Blake v. Baker et al

Filing 60

ORDER: IT IS ORDERED that petitioner's Motion for Reconsideration of Denial of Motion for Stay and Abeyance 54 is DENIED. FURTHER ORDERED that petitioner shall have twenty (20) days within which to file a Notice of Abandonment of Unexhausted Claims, indicating that Claims One through Five, Six(A)(B)and(D), Seven(A-F)(H-J),and Nine through Thirteen are to be deleted from his amended petition 17 . FURTHER ORDERED that, if petitioner does not abandon his unexhausted claims, the amended pe tition 17 shall be dismissed.FURTHER ORDERED that, if petitioner abandons his unexhausted claims, respondents shall have sixty (60) days from the date of Notice of Abandonment within which to file an Answer to the remaining claims in the second amended petition 17 . Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 3/14/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

'
. . 1

'

j
i

1. .l , '
.
.
' j

1
.
j

2
'

3
4 '

5
E k
i

6 7

UNI TED STATES DI STR I C O URT CT
i

DI STRI O F N EVADA CT

8 . 9 Acyoxso MAxusl su a - Ax
1 0
II vs
.

2 : i
!

Peii r ttone,

) ) )
) ) ) ) ) ) )
/

3:9-v- 327- 0 c 00 RCJRAM . ORDER
.
'

1 E. Mc 2 K. oANl -et . st, al, 1 3 Re p nt. s onde s
1 4

1 5
(

A Ne d ur con ce Peii e Alons Ma lBlkeoftemur r oft y va aj y vitd tton r f o nue a h des wo oung

1 women. He uns c s f ly a a e hi c c i a d s n e tofde t i t s a e c t He ha 6 uc e s u l ppe l d s onvi ton n e t nc a h n he t t ours. s

1 p ii dt scour frha a c pu r ifpus a t 28U. C.û2254.OnNo mbe 2, 0 7 cttone hi t o be s or s ele ru nt o S. ve r 201 ,
i
I
. Blake v. McDaniel et al

.

2 2() Ecy 2) J t Cou td idhi motonf sa a da y ce ( eOr ,xov. , ) 0, No.j , 8 hc r ene s i or ty n be an . Se der 1 Pe di g be or t Cour i Pcii rsM oto t Re sde ( o . co .Nov. 2 0, 9 n n f e he t s ttone ' in o con i r M t Re ns, 2, 01 ECF
Doc. 60

2 No.5 .Fort r a o gi n he en,heCour d ni t moton. 0 4) he e s ns ve r i t t e es he i
!
I

21

I denyi t ori nalm oton,t Cour concl n ng he gi i he t uded t Pettonerbad notesabls hat ii t i hed good

22 ca s ' f f lngt ex us saec r r me e a r quie by t Supr meCour i Rhi sv u e' or aii o ha t t t ou t e dis s e r d he e t n ne .

23 We e ,5 U. 269( ) Peii ragu statt Cour ma a er oust a ke hol n b r 44 S. 2005 . ttonc r e h he t de n rone f n t dig bl

i
r

24 t ti fe tvea ssa eofpos- nvito c e ca ne rc nsiuegoodc eu rRhi s. ha nefci s itnc tco cin ounsl n ve o ttt aus nde ne ' ' 25 ( ot Re ons 4) TheCour ma nos h ho dng bu c cl d t tPetton rsc amst hi M . c . . t de uc l i t on ude ha ii e ' l i hat s
26 postconvi i counself l t r s pot i i m ert i cl m s i st e cour,and t s cton aied o aie entaly iorous ai n at t hat uch

i
.

:

'

!
!
Dockets.Justia.com

'

'
I

rv z

.

.

.

i !
1 l f l e w asbeyond hi contol weei um ce t me t h goo ca s san r ( eorer . aiur s r , r ns into e te d u e t dad. se d 4)

2 TheCou trjctdt sar ntb c s s hacam c dbemad b vi al e r ha a r ee e hi gume e au e uc li oul e y c ly vey be s
i 3 c uspe ii rs e ng a sa w hi h r ul woul c e ry c l c w ih t Sup e e Co ts om ttone e ki t y, c es t d l a l onti t t he r m ur '
'

4 gu da e i Rhi s t tm i d pe ii s d onl bes a ed i lm ie c r um s a e . Woot n v i nc n ne ha xe ttons houl y t y n i t d ic t nc s e .

i
!

5 Kikl d, F. 1 9,1 4 ( t Ci.20 .Thus t Co t nid t moton t say n r an 540 3d 01 02 9 h r 08) ,he ur de e he i o t , ot

6 b cueictg rcl rjce ten to ta iercieassa c o p s-o vcinc u sl a ea s t ae oial eetd h oin htn fet sitn e f otc n it o n e cn y v o
7 s r e a goo c us f f ii t e a t bu be a e Pe ii r sa gu e s i s or ofg e v s d a e or a lng o xh us , t c us ttone ' r m nt n upp t ood
8 cause,assetf lh i hi i talm oton,wer t generc. ol n s nii i e oo i

! I ;

9

Th Cou tde lne t r c i e . Alhoug t Co t d notm a s h a bl nk r i i e r c i s o e ons d r t h he ur di ke uc a et ulng n

1 t orgi or r o rc i rtont Co ttndst ta amat oflw aStikand-y cli 0 he i nal de, n e onsdeai he ur ' ha s ter a i rc l bpzl am
ll ofi fec i a s s a e ofp t c c i 'c s lc nnotc tt e g c us f f ii t ne f tve s i t nc os - onvi ton oun e a onsiut ood a e or a lng o

i
!

I e us acli i afd a h e c pusa i Se Marl zv Sc 'o, F. 7 1 7 (*Ci. 2 xha t am n e erl ab as or cton. e t . hl 623 3d 3 , 43 9 r he r
.

1 2 1 )(iigColmanv Tho on,5 1U. 72 75 ( 991) Landr m v Mich l6 F. 9 3 0 0 ctn e . mps 0 S. 2, 2 1 )' , u . t el, 25 3d 05, 1 9l ( hCi. 1 ( tngColman,5 U. at75 * nnyla a n Fi e 481U. 551 555 4 9 6t r 20 0) cii e 01 S. 0,Pe s v ni nly, S. ,

1 (9 7) Th 1wo tip it a be cerntiCi uto oe adcd :çA)y 5 18). ea n hs on hs en la i hs r ifr vr eae t n c (
1 i fe tv nesoîg latone i t po -onvitonprc s i notc sdee c us frt 6 nefcie s an tr y n he stc ci o e s s on i rd a e o he l pur e ofe sng()prce a dea ta t tsa .'Mannigv Fose , F. 1 2 11 7 pos s xcu i a o durl ful tha tge' n . tr 224 3d 1 9, 33
I

1 ( hCi.20 ( tn Colman,5 U. a 7 . 8 9t r 00) ciig e 01 S. t 52)
19 Thi does notm ean t postconvi i couns ' actonscan neversuppor a s s hat cton els i t howi of ng

i
(

2 g o c u e Go dc u ec ne itfre a l, a e o acam ta p s-o vcinc u s l 0 o d a s . o a s a xs,o x mpe b sd n li h t o tc n it o n e o
21 i or d a pe ii ne ' i tuc i a t r by obt i e a wor e o c e t n t pe ii rw o d gn e tto r s ns r tons nd he e an d s ut om ha he ttone ul 2 ha r a he on hi own. Buts h a cl i i d fe e f o a i f e tve as iuncec ai . 2 ve e c d s uc a m s i f r nt r m n ne f c i s s lm 23 A lhough s a cl m i vesa pettoner' postconvi i ator t uch ai nvol ii s cton t ney,i i atis cor a . ts t e

j
i
I

2 gre-aitcam o etra itr rnewi aptinrs blyt peet cam.Sei.t 4 adnvr y li fxenlnef ec t eio e'ait o rsn a li e d a e e h t i
25 11 ( di t ata ator e si e fr nc wih apeiin duet ac ntitofit r s c s 34 hol ng h n t n y' ntre e e t tto o o lc n e e t an uppor t
26

l

Se Stikan v Was ngt 4 U. 688(1 ) e rc l d . hi on, 66 S. 984 .
2

j '

'

.
:, ;0 .. . ., I .

!

1 ca s c usngapr e ald aul) l et rwor ,ç atore din'doag e ughj bi u e xc i oc dur ef t. n he ds d t n y d t my ood no o n
2 po tc i ton p oc e ng ' c nn con tt t goo c us , e i a 11 but ç y a t ne s - onv c i r t di s ' a ot s iu e d a e s e d. t 33, çm tor y
I

3 i er er w ih m y atem pt t pr entm y petton' can,see i atIl34. A contar concl on nt f cd t t s o es ii ' d. r y usi

.

i

4 woul noton y f usr t t e pur os sofA EDPA,i woul e o t Su e e Co tse lc t d l r ta e h p e t d r dc he pr m ur ' xp i i

5 rjctonofapuai rg t pos-onvitonc s li Fl e be a eiwoul e us prce url ee i ttve ihto tc ci oun e n . y, c us t d xc e o d a nl
; 6 d a t ba edpur l upont epe f r nc oft tc uns a m e s e notbyt egoodc us efuls s ey h ro ma e ha o el s a ur d h a e
ii ai y he ist nd r , 7 sa r but t pr eso lsa r ofSrc an . Pettonercl m sonl t fr ki oferor t nda d, by he ofsina tndad tikl d !
i '

8 whi cannots ch upportat ng ofcaus indi e.

9

I I TH ER EFO RE O R DERED t tt ttone ' M oton f Re ons de a i ofDe al T S ha e ii r s pe i or c i r ton ni

i ! '
!

1 ofMoto frStya Abe an e'( ke #54)i DENI 0 in o a nd y c ' doc t s ED. 11 I I FVRTHER o l t t tpeii rs l hav t y ( 0)daysfom t d t t s T s toslxo ha ttone ba l e went 2 r he a e hi
I or ri e er d w ihi whi h t Il a Notc ofAba onm e ofUne ause Cl i ,i di tng 2 de s nt e t n c o ie ic nd nt xh t d a ms n ca i

1 t tCli Onet o hFi Si( ( a d( ,Se nA- ( J, dNi t oug Thite aet 3 ha ams hrug ve, xA)B) n D) ve ( F)H-) an ne hr h re n r o
1 bed ltdfom hi a nd dpeii ( ke #1 . 4 eee r s me e tton doc t 7)
l5 I IS FU RTH ER O R DER ED t ,i Pettonerdoesnota T hat f ii bandon hi unexhaused cl m s s t ai i

1 wihi t tmea lwe t a n d pciin ( c t/1 s l bedimis d u rRo ev.Lundy 6 t n he i lo d, he me de tto do ke / 7) ha l s s e nde s ,

;
:
I
i

1 455U. 5 ( 9 . 7 S. 09 1 82) 1 8 I I FURTHER ORDERED t t i Peiine a ndo hi un ha td camswihi t e T S ha , f tto r ba ns s ex use li tnh
1 tmeal ds e ponde t s a l v sxt ( da fo t eda et Notc ofAba nme i 9 i lowe r s n s h l ha e i v 60) ys r m h t he ie ndo nt s
2 Gl w ihi whi h t fl a Ans t t r m a ni cl i s i t e s co r vi e a e d pe ii 0 ed t n c o ie n wer o he c i ng a m n h e nd e s d m nde tton

21 ( ke #1 ) doc t 7.
22 DATED : M ar h 1 2011 c 4,
. ' .' 23 24 25

I !
1

I TED ST ' s ol t c' JUD E JNI sTll r '
.

:
I
;

26
3

.
.

I k

'