Brooks v. Gedney et al

Filing 4

ORDER granting 1 Motion/Application for Leave to Proceed in forma pauperis; full fee due in monthly instalmts due; $0 due immediately; clerk shall send to A. Peralta at NDOP. Clerk shall file complaint and send along with blank form to Plaintiff. Defendant Bannister terminated. Amended Complaint due within 30 days. See order for specifics. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/30/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - LG)

1

-N

2

1' ' ., :,
..

.,

r n ;?

,. .

.

3

4
j 6 7 8 9 10

J
-

UN I E D STATES DISTR I T C O U R T T C
D IST R IC T O F NEVAD A

11

STAN LEY W .BROOKS, #67477 1 2 Pli tf, an if 1 v. 3s 1 DR. 4 KAREN GEDNEY,e aI, t. 1 5
16

Defnda t. e ns

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )
/

3: 0 c - 0481RCJV PC 1 -v 0 - ORDER

1 7
Brooks v. Gedney et al

Thi i a prs ne cii rg t a ton fld purua tt 4 U. . .j 1 83. Pli tf s s s io r v l ih s ci ie s n o 2 SC 9 an if
Doc. 4

l a plc to t pr c e lfo mapau e i i grntd( o ke /1.Thec ur n w rviwstec mplit 8 p iain o o e d ' r n p rs s a e d c t/) o t o e e h o an .
19 1 Screeni g St ndard . n a

20

Purua tt t ePrs ne LiiainReo nActI LRAI fdea c ursmus dimisa s n o h io r tg to fn P ,e rl o t t s s

2 1 prs ne ' c a m s ē ft e a l ga i n o pov r y i un r ey ori t e ac i n d s fi ol us o m a i i us' i o r s l i , ē h le to f e t s t u ' f h to i rv o r lc o , i ' i ' 22 ē a l t s a eac ai o whi h r le m a beg a t dy' rēs e sm one a yr le a a ns ade e da t t is o t t l m n c e i f y r n e 'o 'e k f t r e i f g i t f n n who

23 i i mu efo s c r le, 28U.. .j1 1 ()2) A cam i lgal fioluswhe i lc sa s m n rm u h eif' ' SC 9 5e( . li s e ly rv o n tak n 24 ag a l ba i et e i lw ori fc. ez ev.Wila s, U..31 325( 989 . c ur ma , ru be ss ih rn a n atNitk lim 490 S 9, 1 ) The o t y
25 t e e or ,dim is a c ai a f i ol us whe e i i ba e on a i di p t bl m e il s l ga t e r or h r f e s s l m s rv o r t s sd n n s u a y rte s e l h o y 26 w he e t e f c ua c nt nto s ar c e ry ba e t s 1 .a 327.Th c ii a i q iy i w h t e a r h a t l o e i n e la l s ls . d t e rtc l n u r s e h r

Dockets.Justia.com

1 constt tonalcl i ,howeveri arf ly pl aded,hasan ar uabl l galand f ct albass.SeeJackson iu i am n tu l e g ee au i

2 v Arz na,8 5F.d6 9,6 0( *Ci.1 8 ) . io 8 2 3 4 9 r 9 9 .
3 Dim i s lofacom pl i tf rf iuret st t acl i upon whi h relefm ay be gr nt d i s sa an o a l o ae a m c i ae s

4 pr vie fri Fe ea Rul ofCiiPr c due1 ( )6)a dteco r a ple tesm esa dadund r o d d o n d rl e vl o e r 2 b ( , n h u tp is h a tn r c 5 Se ton 1 15 e ( )whe r viwi gt ea e ua yofac m pli to a e d d c mpl i t Re iw unde c i 9 ( )2 n e e n h dq c o an r m n e o an . v e r 6 Rul 1 ( )6 i es ntal ar lngonaq eto oflw.Se Cha pe v. abo atr Cop.o Ame ia, e 2b () s se ily ui u sin a e p l f r oy r f rc 7 23 F.d71 , ( t Ci.2 00) A co plitmus co ti mor ta atfnnuli rctto ofte 2 3 9 723 9h r 0 . m an t nan e h n lo ac e iain h
8 el m ent ofa cause ofactoni'i m us cont i f ct alalegatons s fici ntt tr ie a rghtt r lef e s i 't t an a u li u t e o 'a s i o e i

9 a ov t e s e u a i e l ve . Be lAtantc Co p .v T om bl ,550 U . .5 4, l 7 S.Ct 1 55,1 65 b e h p c l tv e l' l l i r . w ' y S4 2 .9 9

1 ( 00 ) tf epla i gmus c nti s m ehi g mo e.ha .asae e toff cst a me eycr ae a 0 2 7 .t ' e d n -h t o an o t n r .. n . t tm n a t h t r l e ts t. 11 s s i i n g f algal c g i a l rg tofa to .' #. J r viwi g ac mpll tunde t i sa d r , u p co o j e ly o n z b e i h ci n '/ n e e n o an r h s tn a d
12 t e courtm us acceptas tue t e alegatons oft e com pl i ti quesi n,Hos ialBl g.Co.v.Re h t rhli h an n to pt d x

1 Ho pialTr s e s,4 5 U. .738 740 ( 976) c nsr e t e pladi g i t e lgh mos f v r bl t 3 s t u te 2 S , 1 , o tu h e n n h i t t a o a e o 1 pl i tf a dr s l ealdo bt i t epli tf' fvo . nkn v M cKeihe , U. . 1 421( 96 ) 4 an if n e o v l u s n h an ifs a rJe is . t n 395 S 41 , 1 9 .
l5 Alegatons i a pro se com pl i t ar hel t l ss sr ngent s anda ds t a f r al li n a n e d o e ti t r hn om

1 pladngsdrūe b lwy r.Se Hu he v Rowe, U..5,9( 980 * n sv Ke n r 40 U.. 6 ei a d y a es e g s . 449 S 1 ) Haie . r e , 4 S , 1 51 5 0- 1( 97 )Lerc ra l s ealoBalsr r v Pa llaPolc De ', 1F.d6 6,69 (t 7 9, 2 2 1 2 p u im ; e s ite i . cjc ie p t90 2 9 9 9h
1 Ci.1 9 ) Alo pa'ofac mplittldbyaprs ne ma bedimis dsu s ont, ve,fte 8 r 9 0. l r l t o an ie io r y s se a p e howe ri h
19 prioner scl i s l ck an ar uabl bas seiheri l w ori f ct Thi i cl descl i sbas d on l gal s ' am a g e i t na n a . sn u am e e

20 c ncusonst at r l tna l ( . . ai sa ans d fnda t who a ei m unefo s i o cli sot o l i h a e m e b e eg cl m g i t e e n s rm r m u t r am -

ll ifige e t alga itr swhihee rydoe not xit, wela camsbae o fncf la t a n rn m n of e lnee t c lal s e s)as l s li sd n a iu fcu l

22 algains(..a tsi ordeusona se ais.SeeNetke 49 U. . t3 7- 8*e aloMc e v r le to cg fn atc l i l c n ro ) i , 0 S a 2 2 , e s K ee z s
23 v Blc ,93 F.d795, ( t Ci.1 91. . ok 2 2 798 9h r 9 )
24 25 26

2

1

To s san a a to und rscin 1 83 aplitf mus s ow ()ta tec nd c u ti n cin e e to 9 , anif t h 1 h t h o u t

2 c mplie ofwa c mm itdbyaperona tngunde colrofsaelw;a d( )t a tec nd c o an d s o te s ci ro tt a n 2 h t h o u t
3 deprved t epl i tf ofaf der lconsiutonalorst t t r r ght'Hydri kv. unt n 466 F. d 676,689 i h a n if ea tt i a u o y i .' cHe 3

4 ( t Ci. 6) 9h r 200 .
5 l . I st ntCom pl i t I na an

6

Pl i tf , who i c r e ty i c r e a e a N o t e n N e a a Co r c i na Ce t r a n if s u r n l n a c r t d t rh r vd r e to l n e

7 (Q NCC' ha s e DrKae Ge n y c re tonsofie Beg, ade Be ed tiAso it W ade tN ' s u d . r n d e , o rci ) fcr r W r n n et, s cae r n
8 of ogr m s(6 W P' LiaW a s , ndN e a aDe al e tof r e tons(t D OC' M e ia Dieco Pr a ( A ' s lh a ) v d p lm n Co r ci ē N ' d c l r tr )
9 Dr Ba nit r.Pl i tf as e t t a t ough hei di betc,D r Gedney hasdeni d hi i s ln, uli g . n se a n if s r s h t h sa i . e m n u i res tn 1 i blndnessi hi l f eyeand nearblndnessi hi r ghteye.H eal o cl i st athe s fer consanty 0 ni n s et i n si s am h ufs tl 1l fom pai i bot e es.Pl i tf alegest athe hasbee deni d any tai i g ort er py t dealwihhi r nn hy a n if l h n e r nn ha o ts 1 blndnes a d deni d a tblnd ca e' t atDr.Donnely or er d.Pl i tf alo ass rs t atof i erBe g 2 i sn e ii n 'h l de an if s et h fc r 1 and Gedney cons ied t s ootandkil ai tf i or ert s op t el w s i.Healegest atBer tsetup 3 pr o h l pl n if n d o t h a u t l h gs 1 pl i tf i poston t be s otby hi wih as ot un upon l avi g m y cel and t en or er d m eoutof 4 a n if n ii o h m t hg en l h de 15 m y cel i t har sway cli i g 1 ēhoul n' f k w ih G edney.'Pl i tf st t st att e i t w e ton lno m am n s d t t '' a n if a e h h n e n i 1 ofa uni entfed i di i ualpr ve t dhi m ur e .Fi aly, ai tf cl i st atW alh alow edofi er 6 n d ii n v d e n e s d r n l pl n if a m h sl tc s 1 t conts at hi t pe pl ye f rbooksf rt e blnd. 7o ic e s a a ro oh i l8 Pl i tf cont ndst atdef nda t havebeen delber t l i dif r ntt hi s rousm e i al a n if e h e ns i a e y n fe e o s e i dc

1 needsi vi l ton oft eEi ht Am endm ent TheEi ht A m endm entprohi ist ei poston ofcr el 9 n o ai h gh . gh b t h m ii u

20 a d u us al s m e t a d ' m bodi sbr a a d i e lsi c nc pt ofdi n t , vii e s a da ds n n u punih n s n ē e e o d n d a itc o e s g iy ci lz d t n r ,

21 huma iya dd c nc .'Eselev. nt n e e y' t l Gambl, U.. 1 (976) A deane o prs n rscam of e 429 S 97, 02 1 . ti e r io e ' li
22 i adequat m edi alcar doesnotconsiut cr eland unus al n e c e tt e u u puni hm entunl sst em i teat entr s s s e h sr m ie 23 t t e l vel of tdelbe at i dif r nce t s rous m edi al needs.' 1d. at 106. The ēdelber t oh e s i r e n fe e o ei c ' i i ae

24 idifrnc 'sa dadivole a o jctvea dasb e tvepr n .Fis,healg dde rvainmus n fee e'tn r n v s n b e i n u j ci o g rtt le c p i to t

25 be,i o j cietr s ts fiinty sro s'Far e v Brnn n,51 U..825,8 4 ( 99 )(iig n b e tv em ,tu fce l eiu .' m r . e a 1 S 3 1 4 ctn 26 Wis n v Se tn 5 1U. .2 4,298( 991) Se o d,t eprs n ofi ilmus a twih a d ufi inty lo . ie 0 S 9 1 ). c n h io tca t c t t tce l s
3

1 c l a l sa e of i dy w hi h e t ism or t a m e ene lge ce butl s t a c ndu tund ra e f r u p b e tt m n ' c n a l ' e h n r gi n , es h n o c e tk n o
t e ver pur os of causi g hann. Farmer,511 U . .at 837, A prson of i i ldoes not act i a h y pe n S i fc a n

d lbe a e y i d fe e t a ne unl s t e ofi i l t now sofa d dir ga dsa e c s i ers t i m a e e i r t l n i f r n m n r e s h fc a t k n se r n x e sv ik o n t he lh ors f t . 1 . at ae y' d '
l appl i g t i sandar ,t e Ni t Cicui has hel t at bef r i can be sai t ata n yn h s t dh nh r t dh oe t dh

prs ne ' c vi r g t ha e be n a rdge , t e i dif r n e t hi m e i a ne dsm us be s bs a ta . io r s i l i h s v e b i d t h n f e e c o s d c l e t t u tn il
M er tndi f r nce, t eglge ces or E edi alm al r ctce'w ilnots ppor t i caus of acton.' e i fe e ' n i n ' m c pa i l u t hs e i'

Br u htnv Cutrlab r tre , 221.d458, (t Ci.1 0)ctngfxc/, U. .t1 06. o g o . te v o a o is 6 72 460 9h r 98 , ii /fc 429 S a 05SAJco pli tta ap yiinlasbenne lge ti dig osngorte tngame ia c ndtc d e C I m an h t h sca l e gi n n a n i rai dc l o iim o s
nots at avald cl i ofm edi alm it eat entundert eEi ht A m endm e t M edi alm al ractce does te i am c sr m h gh n. c pi notbecom ea consi tonalvi lton m er l becaus t e vi tm i a prs ner.'Est le v.Gam bl ,429 tm i oa i ey e h c i s io ' e l e

U..a 1 6,s ealoAndes nv Cou t o Ke n,45F.d 1 1 ,1 6 (t Ci.1 ) Mcc c i v S t0 e s ro . ny f r 3 3 0 31 9h r 995 . m kn . , k mi , 4 F.d 1 5 , 0 0 ( t Ci. 9 2 ( v r ue o ot e gr u d ) H . Te h .I c v Mi e , ī t 97 2 0 0 1 5 9h r 1 9 ) o e r ld n h r o n s, ' , c s,n . . l r h MY l l 4 F.d 11 3,11 6 (t Ci.1 97(n ba c, Eve gos ne lge c i is fiintt esa ls 0 3 3 3 9h r 9 )e n ) n r s gi n e s n u fce o tbih dei e aei difr ncet s ro sme ia ne ds Se Woodv Hou ewrght900F.d 1 32,1 3 ( t lb r t n fee o e i u d c l e . e . s i, 2 3 3 4 9h
Ci.1 0) A pione ' meedia r e e twihdign ssorte t e tdoe no s p o'acam of r 99 . rs rs r sge m n t a o i ram n s t u p l li t deieaeidifrnc .S nc e v Vids8 lF.d240 242( t Ci.1 89) lb rt n fee e a h z . l 9 2 , 9h r 9 .
D e a of o i t r e e c wih, m e i a te t e t c n a s a ount t de i e a e ly , r n e fr n e t d c l r a m n a lo m o lb r t

i difr nce Se let . n e , 9F.d 1 91 1 9 ( t Ci. 06) Clm e tv Gome , F. d898 n fee . e tv Pe n r 43 3 0 , 0 6 9b r 20 . e n . , z 298 3 ,

905(tCi. )Halet . gan, F.d73 , 44(tCi. 9b r2002 . ltvMor 296 3 2 7 9h r2002)Lo e v Smih, F.d1 22, , , . p z . t 203 3 1

1 31(tCi.1 96)Jacz'nvMcnts , 0F.d33 , (tCi,1 6)M c uc i vSmih, 74F.d 1 9b r 9 . lo . l o h 9 3 0 332 9b r 99 . G kn . t 9 2 , ,
1 50 1 9(*Ci.1 92)ov ruldonote gr und b F'' T c s,I c v Milr 1 F.d 1 33, 0 , 05 9 r 9 er e h r o s y A. e h . n . . le , 04 3 1 /Y ('Ci.1 97 (nba c;Huchns nv Unie Stts 838F.d39 ,3 4(tCi.1 88.W heete 9h r 9 ) e n l t i o . td ae , 2 0 9 9b r 9 ) rh
prs n ri algi gt a de a ofme ia te t e t vi c sde i e aei d fee c , io e s le n h t ly d c lr am n e n e lb r t n ifr n e howe e ,hep ione v r t rs r

mus s ow ta tedea ldt frhe ij r .SeeHalet,2 6F,da 745-6. t h h th ly e o u t r nu y lt 9 3 t 4, McGuc i, F.da kn 974 2 t

1 60. a lyv Ne . Ofstt Prs nComm 's 766F.d404,40 (tCi.1 )( e c ra ) 0 , p e . v Bd. ae io Sh r, 2 7 9h r 985 p r u im .
4

1 Pl i tf s at san Ei ht Am endm entcl i agai stDr K ar n Gedney. a n if t e gh am n .e 2 W ih r s ectt pl i tf'sr t laton cl i i countI ,t es a ls aprm af ci casef r t e p o a n if' e a i i am n I o t b ih i ae o

3 r t la i n, a ntf m us a l g a d s o t a de e da t a t d t r t la ef rhi e e c s ofapr t c e e a i to pl i if t le e n h w h t f n n s c e o e a i t o s x r i e o e td
4 actviy, def ndant 'actonsdi notser e al gii at penol gi alpur os .SeeBar et v.Cent ni i t and e si d v e tm e oc pe nt o,

5 31 F.d 81 ,81 ( t Ci.1 9 ) Pr t v Rowl nd,65 F,d 8 2,8 7 ( t Ci.1 95 . A pli tf 3 3 6 9h r 9 4 . at . , a 3 0 0 9h r 9 ) an if
6 as ertng ar t laton cl i m us dem onsr t atbutf r'caus lnexusbet ee t e aleged r t laton si e ai i a m t ta e t - o ' a w nh l eai i

7 a dpli tf' pr t ce a tv t (. .tlngalga a ton .M c onal v Hal, 0F.d 1 ,1 ( s Ci. n an ifs o e td c iiy ie,ii e l c i ) D d . l61 2 6 8 1 t r

8 1 7 )s eMtHe lh Cf ' hool itBd.fEduc v. yl, U.. (977 .Theprs ne mus 9 9 ,e . aty y Sc D s. o . . Do e 429 S 274 1 ) io r t
9 s bm i evi e ce, t erdiectorcicum s a tal t es a ls alnk bet eent eexer ieofconstt i nal u t d n eih r r t n i , o t b ih i w h cs im o 10 rght and t e alegedl r t lat r acton.Pr t,65 F. d at806. Ti i g oft eevent s r oundi g t e is hl y ea i o y i at 3 mn h sur nh 11 aleged r t laton m ay cons iut cicum st ntalevi ence ofr t lat r i t nt See Sor nno ' Gasco, l ea i i tt e r ai d eai o y n e . a s

1 I c v Mor an,8 4F.d 1 1 ,1 1 ( t Ci.1 89 .Plitf saesartlain cam a ais Dr 2 n . . g 7 2 3 0 3 6 9h r 9 ) anif tt eaito li g n t .
l3 Kar n G edney and cor ectonsof- erBer . e ri tc i g 14 W ih r s e tt Banni t r pl i tf aleges gene aly t atunde Banni t rt e m edi al t epc o se , an if l rl h r se h c

1 d pat e t sde idhi a ytanigo tea yt a a toblndne s Howe e,ilibiiyu d rgl 5 e rm n ha ne m n ri n rh rp o d p t i s . v rtgla lt n e ' j
16 1 83 arsesonl upon a s ow i g ofper onalpari i aton byt e def ndant A s per iori onl la l 9 i y hn s tcp i h e . u v s s y ib e 17 f r t e consiutonalvi ltons of ...s bor i at s i t e s per i or pari i at d i or diect d t e oh tt i oai u dn e f h u vs tc p e n reh

1 v ol tons o kne o t evi l ton a d f ie t a tt pr ve t h m .Th r i no r s o de ts pe i r 8 i ai , r w f h o a i s n a ld o c o e n t e e e s e p n a u ro

1 la ii unde (q1 83. Ta lrvLit88 F.d1 4 ,1 45(QCi.1 8 )(iainso itdls ealo 9 iblt y r j 9 ' y o . s, 0 2 0 0 0 9' r 9 9 ctto m te ;e s ' 20 Hydrc vHuntr 500F.d978, 8(tCi. ) Ore v Was igtnCou t,Stt o on,8 F.d ik . e , 3 98 9b r2007 . tz . hn o , ny ae f 83 21 8 4,8 9 (t Ci.1 96 (on ldig pope t dimiswhee no ale ainsofk owldge ofor 0 0 9b r 9 ) c cu n r r o s s r lg to ne 22 p riiaini alge vilton .Plitf doe no alg ta Ba nitrpatcpae i,die tdo a tcp to n le d oai ) anif s t le e h t n se rii td n rce r
23 f ied t actt pr ventvi l tons of pl i tf s Ei ht Am e dm entrght . A ccor i gl ,pl i tf s al o oe oai an if gh n is d n y a n if

24 c a m s a ai s de e da tBa nit ra e di m is d,a d he i di m i s d f o t i a to . li g n t f n n n se r s s e n s s s e r m h s c in
25 W ih r s e tt W a den Be edeti pl i tf st t st athei ēf r edbyW a den Benedeti t epc o r n t, a n i f a e h s to c r t

26 t f nd f rhi s l wih no ass sance ata1.' W hie pl i tf appear t com pl i t atBenede t has o e o m ef t it l' l a n if so an h ti

5

l been delber t l i dif r ntt hi s rousm edi alneeds f rtai i g ort er py t adaptt blndnes , i aey n fe e o s e i c o r nn ha o oi s 2 hi alegatons agai s Benedetiar t o vague f rt ecour t det r i e whet ert ey s at an Ei ht sl i nt t eo oh to em n h h te gh

3 A m e dm e tm e i a c a m . Pl i tf f is t i e tf w ha s e ii a tonsBe e e t t o a d how nn d c l li a n if a l o d n iy t p c fc c i n d ti o k n
4 B enedetialegedl vi l t d hi constt tonallght .A ccor i gl ,pl i tf scl i sagai s Benedeti tl y oae s i- i u is d n y an if am nt t
5 m ustbe di m i s d. However becaus hi alegatons agai s Be edet m a i plcat hi Ei ht s se , esl i n t n ti y m i e s g h

6 A m endm entr ght ,he m ay a e d hi com pl i t is mn s an. 7 W ih res ectt Lia W alh,pl i tf salegatonst ats e alow edhi t pepl yert be t p os s a n if l i h h l sa ao

8 confscat d ar al o t ovaguef rt ecour t det r i ewhet ert e st t acl i .Pl i tf cl i st at i e eso oh to e m n h h y ae am a n if a m h 9 t i w asdonet puni h and t r e t Pl i tf scl i sagai s W al h ar di m i s d.Tot e ext ntt a hs o s o m n . a n if a m n t s e s se h e ht
10 pl i tf s e s t brng a r t laton cl i ,he has l ave t am end hi cl i sagai s W alh. As wih a n if e k o i ea i i am e o s am nt s t

11 B enedeti pl i tf m usts ecii alyi entf W al h' actonsand how t oseactonsalegedl vi l t d t, a n if p fc l d iy ss i h i l y oae 12 w hats ecii constt tonalrght ofpl i tf . p tc i- i u is a n if 13 A ccor i gl ,pl i tf hasl ave t f l an am ended com pl i t l pl i tf el c st fl d n y a n if e o ie a n . f a n if e t o ie

1 an am ended com pl i t he i advied t athe s oul s ecii aly i e tf each def ndantt t ebes of 4 an , s sh h d p fc l d n iy e oh t 15 hi abiiy,cl r f whatconstt tonalrghthe beleveseach def ndanthasvi l t d and s pporteac s lt a i y iu i i i e oa e u h 16 cl i w ih f ct alalegatonsabouteach def ndantsac i ns Agai ,t er can beno labiiy under42 am t a u l i e ' to . nhe i lt

1 U. . , 1 3unls teei s meafr aielnkorc nne to bewe nadee d ntsa to sa dte 7 SC j 98 e sh r s o fim tv i o cin t e fn a ' cin n h 1 cli e de rvain.Riz v Goo e423U.. ( 9 6)Ma v. 8 am d p i to z o . d , S 362 1 7 . y Enomoo, F.d1 4,1 7(tCi. , t 633 2 6 6 9b r

l 1 80 ,Joh s nv. fk,58 F.d7 0, (t Ci.1 78 .Plitf scamsmusbestfrhi s o t 9 9 ) n o Dul 8 2 4 743 9h r 9 ) anif li . t e ot n hr
zt and pl i t r s,si pl ,conci el and diecty.See Swi r ei w iz v.Sor m a N A. 534 U , .506,514 j an e m my sy rl ek e c e , S

21 (00 ) Fe . Ci. 8. 2 2 * d R. v P. ,
22 Pl i tf i i f r ed t att e courtca notr f r t a pror pl adi g i or er t m ake a n if s n o m hh n ee o i enndo 23 pl i tf s am ended com pl i t com pl t .LocalRul 15-1 r quies t at an am ended compl i tbe a n if an ee e erh an 24 com pl t i isel wihoutr f r ncet anyprorpl adi g.Thi i because,asagener lr l ,an am ended ee n t f t eee o i en ss a uc

25 co pli ts pe s de t eo i i a c m pli t Se Z(l v. y,3 5F.d 5 ,5 ( t Ci.1 6 ) Onc m an u r e s h rgn l o an . e /? Rha 7 2 5 7 9h r 9 7 . e . x
26 pl i tf tl s a a e d d co pl i t t e orgi a pl a i g n l nge s r e a y f nc i n i t e c s . a n if i e n m n e m a n , h i n l e d n o o r e v s n u to n h a e

6

1 The e or , n a a e d d c m pl i tasi a org nal m pl i t e c c ai a d t ci v l e e t a h r f e i n m n e o a n , n n i i co a n , a h l m n h n o v m n ofe c
2 def ndantm ustbe s f-ci nty aleged. e ut e l l i 3 11 . Concl si n 1 uo

4 I I THEREFORE ORDERED ta plitf' a plc ton t pr c e i fo ma TS h t an ifs p iai o o e d n r 5 pau e i ( oc e #1 wiho tha i gt pr pa t ef l flng f ei GRANTED;pl itf s alnot p rs d k t ) t u v n o e y h u l ii e s an if h l be
6 r quie t pa a i ii li s a l e tf e Ne e t e e s t e f l f l g f e s a ls il d e, ur ua tt e r d o y n n ta n t lm n e . v rh l s , h u l ii e h l tl be u p s n o n

7 28 U. . .j 1 l a a e de by t ePrs n rLii ai n Ref nn Actof1 96. Themova th r i i S C 9 5, s m n d h io e tg to o 9 n e en s
8 per it d t m ai t i t i acton t concl si n wihoutt e necesst ofpr pa m entoff es orcos sor m te o n a n h s i o uo t h iy ey e t

9 tegvigofsc rt teeo .Thi or e grntngi for apau e i sa'ss alnote tndt t e h in e u iy h rfr s dr a i n m p rs tt h l xe o h u
j( i s ance ofs bpoenasatgove z entexpe s . ) su u nm ne

11

I I FURTHER ORDERED t a , s a tt 28 U. . .j 1 1 , a e de byt e TS h t puru n o S C 9 5 as m n d h

12 Prs nerLii aton Ref r Actof 1996,t eN evadaD epa t entofCor ectons s al pay t t e Cl r io tg i om h rm ri hl o h ek 13 oft e Unied St t sD iti tCour,Di tictofNevada,20% oft e pr cedi g m ont ' depost t t e h t a e sr c t sl hen hs is o h

1 a c untofStnlyW . o ks l m at No. 477(nmo t st a t ea c un e c e s$1 . 0 untl h 4 co a e Br o , n e 67 i n h h t h c o t x e d 0 0 ) it e
l f l $35 flng f e ha be n pai f rt i acin. The Clr s a ls nd a c py oft i or e t t e 5 u l 0 ii e s e d o h s to ek h l e o hs dr o h
l6 atenton ofAl er G . rala, efofl m at Servi esf rt eN evadaD eparm entofPrsons,P. . ti b t Pe t Chi ne c oh t i O Box

1 7 11 Ca s n Ciy, V 897 2. 7 0 , ro t N 0
l8 I IS FURTH E R O R D E R E D t at even i t i ac i n i dim ised,ori ot e vi e T h, f h s to s s s s hn s

1 uns c e sul t e f l flng f e s alsilbe due purua tt 28 U. . .j1 1 ,a a e de b t e 9 u c s f , h u l ii e h l tl , sn o SC 9 5 s m n d y h
20 Pr s nerLii aton Ref r Actof 1996. io tg i om

2l
22

I I FURTHER ORDERED ta t eClr s al LE tec mplit(oc e #11. TS h th ek h lFI h o an d k t - )
I I FURTHER O R D E R E D t a pl i tf ' Ei ht Am e dm e t e i a c a m ag i s TS h t a n ifs g h n n m d c l li an t

23 D r K a e G e ne M A Y PRO C E E D . . rn d y 2 4 I I FUR TH E R O R D E R E D t a pl i tf ' r t la i n cl i s s tf rh i c u t1 TS h t a n if s e a i to a m e o t n o n 1

2 a ai s Dr Ka e Ge ne a d c r e tons o fc rBe g M A Y PR O C E ED . 5 g n t . rn d y n orci fie r
26 IT I FURTH E R O R D E R E D t atpl i tf ' cl i s agai s def ndantBa ni t rar S h a n if s a m nt e n se e

7

DISM ISSE D . D ef ndant Bamzst ri D I M ISSED fom t i acton. e s ie s S r hs i IT IS FU R T H ER O R D E R ED t at pl i tf ' Ei ht Am endm ent cl i s agai s h a n ifs g h am nt

de e da t W a de Be e e t a e DI M I SE D wi h l ave t am e d i c nf nnan e w ih t e fn n r n n d ti r SS te o n noo c th
i stuctonspr vi ed i t i or er nr i o d n hs d . IT I FUR TH E R O R DE R ED t atpl i tf ' cl i sagai stdef nda tLi aW all ar S h a n if s a m n ens sl e

D I M I SED w ih l a e t am e d i c nf r a c wih t e i sr cto sp ovi e i t i or e . SS t ev o n n o o m n e t h n tu i n r d d n h s d r

I I FURTHER ORDERED t a pli tf wil a et it ( 0) fo t ed t t a TS h t an if lh v h ry 3 day: r m h a e h t
tlsOr eri ent r d t fl hi am ended compl i t i he choos st fl one,i conf nnancewih t i li d s e e o ie s an , f eoe n o t hs O r er. The am ende com pl i tm us be a com pl t docum enti and ofisel,a d wils per ede t e d d an t ee n t fn lu s h orgi alcompl i ti isentr t . Any alegatons pari s orr quest f rr leffom prorpaper t at in a n n t ie y l i , te , e s o ei ' r i sh arenotcanied f m ar i t eam ended com pl i tw ilno l nge bebef r t ecour .Faiure t am end o dnh an l o r oe h t lo w ilres l i t e m ater proceedi g as t t e cl i salow ed i t i order. l utn h t n o h am l n hs
IT IS FURTH ER O R DE R ED t ati pl i tf chooses tlfl an am ended com pl i t h f a n if t ie an,

he s al cl ary tte t e am ended com pl i t as s ch by pl ci g t e wor s EFI ST AM EN D E D ' h l e l il h an u an h d CR '

i m e itl a ov ēci iRi ht Compli tP r ua to42U. . . 1 83' pa e1i t eca ton, nd m d aey b e d v l g s an u s n t S C j 9 3on g n h p i a
pl i tf s al pl ce t e case num ber, 3: 0-C V - 0481- C J- PC , above t e wor s 'FI ST a n if h l a h 1 0 R V h d CR A M EN D ED 'iIt e s acef rtc as No.' 'I h p ot e ' IT I FURTH E R O R D ER ED tm tt eCl r shal s nd t pl i tf abl nk s cton 1983 S l h ek l e o an if a e i ci i rght com pl i tf rm w ih i sructons al ng wih one copy oft e or gi alcom pl i t vl i s an o t nt i o t h in an . pr vi ed i t i or e . o d n hs d r D A TE D t i 30t dayof hs h

Novem ber

,

201 . 0

I D S'' T R IA

I T R I T JU D G E SC

8