McGuire v. State of Nevada ex rel. Nevada Department of Corrections et al

Filing 9

ORDER. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the Clerk shall FILE the complaint (docket 1 -2). FURTHER ORDERED, plaintiff's Eighth Amendment claim MAY PROCEED. FURTHER ORDERED, plaintiff's Fourteenth Amendment claim is DISMISSED. FURTHER ORDERED, defendant(s) shall file and serve an answer or other response to the complaint within thirty (30) days following the date of the early inmate mediation. If the court declines to mediate this case, an answer or other response shall be due within thirty (30) days following the order declining mediation. FURTHER ORDERED, the parties SHALL DETACH, COMPLETE, AND FILE the attached Notice of Intent to Proceed with Mediation form on or before thirty (30) days from the date of entry of this order. FURTHER ORDERED, plaintiff is provided filing instructions and requirements, see order for details. FURTHER ORDERED, defendants' 4 motion to extend time is DENIED. Signed by Magistrate Judge Robert A. McQuaid, Jr on 11/29/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - KO)

Download PDF
' @ ' = --- - -- - - F'y -) . ktC E k RD ' ( '3 -' - F-0Q ' RCJ'0 - S Rl' EF D C l , 5 f 7)i ' ,s t'k,flci yE ' E C 2 7; 7 Q $ 0 20 l t tghl ls tW l ty au CEky (s'h'OJ g yqlcau V , t' g )(Fj Fk p ya I un I yJ!. I ,J. E! I , U N IT E D ST A T E S D I T R IC T C O U R T S D IST R IC T O F NEV A D A ROBERT M CGUI E, R /83383 / Plitf, anif vs . STATE OFNEVADA,e aI, t. D e e da t . fn n s ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) / 3:0-v- 0488HDM - AM 1c0 R ORDER Thi i aprs ne cvirg t acin tldpurua tt 42U. . .j1 83.Thec ur now s s io r i l ih s to ie s n o SC 9 ot McGuire v. State of Nevada ex rel. Nevada Department of Corrections et al r vi w s t e com pl i t ee h an . Doc. 9 1 Scr e i g St ndar . enn a d Purua tt t ePrs nerLiiainReor Ac I LIAI fdea c ursmus dim isa s n o h io tg to f m t P t , e rl o t tss 21 pr s ner s c ai s i t e a l ga i n ofpove t i untue, or i t e a ton i f i ol usorm alc o s' i o ' l m , tf h le to r y s r ' f h c i ls rv o ' ii u y ' tf ist s a e acl i on whi h r lef a begr nt d, or e ksm one a yr le a a ns ade e da twho la l o t t am c ei m y ae' te 's t r ei f g i t f n n 23 i i mun fo s c rle. 28U.. .j 1 1 ()2 . A cam i lg lyfiolu wh ni lc sa sm e r m u h eif' ' SC 9 5 e( ) li s e al rv o s e t a k n aruabl ba i et e i 1w ori f c. ez ev Wilams, U. .319,325( 989) Thec ur may, g e ss ih r n a n a t Nitk . li 490 S 1. ot t e e or ,dim isa c am asfi ol uswhe e i i ba e on a i diput bl m e ils l ga t e r or h rf e s s li rv o r t s sd n n s a y rte s e l h o y w he e t e f c ua cont ntons a e c ea l bas l s . 1 . a 327. The crtc l i quiy i whe he a r h at l ei r l ry ee s d t ii a n l s tr Dockets.Justia.com 1 c ns iuto alcl i ,how e e i a tuly pl a ed,ha a a g abl l gala d f c ualba i .Se Jac s n o tt i n am v r n rf l e d s n ru e e n at ss e k o 2 v Arz na,88 F.d639,640(tci.1 89 . . io 52 9h r 9 ) 3 Di m i s lo a c m pl i tf rf iur t s a e acl i upo w hi h r le m a begr nt d i s s a f o an o a l e o t t am n c e if y aes 4 pr vie fri Fedea Rul ofCi iPr ce u e1 ()6) a dtec u t pple t esm esa dadu de o dd o n rl e v l o d r 2 b ( , n h o r a is h a tn r n r 5 Se to 1 1 ()2)whe rviwigt ea e ua yo acomplitorame dedc mplit Re iw u de cin 9 5 e ( n e e n h dq c f an n o an . ve n r 6 Rue1 ( )6 i e s nil ar l go aqu sino lw.S eCh p e v fa or tr Cop.fzme ia l 2 b ( ) s se t l u i n e to f a e a p l . b a oy r o l rc , ay n 7 232F.d71 , ( t Ci. 3 9 723 9h r 2000) A c mplitmus c nti mor t a alfr uli rcttonoft e . o an t o an e h n to m ac e iai h 8 e e e t ofa c us ofa toni i m us c nt i f ct alale a i ns s fi i ntt t aie a r ghtt r le lm n s ae ci ' t ' t o an a u l g to u t c e o t s i o e i f r 9 a ove t e s ec l tve l ve . Be lAtantc Co p.v Twombl ,550 U . .544, 1 7 S.Ct 1 55,1 65 b h p u a i e l' l l i r . ' y S 2 .9 9 1 ( 007) t-hepla i gmus eonans meti gmo e.ha ,. sae e toff csta meel ce tsa 0 2 . - e dn l t ti o hn r .. n .a ttm n a t h t r y rae t 11 s s ii n lf algal cogniabl rg tofa ton. f .I r viwi gac m plitunde t i sa dad, u p co o j e ly z e ih ci ' # n e e n o an ' r hs tn r 1 t e c ur m us a c ptast ue t e a l ga i ns of t e c m pl i t i q e ton,H o p ialBl g.Co.v Re 2 h ot tce r h le to h o a n n u si st d .x 1 Hos ialFm xc -,425 U..7 8,7 0 ( 976) c nsr e te pla ig i te lghtmes fvoabl t 3 pt /c S 3 4 1 , o tu h e dn n h i ta r e e 1 panif n rs l eal o b si t ep an ifsfv r J n isv Mc ete , 9 U, . 1 4 1( 9 9 . 4 litf a d e ov 1d u t n h litf' a o . e kn . K i n 3 5 S 41 , 2 1 6 ) h 1 A le a i ns i apr s co pl i ta e hel t l s s r ng nts a d r st a f r a pl adi gs dr fe by 5 l g to n o e m an r d o e s ti e t n a d h n o m l e n a td 1 lwyes Se Hu he v. l e, U.. 9( 980) Haie v Ke ne , U.. 9, 21( 972)+e 6 a r. e g s Stw 449 S 5, 1 ; n s , r r 404 S 51 520- 1 r 1 cu imj s ealoBalsr r v PacscaPolc De ' 901F.d696,699(t Ci.1 90 .A1orpa to 7 ra ; e s ite i . ie p t , 2 9h r 9 ) 1 r f 1 aco pl i ttld byaprs ne m a bedim is d s as ont , 8 m a n ie io r y s s e u p e howe e , ft eprs ne ' cai slc a v r i h io rs l m a k n 1 a gua l bas se t e i 1 w ori f c .Thi i cl de c ai sbas d on l ga c nc us o st at eun e a l 9 r b e i ih r n a n at sn u s l m e e l o l i n h ar t n b e 20 (. . li sag i s defnd nt whoaei munefom s i o cli sofi fige e tofalg litrs eg cam an t e a s rm r ut r am n rn m n e a n eet 21 whih ce rydoesnote it,a welascai sbasd o fnciulf cualalg tons( b.fntsi or c la l x s) s l l m e n a f a t le ai eg a a tc 22 delsonalsenais.Se Netk , U. . t327- 8; ealoMc e v rv Blck 932F,d795,798 ui c ro ) e iz e 490 S a 2 se s K e e . o , 2 23 (t Ci.1 91 . 9h r 9 ) 24 Tos sai a a tonunde scin 1 aplitf mus s ow ( )t a tecond c u t n n ci r e to 983, an if t h 1 h t h ut 25 c mplie ofwasc m mitd by apes n a tngunde colrofsae lw;a d ( )tattec nd c o an d o te ro ci ro tt a n 2 h h o u t 26 de rve t e pl i tf ofa f de a co s iutona o s a ut r r gh , Hydri k v Hunt r,466 F, d 676, p i d h a n if e r l n tt i l r t t o y i t' ' c. e 3 2 1 689( tCi.2006) 9h r , 2 I . I s antC om pl i t l nt an 3 Plitf,who i i c r eaed a E1 Stt Prs n ( SP') ha s e ESP c re tons an if s n ac rt t y ae io i ', s u d E o rci 4 of i e sTom St bbs, a i Dr m m ond, nd M i ha lLee Pl i tf aleg st e f low i g:on ora out fc r u D vd u a ce . a n if l e h o l n b 5 Augus 24,2008, e da t us d e c s i e f r e a ai s pl i t f w hie he washa dc f ed and i 1 g t def n n s e x e s v o c g n t a n i f l n uf ne 6 io s Dee d n s sa l d, e t gn l c e 'p an ifc u igij re ,n l dn alr es el g r n . fn a t t sut b a,a d kik d' litf, a sn nu is i cu i g ag w li a e n 7 a ove hi l f t m pl t a r quie s r er . H e c ntnue t s f e di z nes , ur ed vi i n,da a e b s e te e h t e rd u g y o i s o u f r z i s bl r so m gd 8 neves he da he a d j it da a e. Plitf cai s vi ltons of hi Eiht a d Foure nt r , a c s n on m g anif l m oai s gh n te h 9 Am endm entrght . is 1 0 Att eout e , he c ur not st a , t he e apa tc l ra e dm e tt r vi e an e plc t h s t t o t e h t tW r ri u a m n n p o d s x i i 11 t xt a s ur e of c ns iuton l pr t c i n' a a ns a pa tc l r s r of gove nm en be a i r ha e ul o c o tt i a o e to g i t riu a o t r t h vo, t t 1 Am e dm e t no t e m or g ne a i ed noto of s bs a tve due pr c s ,'m us be t e gui e f r 2 n n, t h e e r lz in u t n i o e s' t h do 1 a ayzigg plitf'lcai s''Alrghtv.Olve ,51 U. . 273- 4( 994)( eh quit C..f r 3 n l n a an its l m .' b i i r 0 S 266, 7 1 R n s, J,o 1 plrlt)( uotngGr ham v Con or 490U. . 395(1 8 ).Theeor , aitf scai swilb 4 u aiy q i a , n, S 386, 9 9) rf e pl nif l m l e 1 ana yz d un ert e Ei ht A m e dm e trghtt be f e f om cr e a d unus al 5 le d h gh n ni o re r uln u puni h e tr t e a y s m n ah r n 1 ge e a i ed notons ofs bs a tve due p oce sund r t e Four e nt Am e dm e t a d hi Foure nt 6 n r lz i u tni rs eh te h n n, n s te h 17 A m endm entdue pr cesscl i i di m i sed. o am s s s l 8 The Ei ht A m e d e tpr hi ist e i pos ton ofc uel u us al gh n m n o bt h m ii r and n u puni hm e t a d s ns n 1 ie bo i sbr a a d i e ls i c nce t ofdi niy, vii e s a da ds hum a iy a d dec nc .'Es e l 9 m d e o d n d a i tc o p s g t ci lz d t n r , nt n e y ' t le 20 v Gambl,429U. .9 ,1 2( 976) tl rhe e e prs nofi il sa da c s dofusnge c sie . e S 7 0 1 . lq j n v r io tcas tn c u e i x e sv 21 p y ia f rei voaino t e( ihhAme d e t,h c r j diiln ur i . . te f rewa h sc lo c n ilto fh E g t n m n jte o e u ca iq iy s .wheh r o c s 22 a pled i a good- a t e f r t m a n a n orr sor di c plne orm alci us y a d s ditc ly t ca s pi n f ih f o t o i t i et e si i , i o l n a sia l o u e 23 har .'Huds nv Mc ilan,5 3U. .1 6- (1 9 )s ealo Whilyv. be s 475U. . 1 , 21 m' o . M li 0 S , 7 9 2 ; e s te Al r , S 3 2 320- 2 (98 ) Wat v Mc in y, 9 F.d71 7 1( tCi. 0 5 . ri e vStn o d 3 3F.d1 7 , 1 4 4 l 6 ; t . K n e 3 4 3 0, 1 9h r2 0 )Ma tn z . a f r , 2 3 1 8 1 8 s , 25 (tCi, 9b r 2003)Mar ue v Gute rz 322F.d689, - 2( tCi, ; q z . ire , 3 6919 9h r2003)Clme tv Gome , F.d ;en. z 298 3 2 8 8 9 3( lCi. 0 2 ; ef r v Go e , 67F.d8 5 9 0( tCi. 0 1 +e c ra ) S h e kv 6 9 , 0 9h r 2 0 ) Jf es . m z l 3 9 , 0 9h r 2 0 ) r u im ; c w n . 3 l Har or , F.d 11 11 6( :Ci. f d 204 3 87, 9 9h r 2000)Robisv Me c am, F.d 1 36,1 41( 'Ci.1 95) ; n . e h 60 3 4 4 9h r 9 ; 2 Be gv Kicheoe 794F.d457, ( tci.1 86) W hendeemi igwh te t ef rei e ce sve r .n l, 2 460 9h r 9 . tr nn eh r h o c s x s i , 3 tec u ts o l l o t te x e to ij r ...ten e f ra pl ai no f re te rlto s i h o r h u d o k o h s tn f nu y ,h e d o p i to f o c ,h eain hp e c 4 be w e n t a nee a d t e a ountof f r e us d,t e t r atS e s na l pe c i e by t e r s onsbl t e ht d n h m oc e h h e ra o by rev d h ep i e 5 of i i l , a d ny ef orsm a e t t m pe t e s ve iy ofa f r ef lr s ons .' H ud on,503 U . . t7 fc a s ' n a f t d o e r h e rt o c - e p e '' s u Sa 6 ( uotngWhily, U. . t321' eealoM arie ,323F.da 118 .Alhought eSuprm eCour qi te 475 S a ) s s p tn z 3t 4 t h e t 7 has neverrequied a s ow i g t atan em er ency siuaton exi t d,t e absence ofan em er ency m ay r h nh g ti s e lh g 8 be pr ba i e ofw he he t e f r e was i de d i ti t d m a i i usy or s ditc ly.' Jor an, o tv t r h oc n e n lc e lc o l a sia l ' d 986 F. d 2 9 a 1 n.; e aloJe/r , F.da 913( ei eaeidifrnc sa dada ple wheet eei no t 528 7 s e s f- 267 3 t d lb rt n fee e tn r p is r h r s s 1 S ng igprs ns c rt me s r ';J h s nv Lewi,2l F.d726,734( 'Ci. 0 i o n io e u iy a u e' o n o . s 7 3 o ) 9h r 2000) M orove, . er 1 teei none df ras owi gofs rousij r a ars l oftef re,butt elckofs c ij l i 1 hr s eo h n ei n u y s eu t h o c ha u h nu' s y 1 r l va tt t e i quiy. Se H u s n,503 U . .a 7- ; ar i e ,323 F. d a 11 4;Sc w e k 204 F. d 2 ee n o h n r e do S t 9 M tn z 3t8 h n, 3 1 at 1196. Pl i tf s at s an Ei ht Am endm entexces i e f r e cl i agai s def ndant . 3 a n if t e gh sv o c am nt e s 14 1 1. C oncl s on 1 ui 1 5 I I T H E R E FO R E O R D E R E D t a t e Cl r oft e Cour s a l L E t ec m pl i t TS h t h ek h t h l FI h o an 1 ( oc e /12 . 6 d k t/ -) 1 7 1 PR O C E E D . 8 1 9 I I FUR T H ER O R D ER E D t a pl i tf ' Fou t e t A m e dm e t c ai i TS h t a n i fs re n h n n lm s I I FU R TH E R O R D E R E D t a pl i tf ' Ei ht A m e dm e t c ai M A Y TS h t a n if s g h n n lm 20 D I M ISSE D . S 21 I I FURTHER ORDERED t a dee da ts s alfl a dsr ea a s erorot e TS h t fn nt) h l ie n e v n n w hr 22 rs ons t t eco plitwihi t it ( 0)da sf lowi gt edaeofteeal im aeme iton.I e p e o h m an t n h ry 3 y o l n h t h ry n t dai f 23 tec ur de lnest me it t i c s , na s e oroterrs ons s albeduewihi t it (0)days h o t ci o dae hs a e a n w r h e p e h l t n h ry 3 24 f lo i g t e or e dec i i g m e i ton. o l w n h d r ln n d ai 25 I I FU R T H E R O O E M D t a t ePM i SSH A L L D E T A C H , O M PL ET E , N D TS h th e C A 26 FI E t eatac e N o i eo l t ntt Pr ce d wih M editon f r on o be or t i' ( 0 da sfom L h t h d tc f n e o o e t ai o m r f e h ry 3 ) y r t 4 t e da e ofe t' oft i or e . ht nl y hs d r I I FUR T H E R O R D E R E D t a hen e orh, a ntf s al s r eupon de e da t , r TS h t c f t pl i if h l e v fn n s o , i a a pe r nc ha be nmadebyco ns luponteiatr e t)ac pyo e er pla ig, ton, f n p aa e s e u e, h r to n y s, o f v y e dn moi or ot e docum e ts bm it d f rco sder to by t e c ur .Pl i tf s a li c udew ih t e o i i a pa e hr n u te o n i a i n h o t a n if h l n l t h rg n l p r subm it d f rf lng acerii at s atng t e dat t ata tueand cor ectcopy oft e docmnentw asm aied te o ii tf c e t i h eh r r h l t t e de e da t orc uns lf rd f nda t .I couns lha e t r d a notc ofa pe r nc , he pl i tf o h fn n s o e o e e n s f e s n ee ie p a a e t a n if shal diects r i e t t e i di i ualatorney nam ed i t e notce of appear nce,att e addr s s at d lr ev c o h n v d t nh i a h es t e t een.Thec ur ma dir gada ypa errc ie byaditit udgeorama itaej dget a ha h ri o t y se r n p e ev d src j gsrt u h t s notbe n f l d w ih t e Cl r , nd a y pa e w hi h f ist i c ude a c r ii a e s ow i g pr pe s r i e. e ie t h e k a n p r c a l o n l e tt c t h n o r e v c I I FURTHER ORDERED t a d fndans motont extndtm e( oc e #4)i TS h t e e t' i o e i d k t s D E N IE D . D A TE D : N ovem ber29,2010, > U N I ED STA T ES M A G I T R A TE JUD G E T S 17 1 8 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 5 1 2 N am e 3 Prs n N um be io r 4 A dd e s rs 5 6 7 LT I ED STA TE S D I TR I T COU R T NT SC D I TRI T O F N EVA D A SC 8 9 1 0 11 1 2 1 3 Pli tf, anif v. Dee da t. fn n s ,) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) Ca eNo. s NOTI E OF I TENT TO C N PROCEED W I H M EDI TI N T AO Thi c s m a be r f r e t t e D i ti tofN e a a' e ry i m a e m e i ton pr g a . The s ae y eerd o h sr c v d s al n t dai o rm w hl h t e pa tes m e t w ih a i pa tal c ur - p oi t d m e i t r i a efor t b i g abou a ch ri e t n m ri o ta p n e d ao n n f t o rn tn 15 expedi ntres l t on t ati s tsf ct r t al partes. e o ui h s ai a o y o l i 11 6. Do you w i h t pr ce d t ea l m e i ton i t i ca e? s o o e o ry d a i n h s s Yes No 1 pu pos oft i notcei t as e st e s ia iiy oft i c s f rm e ito . M editon i apr ce sby 4 r e h s i s o s s h u t b lt h s a e o d a i n ai s o s l 2. 7 18 19 20 l no, e s sa et er as nt )you do notwih t p o e d wih mediton? f pla e tt h e o s s o rc e t ai 21 3. 22 23 24 Li ta y a d a 1c s s i c udi g t eca enum be , ha pl i tf hasfl d i f der lo s a e cour s n n 1 a e ,n l n h s r t t a n if ie n e a r t t t i t els fveye r a dtenaur ofea hcae.( ta h a diina pa e i ne de ) n h a t i as n h t e c s A tc d to l g s f e d . 25 4. Lita y and alca e ,i cudi g t eca enumbe ,t a a e c re ty pe di g ora y pendi g sn l ss n l n h s r h t r u rnl n n n n 26 g iva c sc nc r i gis esorcai sriedi t i c s .( ta haddiina pa esi ne de ) re n e o en n su l m as n hs a e A tc to l g f e d . 6 1 2 3 4 5. A r t e e an ot e com m en syou woul lke t e pr s t t e c ur a o twhet e t i c s i ehr y hr t d i o x es o h o t b u h rhs ae s s ia l f rm e i ton. Y ou m a i cl de a br e sat m e ta t why yo be i ve t i c s i utbe o dai yn u if t e n s o u le h s a e s 5 6 7 8 9 s ia l frme iton.( ta ha diinalpa e i nee e ) utbe o dai A tc d to gs f dd. Thi f r s albefldwiht eClrkoft eCour o orbeor t it ( 0)daysfom t e s o m h l ie t h e h tn f e h ry 3 rh 10 dat oft i order. e hs 11 Couns l f r de e da t : By s g i g t i f nn you a e c r iyi g t t e co r t a you h v e o fn ns in n h s o r e tf n o h utht ae c ns led w ih a r pr s n a i e oft e N e a a D e a t e tofCor e tons c nc r i g pa tc pa i n i o ut t e e e t tv h vd p rm n rci o enn ri i to n 12 m edi t on. ai 13 1 4 l5 Da e t i td hs da of y ,20 . 1 6 Si na ur g te 17 1 8 1 9 20 21 22 23 24 N a e ofpe s n who pr pa e or m ro e rd hel e pr pa e t i doc m e t p d e r hs u n 25 26 7

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?