Lewis v. Allen et al

Filing 21

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that Plaintiff's 5 Application to Proceed in Forma Pauerpis is GRANTED. Plaintiff shall not be required to pay an initial partial filing fee. However, even if this action is dismissed, the full filing fee must still be paid. FURTHER ORDERED, the NDOC shall pay to the Clerk of the USDC, District of NV, 20% of the preceding month's deposits to Plaintiff's account (inmate #96337), in the months that the account exceeds $10.00, until t he full $350 filing fee has been paid for this action. The Clerk shall send copy of this order to the Finance Division and to the Chief of Inmate Services for the NDOC. (Sent: 8/6/2010.) FURTHER ORDERED, plaintiff 9 motion to amend/co rrect complaint is GRANTED. FURTHER ORDERED, count one of the amended complaint shall proceed against defendant correctional officer J. Allen on a claim of deliberate indifference and a claim of retaliation, count two shall proceed against def endant correctional officer R. East on a claim of denied medical care, and count four shall proceed against defendant correctional officer D. Patterson on a claim of excessive force. FURTHER ORDERED, count three is dismissed with leave to amend in co nformance with the instructions provided in this order. FURTHER ORDERED, plaintiff shall file his "Second Amended Complaint" within thirty days of the date of this order. Failure to amend will result in the matter proceeding as to the counts allowed in this order. FURTHER ORDERED, all pending motions 4 , 7 , 8 , 12 , 16 , and 17 are DENIED as discussed herein. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 8/3/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - KO)

k
i

. q ... 1' . .D 1 iu è

,

(

:

'

2.--.. ---.7. .- . y l ' ' lt - , 2 1 i l ' 00 sA
; t. . . . . . . ..

W -U J ! . ....' . ..j . ... ., $t fr.-.t .. i.fj. .'/j ?j... h - . , vey .. u .,c - -- . . . - --

1 E ! :

1
2 3

'

i

.
' .. ..?

t .

.r -' L'' 'u'- :' -t ! re ' '' ' . .
-. .. . -

i . -; u .

1
.l i .. .

(

L . - - Q+.v- ' X -.. . 2. ' -

4
5

UN I ED STATES D I T R I T CO U R T T S C
DISTRI T O F NEVAD A C

6 ANTHONY LEW I , S 7 Plitm an i

) ) )

3:0- v- 083- CJV PC 1c0 R ORDER )

)
8 vs . 9 J ALLEN,e aI, . t.
1 0
11

Dee d nt. fn a s

) ) ) )

Pl i tf A nt onylew i, s bm it daci irght com pl i tandupon t ecour ' or er a n ir h - s has u te v li s an h ts d ,

1 ha tldarvie a pl aint pr cedifomapau e i( oc e /5 . sdonteifr aina out 2 sie e sd p i to o o e n r c p rs d k t/) Bae h no m to b
13 pl i tf' X anci l t t s,ncl di g a yaddii nalnf r atonpl i tf ra yhavepr vi ed,t ecourtlnds a n ifs a sau i u n n to i o m i a n if r od h i

1 t a pl i tf i N O T a l t pa a i ii l nsal e t pa m e tt w a dst e f l fl g f e p r ua tt 28 4 h t a n ir s b e o y n n ta i t l n y n o r h u l ii e u s n o m n

1 U. . . 1 1 Plitfwi, ve, rquie t ma emonhl pa me t twadst ef l$3 0.0 5 SC j 9 5. anif l howe rbe e rd o k l t y y ns o r h ul 5 0
1 fl g f ew he h ha f ndsa a lbl . 6 ie n n e su vi e a

1 7
Lewis v. Allen et al

Plitfha as fldt ef lowi gm o i n : moto t a e dhi c mpli tdoc e /9 , an ir s lo e h ol n to s a in o m n s o an ( k t/)
Doc. 21

1 a da e de c mplit(oc e /1 ) t omotonsrquetnga poit e tofc uns lt omotonst 8 n m n d o an d k t/0 ,w i e si p nm n o e,w io
l e t n hi cop wor alw a c f rpur os sofa ha e sa ton ( oc e # 4 a d #1 ,a moto f r 9 x e d s y k lo n e o p e b a ci d k t n 2) in o

2 pei ia' ijncin( oc e #1 )a donefratmporr r sr iigor e ( oc e /1 .He ha 0 rlm n l nu to d k t 6 n y o e ay etann d r d k t/7) s 21 wrte sv rletr t tee ur c mpliigofhi te t e ti prs n(oc es/1 #1 ,a d/1 ) itn e ea ltes o h o t o ann s r am n n io d k t /3, 4 n /5.
22 1 . Pr lm i ary M at ers ei n t

23

The c ur s alde y hi va i us motonsasd s us ed beow . o t h l n s ro i ic s l

24
25

A.

I i n t eReif nu c i v lc
Ther ar t o ale nat t ss,one ofwhih m us be m eti or ert gr nta pr lm i ar e e w tr e e t c t nd oa ei n y

26 ijncin.Thefrtts rquiesta ac ur f d( )temovngpa t wi s fe irpaa l ijr i nu to ls et e r h t o t m 1 h i ry l u rr re rbe nuy f l

Dockets.Justia.com

1 teijncierle inot a td;()teeiasbsa ta l eioodtath movigpat wiluc e d h nu tv eifs grne 2 h r s u tnili lh h te n ry ls c e k 2 o temeis ( )nb lncn tee uiishen mnovigpat wi not hame mo eta t emovig n h rt' 3 i aa ig h q te t o , n ry l be r d r h n h l n

3 pa t i hepe ; a d ( )g a tng ijncierle i i tepubi itrs. Mari v.I tr atonal ry s l d n 4 rn i nu tv eif s n h lc neet tn nen i 4 Olmpi Commite,7 0F.d67 ,67 - 5(t Ci.98 ) Thesc n ts r q ie t emovigpat yc te 4 2 0 4 7 9h r1 4 . e o d et e urs h n ry 5 t de on ta e et e ( ) a c mbiai n of pr ba l s c e s on t e me is a d t e pos iit of o m sr t ih r 1 o n to o be u c s h rt n h sb ly i
6 irpaa l ham;o ()ta srousq e ton aerte a dtebalnc ofhads i tpss apl i hs re rbe r r 2 h t ei u si s r as d n h a e r hp i h r y n i
7 f vor. f .at675. a #

8

Plitf' motons f r t m po ay r sr iig o de an pr l ia' ij n to a e an ifs i o e r r e tann r r d ei n l n u c in r my

9 i s m ci ntt obt i t ereques ed r let Hehasnots ow n alkelhood ofs eces on t em ert ,m e el n u e o an h t ei l h ii ush is r y 10 outi i g t e f ct ofhi com pl i ti a m or s cci ctm anne . H ehasnotaddres ed i any f s i n t e ln n h a s s an n eu n r sn a ho h 11 f ct rofir par bl hal publc i t res or t e equii st t enonmovi g pary. Pl i tf al o f ist ao re a e m i ne t h te o h n t an ir s a l o

l de onsr t t a t e e a e s ro sque tonsr ie i hi c m p ai ta d doesnotdic s t eba a c of 2 m ta c h t h r r e i u si as d n s o l n n s u s h ln e
13 har s i s. Neiherdoeshe i entf any new devel pm ent eris es t atwoul hi hlghtf r t e court d hp t d iy o s su h dgi oh 14 an ur entore er entsiuaton. g mg ti
15 B. Copywor k

1 6

Th moto sfrc ppv r (oc es#4a d/1 )s albede idbe a s ti i nota e in o o o k d k t n /2 h l ne c u e hs s

1 h be sa ton a dbe a s t e e i n pr s n ne d s o n b pl i tf f ra dii na c pp v r f nds He 7 a a c i n c u e h r s o e e t e h w y a n if o d to l o o k u . 1 ma r n w t e m o i n a a l t rtm e i he i a l t s a e a s ecfc n e . 8 y ee h to t a e i f s b e o t t p i e d
19 C. Couns l e

20

Themotonsfra poit e t c unsl( oc es#7a d#8 s alalobede ida t i i o p nm n of o e d k t n )h l s ne ths

21 tm e. A l i a ti a c vi rgh a ton doe noth ve a Si t Am e dm e trgh t a poi t d c un e . i ig n n i l i t ci t s a xh n n i t o p ne o sl

22 Stret v S el an, 54F,d1 49,1 25 (*Ci. 981.l v r l ie c c msa c s fdea c urs o s h . p lm 6 2 3 3 3 9 r 1 ) n ey i td k u tn e,e rl o t m
23 ar empower d t r ques an atom e t r pr s ntani di entci i ltgant The cicum s ancesi whi h e e oe t t y o e ee ng v l ii . r t nc

24 a c ur w ilm a e s c a r q e t how e e ,a e e c e i gl r r ,a d t e c ur wilm a e t e r q es o t l k u h e u s, v r r x e dn y a e n h o t l k h e u t
25

26

2

l un e onl e ta r iar cic msa c s Unte Sttsv. 64Ac e o Land,7 5F.d79 , 9- 0 d r y xro dn y ru tn e . 'd ae 30. rs f t 9 2 6 79 8 0 2 (tCi.1 86 ,Wibor v Es ale o ,7 9F.d 1 1 (tCi.1 6) 9b r 9 ) l n . c d r n 8 2 328, 331 9b r 98 . .
3 A f di g ofs c e c ptona c r um s a c s r quiest a t e Cour e aua e bot t e ln n u h x e i l ic t n e e r h t h tvl t hh
4 lkelhood ofs cees on t e mert and t e pl i tf' abiiy t ar i ul t hi cl i s i pr se i lghtof ii u sh is h an ifs lt o tc a e s am n o n i

5 t e c m pl x t o t e l g lis e iw ol e . N et e f c or i d s ostv ,a d bot mus be vi w e h o e iy f h e a s u s r v d ih r a t s ip ii e n h t ed

6 tgeh ri makigatndng. T relv Sr wc,9 5F.d 1 1 1 1 (tCi.1 9Lliig Wibor , o te n n i i e rl . c r 3 2 0 5, 0 7 9b r 9 lctn l n
7 s pr ,78 F.d a 1 31 .Thedititco r hascon ie a l d s r toni ma i gt es f digs u a 9 2 t3 ) src u t sd r b e ic ei n kn h e m n .
8 Th Cour wil e t ra o de die tng t ea poi t e tofc uns l Th pl i tf ha e t l not n e n r r r c i h p n m n o e . e a n ir s
9 aleady dem onsr t d t athe î f ly abl t ltgat t i case on hi own. H e has s bm it d varous r ta e h s u l e o ii e h s s u te i 10 document t t e Cour,and i per ecty fuenti Engls . M or over none oft e is esi t i cas i so h t s f ll n ih e , h s u n hs e s

1 pa tc lry c m plx,whi h i d c t st a t e pl itf w il a l t l i a e t i c s on hi own. 1 riua l o e c n i a e h t h a n if l be b e o i g t h s a e t s 1 2 A d ii na l ,pl i tf i a vie t att e co r w i not c nsde r que t or notc s d to l y an if s d s d h h u t l l o i r e ss ie

l pr vi edi t ef nn ofal ter.I pl i tf hass ecii cl i st makeorw ihest pr s ntt ecoul w ih 3 o d nh o e t f an ir p fc am o s o ee h -t t

1 s e i cr que t , mus do s i t e f r of m oton whi h, ncet ec m pl i th sbe n s r e e a d 4 p c t e s s he t o n h o m a i i co h o an a e c e n d n l a pr ve by t e c ur ,mus a s be s r e upon t e d f n a t . 5 pod h ot t lo evd h ee d n s 1 6 The a e de c m pl i tal g n vi lton ofhi co s iutona rg t und r42 U . . . m n d o an l i g o a i s c s n tt i l i h s e SC

1 j 1 83i s be tt tepr vsonsof28U.. .j 1 1 a d tecour' r vew un c tatsatt i 7 9 s u jc o h o ii SC 9 5 n h ts e i d r h t ue s
l dic s c be ow . 8 su s d l

1 I. 9I
20

Sc e ni gPuruantt 2 U.. .j191 A re n s e 8 SC 5
Feder lcour sm ustconductapr lm i ar s ree i g i anycas i whi h aprioners eks a t ei n y c n n n en c s e

21 rdr s 9om agov rme tle tt o ofic o e plye ofag vemne tle tt .See28U.. .j e es cn na niy r lc r r m o e o r na niy SC 22 1 1 a . Tosaeacam unde 42U.. .9 1 ,aplitf mus alg t oe snilee e t:() 9 5A() tt li r SC 983 an i t le e w se ta lm n s 1 2 ta arg ts c rdb teCo siutonorlwsofteUntdSttswasviltd, n ()t a tealge 3 h t ih e u e y h n tt i a h ie ae oae a d 2 h t h l d e
24 vi lton w a c m r it d by ape s n a t g unde co orofs a el w . S e We tv At i s 487 U . . oa i s o n te ro ci n rl tt a e s . kn , S 42,

25 48 ( 988 . 1)
26 3

1

D im is lofacom pl i torpar t er off rf iur t s at a cl i upon whih r lefcan s sa an t h e o a l e o t e am c ei

2 begr n e i pr viedf ri Fe eal eofCiiPr ce ur 1 ( )6 ,a dt ec ur wi a pl t es m e a t d s o d o n d r Rul vl o d e 2 b () n h o t l p y h a l 3 sa d r unde j1 1 whe r ve igac mpli t a a en e c mplit Re iw unde Fe . Ci . tn a d r 9 5 n e iw n o an or n m d d o an . v e r d R. v

4 P.1 ()6)i es nil ar l gonaquetonoflw.NorhStrI t1v Arz naCbz .Co m ',7 0 2 b( s se tal ui y n si a t a n . io p m n2 5 F.d 578 58 ( t Ci.l ) l c nsde igwh t e plitf h ssatdacam uponwhc r l fca 2 , 0 9 h r 983 . n o i rn e h r an ir a t e li ih ei n e
6 be gr nt d,al mat ralalega i ns i t e compl i tar accept d as t l and ar t be cons r ed i t e a e l e i l to n h an e e ne eo tu n h

7 lgh mos fvor bl t t e plitf Ru s l v Landre ,621 F.d 1 37,1 39 ( t Ci.1 8 ) i t t a a e o h an il s e l . l iu 20 0 9h r 9 0 .
8 A legatonsofapr s compl i antar hel t l sssrngentst ndar st an f nnalpl adi gsdr fed by li oe an e d o e ti a dh o en at

9 lwy r.Haie v Kene , 4U.. 1 , 20( 9 2)( e c ra ) Howe e ,fia pe r t ac rant a es n s . r r 40 S 5 9 5 1 7 p r u im . v r i t p as o e ti y
1 t at a pl i tf wilnot be entted t r lef under any s t of f ct t at coul be pr ven under t e 0h a n ir l il o e i e a sh d o h 11 alegatonsoft e compl i t t e courtmay sua s ont dim ist e ca se ofacton orpor i nst er of li h an , h p e s sh u i to h e

1 Haltv We dl v Co.67 F.d 1 05,1 09(t Ci.1 82 . 2 e . n n . , 2 2 3 3 9h r 9 )
l 3 An entr com pl i torpor i nst er offl d bya prs ners al be dim is d sua s ont ie an to h e ie io hl s se pe

1 i i i fiol us maii us orfist sae a cam upo whih r l fma be g a t d.28 U. . .j 4 f t s rv o , lco , al o t t li n c ei ey r ne SC

1 1 1 A() Thi icude tos ta pose slga c ncusonsta aeuntna l (.. wheen te 5 9 5 b . s n l s h e h t ss e l o l i h t r e be eg, r i h
1 d fnd nt a ein unefom s iorcam sofnfige e tof lga it r s whihceal doe no e it 6 e e a s r rm r u t li i rn m n a e ln e e t c l ry s t x s)

1 a wela t os t a onl co ti fncflfcua alg to s ( .. clirsdeciig fnatcor 7 s l s h e h t y n an a iu a t l l ain , eg, ari srbn a tsi e

1 d lsona s e ais.Thec mplit e heeni s be tt s as o t ds is l irt sr ieo te 8 eu i l c n ro ) o an fld ri s u jc o u p ne im sa pro o e vc n h
1 named def nda t . 9 e ns
20 1 1 1. D icusson si

21

Pl i tf bri gsf urcl i s f rr lefwhih ar bas d cli st atprson cor ectonal an if n o am o e i c e e am h i ri

22 oë cer have vi l t d hi Ei ht Amendmentrght i varousw ays.Pl i tf i enttes f ur s o ae s g h i sn i a n ir d ii o 23 def ndant 't r e cor ectonalofk er ,nam i g t em i t ei i di i ualcapa ii s and Diect rof e s, h e ri fs n h n h rn vd c te , ro

2 Prs ns Howa d Skol ik, 4 io , r n c who i na e i hi i di i ua an ofi i l pa ii s A pe s n c n otbe s m d n s n v d l d lc a ca c te . ro a n

25 s e i hi orhe ofkil a a iyfrmo e da a e.Onl ij n tv r l fi a ai bl fr u d n s r l a c p ct o n y m g s y nu cie ei s v l e o e a
26
4

1 de e da t s i t be a tng i t erofi i lc pa iy. On t e ot e ha d,pe s na c pa iy s iss e f n n s ad o c i n h i ïc a a ct h hr n r o l a ct u t e k
2 t i poseper onallabiiy upon a gover m ent lom ci lf ractons t ken undert e col rofs at om s i lt n a ao ia h o te

3 lw.Ke tc v Gr ham,473U. .1 9,1 (98 ) a nuy . a S 5 65 l 5 .
4 To pr vai unders cton 1983,a pl i tf m ustdem onsr t t athehass fer d a el ei an ir ta e h uf e 5 vi l ton ofrght pr t ct d by t e c ns iuton orf der ls at t ,ca s d by t econductofa per on o ai i s oe e h o tt i e a t ue u e h s

6 a tngu de c lrofsaclw.Crmptnv Gats 947F.d 1 1 ,1 20(tCi.1 91. ci n r oo tt a u o . e, 2 4 8 4 9b r 9 )
7 8 CountOne I countone,pl i tf cli s a vi l ton oft e Ei ht Am endm ent as aul and sander n an if a m o ai h gh ,s t l

9 wh ndee da tCorecinal rc r( / )J Al nsae publcyi teprsnc ofohe imaes e fn n r to Ofie C O . l ttd il n h ee e t rn t e
10 t atpli tf w as a s ïch and a r t Pl i tf cont ndst att e def ndantt ok t es actonsbecaus h a n ir nt a . an ir e hh e o he i e 11 pl i tf tw r t hi up' f ranot eri ci ent an ir t o e m 'o h nd . 12 Alegatonst atprs n om cil caled a prs nera çsnich' i t epr s nceofot er lih io as l io ' t 'n h e c h

1 i m at sar s fi intt s at a cli ofdclber t i dir r nce t an i m at ' s f t . See 3 n e e u lce o t c a m i a e n fc e o n es a ey
1 Val ndi gham v.Boir u z866F.d 1 3 ,1 3 (tCi.9 9 .Howe e,h cam ma b rjce 4 an 2 1 4 1 9 9h r1 8 ) v r te li y e ee td v o q e,

15 i ot eri m at shavenotact aly t ken r t lat r sepsagai s t e lbel d i m at . M or an v. fh n e ula e ai o y t nth a e n e g

1 Mac on l 41F.d 1 91 1 9 -4( 'Ci.1 94 . 6 D at i 3 2 , 2 3 9 9b r 9 )
1 7 H e e pl i tf c m pl i s t a t e de e da tsa ton c us d ga g m e be i m a e t r , an ir o an h t h f n n ' c i a e n m r n ts o 1 w a tt fg tpl i tf H e doe nots a e he ha be n as a le ,b tt a t e e i a t r a ofh r . Th s 8 n o h a n il l s tt s e s u td u h t h r s h e t a m i 1 cou ts a e a c a m u de t eEi ht A m t dm e tf r d lbe at i dil r nc t t ei nat ' s f t . 9 n tt s li n r h g h m n o e i r e n fb e e o h m e s a e y
20 Addii naly,pl i tf- t t sa cli f rr t laton. to l an ilsa e am o eai i 21 Alegatonsofr t la i n agai s a prs ner' Fis Am endm entrght t speech ort li e a ito n t io s r t i so o

2 peii n t egov r m e tma s p o tas ci n 1 3 cam .Riz v. 2 tto h e n n y u p r e to 98 li z o Dawso ,778 F.d 527 53 ( t n 2 , 2 9b 2 Ci.l ) s eas Val n igha ,86 F. d a 11 5.To e tbls aprm afci c s ,plitf mus 3 r 985 . e lo a d n m 6 2 t 3 , sa ih i a e a e an if t
24 alege and s ow t atdef ndant act d t r t lat f rhi exer i e ofa pr t ct d actviy,a d l h h e s e o cai e o s cs oe e it n

25 def n a t 'a ton d d no s r e a lgii a epe ol gi a pur os . Se Bar e tv Ce t ni 31 F. d e d n s c i s i t e v e tm t n o c l p e e n t . n o , 3
26 5

1 81 ,81 ( tCi.1 94) Pr t v Rowl nd,65F.d 80 ,8 7 ( t Ci.1 95 .Pli tf m a pr ce d 3 6 9b r 9 . a t . a , 3 2 0 91 r 9 ) an i y o e '
2 agai s def ndantJ.Alen on CountOne. nt e f 3 4 CountTw o Pl itf advies t e courtt athe hascert i m edi alcondii ns t atr quie s eci l a n if s h h an c to h e r p a

5 equi m ents ch asa wheel hai,a s r p f rhi f otdr p and a writhand br ce. I t i count p u c r ta o s o - o s/ a n hs ,

6 pl i tf a l ge t a h sm e i a e ui m e twasi p o e l co ts a e a d wihh l b de e da tR. an i le s h t i d c l q p n r m r p ry n i c t d n t e d y f n n
7 Eas aterdef ndantEastconduct d an i pr pery doc m ent d cel s ar h. He f rt eralegest at tt e e mol u e le c uh l h 8 Eas r f sed t confrm t att e medi alequi m entwasaut orzed by adoct r sor erand t att e t eu o hh c p hi o' d hh

9 e ui m en , ih t e e ce ton oft e w h e c a r hasnotbe n r t nz d t hi . q p tw t h x p i h e l h i, e eu e o m
1 0 A prs ner scl i ofi adequat m edi alcar doesnotcons iut cr eland unusual io ' a m n e c e tt e u

11 punihm e tunl s t e r it e t e trs st t e lve ofi e i e a e i dil r nc t s rousm e i a s n e s h n sr a m n ie o h e l t l r t n f- e e o e i db e dc l

1 ne ds' Ese l v Gambl , U. . 1 6 ( 9 6) Thei ei e aei dfe e c 'sa d r ivole 2 e . tle . ' e 429 S 97, 0 1 7 . ç l r t n ir r n e' tn a d n v s db

1 a obe tvea das be tvep o g.Fis,teal ge de rvainmus b ,i obe tvetr s 3 n jcï n u jci r n rt h l d p ï to e t e n jci em , 1 çufiinl srous'Far e v Brnnan,511U..8 5,83 ( 99 )(iig Wis nv. tr 5 1U,. 4 t fce ty ei . m r . e s ' S 2 4 1 4 ctn lo Seie , 0 S
1 294, 8 ( 9 1 ) Se o d,t ep io ofiil ta twih at um ce tyc la l sa eofri dp 5 29 1 9 ). c n h rs n lca mus c t t in l up b e t t nn ' s '
1 whi h ent ismor t an m er neglgence,butl s t an conductunderaken f rt ever pur os of 6 c al eh e i es h t oh y pe 1 causng hann. Far erv.Brennan,51l U . .at837. A prs n ofk i ldoesnotacti a delber t l 7 i m S io l a n i aey l8 i dir r ntm annerunl s t e oti i ltknow sofand dir gar san exces i erik t i m at healh or n fe e e s h lc a t se d sv s o n e t 19 s f t .'f .Prson ofi i l ar delber t l i dir r ntt a prs ner' s rousm edi alneedsw hen t ey ae y' # i fca s e i a e y n fe e o io s e i c h 20 çi t r er w ih teat entonce pr s rbed.' Est le v.Gambl ,429 U . .at104- 5. tn e f e t r m eci ' el e S 0

21
22 i dil r nce. n fb e

He e, antf s a e a c a m f rr l fa ans de e da tR . s o a c a m ofdei e a e r pl i if t t s l i o e i g i t f n n Ea t n l i e l rt b

23

Coun Th e t re

2 4
26

l t i cai f rr lelplitf al ge a Eiht Ame dmc tvi lton o deie ae n h s l m o eif an ir l s n g h e n n o ai f l r t b

25 i dir r ncecont ndi g t atbe hascompl i ed çt r ugh al t epr per c annel' t hi cas wor er, n fe e enh a n ih o lh o h s' o s e k
6

1 t e A s it ntW ar en and W ar e ofLovel ck prion and t Diect r Skol i t athi lf i i danger h ss a d dn o s oro nk h s ie s n 2 dby 4 dir r ntgangs'and t e tw or s r ad t a f w prs ns'and t athe hasas ed f r an i t r t t t fe e ' h ç d pe o e io ' h ko n e sae 3 t ansf r butt att et ansf rhasbeen r f s d. r e, h hr e eu e 4 Pl i tF scl i i uncl araboutw ha orwho hasact d t caus t e gangst t r a en an i am s e t eo eh o he t

5 hi ,buthenot st att e t r at and t e need t def nd hi s l fom t e gangs hasr s led i hi m e h h he s h oe m ef r h eut n s

6 bei g desi nat d a gang m em ber He f rt er alegestt ey bl m ed a l ton m e,'buthe i uncl arast n ge , uh l th a o ' s e o
7 w ho it ey' a e. lh ' r

8

Asdicus ed a ove i countone,t e prs n ofi i l and em pl yeesm ay be hel ss b n h io lc a s o d

9 res onsi l i t ey are delber t l i dil r ntt a s bs antalr s ofhann t an i m at . Thi count p be fh i a ey n fb e o u t i i k one s

1 wi ne dt bea e de t de ciemor ce ryters ofham orijr ta plitf fc s wh he 0 l e o m n d o s rb l e lal h ik r nu y h t an if a e , o
11 belevesi r s onsbl f rt atrs -t e St ey' i t i cl i and whatçt ey' have done t ca s t e i s e p i e o h ik h çh ' n h s am eh ' o ueh
1 rik ofhann. 2s 1 3 CountFour

1 4

I t i cam f rr l fpli tf de c iesev nt whih r s le i plitf bengS r b e fom n h s li o e i l an if s rb e e s c e u td n an if i ç a b d r g

1 b hn a dtrwnoutofgiqwh ec arbyd fn a tD. tes n,who,aon wihote 5 e id n h o hs e lh i ee d n Patro l g t hr

1 c re tona omceste r srie hi ontegr un usnge cesvefrea dc usn ij r . 6 or ci l r h n e tan d m h o d i x si o c n a ig nu y
17 W hen aprs n ofi i lst ndsaccus d ofusi g exces i ephysi alf r e i vi l ton oft e cr el io lc a a e n sv c o c n o ai hu 18 and unus alpunihm entcl us oft e Ei ht A m endm ent t e ques i n t r son whet erf r e w as u s ae h gh ,h to u n h oc 19 appled i a good-aih efbrtt m ai t i orres or dici lne,orm alci usy and s ditcaly f rt e in f t l o n an t e s pi io l a si l o h

20 p r os ofca sng h nn.Hud onv. c ila ,5 3U. .1 7 ( 9 2)( ii g Whily v Al e s 47 up e ui a s M M lin 0 S , 1 9 ctn te . b r , 5 21 U. .3l ,320- 1( 98 ) .l de e rii gwh t e t eus off r ewa wa t n a d un c e s r ,ti S2 2 1 6 ) n t rnnn e h r h e o c s n o n n c s a y i s
22 pr pe t consderf ct r s ch ast e need f rapplcaton off r e,t e r l tons i bet een t eneed o ro i a os u h o ii o c h ea i hp w h

23 a d t e a oun off r e us d t e t r a r a ona l pe c i e by t e r s o sbl oK ci l,a d a y n h m t o c e , h h e t e s b y r ev d h e p n i e as n n
24 efbr smade t t m pert e s vert oft e f r ef lr s ons . H udson,503 U. .at7. The e t ntofa lt oe h e iy h o c u e p e S xe

25 prs ne' ij r i as afcorta ma s gg s wh te teus offr ec ul plusbl ha ebe n io rs nu y s lo a t h t y u e t eh r h e oc o d a i y v e
26
7

l tough ne esayi apatc lrst ain.1 .Alhoug tea snc ofsro sijr i rlv ntt h t c sr n riua iu to d t h h b e e eiu nuy s ee a o
2 t e Ei h h Am e dm e ti quiy,i i no de e m i a ï e.f . Th tï , e ofe c s i e ph sc lf r e h gt n n n r t s t t r n tv # a s us x e sv y i a o c 3 a ans a prs ne m a co s iut c ue a d un s a pun s m e te e t ough t e prs ne doe not g i t io r y n tt e r l n u u l i h n v n h h io r s

4 s fe s ro sij r.1 . 9.TheEiht Ame dme tspr hiiino cue a dunus a punsme t urr eiu nu y d at g h n n ' o bto n r l n u l ih ns
5 ne e s rl ex l de f om c nsiuto al e ogn ton d m i i u us s ofph sc lt r e. #.a 9- 0. c s a i c u s r o tt i n r c ii e n m s e y y ia b c / t 1
6 H er pl i tf alegest athe compled w ih ever t i g tt ey t l m e t do,'butdes ie e an ir l h i t y h n ih o d o' pt

7 h scoo e a i n t e de e da tpu hi kne i pl i tF sba k,gr b e hi l g , l g t e up a a n t i p r to h f n n t s e n a n i c a b d s e s puli h m n g is

8 hsbutoc s a1c usn plitf t s fe pai a d ij l t hi f c a d l . Pli ifalge t a i t k , l a ig an if o u f r n n n u' o s a e n i am f l s h t y p e
9 be a s ofhi p ysc ld s b l y t e l v l f r e wasu ne e s r a d e ce sve cu e s h i a i a ii h e e of o c t n c s a y n x si .
10
11 1 1 1.

Pl i tf hass at d a cli ofexces i e f r eagai s de endantPater on. an ir te am sv o c nt f ts
Concl si n uo

1 2

Plitf s al pemitdt pr c e if r apau e i wiho tp e a igafln fe anir h lbe r te o o e d n o m p rs t u rp yn i g e . i

13 Hi varousmotons s al be de i d att i tm e.He s al bepennit d t pr ceed as t count one, si i hl ne hs i hl te o o o s 14 t o,and f urast t e def ndant s ecii aly named i t os count and i entfed as def ndant ,e. . w o oh e s p fc l nh e s d ii e sg

1 c untone -de e d ntJ Al n,c un t o -de e da tR.Ea t c un f ur-de e da tD.Pa t r on. 5o fn a . l o t w e fn n s; o t o fn n te s

1 Cou ttres al dimis dwihoutprjdiea dwihla et a e di c nfr a cewihti 6 n h e h lbe s se t eu c n t e v o m n n o o m n t hs
17 or e . dr

1 8

I I THEREFORE ORDERED t a Pl itf' Ap lc to t Pr c e i For a TS h t a n ils p i a i n o o e d n m

1 Pa pe i ( oc e #5)i GRANTED.Plitf s al berquie t pa a iiil rilfl gfe 9 u rs d k t s anif h lnot e r d o y n nta pa ta i e . n
20 How e e ,e e i t i a ton i dim is d,t e S I tl g f e mus sil pa d pur ua tt 28 U . . . v r v n f h s c i s s s e h I ii e n t tl be i sno SC

21 j l 1 ()2) 9 5b ( .
22 I I FUR T H E R O R D E R ED t atpl i tf i per it d t mai t i t i acton t TS h a n ir s m te o n a n h s i o

23 con l son w ih u t e n c s i ofpr pa m e tofa y a dii nal e sorc s sort e gi i g ofs c rt cu i t o t h e e st y ey n n d to f e ot h vn e u iy

24 teeor ThsOrergz tngfor apau e i satssalnotc tndt teis a ceofs b oen sa h rf . i d rn i m p rs t u h l xc o h su n up a t
25 gove nm entexpens . r e

26
8

1

I I FURTHER ORDERED ta, s a tt 28U. . . l l b)2) teNe a a TS h tpuru n o SC â 9 5( ( ,h v d

2 D epa t entofCor ectonss al pay t t e Clr oft e U nied St t sD iti tCour ,D iti tof rm ri hl o h ek h t a e src t s rc

3 Ne a a, ofteprc digmont' de ost t PlitY sa c un (nmae#9 3 7 ,i temo ts v d 20% h e e n h s p is o an i c o t i t 6 3 ) n h nh
4 t a t ea co nte c e s$1 .0,u tlhef l$35 Gl g f eha be npad f rt i a ton.Thece k h t h c u x e d 00 n it ul 0 i e s e i o h s c i n lr
5 oft e Cour s al s nd a copy oft i or ert t e Fi anceD i ii n oft e Cl r ' O fk e. The cl r h l h le hs d o h n v so h ek s l ek

6 s al alo s nd a copy oft i or ert t e atenton oft e Chi fofI nat Ser i esf rt eN evada hls e hs d o h t i h e m e vc o h 7 Deparm entofCor ectons,P. .Box 7011,Ca s n Ciy,N V 89702. t ri O ro t 8 IT IS FURTH E R O R D ER ED t epl i tt s moton t am enc/ or ectcom pl i t h a n ir io lc r an

9 (oc e #9 i g ant d. d kt )s r e
1 0 IT IS FUR TH E R O R D E R ED t atcountone oft e am ended com pl its al pr ceed h h an h l o agai stdef ndantcor ectonalom cer J.Alen on a cl i ofdelber t i dir r nce and a cl i of n e ri l am i a e n fe e am 1 r t laton,countt o s al pr ceed agai s def ndantcorectonalofi er R.Easton a cl i ofdenid 2 eai i w hlo nt e ri lc am e 13 m edialcar ,and countf urs al pr ceed agai s def ndantcorr ctonalom cerD .Pater on on a c e o hl o nt e ei ts 1 cl i ofexces i e f r e. 4 am sv o c 15 IT IS FUR T H E R O R D E R ED t atcountt r e i dim is d w ih l ave t amend i h h e s s se te o n

16 conf r ance w ih t e i s r ctonspr vi ed i t i or er om t h n tu i o d n hs d . 17 IT IS FURTH ER O R D E R ED t atpl i tf s al Gl hi çSecond Am ended h an if h l e s '

18 Compl i t'wihi t it daysoft edat oft i or er. Faiur t amend w ilr s l i t e m ate a n ' t n h ry h e hs d l eo l cutn h tr 19 pr ceedl g ast t e count alow ed i t i or er o oh sl n hs d .

20
22 23
24

I I FURTHER ORDERED ta alpe digmotons( oc es#4,7,8,1 ,1 ,a d TS htl n n i d kt 26n
DATED t i 3r day ofAugus , 2010. hs d t

21 1 )aeDENI D a dic se heen. 7r E s s u s d ri

D ' A T , D I TR I T JUD G E T 'S C
25

26 9