Higgs vs Dwight Neven, et al

Filing 17

ORDER DENYING 5 Motion to Dismiss. FURTHER ORD Rs' answer due by 4/23/2011. FURTHER ORD P's reply to the answer due within 30 days from service of answer. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 3/24/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

qi

.

X# '

yj y yj
.

ay yy ; y yy
.

E EE hC R D
'

otsti 'i ( ucj l fl' fy ) c a N 'g 's r ' j

--- SECSE(LR / )?

I

E 1
I i I

?Aj g j s j j j
1

2
3
4

-

-

.

: 3 7
.. -

gtâsLS pl /a.c ly in! j su tr jr '4 I jp -

f j yl j , j ç wa gr
.-

:

-

-

CE Y FUT

5
i !
I i I
l

.

6
7

UN I TED STATES DI STRICT C O U RT DI STRICT O F NEVAD A '

8

1

9

1 CHAZ HI 0 GGS
,

.

11
12 vs.

Peiine , tto r
.

'

1 DWI NEVEN,e al, 3 GHT t . 1 4
1 5
1 6

i
'

!

Res de s pon nt.
'

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
/

3: 0-v- 0- -l M l c 0005 RCJ lA

ORDER
.

i
;

I i

'bi acton i apetton f a wrtofhabe cor f l pur uantt 28 U .S. j225 by r s i s ii or i as pus ied s o C. 4,

1 cha Hi s a x evadast t prsonerr pr sent d bycouns . Bef e t cour i r spondent ' 7 z gg , ae i e e e el or he ts e s
Higgs vs Dwight Neven, et al

1 mo i t dim is( No 5 . 8 ton o s s ECF )
Doc. 17

.

1 1 Pr e alH it y 9 . oc dur s or

.

2 0
E
E

OnJ n 2 , 0 ,h S c n J dca Ditit utnafrteço nyo Wah e e trd u e 9 2 07 te eo d u iil src Co ri o h u t f s o ,nce

:
:

2l aj dgme puru ntt aj r vedittndi peii e gulyofmur ri t trtde re ( hi t u nt s a o uy r c i ng tton r it de n he is ge . Ex bi 22 98)1Thej ' s t pe lya lf i prs wiht posi lt ofpar ea rtny r,a dte . ul ethe nat tie n ion t he sbiiy y ol Ae e eas n h 23 c ts n e c hi ac r ng y (#..On J y 1 2007, ttone purue adie ta a . our e t nc d m co di l . / ) ul 8, pe ii r s d r c ppe l
2 ( bi 1 ) Pettone ,b wa ofc ns l fld h sope n bre wi. t Ne ad Su e Cou t 4 Exhi t 07 . ii r y y ou e, ie i nig if t he v a pr me r. h
'

.

25

26

l Thee hi t r f l nc d i t so de a ef x bis e e e e n hi r r r ound i t Co tsr c d a ECF No. 9. n he ur ' e or t 6-

'

;

!

Dockets.Justia.com

'

j
!

X +

1 i

!
l

1

l ( bi 11 .OnSe tmbe 1 2 t Ne ad Su e Cour is cdisorerofafr nc Exhi t 7) pe r 6, 008,he v a prmc tsu t d fima e. 2 ( bi l ) Pctton rGldapeiinfrrhe rng, chwa de e ( iis1 & 1 1. Exhi t 34 . ii e e tto o e ai whi s nid. Exhbt 37 4 )
3 Rem itt i ued on Febr y 9,20l0,af e bei r aled once t publsh t or ofaf i nce. tiur ss uar t r ng ec l o i he der fnna

4 ( bis1 1 ) Exhi t 42-45 . 5
!

Peii rsldhi fdea ha a peii onJ uay27, 0.( No.1.Thepeii ttone e s e rl be s tton an r 201 ECF ) tton -

6 c ai Gvepoun frrle .(#..Reponde t ha fldamotont dimist peii , ont ns ds o eif / ) s ns ve ie i o s s he tton
1 .
:

7 agui t t o r ng ha Grunds111wer note a tdi sat c ur.( No.5) Peiine opp edte -1 e xh use n t e o t ECF . tto r os h
8 moto ( No.11. Res de sGldar pl ( No.l ) in. ECF ) pon nt e e y. ECF 2.
9 I . D icus on I s si

ë
I

1 0

A f de a c twiln gr nt sa eprs e ' pe ii f ha a r ifu i te p ion rha e r l our l ot a a tt ion rs tton or be s ele ntl h rs e s

i
'

1l e use hi a ia esaerme e fraIcli r sd.Ros v Lund 455U. 509( 982,28 xha td s valbl tt e dis o l ams aie e . y, S. 1 ) . 1 U. C.j225 1 A p ii rmus gietesaec t af roppotniyt a tonea o hi 2 S. 4(8. ettone t v h tt ours ai ru t o c ch f s
13 cl m sbef e hepr ai or esent t e cl m si a f alhabeaspetton. O 'uli an v.Boer ,526 U . s hos ai n eder ii S lv ckel S.

!
ë
:

!
'

1 8 8 (999)s ealoDu anv He r 51 U. 36 36 (995) A cam rmai 4 38, 44 1 , e s nc . ny, 3 S. 4, 5 1 . li e ns .
l unexha t untlt pettonerhasgi t hi tavaiabl st e cour t opporuniy t 5 used i he ii ven he ghes l e at t he t t o

/

l con i rt e cl i t r gh die a pc orsat c l e a r vi w pr c edi gs Se Ca e v M o e 6 s de h a m h ou r ct p al t e olat r l e e o e n . e s y . or ,

1 3 F. 8 9l ( bCi. 4) Gario v Mc t y 65 F. 37 37 (tCi.1 ) 7 86 3d 96, 6 9t r200 , rs n . carhe 3 2d 4, 6 9b r 981. .
'

1 8

A habeas pettonerm us Spr entt st e court w ih t s e cl m heur upon t ii t l es he at s t he am ai ges he

( ' : @
I '

1 fdeal ou t' Piar v Co ,40 U. 270,2 (971.Thefdea c siutona i iai s 9 e r c r.' c d . nnor 4 S. 76 1 ) e rl on tt i lmplc ton 20 ofacai notus is sofsaelw, tha be nr sdi t sat c tt ac e ee usi l m, j tsue tt a mus ve e aie n he t e our o hiv xha ton.
21 Yba r v sumne , F.Supp.1 0,1 ( Ne 1 )( tngPiar 40 U. at 6:.To ra . r 678 48 481 D. v. 988 cii c d, 4 S. 27 22 ac e e ha ton,h saec tmus bed l tdt t fc t tt prs e (s as ri cli hive x usi te tt our t l ere o he a tha he ion r i) setng ams a
23 u rt Unie St t sCons iuton ' nd gi n t e opp - t t c r cta l ge vi a i oft nde he t d a e tt i ' a ve h oluniy o ore le d ol tons he t

;

:
I

:

' I i
!

24 pione' fdea rght.Dunc v Heny,51 U. 36 365(995) seHiv av Woo 1 F.d rs rs e rl i s an . r 3 S. 4, 1 * c ial . d, 95 3 , 25 1 1 06( bCi.1 99) l i we l etc t t2 U. C. 2 b ' ov d asmpl an cea 098, 1 9: r 9 . t s l s tld ha 8 S. j 254( ) t i es i e d l r pr
26
2

i

a

i
i I
I : :
.

.

I !

1 i r i t pot i ltgant bef eyou brng any cl m st f alcoul,be s e t you fr nstucton o ental ii s: or i ai o eder t ur hat ist

ha e tk n e chonet sa eco t'Ji n zv Rie 27 F. 47 481( * Ci. )( uotng Ro e v ae a o tt ur. mie . c , 6 3d 8, ' 9 r 2001 q i s

v Lun y,455U. 50 52 ( 9 ) . d S. 9, 0 1 82).
l t i t cas r pondent ar t Gr n he nsant e, es s gue hat ounds 1 l,and l oft f alpetton ar ,1 1l hc eder ii e unexhaused,becaus som eofpettoner' ar e sand cas ciatonswer pr ent t t t e ii s gum nt e ti e es ed o he Nevada Supr e Courti hi petton f r em n s ii or ehearng,r hert i hi openi brefon diectappeal i at han n s ng i r . A cl m r s f t f r ttm e on dicr i y r ew t t st e' hi ai aied or he i s i s etonar evi o he at s ghestcourtand

d nid,wih tc e e tou omme ,i note use Ca e v Moo e, F. 8 91 ( Ci. 00 nt s xha td. sy . r 386 3d 96, 7 9* r 2 4)
( tng Ca tle v Pe pls, U. 3 ,35l( 98 ) Howe r wh r t saehihe tc r cii s il . o e 489 S. 46 1 9). ve , e e he t t g s ou t
addr ses t mert ofar ent pr ent i a petton f r es he is gum s es ed n ii or econsi aton orot di etonar der i her scr i y

I r iw,tecamsar pr e l e ha td.Cha r v Mc e,5 F. 1 91 1 95 11 (t l eve h li e op ry x use mbes . Danil 49 3d 1 , 1 - 99 9h Ci. 8) Gr e v Lambe t 288F. 1 ,1 6- 08 ( * Ci. 2) r 200 . e n . , r, 3d 081 08 1 8 9 r 200 .
Thi Cour has r ewed Gr s t evi ounds1 1 oft f alpetton,al wih t st e petton f -11 he eder ii ong t he at ii or

rhe rng( hi t1 ,h Nev daSuprmeCour' or rdcn ngrhe rng( bi 1 ) a e ai Ex bi 37)te a e ts de yi e ai Exhi t 41, nd
ot r evantdocum ent i t st e cour r d. n eN evada Supr eCourtdi notdeny t her el s n he at t ecor em d he cl m si t petton f r ai n he ii or ehearng wiboutcom m entoropi on. I ead,t Nevada Supr eCour i t ni nst he em t i ued an 11 pageor dicussng t m erisand uli at y denyi t cl m s pr ss der s i he t tm el ng hc ai esent i t cd n he

peii f r e rn ( hi t1 ) Ass h,tecamsta weema i t peii f tton or eh a ig. Ex bi 41. uc h li h t r de n he tton or
r chearng,whi ar r i ch e epeat i t f alhabeaspetton atGr ed n he eder ii ounds1 1 ,and 11 ar pr l ,1 1 , e opery

e use On r vi w oft sa e c tr c d,a lgr undspr s nt d i t f de a p ii ha e xha t d. e e hc t t our e or l o e e c n he e r l ctton v
'

21 b n e us e i s a e c t Res onde sm us fl a a we ; . t e m e is a r s i a l ee xha t d n t t our . p nt t ie n ns r on h r t $ dd e sng 1
gr oundspr ent i t f der habeaspetton. es ed n he e al ii
J

23 1 1 Conc us on 1. l i

I I THEREFORE ORDERED t trs T S ha eponde s motont dimis( No. i nt' i o s s ECF 5) s
25 DENIED .
3

i

1

I I FURYHER ORDERED t trs de sSHALL FI AN ANSW ER t a1 T S ha epon nt LE o1

2 gr dsoft peii wihi t r y( day fo t e r oft sor r n ea wers l i l oun hc tton t n hit 30) s r m he nty hi de . ns hal ncude
3 subsantve ar ent on t m ert ofaI gr t i gum s he is l ounds i t petton. No f her m otons t di is n he ii urt i o sm s 4 w ilbe ent ai l ert ned. l f lng t ans n ii he wer,r pondcnt s lcompl wih t r r ent ofRul 5 es s hal y t he equiem s e

5 oft RulsGov r ngPoc di i t Unie SttsDititCou t un r28U. C.j 4. he e eni r ee ngs n he td ae src rs de S. 225
6 I IS FU RTH ER O R DERED t pettoner' r y t t ans ers lbe fl no l er T hat ii s epl o he w hal ied at h Dat t s 24t ed hi day ofM ar , 2 ch
'

7 t a t r y( day a trb ngs ve wih t ea we . h n hit 30) s fe ei er d t h ns r
8
9

1 0
lI

UNI TED ST

- DI S STRI J DGE CT U

1 2 1 3

15

1 6
1 7

I

18 1 9

21

22

23

25
4