Panzarella Consulting, LLC v. SINGLE TOUCH INTERACTIVE, INC. et al

Filing 19

ORDER GRANTING 4 Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 12/29/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

#

Fl ' - - El.râ ED ' NE R E

ttst ai s r ; l l l i - g uoa ûN 7. l 7i
2

-' - PSCEIE V Sf k o0 ' lg q

CE 2 S 2 : ' C 2
t jy y a y y y j y y y jy y y y j y y y y t jy y Dllél rOFNIy IA s kz rA ;

g y

4
5
6

UNI EDS AT Soll c'dt T T E sw r s '
ol Tm c' (F NEVAOA s rj
PA N ZA R ELLA cox su t m c ,Llc, l -

pp gy

7

Pl i tf, a n if 8

vs .
9

3: 0- v- 042 - C J R A M 1 c 0 4R O RDER

SI G LE TOUCH I TE RA C TI E,I C . tal, N N V Ne.
10
D ef ndant . e s
11

1 2

Th sc s a i e ou ofa c m or ton' i s a c ofa dii nal t c wihoutm a nt i i g i a e rs s t o a i s s u n e d to s o k t i an n

13 Pl i tf ' pr pori nat ow ner hi i t e com or ton,i contavcnton oft e cor or ton' a n ifs o to e s pnb ai n r i h p ai s

1 c nta twih Pl i tf. Pe di g be or t e Cou ti Def nda t 'M oto t D im isf rLa k of 4 o r c t a n if n n f e h r s e ns in o s s o c

1 J rs iton( CFNo. ) Fo teraonsgie heen,teCo r grnt temoton.Atte 5 u idci E 4. rh es v n ri h u t a s h i h

l he rng,Plitf a mitdalc ofurs ito ,butteCour wilme oraieisra onsfr 6 ai anif d te a k j idcin h t l m ilz t e s o
1 t e r lng. 7 h ui
Panzarella Consulting, LLC v. Single Touch Interactive, Inc., et al Doc. 19

! .

11 8. 1 9

FACTS A N D PRO C E D U R A L H I T O R Y S Pl i tf pa za ela Co s li g,LLC pos e s sce t i w a r nt t pur h s t e soc of a n if n r l n u tn s s e ra n r a s o c a e h t k

20 Dee da tSigeTouc ltrctv ,Ic tl-l'- warnt ta weeta serdt Plitf by fn n n l h nea ie n .'sr' l ra s h t r rn fre o anif 2I Parc J Pa z rla,hema a e a da p rnts l o ne ofPlitf.Se Pan aelaDe l tik . n ael t n g r n p ae oe w r anif( e z r l c.
22 !! 1 5, g.2 ,201 ,ECF No. ) Pl i tf ' pr d ce s ri i tr s,Pati kPa z r la, - Au 6 0 9 . an ifs e e s o n n e e t rc n a el
23 a quied t es wa r nt a pa m e tf rc ns li g s r i eshe p ovi e t STlu de c n r ct c r h e r a s s y n o o u tn e v c r ddo n r o ta .

24 ( ompl! 6-8, No.1.Thec nrc c naisa ' nt- iutonca s 'rquiigSTlt C .! ECF ) o ta t o t n n K idl i lu e'e rn a o 25 manti Plitf' pec ntg ownes i i STI (d.!9;e Conta t!6,ECFNo.1Ex. . i an anifs re a e rhp n .1 s e rc A)

Dockets.Justia.com

!

1 Plitf ale e ta STItr ug tea tonsofisdie tr,icudn Defnda tAntonyG. an if lg s h t ,h o h h ci t rcos n l ig e n h
2 M acal so,i s ed addii nals ock t M acal s hi s l,w ihoutm ai t i i g Pl i tf s u su to t o u o m ef t n a n n a n if

i

I

3 pec na eownes i.( e i. 3 ) Plitf as ale e ha igbe npado l $3 0,0 ofa re tg rhp S e d ! 0 . anif lo lg s vn e i ny 2 0 0 4 pr mie $350,00cahc mpe ston.(e i. 7) o sd 0 s o n ai S e d ! . 5 ' Plitf s e Defnda t i ti Cour onf u c us sofa ton:( )Bra hofConrct anif u d e ns n hs t o r a c ci 1 e c ta ' ,

I

6 ()Qua tm Meui;3)Fru an Bra hofFiu ir Dut'a d( )Co srcieTr s. 2 nu r t( a d d e c d cay y, n 4 n tu tv u t 7 Dee da t ha emo e t dimisf rlc o s be tmatrj rs iton. fn ns v v d o s s o a k f u jc te u idci '

1

8 l. L GA SAN A D l E LT DRS
9 Fe ea co rsaeo lm ie j rs iton, se sn onl tos powesgrntdbyte d rl u t r f i td uidci po ss ig y h e r ae h 1 Consiutonorsaue. eUnie Sttsv Ma k ,5 0F.d7 9,8l (t Ci.20 8 (iains 0 tt i ttt Se td ae . ra 3 3 9 0 9h r 0 ) ctto ll omitd) Thepat aserigfdeaj rs itonbe r tebure ofo ec migte te . ry s tn e rlu idci as h d n v ro n h

l
d

'

1 prs mpina ans i. k one v Gu r inT#-I s Co.fAm.511U. . 377(99 ) 2 e u to g i ttKo k n . a da e n . o , S 375, 1 4 .
1 Fe ea Rul o CiiPrc dur 1 ( )1 prvie a afr aiedee s vi amotont dimis 3 d rl e f vl o e e 2b () o d s n fim tv fn e a i oss

1 frlc ofs be tmatrurs ito .Fe . Ci. 1 ( )1.Addiinal,ac ur ma r ie 4 o a k u j c te j idcin d R. v P. 2 b () to ly o t y as
1 t eq e tonofs b e tmatrj rs itons as on ea a ytm edurngpe de c oft ea ton. 5 h u si u j c te u id ci u p t t n i i n n y h ci

1 Unie Sttsv. r no- orlo,3 4F.d8l 8 0(t Ci.2 03) tl l e afd r lc ur 6 td ae Mo e M il 3 3 9, 3 9h r 0 . tW h n e ea o t 1 co clde ta i lc ss be tmate j rs iton,teco r mus ds istec mpliti is 7 n u s h tta k u jc- tru idci h u t t im s h o an n t
1 e trt. Ar au hv Y&. Cor .546U. . 00,5l ( 0 6)(iig 1 J M o r et .Mo r ' 8 niey' b g . H p , ' S5 4 2 0 ctn 6 . o e a1, o es 1 Fe ea Prciej 1 6.6()pp.1 688t 1 6-9(de . 9 d rl a tc 0 6 1, 0 - o 0 8 3 d 2005). )

20

Se ton 1 2()o Til 28ce tsoiia j rs itoni tedsrctc ursbewee ci 33 a f te rae rgn lu idci n h iti o t t n

21 ctz n ofdif r ntsatswh r tema tri co tov r yc c e st es m orvaueof$7500 . iie s fe e t e c e h te n n r e s x e d h u l ,0

22 Se 28U. . . l a a d()l.Alhoug Aril IIofteCo siuinpe nisConge st e SC j 332(. n a() t h tce I h n ttto n t ) rs o

23 ce t fdealu iditonwh r teei mii a diest,ie,wheean plitf i dies rae e r j rs ci ee h r s nm l v riy .. r y anif s v re
24 fom a ydee d n, at Far Fiet Cas Co.v Ta hie 38 U..5 3,5 0-31( 967, r n fn a tSt e m r : . . s r , 6 S 2 3 t 1)
25 s c i n 1 32 r quie c m pl t di e s t , .. e e y pl i tf m us be di e s fom e e y e to 3 e r s o e e v r iy ie , v r a n if t ' v re r vr
Page 2 of 4

1 dee da ts eLicol Prp.Co. .Roc e 5 6U..81 8 (005)( iigStawb igev Curis fn n, e n n o v h,4 S ,2 2 ctn r rd . t , s 2 7U..2 7( 8 6) Fortep r ossofdiest,almie Ia iiyc mpa yi aciienof S 6 1 0 ). h u p e v riy i td iblt o n s tz
3 ever sat ofwhi h is owner and m em ber ar cii ens.Johnson v.Col m bi Pro s. yte ct s s e tz uap

4 Anc orge 437F.d89 ,899( t Ci. 6) ha, 34 9h r 200 .
5 11 1. 6 AN A L Y SI S Def ndant ar ue t atPl i tf i a cii en ofCalf r i becaus t ati wher isonl e sg h a n if s tz io n a eh s et y

7 o fc ( nd he c isprncia plc ofbusn s)i l c td,a dt a i i t e eor notdie s fie a ne t i p l ae ie s s o ae n h t t s h r f e v re

8 wihDefnda t.Plitf i n tac r orto , we e, o28U.. .j 1 32()l,whih t e ns an if s o o p ain ho v rs SC 3 c( ) c
9 gover st e cii ens i ofcom or tonsf rt e pur osesofdi er iy,doesnotappl . As a lm ied n h tz h p ai oh p v st y it

1 la iiyco pa y(çLC' , ve, aitf i actze ofe er sat ofwhihisidiiua 0 iblt m n $ ' howe rPl nif s ii n v y t e L) c t n vd l
m em ber and owner ar cii ens,Johnson,437 F. d at899,and Def ndant not d t i poi tat s s e tz 3 e s e hs n

1 teherng.Alho ghrgsee a a LLC i Wyomig,(e Compl! 1, anifi i fc a 2 h ai t u e itrd s n n n se . )Plitf s n a t
l cii en ofCalf r i f rpur osesofdi er iy,becaus Pati k Panzar la,t e m anagerand s l 3 tz io n a o p v st e rc el h oe

owne ofPlitf,(e Pa zael De l1 1 5,i aciie ofCaiom i.Thep blcrc r sof r anif s e n rla c.1 - ) s tz n ! lf a u i eod
15 t e St t ofW yom i g show t atPl i tf i a LLC wih isprnci alof i e and m aii g a dr s at h ae n h a n if s tt ip fc ln d e s

31 5 W a nutAve ,M a ha t n Be c , 9 266 a d t a Pa rc Pan a e l i a 0 l . n ta a h CA 0 , n h t ti k z r la s

1 ç e bi / a a e 'Se W yom i g Se r tz ofSt t, lng Se rh,htps/wyobi. y.ov 7 t m rM n g n ' e M n c eay a c Fii a c t :/ zw g /

1 Busne s iigDetisapx? iig um=zol - oos8 6 l(qtviie Sept l 201 ) Thi 8 i s/ ln al.s F ln N o o s 7 ls std . , 0 . s
addr s i i f ctt e r sdence ofa tPati k J.Panzar laz'asDef ndant ar ue.See es s n a b c i ' rc cl ' e sg

btpi/ ww.a ae rh.om (a tviie Se t1 201 .Dee dan ST1i aNev dac rorton t /w z b sac c ls std p . , 0) fn t s a op ai 21 wihisonl ofiesi Calf r i, ndDee da tMa aus rsd si Caiom i,(e Ma als t t y tc n io na a fn n c l o e ie n lf a s e c u o De l!,2 3, No. , kigbohDee da t ciie sofCaior i, e 28U. . . c. 1 - ECF 5)ma n t fn ns tz n lf na s e SC

23 91 32()1,()1; rzCor .v Fre d,1 0S.Ct 11 1 11 2( 01 )(oligta te 3 a() c()He t p . in 3 . 8 , 9 2 0 h dn h th prncpa plceo busne sofaco ortonunde 9 1 3 ()1 i ishe d uatr orS ev iila f is m ai r 3 2 c() s t a q res t r' ne 25 c ntr'.Be a s alpatc aectz nsofCaior i, onl i teenoj rs itonu de e e' c u e l ris r iie ) lf na not y s h r uidci n r
Page 3 of 4

'

!

I

'

1 j 1 () Co grs d esno ev nha etea iiyt ce t fd r luiditonov rt i c s . 332a, n e s o t e v h b lt o rae e ea j rs ci e hs ae
2 Se U. . ns. t 11 j 2, .1 Ta hie,3 6 U. . t530 31 n e ebengnodi e st bewe n e S Co tar. 1, c1 ; s r 8 S a - . r i v r iy t e

3 tepate a dnofdea cli s teCo r dimis stec s frlc ofs b e tmatr h ris n e rl am ,h u t s se h a e o a k u j c te

4 j rs ito . u idcin
I I 5 CONCLUSI N O

I
l

6

I I HEREBY ORDERED ta teM oint Dimisf rLa kofJ rs iton( CFNo. TS h th to o s s o c u idci E
,

! 1
i i
I

7 4 iGRANTE . )s D
8
9
1 0

l 1
!
.
'

I I SO ORDERED. TS
Dat d:Decem ber29.2010 e

I
I

1l

Unie St sD iti t udg . td src J e

ROBE

C. ONES J

I
1 l I i :
i
I

l 2
1 3
14 15 ' '

'

''

.

i
I
!
!

1 6
17
18

(

:
E

1 9
20

r
!

21
22

i :
l
l

I

23
24

1
i

!
i
i
I

i

25
page 4 oj 4 r

;

I

'