Zakouto v. Skolnik et al

Filing 28

ORDER. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Defendants' 19 & 20 Motions for Summary Judgment are GRANTED. The Clerk shall enter Judgment accordingly. Signed by Chief Judge Robert C. Jones on 6/1/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - KO)

..

jz
:
.

1 1:
. .
'
r

'. s E T RE
NE b

l

. jg
,
:

, j. FL D â
. lE ê
.

,

.

'

.( (l
i. !
b1
,

.n..,c
; .g. j
sf.
yj
'-vj j,j
va
.z
t

X U S U X TI LVVG R
N E PR I Q. U D

t
r
J
uN j2 ! ) t
gf: :
.
?t''
!.
$'
ï
l
)J y
7'?
'
'

2

:
$

1
,

.

.
.

-

4

.

c
uRKu oc qcr t
s i l-w ar

D I S V/ h n w
YXC F fYf su
,
5

B:
Y

'-b- ; r:. -- - : :.
- c. .u

6

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT

7

.

DI
STR I O F N EVA DA
CT

8 VI
TALY M KO UTO ,

9
1l
(
I

ll
1:
!

.

Pl n i
ait
s,

3:9- 0O 4 RCJ RAM)
0 CV- 33 - (

h
k
l

''
:'

(

HO W ARD SKO LNI ela/,
K,
,

''
'
.

''li 1 . '
l't'
J

I

1
3

Def
endant
s.

1
4

:

1
5

Be o et e Cou ti t e Rep t d Re qrl n yt o t e Untd St t sMags rt
fr h
rsh
oran s qre d i f h i
on
e ae
ita e

1 J d ( No.27 (Re omme ai n ' t éd on F: u y 1 2O11 i whc te
6 u ge ECF
)u c
nd t )Jher
on
brar 4, , n ih h
l uagsr e au ge r ommen s kà ti càit'r' oeen ans uoin frsumma,
,
itat d ec
d h t hs ir g a' f d t, to o
' n
t
.
y
.

1 Jd
8 u gmen ( No 1 an 20 .
t ECF s. 9 d )

i

'
'
.

1
9

Noobecton t t Reporand Recommendaton hasbeenfl
j i o he
t
i
i
ed.

20
'

1 Dl
. scussl
oN

.

21
Thi Coud '
s
may acc ,rj ,or modiy,i whol or i par,t fndi or
ept eect
f n
e
n t he i ngs
22 r
ecommendatonsmadebyt magi r e.28U. C. 636( ( .Furher under28 U. C.
i
he
stat '
'
S. j
b)1) t ,
S.
''

2 j6 ( ( )ia p ymak sat yobeci t t ma it4t jd sr omme ai ,
3 36b)1,f ad
e i
mel j t o he jsr e u ge' ec
on
nd t
on
2 tenti Cou i rqurdt % ead n od ér hai o to ep o o teIe or
4 h hs d s e ie o mak e ov lt mi t f h s odins fh rp t
on
.
'

1

25 and r
ecommendaton)t whi obect i made.' Nevedhel t sat e does not
i o ch j i s
on
D.
ess, he t ut

26 'equiel someI
r r )
esserr ew byIhi Cour)wheinoobect ar fl 'Thomasv. n,
evi
ts
t
j i
ons e i '
ed.
Ar 474
27

28

:.''. ' '
J. . C

,

'Foranobeci t betr y, padymusts v andfl iwihi 10daysaferbei
j ton o i
pçl a
ere
i t tn
e
t
ng
s v dwi t magsr ej gesr od qn r ommen at 2 u.. j6 6b() .
ere t he
h
itat ud ' ep
'
d ec
d i 8 sc. 3 ()1(
on.
c)
l

j....

(

jyyj.
jj yj
j yj
.

t

.Et.-;
'è,;; .
' . .. ,
z

- qF !iFi
: -':. :k
- ;i '
'

q

l u. 1 , 4 -so(s ) lse , n rh t uq tl . di o rqur oc n c ' y
s. 40 l g 1 as. n tap u de tesàli,pscou sn te i
edt o du t'
an

I

2 r iw a al . o a yis t fjgo t es l -t :nobe t . I a 1 9.Si l l t e
eve t 1. . f n s ue ha ip t h ujgcc a j c i ,, d. t 4
of
on
mi y,h
ar
k3 Nit ci uih r c nz dt t ditit o tsno r qurd t r ve amagit ej d '
n h r t as e og ie ha a sr c uri t e i o e iw
c
c
e
sr u ges
at
4 r dandr
epo
ecom mendatonwher
i
enoobj tonshavebeenfl seeuniedst esv.
eci
ied.
t at Revna-

I

E
i

l

,

l.t. . '
t. .
't
$
.

.

!

5 Tani 328 F. 1114 ( h Ci.
a,
3d
9t r 2003)( sr di t sandar ofr ew empl byt
di egar ng he t
d evi
oyed he

!

6 ditit
src coudwhenr ewi ar t r ommendat t chnoobj tonswer madel
evi ng eporand ec
i owhi
on
eci
e
.
'
7 seeal Schmi v.
so
dt Johnsone, F.
t 263 supp. 1 1 1226( Arz.
2d 2.9,
D, i 2003)(eadi t Ni h
.r ng he nt

i

8 Cicui' deci on i Revna- a as adoptng t vi t di rc couds ar notr r t
r ts
si n
Tapi
i he ew hat stit
e
equied o

i

9 r ew ' i t i nott subectofan obj i ''.Thus,it e i no obecton t a
evi ' ssue hats
any
he j
ecton.)
'
f her s
j i o

1 ma it t u g'rc mme dt nte tiCo rma a cptercmmed t nwio t
0 gsr ejd eseo nai ,h nhs ut y ce th eo nai t u
a
o
o h
q

ll r i Seee. .
evew.
q.Johnst 263F,
one,
supp. at1 26(
2d . acceptng, t r ew, magi r e
2
i wihout evi a
stat

:

1 jd ' r omme da i t whihnoobe t ! sfe .
2 u ges ec
n t o c
on
j ci wa i d)
on
l
1
3
I t scas t ehavebeennoobeci fl t t Magitat Judge' Rep tand
n hi e,her
j tons i o he
ed
sr e
s or
1 Recom m endaton Al
4
i
t
hough noobectonwasfl t sCoud hasr ewedt Repod and
j i
i hi
ed,
evi
he

l

.

.

1 Recommendaton ( No. andacc si.Acc di y,
5
i ECF 27)
ept t. or ngl
1
6
I I HEREBY ORDERED t t f d t ' inf Su
TS
ha Deen an s Mot or mmar u gmen ( No
o
yl d
t ECF s.
:

i
;

1 1 and2o)ar GRANTED.
7 9
e
1
8
1
9

The Cl koft Cour shalen erJudgm entaccor ngl
er
he
t l t
di y.
Dat Thi 1stday ofJune,2011,
ed: s

20
21

2
2
23

'

RO B RT C J N ES
C hi Di t i t our Judge
ef s r
t
:

24

25
26
27

28

2