Truesdell v. Donat et al

Filing 20

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that defendants' 13 Motion to Disqualify is GRANTED. Signed by Magistrate Judge Valerie P. Cooke on 10/04/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

l
2 3
4

UNI ED STATES DI TR I T CO UR T T S C
DI T R I T O F NEV A D A S C

RI HARD A. C TRUESDELL 5 6 7 8 W I LI M DONAT,e al, LA t. 9
1 0

Plitf anif

Dee dant. fn s

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

3:0-v- 0453- RH- PC 1c O LV ORDER Octbe 4,201 or O

11

Bef r t eco r i dee da tAda W as n' (le e da f'moto t diquaiyplitf o e h u ts fn n m to s ld f n n ) in o s lf an if

1 RihadTr e dels(tlitf' c unsl( l .Plitfop osd(/5)a ddee d n rple (/ 7 . 2 c r u s l' G an if' o e # 3) anif p e /1 , n fn a t e id /1 ) p )
1 Theco r he d ahe rng on t e i sa tm o i n o Se t m be 23,2010. Upo t or ugh r viw o 3 ut l ai h n tn to n p e r nh o ee f
1 t e m oton a d co sde a i n of o a a gum e t t e c ur gr nt de e da t 'm oton t di qua i y 4h in n i r to rl r n ,h o t a s fn n s i o s lf 15 pl i tf sco ns l a n if u e.

1 6

1.FACTUAL & PR O CED U R AL BA CK G R O U N D

l 7

Plitf,as nircore tona ofi e oft eNe adaDe a t e tofCore tons(t DOC') an if e o rci l tc r h v p rm n rci : N ',

1 brngshi c mplitpurua tt 42U. . .j1 f rviltonofhi Fis Ame dme trgh s(/ , 8i s o an s n o S C ' 983 o oai s rt n n i t /1
Truesdell v. Donat et al

1 p.6) Addiinal,plitf alge vi lton oft e Uniom e Se rc s Emplyme t a d 9 . to ly an if le s o ai h f r d n ie o nn
Doc. 20

20 Re m plym e tRiht Ac,38U.. .j4301e s q.a dac us sdee da tNDOC off iu et e o n gs t SC t e , n c e fn n alr o
21 e e c s r as na l c r i hii g, r i i g,s pe vii g, ndr t i i g i di i ua def nda t .I a x r ie e o b e a e n rn tan n u r sn a e an n n v d l e n s d t
22 6 7. -

23

l 2006, n NDOC de ot dpl i tf fom s ni rc reci na ofi e t c reci na ofie i m e an if r e o o r to l fc r o o r to l fc r n

2 r s ons t an of - u y vi l ton. 1 .a 2. Pl i tf s ughtpr m oton one ye rl t r i Sept m be 4 ep e o fd t o a i dt a n if o oi a ae n er

25 2007, NDOC o fc a sdenid hi pr m o i n des iepli tf sc am t atde e da tW a s n but fi i l e m o to p t a n if l i h fn n to 26 a vied hi t a he wa ç um be t o on t e ls . IL a 2. Pli tf a pe ld t e decson t ds m ht si n rw h it' 6 t ' an if p a e h ii o 27 d f nda tSkol i .f . t3.De e da tSkol i as e de end nt Heli g a dW a s nt m e twih ee n nk # a fn n n k k d f a s ln n to o e t

28 plitf.Ac or i gt plitf, fnda t as ns i ,toudi megrasygi) hiy' lge l an if c dn o an ifdee n W to ad û yd e e sc ont s'ale dy

Dockets.Justia.com

1 r frncngplitf sj m pi tec ai ofconm a dt tl hi a pe l t de e da tSkoli .1 . eee i anif u n h h n n n o 'e s p a wih f n n i nk d
l A tt e N ove ber2007 m ee i g, a n i fr ve l d t de e da t H e lng a d W a s n t a he fl d h m tn pl i t f e a e o f n n s li n t o h t ie

3 ane ua e plyme t q l m o n opporuniy(tEO') omplit le igt atr of blcc nc r ,'ncudig t t: E 'c an algn ç te s pu i o en'i l n m
4 cl i st a t e a s ci t w a d nson t ehii g pa elt e et y ng t kee t e good ol boyss s e am h t h so ae r e h rn n l r r i o p h w d y tm 5 a i e, i vi l ton of t e D e a t e ts m is on s a e e t'a d enga i g i : o r pton i t e lv n o a i h p rm n ' s i t t m n ' n gn n i ru i n h c
6 pr m otonalproces .' f . Pl i tf succeeded i hi appealand N D O C pr m ot d hi t s ni r oi s' J a n if ns o e m oeo

7 c r e tona ofi e i J num ' 2008. 1 .a 4. Pl i tf a guest a due t e e c s ng hi pr t c e o r c i l tc r n a y dt a n if r ht o x rii s oe td 8 Fi s A m e d e t i ht durngt e a pe la d EEO pr c s e , w a s bs que ty pl ce on at ve rt n m n rg s i h p a n o e s s he s u e n l a d i9 d y s s e s on i 2008,pr hi ied f om ac i g as a ta ni g ofi e ,a d de i d pr m oton t a up n i n o bt r tn r i n tc r n ne o i o
10 s r eant 1 .at4- . eg d 6

11

l t e s m e m ont t a pl i tf a pea ed t e de i lof pr m o i n by de e d ntW a s n, nh a h h t a n if p l h na o to fn a to

1 s meoneflda a o ym o sc mplitagans dee da tW as n(/3, 3) Thi c mplitwas 2o ie n n n u o an i t fn n to /1 p. . s o an
1 o e o s ve al nonym ousc m pl i t f l d ag i s de enda t a s n, c l dt a i t r a af ais 3 n fe r a o a n s ie a n t f n W t o whi h e o n n e n l f r 1 i ve t g ton by N D O C i 20 8.1 .D e e dant a s n hi e J f r y D i ke s n, a n i fsco ns l 4 n si a i n0 d fn W t o r d e f e c r o pl i t f ue 1 i t e i s a tdiput , o r pr s n hi i t e i t r a af a r i ve t g t o . I . W a s n c a m s he 5 n h n t n s e t e e e t m n h n e n l f is n si a i n d to l i 1 s a e t i hl c ntde t a i f r a i n about t e c s a d a out pr s n m a a e e t a d t e 6 h r d t g y o i n i l n o m to h h ae n b io ngm n n h 1 W a de ' w ih M r D i ke s n. 1 . The e en s gi i g rs t t e i t r alaf a r i ves i a i n by 7 r n' t . c ro d v t v n ie o h n e n f i s n tg to

1 NDOC it W as n' co duc occ re d rng 2007 a d 2008 (/ 3,Ex.A,p.3) Thei sa t 8 no to s n t u rd u i n /1 . n tn
1 c m plita ais defnda tW as nbypli tf i cudese e t oc urigfom 2006t 201 ( l. 9 o an g n t e n to anifn l v n s c rn r o 0#)
20 D e e da t a s n di no c ns nt o M r D i ke s n' r pr s nt t o ofpl i tf a a ns hi . f n n W to d t o e t . c ro s e e e ain a n if g i t m 21 1 . He i co c r e t a M r D i ker on' r pr s nt ton of pl i t f m a r s l i t e us ofhi d s n en d h t . c s s e e e ai a n if y e u t n h e s

22 c nfde ta i f r ai n, aneddtrngt ef r e m al r t hi di a va t gei t ecu r ntc s . o i n il n o m to obt i li h o m r te ,o s s d n a n h r e a e
23 1 . M r D i ke s n c ai she i asno r c l oft e t pi s'di c s e w ih de enda tW a s n w he d . c ro l m ç h e al h o c ' s u s d t f n to n

2 hep e iusyrpr sntdhi durngt eitr alaf isi ve tgai n(/5,p. . 4 r vo l e e e e m i h n en far n si to /1 2)
25 26 A . D i cus i n s so l . LE G A L D I C U SSI N I S O

27 28

1 .

Loc lRul I 10 7 a)a d Ne adaRul o Pr f si nalConduc 19 a e A -( n v e f o e so t.

Unde Loc lRul I 1 - ()a ator e admitdt prciebeor teU. . src Cour r a e A 07a n t n y te o a tc f e h S Ditit t
2

1 f rt eDiti tofNe a aés alad e et t esa d r ofc nduc pr s lbe by t e M ode Rul s o h src v d çh l h r o h t n a d o t e ci d h le
2 of Pr f s i nal Conduct as a opt d a d a e ded f om tm e t tm e by t e Su r m e Cour of o e so d e n mn r i oi h pe t 3 N eva a. N e ada Rul of Pr f s i nalC o du t 1. gove ns dute owed b c uns lt f nne d' v ' e o e so nc 9 r is y o e oo r 4 c i nt . The nle pr vi es : l w ye who has f r e l r pr s nt d a c i nti a m a t r s al no le s l o d :ç a r A o m ry e e e e le n te h l t 5 t e e f e r pr s nt a ot e pe s n i t e s m e o a s bs a ta l r l t d m al r i w hi h t at h r a tr e e e n h r r o n h a r u t n i ly e a e te n ch
6 per on' i t res sar m at ri ly adver e t t e i t r s soft e f r erclentt l sst ef r erclent s s ne t e e al s o h n ee t h om i m e h om i

7 gie if nnedc ns n, ontnnedi wrtng. Ne . Pr fConduc 19() Ther l f rhe saes v sno o e tc i n ii ' v R. o . ' t . a. ue u t r tt
8 t a a a t r e s oul notû s i f r a i n r l tng t t e r pr s nt ton t t e di a va t ge oft e h t n to n y h d k e n o m to e a i o h e e e a i o h s d n a u h 9 f r e c i nt e tast e eRul sw oul per i orr quie .. o whe t e i f r a i n ha be om e o m r le exc p hs e d m t e r .r n h n o m to s c 1 ge e aly kno l ' nors oul a a- r e di c os i f nna i n r l t d t t e f nnerr pr s nt ton 0 nr l w u' h d n to n y s l e n o to e a e o h o t e e e ai

11 u ls r quiedo per itdbyt er ls 1 .a 1.() n e s e r r m te h ue .d t 9 c .
1 2 To s c e s uly a gue f rdi qua ii a i n ofc uns l a pa t m us s ow t a t e a t r e i u csf l r o s lfc to o e , ry th h t h to n y t 1 i s e i g t diqualf pr vi usy ha a a t r e - le tr l tons i w ih t epa t , ha t e f r er 3 s e k n o s iy e o l d n to n y c i n e a i h p t h ry t t h o m 1 a d c r e t a t r a es bs a ta l r l t d, nd t at hecur e t e r s n a i n i a ve s t t epa t 4 n u r n m te s r u t n i ly e a e a h t r n r p e e t to s d r e o h ry

15 s e igdiqu ltc ton.Ne .Yelw CabCor . DitCt,1 3Ne . 50,1 2P.d7 7( 007) e kn s aii ai v lo p v. s. . 2 v 44, 5 3 3 2 .
1 The N e ada Supr m e Cou tado t d t e Se ent Cic i' t r e pa tt s t de e n i e w he he 6 v e r pe h v h r u ts h e r e t o t n n tr

1 fnne a dcu rntma tr aes bsa tal r ltd,die tng e u t t :( )d tr iet ef cual 7 o r n re tes r u tnily eae rci o rs o 1 eem n h a t 18 s o e oft e f r er rpr s ntton,() e auae i i i ra ona l t ifr tatc nfdenil cp h o m e e e ai 2 v l t f t s e s b e o n e h o i ta 1 if r ainwoul ha epase fom t ef r e cintt t elwye i t a r pr sntton,a d( ) 9 n o m to d v s d r h o m r le o h a r n h t e e e ai n 3
20 de e m i e i t a c ntden i li f r aton i r l va tt t epr s ntm a t r Wai v Ei ht Ju i i l tr n f h t o i ta n o m i s e e n o h e e te . d . g h d ca

21 DitCour,1 1Ne .605,61 ,11 P.d 1 1 ,1 23( 005) s. t2 v 0 9 3 29 2 2 .
22 23 1 1 AN A L Y SI 1. S D e e da tW a s n c a m st a M r D i ke s n o t i ed c nt de ta i f r a i n f om hi fn n t o l i h t . e r o b a n o i n i l n o m to r m

24 du ighi rprs nttonofW as ni 2008(/ 3, 3) W hiet eexa tco tntoft ec nfd ntal rn s e e e ai to n /1 p. . l h c n e h o ie i 25 c mplit a ansdeenda tW as nt a weet es be t MrDikes n' fr e rprs ntton o an s g i t f n to h t r h u j c of . c ro s o m r e e e ai
26 i un now n t t e c ur ,de e da tW a s n s a e t a he di c os d s ns tve i f r a i n r ga di g sk o h o t fn n to tts h t s l e e ii n o m to e r n

27 prs nma a e e tandt ec am sa a ns hi .I M r Di ke s nnow r pr s nt pli tf i as i io n gm n h li g i t m d . c ro e e e s a n if n u t
28 a a ns de e da tW a s n and o he prs n of i i l a l gi g,am ong ot e t i gs t a de e da t g i t fn n to t r i o fc a s le n h r hn , h t fn n
3

1 W aton a d ot e as ocit wa de s f ie t pr m ot hi i vi l ton of prs n pe s nnel s n h r s a e r n a ld o o e m n o a i io ro

2 pr c dur s( 1 p. .Plitf beive ti i apatr ofbe a ire i e cigt or pto i t e o e e # , 2) anif le s h s s ten h vo v d n n t ru in n h c
3 pr m o i nalpr c s . f . a 3. M r D i ke s n c ai s he c n ot r m e be any confden i l o to o e s' # t ' . c ro l m an e m r i ta 4 i f r a i n c nve e t hi by hi f r erc i nt def nda tW a s n, a dt a t ef r e andc re t n o m to o y d o m s o m le , c n t o n h th o m r u rn

5 matr aeno s bsa tal r ltd(/5,p. . te s r t u tnily eae /1 2)
6 A. Att rne ClentR el t ons i and R epres ntat on A dverseto the Form er C lent oyi ai hp e i i

7

Pa te ag ee a t eSe t m be 23, ri s r d t h p e r 2010he rngt a de enda t me t ebur e ofpr vi g ai h t f ns th dn on

8 e em e t one and t r e pr vi usa - r e - le tr l tons i a d a c r e ta t o t a i a ve s t l ns h e , e o to n y c i n e a i h p n t u rn cin h t s d re o

9 t ef r e cle t unde Nev da Ye l w CabCo.Fis i i undiput dt a de e dantW a s nhie h o m r in, ra lo rt ts s e h t fn to r d
1 M r Di ke s n t r pr s n hi d rng N D O C ' i t r ala f i s i ve tga i n of t e a onym ous 0 . c ro o e e e t m u i S n e n f a r n s i to hn 11 c m pl i t a ai s hi .Cl a l ,M r D i ke s nand de e da tW a s n de e ope a a t r e - le t o ans g n t m e ry . c ro fn n t o v l d n to n y c i n

1 r ltons i durngt ec ur eoft i r pr s nt tont a oblge M r Dike s nt pr t c hi f nne 2 ea i h p i h o s h s e e e ai h t i s . c r o o o e t s o r
1 clent s c nf de tali f r a i n. Sec nd,M r D i ke s n i c r e ty r pr s ntng pl i tf i an 3 i ' o i n i n o m to o . c ro s u rn l e e e i a n if n 1 ac i n t a na es W a s n a a de e da t Fur he , a ntf s c m pl i ta l ges s ve a vi l tons 4 to h t m to s f n n . t r pi i if o a n le e rl o ai

1 b dee da t as na ds e smoneayda a e a dijmcier leficudigma daol tanig 5 y fn n W to n e k tl m g s n n t tv ei n l n n t y ri n
l f re pl ye si de e da tW a s n' post o .The c r e tdi put i diec l a ver et de e d n 6 o m o e n fn n t o s ii n u r n s e s r ty d s o f n a t 1 W a s n,M r Di ke s n' f r e c i nt 7 to . c r o s o m r le . 18 B. 1 9 Subs antalR e atons i B e w e n Form er and Curr ntM at e s ti l i hp t e e tr D e e m i i g whe he t ef nne a d c r e ta tonsa eçs bs a ta l r l t d'i a t ehe r tr n n t r h o r n u rn ci r çu t n i ly e a e ' s t h a t

20 o t e i san m oton. I a dii n t t e t r e pa tt s a o t d by t eN e a a Supr m e Co r i fh nt t i n d to o h h e - r e t d p e h vd e u tn 21 Wai ,heCour pr vi e addii na gui a cea dr s i gt ei s eofs bsa ta r l t dne s sa i g dt t o dd to l d n d e sn h s u u t n il e ae s , t tn
22 t a t e btr e ofpr vi g a r l tons i be w ee t e c r e ta d f nne m a t r f ls on t e pa t h t h td n on e a i h p t n h u r n n o r te s a l h ry

23 movigf rdiquaiiain.Robbisv.Gilck 1 9Ne .1 1 ,1 1 - 8,862P.d 11 5( 993) n o s lfc to n lo , 0 v 0 5 0 7 1 2 91 .
24 W hiet epa t mus ha ee i e cet s p or t er ltons i , hepa t i no r quie t di ul e l h ry t v v d n o u p th eai hp t ry s t e r d o v g 25 c nfd nta i f r a i n.I a 1 18 Rahe , hec u ts o l unde tkeaG eaitc a pr ia'of o e i l n o m to d t 0 . t r t o r h u d ra ç lsi p a s l' r
26 w he he contde ta i f r a i n lke y pa s d be w e n t e f r e c i nt nd t ea t r e t a c ul t r i n i l n o m to i l s e t e h o m r le a h to n y h t o d 27 be ha m f lt t e f r e cle ti t e pr s ntm a t r 1 . r u o h o m r in n h e e te . d 28 I Robbi s t e c ur c nc uded t a s m pl be a s t e f nuera d c r e tr pr s nt tons n n ,h o t o l h t i y cu e h o n u rn e e e ai
4

nv d c l l a tc l i i t n h th a e r u t n i ly e a e d n 1 i vol ed m e i a m a pr c i e c a m s d d no m ea t a t e c s sw e e s bs a ta l r l t d.1 . l

fc,h c s si v le dfe e tij re mz tec u to n t a iwo l b ç u es e ulto 't a tte a e n ov d ifr n n u is d h o r f u d h tt u d e t r p c ain'o p
3 s gge tt att e a t r e ga ne co fde tali f r a i n f om t e f nne cle tt a c ul be us d u s h h to n y i d n i n i n o m to r h o r i n h t o d e i t epr s ntc s . I L I c n r s , hi cour di tng ihe m edi alm a pr c i e diput s s c a n h e e a e 6 n o ta t t s t si u s s c l a tc s e , u h s h am n n ,r m o n s rm n to a e . e e . . le s 5 t e cl i s i Robbi s f om e pl ym e tdi c i i a i n c s s Se Col s v Wz Char i ',992 F.

Supp.1 1 ( . v.1 98) Thec ur r as nst a tu lkemaprciec s sa is ei Rob is, 2 4 D Ne 9 . o t e o h tln i l a tc a e t su n b n
t e pa t c nduc of t e def nda t e pl ye c n be us d t es a ls a pa- l or pr c i e of h so t h e n m ora e o t b ih te ' tn a tc

dici iain t s ppor a e plye ' cai ofdic i i ai n.' d a 121 (ii gHawkisv. s rm n to o u t n m o e s l m srm n to 'l t 7 ctn n

He ne i Tec .Ct ,900F.d 1 1 5- 6(t Ci,1 90). I Cols plitfsalge apatr n pn h n 2 53, 5 5 8h r 9 ) n e , anif le d ten
a d pr c i e o di c i i a i n a a ns de e da t .I . The c u tf u d t a pl i tf s a t r e , ho n a tc f s r m n t o g i t f n n s d o r o n h t a n if ' to n y w e e e e fn n s n ir a e e r n o t a tc n i e , i y an d 11 r pr s nt d de e da t i apr o c s r ga di g em pl ym en pr c i esa d polci s lkel obt i e c ntde ta i f r a i n r l t d t pl i tf s c a m s of d s rm i a i n. 1 . A s a r s l,t e cour o i n i l n o m to e a e o a n if ' l i i c i n to d e ut h t di qua ii dpl i t f s a t r e be a s def nda t di not s lfe a n i f ' to n y c u e e n s d cons nt ohe r pr s n a i n ofpl i t f s e t r e e e t to a n if . 1L 6 H e e, r Di ke s n r pr s nt d de e da tW a s n i K N D O C i t r a a f i si ves i a i n r M . c ro e e e e fn n to n n e n l f a r n tg t o ba edon as resofni e a o lm o sc m pl i t r ga di g def ndant a s n' pe f nnanc .W hie s ei n n n r u o an s e r n e W to s ro e l t ec nt nt t ea o ym o sc m pl i t i unknow n, n or l r um e t f nda t i di a e t a one h o e of h n n u o an s s i a a g n de e n s n c t d h t oft eco pl i t i c ude a l ga i nsa a ns de e dan W a s n t a m ir r d a i ci e tf rw hi h h m a n s n l d le to g i t f n t t o h t r o e n n d n o c pl i tf r c i eda di c plna y s s ens on.W ihou di cl s ng t epr c s de aisof hea on m ous a n if e e v si i r u p i t t s o i h e ie t l t n y co pl i t de enda t a gue t a t e f c ua sm ia iy be w e n t e t o i ci e t i a l a t m an , f ns r h t h a t l i lrt t e h w n d n s s t e s u e tv , f co l i evi n e h t a n if y ie h n o an a n t 21 s gg si e i not nc us ve, de c t a pl i t f m a havetl d t ea onym ousc m pl i t gai s

d fn a t as nwhl h wa as p ts i gt ea pe l h t st es b e t f h p e e t cin l e e d n W to i e s lo tru n h p a t a i h u j c o t e r sn a to . f e
t i i t e c s , r D i ke s n de e de W a s n ag i s a c m pl i tl dge by pl i tf durng t e h s s h a e M . c r o f n d t o a n t o an o d a n if i h i t r al nve t g ton, l henow ptr ue sm ia cl i son beha fof a ntf r ga di gW a s n' n e n i s i a i whie ts s i l r a m l pl i if e r n to s pe f r a ce. Thi r l tons i be w ee t e m a t r w oul r nde t e û ubsa ta l s m ia ,'i rom n s e ai h p t n h te s d e r h m i t n i ly i l r' f s not t e e a t s m e. A bs nt c ns nt by de e da t W at on, t i s r of die t c nfi t i not h xc a e oe fn n s hs o t r c o lc s pe m i s bl unde t e r l s r si e r h ue . H ow e e ,e e i t e c u t d es no be i ve t i e i enc s ppo t a di e tr l tons i vr vn fh or o t le h s v d e u r s r c e ai h p
5

1 bew e n t et o cai s i silfndst a contde ta i f r a i n lke y pas e fom def nda t t e h w l m , t tl i h t i n il n o m to i l sd r en 2 W a s n t M r Di ke s n a d t a t e i f r a i n i r l va tt t e c re ta to . Thi c s i t o o . c r o n h t h n o m to s e e n o h u r n c i n s ae s 3 a al goust Cols.I t epr s nta ton, ai tf al ge apa- l oft o r ptoni t epr m otona no o e n h e e ci pl n if le s te' l r u i n h o i l tn c

4 pr c s , j s a p an if i Co e cam e ta Arz n Ch ri ' e g g d i a p ten o o e s' u t s litfs n ls li d h t io a a l s n a e n atr f ' e
5 di c i i a ol e pl ym e tpr c i e . Es a ls i g a pa- l orpr c i e ofs c unl w f l ac i es s rm n t ' m o n a tc s t b i h n y te ' tn a tc u h a u pr tc 6 r quiespr oft a de enda t , outne y a d ove tm e,e g ge i i pe ni s bl co duc . l t i er o ht f ns r i l n ri n a d n m n si e n t n hs 7 ca e pl i tf s c uns l M r D i ke s n,m a ha e sr tha d know l dge of s c conduc be a s s , a n if o e , . e r o y v s- n e uh t cu e

8 he r pr s nt d W a s n,a a s c ae wa de r s o sbl f rempl ym e tde i i ns i apr vi us e ee e to n s o i t r n e p n i e o o n c so , n eo

9 a tonr gadigW as n'j bpef r anc a dprs nma a e e t Defnda t ne dnot ovet ci e r n to s o ro m e n io n g m n . e n s e pr o
1 t ec u t ha M r D i ke s n ac ualy pos es esc nf de tali f r a i n a outpr s n e pl y e t 0 h o r t t . c ro t l s s o i n i n o m to b io m o m n

l1 pr c i e t a he m a us a ans def ndan W a s n. Ra he ,t e c ur m us m a e a ç e lsi a tc s h t y e gi t e t to trh ot t k ç a itc r
1 a pr i a ' of whe he M r Di ke s n Ik l pos es e s ch c nfde ta i f nna i n. Gi e t a 2 p a s l' t r . c r o i ey s ss u o i n i l n o to vn ht 1 pl i tf ale e a pa- l of c r u t pr c i e by de e dan s s e ii aly i c udi g de enda t 3 a n if l g s te ' tn o r p a tc s f n t , p c fc l n l n f n 1 W a s n, nd t a pl i tf sc uns l M r D i ke s n, evi us y r pr s nt d def nda tW a s n i an 4 t o a h t a n if o e , . c r o pr o l e e e e en to n 1 i t nz l f a r i ve tga i n a dr s i g c m pl i t t a ar s a t e s m etm ea t epr s nt s u e, 5 n e a a f i s n s i to d e sn o a n s h t o e t h a i s h e e di p t

1 t ec ur fndst a i i lkel t a M r Dikeron pos e s scontdenta i f nna i n t a co l be 6 h o ti h t t s i y h t . c s s se i il n o to h t u d
1 us d aga ns hi f r e c i n . Furhe ,de e da tW a s n has no c ns nt d t M r D i ke s n' 7 e i t s o m r le t t r fn n to t o e e o . c ro s

1 rp e e ttono plitf a ans hm .l t eitrsso j siea df in s t Mr Dik ro ' 8 e r sn ai f anif g i t i n h ne e t f u te n ar e s o . c e s n s
1 f r e c i nta d f rt e f r go ng r as ns t e c ur gr nt def nda t 'm oton t di qua i y. 9 o m r le n o h o e i e o , h o t a s e n s i o s lf 20 V I C O N C L U SI N . O

21

Pli tf ' c t s lm a notr p e e tac intw ih i t r ssadve s t af r e cinti t e a n ifs o m e y e r s n le t ne et . r e o o m r le n h

22 s m e o as bsa ta l r l t dm a trwihoutt e f r e cle tsc ns n .De enda tW a s n i a a r u t n ily e ae te t h om r in ' o e t f n to s 23 f r e ci nt pl i tf scot s l t i t r ssa ve s t pl i tf .De enda t pr s nt de i e c o m r le of a n if m e wih n e e t d r e o an if f n s e e e v d n e
24 s gge tve of a r l to s i be w ee t e f r e a d c r e tm a t r ,a d t e co r c ncl de i i u si e ai n h p t n h o m r n u r n te s n h u t o u s t s 25 r a ona l t i f r ha c ntde t a i f r a i n pas ed fom d f ndant a s n t pl i tf sc uns l e s b e o n e t t o i n i ln o m to sr ee W t o o a n if o e 26 t a i r l va tt t e c r e tc s . h t s ee n o h u rn a e 27 // / 28 // / 6

1

I I THEREFORE ORDERED t a dee da t' moton t diqualf (/3) TS h t fn n s i o s iy /1
G R A N TE D .
D A TE D : O ct ber4,2010. o

' X
U N ITE D STA T E S M A G IS R A T E JUD G E

7