Veterinary Ventures, Inc. v. Farris

Filing 55

PROTECTIVE ORDER re confidential information. Signed by Magistrate Judge Valerie P. Cooke on 6/30/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

ase 3: 9- v- O732- C J- P C Docum ent47-1 Fi d 06/ 4/ 0 Page 2 of9 Oc0 RV l e 21

N evada BarNo.71 4 6 2 J r y M . yde ,Es . er Sn r q N evada BarNo.6830
3

1 RobertC.Ryan,Es . q

FLl 1ig EIFZ NEE

FECEIFD V . SE k DZN FE CC NSE F F IS'FFE OF d U A IE CD

4 Se o dFlo cn o r

HOLLAND & H A RT L p u 5441 Ki t ke Lane ez

JtF SC 2 1 J 1 50
C Et tSEI FCTC 1F L F 1 IF î; l J 1 K NC 9 D1I IT0F)E C A S FC 1V D
--- - - - - -zw .. :. , .

R eno,N V 89511

5 Phone ( 75 32 - 0 0 :7 ) 73 0 Fa :( 75 78 - 1 9 x 7 ) 66 7 6 Ato ne sf rPl i t tr y o a n x
7
8 9

Vet rnar Ve t re Inc. ei y nu s

qY '

Df!!V 7I

--

T H E UNI E D STATES DI T R IC T CO U R T T S FO R THE DISTRI T O F N EV A D A C CA SE N O . 3: 9- V - 0732- CJ- PC :0C 0 RV PR O T EC TW E O R D ER

1 0

m
'

11 VETERI A RY V EN TU RE S,l C . N N, a N e ada cor ol ton v p -i a 1 2 Pl i tf , a n if l3
V.

i

d; 1 4
I

;&

BARRY FARRI d a SI R RA BI SCI N C E, Sb E OE

2
Q
=

l t l L C, 5L
c& 1 n 6
l7

i :j t

I

C)

De e da t. fn n s

1 8
Veterinary Ventures, Inc. v. Farris

puru n t Rul 26()oft eFe e'lRulso Ci i Pr c dur ,hef lowi g Pr tctv sa t o e c h d l a e f v l o e e t o l n o e ie
Doc. 55

19 or e hasbee ent r d by Court dr n ee .
20 Proceedi esand I f r at on G overned n nom i
21 1.

Thi Or e a da y a e d e t ormod fcainshe eo (pr tci eOr e ' s d r n n m n m ns ii to r t ' o e tv d r' )

22 s al gover a y docum e t i f nnaton orot e t i g f r i he by any pary,t a y ot er hl nn n, no i h r hn uns d t on h 23 pary, and i cl desnom partesw ho r cei e a s bpoena i connecton wih t i acton.The t nu i ev u n i t hs i 24 i f r aton pr t ct d i cl des buti notlm ie t ,answer t i t roga ores a s er t n om i oe e n u , s i td o s o ner t i , n w s o 25 r quessf radm i son, r s onsest r ques sf rpr ducton ofdocum ent ,deposdon e to si e p oe to o i s i

26 tans rpt and vi eotpes, deposton exhi is and ot erwrtlgsort i gspr duced,gi en or r ci s da ii b t, h iil hn o v
27 fl d i t i acton t atar desgnat d by a pary as' onfdentalI f r aton'or' onfdental ie n h s i b e i e t ' i i n om i C 'ii C

28 A tom ey EyesOnl I f r aton' i accordancewih t e t r soft i Or e , asw el ast any t y n o m i 'n t h em hs d r lo 1

Dockets.Justia.com

ase 3: 9- v- 0732- C J- PC Docum ent47- Fi d 06/ 4/ 0 Page 3 of9 0c0 RV 1 l e 21

l copi s,exce pt ,absr ct,anal s s s m m ares desc i tons orot erf r sofr cor e e r s ta s y e, u i , rp i , h om e dd
2 i f r aton cont i i g,r fectng,ordi cl sng s ch i f r aton. n om i an n e l i s oi u no m i

3 D esenaton and M ai t nance oflnf rm aton ii ne o i

4

2.

Fo pumos softi Pr t ci eOr e , a te' o fde ta I f r aton' r e h s o e tv d r ( ) h ' n i n i l n o m i ' C

5 desgnaton shal m ean t att e doc m entcont i sa tade s cr torot erc ntdentalt chni al ii l hh u an r ee h oi ie c 6 orbusnes i f r a i n,orot eri f r aton r quie by 1 w oragree entt be kept i s n o m to h n o m i e rd a m o

7 c nfde ta a d( )t e' onfd nta Ator e Eye Onl 'd sgnai n s a l a ta t e o i n il n b h ' i e il t n y s y' e i to h l me n l t h C l
8 docum entcont i si f r aton t att e pr duci g pary deer s es eci ly s nstve,whi h m ay an n o m i h h o n t n l p a l e ii c

9 i cud ,bu i n tlm ie t ,()c n i e ta r s a c a d d veopm e ti f r ai n (i hihl n l e t s o i td o i o fd n il e e r h n e l n n o m to . i) g y
1 s nstvebusne s fna ca , a e , ma keig i f r ai n,(i)tc nia i f nnai n 0 e ii i s , i n il s l s or r tn n o m to ii e h c l n o to 1 r ltngt a y pr s nto f tr pr du t , i )a y ote tc nia i f nnain t a a 1 eai o n e e r u u e o c s (v n h r e h c l n o to h t 1 d sgnaig p ry r g r sa h g l s nstve o ( )i f nnai nr lva tt orc pa l o beng 2 e i tn a t e a d s i h y e ii , r v n o tö ee n o a b e f i
:j . F 1 1Q 1 $. 4 ma tr Con i e ta I f r a in a d Conlde tal tr e Eye Onl I f r a in d e not te . fd n il n o m to n i ni Ato n y s y n o m to o s St x 1a ï r ' r ' - 1 i cl de a d t i Pr t c i e Or e s a l a pl t , : E * 5 n u , n h s o e tv d r h l not p y o Ia (V bq 8 fk ' ifr ainta iarayi te nom t h ts led n h o '
.

1 u iie f rt epr p r ton orpr s c tonofap tnta plc ton d aln wih s c s b e t 3 tlz d o h e a a i o e ui a e p iai e ig t u h u j c

t W c : 1 klowldg orpos e so oft ep ry t who ds lslei mad unls t a pa t i a r a y zk . 1 6 l e e z' < s s in h a t o m ico t s e e s h t ry s le d r
1 bound by agr em entnott di cl ses ch i f r aton,ori f nnaton t athasbeen di cl s d t 7 e o s o u n om i no ih s oe o l8 t e publc ort i d pe s ns i a m al erm aki g s c i f nnaton no l ngercontdental h i hr r o n m n uh no i o i i, 1 pr vi ed t e pr duci g pary ca m eett e bur en ofesabls i g t e f ctofl ck ofpror 9 od h o n tn h d t ih n h a a i 20 knowl dge orpos es i n by adequat prordocum ent r evi ence. e s so ei ay d 21 3. D ocum e t and t i gspr duce dulng t e c ur e oft i ltgaton w ihi t e ns hn o d i hos h s ii i tnh

x

22 s o eofpa a rph 2( )a ove ma bede inae byt epr du ig pa t a c n anng cp rga ab , y sg td h o c n ry s o t li '
23 ContdentalI f r aton by pl ci g on each page and each t i g a l gend s bs ntaly as i i nom i an hn e u m il
24 f low s: ol

25 // / 26 // / 27 // / 28 // /
2

ase 3: 9- v- 0732- C J- PC Docum ent47- Fi d 06/ 4/ 0 Page 4 of9 0cO RV 1 l e 21

1 2 3

CO N FI EN T I L INFO R M A T I N D A O SU B JE C T TO PRO TE C TI E O R D ER V Docum ent and t i gs pr duced durng t e cour e oft i ltgaton wihizt e s ope of s hn o ih s h s ii i trh c

4 pa a rph 2 b)a ovema bed sg ae b t epr d cn pat a c n anig Co fd nta rg a ( b y e in td y h o u ig ry s o t i n n i e il
5 A tor ey Eyes Onl I f r aton by pl ci g on each pa e and each t i g a l ge d s bsantaly tn y nom i an g hn e n u t i l
6 as f low s: ol

7 8
9

C O N FD EN T I L ATTOR NE Y EY E S ONLY A INFOR M A T IO N SUBJECT TO PR O T EC TI E O R D E R V

jt l

A pary m ay desi nat i f r aton dicl s d ata deposton asConfdental t g e n om i s o e ii i

l1 I f nna i n orConfde talAtor ey EyesOnl I f nnaton by r questng t e r porert s n o to i ni tn y no i e i h e t oo 12 desgnat t e tans rptorany porton t er ofatt e tm e oft edeposton.l no s ch i e h r ci i he hi h ii f u

1 d sgnain i ma ea t etmeoftede osto , nypa t s a l vet it ( 0)c lnd rda s 3 e i to s d t h i h p iin a ry h l ha hry 3 ae a y '
D: .

1 atr h d t o ted p st nt d sg ae i wrt gt teoh r at sa dt tec u t 4 fe te ae fh e o io o e in t,n in o h te p ri n o h o r i i e x 1 y& , j k ) 1 rp re, eh rteta srp i t b d sg ae a Co f e t lno maino Co f e t l 4 5 e o trwh te h rn cits o e e in td s n i ni l fr t r n i ni da o da @a é 1 lk At r e sE t ny o 1ïm: 1 76 1 y sOnyIfn ain l n sc dsg ainima ea tedp st no wi . e l no n t .f o u h eint s d th eoii r ti o o o hn
-

Z - j; $t

' -

.;

1 s c t it ( 0)c lnda da pe id ( urngwhihpe i d teta s rpts albete tdas 7 u h hry 3 a e r y ro d i c ro , h r n c i h l r ae
18 ConfdentalA tom eysEyesO nl l f r aton,unl s t e di cl sng pary cons nt t l s ii t y no m i esh s oi t e s o es

1 co fde ta te t e toft ei f nnai n) t ee tr de o iin wilb c nsdee de oi of 9 n i n i l r am n h n o to , h n ie p sto l e o i r d v d
20 Confdentall f r aton orConfdentalAtor eysEyesOnl I f r aton.Each pary and t e i i no m i ii tn y no m i t h 21 cour r polershal atach a copy ofany f aland tm el wrten desgnaton notcet t e te t lt m i y it ii i oh
22 tans rptand each copy t e eofi ispos esson,cusody orcont ol and t e pori ns r ci hr n t si t r, h to

J3 desi nat d i s c notce s al t er aferbe ke t d i accor ancew ih t i Pr t ctve Or er l . g e n u h i h lh e t ae n d t h s oe i d .t 24 i t e r sponsbiiy ofcounself reach part t m aizai m at ral cont i i g Confdental sh e i lt o y o lt n e i s an n ii 25 I f r aton orConfdentalAtor ey EyesOnl l f r a i n i a s ctr m annerand n om i ii tn y n o m to n e le
26 appr pra el i e tfed s ast alow accesst s ch i f r aton onl t s ch pesonsand o it y d n ii o o l o u nom i you l

27 unders ch t nnsasi per ït d unde t i Pr t ctve Or er. ue s m te r hs oe i d
28 // / 3

ase 3: 9- v O0732- C J V P C Doc m en 47- Fi d 06/ 4/ 0 Page 5 of9 O cRu t1 l e 21

1 Inadvert ntFaiure t Desi nat e l o ee

2

4.

The i adverentf iur t desgnat orw ihhol any i f r aton asconfdental n t al e o i e td n om i ii

3 orprvieged wilnotbedeem ed t wai e a l t rcl i ast isconfde talorpri ieged il l o v ae am ot i ni vl 4 nat re,ort st p t epr duci g pary f om desgnatng s ch i f nnaton asconfdentala d/ r u ooh o n tr i i u no i i i no

5 prvie e wihi tn ( 0 da soft edic ve y o s c ia ve tn d sg ai n o pr du to . i lg d t n e 1 ) y h s o r f u h n d re t e i n to r o c in
6 Such f iur s al be cor ect d by pr vi i g wrten notceoft e e r rand s bstt ton copi s al e h l re o dn it i h ro u iu i e

7 oft e i advertnty pr duced docum ent ort i gs.Any pary r cei i g s ch i adverenty hn el o s hn t e vn u n tl
8 um nar ed ori pr pery mar ed doc m ent ort i gss al m ake r as na eefort t r t ive k mol k u s hn h l eo' b1 f s o e re 9 docum ent and t i gsdi ti ut d t per onsnotentted t r cei e s c Confdental s hn srb e o s il o e v u h ii 10 I f nnaton. The i f r aton s al be teat d by t e r cei i g part ascontdentalfom t e no i n om i h l r e h e vn y i ir h 11 tm e t er cevi g part i notte i wrtng oft echange i t e desgnaton. i h e in y s ii d n ii h nh ii 12 Chale ee t D esenadons ln o i

% 1 t ; 1 An rc iigp ryds ge igwi ad sg ainma rq etnwrt gta tep o u ig 4 y e evn at ia ren t ein to y e u s i in h t h rd cn h i o 7 t 1 1 p ryc a g ted sg ain Th po u igp rysalh nh v tn( 0 b sn s d y atr ' t ( 5 a t h n e h e in t . e r d cn at h lte a e e 1 ) u ies a s fe o
' -

àj .
.

l3

5.

A r cei i g pary m a chalengea pr duci g pary' desgnaton atany tm e. e vn ty l o n ts i i i

x : s& 1

@: ( s z i i $ 1 7 r u 1 r c i t ac al n en tcet a v s t er c i i gpa t wheh ro no i wilc a get e e t a k ;1 6 e ep of h le g o i o d ie h e ev n ry t e r t t l h n h z
18 busnes day tm efr m e,and afe t e cons laton r quied underLocalRul 26- ,t e is ia tr h ut i e r e 7h

I

1 d sgn to . ft ep risa euna l t r a h a r e e tafe t ee piai n oft i t n( 0 7 e i ai n l h a t r b e o e c g e m n tr h x r to e hs e 1 )
19 r cei i g pary m ay atany tm et er afers ek aCot ' Or ert ale t e confde talsat sof e vn t i het e ut d o t r h i ni t u 20 t e desi nat d i f nna i n.Untlany diput unde t i pan gr ph i rzed upon by t e Courq h g e n o to i se r h s a a s tl h 21 t e desi naton s al r m ai i fzlf r eand efectand t e i f r aton s al contl e t be h g i h l e n n tl o c f h n o m i h l im o
22 accor ed t e conf dentalteat entr quied by t i Pr t ctveOr er The bur en of dh i irm er hs oe i d. d 23 esabls î g t ata y desgnaton i corectleswih t epr duci g pary. t ihn h n iisr i th o n t 24 Dicl s re and Use ofConfdentalI f rm aton s ou i i no i

25

6.

I f nnaton desi nat d asConfdentalI f nnaton orConfdentalAtor ey no i ge i i no i ii tn

26 EyesOnl I f r aton m ay onl beused f rpur os soft i ltgaton,i cl di g s tl m ent y nom i y o pe h s ii i n u n e te

27 negotatom spr par ton,ti l and appeal Conl dentalI f r aton orConfi entalA tom ey ii e a i ra , . i i n om i di t 28 EyesOnl I f nnaton m ay notbe us d underany cicum s ncesf rpr s cutng any pa ent y no i e r t o oe i t
4

ase 3: 9- v- O732- C J- PC Docum en 47- Fi d 06 24/ 0 Page 6 of9 0cO RV t1 l e /1

1 a plcaton,f rpat ntlcensng orf ra y ot erpur ose,exce tasm ay be r quied by l w . pii o eii on h p p er a 2 Confdentali f r aton orConfde talAtor ey EyesOnl I f r aton m ay be dicl s d t i i n om i i ni tn y n om i s oe o

3 t e Cour,cour r porer ,and cour per onneli t e a ove- aptoned ltgaton;pr vi ed i i h t te t s ts nh b ci ii i o d ts
4 di cl s d unde s alori accor ancew ih t e LocalRul s. s oe re n d th e

5

7 .

S b e tt paa r ph 1 beo , fde ta I f nnato ma bed s l s d by u j c o rg a 0 lw Con i n il n o in y ico e

6 tl r cei i g pa t onl t t e f low i g i di i ual pr vi ed t a s ch i di i ual ar le e v n ry y o h o l n n v d s o d h t u n v d s e

7 i f r e oft etr soft i Pr tc ieOr e :()t o ( )e pl ye soft er c i i gpa t n o m d h em h s o e tv d r a w 2 m o e h e ev n ry
8 who a e r quied i good f ih t pr vi e as i t nce i t e conductoft i ltga i n,i cl di g re r n a t o o d s sa nh h s ii to n u n 9 any setl m entdicus i ls,and who ar i entfed ass ch i wrii g t counself rt e te s sol e d ii u n tn o oh

1 de i naig pat i a va ceoft edicos r ;( )t o ( )i - ous c uns lwhoa ei e tfed 0 sg tn ry n d n h sl u e b w 2 n h e o e r d n ii

11 byt er c i i gp ry;()ousdec uns lf rt er c i i gpa t;( )s p ori gpe s n e h e ev n a t c ti o e o h e ev n ry d u p tn ro n l 1 e plye by ( )o ( ) s c aspm-lgas lga s c ea i s daae tyce ks lga ce k a d 2 m o d b r c, u h ae l, e l e r tre , t n r lr , e l lr s n 1 pdv t ph t c p i g s r ie ;()e pe t o c ns la t; nd ( a y p ronsr q e td b 3 a e o o o y n e v c s e x rs r o u tn s a 9 n e s e u se y

$ 1 @ ; 1 c t s lofr ihsr ie s c a d c me t o ig i a esa nng mo ktiljz 4 om e t uns e vc s u h s o u n c dn ,m g c n i , c ra,uy :ç A 7 k > 1 po in ,rn lt nsw ie , cour rportng s rvies,de ons atveexhi i pr par ton,or i o u g % 5 r fl g ta sai e c s te i e c m ki bt e ai
u.

1j .

ja p i
-

I.

t ; * & 1 tece t no a yc mp tr aa aefo d c me t. 2 = 6 h rai f n o ue d tb s rm o u n s ' o
1 7 8. Su j c t p r g a h 9a d 1 beow,Confd nta Ato ne Eye Onl be to aa rp n 0 l i e il l r y s y
18 I f nnaton m aybe di cl sed by t ere ei i g part onl t t e f low i g i di i ual pr vi ed no i so h c vn y y o h o l n n vd s o d

1 tmts c idiiuasar if r e oftetr so ti Pr tcieOrer ()o tiec ur e f r 9 l u h n vd l e nom d h em f hs oe tv d :a usd o l l o s
20 t er c i i gpa t ;( )no - tor e s ppo t g pe s nne e pl ye by () s c a p r l g l, h e evn ry b n a t n y u ri ro l m o d a , u h s a a e a s n 21 lga s c ea is daae t' c eks lga ce k , i aep ot c pyig s nr e ;()e pe t o e l e r tre , t n l lr ,e l lr- prv t h o o n e i s c x rs r y s c
22 c ns la t;a d( )t os idi iua st wh m c u s lf rt epa t de inai gt emae i l o u tn s n d h e n vd l o o o n e o h ry sg tn h tra
23 hasagr ed i w rtng t att e m at ralmay bedi cl s d. e n ii h h ei s oe 24 9. I t e eventt er cei i g pa- i pr ceedi g i t i a ton pr se,t epm se nh h e v n lt s o y n n hs ci o h

25 paly s al notbe alow ed accesst m at ral ort i gs desi nat d by t epr duci g pary as ' hl t l o ei s hn ge hon t

26 Co ld nta Ato ne Eye Ony I f r ai n. Sube tt pa-g a h 1 ,hewm s pa t ma n e il tr y s l n o m to jc o l r p 0 t a e ry y
27 m ove t r ques t att e Courtper bnn a i cam er r vi w ofmat lal desgnat d oe th h f nn aee ei s i e
28 Confde talA tom ey EyesOnl I f r aton t detr i e i i i neces ar t di cl s t e i ni t y no m i o em n f ts s y o s oe h
5

ase 3: 9- v 00732- C J V PC Docum ent47- Fi d 06/ 4/ 0 Page 7 of9 0 cR1 l e 21

l m at ral t t epro separt ' expert Ot e ie,i i deem ed sufi i ntf rt e Courtt t ke ei s o h ys . h m s ts tc e o h oa 2 i t consdem ton any i f nnaton i t e r vi w ed m at ral s ppori g t eprt separy' no i i no i nh e e ei s u tn h a ts

3 cl i s. am

4

1. 0

Plort dicl si g ConfdentalI f r aton orConfdentalA tor ey EyesOnl i o son i i nom i i i tn y

5 I f r aton aspr vi ed i par gr phs7 a d 8 above,r s ectvel ,t e r cei i g pary shal n om i od n aa n ep i y h e vn t l 6 pr vi e t tl pr duci g pary a si ned Confdentalt Agr e enti t ef r ata hed as o d o le o n l g i i iy em n h o m tc

7 Exhi i A sgned by t epr pos d i di i ualt whom a di cl sur w ilbe made,t er s m e or bt i h o e n vd o so e l h eu
8 cunicul m viae oft e pr pos d exper orcons lant t e exper orcons lantsbus ness u t hoe t ut ,h t ut ' i 9 afii ton,a d any cur e tand pas cons li g r l tons i si t ei dusr . Thepr duci g fla i n rn t u tn e a i h p n h n ty on

1 pa t s al te e fe ha etn ( 0)busne sd ysfo r c i toft eCon i e ta iy 0 ry h l h r a tr v e 1 i s a r m e ep h fd n ilt ll Ag e m e t oo j c t a ypr pos di dvi ua.Suc o j c in mus bema ef rg o c us r e n t b e t o n o e n i d l h b e to t d o od a e 1 a di wrtng, t tng wihpa tc lrt t er a o sf ro j ci n.Fal r t ob e twihi tn 2 n n ii sai t riu a iy h e s n o b e to iu e o j c t n e

1

' 8 4 h e evn a t y p l o h u to eov h t . ee h lb o ico u e ? J ; ; 1 terc iigp ryma a pyt teCo r t rs letematr Th r s al en ds ls r -% e : ; : / 1 t a ypo o e idvd a d rn tetn(0 b sn s d yo j cinp r d u ls ta p ro 4b 5 o n r p sd n iiu l uig h e 1 ) u ie s a be t ei , nes h t e id oo
: 1; ç :. t
.

j

1 (0 b sn s dyssal o si t apo a.Iteprisaeu a l t rslea yojcin 3 1) uies a h lc ntue p rvl fh at r n be o eov n be t , t e o

fa m 6 i8 d

1 g # Q 1 i w a v d b t epr du i g p ry, oria yobe t ni ma e unt tepa t sh vers le t g Z 6 s ie y h o c n a t f n jci s d , i h ri a eov d : o l e
x

1 teo jcin, rt eCou t sr ldup naz rs l ntmoton. 7 h be to o h r ha ue o t eum y i
18 11. Couns lsm l beres orsbl f rt e adher nceby t id- ary ve dor t t e ell p si e o h e hr p t n s o h
19 t r sa d condii nsoft i Pr t ctveOr er Couns lm ay f lilt i oblgaton by obt i i g em n to hs oe i d. e u fl h s i i an n

20 a sgned Confdentalt Agree enti t e f r atached asExhi i B. i i i iy m n h om t bt
21 1. 2 Confde talI f r aton orConfdentalAtor ey EyesOnl I f nnaton m ay i n i n om i ii tn y no i

22 be dicl s d by a r cei i g pary t a pe son,notaleady alow ed accesst s ch i f r aton s oe e vn to r r l o u n om i 23 undert i Pr t ctve Or er i c uns lf rt e desgnatng pary agr est att e m at ralm ay be h s oe i d ,f o e o h ii t ehh ei

24

di cl s d t t eper on. A pa t m ay dicl se isown conldentali f r aton t non- ari s s oe o h s ry so t i i n om i o p te

25 asi seesfta d m ay di cl s t e opposng part ' conldentali f r aton t any ofi er t in s oe h i ys i i no m i o tc ,
26 27 di e t r empl yee,ator ey,oragentoft atopposng pary. I t e eve tofdi cl s r under r co , o tn h i t nh n s o ue t i par gr phoonl t epe son,hi orhercouns l and ot erper ors t whom dicl sze m ay hs a a yh r s e, h slo s o lr

28 be m ade,a d who ar bound by t ePr t ci e Or er r ny bepr s ntdudng t e dicl ste or n e h o e tv d ,n ee h s o tr 6

ase 3: 9- v- 0732- C J- P C Doc m en 47- Fi d 06/ 4/ 0 Page 8 of9 0cO RV u t1 l e 21

l dicus i n ofConfde talI f r aton orContdentalAtor eys EyesOnl l f r aton. s so i ni no m i ii tn y no m i
2 D icl s r ofm at ralpur uantt t i par gr ph s al not by is l,cons iut aw ai eroft e s oue ei s o h s a a h l , tef tt e v h 3 contdentalsat soft e m at rals dicl s d. i i tu h ei o s o e
4 Non- art Inf rm aton pvo i

5

13.

The exi t nce oft i Pr t ctve Or ers al be di cl s d t any pers n se hs oe i d hl s oe o o

6 pr duci g docum ent ,t ngi l t i gsort s i ony i t i acton w ho m ay r asonabl be o n s a be hn e tm n hs i e y 7 expect d t desr confdentalteau entf rs ch docum ent ,t ngi l t i gsort s i ony. e o ie i ir ou s a be hn e tm 8 Any such per on m ay des gnat docum ent ,t ngi l t i gs ort s i ony confdentalptr uant s ie s a be hn e tm i i zs 9 t t i Pr t ctve Or e . o hs oe i dr 10 Fii e Docum ent W ih t e Court ln s th 11 l. 4 No part ornon- ary s al fl orsubm i f rtlng aspartoft e cour r cor y p t h l ie t o ii h te d

12 any docum ent unders alwihouttr tobt i i g l ave ofcourt N ot ils a di g any s e t is an n e . w tlt n n 13 agr em entam ong t epari s,t epary s eki g t fl a paperundersealbear t e bur en of e h te h t e n o ie sh d
M

2
Q

@; 1 o ec migtepeu p ini fv ro p bi a c s t p p r fe i c u t 4 v ro n h rs m to n a o f u l c es o a es i d l o r. c ll 59 t# 1 5 1 . P o u igo rc iigc nie t lifr ain 5 r d cn r e evn o ld ni n om t , a o

jr

oohniecmpyn wi rtevs o lig t h

H c

x â 1 te tr soft i Pr tci eOr e ,s al no ( )o e aea a ad iso bya ypa t t a a y L = 6 h em h s o e tv d r h l t a p r t s n m s in n ry h t n
17 pari ul rContdentall f r aton orConfdentalAtol eysEyesOnl l f r aton cont i s tc a i i n om i ii tm y nom i an

1 o r fe t t des c esora y ohe tpeofc nfde ta orpr prea y i f r ain;( ) 8 r elc s m e r t n t r y o i n il o itr n o m to b

1 prj dieterght ofapat t o jc t tl pod cinofif r ainormaeilta te 9 eu c h i s ry o be t o le r u to no m to tra h th 2 pat d e notc nsde t bewihi teso eofdso ey;()prj dieterght ofapa' 0 ry o s o i r o t n h cp ic v r c eu c h i s l, t y 21 t se adeemiainb teCo r ta patc lrmaeil beprdu e ;()prj diete o e k tr n to y h u th t riua tras o c d d eu c h 2 rg t ofapat t a pl t teCo r frfrhe prtcieodes or()prve ttep ris 2 ihs ry o p y o h u to u t r oe tv r r; e e n h a t e
23 fom agr ei g i wrtng t alerorwai e t e pr vii nsorpr t ctonspr vi ed f rher i r e n n ii o t v h o so oe i od o en 24 w ih r s ectt any pari ul ri f r aton orm at ral t ep o tc a n o m i ei . 25 Concl sou ofLii aton ui te i

2 6

1. 6

W ihl sxt ( 0)c lnda da safe f a j dgme ti t i a to i cldi gt e t ' i y 6 ae r y tr m l u n n n h s cia n u n h

2 e ha si nofa1a pe l, wihi sx y( 0)c lnda da sa trdim is lp rua tt a 7 x u to l p a s or t n it 6 ae r y fe s sa u s n o 28 s tlm e ta r e e t e c pa t orot e pe s n s b e tt t etr soft i Pr tc i eOr e ete n g e m n , a h ry h r ro u j c o h e m h s o e tv d r
7

ase 3: 9- v- 0732- C J- P C Docum ent47-1 Fied 06/ 4/ 0 Page 9 of9 0cO RV l 21

1 shal be underan oblgaton t desr y orr tm lt t epr duci g pary a1 m at ral and l i i o to et o h o n t 1 ei s 2 docum ent cont i l g Confde talI f r aton orContdentalA tor ey Eyes Onl s a n' n i ni n om i i i tn y

3 I f nnaton,and t ceriy t t e pr duci g part s ch destucton orr t r .H ow eve ,out i e no i o tf o h o n yu ri eu n r sd
4 counself rany pary s al be entted t r t i a1 courtpapel ,t i lta s rpt ,exhi isand o thl il o e a n 1 s ra r n c i s bt

5 atom ey wor pr vi ed t atany s ch m at ral ar m ai t i ed and pr t ct d i accor a ce t k od h u e i s e n an oe e n dn
6 wih t e t r soft i Pr tctve Or er t h em h s oe i d. 7 O t er Proceedi es h n
8 17. By e t rng t i O r era d lm ii g t e di cl s r ofi f r aton i t i cas , n e i h s d n i tn h s o u e n o m i n h s e

9 tz Cour doesnoti t nd t pr cl de anot ercourtfom fndi g t ati f nnaton m a be le t ne o e u h r i n h no i y

1 r lv nta d s b e tt dicls r i a ot e c s .An pe s norpa t ss b e tt t i 0 ee a n u j c o s o u e n n h r a e y ro ri u j c o h s e 11 Pr t ci eOr e t a ma bes b e tt amo i nt d s l s a ot e pa t' i f nnain o e tv d r h t y u j c o to o ico e n h r rys n o to
12 desgnat d Confdentalpur uantt t i Pr t ctveOr er s al pr m pty notf t atpa t of ie ii s o h s oe i d ,h l o l iy h ry 13 t em oton s t ati m a have an opporuniy t appe rand be hear on whet ert at h i oh t y t to a d hh

$ 1 @ J 1 lfr ains o l b ds ls d 4 no m t h ud e ico e . o x ! az 1 q 7 L % 1 Re e is 15 m de Zi k ' i2 é j il
.

i;

.

tg r : 1 c .u 6 j
I

1. 8

I i Or e e by teCo r ta t i Pr t ci eOr e wilb e f r e byt e t s d r d h u t h t h s o e tv d r l e n o c d h

1 sncil stfrhi Rul 37b)o teFe ea RulsofCiiPrce ur a ds c ohe 7 a toz e o t r e ( f h d rl e s l vl o d e n u h t r
18 s lc i msasm ay beavaia l t t e Cour,i cl di g t e powe t hol partes orot er a lto lb e o h tn u n h ro d i h

1 v oa o soft i Pr tc ieOr e i c ntm ptAl ote r m e isa albl t a ype s nt) 9 i lt r h s o e tv d r n o e . l h r e de v ia e o n ro s

20 ijle b aviltonofti PrtcieOr e aef lyprsnrd. ntrd y oai hs oe tv d r r ul e e e
21 l9. Any part may petton t e Cour f rgood ca s s ow n,i t e events ch pary y ii h to ue h nh u t 22 desr sr leffom a t r orcondii n oft i Or e . ie e i r em to hs d r 23 I I SO ORDERED TS

2 4
25 26

D

ae :n i 5r d yo td s ) a f

N

, 0l . 20
<

f

'j y

U nie St t s M agi ta e J dge td ae sr t u
27 28
8