Mauwee, Sr. v. Palmer et al

Filing 9

ORDERED Clerk shall FILE the complaint. FURTHER ORD P's complaint is DISMISSED with prejudice for failure to state a claim for which relief may be granted. FURTHER ORD Clerk shall enter judgment accordingly and close this case. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

.

' q
.
. . t< . .
. , '' ' .w

e

Y

.

' . .
.

!
.
. . .

T
.

)

g

t$ r ' l'

l

.

'
2

2

'
Q.
.

,

?
4

. .'?

.

5

6
7

U N I ED STATES DISTRICT C O U R T T
8
9

D I TR IC T O F NEV A D A S

1 0

11 1 2

EUGEN E A.M AUW EE,S . R, *30 00 4 Pl itf, an if

1 vs 3. 1 J CK PALM ER, /al, 4A c.
1 5
16

De e d nt. fn a s

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
/

3: 0-v- 025 - CJRAM 1 c 0 0R -

ORDER

l 7
Mauwee, Sr. v. Palmer et al

Thi i aprs nercvi lgh sa ton fldpurua tt 42U. . .j 1 3.Thec t'now s s io i li t c i ie s n o S C 98 olt l
Doc. 9

l8 r viw st e com pl i t ee h an . 19 1 Screeni g St ndard . na

20

Purua tt t ePrs ne LiiainRcor Ac I LRAI fdealc ursmus ds isa s n o h io r tg to f m t P . e r o t t im s

21 prs ner scl i s ti t e alegaton ofpovcry i unt ue,-ori t e acton ti f i ol us orm alci us,' io ' a m , 'f h l i t s r - fh i ts rv o io ' 22 'f ist sat acl i onw hi hr iefm ay begr nt d,' Kseeksm one ar relefagai s adef ndantwho ta l o t e a m c ei a e 'or ' ty i nt e

23 i i m u efo s c rle ' 28 U. . .j 1 l e( ) A cai i lgal fi o o swhe i l c sa s m n r m u h eif ' S C 9 5( )2 . l m s e ly rv l u n ta k n
24 arpabl basseihe i lu,) i f c. ez c1 I li nl-#9 )U. .319 325 ( 98 ) Thecou tma . é e i t r n a (r n a tNitk ' n la s t S . . 1 9. ry
25 t e ef r .dim i s a cl i n as fi ol usu' c e i i bas d on an i di put bl m er tes I galt c r or h r oe s s an rv o hr ts e ns ay il s e hoy
26 wher t e f ct al cont ntons ar cl arl bas l s . 11 at 327.Thc crtcal i quiy i whet er a eh au ei c e l' e e s (. ii n r s h

1
Dockets.Justia.com

M

l c nsi tona c a m ,howe e i a tu l pl a e , a ar u bi l ga a d f c-a ba i . eJ'ccon o tm i l l i v r n r f ly e d d has n g a e e l n a t l s s Se t / u zs

2 v Arz na,88 F.d 6 9,6 0( tCi.1 89) . io 5 2 3 4 9h r 9 .
3 D im i s lofa compl i tf rf iur t sat acl i upon whi h relefm a be gr nt d i s sa an o al e o t e am c i y ac s

4 pr vi e f ri Fe e a Rul ofCi i Pr c du e 1 ( )6)an t eCou ta ple t es m esa d r unde o d d o n d rl e v l o e r 2b ( , d h r p is h a tn a d r 5 Se to 1 5 e ( )whe r viwi gt ea e ua yofac mpli t a e de c mpl i t Re iw unde ci n 91 ( )2 n e e n h dq c o an or m n d o an . v e r

6 Rul 1 ()6 i esntal ar lngo aqueto o lw.Se Cha pe v Lab r tr Cor .( Ameia, e 2b () s se ily ui n sin f a e p l . o a oy p f rc 7 232F.d 7l , 3 ( t Ci. 3 9 72 9 h r 2000) A c m pli tmus c nti m o et a at o m uli r ct ton oft e . o an t o an r h n t r ac e iai f h
8 el m ent ofa caus ofactoni'i m ustcont i f cm alalegatons s fici ntt tr i e a rghtt r lef e s e i 't an a li u i c o ta s i o e i

9 above t e s ecul tve l vel' Bel Atantc Col .v.Twom bl ,550 U . .544,l27 S.Ct 1955, 1965 h p a i e .' l l i p y S .

1 ( 007 .tf epl a i gmus c nt i s m ehi gmor ..ha .. sae e toff cst a m e ey c c tsa 0 2 ) t ' e dn -h t o an o t n e. n . t tm n a t h t r l r ae ta 11 s s ii n g f algal c g ia l rg to a to . f .nr viwi gac m pli t rt i sa da d,he u p co o j e ly o n z b e i h f c in ' J I e e n o an unde h s tn r t '
1 coul m ustacceptastuet e alegatonsoft ecom pl i ti ques i n, os ial l g.Co.v. 2 t rhli h an n to H p t B d RexH os ial pt

1 Tr s e s 425U. .738 740 ( 976) c nsr et epla i g i t elgh m os f vor bl t pli tf a d 3 u te, S, 1 , o tu h e d n n h i t t a a e o an if n 1 r s l caldou t i t epl itf sfvor Je knsI M c et e ,3 5U. . 1 42l( 969) 4 e o v 1 b s n h an if a . n i ) K ih n 9 S 41 , . 1.
15 Alegatons i a pr se com pl i t ar hel t I ss s rngent s andar s t an f r al li n o a n e d o e ti t d h om

1 pladngsdr te by lwye s SeeHu he v. p c 449 U. . 9 ( 980 , ne v Ke ner 40 U. . 6 ei at d a r . g s Stw , S 5. l ) Hai s . r , 4 S .

1 51 ,5 0- 1( 97 )+e c raml s ealoBalsr l''Pac'c Polc De ' 90lF.d6 6, (t 7 9 2 2 l 2 r u i ; e s iteu3. ila ie p t f , 2 9 699 9h
18 Ci.l .Al o pa-ofac m pli tGldbyaprs ne ma bedim is ds as ontn r 990) l r l t o an e io r y s s e u p e howe e ,ft e v ri h
19 prs ner' cl i sl ck an a guabl basi eiheri l u'cri f ct Thi i cl descl i s bas d en l gal io s a m a r e s t na , n a . sn u am e e

20 c ncusonst a a cuntna l ( . . li sa ans dc c d nt who a ci m t efom s i orcam sof o l i h t r e b e cg ca m g i t f n a s r m m r u t li

21 i fi g m e to alga i t r s whihceal doe note it. wcl c am sba e o f ncf l a m a n rn e n f e l n e e t c l ry s x s) as l as li s d n a iu f c l
22 algai ns(. . a tsi ordeuso a s e a i s .S eNetke 490U. . t3 7 28. e c/:M c e v l le to gg f n a tc l i n l c n ro ) e i . z S a 2 - , e .? K e e. s$ '

23 3 Bl c .93 F.d 7 5,7 8 ( t Ci.1 1 . ' o k 2 2 9 9 9 h r 99 ) .
2 4 To s san a a to u de s c i n l u ti n c in n r e to 983.apl i tf mus s o (1 t a t e c ndu t an if t h w ) h t h o c 25 c m pl i e ofwasc m m itd by a pe s n a tng unde c l rofsa e lw :a d ( )t a t e c nd c o an d o te ro ci r oo tt a n 2 h t h o u t
26 deprved t epl i tf ofaf der lcons iutona orst t t r rght'llxl'cl,. llt l.466F. d 676.689 i h a n if ca tt i l a u o y i .'-j li'''H llc ' s 3

1
.

>

1 ( tCi. ) 9h r 2006 .
2 l . I s antCom pl i t l nt an

3

Plitf, iic reac a Lov lc Coreto al ntr(tCC')hass e teStt anifwho sn ac rtd t co k rcin Ce e 'L ', u d h ae

4 o Ne ad ,heNc a aDe a t e to Core tons(t DO C' , f v at v d p rm n f r ci t N ' LCC' W ade J c Pam e , s ca e ) S r n a k l r As o it
5 W ar en Ron H alt ad and Ass ci t W ar en Robe tLeGr nd. Pl i tf cl i st athe i a s iiual d se o ae d r a a n if a m h s p rt

6 l ade and el erofNatve Am crcan reigi us actvii satLCC. He alegest e f low i g:an ofi er er d i i io i te l h ol n fc
7 confs a edan eagl t l n-asac e NatveAm e i anr lgi usartf ct t atw asi pl i tl spos es i n. ic t e ao rd i rc e i o ia - h n a n ir s so

8 W hen hi greva ces wer uli at l de i d,pl i tf s ughtt send t e s cr d cagl t l n hom e. sin e tm e y n e a n if o o h ae e ao
9 However he w asi f nncd on M a c 24,2010 t ati had been des r yed. Pl i tf ass rt vi l tons , no rh ht to a n if e s o a i

1 ofhi Fis ,Ei ht a d Foureent A m endm entrght . 0 s rt g h n th is 11 W hiepl i tf pur orst ass l acl i f rt ede rva i n ofhi Fis Am endm ent i ht l an if p t o e' a m o h p i to t s rt rg

1 t fee exer i e of r lgi n, t e gr vam en of pl i tf s compl i t i t at he was deprved of t e 2 or cs ei o h a a n if an s h i h
1 opponuniy t send hi confs at d pr pery hom e. I H udson n Pal er t e Unied St t s Supr m e 3 to s ic e o t n m ,h t ae e

1 Cour hcl t ati t ntonalde rvaton ofan i m at ' properyby prs n empl yeesdoesnotvi l t t e 4 t d h ne i pi i n es t io o o ae h l5 DuePr cessCl usc, ovi edt atadequat sat pos - eprvaton r m edi sar avaiabl .468U . . 7, o a pr d h e t e td i i e ee le S 51

1 5 3- 34, 0 S. t31 4. 2L. d.d39 ( 984) Ne a alw pr vi e f rcvia to sf rt ewr ng u 6 3 5 1 4 C . 9 8 E 2 3 1 . v d a o d s o i l c in o h o f l
17 deprva i n ofpr pe t by s a cof i i l .See NRS 4l . 31'N R S 41. 322. Pl i tf m a s ek r dr s i to o ry t t fc a s 0, 0 a n if y e e e s 18 i t e sat s scm ,buthccannots ei f der lcou: on t ccl i t att e sat de r vcd hi ofpropery n h t e yt u ne a t h am h h t e p i m t
19 wihout due pr ces of t e l w . Ther f r p pl i tf ' cl i s f r deprvaton of pr pery wil be t os ha e o e a n if s a m o ii otl

20 ds isdwihprj dic im se t eu c .
21 Pl i tf s t f rt no alegatons t at i plcat t e Fist Ei ht or Foureent a n if e s o h li h m i eh r. g h th 22 Am endm c t . Accor i gl -t osecl i sar dim iscd. ns dn y h am e s s
23 1 1 Concl si n 1. uo

24

I IS TH E R E FO R E O R D ER ED t att eCl r s al FILE t e compl i t( ocket#1 T h h ek h l h an d -

25 1 . )

26

I I FURTHER ORDERED t a pli tf- c mpli tsDI M I SED v'hpr j die TS h t an ifs o an i S S st cu c i

I

-

I

1

*

1 f rf iur t sat a cl i f rwhi h r lefm aybegr nt d. o a l e o t e am o c ei ae

I I FURTHER ORDERED ta teClr s al ntrudg e t c or igl a dcos TS h th ek h le ej m n a c dn y n l e
t i cas . hs e

D A TED t i 29t day of Novem ber hs h

2010.

D STA T - DI TR I T JUD G E SC

4