Hutchins v. Nevada NDOC et al

Filing 5

ORDER GRANTING 1 Motion/Application for Leave to Proceed in forma pauperis. FURTHER ORD NDOC shall pay clerk from inmate account. Clerk shall sent copy to NDOC Inmate Services. ( Sent 9/17/2010 ) FURTHER ORD even if this action is dismissed the full filing fee is due. FURTHER ORD Clerk shall FILE the complaint. FURTHER ORD that all claims against Nevada Department of Corrections (NDOC), NDOC Offender Management Division (OMD), Ely State Prison, Northern Nevada Correctional Center, Nevada St ate Prison, and Jeff Froschauer are DISMISSED with prejudice. These Ds are DISMISSED from this action. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that P's Eighth Amendment claims against Ds Howard Skolnik, James Baca, E.K. McDaniel, Debra Brooks, Pete Gibson, Noal, and Jim Benedetti may proceed. FURTHER ORD Clerk shall serve AG with this Order, attached mediation forms, and complaint. ( E-service performed 9/17/2010. ) AG shall advise by 10/8/2010 re acceptance of service. If service accepted then answer/respo nse due 30 days from notice of acceptance. FURTHER ORD parties SHALL DETACH, COMPLETE, AND FILE attached mediation form by 10/17/2010. FURTHER ORD henceforth P shall serve Ds documents submitted, with certificate of mailing. Signed by Judge Larry R. Hicks on 10/15/2010. ( Attachments: # 1 Complaint )(Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

,--

FL D IE ENTE E a:

u coyg a so w p (r )ç tûls bp J E ûFI g j lt z / 1 s u io N én

ït t /)tt t s k x ..i i o

y,e kt % L... a 6ö % % - % f 5 m
ya

jjj ut t jj jy; ,
6 *
ayII,sy laéoy y jy yC O jya; DSH T sçEy y yI F x

W Y GOCC
M S I N t be OI l r m

Dpr 2Uy

VM YED STATES DI TR I T COURT SC

DI TR I T OF NEVADA SC

'flt s i.-o -tcm ï t
v s
.

êx , vi
Pli tf, an if

)
) ) ) )

. s CASE NO- v.5 . zoc / z y y ( obes pple byt eClr ) T u id h ek

tW t de tt oc.u .t c re b td E%? G . .:tY kf f b= , % ? s s hk t
hm h - è lt X KqC, t . . . R ,

) ) )
) )

CI LRI HTSCOMP AI T WG LN
PURSUANT TO

)

4 U... 18 2 SC b 93

t-xt sjn'b .v-xk. . - x- fçth ' tb . . s ,) j r f anuévt 'Af; Itkû .'..Gï .ds ' a n cf, & s G .. w = -' ,.6 b
D e e da ts . f n n t) )
-

A. JURI D I TI N SCO
Hutchins v. Nevada NDOC et al

1 T icmpanalgshth cvlihsoPani,'es s ï o ) hso litl etate iir t f litftq o 1 e g ft
Doc. 5 Att. 1

$% ' .

t lntPlitf sna e pi anif m )

woretrist h psnyed a e l se

. . $- . S-

-

,e wr e

vi l t d b t e a tonsoft ebe o n m ed i di i u l whih we e die t d a ans o ae y h c i h lw a n v d a s c r r ce g i t

Patftl.ktt.F: #; t . ., .tt ..n wrnwn dt lniat t - ' .% %. . ? o u oo ig as if ,ï #. 5 % e
(nsiuin/iywheeviltono c re ) i ttto ct r oai c u rd ( o nt1) Cu I

â btq -c.hïö . b 't l
( on 1 C u t)

,n ad

t oun 11 c t 1)

.

Dockets.Justia.com

t

hw

M akea c py o t i pa et pr vi et e beo o f h s g o a d h lw
.

i f nnal ni youar na i gmo et anhve()defndant n o to f e mn r h Se s
' .

kx o c p o a ov ' l x1

2 Dee d nt Holcf 8koni ) fn a o-. a ik rsde atcg x t c'r k, , î:'e' e i s o c. zs )v ' z . b , ( 1n meo frtd fn a t 1 1 a f is ee d n) (d rs i t s d fn a t a d es fi t ee d n ) r a d i e pl y d a b ier n z tw K lôc n s m o e s r h k l ll .n i defndn ti s e i hi/ e s e n s u d n sh r ( ee d ntsposto a dtte i a y) d fn a ' iin n il,f n < idvd a ' ot il a a i .( h c o eo b t ) E pan h w ti d fn a t s n iiu l . f a c p ct C e k n r oh . x li o hs ee d n wa Kk y

wtn cig unde c lrofIw :' . r oo a
1

'

.

'

1,
'

3 Deedn 'S/ J 'oftr!dee da t rs e a ) fn atJt na e cis fn n) ei s t d (I1CmI ' 1r v m 1
'

(ddrs i frtdee da t a e s f ls fn n)
. .

.

adsm oea (defendant'sposiionandttl,ianyl . senatsudnuhr nieyyds nidfdniseil e e w t ie f
X idvd a % o ca cp ct.( h c o eo b t) Ex li h w tid fn atwm n iiu l m il a ai C ek n r ol . pan o ls ee dn s y l l
. '

a tn ci g

ldcool: meorfw rl a
,

-.
(ddrs i frtdee d nt a es f ls fn a ) .

4 Dee da tE. . F1 hcnll ) fn n V c ' k rsd sa eie t ( 1na eoffrtdefnda t 11 m is e n )

a die pe e a n s m ly d s
a tug Cj
!

.Thsd fn n tise i hshr i ee d n s ud n i/e

( ee d n ' p sto a dtt ,fa y d fn n ts o i n n ie i n l i l X idvdml * ofiilc pa iy.( he ko eo * t9.Ex li ho ti dee da twa n iit % lca a ct C c n r 1 p an w hs fn n s
u de c lreflw : n r oo a

5)Dee da t h(A, Rrh k& fn n ,r' an t Ix rsde a ei s t ( 1n meo irt ee d n) 1 1 a f s d fn a t
a di e pl y d a n s m oe s

(d rs i trtd fn a t a de s f is ee d n )

.

.n i de e d n i s e i hi/ e s f n a t s u d n sh r

( ee dn tspo iina dtte,fa yl d fn n ' sto n il i n ' idiiu ! ' ofk ilca a iy.( he koneorb t) Expli how t i dee da twa K n vd a K t a p ct C c oh . an hs fn n s
a tng ci u de c lrofIw : n r oo a
a

x

'

up u mes pl ' /e aopv's pe r - D lr .
.

, .

' j k j r

.

(l jk yj !j :i jr j

'

j , ,

, , .

j j j

, , b

1,! ! j: . :, 'q 1j j; 4q 1

z

g

'a l

&a, L

U . .C . . C C

.

o

j :

.

tj
. .

.. , , jj c .

O

's S

ws

-

tj eed n J11n oleffrt à,1at) rsds t aD fn at (b1 at Tf .ben-nt eie a k n ame m .dee ds is f
a d i e pl y d a n s m oe s ' y

(d rs iGrtd fn n t a d es f s ee d n)

,

.n i dee da ti s e i hi/ e s f n n s u d n sh r

(efnda tsposto a dtte i a yl d e n ' iin n il,f n S idiiua % ofiilcpaiy.( hek o eo boh .Ex li how t i d fnd ntwa n vd ) lca a ct C c n r t) p an hs ee a s
a tng ci un e cooroflw : dr l a

7 J rsit ni iv k dp ru n t 2 U.. . 1 4 ()3 a d4 U.. . 1 8 .I y uwih ) uidci s n o e u s a to 8 SC j 3 3 .( ) n 2 SC 9 9 3 f o s o t a srj rs itonu de difrn o a diina saue ,ls te beo . o setu idci n r fee t r d to l ttts itb m lw
l '
' N

'

'

'

n
.

A

B .NA'' R E O F TH E CA SE I U

1 )

Bre l sat t eba kgrundofyot c s . ify t e h c o l ae r
f '
.

'
'
'

'

'

'
%

.

.

o.
.

.
.

f '
' ' '

,.
j

. x
.

@

dcIkr c ltif rn- . bL ..lt me lclocrî f oktin; l' ccc i l nlfc çt / b t e't .'i ol. n l l tc s q.ïh d c . rt i x. sq
'
'

* 1

m

'

A

l e

'#P

!

f. !

.

. .

.

C.CAUSE OF ACTI N O
3

cotl ' I xr

n eolwn c irh hs en ia dUt.l'#' Gfht Avh nimeï fl ig ili a abe vo t : nv t. s q h vt o vg le ' aF e R ft Qmk U sck c k owxC*uuthne ul soslL ntAm c t klv t b s- u : c - r . io s z kfs n
f z z uc r i wt 'r e a r z k z $T -. .z t a c t .t : . y Sf s ' . r t =v c = 7. .iQ. SL'%
Su pori gFa t : l cudealfc yo c nsde i po tnt Stt t efc sce ry, p tn c s En l 1 a t u o i r m ra . a e h a t la l
i you own w o ds a d wihou cii g l ga a t ort ora gum e t Be s e y u nr r , n t t tn e l u h iy r n. mo

deciee a tywh teahs e i cd fnd n ( yna e)di t volt you rghtl srb x cl a c p ci ee a t b m d o i ae r i s.

( % eZelkk hïs ss foé Gmkx esma tk %G R edmti 4 ) w : kss t uu ï f .' t? a me q o
tsàt1 it f -s t ow C oetfod olosLktp mf hv tn t es ' v . = tc- k x i - 0-u t j o à uc : d . v
. .
-

hq s t . xu - v c t k x q -d At c - u ït l t é Bu t u eodauis Ifwï g f f -..ifst ' oz i ac h lo a s p - ï' uk- h , - . o l rx e tl B tl s.S. t sdsy kfa c G k aou ,bsbt Ek ok. L. m cblni. lGb

bs k qe sksfjxlne t tm . -tïk- j i
-

a-

ts

' 'f Ls ôb tm

4 E s o b ocyt m eo ? k -t = f fp th ït k tRd t t ïï. N o x o l o v ao tl wktvs Clos- é h tc ?t4 v&k t è t wv ttd i w fv l o tl s tq i s

t lt l î s tïy s E wï - om kts qts tîz m A m ï ozh kw vt k - s t v t .' f q tw o G toz bq-lu dsîècfeïv 'odt feztf t f uf Esf otx tp -. l -- t L # xs - ' s -a o c. o *. dx m lt téa' l Vt scft ui t i tk vbq bz. a xek s e -sm z u r -c ba s k w tws a aoao AE c s. A : b .- t aé. c t o
I E tt.l. . - t & C.
'

At b h s lctl hlé dwts ç os gufpsk si d bq B: l s ts s at c s G
cz . r t ' j yc
-

r

a

c ' ç at . m

' $L 2 e a j i s n j s - y4 uR . u t -xks ue Lu ' atm c k tuttz ltG/i T- f z t wBoob t ot d t k - m z s t c o om z qz g ' G. ct 4s u tt t d io s t o sf ' ' ï o t d
Az oi W G tknt kï'u 'o ôc- oc tt at î s c: -

4

*

.

'

. .

)uq s p .y .

&

wtqb at s iïïhï ? > kf4 k tt t yhf. f ? m - lxïvf t ï . t tm t t tt t
t ï is At E s ? f2: tle kz tt E yï qtûct tk ï ' t tt v vx v

f sk tîï kt t t ïfo b t f lf tom s A- ùs i tm t - b .s x o t -i . b ö/tk sf /
K è ' C:fE J ' ïAtfE . Lk A wï d i's u f' % I : / L Sï #? â a t cv la tE k

k iool szo tt u de ttk e ftt esï i ftk l te v y o - o fq ' s t t Eï dtv k f b oo, o q ftq e s

1 Tx Vsc kbsz Jt s ff o t? ï 4 ïsft, 3 .J a o b t jf . q x t öv + v
.
' .

kt ïvh?.Lut k mVt. 1G.Atttwfx/NN ïb un Yt6 d lW kotkf fita tbjs. b 4w tq 4 tû ttt' f s . t k/
Q iJ% tt:+ t ?fttf ïf t fG Ey sz f , t et? td o J p q k

Roct Ttktsgozt:d %o Rq4 t s-hdo t x 't lt f tj ax t?k is t t %kG L t v si it t teN x à s ï tftk t 't ah j l fkW t tl' x x G - s ooi eqf o . <

tt Gw ' A Aï vt Ti wï dittktt ttk î q b é h v ïk t t: t i s yta kwî ï G ùkooy ts 'xtct zt kvbts At -4 d J -o : wg ' st kï$4' % % & wvq oz k ozotj t i h v 6t . : f t t' k G

( WGvsk f G:ztt fï o ïkf y é U to i t s o to t s t u

L jtCod: t yo. t o l a. k w-ç i kcïwl ' à t ï c î % vv l e s : ' iip i +o ï j u yo ': ).. bv k îls yjj ssyyyq u y .- . ïio xooEïo j s o mo -. .. -çt i h wm y ?y t y î î q.< L twlktzkBl.stk é f y G kktyï. f tSs Gx ot jut t t l t to l t
-

j

-

-

>t bkkG ,
.

-

w t.t t
.

.

.

c t ,L ttn -, k k k -

Tk1 9 è G - L- G G V A

Bf a 1a m /

ô ktt om Y . Bû

or j

ouk Yt.t % ' Tk

kGo v lkî ï % btt e 'L. e % :

' ,

y-zs (j a
l ö t kf- %:' l d tk ' %up p G ' Vïokz h f ' x u: Y t k

tt . dtatoif tzùfktut y tneots: ob :eu lbykutêcom ss Jt s çol :s eï b le o u pss t -s o.
-

dsislosotk çEïé ?G.j m o ,tol ïtyky u yot eey f sj-q t t ss% yy ,y u t tu b fy # a . s kl s. oa
î û

to z

,

li n V ttt.e 4o. kqA' z . us z os
.

k u z c it hk a k5 t : # -.l oebt ï . : . t . td jo t lk uk j i k

fzk. t

slnkk (42.kzs-tc-..yuhti ïïat. V:-tev,ù:. ttjtv f .h ;co tt- . b ft fzk f . t f t u oz k t . f
l t s t ikw kk e f . t tit t t su w tt s Ak ta u k a tq
.

Afo-t utst ïtzr p , k +k y O 9otcttt&uùqftesf yuhjr qtîoqûo't, ôcoîxqes ua at 't:tbt/u4s e C x w s i ?s. utt q a - p a . sa f : lu o h
s4 uy sf ctfns t ùsb t u t -o ) o u
fto b k u- tofqq d g f q ït sk Rae R ti A 'g f tqt k z l t s

ë t 1o t . ? f q's. L>ot k-k s . 2 % t t kl - w ctu t o
C- zksd j, o
-

l ttittauetloktit at tukfpuf o 'tkecf ftqk s oa o .t b mlf zo. 'x Yt s j g t. .. F f e yk m t
.

sel oz tL aèk îud tt : kssoeu p u ï w t o' s k td z x q z tG e è t . t ûroeesat wt dtyt at tt tzb z h o- t ev i q ' ift s on '2k111 lwïlu tt f.sit f pzot I t j ' z q çc : l a x

L-b b t

tq oy

boto jtllc-f'sikwde ,,qctj?kb tssd uu ias jt x1.?t fw i k te itxt j ïxw tw1 . k s b3 k n 4 lq =
t' (.

Lt ,, .,0 l axl mkkt-.l f yo?s %(a? - t 2 k:8 ( . ,t t ct - z -t - à) Mö xtt i ïtk ft wn A.AAI- :-t> i t it t kf A xo VI i f . O s

r. (dds to,brf û- i toote-t î f t to t so sk4t
.

CJso o f tot. esw ttk odo tt aV i à a o t z -oc t tïa t m k t ky àu L ( o,twkz fyo cokîwtswwft u n
(. ï
.-

Mï ïif fuê CNï / Y Llïoll bt fi. o o oo t fCG l kt x x

tlldot ûjuko.ttabka kt : k o e na iIfke ooese t ss t otfk ylzg ù oof ù . aqo .oft l tu èx ï %
-

o 'ki cowïï ï o ot t k tc kskle, t. fo o hw o l c

Q u tïR zu tfttï st,s?f k ptçtp h g f i fs t--j st ez t t.tk aö lo , o a t t
t ff: ba o eï b ku ô- tkoê 6 ls - îâ z ko t m a b o s îl co :sto R : h . wï d.x h zto ïz b -o ko 2 a 'î t s i e , a
fz s lx. Rud t koatl t tat vm t kv io vg û kt s s . o o . l yh A I- stiotf o E e..t qs Yktlç ' zl fo fht z oofa t 'd ît'u l t j v îs t :k K wlvo z t aspfet tqô - i ht t' ,
.

t

C- kl o t skfta t i Aî k s o kt , ItkGqt/, o fx i i s te o ' o o çl ', C I . z tL / c: gft ' s fet ùf s foEca, iazq dvff h s t. i t u i l f k k k o -:tt öki %k4 E. .M ebenl j T-oô4t h t jt tïkt Jk-aq> G 'f v k Aj

t fhttl A.t tk ot ttobl uo x oefb s 8 t k t? é- t t kf ï kmk t to z

ï Alw ac sa( m ?G so : Acokfû .ôt LkA t ei 'c ay e o tl I
t L à. .m li evt 4+f .. : : P k 4fR$4 t t t lAo ls t o ot Lc oei ' A'Gd ftt dhe 1 ftf U. j m td j t e: fl tti ù

R t f @p- ltt c / xq

(u- ï l&

.
'

.

'
'

j .y4 q' j
.

lt k

t o,pttti / m buf ï ,ax q-t o ft l tk? w - lc tc 'h fa j i él lî - d & l :fet %t fck Aud h fé l tt lki us i . v - t t-- t tt o v t

kïa t e k5 Lf kk èkos ww éz ws CofE c , çk o t u jf o ïs

lbe:ïk lAtt-ofgkvçes s. l'hk ,swfkmzo-)tk&yv uoxu swksftac a uzc koïj k s t t g Lk s ee s s s a e
fo) l s fftnf? f d tg.Ret qmu i h z f r 4ut t k ù ï t ogsa sè los %'. Akd dlat ?s t tk % ' t wa z t - f u f? k
q. . .. % t?

.

O l s

Nltt : lk mtéfhttk tf %ud (44G2 E4 ikoè lol e '' s e. s-sc s: d .$ $. 8 tik x
t rok oew tu wcot ît ss sqndf m s h tu ,Tu o h k :t - l o t o x ku -t C.krb f tt n tlt tï kseetlfe Lto ? tsoG , o zf ï ' kî. l s t co q ïk ö d tg
zld.tlv t xu fgè ho onc u s en t u: l lAz on tvï ô % / tï zs s à k kft p

ihe ? so mt ' ï-ts t d- t k t fak ' th ? b t / . f o . xu u t t st s s ou t

'uttctok oli ktAul Wb p w l llt Q dtet Yc r f-f n k u t q b stt l sk.
kf t t oe s? t ï 81 Awh o4m tnt p? % t ufisi lo e f a ts s x ' v tf k ù s C t siç ots v; x k on
'

-. 1 q st . h t kes î f Go ts ' tzoelo A : : s x, l slv ? ' t ï: t ss cfe . k ïs o
.

)

(vct clt ps ttïtk; lwskh t kt ct t.fonl-u , lf - -h - o k vk w vq a z, u t tl x i
CooAflustï gq éew. eo s'9.d A Co x k st> lluu txb. at , f h o vu x
.

ïfkosfq W gZ's f. ùtp4lwtu ïorîtat k x.fv d x a u tc q ff t f ? ts t 'a l iv tt sb sz n v rv kuaoes' B olk 4b foe b .. a av x s us l s hl t
sxkeost, t &,.nqô u fM - . ï q t ok ble. ki s k. ï z o lu c ' bG -c%- %%@t Aq/ Q:bç- %-%q tA t % a

'

(ti b Lg

COINT H J n ef lo i gcvi rght ha be nvi ltd; o lw n i l i s s e e ae -

S p ot gF cs (n ld alat o c nie i p ra t Stt tefcscer , u p ri a t;Icu e lfc ï u o sd rm otn. ae h at lal n y i y u o nwod , n wi o t in lg l uh rt o ag me t Besr ( u n o r w rsa d t u ct g e a a toi r ru n. ue o h l y

de ciee a tywha e c s e ii dee da t(yna e di t vill you ng t) srb x cl t a h p cfc fn n b m ) d o oae r h s.

5

:

Nw' .
e

Y

I

.

.

E.REQUEST FOR RELI F E
Ib le e t a la e tte t t e f low i g r le i e i v h t m n il d o h o l n e i f
/ '. *r
qq
'
.

.

. '

d

*

*

#$ . '
'

.h 0r s
:
I N

l1 -. $

'
'

<t. ô
.

:

I.
u.
.

:. (

'

' '

. s

!c

,i hr

. .

Iu de s a d t a a f l e sa em e to a s e t a y q e to i t i ço pl i twil n r tn h t as tt n r n w r o n u sin n h s m an l

s be tmet pen lisofpejr . 1DECLARE UNDER PENALTY (F PERJURY ujc o ate ruy )
U N D E R TH E LAW S O F TH E UM T ED STATES OF AM E R I A THA C
'j

TH E

FOQEGOG G I TRUEAND COQRECT.Se 28U.. . 1 46a d 8U.. . 1 21 S e C97 n S 6.
.

'
' l a eofPes nwhoprpa e o hepe Nm ro e rd r l d

t
( inaueofPlit Sg tr an i

( . #

i

pprtsopiioPii ra h c lnf tlnm e e i m atn at
(lt) Iae ( d iina s a ei n e e ;de tf wh ti b igc niued A dto l p c f e d d i niy a s en e tn )

l
. -

(
!

9

G

..

.

Q
V

X>

d
.

/

km uy Y O cfX = T z$ / .
'

.
-

U

* :3 y
.-

2 XY $ > o O >o / o
9Y

0 zO .' A :c ' oJ :o ' < %
w

V/ O