Panzarella Consulting, LLC v. SINGLE TOUCH INTERACTIVE, INC. et al

Filing 19

ORDER GRANTING 4 Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 12/29/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DRM)

Download PDF
# Fl ' - - El.r ED ' NE R E ttst ai s r ; l l l i - g uoa N 7. l 7i 2 -' - PSCEIE V Sf k o0 ' lg q CE 2 S 2 : ' C 2 t jy y a y y y j y y y jy y y y j y y y y t jy y Dlll rOFNIy IA s kz rA ; g y 4 5 6 UNI EDS AT Soll c'dt T T E sw r s ' ol Tm c' (F NEVAOA s rj PA N ZA R ELLA cox su t m c ,Llc, l - pp gy 7 Pl i tf, a n if 8 vs . 9 3: 0- v- 042 - C J R A M 1 c 0 4R O RDER SI G LE TOUCH I TE RA C TI E,I C . tal, N N V Ne. 10 D ef ndant . e s 11 1 2 Th sc s a i e ou ofa c m or ton' i s a c ofa dii nal t c wihoutm a nt i i g i a e rs s t o a i s s u n e d to s o k t i an n 13 Pl i tf ' pr pori nat ow ner hi i t e com or ton,i contavcnton oft e cor or ton' a n ifs o to e s pnb ai n r i h p ai s 1 c nta twih Pl i tf. Pe di g be or t e Cou ti Def nda t 'M oto t D im isf rLa k of 4 o r c t a n if n n f e h r s e ns in o s s o c 1 J rs iton( CFNo. ) Fo teraonsgie heen,teCo r grnt temoton.Atte 5 u idci E 4. rh es v n ri h u t a s h i h l he rng,Plitf a mitdalc ofurs ito ,butteCour wilme oraieisra onsfr 6 ai anif d te a k j idcin h t l m ilz t e s o 1 t e r lng. 7 h ui Panzarella Consulting, LLC v. Single Touch Interactive, Inc., et al Doc. 19 ! . 11 8. 1 9 FACTS A N D PRO C E D U R A L H I T O R Y S Pl i tf pa za ela Co s li g,LLC pos e s sce t i w a r nt t pur h s t e soc of a n if n r l n u tn s s e ra n r a s o c a e h t k 20 Dee da tSigeTouc ltrctv ,Ic tl-l'- warnt ta weeta serdt Plitf by fn n n l h nea ie n .'sr' l ra s h t r rn fre o anif 2I Parc J Pa z rla,hema a e a da p rnts l o ne ofPlitf.Se Pan aelaDe l tik . n ael t n g r n p ae oe w r anif( e z r l c. 22 !! 1 5, g.2 ,201 ,ECF No. ) Pl i tf ' pr d ce s ri i tr s,Pati kPa z r la, - Au 6 0 9 . an ifs e e s o n n e e t rc n a el 23 a quied t es wa r nt a pa m e tf rc ns li g s r i eshe p ovi e t STlu de c n r ct c r h e r a s s y n o o u tn e v c r ddo n r o ta . 24 ( ompl! 6-8, No.1.Thec nrc c naisa ' nt- iutonca s 'rquiigSTlt C .! ECF ) o ta t o t n n K idl i lu e'e rn a o 25 manti Plitf' pec ntg ownes i i STI (d.!9;e Conta t!6,ECFNo.1Ex. . i an anifs re a e rhp n .1 s e rc A) Dockets.Justia.com ! 1 Plitf ale e ta STItr ug tea tonsofisdie tr,icudn Defnda tAntonyG. an if lg s h t ,h o h h ci t rcos n l ig e n h 2 M acal so,i s ed addii nals ock t M acal s hi s l,w ihoutm ai t i i g Pl i tf s u su to t o u o m ef t n a n n a n if i I 3 pec na eownes i.( e i. 3 ) Plitf as ale e ha igbe npado l $3 0,0 ofa re tg rhp S e d ! 0 . anif lo lg s vn e i ny 2 0 0 4 pr mie $350,00cahc mpe ston.(e i. 7) o sd 0 s o n ai S e d ! . 5 ' Plitf s e Defnda t i ti Cour onf u c us sofa ton:( )Bra hofConrct anif u d e ns n hs t o r a c ci 1 e c ta ' , I 6 ()Qua tm Meui;3)Fru an Bra hofFiu ir Dut'a d( )Co srcieTr s. 2 nu r t( a d d e c d cay y, n 4 n tu tv u t 7 Dee da t ha emo e t dimisf rlc o s be tmatrj rs iton. fn ns v v d o s s o a k f u jc te u idci ' 1 8 l. L GA SAN A D l E LT DRS 9 Fe ea co rsaeo lm ie j rs iton, se sn onl tos powesgrntdbyte d rl u t r f i td uidci po ss ig y h e r ae h 1 Consiutonorsaue. eUnie Sttsv Ma k ,5 0F.d7 9,8l (t Ci.20 8 (iains 0 tt i ttt Se td ae . ra 3 3 9 0 9h r 0 ) ctto ll omitd) Thepat aserigfdeaj rs itonbe r tebure ofo ec migte te . ry s tn e rlu idci as h d n v ro n h l d ' 1 prs mpina ans i. k one v Gu r inT#-I s Co.fAm.511U. . 377(99 ) 2 e u to g i ttKo k n . a da e n . o , S 375, 1 4 . 1 Fe ea Rul o CiiPrc dur 1 ( )1 prvie a afr aiedee s vi amotont dimis 3 d rl e f vl o e e 2b () o d s n fim tv fn e a i oss 1 frlc ofs be tmatrurs ito .Fe . Ci. 1 ( )1.Addiinal,ac ur ma r ie 4 o a k u j c te j idcin d R. v P. 2 b () to ly o t y as 1 t eq e tonofs b e tmatrj rs itons as on ea a ytm edurngpe de c oft ea ton. 5 h u si u j c te u id ci u p t t n i i n n y h ci 1 Unie Sttsv. r no- orlo,3 4F.d8l 8 0(t Ci.2 03) tl l e afd r lc ur 6 td ae Mo e M il 3 3 9, 3 9h r 0 . tW h n e ea o t 1 co clde ta i lc ss be tmate j rs iton,teco r mus ds istec mpliti is 7 n u s h tta k u jc- tru idci h u t t im s h o an n t 1 e trt. Ar au hv Y&. Cor .546U. . 00,5l ( 0 6)(iig 1 J M o r et .Mo r ' 8 niey' b g . H p , ' S5 4 2 0 ctn 6 . o e a1, o es 1 Fe ea Prciej 1 6.6()pp.1 688t 1 6-9(de . 9 d rl a tc 0 6 1, 0 - o 0 8 3 d 2005). ) 20 Se ton 1 2()o Til 28ce tsoiia j rs itoni tedsrctc ursbewee ci 33 a f te rae rgn lu idci n h iti o t t n 21 ctz n ofdif r ntsatswh r tema tri co tov r yc c e st es m orvaueof$7500 . iie s fe e t e c e h te n n r e s x e d h u l ,0 22 Se 28U. . . l a a d()l.Alhoug Aril IIofteCo siuinpe nisConge st e SC j 332(. n a() t h tce I h n ttto n t ) rs o 23 ce t fdealu iditonwh r teei mii a diest,ie,wheean plitf i dies rae e r j rs ci ee h r s nm l v riy .. r y anif s v re 24 fom a ydee d n, at Far Fiet Cas Co.v Ta hie 38 U..5 3,5 0-31( 967, r n fn a tSt e m r : . . s r , 6 S 2 3 t 1) 25 s c i n 1 32 r quie c m pl t di e s t , .. e e y pl i tf m us be di e s fom e e y e to 3 e r s o e e v r iy ie , v r a n if t ' v re r vr Page 2 of 4 1 dee da ts eLicol Prp.Co. .Roc e 5 6U..81 8 (005)( iigStawb igev Curis fn n, e n n o v h,4 S ,2 2 ctn r rd . t , s 2 7U..2 7( 8 6) Fortep r ossofdiest,almie Ia iiyc mpa yi aciienof S 6 1 0 ). h u p e v riy i td iblt o n s tz 3 ever sat ofwhi h is owner and m em ber ar cii ens.Johnson v.Col m bi Pro s. yte ct s s e tz uap 4 Anc orge 437F.d89 ,899( t Ci. 6) ha, 34 9h r 200 . 5 11 1. 6 AN A L Y SI S Def ndant ar ue t atPl i tf i a cii en ofCalf r i becaus t ati wher isonl e sg h a n if s tz io n a eh s et y 7 o fc ( nd he c isprncia plc ofbusn s)i l c td,a dt a i i t e eor notdie s fie a ne t i p l ae ie s s o ae n h t t s h r f e v re 8 wihDefnda t.Plitf i n tac r orto , we e, o28U.. .j 1 32()l,whih t e ns an if s o o p ain ho v rs SC 3 c( ) c 9 gover st e cii ens i ofcom or tonsf rt e pur osesofdi er iy,doesnotappl . As a lm ied n h tz h p ai oh p v st y it 1 la iiyco pa y(LC' , ve, aitf i actze ofe er sat ofwhihisidiiua 0 iblt m n $ ' howe rPl nif s ii n v y t e L) c t n vd l m em ber and owner ar cii ens,Johnson,437 F. d at899,and Def ndant not d t i poi tat s s e tz 3 e s e hs n 1 teherng.Alho ghrgsee a a LLC i Wyomig,(e Compl! 1, anifi i fc a 2 h ai t u e itrd s n n n se . )Plitf s n a t l cii en ofCalf r i f rpur osesofdi er iy,becaus Pati k Panzar la,t e m anagerand s l 3 tz io n a o p v st e rc el h oe owne ofPlitf,(e Pa zael De l1 1 5,i aciie ofCaiom i.Thep blcrc r sof r anif s e n rla c.1 - ) s tz n ! lf a u i eod 15 t e St t ofW yom i g show t atPl i tf i a LLC wih isprnci alof i e and m aii g a dr s at h ae n h a n if s tt ip fc ln d e s 31 5 W a nutAve ,M a ha t n Be c , 9 266 a d t a Pa rc Pan a e l i a 0 l . n ta a h CA 0 , n h t ti k z r la s 1 e bi / a a e 'Se W yom i g Se r tz ofSt t, lng Se rh,htps/wyobi. y.ov 7 t m rM n g n ' e M n c eay a c Fii a c t :/ zw g / 1 Busne s iigDetisapx? iig um=zol - oos8 6 l(qtviie Sept l 201 ) Thi 8 i s/ ln al.s F ln N o o s 7 ls std . , 0 . s addr s i i f ctt e r sdence ofa tPati k J.Panzar laz'asDef ndant ar ue.See es s n a b c i ' rc cl ' e sg btpi/ ww.a ae rh.om (a tviie Se t1 201 .Dee dan ST1i aNev dac rorton t /w z b sac c ls std p . , 0) fn t s a op ai 21 wihisonl ofiesi Calf r i, ndDee da tMa aus rsd si Caiom i,(e Ma als t t y tc n io na a fn n c l o e ie n lf a s e c u o De l!,2 3, No. , kigbohDee da t ciie sofCaior i, e 28U. . . c. 1 - ECF 5)ma n t fn ns tz n lf na s e SC 23 91 32()1,()1; rzCor .v Fre d,1 0S.Ct 11 1 11 2( 01 )(oligta te 3 a() c()He t p . in 3 . 8 , 9 2 0 h dn h th prncpa plceo busne sofaco ortonunde 9 1 3 ()1 i ishe d uatr orS ev iila f is m ai r 3 2 c() s t a q res t r' ne 25 c ntr'.Be a s alpatc aectz nsofCaior i, onl i teenoj rs itonu de e e' c u e l ris r iie ) lf na not y s h r uidci n r Page 3 of 4 ' ! I ' 1 j 1 () Co grs d esno ev nha etea iiyt ce t fd r luiditonov rt i c s . 332a, n e s o t e v h b lt o rae e ea j rs ci e hs ae 2 Se U. . ns. t 11 j 2, .1 Ta hie,3 6 U. . t530 31 n e ebengnodi e st bewe n e S Co tar. 1, c1 ; s r 8 S a - . r i v r iy t e 3 tepate a dnofdea cli s teCo r dimis stec s frlc ofs b e tmatr h ris n e rl am ,h u t s se h a e o a k u j c te 4 j rs ito . u idcin I I 5 CONCLUSI N O I l 6 I I HEREBY ORDERED ta teM oint Dimisf rLa kofJ rs iton( CFNo. TS h th to o s s o c u idci E , ! 1 i i I 7 4 iGRANTE . )s D 8 9 1 0 l 1 ! . ' I I SO ORDERED. TS Dat d:Decem ber29.2010 e I I 1l Unie St sD iti t udg . td src J e ROBE C. ONES J I 1 l I i : i I l 2 1 3 14 15 ' ' ' '' . i I ! ! 1 6 17 18 ( : E 1 9 20 r ! 21 22 i : l l I 23 24 1 i ! i i I i 25 page 4 oj 4 r ; I '

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?