 ( iainomitd) t-heis ei o v p, 0 3 249 9h r 9 ) ctto te .i- su s l
1 notwhehe apl i tf wiluli ael pr valbu whehe t ecli a ti e tte t ofe e i enc 6 t r an if l tm t y e i t t r h a m n s n il d o f r v d e

1 i s ppo toftecli s'Sc eue v Rhode ,41 U. .23 , ( 97 ) ov r uld o ote 7 n u r h am . h r ' ' . s 6 S 2 236 1 4 , e r e n h r 1 gr un sb ftrtw v. tger l , U..800.807( 982) Ho e e,aplitf soblgaint 8 o d y fz/ Fiz a d 457 S p 1 . w v r an if i to o
1 pr vi e t e gr undsofhi e tte e tt r le r quie m or t a l be s co c usons a d a 9 odh o s n il m n o e i f e r s e h n a l, n l i , n

20 f r ul i r ct ton oft eelm e t oft eca s ofa to . l AtantcCor .v Twombl ,1 7 S. o m a c e iai h e n s h u e c i n Bel l i p. y2

21 Ct 1 55,1 65( 007) t a t a alg tonsmus bee ought r ieargh t r le a ovete . 9 9 2 .e cu l le ai F tn o as i t o eif b h
22 s e ul tvelve on t ea s m ptont a alt e al ga i nsi t ecompl i ta et l ( ve i p c ai e l h s u i h t l h le to n h an r n e e n f

23 doubtuli fcl'f .itr alcttonso itd . f n a t. J (n en iai m te ) '
24 1 1 1. D i cus i n s so

25 St t t ofLi i a i ns au e m t to
26 2

1

W he t eEEOC de lnest purueacli i i rquie t notf tecai a tt a hehas nh ci o s am t s e r d o iy h l m n h t

2 nieyda st fl acvla ton. U. . .j2000 - ( ( ) Thi ni eyda flngpei do eae n t y o ie ii ci 42 S C e 5 9 1. s n t y ii ro p rts 3 asasaut o lmiainf rt ecam . holrn PacfcBel 963F.d264, (t Ci.19 2 tt e f i tto o h li Sc a ii l, 2 267 9h r 9 )
4 (ii gEdwa dsv OccdentlChe .Cor .8 2F.d 1 42,1 45(t Ci.1 90).tfcaman ctn r,ia m p , 9 2 4 4 9 h r 9 )t li t l
5 f ist tl wihi 90- a pe i d, hea ton i ba r d. f . a l o ie t n d y ro t c i s r e ' J '
6 H e e, he EEOC i s ed Ta l ra r g t t - ue l te on O c o e 2,2008.Tay o di notfl rt su y o ih -o s e tr tb r lr d 'e i

7 hi Til Vl s i untlAprl1 , s te 1 u t i i 7 2008.ove onehundr d da slt .Acc r i gl ,Ta i r sc m pli t ,r e y ae o dn y yo ' o an
8 i tl e ba r d. s i - re u 9 Equiabl T oli g t e ln

1 0

Ta l ra gue t a at oughhefl d hi c m pli tlt , i e tte t e u tbl t li g of y o r s h t lh ie s o a n ae he s n il d o q ia e o ln

11 t e lm ia i ns pe i d be a s he di notr c i e hi r g tt - ue I te untlFe n l r 1 , h i t to ro c u e d e e v s i h -o s e t r i b a y 0 2009. 1 D o . Ta l rm oved f o t e a dr s ofr c r on Apr l 1 , 2 e #9. y o rm h d es e od i 5 2008,a t r he t l d hi N ER C fe ie s

l cli .He wasnotIvi gatt e a dr s o r e r whe t eEEOC is e hi rghtt -uelte a d 3 am in h d es f e od nh s u d s i -o s e tr n
1 he di di notr c i e notc ofhi r g tt s e untlhe c nt c e t e EEO C on Fe r a! l , 4 dd e ev ie s ih o u i o a td h b u y 0 2009.

1 The e o e,Ta l rar ue t a t etm ef rt elm ia i nspe i d s oul bet led u tlt edae he 5 r fr y o g s h t h i o h i t to ro h d o l n i h t
1 r ce ve no i e Doc #9. 6 e i d tc . .

1 7

Howe e , quia l t li g o t eni e yda pe i d i g an e on y whe t ecl i a t v r e tb e o ln f h n t y ro s r t d l n h am n

1 e e c s sr a o abl du dii e c i ke pi g t eEEOC a r as ofa d e se a ge a d sa si 8 x r i e e s n e e lg n e n e n h b e t d r s h n s n ty n

1 c ntc wiht eEEOC. eNemiav Shel Eur c r.I c. l1 F.d380( t Ci.1 97) 9 o at t h Se l d . l o a s n , 2 3 y 9h r 9
20 ( oli gt a fiur t pr vi eEEOC wih ne a drs di notc nsiuet ee ecieofdue h d n h t al e o o d t w d es d o ttt h x r s 21 diie c ) Hee Tayirdi note ecieduediienc i puruighi cai wihteEEOC. lg n e . r, o d xr s lg e n s n s l m t h 22 Ta lrfldhi EEOC c ageo M a 22,20 8, fe Ta lrha move fom tea drs of y o ie s hr n y 0 q tr yo d d r h d es

23 r co d,bu hef iedt c a gehi a dr s ori f r t eEEOC t a heha ar a y move . t e , er t al o h n s d es nom h ht d le d d Furh r
24 Ta l rf ie t ke p i dii e tco t c wih t e EEOC ; w a t d m o e t a ni e m ont st y o a l d o e n lg n n a t t h he ie r hn n ho

25 co t c t e EEOC a outhi c am eve t oug hekle t e EEOC had no wa t c nt c hi by nath b s li nh h lw h y o o at m
26 3

m al Thus Ta l rdi notexe c s due dii e c i purui ghi ca m . c r i gl - hecou t i. , yo d r ie lg n e n s n s li Ac o d n y t r
2 de lnest t l t e s a ut oflm ia i ns pe i d. c i o o l h t t e i t to ro

4
6

I I THEREFORE ORDERED tatdetndant'motc t dim is( oc. i TS h k s im o s s D #2) s
G R A N TED .

I I FURTHER ORDERED ta tecekofco r s al e trj dg e ta co digl . TS h t h lr u t h l ne u m n c r n y
I I SO ORDERED. TS
%

ox-so ti z r hs

r yo- e tmb r2 0 . a fs pe e, 0 9

L RY R.H I K S C LJ TED STA TE S D I TR I T J D G E M SCU

1 6
17 18 19 20 21 22
23

4