Banuelos v. Pinnacle Financial Corporation et al

Filing 28

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that the 3 Motion to Remand is DENIED. FURTH ORD that the 6 and 11 Motions to Dismiss are GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. All claims are dismissed except that for statutorily defective disclosure. FURTH ORD that the 19 Motion to Amend is DENIED. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 3/24/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - PM)

!

.

!
.

i

.

7

$
- - - .
. ... - . . . -

Fl ' LLo Lt s s 'i g o t

N

r yys st y
0 pc n F f c,

1

cvsgl o.b voc , ous k--.- t j vf R s î

2
3

P R ,?? 2 1 31
yy. cyj k . os , ysycjo yg:t y j ovij s y g sso gf

4 5

XP VT

6
7 8 RU BEN BAN UELO S,

UNI STATESDITRI COUéT TED S CT
DISTRICT O F N EV ADA

Pl ntf, ai if 3: 0- 00300-RCJl cvRAM
V S.

l1

PI NAC LE FI AN CI L CO RP.etal, N N A . Def endant s.
l3

O RD ER

Thi i a st s s andar f ecl ur cas i vi one pr t The Com pl nti a Gfy- xd or os e e nvol ng opery. ai s t si page M ERsconspiacy t com pl ntlstng t reen caus ofacton. The cas i notpartof r ype ai i i hit es i es

Cas No, 09- 0211 J i t e Dit i tofA rz a b a a selgi e f t a f r e 2: md9- AT n h s rc i on ut ppe r i bl or r ns e .
Pendi bef e t Cour i a m oton t r ng or he ts i o emand,t m otonst di i and a m oton t am end wo i o sm ss, i o
Banuelos v. Pinnacle Financial Corporation et al Doc. 28

t Compl n . Fort e r as gi n h ei t e Cou t ni s t m otonst r m a a d a e he ai t h e ons ve er n, h r de e he i o e nd n m nd
and gr s t m otonst di is i par. ant he i o sm s n t 1 . TH E PR O PERTY

2l

Cal A. ndRu Ba elsg eln Pi a eFia alCom.(s nna e' a ros a ben nu o av e der nn cl n nci ' pi cl ' ) $1 932pomis yn e s c e byad doftus ($ 't purha era pr erya 88, r jor ot, e urd ee r t $DOT' o c s e l op t t ) 1 4GeogeownDr,Col Sprng , 895 (heçpr ery'. DOT,Feb.1 2007,ECFNo. 781 r t . d i s NV 06 t s op t' ( ) , l l,Fis Amerc nTil Co. Ne ad (s rtAmeia Ne da'wa t tuse .( ei ) 2-) rt ia te of v a CFis rc n va ' s he r te Se d.. )

.

25 Pl n ifde a t an Fis Ame ianTil I ur n e Co. ç rtAmcrca ', a ntf BAC aitf f uled, d rt rc te ns a c (t s Fi i n' as ge or )

Dockets.Justia.com

f

.

I HomeLoa Sevi ng,LP(' ', e an ieofd aul(ç ns r ci ç BAç' Gld otc ) ef t ç NOD'.@ OD, un 1 20 ' ) J e 9, 09, 2 ECFNo.1 2) Twoda Itr BAC s bsiutdTr teComsa tuse ( bsiuto J 2- . ys ae, u tt e use s r te.Su tt in, une
3 21 2009,ECF No.l 3) Tr t Cor no ie as ef Oct er1 2 ( tc of , 2- . usee ps tc d al or ob 3, 009. No ie

4 Tr tesSal (% OS',Sep. 2 ECFNo.1 5 .I noie asco s efrAprl9 use ' e 1 ' t23, 009, ) 2-) t tc d e nd al o i,
5 201 ( c dNOS,M a . ,20I ECFNo.1 6) 0. Se on r 20 0, 2- .
6 FistAm eri Gl t N O D on June 19,2009. Fis Am eri N evada wass ilt r can ed he rt can tl he

7 t us ee att s tm e. I i notcl t t e wer t s r t hi i ts ear hat hes e he ame entt and even i hey wer Fis iy, rt e, r t

8 A merc n a par ty fl d t e N OD a t e die ton ofBA C, hi h di notye own t i a p en l ie h t h rc i w c d t he
9 benefci i er i t l even i M ERS had t abiiy t tansf t l fom Pi i al nt est n he oan f he lt o r er he oan r nnacl t eo BAC as i l erpum ored t do on Jul 2,2009. Ther i queston off tast st ut iy t at t o y es i ac o at or l Il def i f ecl ur cctve or os e. l II 2 . I3 A NALYSI S The af r atve cl m s f lf r fim i ai ai or easonsgi i ot s t i y i i cas N o ven n her ubsantvel dentcal es.

1 nua e a e i t sc s i t tr g d. Pl i ifha no r pon s s a i el t t 4 nc s pp ar n hi a e n ha e ar a ntf s t es ded ub t ntv y o he
l5 motonst dim i buthasf ed m em or i o s ss il andum sspecii l r usi t do s fcaly ef ng o o.

l 6

Pli ifalomove t r dfrlc of urs ci Def da sr e ba e on antf s s o eman o a k j iditon. en nt emov d s d

I b hfdea quetona dieriyj iditon.Pl ntfsha en al dt ta Dee ans 7 ot e rl si nd v st urs ci ai if v ot l ege ha ny fnd t
l8 ar N evada cii e tzensexceptAdrana Her i nandez and Fis Am èri Nevada. M s.Her rt can nandez i s

1 fa d ln l j n d becaus she i si pl aleged t btanem pl eofoneoft e Def ndant 9 ru ue t oie , y e s m y l o oyt h e
20 com pani and i notpl bl i es s ausi y ndependenty labl on any cl m her n. Fis A m ercan l i e ai ei rt i 2 l N evada i alo notpl bl aleged t have com m it any w r s s ausi y l o ted ongdoi Fis A m ercan ng. r t i 22 appar l Gl t N O D a t diecton oft w r entt butFis A m ercan N evada enty ed he t he r i he ong iy, rt i 23 appear t be a s at entt I f ,Fis A mercan N evada wast orgi tusee,and i so epar e iy. n act r t i he i nal r t t

I

24 woul ha e be pr erf Fis Am e i anN ev da t ha e Gl d t e N O D. N e , t a oun i d v en op or r t rc a o v e h ' he m t n xt

25 c to ry i a oxi t y$1 0 b e onteap oxi t vaueoftes j c pr ery. onrves s ppr mael 90,00, asd h pr mae l h ube t op t
Pa 2 of 3 ge

:

.

i J
(

.

'

1 Ad ton l Pl n ifr ue t c dii aly, aitf eq ss ompe a o y da ge i e e sof$1 00 te esaut y ns t r ma s n xc s 0, 0, rbl tt or
2 damages bas on l s pl t r ed os es us he educton i val oft pr i n ue he opert si pur y nce cbase,punii tve

E

3 dama s a d al n y' fe a co t.Thea nt pryed f coul e i t al r$75, ge , n tor e s e s nd ss mou s a or d asl ot ove y 000
i

i
i E
E '

4

i t cl m swer vald. f he ai e i

Th ei t rf edi st j iditonunde 28U. C.j1 2,a te er s heeor veriy urs ci r S. 33 nd h

5 Cour n e nota esf er qu si j iditonund 91 . t ed ddrs ed al e ton urs ci er 331
6

l famendmen we egr t da r qu se , ta new cl m underx Rs s ton 649. 0 t r an e s e e td le ai ec i 37

7 w oul depend di d sposii y on t det m i i ofan i i f alcl m under 15 U . C. tvel he er naton dentcal eder ai S.

: E
!
!

8 j I 2a woul ter or s por fd al e tonj iditon, swel, toutt Coute n 69 nd d h ef e up t e er qu si urs ci a lwih he r ve 9 e nigDefn t'c t tonta fdeal si urs ci i s xami n e dans oneni h t e r quetonj iditon s uppore b s doncl ms td a e ai
1 ofTI an RESPA vi a i pl d un rva i s o h ca e ofa ton. As t t m e isoft 0 LA d ol tons e de rou t er us s c i o he rt he
11 put i new cl m ,I atve ai ender and f ecl ng enttesar sm pl notdebtcolect sundert s or osi ii e i y l or he l2 st ut The pr at e. opos am cndmtntw oul notcur any defci es. ed d e i enci

E
'

!

1 3

CO NC LUSI ON

1 4
'

I I HEREBY ORDERED t tt M o i t Rema ( No,3 i DENI TS ha he ton o nd ECF )s ED.

I 5
'

I I FURTHER ORDERED ta teM oi st Dimis( Nos 6,11 ae TS h t h ton o s s ECF . ) r

16 GRA NTED i par and D EN I i par. A l cl m sar di is exceptt f st ut l n t ED n t I ai e sm s ed hat or at oriy I7 def tve f ecl ur ec i or os e.

'
:

! I

l 8
1 9

I I FURTHER ORDERED ta teM oi t Ame ( No.l i DENI TS h t h ton o nd ECF 9) s ED.
I I SO O RD ERED . T S .
'

20 D at t s 24t day ofM ar 2011. ed hi h ch,
21

22

R

- C.J ES RT ON
'

i
23
!

Unie ttsDiti J dge t ae srct u
24 25

: i
I

:

(

Page 3 of 3