Mellema v. Gammick

Filing 15

ORDERED that this action is DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE. Clerk shall enter judgment accordingly. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/3/2009. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

.

. . . .. = .

' .

. , .-. -

'

'

.

T q

w . .. ..
..

'

; .

(
! .

1 2 3 4
5

!
J ;
..
... ..

I
!
;
'

' Wî ' - '
.
.

àl #

' '

'
.

'

,
N

.. .

: .

r
.

; j

6

UNI E D STATES DI T R I T CO U R T T S C

7

DI T R I T O F NEVA D A SC

9 l a 1 2
1 3

8 MC EL M LEPl,ti, IHLE ELMai C An
Df dn . e nat es

) )
)

39 V31 C(A ) :- -3- J M 0C R R
ORDER

1 RCA.G M IK,etaI, l IHv A MC . R D
1 4

y )
)

)

Bef r t e Cour i t e Repor and Recom m endaton oft e Unied St t s M agi tat oe h ts h t i h t ae sr e

1 Judge ( 1 )(' ec m mendaton' ent r d on Sept mber23, 5 #4 ' o R i ' ee ) e 2009,Thi acinwasrf red s to ee r
1 t U. . agitat Robed A. 6 o S M sr e Mcouai ,Jr,pur uantt 28 U S. . 6 6( )1 ( ) dLR I 1 d.s o C j 3 b ( )B an B1 4.Afera t or u h r viw , he Magi tat Judge r com m ends t att i Cour ent ran or er 7 t h og e e t sr e e h hs te d
.

1 d s isn t i aci n wi prjdie,No o j c int t e Rep r a d Re o me da in h s 8 im s ig hs t o t eu c h be t o h o o t n c m n to a
1 been fl d. 9 ie
20 1 D l cussl N . s o

21

Thi Cour ' ay accept rj c,or modi ,i whol or i par,t e fn igs or s t' m , ee t fn y e n t h idn
.

22 r c m m endatons made byt e magitat '2 U. . . 63 ( )1 .Fu terun er2 U. . . eo i h s r e ' 8 S C j 6 b ( ) rh , d 8 S C

2 j 63 ( )1 ,i a pa t mak sa tmey o j cin t t e magsr t jdge' r c mmen ai n 3 6 b ( ) f ry e i l be t o h o ita e u s e o dt , o 24 t ent i Cour i r quied t ' ak ade nov det r iaton oft oseporinsofte (epod h hs ts e r o ' e m o em n i h to hr
25 and r c m mendatonqt whih objcton i made.l Nevedhelss,t e stt t does not eo ioc ei s ' e h aue 26 'equieg)some Isserr viw by (hi Courqwhen no obj cinsar fld. Thomasv A r , 'r r e ee ts t e to ei ' e' n
.

27 28
1

Fc a o jc lnt bet ey ap rymu t e v a d feiwi l 1) a s atrb dgs re wi te ma ltaeldg , e ot nd ) n be l o .m l. at s s re n l t t n ( d y l en ev d t t qsf t u esr p ra r o I l h e hl

rc mmedtn28U. . j6 6b)1( ) eo nai . S C. . 3 ( ( )C . o
1

1 474 U. .1 0,1 9-50( 985) Isead,undert esat t ,hi Couri notr quiedt c nduc S4 4 1 .n t h t ue t s ts e r o o t

2 ' n rviw a al,. o an is et a i n thes be t f o j c in,..a 1 9.Si i r , ' y e e t I . f y s u h ts o t u jc o an be t '! t 4 a o '# ml l ay
3 t e Ni t Cicui has r cogni ed t ata di t i tcour i notr quied t r vi w a m agi t at h nh r t e zh s rc ls e r oee sr e

4 5 6 7

j dge' r por and r c m mendatonwher noobecinshave beenfld. Uni d St ts u se t eo i e j to i See t a e e e v.Revna- api , F.d 1114( t Ci, T a 328 3 9 h r2003)( ir gar igt est ndar ofrviw emplyed d se dn h a d e e o byt edititcourwhenr viwigar porandr c mm endatont whihnoobectonswer h src t e e n e t eo io c ji e madel see alo Schmitv. ; s d Johnst ne,263 F. upp. 1 19,1 26 ( . i.2003)(eadig o s 2d 2 2 D Arz rn

8 t e Ni t Cicui' deci i n i Reyna-r pi as adoptng t e vi w t atdi t i tcour s ar n t h n h r ts so n -a a iheh s rc t eo

9 r quied t r viw ' ny isue t ati nott e subjctofan obj cin.) Thus,it er i no e r oee a s hs h e e to '. fh e s 1 obecin t a magitat j dge' r c m mendaton, t en t i Cour may acc pt t e 0 j to o sr e u s e o i h hs ' t eh 11 r c mmendatonwihoutr viw.See e. .Johnst ne,263 F, upp.2d at1226 ( cc ptng, eo it ee n, o s aei
I wih utr viw,a magitat j dge' r c m mendatont whihnoobectonwasfld) 2 to e e sr e u s e o io c ji ie . 1 3 I t i cas , endanthasn tfldanobectont t e Magitat Judge' Reporand n hs e def o ie j i oh sr e s l 1 Recommendaton.Alhough no objctonwasfld,hi Cour hasr viwed te Repor and 4 i t ei i ts e t ee h t

1 Recommendaton ( 1 ) and accept i.Accor igl, 5 i # 4, st dn y
1 6 I I HER EBY O R D E R ED t att i ac i n i D I M I S E D W I H PREJUD I E . The TS h h s to s S S T C

1 Clr oft e Cour shalent rjdgmentac or ig. 7 ek h t l eu c dn
1 8
1 9
20
21

I I SO O R D ER ED . TS
DATED :Thi '/ day ofNovem ber 2009. s ,
ts n r

2:

'

23
24 25 26 27 28

R obed C,Jo UN I E D ST T

S D I TR I T JUDG E S C