Knox v. Arguello et al

Filing 10

ORDERED Clerk shall FILE the complaint. FURTHER ORD the complaint is DISMISSED with leave to amend. FURTHER ORD P may file amended complaint by 8/22/2010. FURTHER ORD P shall title amended complaint as "FIRST AMENDED" w case number above. F URTHER ORD Clerk shall send P 1983 form w instructions, and copy of the original complaint. ( Form and copies mailed to P 7/8/2010 ) Signed by Magistrate Judge Robert A. McQuaid, Jr on 7/6/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

RL D E ENTERE D

PEOEI D W SE VE 0N BD tQJS LFF ICO R C F IN E/A TE F E P Z

1

U

IL - 7 21 I. J 00

2

5 4
5

U 6R USDIT IT O U T îV S BC O R
DITRIT0FNE ZDA SO V

B: Y

-. - - - - - - - DS E Y PC

6
7

U N I E D ST A T E S D I T R I T C O U R T T S C 8
D IST R I T O F NE V A D A C 9 10

M ONTEN EQUE NAKI KNOX, A 11 1 2 1 3 l 4
15 l6 17
Knox v. Arguello et al

Plitfl an it
vs .

TANI ARGUELLO,e al, A t.
Defnda t. e ns

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
/

3:9c - 0559- DM -t M 0 -v 0 H IA
ORDER

Plitf hass bm itdapr s cii rg t compli tpurua tt 42U. . .j1 83. anif u te o e v l ih s an s n o SC 9 Pli tf ' a plc tont pr c e i for apau e i wa grntd t Marh29 201 ( oc e /9 . an ifs p iai o o e d n m p rs s a e m c , 0. D k t/)
Doc. 10

18

TheCour now r viwsplitf sc mplit ( o ke /12) t e e anif o an . D c t/ - .
1 9 1 Sc ee i g St ndar . r nn a d
20

Purua tt t ePrs ne LiiatonReor ActI L1AI fdea c ursmus dimisa s n o h io r tg i f m P k ,e rl o t t s s
pr s ner' cl i s,çi t e alegaton ofpovert i k t ues'ori t e acton ûi f i ol us orm alci us,' i o s a m tf h l i y s m r ' fh i ts r v o io '

21
22

l a l t s a e a c a m on whi h r le m a be g a t d, ort e ks m one a y r le ag i s a de enda t i is o t t l i f c e if y r ne ' l e 's tr e if a n t f n

23
24

whoi i munefo s c rle ' 28U. . .9 1 1 e ( ) Dim is lofacomplitfrfiur t sm rm u h eif ' S C 9 5()2 . s sa an o al e o
sat a cai upon whi h r le ma begr nt d i pr vi ed f ri Fe e alRul ofCi i Pr ce ur te lm c e if y a e s o d o n dr e vl o d e

25

l ( )6) a dt eCour a plestesm esa dadunde Se ton 1 l ()2)whe rviwigte 2b( , n h t p i h a tn r r ci 9 5 e ( ne e n h
26

a e ua y ofa c m pl i tora e de c m pl i t dq c o an m n d o an ,

Dockets.Justia.com

1

Reviw unde Rul 1 ()6 i e s nilyanligonaq esinoflw.Se Cha pe e r e 2 b () s se tal ln u to a e pl

2 v fa o atr Cop.fAme ia 2 2F.d71 , 23( t Ci. 0 0 .Dimis l o fi r t saea . b r oy r o rc , 3 3 9 7 9 h r 2 0 ) s sa fr al e o tt u
3 c a m i pr pe onl i i i c e rt a t e pl i tf c nnotpr ve a y s toff ct i s ppo toft e cl i l i s o r y f t s l a h t h a n if a o ne a sn u r h am

4 t a woul enttehi orhe t rle.Se More v Wale ,1 5F.d 756,759(t Ci.1 .l h t d il m r o eif e ly . k r 7 3 9h r 999) n
5 m a i g t i de e m i a i n,t e Cour t kesast u al a l ga i ns o m a e i lf c s a ed i t e k n h s tr n to h ta r e l le to f t ra a t t t n h

6 co pli t a d t eCour c nsr e t em i t e lghtm os f vor bl t t epl i tf. Se War haw v m an, n h t o tu s h n h i t a a e o h an if e s .

7 XomaCor .74F.d955,957(t Ci.1 96) Ale ainsi upr s c mplitaehel t ls p, 3 9h r 9 . lg to n o e o an r d o e s
8 srnge tsanda dst a f r a pla i gsdr fe by lw ye s Se Hu he v Rowe,449 U. .5,9 ti n t r h n o m l e d n al d a r . e g s . S

9 ( 9 0 , n sv Ke n r 4 4U. . 9 5 0 21(97 )+e c ra ) s eas Ba ite i . c c 1 8 ) Haie . r e , 0 S 51 , 2 - 1 2 r u im ; e lo lsr r v Pa 6 a .
1 PolceDe t 901F.d696,699(t Ci.1 90) 0 i pt , 2 9h r 9 .
11 A l orpa t a c m pl i tsl d b a pr s ne m a t e e or be di m i s d s a s ont i 1 r of o a n e y io r y h rf e s se u p e f 1 t e pr s ne ' cl i s l ck a a gua l bas seihe i l w ori f ct Thi i c ude c a m s ba e on 2 h io r s a m a n r b e i t r n a n a . s n l s li sd

13 lga c nclsonsta aeune a l (. . am sagans defnda t whoaei m u efo s i o e l o u i h t r tn b e eg cli i t e ns r m n rm ut r 1 cai sofifi g men ofalga itr s whihce rydoe note it,aswela cai sbasdon 4 lm n rn e t e l nee t c lal s x s) l slm e

1 fncf lfcua ale ains(..fntsi ordeusona se ai s.Se Netkev Wilams 490U, . 5 a iu a t l lg to eg a a tc l i l c n ro ) e iz . li , S 1 31 ,327- 8( 98 ) s ealoM c e v rv Blc , 2F.d795,798( t Ci.1 91, 69 2 1 9 ; e s K e e . o k 93 2 9h r 9 )
1 I . I s ant Com pl i t 7 l nt an 18 Pl i t f ,a i m a e a N eva a St t Prs n durng t e tm e pe i d r l va tt t e a n if n n t t d a e io i hi ro e e n o h

1 c m pli t na e t ef low i g pe s nsa d f nda t :Ta i Ar uel , r c i n le t na t Pa rc 9 o an , m s h o l n r o s e e n s n a g lo core to i u e n ' tik ,
20 M c a ar , or ec i na s r ea t Ta iha Cr on, orec i na o tc r Davi ,c r e tonalofi e ; N m a c r to l e g n ; b t e c r to l fi e ; s o rci tc r

21 a s c ae war en J m esBac ; a lbr r s pe viorM a tTily;he d ca ewo ke Za pa i i so it da a lw i ay u r s t le a s r r p tn ;
2 c r ec i na of i e Shor y;a d cored i na of i e Fr c e . 2 o r to l f c r en r o l fc r e h r 23 A . Def ndant i Thei O f i i lCapac te e sn r fc a iis

24

Pl i tf s e a lde e da t i bot t eri di i ua a d o tcalc pa iis.I an if u s 1 f n n s n h h i n v d l n fi i a cte n

25 Ke t ck v Gr ham , he Supr m e Cour c a ii d t e ditnc i n bew e n ofi i la d pe s na nu y . a t e t l rfe h si to t e fca n r o l

26 ca a iys is 473U. .159,1 5( 98 ) TheCour e pli e ta whieidi iua ca a iys is p ct u t. S 6 1 4. t x an d h t l n v d l p ct u t
2

1 s e t i pos pe s na la iiy upon a gove nm e tof i i lf ra t o speror e unde col rof e k o m e r o l i b lt r n fc a o c i n fmd ro 2 s a e l w , t c alc pa iy a tonsgene a l r pr s nta ot e w a û fs i g a e tt ofw hi h an t t a ofi i a c t c i r ly e e e n h r y ç u n n n iy o c

3 ofi e i a ag nt' I .(uoigMonelv New Yo kt / De 'o socilSe vie ,436U. .658, tc r s n e . d q tn ' l. r 7y p t f a r c s S 4 690n.5( 978).l or e t esa ls pes nalla iiyi a51 83a ton,aplitf mus s ow ta 5 1 ) n d r o tbih ro ib lt n 9 ci an if t h h t
5 an i di i ual actng undercol rof sat l w ,caused a depri aton ofa f der lri ht. G r ham ,473 n vd , i o tea vi eag a

6 U. .a 1 6.By c nta t i a ofi i lc pact a ton,apl i tf mus de onsr t t a apolc o S t6 o r s, n n tc a- a iy ci a n if t m tae h t iy r
7 cus o ofa e tt c n rbut d t t e vi l to o a f de all w , I . Tha i t s y, the ac i n t a i tm n n iy o t i e o h o a i n f e r a d ts o a ç t to h t s 8 alege t be uncons iutonali pl m e t ore e ut sa polc s a e ent or i a c , eg l ton or l do tt i m e ns x c e iy t t m , d n n e r u ai 9 dec son of i i ly ad pt d a d pr m ul a ed b t a body' ofi er . M o e l 436 U . .a 690. ii fca l o e n o g t y h t s fc s' ' n l, St

1 0

l-' saeacai unde j1 8 ,aplitf mus alget eviltonofarghts c r d i o tt l m f r 9 3 an if t le h o ai i eue

11 by t e Cons iuton and l w s oft e U nied St t s,and m ustshow t att e aleged deprvaton w as h tt i a h t ae hhl ii

1 commitdbyapes na tngunde c lrofsaelw . We t487U..a 48(iainomitd) 2 te ro ci r o o tt a ' s, ' S t ctto te ,

1 Sttsandsaeofi er s e i t erofiilc p ctesaeno G e s ns'orpur os sofaj1 83 3 ae tt lc s u d n h i fca a a ii r t t ro 'f p pe 9 1 a tona dma notbes e unde t esaut.Wilv M ih.De 'o stt Polc , 1U. .58,71 4 ci n y ud r h tt e l . c p t f a e ie 49 S 1 ( 989) Ont eoterha d,j1 83alwss isa ans saeofiesi t eridiiualc pa iisf r 51, hh n 9 lo ut g i t tt fc r n h i n vd a cte o

1 a t t e t o i t er tca c pa iis Hae v Meo 5 2U. . 1 26( 9 1.ldv d asma 6 cs h y o k n h i of il a cte . f r . l, 0 S 2 , 1 9 ) n ii u l y i
1 no bes e i tei ofi ilca a iisund rj 1 83f rtera tons a dplitf ha fie alge 7 t u d n h r tca p cte e 9 o h i ci , n an if s ald le
18 t a a polc orc s om c nti ut d t vi l tonsoff de all w . Pl i tf scl i s a a ns a 1t e ht iy ut o rb e o o a i er a a n ip a m g i t 1 h 1 de e da t i t e rof i i lc pac tesa e di m i s d w ih l a e t a end. 9 f n n s n h i f c a a ii r s s e t e v o m 20 21 B. C ountI Pl i tf a l ge a Ei ht Am e dm e tvi l ton ofhi rght , pe ii aly,a f iur t a n i f le s n g h n n o ai s i s s c fc l al e o

22 pr vi epr t c i n a a ns a t c b ot e i m a e . o d o e t o g i t ta k y h r n t s 23 To c ns iut c ue a d unus a pu ihm e ti vi l ton oft e Ei ht A m endm e t o tt e r l n u l n s n n oai h gh n,

2 pr s n c ndii nsm us i vol e t hew a t n a d unnec s at i fi ton ofpa n. Rho e v 4 i o o to tn v ' t no n e s y n lc i i' ' ds.

25 Cha man,452U. . 3 7(1 81.Alhoug prs nc ndiinsma ber srciea dharh, p S 337, 4 9 ) t h io o to y e titv n s
26 pr s n of i i l m us pr vi e pr s ne sw ih f od,c ot i g,s e t r s nia i n,m edi alc r , nd io fca s t o d io r t o l h n h le , a t to c ae a

3

1 pes nals ft .1 .Tou s itv M c arh ,801F.d 1 11 7( t Ci.1 86) Ho twi v Ra , ro aey d ; s an . c ty 2 080, 0 9h r 9 ; p o t . y

2 6 2F,d 1 3 , 2 6( t Ci. 98 ) W h r ap io e alg sij re se m igfo u s f 8 2 2 7 1 4 9 h r 1 2 . e e rs n r l e nu is tm n r m n ae e
3 c ndii nsofc ntne e t prs n ofi il may b hed la l onl i t e a t d wih t e i e a e o to o i m n , io fc a s e l ib e y f h y c e t ' lb r t d

4 idifrncet as bsa talrs ofs rousham , Fr s v Agnos 1 2F.d 11 4,( t Ci.1 98 n fee o u tn i ik e i r ' ot . ' , 5 3 2 9h r 9 )
5 ( ii g Far e v Br nnan,511U. .8 5,835 ( 9 4) Thedelbe a ei dif r ncesa dar i vol es ctn mr. e S2 19 . i r t n fe e t n d n v

6 a o j ciea das b e tv p o g.Fis,h alg dd p i ai nmus b ,no jcietr s n be tv n u j cie r n rtte le e e rv to t e i be t em , v
7 çs fiintysrous' Far e v Br nnan,511U..a 8 4(ii g Wis nv Seie ,501U. . lu fce l e i .' m r . e S t 3 ctn lo . tr S 294, 8 298( 991) Se o d,heprs nof cilmus i no ofa ddir g r a e ce svers t imae 1 ). c n t io s a t t w n se a d n x s i ik o n t k
9 he lh ors f t . f .a 837.Thus $ prs n ofi ilm a behe d labl u de t eEi ht at a e y' # t ' ,û io tc a y a l i e n rh g h
1 A m e dm e tf rde yi g hum a e condii nsofco tne e tonl i he know st a i m a e f c a 0 n no nn n to ni m n yf h t n ts a e 1l s bs an i lrs ofha n a d di r ga dst a r s by f ii g t t ke r as na l m ea ur st a a e i . u t ta i k n n se r h t ik a ln o a e o b e s e o b t t' ' 1 Far erv Br nnan,511 U . . 835. Pr s n ofi i l m a a oi labiiy by p e entng e i e c t a 2 m .e S at i o tc a s y v d i lt rs i vd n e h t 1 t e l cke know l dge oft e r s ,orby pr s ntng evi e ce ofa r as nabl , be tuns c e s ul 3 hya d e h ik ee i dn e o e al i u csf , 1 r s ons t t e r s , I .a 844- 5. M e e neg i e c o t e par oft e p i on ofi i li nots fi i nt 4 e p e o h ik d t 4 r lg n e n h t h rs tc a s u tc e

1 t e t bls la iiy, r t e , h ofi i lsc nduc mus ha ebe nwa t n.Far e v Br nnan, 5 o sa ih i b lt but ah r t e tc a ' o t tv e no mr. e 1 511U. . t835;Fr s v Agnos ,l F. d a 11 8; e aloDanil v.Wilams 474 U. .3 7,3 6 Sa ot . e 52 3 t 2 s e s es li , S2 3

1 ( 986) 71.
1 8 l t e i s a tc s ,pl i tf li c r or t sby r f r nc ' a l ga i nss tf r h i a n h n t n a e a n if çn o p a e e e e e ' le to e o t n

1 c m pl i thealeg dl tl d wih t ecour on Se t m be 25 2009.TheCour ha no r c r ofs c 9 o an l e y 'e t h i t pe r , t s e od u h
20 tlng. M or ove , c m pl i tm us be com pl t i is l a d m us notm a er f r nce t ot e ii e r a o an t e e n te f n t k eee o hr

21 doc m e t .Pl i tf a lge i t e i sa tc m pli tt a hea d a ot e i m a e Ca lJ s uass oke u n s a n if le s n h n t n o an h t n n h r n t , r o h p

22 ' fw ba wods'oe c ote onFe r m' 27,2009.( ompl,a p. ,OnM ac 1 ,2009, t e d r 't a h h r a bu y C . t 4) rh 4
23 i m a eJ s uawashous d i pli tf sc l. On M a c 1 ,2009,pl i tf a d i m aeJ s ua n t oh e n an if e l rh 4 an if n n t o h

24 d ca e air c 'a dt gre t stl t erdifr n e .'(d..Ho e e,fom M ac 1 - 8 e lr d t u e' n ç e d o ete h i fee c s' 1 ) w v r r t a rh 4 2 ,
25 ç litf r c ie a dino e mulil tleasmad b im aeJ s uasg ng. (#.,Plitf t anif e ev d n g r d tp e lr t p e y n t o h ' a ' f ) an if ' 26 ale est a onMac 28,2009,imaeJ s uawa rmovedfom hi c l.(dj Plitf f rhe lg h t rh n t oh se r s el I . anif u t r
4

.

*

1 ale est a on A pr l23,pl i tt w asnotfe by a s c a e w a de Ba a t a he w a bei g r que t d lg h t i a n if iid s o it r n c h t s n e se

2 a teg m .At13 ta d y panif sç ta k db g)g ng' (d) th y :0 h t a , litf wa û tc e y a a . I , a '
3 A st t e i di i ua def nda t ,pl i tf a l ge t a :to n M a c 31 20 9, / Cr on o h n v d l e n s a n i f le s h t t rh , 0 co e

4 a d tt e saf wa giln tfe of h tr a r c ie b me b r ofimaeJ s u ' e t u a e n o h r tf s sc o iid t e h e t e ev d y m e s n t o h as no rg ,
5 a whihtmeplitf rquetdpr tctv c sody. ( omplit a p.5 .Plitf alge ta t ci an if e se oe ie u t ' C ' an , t ) an if le s h t

6 asocaewade Ba aa dc s wor e Za pai iweema ea aeoftetpotntal(o lop rs ie s it r n c n a e k r p tn r d w r h ç e i fr p e sv 7 maie'a dbra he t erdut ofc r .(J..Plitf ale est a t e rf s dt alow hi t lc ' n e c d h i y a e . ) an if lg h t h y eu e o l m o J
8 ta sera dt i r s le i a unne e sr atck.(#.. r n f n h s e utd n n c say ta f )
9 TheCour tndst a pl i tf sa e a c gni a l cai f rdelbe ae i dif r nc t ti h t an if tt s o z b e l m o i r t n fe e e o l t es rousrs ofbei g a- c e by ot e i m a e ,a t de e da t Cr o , c ,a d Za patni 0 h e i ik n ta k d t h r n t s s o f n n s e n Ba a n p ti .
11 How e e ,t e co pl i ti va ue r ga di g a y Eo he s af ' ho kne ofa t r a t pl i tf ' v r h m a n s g e r n n bt r t f w w h e t o a n ifs 1 physca s f t ,y tdi no hi g t pr ve ti. The ef r ,t e Cour w ila l w pl i tf t f l an 2 i l aey e d t n o e n t r oe h t l lo a n if o ie I am e de c m pl i t s e iyi g w hi h,i a y,ot e pr s n s a fm e be s a t d i delbe at . 3 n d o an , p c f n c fn h r io t f m r c e n i r e
14 i di f r nce t hi saf t . n fe e o s ey 15 C. C ount11

1 6

Pl i tf a lge avi l ton ofhi Fis Am e dm e trghtt a c s o t ec urs a n if le s o ai s rt n n i o c e s f h o t.

1 Pl i tf a a n çi c r or t sby r f r nc ' ale a i ns m ad i a ot e com pl i t Pl i tf i 7 a n if g i sn o p a e e e e e ' l g to en n hr a n . a n if s 1 r m i de t a t e co pl i tm us be c m pl t i is l a d m us notm a e r f r nc t ot e 8 e n d h t h m an t o e e n t ef n t k ee e e o h r

1 doc m e t . Pl i tf al ge t a hesa t dt ha e ditc li swih t e lw lb a y sa fon M ay 25, 9 u n s an if le s h t t re o v fi u te t h a i r r t f
20 2009. Pl i t f alege t a 1 w lb ar s pe v s rM a tTil y deni d hi l ga s pple . a n if l s h t a i r y u r io t le e m e l u is 21 A prs ne ale i g a vi l ton ofhi r g tofa ce st t e c ur sm us ha e s fe e io r lg n o ai s ih c s oh o t t v ufr d

22 l cua ij r . Le f v Ca e ,51 U..343,349- 0( 996) Thergh t a c s tec ursi ç t l nu y' w x . sy 8 S a ' 51 . i t o ce sh o t s
23 lm iedt diec crm i a a pe l , bea c r uspr ce di gs a d cvi rg t a tonsc al ngi g i t o r t i n l p a s ha s o p o e n , n i l i h s c i h le n

2 c n i o so c n ie e t f . t3 4 5 .ç' im aec n o e tbihr lv n a t a ij r smpy 4 o d t n f o fn m n . # a 5 - 5 û. n t a n t sa ls ee a t cu l nu y i l i -n î
25 by e tbls i g t a hi prs n' l w lbr r o lgala ssa c p ogr m i s b- a i s m et e r tca sa ih n h t s i o s a i a y r e s it n e r a s u p r n o h o e i l 26 s ns . I a 351 Rahe , hei m aeûm us go one se f rhe a d de onsr t t a t elbr l or e e' d t . t r t n t b t ' tp - t r n m ta e h t h i a' u y

5

1 lg la ssa c p o rm hn e e hsef Mst p ru alg lcam . 1 .Th a ta-nu y e a sitn e r ga id r d i fo o u s e e a li ' d e cu lij r '
2 r quie e tm a da e t a a i naeçde onsr t t a a no fi ol usl ga cli ha be n e r m n n t s h t n m t ç m ta e h t n rv o e l a m d e
3 f us r t d o w asbei g l pe e . I .a 353, l fcwf v Cas y, he Supr m e Cour de i e r tae r n m d d' d t ' n .. e t ç e t ln d 4 prs ne s rghtofac es t t e c ur sass m pl t e û i htt br ng t c ur a gre anc . f .a 354. io r ' i c so h o t i y h t g o i o o t iv e' # t r ' 5 I t e i s a tc m pl i t pl i tf a l ge s m pl t a t e pr s n lbr r s pe vior n h n t n o a n , a n if le s i y h t h i o i a y u r s

6 de i dhi lga s pple .Pl itf doesnotal get a a y de e da thi de e hi eforst b i g a n e m e l u is a n if le h t n f n n n r d s f t o rn
7 l w s i r ga di g a diec c i i ala pea , be s c r us pr c edi gs o c vi rght a ton a ut e r n r t r m n p l ha a o p o e n , r i l i s ci 8 cha l ngi g c ndii nsofc nf ne e t l or e t s a e a cl i f rdeni lofac es t t e c ur s le n o to o i m n . n d r o tt am o a c s o h o t, 9 pl i tf m us ale e t a h w a hi de e i hi a t m ptt pr s nta I w s i t a ft w ihi t os a n i f t l g h t e s n r d n s te o ee a u t h t is t n h e 1 ca e ores The c m pl i tf ist s a e a cl i f rde i lofa c s t t e c ur s Ther f r ,Count1 0 tg i . o an al o tt am o n a c e s o h o t. eo e 1 1l i di m i s d wih l a e t a e d. s s se t e v o m n 1 2 1 3 D . C ountI I l Pl i tf a l gesa v ol ton ofhi Foure nt Am e dm e tr ghtt e u lpr t c i n. a n if le i ai s te h n n i o q a o e to

14 The EqualPr t cton Cl us w as i t nded asa r sri ton on s at l gil tve acton i consit ntw ih oe i ae ne e t ci t e e sa i in se t

1 el m e t lco s iutona pr m i es Thust e Cour hast e t d a û r s m ptve y i vi i ust os 5 e n a n tt i l e s . h t r ae s b e u i l n d o h e p 1 cl s i i a i nst atdi a va t ge a t us e tc a s 'ort a i pi ge upo t e e e c s ofa 6 a s fc to h sd na s p c ls , h t m n n h x r ie

17 tunda e tlrght''Pllrr Doe 457U. . 2, 6- 1 ( 98 )ctn M c-u hln v Flrd , f m na i . ' y e . S 20 21 2 7 1 2 iig la g i . o ia

1 3 9U. . 8 , 9 (9 4 . r b y s i .UntdStts 3 0U.. ,1 0( 9 3 )s eas Du nv 8 7 S 1 4 1 2 1 6 ) Hia a a k v i a e, 2 S 81 0 1 4 ), e lo n . , e
1 Blmsei,405U. ,330,336( 972 . 9 u tn S 1)
20 Pl i tf a l ge t a ha r c i e unf vo a l t e t e tbe aus ofhi r c almz a n if le s h t s e e v d a r b e r a m n c e sai d

21 r lgiusbac gr und.( ompl,a p. .Plitf a pe r t alegeta hes bs rbest aMusi ei o ko C . t 7) anif p as o l h t u ci o lm
2 belef Pl i tf a lge t athewa de i d açditc nf r i g t M usi bele , bu hedoesnot 2 i . an if le s h s ne s e o om n o lm if' t '
23 alege t a he r q es e s c a di tf om any oft e de e da t ,ort a a y oft e nam e def nda t l h t e u td u h er h fn ns htn h d e ns

24 de id hi a diti co f r a c wihhi r lgi usbe if Pl i tf as va ue yaleg st a he was ne m e n n o m n e t s ei o le . a n if lo g l l e h t
25 ç e u ' wih dif r ntcel a e i a a tm ptt obt i hi addr s esa d at c hi f m iy. Pl i tf t t p ' t fe e s lm t s n n te o an s e s n ta k s a l a n if 26 al ge t a her ceve t r a s buthedoesnotal get a a y oft ena e de e da t t r aene le s h t e i d h e t , le h t n h m d fn n s h e t d

6

.

*

1 hi . Pli tf hasf iedt a lget ata y oft e de e dan ste t d hi unf vor bl o unf il m an if a l o le h n h fn t rae m a a y r a ry
2 be a s ofhi r c orr lgi us be i f . The e or , he Count1li di m is d w ih l a e t a e d, c ue s a e ei o le s rf e t 1 s s se t t v o m n
3 111 C oncl son . ui

4

I I TH E R E FO R E O R D E R E D t att e Cl r oft e Cour s al FI E t e TS h h ek h th l L h

5 c m pl i t( oc e /1 2) o an D k t /- .
6
7 am end.

I I FUR T H E R O R D E R E D t a t e c m pl i ti D I M I SE D w ih l a e t TS h t h o an s S S t ev o

8

I I FU R T H E R O R D E R E D t a pl i tf m a tl a am e de c m pl i tw ihi TS h t a n if y i e n n d o an t n

9 f ry-ie( 5 daysoft edaeofentyoft i or e,i hebeivest a heca c r tedefcsof o t fv 4 ) ht r hs d r f le h t n ue h et
1 t e c m pl i td s r be abo e The a e ded c m pl i tm us be a c m pl t doc m en i and of 0 h o an e c i d v . mn o an t o ee u t n

1l is l,a d wils pe s det eorgi a co p a nti ise tr t .Any al gai ns pa te , r que t te f n l u r e h i n l m l i n t n iey le to , ri s or e ss 1 f rr le fom prorpa e st a a e notca re f r a d i t ea e de compl i twilno l nge be 2 o e if r i pr h tr ri d o w r n h m n d an l or
1 be or t e Cour . I pl i tf doe notf l a am e ded c m pl i t t e ac i n m a be dim i s d, 3 f eh t f a n if s ie n n o a n , h to y s se 1 4 I I FUR T H E R O R D E R E D t a pl i tf s a lcl a l tte t e a e de c m pl i t TS h t a n if h l e ry il h m n d o a n

1 ass c byplci gt ewor sI I ST AM EN DE D' i m e it l a ovel i i Ri h sCompl i t 5 uh an h d :R F ' m d a ey b i vl g t c an

1 Purua tt 42U. . .j 1 83'onpa e1i t ec pin, plitf s alplc t ec s numbe 6 sno SC 9 3 g n h a to and anif h l a e h a e r
1 3; 9- v- 0 59 H D M - A M a ove t e wor s ' I ST A M EN D E D ' n t e s ac f r û a e N o,' 7 0 c 05 R b h d TR ' h p eo t s i c '

l 8

I I FURTHER O RD ERED t a t eClr s al s nd pl i tf abl nk s c i n TS h th ek h l e a n if a e to

1 1 8 ci i rght co pli tf nn wih i snl i nsaon wih onec py oft eorgi alc m pli t 9 9 3 vl i s m an o t nt d o l g t o h i n o an.
20
21 22

DA T ED : J l 6,201 . uy 0

U N I ED STATES M A GI TRATE J DG E T S U

23
24

25
26

7