Fitzgerald v. State Of Nevada

Filing 13

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that the Motions to Amend 11 12 are GRANTED. The Clerk shall detach and FILE the first amended complaint (ack'd).FURTHER ORDERED that the State of Nevada is DISMISSED with prejudice. FURTHER ORDERED th at Count Two of the Amended Complaint is DISMISSED without prejudice and with leave to amend. Plaintiff shall have thirty (30) days to file a Second Amended Complaint. Failure to file an amended complaint will result in the matter proceeding as to Counts One and Three only. (Amended Complaint deadline: 12/31/2010) Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

.

'

.w . . .

i ; )t . y
1
2

l

,
L i . ' î

3 4 5 U N I E D STATES D I T R I T C O U R T T S C DISTRICT OF N EV A D A

6 MARTY SCOTT FI ZGERALD, T 7 Plitf anif
8 vs , 9 S ATE 0F NEVADA, tal, T e. 1 0 11

De e d nt. fn a s Pli tfl o f apls ne i t ecu t dyofteNev daDe a t e t Co r c ins ha an if wh s i o r n h so h a p rm n of re to , s

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

Ca eNo. 0 -v-28&RCJVPC s 3:9 c 0 ORDER

1 s bm it d a M oton f rLe vet Fie aFis Ame d d Compli t( oc e /1 )a d apr pos d Fis 2 u te i o a o l rt n e an d k t / 1 n o e rt

1 Ame de Complit( o ke #11 1a d/1 ) Themoto st a e ds albega tda nodee da t 3 nd an d c t - n /2 . in o m n h l rne s fn n 1 h sa pe rd.F. . ..1 a( ) Theame d dc mplithasbe nsr e e purua tt 28U.. .j 4 a p ae R C P 5()1 n e o an e cen d s n o SC
15 1 15A asdi cus ed bel w . 9 ss o

1 6

Purua tt tePrs ne LiiainReonnAc I LRAI fd rlc ursmus dim isa s n o h io r tg to f tP , e ea o t t s s

17 pr s ner scl i s,ti t e alegaton ofpover y i untue,'ori t e ac i n ti fi ol us orm alci us,' i o ' a m tf h l i t s r ' f h t o ts rv o io '
-VPC Fitzgerald v. State Of Nevada

1 S a l t sa eac a m on whi h r le m a beg a t dj o ds e sm one a yr le a ai s ade e da t ho 8 ç is o t t l i f c e i f y r n e ' r çe k ' tr e if g n t f n n w
Doc. 13

1 i i munefom s c rle. 28U.. .j1 1 ()2) Dimis lofac mplitf rfiur t saea 9 sm r u h eif' ' SC 9 5 e( . s sa o an o al e o tt

2 cam uponwhihr le ma begrntdi povie fri Fe ea Rul ofCiiPr ce ur 1 ()6 ,nd 0 li c eif y a e s r d d o n d rl e vl o d e 2b ()a
21 te Co r a plest esm e sa dad un e Se ton 1 1 ()2 whe rviwig te a e ua y o a h u t p i h a tn r d r ci 9 5 e() n e e n h d q c f
22 c m pl i tora e de c m pl i t o an m n d o an .

23 Re iw unde Rul 1 ()6 i e sntal arlngo aquetonoflw.Se Ch p e v. ve r e 2b () s se ily ui n si a e ap l 2 La or tr Cor .o Ameia 23 F.d71 ,7 3( t Ci. 000) Dim is lfrfiuet saeacam 4 b aoy p f rc , 2 3 9 2 9h r 2 . s sa o alr o tt li
25 i pr pe o l i i i c e r t a t e pl i tf c nno p ove an s toff c si s p o toft e c a m t a s o r n y f t s l a h t h a n if a t r ye at n upr h li h t

26 wo l e ttehi orhe t rlef Se More v Wale ,1 5F.d7 6, ( t Ci.1 9 ) l ma ig u d nil m r o ei . e ly . k r 7 3 5 759 9h r 9 9 . n kn

Dockets.Justia.com

1 t i det r i aton,t eCourtt kesastueal alega i nsofm at r alf ctsat d i t ecom pl i t and t e hs em n i h a r 1 l to ei a t e n h an, h 2 Courtconsruest em i t e lghtm os f vor bl t t epl i tf .See War haw v. t h nh i t a a e o h an if s Xoma Cor .74 F. d p, 3

3 955,95 (t Ci. 996 .Ale ainsi apr s c mplitaehedt ls srng ntsa dadst a 7 9h r1 ) lg to n o e o an r l o es ti e tn r h n
4 f r a pla i g dr he bylwye s S eHu he v. o m l e d n s a d a r . e g s Aowc, U, . ,9( 980 . ne v Ke ne , 449 S 5 1 ) Hai s . r r 404 ,

5 U..51 ,5 0- 1(972 @e cu /rl s eas Balsrr v. 6 c Polc De ' 9 1F.d6 6,6 9 S 9 2 2 1 ) r rk a ; e lo ite i Pac a ie p t 0 2 9 9 , 6 (t Ci,9 0) 9h r1 9 .
7 Al orpal ofa com pl i ttl d by aprsonerm ay t er f r be dim ised sua s ont i l 4 an i e i h eoe ss p ef

8 t eprs ne ' c a m s lck a a gu bl ba i e t e i 1 w cri f ct Thi i c ude cl i sba e o l g l h io r s l i a n r a e s s ih r n a n a . s n l s am sd n e a

9 c ncusonsta aeuntna l (..camsag is dee da t whoaei munefom s iorcamsof o l i h t r e be cg li an t fn ns rm r ut li 1 i fi ge e t al g li tr s whihcla l d e no e it, swe l scai sba e onf ncf l a m a 0 n rn m n of e a n e e t c e ry o s t x s) a l a l m s d a iu f c l
11 ale ai ns( . .a tsi or l so a s e ai s.Se Nei kev Wilams 490U. . 9, 27- 8( 98 ) lg to cg f n a tc deu i n l c n ro ) e t . li , z S 31 3 2 1 9 , .

1 s ealoMc e v rv BIc ,93 F.d795 798(t Ci.1 91. 2 e s K ee . o k 2 2 , 9h r 9 )
13 Pl i tf ' cl i sr l t t t e deni lofm edi alt eat entf rdam age t hi neck and a n i fs a m e a e o h a c rm o os

1 bac a d f r He a ii C. He na e va i uspr s n ofi i l a de e d n si bot t e r o t c a a d 4 k n o p tts m s ro i o fc a s s f n a t n h h i fi i l n 1 i di i ua c pa ii si cud ng t eun d ntfe m e be sof heM e i a Re i w Pa e .He a s na es 5 n v d l a c te n l i h i e i i d m r t dc l ve nl lo m 1 t e St t o Ne a a a adef nda t 6 h ae f v d s e n.
17 The El vent Am endm entbar Secton 1983 s is agai s sat s- and t ei agenci s eh s i ut nt t e hr e.

l SeeHyl nd v Wo de l 7F.d 405, 3( t Ci.l ) a e de ,1 7 F.d 11 5, c /dene .52 8 a . nnl 3 41 9 h r 997 , m n d 2 3 3 c r. id 2

1 U..11 8(998 , a v De arme to core tons 66F.d245,2 849( t Ci.1 ) T ylrv 9 S 4 1 ) Luc s . p t n f r ci , 3 4 - 9h r 995 ; a o . 20 fit 88 F.d1 40,1 ( t Ci.1 89 (oligta teNe a aDe a t e tofPrs nswasasae s, 0 2 0 045 9h r 9 ) h dn h th v d p rm n io tt

21 a e c e tte t Elve t Ame d e ti munt) Thus teStt ofNe a as albedimis da a g n y nild o e nh n m n m iy . ,h ac v d h l s se s
22 de e d nti t i a to . As t t e m e be soft e M e i a Re i w Pa e ;t os i di i ua sca o l f n a n h s c in oh mr h dc l v e n l h e n vd l n ny

23 bes e i t erofi ilc pa iyfrij nci erle ,Se Arion ns o Ofif/Engls v Arz n , u d n h i tca a ct o nu tv eif e rz a f r /ct z ih . io a 24 52 U. . 6 n.4( 997 ,Wilv Mih. p 'o stt Polce 491U.. 71n.1 (989 . ik 0 S 43, 9 2 l ) l . c De tf ae i , S 58, 0 1 ) Hydrc ,
25 v Hu tr 500F.d978, 7(tcr2007 .Theme be softeMe ia Re iw Pa els alnotbe . n e, 3 98 9h i. ) m r h dc l ve n h l
26

2

1 sb e tt aj dg e tofmon yd ma es ujc o u m n e a g.
2 3 CountOne l t i count pl i tf st t s a vald cl i undert e Ei ht Am endm entf rdeni lof n hs , a n if a e i am h gh o a

4 ade uat m edi alcar . qe c e 5 CountTw o

6

l c unt w o, a n ifa l ge t e d f nda t n e hi duepr c s a deq a pr t c i n n o t pl i tf le s h e e n de i d m o e s n u l o e to

7 on t ebass ofhi r c . He c nt ndst a he, whie m a , a de i d m e i a / u g c lte t e tf r h i s ae oe h t a t n w s ne d c ls r i a r a m n o
8 hi da aged back and neck w hie anot e i m at ,a bl ck m an,w as gi en s r i alteat ent H e sm l hr n e a v u gc r m .

9 c ntndsti dici iaoyte t e tc usdi n utorz dij r't hi . o e hs srm n tr ram n a e ç a h ie nu y'o m u
10 The EqualPr t cton Clus di ect t attal per ons sm iary cicum sanced s al be oe i a e r sh 61 s i ll r t hl

11 te td alke' Pl lrv Doe 457 U. .202 20 ( 9 2 . A s ci n 1 8 pli tf al gng a e ua r ae i .' y e . , S , 6 18 ) e to 9 3 an if le i n q l 1 pr tc invi ltonmus p o et a : 1 t edefnda t te tdpl itf d fe e tyfo ot e ssm ia l 2 o e to o a i t r v h t( ) h e n s r a e a n if ifr n l r m h r i l ry 1 st ae ;2)teune u lr am e t sba e ona inpe nisbl cls iia im; 3)hede e d nt a td 3 iu td ( h q a te t n wa s d n r n s f e a sfc tc ( t fn a s ce

1 wihdici iaoyitnti a pligti ca sfc to ; nd()plitf s fee ij r a ars lof 4 t srm n tr n e n p yn hs lsiiain a 4 anif u frd nu y s eut

1 tedsrmiaor ca sfc to . av Ci o chio, 4F.up .d11 2,11 7( . . a.00 )s e 5 h ici n t y lsiiain Mou . t f c 32 s pz 3 3 E D C l2 4 'e y , 1 Barenv Harigtn,1 F.d 11 3,ll 4( t Ci.998 ( s cin 1 3plitf algngde ilof 6 r . rn o 52 3 9 9 9h r1 ) a e to 98 anif le i n a
1 equalpr t cton tm us s ow t att edef nda t act d wih an i t ntorpur os t di crm i at agai s 7 oe i s th h h e ns e t ne p eo s i n e nt

1 plitfbasdo me bes i i apr tce c1s.) V nPool . ' an Ctul o anFr n ic , 2 8 anif e n m rhp n oe td as'' a ', v Cly d lrf l / y a cs o 75 1 F,upp.91 ,92 ( . . a11 90 (s cin 1 8 pantf mus pr vep ros fldici iain by 9s 5 7 N D C .9 ) e to 9 3 li if t o u p eu srm n to 20 de o sr tngt a heç e evldqdifr ntteam e tfo t a r c i e by o he ssm ia l st ae , m n tai h t t c i e fee r t n r m h t e ev d t r i lry iu t d' r '
21 a dta tete t e tc mplie ofwa unde c lrofsaelw) n h th ram n o an d s r oo tt a ,
2 2 H e e pl i tf hasnotale e t a t e de ii n t g a tt e b a k i m a e t e r quie r , a n if lg d h t h cso o r n h l c n t h e r d 23 s r e' a d t de y hi t e s r e y wasbas d o r c ,Ra he , m e e y a l g st a t o i m a e of ug l n o n m h ug r y e n a e t r he r l le e h t w n t s

2 dif r n r c swe e te td dif r nty. The e f csdo no sa e a cai unde t e e ua p o e ton 4 fe e t a e r r ae fe e l s at t tt l m r h q l r t ci
25 cl us . Thi counts al be di m i s d w ih l ave t am end. ae s hl s se t e o
26 3

CountThr e e Pl i tf hassat d acl i undert eFi s and Foureent A m endm entf rr t laton on a n if te am h rt th o e ai i

t e ba l oft e f c spr s nt d i t i c a m f rr le . h ss h a t e e e n h s li o e if

I I THEREFOREORDERED t a teMoto st Ame d( oc e /11a d#1 )ae TS h th in o n d k t/ n 2 r
G R A N T ED . The Cl r oft e Cour shal det ch and FILE t e fr ta e ded com pl i t ek h t la h is m n an .

I IS FURTH E R O R D E R E D t at t e St t of Nevada i DISM ISSE D W IT H T h h ae s PR EJU D IC E . I IS FU R T H ER OR D E R ED t at Count Tw o of t e Am ended Com pl i t i T h h an s D I M ISSE D W I H O U T PR EJU D IC E AND W I H LEAV E TO AM E N D . Pl i tf s al have S T T a n if h l t i t dayst tl a SecondAm ended com pl i tw hi haddr s est edefci nci souti ed i t i Or e . h ry o 'e i an c es h ie e ln n h s d r Faiur t tl an am ended com pl i twilres l i t e m aterproceedi g ast Count One and Three l e o 'e i an l ut n h t n o s onl . y D at d t i 29t day ofNovem ber e hs h
,

2010.

I N I ED STA ' S DI TR I T J D G E JT SCU

4