Zakouto v. Skolnik et al

Filing 28

ORDER. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Defendants' 19 & 20 Motions for Summary Judgment are GRANTED. The Clerk shall enter Judgment accordingly. Signed by Chief Judge Robert C. Jones on 6/1/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - KO)

Download PDF
.. jz : . 1 1: . . ' r '. s E T RE NE b l . jg , : , j. FL D â . lE ê . , . ' .( (l i. ! b1 , .n..,c ; .g. j sf. yj '-vj j,j va .z t X U S U X TI LVVG R N E PR I Q. U D t r J uN j2 ! ) t gf: : . ?t'' !. $' ï l )J y 7'? ' ' 2 : $ 1 , . . . - 4 . c uRKu oc qcr t s i l-w ar D I S V/ h n w YXC F fYf su , 5 B: Y '-b- ; r:. -- - : :. - c. .u 6 UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT 7 . DI STR I O F N EVA DA CT 8 VI TALY M KO UTO , 9 1l ( I ll 1: ! . Pl n i ait s, 3:9- 0O 4 RCJ RAM) 0 CV- 33 - ( h k l '' :' ( HO W ARD SKO LNI ela/, K, , '' ' . ''li 1 . ' l't' J I 1 3 Def endant s. 1 4 : 1 5 Be o et e Cou ti t e Rep t d Re qrl n yt o t e Untd St t sMags rt fr h rsh oran s qre d i f h i on e ae ita e 1 J d ( No.27 (Re omme ai n ' t éd on F: u y 1 2O11 i whc te 6 u ge ECF )u c nd t )Jher on brar 4, , n ih h l uagsr e au ge r ommen s kà ti càit'r' oeen ans uoin frsumma, , itat d ec d h t hs ir g a' f d t, to o ' n t . y . 1 Jd 8 u gmen ( No 1 an 20 . t ECF s. 9 d ) i ' ' . 1 9 Noobecton t t Reporand Recommendaton hasbeenfl j i o he t i i ed. 20 ' 1 Dl . scussl oN . 21 Thi Coud ' s may acc ,rj ,or modiy,i whol or i par,t fndi or ept eect f n e n t he i ngs 22 r ecommendatonsmadebyt magi r e.28U. C. 636( ( .Furher under28 U. C. i he stat ' ' S. j b)1) t , S. '' 2 j6 ( ( )ia p ymak sat yobeci t t ma it4t jd sr omme ai , 3 36b)1,f ad e i mel j t o he jsr e u ge' ec on nd t on 2 tenti Cou i rqurdt % ead n od ér hai o to ep o o teIe or 4 h hs d s e ie o mak e ov lt mi t f h s odins fh rp t on . ' 1 25 and r ecommendaton)t whi obect i made.' Nevedhel t sat e does not i o ch j i s on D. ess, he t ut 26 'equiel someI r r ) esserr ew byIhi Cour)wheinoobect ar fl 'Thomasv. n, evi ts t j i ons e i ' ed. Ar 474 27 28 :.''. ' ' J. . C , 'Foranobeci t betr y, padymusts v andfl iwihi 10daysaferbei j ton o i pçl a ere i t tn e t ng s v dwi t magsr ej gesr od qn r ommen at 2 u.. j6 6b() . ere t he h itat ud ' ep ' d ec d i 8 sc. 3 ()1( on. c) l j.... ( jyyj. jj yj j yj . t .Et.-; 'è,;; . ' . .. , z - qF !iFi : -':. :k - ;i ' ' q l u. 1 , 4 -so(s ) lse , n rh t uq tl . di o rqur oc n c ' y s. 40 l g 1 as. n tap u de tesàli,pscou sn te i edt o du t' an I 2 r iw a al . o a yis t fjgo t es l -t :nobe t . I a 1 9.Si l l t e eve t 1. . f n s ue ha ip t h ujgcc a j c i ,, d. t 4 of on mi y,h ar k3 Nit ci uih r c nz dt t ditit o tsno r qurd t r ve amagit ej d ' n h r t as e og ie ha a sr c uri t e i o e iw c c e sr u ges at 4 r dandr epo ecom mendatonwher i enoobj tonshavebeenfl seeuniedst esv. eci ied. t at Revna- I E i l , l.t. . ' t. . 't $ . . ! 5 Tani 328 F. 1114 ( h Ci. a, 3d 9t r 2003)( sr di t sandar ofr ew empl byt di egar ng he t d evi oyed he ! 6 ditit src coudwhenr ewi ar t r ommendat t chnoobj tonswer madel evi ng eporand ec i owhi on eci e . ' 7 seeal Schmi v. so dt Johnsone, F. t 263 supp. 1 1 1226( Arz. 2d 2.9, D, i 2003)(eadi t Ni h .r ng he nt i 8 Cicui' deci on i Revna- a as adoptng t vi t di rc couds ar notr r t r ts si n Tapi i he ew hat stit e equied o i 9 r ew ' i t i nott subectofan obj i ''.Thus,it e i no obecton t a evi ' ssue hats any he j ecton.) ' f her s j i o 1 ma it t u g'rc mme dt nte tiCo rma a cptercmmed t nwio t 0 gsr ejd eseo nai ,h nhs ut y ce th eo nai t u a o o h q ll r i Seee. . evew. q.Johnst 263F, one, supp. at1 26( 2d . acceptng, t r ew, magi r e 2 i wihout evi a stat : 1 jd ' r omme da i t whihnoobe t ! sfe . 2 u ges ec n t o c on j ci wa i d) on l 1 3 I t scas t ehavebeennoobeci fl t t Magitat Judge' Rep tand n hi e,her j tons i o he ed sr e s or 1 Recom m endaton Al 4 i t hough noobectonwasfl t sCoud hasr ewedt Repod and j i i hi ed, evi he l . . 1 Recommendaton ( No. andacc si.Acc di y, 5 i ECF 27) ept t. or ngl 1 6 I I HEREBY ORDERED t t f d t ' inf Su TS ha Deen an s Mot or mmar u gmen ( No o yl d t ECF s. : i ; 1 1 and2o)ar GRANTED. 7 9 e 1 8 1 9 The Cl koft Cour shalen erJudgm entaccor ngl er he t l t di y. Dat Thi 1stday ofJune,2011, ed: s 20 21 2 2 23 ' RO B RT C J N ES C hi Di t i t our Judge ef s r t : 24 25 26 27 28 2

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?