Knox v. Arguello et al
Filing
10
ORDERED Clerk shall FILE the complaint. FURTHER ORD the complaint is DISMISSED with leave to amend. FURTHER ORD P may file amended complaint by 8/22/2010. FURTHER ORD P shall title amended complaint as "FIRST AMENDED" w case number above. F URTHER ORD Clerk shall send P 1983 form w instructions, and copy of the original complaint. ( Form and copies mailed to P 7/8/2010 ) Signed by Magistrate Judge Robert A. McQuaid, Jr on 7/6/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)
RL D E ENTERE D
PEOEI D W SE VE 0N BD tQJS LFF ICO R C F IN E/A TE F E P Z
1
U
IL - 7 21 I. J 00
2
5 4
5
U 6R USDIT IT O U T îV S BC O R
DITRIT0FNE ZDA SO V
B: Y
-. - - - - - - - DS E Y PC
6
7
U N I E D ST A T E S D I T R I T C O U R T T S C 8
D IST R I T O F NE V A D A C 9 10
M ONTEN EQUE NAKI KNOX, A 11 1 2 1 3 l 4
15 l6 17
Knox v. Arguello et al
Plitfl an it
vs .
TANI ARGUELLO,e al, A t.
Defnda t. e ns
) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
/
3:9c - 0559- DM -t M 0 -v 0 H IA
ORDER
Plitf hass bm itdapr s cii rg t compli tpurua tt 42U. . .j1 83. anif u te o e v l ih s an s n o SC 9 Pli tf ' a plc tont pr c e i for apau e i wa grntd t Marh29 201 ( oc e /9 . an ifs p iai o o e d n m p rs s a e m c , 0. D k t/)
Doc. 10
18
TheCour now r viwsplitf sc mplit ( o ke /12) t e e anif o an . D c t/ - .
1 9 1 Sc ee i g St ndar . r nn a d
20
Purua tt t ePrs ne LiiatonReor ActI L1AI fdea c ursmus dimisa s n o h io r tg i f m P k ,e rl o t t s s
pr s ner' cl i s,çi t e alegaton ofpovert i k t ues'ori t e acton ûi f i ol us orm alci us,' i o s a m tf h l i y s m r ' fh i ts r v o io '
21
22
l a l t s a e a c a m on whi h r le m a be g a t d, ort e ks m one a y r le ag i s a de enda t i is o t t l i f c e if y r ne ' l e 's tr e if a n t f n
23
24
whoi i munefo s c rle ' 28U. . .9 1 1 e ( ) Dim is lofacomplitfrfiur t sm rm u h eif ' S C 9 5()2 . s sa an o al e o
sat a cai upon whi h r le ma begr nt d i pr vi ed f ri Fe e alRul ofCi i Pr ce ur te lm c e if y a e s o d o n dr e vl o d e
25
l ( )6) a dt eCour a plestesm esa dadunde Se ton 1 l ()2)whe rviwigte 2b( , n h t p i h a tn r r ci 9 5 e ( ne e n h
26
a e ua y ofa c m pl i tora e de c m pl i t dq c o an m n d o an ,
Dockets.Justia.com
1
Reviw unde Rul 1 ()6 i e s nilyanligonaq esinoflw.Se Cha pe e r e 2 b () s se tal ln u to a e pl
2 v fa o atr Cop.fAme ia 2 2F.d71 , 23( t Ci. 0 0 .Dimis l o fi r t saea . b r oy r o rc , 3 3 9 7 9 h r 2 0 ) s sa fr al e o tt u
3 c a m i pr pe onl i i i c e rt a t e pl i tf c nnotpr ve a y s toff ct i s ppo toft e cl i l i s o r y f t s l a h t h a n if a o ne a sn u r h am
4 t a woul enttehi orhe t rle.Se More v Wale ,1 5F.d 756,759(t Ci.1 .l h t d il m r o eif e ly . k r 7 3 9h r 999) n
5 m a i g t i de e m i a i n,t e Cour t kesast u al a l ga i ns o m a e i lf c s a ed i t e k n h s tr n to h ta r e l le to f t ra a t t t n h
6 co pli t a d t eCour c nsr e t em i t e lghtm os f vor bl t t epl i tf. Se War haw v m an, n h t o tu s h n h i t a a e o h an if e s .
7 XomaCor .74F.d955,957(t Ci.1 96) Ale ainsi upr s c mplitaehel t ls p, 3 9h r 9 . lg to n o e o an r d o e s
8 srnge tsanda dst a f r a pla i gsdr fe by lw ye s Se Hu he v Rowe,449 U. .5,9 ti n t r h n o m l e d n al d a r . e g s . S
9 ( 9 0 , n sv Ke n r 4 4U. . 9 5 0 21(97 )+e c ra ) s eas Ba ite i . c c 1 8 ) Haie . r e , 0 S 51 , 2 - 1 2 r u im ; e lo lsr r v Pa 6 a .
1 PolceDe t 901F.d696,699(t Ci.1 90) 0 i pt , 2 9h r 9 .
11 A l orpa t a c m pl i tsl d b a pr s ne m a t e e or be di m i s d s a s ont i 1 r of o a n e y io r y h rf e s se u p e f 1 t e pr s ne ' cl i s l ck a a gua l bas seihe i l w ori f ct Thi i c ude c a m s ba e on 2 h io r s a m a n r b e i t r n a n a . s n l s li sd
13 lga c nclsonsta aeune a l (. . am sagans defnda t whoaei m u efo s i o e l o u i h t r tn b e eg cli i t e ns r m n rm ut r 1 cai sofifi g men ofalga itr s whihce rydoe note it,aswela cai sbasdon 4 lm n rn e t e l nee t c lal s x s) l slm e
1 fncf lfcua ale ains(..fntsi ordeusona se ai s.Se Netkev Wilams 490U, . 5 a iu a t l lg to eg a a tc l i l c n ro ) e iz . li , S 1 31 ,327- 8( 98 ) s ealoM c e v rv Blc , 2F.d795,798( t Ci.1 91, 69 2 1 9 ; e s K e e . o k 93 2 9h r 9 )
1 I . I s ant Com pl i t 7 l nt an 18 Pl i t f ,a i m a e a N eva a St t Prs n durng t e tm e pe i d r l va tt t e a n if n n t t d a e io i hi ro e e n o h
1 c m pli t na e t ef low i g pe s nsa d f nda t :Ta i Ar uel , r c i n le t na t Pa rc 9 o an , m s h o l n r o s e e n s n a g lo core to i u e n ' tik ,
20 M c a ar , or ec i na s r ea t Ta iha Cr on, orec i na o tc r Davi ,c r e tonalofi e ; N m a c r to l e g n ; b t e c r to l fi e ; s o rci tc r
21 a s c ae war en J m esBac ; a lbr r s pe viorM a tTily;he d ca ewo ke Za pa i i so it da a lw i ay u r s t le a s r r p tn ;
2 c r ec i na of i e Shor y;a d cored i na of i e Fr c e . 2 o r to l f c r en r o l fc r e h r 23 A . Def ndant i Thei O f i i lCapac te e sn r fc a iis
24
Pl i tf s e a lde e da t i bot t eri di i ua a d o tcalc pa iis.I an if u s 1 f n n s n h h i n v d l n fi i a cte n
25 Ke t ck v Gr ham , he Supr m e Cour c a ii d t e ditnc i n bew e n ofi i la d pe s na nu y . a t e t l rfe h si to t e fca n r o l
26 ca a iys is 473U. .159,1 5( 98 ) TheCour e pli e ta whieidi iua ca a iys is p ct u t. S 6 1 4. t x an d h t l n v d l p ct u t
2
1 s e t i pos pe s na la iiy upon a gove nm e tof i i lf ra t o speror e unde col rof e k o m e r o l i b lt r n fc a o c i n fmd ro 2 s a e l w , t c alc pa iy a tonsgene a l r pr s nta ot e w a û fs i g a e tt ofw hi h an t t a ofi i a c t c i r ly e e e n h r y ç u n n n iy o c
3 ofi e i a ag nt' I .(uoigMonelv New Yo kt / De 'o socilSe vie ,436U. .658, tc r s n e . d q tn ' l. r 7y p t f a r c s S 4 690n.5( 978).l or e t esa ls pes nalla iiyi a51 83a ton,aplitf mus s ow ta 5 1 ) n d r o tbih ro ib lt n 9 ci an if t h h t
5 an i di i ual actng undercol rof sat l w ,caused a depri aton ofa f der lri ht. G r ham ,473 n vd , i o tea vi eag a
6 U. .a 1 6.By c nta t i a ofi i lc pact a ton,apl i tf mus de onsr t t a apolc o S t6 o r s, n n tc a- a iy ci a n if t m tae h t iy r
7 cus o ofa e tt c n rbut d t t e vi l to o a f de all w , I . Tha i t s y, the ac i n t a i tm n n iy o t i e o h o a i n f e r a d ts o a ç t to h t s 8 alege t be uncons iutonali pl m e t ore e ut sa polc s a e ent or i a c , eg l ton or l do tt i m e ns x c e iy t t m , d n n e r u ai 9 dec son of i i ly ad pt d a d pr m ul a ed b t a body' ofi er . M o e l 436 U . .a 690. ii fca l o e n o g t y h t s fc s' ' n l, St
1 0
l-' saeacai unde j1 8 ,aplitf mus alget eviltonofarghts c r d i o tt l m f r 9 3 an if t le h o ai i eue
11 by t e Cons iuton and l w s oft e U nied St t s,and m ustshow t att e aleged deprvaton w as h tt i a h t ae hhl ii
1 commitdbyapes na tngunde c lrofsaelw . We t487U..a 48(iainomitd) 2 te ro ci r o o tt a ' s, ' S t ctto te ,
1 Sttsandsaeofi er s e i t erofiilc p ctesaeno G e s ns'orpur os sofaj1 83 3 ae tt lc s u d n h i fca a a ii r t t ro 'f p pe 9 1 a tona dma notbes e unde t esaut.Wilv M ih.De 'o stt Polc , 1U. .58,71 4 ci n y ud r h tt e l . c p t f a e ie 49 S 1 ( 989) Ont eoterha d,j1 83alwss isa ans saeofiesi t eridiiualc pa iisf r 51, hh n 9 lo ut g i t tt fc r n h i n vd a cte o
1 a t t e t o i t er tca c pa iis Hae v Meo 5 2U. . 1 26( 9 1.ldv d asma 6 cs h y o k n h i of il a cte . f r . l, 0 S 2 , 1 9 ) n ii u l y i
1 no bes e i tei ofi ilca a iisund rj 1 83f rtera tons a dplitf ha fie alge 7 t u d n h r tca p cte e 9 o h i ci , n an if s ald le
18 t a a polc orc s om c nti ut d t vi l tonsoff de all w . Pl i tf scl i s a a ns a 1t e ht iy ut o rb e o o a i er a a n ip a m g i t 1 h 1 de e da t i t e rof i i lc pac tesa e di m i s d w ih l a e t a end. 9 f n n s n h i f c a a ii r s s e t e v o m 20 21 B. C ountI Pl i tf a l ge a Ei ht Am e dm e tvi l ton ofhi rght , pe ii aly,a f iur t a n i f le s n g h n n o ai s i s s c fc l al e o
22 pr vi epr t c i n a a ns a t c b ot e i m a e . o d o e t o g i t ta k y h r n t s 23 To c ns iut c ue a d unus a pu ihm e ti vi l ton oft e Ei ht A m endm e t o tt e r l n u l n s n n oai h gh n,
2 pr s n c ndii nsm us i vol e t hew a t n a d unnec s at i fi ton ofpa n. Rho e v 4 i o o to tn v ' t no n e s y n lc i i' ' ds.
25 Cha man,452U. . 3 7(1 81.Alhoug prs nc ndiinsma ber srciea dharh, p S 337, 4 9 ) t h io o to y e titv n s
26 pr s n of i i l m us pr vi e pr s ne sw ih f od,c ot i g,s e t r s nia i n,m edi alc r , nd io fca s t o d io r t o l h n h le , a t to c ae a
3
1 pes nals ft .1 .Tou s itv M c arh ,801F.d 1 11 7( t Ci.1 86) Ho twi v Ra , ro aey d ; s an . c ty 2 080, 0 9h r 9 ; p o t . y
2 6 2F,d 1 3 , 2 6( t Ci. 98 ) W h r ap io e alg sij re se m igfo u s f 8 2 2 7 1 4 9 h r 1 2 . e e rs n r l e nu is tm n r m n ae e
3 c ndii nsofc ntne e t prs n ofi il may b hed la l onl i t e a t d wih t e i e a e o to o i m n , io fc a s e l ib e y f h y c e t ' lb r t d
4 idifrncet as bsa talrs ofs rousham , Fr s v Agnos 1 2F.d 11 4,( t Ci.1 98 n fee o u tn i ik e i r ' ot . ' , 5 3 2 9h r 9 )
5 ( ii g Far e v Br nnan,511U. .8 5,835 ( 9 4) Thedelbe a ei dif r ncesa dar i vol es ctn mr. e S2 19 . i r t n fe e t n d n v
6 a o j ciea das b e tv p o g.Fis,h alg dd p i ai nmus b ,no jcietr s n be tv n u j cie r n rtte le e e rv to t e i be t em , v
7 çs fiintysrous' Far e v Br nnan,511U..a 8 4(ii g Wis nv Seie ,501U. . lu fce l e i .' m r . e S t 3 ctn lo . tr S 294, 8 298( 991) Se o d,heprs nof cilmus i no ofa ddir g r a e ce svers t imae 1 ). c n t io s a t t w n se a d n x s i ik o n t k
9 he lh ors f t . f .a 837.Thus $ prs n ofi ilm a behe d labl u de t eEi ht at a e y' # t ' ,û io tc a y a l i e n rh g h
1 A m e dm e tf rde yi g hum a e condii nsofco tne e tonl i he know st a i m a e f c a 0 n no nn n to ni m n yf h t n ts a e 1l s bs an i lrs ofha n a d di r ga dst a r s by f ii g t t ke r as na l m ea ur st a a e i . u t ta i k n n se r h t ik a ln o a e o b e s e o b t t' ' 1 Far erv Br nnan,511 U . . 835. Pr s n ofi i l m a a oi labiiy by p e entng e i e c t a 2 m .e S at i o tc a s y v d i lt rs i vd n e h t 1 t e l cke know l dge oft e r s ,orby pr s ntng evi e ce ofa r as nabl , be tuns c e s ul 3 hya d e h ik ee i dn e o e al i u csf , 1 r s ons t t e r s , I .a 844- 5. M e e neg i e c o t e par oft e p i on ofi i li nots fi i nt 4 e p e o h ik d t 4 r lg n e n h t h rs tc a s u tc e
1 t e t bls la iiy, r t e , h ofi i lsc nduc mus ha ebe nwa t n.Far e v Br nnan, 5 o sa ih i b lt but ah r t e tc a ' o t tv e no mr. e 1 511U. . t835;Fr s v Agnos ,l F. d a 11 8; e aloDanil v.Wilams 474 U. .3 7,3 6 Sa ot . e 52 3 t 2 s e s es li , S2 3
1 ( 986) 71.
1 8 l t e i s a tc s ,pl i tf li c r or t sby r f r nc ' a l ga i nss tf r h i a n h n t n a e a n if çn o p a e e e e e ' le to e o t n
1 c m pl i thealeg dl tl d wih t ecour on Se t m be 25 2009.TheCour ha no r c r ofs c 9 o an l e y 'e t h i t pe r , t s e od u h
20 tlng. M or ove , c m pl i tm us be com pl t i is l a d m us notm a er f r nce t ot e ii e r a o an t e e n te f n t k eee o hr
21 doc m e t .Pl i tf a lge i t e i sa tc m pli tt a hea d a ot e i m a e Ca lJ s uass oke u n s a n if le s n h n t n o an h t n n h r n t , r o h p
22 ' fw ba wods'oe c ote onFe r m' 27,2009.( ompl,a p. ,OnM ac 1 ,2009, t e d r 't a h h r a bu y C . t 4) rh 4
23 i m a eJ s uawashous d i pli tf sc l. On M a c 1 ,2009,pl i tf a d i m aeJ s ua n t oh e n an if e l rh 4 an if n n t o h
24 d ca e air c 'a dt gre t stl t erdifr n e .'(d..Ho e e,fom M ac 1 - 8 e lr d t u e' n ç e d o ete h i fee c s' 1 ) w v r r t a rh 4 2 ,
25 ç litf r c ie a dino e mulil tleasmad b im aeJ s uasg ng. (#.,Plitf t anif e ev d n g r d tp e lr t p e y n t o h ' a ' f ) an if ' 26 ale est a onMac 28,2009,imaeJ s uawa rmovedfom hi c l.(dj Plitf f rhe lg h t rh n t oh se r s el I . anif u t r
4
.
*
1 ale est a on A pr l23,pl i tt w asnotfe by a s c a e w a de Ba a t a he w a bei g r que t d lg h t i a n if iid s o it r n c h t s n e se
2 a teg m .At13 ta d y panif sç ta k db g)g ng' (d) th y :0 h t a , litf wa û tc e y a a . I , a '
3 A st t e i di i ua def nda t ,pl i tf a l ge t a :to n M a c 31 20 9, / Cr on o h n v d l e n s a n i f le s h t t rh , 0 co e
4 a d tt e saf wa giln tfe of h tr a r c ie b me b r ofimaeJ s u ' e t u a e n o h r tf s sc o iid t e h e t e ev d y m e s n t o h as no rg ,
5 a whihtmeplitf rquetdpr tctv c sody. ( omplit a p.5 .Plitf alge ta t ci an if e se oe ie u t ' C ' an , t ) an if le s h t
6 asocaewade Ba aa dc s wor e Za pai iweema ea aeoftetpotntal(o lop rs ie s it r n c n a e k r p tn r d w r h ç e i fr p e sv 7 maie'a dbra he t erdut ofc r .(J..Plitf ale est a t e rf s dt alow hi t lc ' n e c d h i y a e . ) an if lg h t h y eu e o l m o J
8 ta sera dt i r s le i a unne e sr atck.(#.. r n f n h s e utd n n c say ta f )
9 TheCour tndst a pl i tf sa e a c gni a l cai f rdelbe ae i dif r nc t ti h t an if tt s o z b e l m o i r t n fe e e o l t es rousrs ofbei g a- c e by ot e i m a e ,a t de e da t Cr o , c ,a d Za patni 0 h e i ik n ta k d t h r n t s s o f n n s e n Ba a n p ti .
11 How e e ,t e co pl i ti va ue r ga di g a y Eo he s af ' ho kne ofa t r a t pl i tf ' v r h m a n s g e r n n bt r t f w w h e t o a n ifs 1 physca s f t ,y tdi no hi g t pr ve ti. The ef r ,t e Cour w ila l w pl i tf t f l an 2 i l aey e d t n o e n t r oe h t l lo a n if o ie I am e de c m pl i t s e iyi g w hi h,i a y,ot e pr s n s a fm e be s a t d i delbe at . 3 n d o an , p c f n c fn h r io t f m r c e n i r e
14 i di f r nce t hi saf t . n fe e o s ey 15 C. C ount11
1 6
Pl i tf a lge avi l ton ofhi Fis Am e dm e trghtt a c s o t ec urs a n if le s o ai s rt n n i o c e s f h o t.
1 Pl i tf a a n çi c r or t sby r f r nc ' ale a i ns m ad i a ot e com pl i t Pl i tf i 7 a n if g i sn o p a e e e e e ' l g to en n hr a n . a n if s 1 r m i de t a t e co pl i tm us be c m pl t i is l a d m us notm a e r f r nc t ot e 8 e n d h t h m an t o e e n t ef n t k ee e e o h r
1 doc m e t . Pl i tf al ge t a hesa t dt ha e ditc li swih t e lw lb a y sa fon M ay 25, 9 u n s an if le s h t t re o v fi u te t h a i r r t f
20 2009. Pl i t f alege t a 1 w lb ar s pe v s rM a tTil y deni d hi l ga s pple . a n if l s h t a i r y u r io t le e m e l u is 21 A prs ne ale i g a vi l ton ofhi r g tofa ce st t e c ur sm us ha e s fe e io r lg n o ai s ih c s oh o t t v ufr d
22 l cua ij r . Le f v Ca e ,51 U..343,349- 0( 996) Thergh t a c s tec ursi ç t l nu y' w x . sy 8 S a ' 51 . i t o ce sh o t s
23 lm iedt diec crm i a a pe l , bea c r uspr ce di gs a d cvi rg t a tonsc al ngi g i t o r t i n l p a s ha s o p o e n , n i l i h s c i h le n
2 c n i o so c n ie e t f . t3 4 5 .ç' im aec n o e tbihr lv n a t a ij r smpy 4 o d t n f o fn m n . # a 5 - 5 û. n t a n t sa ls ee a t cu l nu y i l i -n î
25 by e tbls i g t a hi prs n' l w lbr r o lgala ssa c p ogr m i s b- a i s m et e r tca sa ih n h t s i o s a i a y r e s it n e r a s u p r n o h o e i l 26 s ns . I a 351 Rahe , hei m aeûm us go one se f rhe a d de onsr t t a t elbr l or e e' d t . t r t n t b t ' tp - t r n m ta e h t h i a' u y
5
1 lg la ssa c p o rm hn e e hsef Mst p ru alg lcam . 1 .Th a ta-nu y e a sitn e r ga id r d i fo o u s e e a li ' d e cu lij r '
2 r quie e tm a da e t a a i naeçde onsr t t a a no fi ol usl ga cli ha be n e r m n n t s h t n m t ç m ta e h t n rv o e l a m d e
3 f us r t d o w asbei g l pe e . I .a 353, l fcwf v Cas y, he Supr m e Cour de i e r tae r n m d d' d t ' n .. e t ç e t ln d 4 prs ne s rghtofac es t t e c ur sass m pl t e û i htt br ng t c ur a gre anc . f .a 354. io r ' i c so h o t i y h t g o i o o t iv e' # t r ' 5 I t e i s a tc m pl i t pl i tf a l ge s m pl t a t e pr s n lbr r s pe vior n h n t n o a n , a n if le s i y h t h i o i a y u r s
6 de i dhi lga s pple .Pl itf doesnotal get a a y de e da thi de e hi eforst b i g a n e m e l u is a n if le h t n f n n n r d s f t o rn
7 l w s i r ga di g a diec c i i ala pea , be s c r us pr c edi gs o c vi rght a ton a ut e r n r t r m n p l ha a o p o e n , r i l i s ci 8 cha l ngi g c ndii nsofc nf ne e t l or e t s a e a cl i f rdeni lofac es t t e c ur s le n o to o i m n . n d r o tt am o a c s o h o t, 9 pl i tf m us ale e t a h w a hi de e i hi a t m ptt pr s nta I w s i t a ft w ihi t os a n i f t l g h t e s n r d n s te o ee a u t h t is t n h e 1 ca e ores The c m pl i tf ist s a e a cl i f rde i lofa c s t t e c ur s Ther f r ,Count1 0 tg i . o an al o tt am o n a c e s o h o t. eo e 1 1l i di m i s d wih l a e t a e d. s s se t e v o m n 1 2 1 3 D . C ountI I l Pl i tf a l gesa v ol ton ofhi Foure nt Am e dm e tr ghtt e u lpr t c i n. a n if le i ai s te h n n i o q a o e to
14 The EqualPr t cton Cl us w as i t nded asa r sri ton on s at l gil tve acton i consit ntw ih oe i ae ne e t ci t e e sa i in se t
1 el m e t lco s iutona pr m i es Thust e Cour hast e t d a û r s m ptve y i vi i ust os 5 e n a n tt i l e s . h t r ae s b e u i l n d o h e p 1 cl s i i a i nst atdi a va t ge a t us e tc a s 'ort a i pi ge upo t e e e c s ofa 6 a s fc to h sd na s p c ls , h t m n n h x r ie
17 tunda e tlrght''Pllrr Doe 457U. . 2, 6- 1 ( 98 )ctn M c-u hln v Flrd , f m na i . ' y e . S 20 21 2 7 1 2 iig la g i . o ia
1 3 9U. . 8 , 9 (9 4 . r b y s i .UntdStts 3 0U.. ,1 0( 9 3 )s eas Du nv 8 7 S 1 4 1 2 1 6 ) Hia a a k v i a e, 2 S 81 0 1 4 ), e lo n . , e
1 Blmsei,405U. ,330,336( 972 . 9 u tn S 1)
20 Pl i tf a l ge t a ha r c i e unf vo a l t e t e tbe aus ofhi r c almz a n if le s h t s e e v d a r b e r a m n c e sai d
21 r lgiusbac gr und.( ompl,a p. .Plitf a pe r t alegeta hes bs rbest aMusi ei o ko C . t 7) anif p as o l h t u ci o lm
2 belef Pl i tf a lge t athewa de i d açditc nf r i g t M usi bele , bu hedoesnot 2 i . an if le s h s ne s e o om n o lm if' t '
23 alege t a he r q es e s c a di tf om any oft e de e da t ,ort a a y oft e nam e def nda t l h t e u td u h er h fn ns htn h d e ns
24 de id hi a diti co f r a c wihhi r lgi usbe if Pl i tf as va ue yaleg st a he was ne m e n n o m n e t s ei o le . a n if lo g l l e h t
25 ç e u ' wih dif r ntcel a e i a a tm ptt obt i hi addr s esa d at c hi f m iy. Pl i tf t t p ' t fe e s lm t s n n te o an s e s n ta k s a l a n if 26 al ge t a her ceve t r a s buthedoesnotal get a a y oft ena e de e da t t r aene le s h t e i d h e t , le h t n h m d fn n s h e t d
6
.
*
1 hi . Pli tf hasf iedt a lget ata y oft e de e dan ste t d hi unf vor bl o unf il m an if a l o le h n h fn t rae m a a y r a ry
2 be a s ofhi r c orr lgi us be i f . The e or , he Count1li di m is d w ih l a e t a e d, c ue s a e ei o le s rf e t 1 s s se t t v o m n
3 111 C oncl son . ui
4
I I TH E R E FO R E O R D E R E D t att e Cl r oft e Cour s al FI E t e TS h h ek h th l L h
5 c m pl i t( oc e /1 2) o an D k t /- .
6
7 am end.
I I FUR T H E R O R D E R E D t a t e c m pl i ti D I M I SE D w ih l a e t TS h t h o an s S S t ev o
8
I I FU R T H E R O R D E R E D t a pl i tf m a tl a am e de c m pl i tw ihi TS h t a n if y i e n n d o an t n
9 f ry-ie( 5 daysoft edaeofentyoft i or e,i hebeivest a heca c r tedefcsof o t fv 4 ) ht r hs d r f le h t n ue h et
1 t e c m pl i td s r be abo e The a e ded c m pl i tm us be a c m pl t doc m en i and of 0 h o an e c i d v . mn o an t o ee u t n
1l is l,a d wils pe s det eorgi a co p a nti ise tr t .Any al gai ns pa te , r que t te f n l u r e h i n l m l i n t n iey le to , ri s or e ss 1 f rr le fom prorpa e st a a e notca re f r a d i t ea e de compl i twilno l nge be 2 o e if r i pr h tr ri d o w r n h m n d an l or
1 be or t e Cour . I pl i tf doe notf l a am e ded c m pl i t t e ac i n m a be dim i s d, 3 f eh t f a n if s ie n n o a n , h to y s se 1 4 I I FUR T H E R O R D E R E D t a pl i tf s a lcl a l tte t e a e de c m pl i t TS h t a n if h l e ry il h m n d o a n
1 ass c byplci gt ewor sI I ST AM EN DE D' i m e it l a ovel i i Ri h sCompl i t 5 uh an h d :R F ' m d a ey b i vl g t c an
1 Purua tt 42U. . .j 1 83'onpa e1i t ec pin, plitf s alplc t ec s numbe 6 sno SC 9 3 g n h a to and anif h l a e h a e r
1 3; 9- v- 0 59 H D M - A M a ove t e wor s ' I ST A M EN D E D ' n t e s ac f r û a e N o,' 7 0 c 05 R b h d TR ' h p eo t s i c '
l 8
I I FURTHER O RD ERED t a t eClr s al s nd pl i tf abl nk s c i n TS h th ek h l e a n if a e to
1 1 8 ci i rght co pli tf nn wih i snl i nsaon wih onec py oft eorgi alc m pli t 9 9 3 vl i s m an o t nt d o l g t o h i n o an.
20
21 22
DA T ED : J l 6,201 . uy 0
U N I ED STATES M A GI TRATE J DG E T S U
23
24
25
26
7
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?