Knox v. Arguello et al

Filing 13

ORDERED THE # 12 Amended Complaint states cognizable claim as follows : Count I as to Ds Creon, Baca, and Zappattini; Count II as to D Matt Tilley; and Count III as to D Shorey. FURTHER ORD Clerk shall E-serve AG this Order, attached Mediation form, and P's amended complaint. ( E-service performed 9/9/2010 ) AG shall advise re acceptance of service by 9/30/2010. If service not accepted for any D then P shall file a motion re unserved Ds. If AG accepts service, then answer/response to amen ded complaint due 30 days following early inmate mediation, or 30 days following order declining mediation. The parties SHALL DETACH, COMPLETE, AND FILE the attached Notice re mediation by 10/9/2010. ( Notice of Compliance is due by 9/30/2010.) Signed by Magistrate Judge Robert A. McQuaid, Jr on 9/8/2010. ( Attachments: # 1 Amended Complaint #12 )(Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

/
F lt I' l E 1.IED NiéI (E
-

.

(751t ? :E (Ff o h: 2!hC: , !2 ) l l .ë %

?iw-t C) è .f -t SLY()I( , :kN ') E

l
1

!

8EF g g y g
..

f

' -c à i ', L( (Vu..7'S'Cr:J cf-' ; T, ' a ?F'r .;û L i :R (
,

3

L7Y : .

2k ;( , LFNL' J .z ,(1J t. ' 'i AA
-

.

OEFI: )Y

U N I E D STAT E S D I T R I T C O U R T T S C
D IST R IC T O F N E V A D A

M ON TEN EQ UE NAKI KNOX , A

11

Plitf, anif vs . TANI ARGUELLO,e aI, A t. Dee da t. fn ns

l 3
1 5

) ) ) ) )

3: 9- v- 0559- D M - A M 0c0 H R O R D ER

) ) ) )
/

Thi i apr s prs ne cvi rg t aci nGldpurua tt 42U. . .j 1 83.By s s o e io r i l ih s to e sno SC 9 or e fldJ l 7,201 ,heCour rviwedplitf sorgna co plit ( oc e #1 ) Theor e d r ie uy 0t te e anif ii l m an . D k t 0 . dr
Knox v. Arguello et al

18

Doc. 13

f und t a pl i tf s a e a c gni abl c ai f rde i e a e i di f r nc a t def nda t Cr on, o h t a n if t t s o z e l m o lb r t n f e e e s o e n s e

Ba a a dZa patni (d) Theor e dim isdt ermaiigcli swih la et fl a a ende c , n p ti . l . d r s se h e nn am t e v o ie n m d
21

c m pli t (#..OnAug s 1 ,201 ,plitf flda a e de co plit ( oc e /1 ) The o an , f ) u t 6 0 anif ie n m n d m an . D k t/ 2 .
C ourtnow r vi w st e am ended com pl i t. ee h an

23

Purua tt t ePrs ne LiiainReonn Ac I LRAI f dea c u t mus dimisa s n o h io r tg to f tP , e rl o rs t s s
pr s ne ' c a m s Ei t e a l ga i n ofpov ry i untue, ori t e a ton t sf i ol us o m a i i us ' i o r s l i , tf h le to e t s r ' f h c i i rv o r lc o ,' ' i ç aist s at a c ai on w hi h r lefm a be gr nt ds' is e sm one a y r lefaga ns a de e da t i l o te lm f c ei y a e ' or ûe k tr e i i t fn n

25

whoi i m unefom s c r le ' 28U. . .âl 5()2) Dimis lofac mplitfrfiur t sm r u h eif ' SC 91 e( . s sa o an o al e o
s at a cl i upon whi h r lefm ay be grant d i pr vi ed f ri Feder lRul ofCi i Pr cedur t e am c ei esod on a e vl o e

Dockets.Justia.com

1 1 ( )6) a dt eCour a plest es mesa dadt de Se ton l l e( )whe rviwigte 2b ( ,n h t p i h a tn r m r ci 9 5()2 ne e n h
2 ade ua y ofa com pl i tora e ded c m pl i t qc an mn o an . 3 Pl i tf , n i m a e a N eva a St t Prs n, m est e f low i g pe s nsas an if a n t t d a e i o na h o l n ro

4 de e dant i t e a ende c m pl i t Ta iha Cr on,c r ec i na of i e ; s c a e w a de J m e fn snh m d o an : b t e o r to l f c r as o i t r n a s
5 Baca;case w or erZappa i i l w lbr l super i orM at Til ysand con- ctonalofi erShore . k tn ; a i ay vs t le ei tc y

6 7

C o ntI u Pl i tf ale e a Ei ht Am e dm e tvi lt o ofhi rght ,s e i i a l ,a f iur t a n if l g s n g h n n o ai n s i s p c f c ly a l e o

8 pr vi e pr tc i n agans a tckbyot e i m aes Bas d on t eale a i nsoft eame ded o d o e to i t ta h rn t . e h lg to h n
9 c m pl i t t e Co r tndst a pl i t f s a e a co ni ab e c a m f rde i e a e i di f r nc t t e o an , h u ti h t a n if tt s g z l l i o lb r t n fe e e o h 1 s rous rs ofbe ng a t c e by ot e i m a e ,a t de e da t Cr on,Ba a a d Za pa tni 0 ei ik i ta k d h r n ts s o fn ns e c,n p ti .

11 Se Far erv Br nnan,511U. . 8 5( 994) e m .e S 825, 3 1 .
12 C ount 1 1

1 3

Pl i tf ale esa vi l ton ofhi Fis A m end e trghtt a c s oft e c ur s a n if l g oai s rt m n i e c e s h o t.

1 Pl i t f ale e t a a a r s l ofde i lofa c s t t e 1 w lbr r ,hi pe ii n f ra wr tofha e s 4 a n if l g s h t s e u t na c e s o h a i a y s tto o i ba 1 c r usw a r t r ed. Pl i tf s a esa c gni a l cl i a ai s 1 w lbr c s pe vi orM at Til y f r 5 op s eu n a n if t t o z be am g n ta i a u r s t le o

1 d nilofa ce st tecouls Se Lc f v Casy,51 U..343,349- 0( 996) 6 e a c s oh -. e w, . e 8 S t N 51 ,
17 CountI l l

l 8

Pl i tf a l gesa vi l ton ofhi Four e nt A m endm e trghtt e ualpr t cton. a n if le o ai s te h n i oq oe i

1 Pl i tf a lgest a hasr ceve unf v r bl te t e tby c r e tona o tc rShor y be a s o hi 9 a n if le h t e i d a o a e r am n o r c i l fi e e cu e f s

20 rca andr lgiusbac gr und,( m e dedCompl,a p.6 .Plitf sae ac gnia l cai a il ei o ko An . t ) an if tts o z be l m
21 a a ns de e dan Shor y f rde i lofequa pr t c i n.Se Pl l r v D oe 45 U . . 2,21 - 1 g i t fn t e o na l o e to e ye . 7 S 20 62 7

22 ( 98 )ctn M c au hlnv Flria,379U..1 1 ( 964) Hiaba as iv Unie Stts 320 1 2 iig L g i . o d S 84, 92 1 ; r y k . td a e,
23 U..81 l 0( 943),s ealoDunnv Blmsei,405U. .3 0, (972) S ,0 1 ) e s . u tn S 3 336 1 .
2 4 C onc us on li

25

I I THEREFORE ORDERED t a t ea e de c m plit( oc e /1 saesa TS h t h m n d o an D k t /2) tt

26 c gni a l c a m asf low s Cou tIast de e da t Cr on,Ba a,a d Za pa tni Cou t1 ast o z b e li ol : n o fn n s e cn p ti ' n 1 o ,

2

1 de enda tM atTil y'a d CountlIast de e da tSho e . fn t le , n 1 o fn n ry
2 3 I I FU R T H E R O R D E R E D a f low s TS s ol : 1 The Cl r s al el c r ni aly s n r a copy oft i or er i c udi g t e at ac e N ot c . ek h l e to c l e e h s d ,n l n h t h d ie

4 o I t ntt Pr ce d w ih M e i t on f r ,a ong w ih a co y of pl i t f s am e de co pl i t fne o o e t d ai o m l t p a n if n d m an, 5 o t e O f i e o t e At orne G e e alo t e St t ofN e ada,t t e at ent o ofPa e a Sharp. nh fc f h t y n r f h ae v o h t in ml

6

2.TheAtor e Ge ealsOfies ala viet eCour wihi t e t - ne( 1 daysof1e t n y n r ' fc h l d s h t t n w ny o 2 ) h

7 da e ofe t r t i or e whe he i c n a ce ts r i e ofpr c s f rt e na e def nda t . A st t n o of h s d r t r t a c p evc o es o h m d e ns o 8 an oft e nmne de e d n s f r whi h t e A to ne Ge e a ' O fi e ca notac e ts l i e, he yh d fn a t o c h t r y n r ls fc n c p ew c t

9 Ofi es altl,unde s altels knowna drs ts oftos deen a ts. tc h l le r e ,h a t d e se ) h e f d nt) 1 0 3.l sr ieca notbea c ptdf ra yoftena e dee da ts, antf s altl a f ev c n ce e o n h m d fn n t) pli if h l ie l1 moin ie tf igteunsr e dee da ts,e uetngis a c ofas mmons a ds e iynga to d n iyn h ev d fn n t) rq si su n e u , n p cfi 1 f lnamea daddrs f rs i dee da ts.Plitf i rmi d dt a,purua tt Rul 4( )oft e 2 ul n e s o ad fn n t) anif s e n e h t s n o e m h 1 Fe ea RulsofCii Pr c dur , eviemus beac om pls edwihi onehundrdt e t ( 20) 3 d rl e vl o e e sr c t c ih tn e w ny 1
1 da soft e da e t e c m pl i tw asf l d. 4 y h t h o an ie

l 5

4.l teAtor e Genea a c pt sl ieofpr c s f ra yna e dee da ts,s c fh t n y rl e e s ew c o e s o n m d fn nt) u h

1 dee da ts s altl an sr ea a s e o ohe r s ons t t ea e de co plitwihi t itr 6 fn n t) h l ie d ev n n w r r t r e p e o h m n d m an t n h r. !
1 ( 0)daysf low i g t e d t oft ee ry i m a emediton. I t eco r de lnest m e it t i ca e 73 o l n h ae h a l n t ai f h u t ci o dae h s s ,

1 a a s e oroterr s o s s albeduewihi t it (0)daysf lowi gt eor e deci ig 8 n n w r h ep n e h l t n h ry 3 ol n h d r lnn
19 m edi ton. ai

20

Thepa te SHALL DETACH,COM PLET E, ris AND FI E t eat c ed No i eofl t nt L h ta h tc ne

21 t Pr c e wihM e itonfr onorbeor t it (0)daysfom tedaeofe tyofti or e . o o e d t d ai o m f e h ry 3 r h t nr h s d r
22 23 D A T ED : Sept m ber 8,201 . e 0

24 25

U NI ED STATES M A GI TR ATE J D GE T S U
26

3

1 2

3
4 N am e 5 Prson N um ber i 6

A ddr s es
7 8

9
1O

U N I ED STATES DI TR I T CO U R T T SC D I TR I T O F N EV A D A SC

l1

Plitf, an if

1 2
1 3
1 4

Defnda t. e ns
l5

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

Cas No. e

NOTI E OF I TENT TO C N PROCEED W I H M EDI TI N T AO

1 6

Thi ca em a be r f re t t eDiti tofNe a a' ea l i m ae me i to pr g a . The ss y e e r d o h src v d s ry n t d ai n o r m pu pos oft i notc i t a s s t e s iab lt oft i c s f rm e i ton.M e i ton i apr c s b r e h s ie s o s e s h u t iiy h s a e o dai d ai s o e s y 1 whih t epa te me twih an i pa talc ur- p oi t d me it ri a e f r t brng a outa 7 c h ris e t m ri o ta p n e d ao n n fo t o i b n e pedintr s l tont a i s tsa t r t a 1 ri s x e e o u i h t s a if c o y o 1 pa te .
l8

1.

D o yo w i h t pr c ed t e ry m e i ton i t i c s ? u s o o e o al dai n h s a e

Ye s

No

1 9

2.
20 21 22

l nonpla esaeter a ont)youdonotwih t pr ce dwshme iton? f e s tt h e s s s o o e t d ai

23

3.

Lita y a d al c s s i cudi gt eca e n m be ,t a pl i tf hasfl d i f de a orsa e s n n l a e , n l n h s u r h t an if ie n e r l tt

24
25
26

c ur i t els fveye r a dt enaur ofe c c s .Atac ad iina pag si nee e ) o t n h at i a s n h t e a h a e ( t h d to l e f d d .

4.

Li ta y a d al c s s i c udi g t e c s num be st a a e c r e ty pendi g ora y pe di g s n n 1 a e ,n l n h a e r h t r u rn l n n nn

gre a c sco c r i gis esorcam sr ie i t i ca e.Atac a diina pa esi iv n e n enn su li as d n h s s ( t h d to l g f ne de ) e d.

5.

A r t er any ot ercom m ent you w oul lke t expr sst t e courtaboutw het ert i cas eh e h s di o e oh h hs e i s ia l f rm edi ton. Y o m a i c ude a brefs a e e ta t w hy you belev t i c s s utb e o ai u ynl i ttm n s o i e hs ae

i s ia l f rmediton.( ta h a diina pa e i ne de ) s utb e o ai A tc d to l g s f e d .

Thi f r s albefldwih t eClr oft eCour o orbe or t it ( 0)da sf om s o m h l ie t h e k h tn f e h ry 3 yr
tl dat oft i order. le e hs

C ouns lf rdef nda t : s gni g t i f r you a e c r iyi g t t e c ur t a you ha e eo e n s By i n h s o m r e tf n o h o t h t v c ns le w ih a r pr s nt tve oft e N e a a De a t entofCor e tonsco ce ni g pa tc pa i n i o u t d t e e e ai h vd p rm rci n r n r i i to n m edi ton. ai D a ed t i t hs da of y ,20 Si na u e g tr .

N a e ofper on who pr pa e or m s e rd he ped p e a e t i doc m e t l r p r hs u n